|
|
|
Journal of Bacteriology, November 2003, p . 6540-6547, Vol . 185, No . 22 Assembly of TolC, a Structurally Unique and Multifunctional Outer Membrane Protein of Escherichia coli K-12
John Werner,1 Anne Marie Augustus,2, Molecular and Cellular Biology Graduate Program,1 Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry,2 Department of Microbiology, Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona 852873 Received 13 May 2003/ Accepted 20 August 2003
Several periplasmic proteins have been identified that function as chaperones or foldases to assist OMP assembly (12, 30) . Skp is thought to be a general chaperone because denatured OmpF, but not the native form, was shown to bind to it in vitro (9) . Consistent with this, it was found that the skp null mutant had drastically reduced OMP levels (9) . Although the original genetic observation did not withstand further scrutiny, additional biochemical (6, 35) and genetic (33) experiments reiterated the role of Skp as a chaperone . Among foldases, SurA (23, 34), FkpA (2, 29), and PpiD (13) represent periplasmic proteins that catalyze peptidyl prolyl cis-trans isomerization (PPIase) in vitro . However, despite their in vitro PPIase activity, it has not been demonstrated that these proteins influence OMP assembly by affecting the cis-trans isomerization of proline peptide bonds . In fact, both SurA (4) and FkpA (2) have been shown to assist in OMP assembly independent of their isomerase activities . Moreover, FkpA has been reported to influence protein folding independent of the presence of cis-prolines (5) . In light of this, it is conceivable that SurA and FkpA promote OMP assembly by acting as general chaperones . The periplasm also contains proteins that catalyze disulfide bond formation (3) . However, since many OMPs, including porins and TolC, the subject of this study, do not contain cysteine residues, they assemble independent of the disulfide isomerase activity . A periplasmic protease, DegP, has received the most attention in connection with OMP assembly . degP null mutants do not grow at growth temperatures above 39°C (24, 40), presumably because of a greater need for the removal of misfolded proteins at elevated temperatures . However, expression of certain misfolded OMPs renders DegP's presence essential at lower growth temperatures (8, 27) . Both biochemical (38) and genetic (33) studies have suggested that DegP can also function as a chaperone . Not all OMPs follow the same assembly pathway involving common assembly factors . Such exceptions are typified by the outer membrane lipoproteins, whose targeting and assembly rely on five dedicated proteins, LolABCDE (25, 43) . This variation most likely reflects the posttranslocational modifications and other structural distinctiveness of lipoproteins . This raises an interesting question of whether other OMPs with a distinct folded structure may also ensue novel targeting and assembly pathways . With this in mind, we examined the assembly of TolC, whose three-dimensional structure and barrel composition are astonishingly different from characteristics of other OMPs used in biogenesis studies .
TolC is a minor but functionally important OMP . It is involved in hemolysin secretion (42, 44), colicin import (10, 14), and antibiotic efflux (16) . It is also exploited by a bacteriophage as a cell surface receptor (17) . The folded structure of TolC is novel in that it forms an extended
Radioactive labeling and assembly assays. Cells were grown overnight at 37°C on minimal medium with glycerol as the carbon source . The following day, cultures were diluted 50-fold with the same medium and grown to mid-log phase (optical density at 600 nm = 0.3 to 0.35) . Ten minutes prior to labeling, 0.01 mM IPTG was added to the cultures to induce TolC synthesis . Cells were labeled as described previously (28) . Labeled cells were pelleted by spinning tubes in a microcentrifuge at 14,000 x g for 15 min at 4°C . To allow proteinase K to enter the periplasm, the outer membrane was permeabilized by resuspending the cells in a buffer containing 20% sucrose, 20 mM Tris-HCl (pH 8.0), 10 mM EDTA, and 0.5% Triton X-100 and incubated for 10 min at 4°C . Proteinase K was then added to a final concentration of 10 µg/ml, and tubes were further incubated for 10 min at 30°C . The protease inhibitor phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride (PMSF; 1 mM) was added to inactivate the protease . Membrane proteins were extracted from pelleted cells by the gentle detergent lysis procedure as described previously (26, 28) . Labeled cell extracts were mixed with an immunoprecipitation buffer (1% Triton X-100, 50 mM Tris-HCl; pH 7.5) containing appropriate antibodies and incubated rocking at 4°C for a minimum of 4 h . The immunocomplexes were precipitated with Pansorbin . The immunoprecipitates were washed several times and analyzed by sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) . The gels were dried and exposed to X-ray films at -80°C . Protein bands were scanned and quantified using ImageQuant software (Molecular Dynamics) . Fractionation procedures. The French press lysis method was used to separate the soluble (cytoplasm and periplasm) and insoluble (inner and outer membranes) fractions (28) . To isolate the periplasm, a gentle osmotic shock method was performed (2) . Labeled cell pellets were resuspended in a buffer containing 0.5% sucrose, 10 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.5), 200 µg of lysozyme/ml, and 10 mM EDTA to permeabilize the outer membrane . This mixture was incubated at 4°C for 20 min . The cells were centrifuged at 14,000 x g for 15 min at 4°C . The supernatant, now containing the periplasm, was removed and treated with proteinase K as described above . PMSF (1 mM) was added to inactivate the protease, and immunoprecipitation was carried out using appropriate antibodies . Western blot analysis. Whole-cell extracts were analyzed on mini SDS-PAGE gels and transferred onto polyvinylidene difluoride membranes (Immobilon-Millipore) . After transfer, the membranes were incubated for 1.5 h with primary antibodies raised against LamB, maltose-binding protein (MBP), or TolC . The membranes were washed, and secondary antibodies (goat anti-rabbit alkaline phosphatase-conjugated immunoglobulin G) were added for 1 h . The membranes were exposed to ECF substrate for 5 min and analyzed using a phosphorimager .
The results presented in Fig . 1B and C showed that although some TolC molecules had already attained the characteristic protease-resistant state at the earliest chase point, the majority of TolC molecules present at the first chase point were protease sensitive . Gradually, all TolC molecules matured into a form that produced the characteristic membrane-anchored 46-kDa fragments . These results showed that TolC progresses through a protease-sensitive state to a protease-resistant state during assembly . Localization of assembly intermediates. An element concerning TolC's assembly involves identifying various assembly intermediates based on their cellular location . Of course, the fully assembled product of TolC is localized in the outer membrane, but nothing is known about the localization of assembly intermediates . This is important to determine, because it will shed light on the cellular pathway TolC takes to get to the outer membrane . Two popular models of OMP assembly evoke that either nascent polypeptides of OMPs are dumped into a soluble periplasmic environment or they remain associated, albeit weakly, with the inner membrane and reach the outer membrane through membrane contact sites . As the physiological significance of such contact sites remains unclear, the discovery of several periplasmic OMP assembly factors has given greater impetus to the notion of soluble OMP assembly intermediates .
Our fractionation analyses entailed two methods . The first method separated the soluble cytoplasmic and periplasmic fractions from the insoluble fractions of inner and outer membranes . The second method aided in the isolation of the soluble periplasmic fraction . To assist in the isolation of soluble and insoluble contents, [35S]methionine-cysteine-labeled cells (
The result presented in Fig . 2C showed that during the early steps of biogenesis, TolC was present in the periplasm but then disappeared around 10 min postchase . As observed for the soluble fraction in Fig . 2A, TolC present in the periplasmic fraction was sensitive to proteinase K . Since cultures were induced with maltose prior to pulse-chase analysis, LamB was also examined as a control protein . No soluble assembly intermediates of LamB were detected (Fig . 2C) . Unlike the periplasmic fraction, LamB was present in periplasm-free shocked cell pellets (Fig . 2D) . It is important to emphasize that the purity of the periplasmic fraction is critical to our claim for the existence of TolC assembly intermediates in the periplasm . Results presented in Fig . 2C showed that periplasmic fractions from all five chase samples were entirely free of any contamination from the assembled (protease-resistant) forms of TolC and LamB and, thus, insoluble membrane fractions . These results unequivocally demonstrate that prior to assembling in the outer membrane, the proteinase K-sensitive TolC intermediates first emerge in the periplasm . The role of known assembly factors in TolC assembly. Several assembly factors have been identified through studies involving model OMPs (12, 30) . These include SurA, a periplasmic peptidyl prolyl cis-trans isomerase (23, 34), Skp, a presumed general chaperone (6, 9, 35), DegP, a periplasmic protease (24, 40) that is also proposed to possess a general chaperone activity (38), and LPS, which is thought to be involved in the assembly of all trimeric OMPs (22) . We examined the effect of null (surA, skp, and degP) or mutant (LPS) alleles of these factors on the assembly of TolC . The initial examination involved Western blot analysis in which the steady-state levels of TolC, LamB, and MBP were examined (Fig . 3A and B) . The latter two proteins served as outer membrane (LamB) and periplasmic (MBP) protein controls . As expected, the level of LamB was reduced in mutant surA and deep-rough LPS backgrounds, whereas MBP levels remained unaltered (Fig . 3A) . In contrast, no reduction in TolC level was observed in either mutant background (Fig . 3B) . We failed to see any reduction in LamB and TolC levels in an skp null background (Fig . 3A and B) . Similarly, the level of TolC, like that of LamB and MBP, was unaffected in a degP null background (data not shown) .
Isolation and characterization of assembly-defective TolC mutants. OMP mutants defective in assembly have been extremely valuable in (i) dissecting the assembly steps (26, 28), (ii) identifying individual residues that play an important role in assembly (26), and (iii) revealing the cellular factors involved in the assembly (15, 19, 26) . We anticipate that this class of TolC mutant would be equally valuable in providing insights into its assembly pathway . The basic premise behind isolating assembly-defective TolC mutants is that such mutants may also display a generally compromised TolC phenotype due to reduced TolC levels . In an attempt to isolate assembly-defective TolC mutants, we exploited a strategy principally designed to isolate TolC efflux mutants . As noted previously (16), TolC is the outer membrane component of an efflux pump consisting of AcrA and AcrB proteins; null mutations in any one of the three genes display a hypersensitivity phenotype . If we were to mutagenize plasmids carrying the tolC gene, only those mutations mapping in tolC would contribute to a hypersensitive phenotype in a genetic background lacking the chromosomal tolC gene . A plasmid tolC clone was constructed that produces TolC at a level similar to that produced from the chromosomal allele . Random tolC mutations were generated by allowing the replication of the tolC plasmid in a mutator strain (mutT, mutS, or mutD) . Mutagenized plasmid DNA was transformed into a genetic background lacking the chromosomal tolC allele . Transformed bacterial colonies were screened by replica plating for their ability to grow on medium containing low or high concentrations of novobiocin, an antibiotic that is normally extruded by the TolC-AcrA/B pump . We concentrated on colonies that grew on low (5 µg/ml) but not on high (50 µg/ml) concentrations of novobiocin, because both the desired class of assembly mutants as well as efflux mutants are expected to be present among them . Colonies that fail to grow on plates containing 5 µg of novobiocin/ml are likely to contain tolC null mutations . On the other hand, colonies that are able to grow on a medium containing a high (50 µg/ml) novobiocin concentration presumably synthesize TolC with normal assembly and efflux activity . The above genetic strategy led to the isolation of two TolC mutants that had reduced TolC levels . DNA sequence analysis of the plasmid tolC gene revealed the presence of point mutations, resulting in the I106N or S350F substitution in the mature portion of the protein . Low TolC levels in these mutants indicated that either the assembly intermediates or assembled molecules are unstable . We carried out assembly assays to test whether the two mutants carrying an I106N or S350F substitution are assembly defective . The results presented in Fig . 4 reveal two interesting observations concerning mutant TolC's assembly: first, unlike wild-type TolC (Fig . 4A) where the level of trimer antibody-recognizable forms reaches a plateau around 10 min postchase, in the mutants a plateau was not reached even after 60 min of chase (Fig . 4B and C) . Secondly, in the case of wild-type TolC, biogenesis of the proteinase K-resistant form closely followed that of total TolC, and by 60 min virtually all TolC molecules had adopted the proteinase K-resistant conformation . In contrast, the mutant proteins assumed the proteinase K-resistant conformation extremely slowly and remained largely proteinase K sensitive even after 60 min of chase .
Fractionation studies revealed two topologically distinct TolC populations . The first population primarily appeared during the early chase period and was comprised of soluble molecules present in the periplasm . This population presumably represented a mixture of nascent mature polypeptides and unassembled TolC molecules . The second population predominantly appeared during the later chase period and was membrane bound . This species likely corresponded to fully assembled TolC molecules, since TolC from steady-state cultures also behaves this way . These topologically distinct populations could also be differentiated based on their protease sensitivity patterns . The soluble periplasmic population was fully sensitive to proteinase K, while the membrane-bound TolC produced the distinct proteinase K-sensitive band of fully assembled TolC . Based on these results, we summarize that the assembly of TolC begins with the emergence of soluble, protease-sensitive intermediates in the periplasm . These soluble intermediates may represent multiple assembly ensembles, including nascent mature monomers, folded monomers, and soluble trimers . The insertion of soluble trimers into the outer membrane, perhaps followed by some additional conformational changes as seen in the metastable-to-stable trimer transition of OmpF (26) and LamB (28), completes the assembly process . It is interesting that, unlike TolC, no soluble LamB assembly intermediates were detected . The existence of soluble LamB intermediates has been hypothesized from genetic data showing that LamB assembly is severely affected in the absence of SurA, a periplasmic foldase (34) . The lack of a detectable soluble LamB assembly intermediate may reflect its rapid conversion into membrane-bound forms (28) . On the other hand, membrane insertion may be a rate-limiting step in TolC assembly where, unlike LamB, trimerization most likely precedes insertion into the outer membrane . Soluble assembly intermediates of OmpF and PhoE have been reported (for a review, see reference 12) . Known assembly factors do not affect TolC assembly. Several periplasmic (e.g., SurA and Skp) and outer membrane (LPS) factors have been implicated in the assembly of model OMPs, particularly that of porins and LamB (12) . However, in a sharp contrast to these OMPs, we show here that the in vivo assembly of TolC appeared to be unaffected in a genetic background lacking either SurA or Skp or producing a truncated LPS core . This would suggest that (i) TolC assembly intermediates fold in a unique manner, and (ii) novel assembly factors may be involved in TolC assembly . It is worth emphasizing that while we observed no obvious effect of SurA or Skp on TolC assembly, it could be due to the existence of redundant cellular activities . For examples, there are at least two other periplasmic peptidyl prolyl cis-trans isomerases (2, 13, 29) that may compensate for the loss of SurA . Curiously, however, such compensation has not been seen in the case of OmpF and LamB, suggesting a more direct role for SurA, perhaps as a chaperone (4) rather than as a peptidyl prolyl cis-trans isomerase, on OMP assembly . Interestingly, while TolC assembly is independent of the LPS core, certain TolC-dependent activities, such as phage infection (17) and hemolysin secretion (39), are drastically affected by the composition of the LPS core . Insight on TolC assembly through mutant analysis. Mutants that influence various assembly steps can be powerful tools in dissecting the assembly pathway . With this in mind, we sought TolC assembly mutants through exploiting TolC's role in antibiotic efflux . We surmised that reduced TolC levels would negatively affect the cell's ability to pump out antibiotics, thus leading to a hypersensitivity phenotype . A TolC mutant-screening method was devised that eliminated null mutants and differentiated isolates with reduced efflux activity from those that maintained full activity . Two TolC mutants bearing I106N and S350F substitutions had an intermediate efflux activity and were defective in assembly, respectively . Assembly and fractionation analyses revealed that while both mutant proteins were severely impaired in acquiring the membrane-bound conformation of fully assembled molecules, they were defective in different stages of assembly . Even though the periplasmic species of TolCI106N was depleted at the same rate as the wild-type TolC protein, its failure to assume the characteristic proteinase K-resistant pattern suggested rapid turnover of the soluble assembly intermediates . In contrast to TolCI106N, the soluble, periplasmic species of TolCS350F was surprisingly impervious to degradation, and over 70% of it persisted even after 60 min of chase . The perseverance of the soluble TolCS350F species showed that its conformation is significantly different from that of the highly labile TolCI106N species . The crystal structure of TolC revealed that I106 is part of a hydrophobic cluster that stabilizes neighboring helices within a monomer (20) . Assuming that the formation of this hydrophobic cluster and helix stabilization occurs during the commencement of the folding process, their destabilization would negatively impact the initial stages of assembly . Thus, the substitution of I106 with N most likely interferes with the folding of nascent monomers . This is consistent with the rapid turnover of soluble TolCI106N molecules, in which the unfolded monomers presumably constitute the largest fraction . The S350F substitution likely interferes with the stabilization of subunit interactions, since S350 forms hydrogen bonds with D162 of the neighboring subunit (20) . Moreover, due to its location in the folded molecule, the S350F substitution is less likely to interfere with the early folding events involving nascent polypeptide chains . Again, this is consistent with our observation that the accumulated periplasmic species of TolCS350F is highly stable, suggesting that monomers have assumed a folded conformation that renders them resistant to degradation by periplasmic proteases . Based on this, we propose that a defect in the oligomerization event blocks the insertion of a soluble but folded species of TolCS350F in the outer membrane . Thus, unlike TolCI106N, the assembly of TolCS350F is defective at a later stage of assembly involving trimerization and membrane insertion . The TolC barrel structure is unique in that it is made up of three monomers . This suggests that at least the ß-barrel portion must assemble in the periplasm prior to inserting in the outer membrane . We assert this because the monomer interface has large exposed hydrophilic surfaces that would make it energetically unfavorable for the ß-strand regions of TolC to be exposed to the hydrophobic environment of the outer membrane . However, if the monomers associate with other monomers to first form a trimer in the periplasm, the assembled ß-barrel trimer would assume a conformation suitable for membrane insertion . The TolCS350F protein, which appears to be defective in the formation of stable trimers, is also defective in membrane insertion, which lends further support to the notion that the trimerization of TolC monomers precedes their insertion in the outer membrane . We have previously reported that the expression of assembly-defective OMPs in a genetic background lacking a major periplasmic protease, DegP, confers lethality (8, 27) . Interestingly, we failed to see such lethality when the assembly-defective TolC proteins were expressed, even though the absence of DegP increased the level of mutant proteins, suggesting that DegP is one of the proteases responsible for the degradation of mutant TolC (data not shown) .
The work presented in this study showed that cellular factors that drastically influence the assembly of other model OMPs have no effect on the assembly of TolC . Perhaps this is reflective of the novel structure of TolC, which involves an unusually large, periplasmically exposed,
J.W . is the recipient of a graduate assistantship from the Molecular and Cellular Graduate Program . A.M.A . was sponsored by the BREU program . This work was supported by National Institutes of Health grant GM48167 to R.M .
What Is Water Purification?,
What Is Fermentation?,
What Is Amino Acid?,
What Is Dna?,
What Is Bioengineering?,
a,
Microbiology,
s,
Microbe,
i,
Microorganisms,
c,
Bacteriology,
e,
Microbes,
o,
Activated sludge,
a,
Microbiological,
c,
Prokaryotes,
n,
Escherichia coli,
n,
Escherichia coli,
a,
Listeriosis,
c,
Staphylococcus aureus,
o,
Microbial,
i,
Bacteriological,
r,
Bactericidal,
a,
Escherichia coli,
s,
Escherichia coli,
c,
Yeasts,
i,
Bactericidal,
n,
Gram negative,
r,
Bacillus,
c,
Escherichia coli,
i,
Haemophilus,
i,
Microorganisms,
o,
Denitrifying,
c,
Pseudomonas aeruginosa
|
© 2005
Transgalactic Ltd (manufacturer of Bioscreen C software) |
Privacy Statement | P.O. Box
1393, 00101 Helsinki, Finland,
Last modified: May 25, 2005
| ||||||