|
|
|
Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy, August 2004, p . 3086-3092, Vol . 48, No . 8 Doripenem versus Pseudomonas aeruginosa In Vitro: Activity against Characterized Isolates, Mutants, and Transconjugants and Resistance Selection PotentialShazad Mushtaq,1 Yigong Ge,2 and David M . Livermore1* Antibiotic Resistance Monitoring & Reference Laboratory, Specialist & Reference Microbiology Division, Health Protection Agency, Colindale, London, NW9 5HT, United Kingdom,1 Peninsula Pharmaceuticals Inc., Alameda, California 945022 Received 30 October 2003/ Returned for modification 28 January 2004/ Accepted 14 April 2004
No potent antipseudomonal drugs have been developed over the last decade, leaving meropenem as the most active antipseudomonal agent available . Doripenem (S-4661) (23) is a new parental carbapenem discovered by Shionogi Ltd . and now being codeveloped, for intravenous use, with Peninsula Pharmaceuticals in North America; phase I trials of a nebulized formulation are also in progress . Like the carbapenems available at present, doripenem has a trans-configured 6-hydroxyethyl group, which protects it against ß-lactamases, and, like meropenem, has some stability against human renal dehydropeptidase I . Doripenem inhibits the growth of nonfermenters as well as members of the family Enterobacteriaceae, anaerobes, and gram-positive cocci (23) . In the present investigation we studied its antipseudomonal activity in detail . This is critical for any carbapenem, not only because carbapenems are among the most powerful antipseudomonal agents, but also because imipenem and meropenem differ in their antipseudomonal behaviors, both from each other and from other ß-lactams (12) . Unlike the cephalosporins and piperacillin, neither imipenem nor meropenem is affected by derepression of the AmpC ß-lactamase or by most of the acquired ß-lactamases that occur in the species (3, 15); however, imipenem and, to a lesser degree, meropenem are compromised by loss of the carbapenem-specific porin OprD . Meropenem, but not imipenem, is also affected by up-regulation of efflux, although this mechanism rarely confers frank resistance (12) . Both imipenem and meropenem are hydrolyzed by the IMP, SPM, and VIM metallo-ß-lactamases now gradually emerging in the species (16, 22) .
MIC determinations. MICs were determined on Mueller-Hinton agar (Oxoid, Basingstoke, United Kingdom) by the method of the National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards (NCCLS) (20) . The drugs tested were doripenem (lot no . CF 2066; manufactured by Shionogi & Co., Ltd., Osaka, Japan), ertapenem and imipenem (Merck, Hoddesdon, United Kingdom), meropenem (AstraZeneca, Macclesfield, United Kingdom), ceftazidime (GlaxoSmithKline, Stevenage, United Kingdom), cefepime (Bristol Myers Squibb, Hounslow, United Kingdom), and piperacillin and tazobactam (Wyeth, Taplow, United Kingdom) . Tazobactam was used at 4 µg/ml in combination with piperacillin . Ciprofloxacin (Bayer, Newbury, United Kingdom), levofloxacin (Aventis, Uxbridge, United Kingdom), and carbenicillin and tobramycin (Sigma, Poole, United Kingdom) were used for mutant selection . Mutant selection. Single-step mutants were selected by plating ca . 5 x 108 CFU, in 100-µl volumes, from duplicate overnight broth cultures onto 9-cm-diameter plates with Mueller-Hinton agar containing antibiotics at doubling concentrations from 2 to 16 times the MIC . Any colonies that grew after overnight incubation at 37°C were counted . Mutation frequencies were calculated, and the results of duplicate plate counts on antibiotic-free agar were taken as the denominator . Multistep mutants were selected by growing the bacteria overnight in 10 ml of cation-adjusted Mueller-Hinton broth, initially with the antibiotic at one-half the MIC . One hundred microliters of these cultures was then transferred to fresh broth with double the original antibiotic concentration, and the culture was reincubated overnight . This process was repeated for up to 12 cycles, with the drug concentration doubled after each cycle or until no further increase in resistance could be obtained . The MICs of the selective drugs and other agents were determined after the 3rd, 6th, 9th, and 12th cycles and/or after the last cycle at which growth was obtained . Serotyping by slide agglutination by the International Antigenic Typing Scheme was used to confirm that the organisms recovered postselection were not contaminants . Molecular characterization of mutants. Outer membrane proteins were extracted from logarithmic-phase cultures with sodium lauroyl sarkosinate and profiled by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis by the method of Chart (2) . ß-Lactamase specific activities were measured with crude sonicates prepared from cells grown as described above for the outer membrane protein studies; 0.1 mM nitrocefin in 0.1 M phosphate buffer (pH 7.0) was the assay substrate, with activity measured by spectrophotometry at 482 nm at 37°C and standardized against the protein concentration .
Activity against P . aeruginosa PU21 transconjugants. None of the class A and D ß-lactamases introduced into strain PU21 caused a substantial increase in the carbapenem MICs, although 1- to 2-dilution effects were seen for transconjugants with several OXA-10-related enzymes, including OXA-10 itself and OXA-14 (Table 1) . These effects were least evident with imipenem and were stronger with doripenem, meropenem, and ertapenem . Extended-spectrum class A (PER-1) and D (OXA-11, -14, -16, -101, and -103) enzymes conferred resistance to all the cephalosporins, aztreonam, and piperacillin-tazobactam . All the enzymes conferred protection against piperacillin-tazobactam in P . aeruginosa . Activity against metallo-ß-lactamase producers. The MICs for P . aeruginosa isolates with metallo-ß-lactamases are shown in Table 1 . Except for one IMP-7 producer (P/6330), these organisms were unequivocally resistant to doripenem and other carbapenems; P/6330 had reduced susceptibility to doripenem and was resistant to the other carbapenems . The metallo-ß-lactamase producers were also broadly resistant to noncarbapenems, except that 12 of the 15 had moderately retained susceptibilities (MICs, 8 to 16 µg/ml) to aztreonam, and P/6330 (again) appeared to be susceptible to ceftazidime . Single-step mutant selection. Mutant selection was performed as a single-step procedure for eight P . aeruginosa strains . Four strains (strains A, B, C, and D) were carbapenem susceptible and nonmucoid, three strains (strains E, F, and G) were carbapenem susceptible and mucoid, and one strain (strain H) was nonmucoid and had an OprD phenotype . One mucoid strain (strain G) was supersusceptible to penicillins, cephalosporins, and aztreonam; all the others (including the OprD organism, strain H) had normal levels of susceptibility to these drugs, typical of those for the species as a whole . The abilities of the antibiotics to select mutants is summarized in Table 2 . Mutant selection with doripenem occurred with fewer of the strains than with the other compounds, and the final multiple of the MIC achieved was lower for doripenem than for other agents, never exceeding quadruple the starting MIC . By contrast, ceftazidime, for example, selected single-step mutants for which the MICs increased up to 32-fold . The patterns of the increases in the MICs for the mutants selected with particular antibiotics mostly showed considerable consistency among the different strains, and the geometric mean fold increases are therefore shown in Table 2 as summary parameters . For most mutants selected with carbapenems, including doripenem, and all those selected with imipenem only, the MICs of carbapenems, not other ß-lactams, were increased by fourfold or more . Occasional exceptions to this generalization, particularly among the mutants selected with meropenem and among the mutants of strain G selected with ertapenem, were organisms with broader cross-resistance, including to noncarbapenems as well as carbapenems .
Multistep mutant selection. Strains A, B, G, and H were used for multistep selection, which was continued for up to 12 cycles . In practice, however, the maximum achievable levels of resistance were reached after five to seven cycles . Multistep mutants mostly (and unsurprisingly) showed broader cross-resistance than single-step mutants . The increases in the carbapenem MICs were eightfold or greater for all six mutants selected with doripenem after three to five cycles; and those of cefepime, ceftazidime, aztreonam, and piperacillin-tazobactam were also increased (Table 3) . These mutants were of the same serotypes as their parent organisms, discounting any possibility that they were contaminants that had entered the culture during the selection procedure . Similar cross-resistance profiles were seen for mutants selected with meropenem, whereas for mutants selected with imipenem, carbapenem MICs increased four- to eightfold, but, with rare exceptions, the increases in the MICs of the other ß-lactams were only twofold, at most . The MICs of the cephalosporins, aztreonam, piperacillin-tazobactam, and, in most cases, ertapenem increased eightfold or greater for multistep mutants selected with ceftazidime, whereas the increases in the MICs of the carbapenems were mostly only twofold . The MICs of all carbapenem and noncarbapenem drugs except imipenem mostly increased eightfold for the multistep mutants selected with carbenicillin; for imipenem, however, the increases in the MICs were twofold or less except with mutants of strain G . The MIC profiles for multistep mutants selected with levofloxacin and tobramycin showed a diverse scatter, but most mutants had little or no cross-resistance to the ß-lactams, including doripenem .
Profiling of mutants selected with doripenem. Outer membrane proteins and ß-lactamase production were investigated for three single-step and two multistep mutants selected with doripenem and, as a control, one single-step mutant selected with imipenem . The MICs for these organisms are shown in Table 4 . Among the single-step mutants, two (D2/DORI/X2/3 and D2/DORI/X2/5) were cross-resistant only to carbapenems, whereas small but consistent increases in the MICs of the noncarbapenems were seen for the third mutant (B1/DORI/X4/1) . The first two organisms mentioned above and the control mutant selected with imipenem were found to have lost OprD (Fig . 2), whereas this protein was retained by B1/DORI/X4/1 . The loss of OprD was also apparent in the two multistep mutants profiled, although these organisms almost certainly had additional mechanisms . None of the single-step mutants showed increased levels of ß-lactamase expression, although one of the multistep mutants showed a small increase in the level of ß-lactamase expression, measured as specific activity (Table 4) .
The loss of OprD increased the doripenem MICs (Table 1), suggesting that, like other carbapenems, doripenem uses this porin to enter the pseudomonal cell . Nevertheless, resistance among OprD organisms also required functional AmpC and was lost in AmpC-DEF mutants, as was also found previously for imipenem (14) . These data suggest that some slow doripenem hydrolysis occurs under periplasmic conditions; and the implication, not yet exploited, is that a completely stable carbapenem analogue would be little affected by the loss of OprD or that a carbapenem might be made fully active against OprD mutants by combining it with an inhibitor of AmpC (17) . Like other carbapenems, doripenem lost activity against isolates with IMP and VIM enzymes . Although still uncommon, the gradual spread of these class B metallo-ß-lactamases is a concern . Until 1997, 12 years after the launch of imipenem, only IMP-1 was known and had been found almost exclusively in Japan . Subsequently, the list of IMP variants has grown to 16, with at least 10 VIM types and 1 SPM type also described and with these enzymes recordedmostly from P . aeruginosain every populated continent except Australia (16, 22) . One outbreak of a serotype O12 P . aeruginosa strain with a VIM carbapenemase in Greece persisted for over 3 years and involved over 200 isolates (16) . In contrast to class B metallo-ß-lactamases, the transfer of various class A and D (serine) ß-lactamases into strain PU21 had little effect on the doripenem MICs, although small increases were seen with OXA-10 and its variants . Similar effects were seen with meropenem and ertapenem, and these results are at variance with earlier results for these comparator carbapenems (4-8) . This difference may reflect the use here of Mueller-Hinton agar and the NCCLS methodology, whereas earlier studies used Iso-Sensitest and Diagnostic Sensitivity Test agars with slightly smaller inocula . The significance is unclear, and in any event, OXA-10 variants are rare and largely confined to Turkey . As with other antipseudomonal drugs, in vitro resistance to doripenem could be selected . Nevertheless, the frequency of mutants resistant to two to four times the starting MIC was lower for doripenem than for the other carbapenems and noncarbapenems tested, and single-step mutants for which increases in MICs were eightfold or greater could not be selected from any of eight strains investigated . The other carbapenems selected mutants from among more of the test strains, and several noncarbapenems, notably including ceftazidime, selected single-step mutants for which increases in MICs were up to 32-fold . Doripenem predominantly selected OprD mutants, the MICs for which were mostly 4 to 8 µg/ml; but, like meropenem and unlike imipenem, it also had some propensity to select other mutant phenotypes with broader low-level resistance (e.g., mutant B1/DORI/X4/1 [Table 4]) . The latter organisms probably had some form of up-regulated efflux . Mutants with this phenotype were predominantly selected by carbenicillin, a compound well known to select for efflux-type variants (21) . Whereas most of these mutant selection results were predictable, the studies did give some surprises, notably, the propensity of strain G, with a very low level of intrinsic resistance to ß-lactams, to yield variants selected with carbapenem with broad-spectrum resistance rather than OprD phenotypes . It is unclear whether the phenomenon was peculiar to strain G or is representative of other strains with low levels of intrinsic resistance . It is likewise unclear why ciprofloxacin tended to select mutants with cross-resistance to carbapenemsputatively nfxC or mexT types (15)from strain D but not from the other organisms . Most of the multistep mutants selected with doripenem or meropenem had cross-resistance to noncarbapenem ß-lactams as well as to imipenem and the other carbapenems, implying that efflux was a component in their behavior, along with the loss of OprD . Those mutants selected with imipenem, by contrast, were mostly resistant only to carbapenems, supporting the view that the selectivity of this agent is almost exclusively for OprD mutants . Although fluoroquinolones and even aminoglycosides can select for efflux types in P . aeruginosa or, in the case of fluoroquinolones, can select for mexT (nfxC) mutants, which have up-regulated MexEF-OprN efflux and down-regulated OprD, few of the levofloxacin or tobramycin mutants showed any cross-resistance to any carbapenem . In summary, the behavior of doripenem greatly resembled that of meropenem, but a few differences may be significant . First, doripenem MICs tended to be lower than those of meropenem for strains with elevated levels of intrinsic resistance, and doripenem seemed to have a lesser propensity to select for resistant mutants than meropenem, perhaps because such mutants tended to be slightly less resistant to doripenem than to meropenem . Whether or not these differences translate into any significant advantage will be revealed only by comprehensive clinical investigations .
What Is Protein?,
What Is Growth Medium?,
What Is Rhizobia?,
What Is Molecular Biology?,
What Is Biotechnology?,
e,
Bacterium,
r,
Microorganism,
n,
Bacteria,
o,
Microorganisms,
s,
Bacteriology,
e,
Bacillus subtilis,
s,
Cell cultures,
n,
S. cerevisiae,
a,
Antibiotics,
a,
Escherichia coli,
o,
Bacteria,
s,
Streptococcal,
c,
Ps. fluorescens,
s,
Cell suspensions,
e,
Multidrug resistant,
r,
Flavobacterium,
o,
Streptomycin,
e,
Microbial,
n,
Microbial,
e,
Microbiological,
s,
Microorganism,
e,
Enterobacteriacea,
c,
Bacillus subtilis,
n,
Microorganisms,
a,
Streptococcal,
e,
S. cerevisiae
|
© 2005
Transgalactic Ltd (manufacturer of Bioscreen C software) |
Privacy Statement | P.O. Box
1393, 00101 Helsinki, Finland,
Last modified: May 25, 2005
| ||||||