|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, January 2004, p . 200-206, Vol . 186,
No . 1
Surfaces of Spo0A and RNA Polymerase Sigma Factor A That Interact at the
spoIIG Promoter in Bacillus subtilis
Amrita Kumar, Cindy Buckner Starke, Mark DeZalia, and Charles P .
Moran Jr.*
Department of Microbiology and Immunology, Emory University School of
Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia 30322
Received 10 September 2003/ Accepted 9 October 2003
In Bacillus subtilis, the DNA binding protein Spo0A activates
transcription from two classes of promoters, those used by RNA
polymerase containing the primary sigma factor,
A
(e.g., spoIIG), and those used by RNA polymerase containing
the secondary sigma factor,
H
(e.g., spoIIA) . Several single amino acid substitutions in
region 4 of
A
define positions in
A
that are specifically required for Spo0A-dependent promoter
activation . Similarly, several single amino acid substitutions in
Spo0A define positions in Spo0A that are required for
A-dependent
promoter activation but not for other functions of Spo0A . It is
unknown whether these amino acids in Spo0A interact directly with
those in region 4 of
A
or whether they interact with another subunit of RNA polymerase to
effect promoter activation . Here we report the identification of a
new amino acid in region 4 of
A,
arginine at position 355 (R355), that is involved in Spo0A-dependent
promoter activation . To further investigate the role of R355,
we used the coordinates of Spo0A and sigma region 4, each in complex
with DNA, to build a model for the interaction of
A
and Spo0A at the spoIIG promoter . We tested the model by examining
the effects of amino acid substitutions in the putative interacting
surfaces of these molecules . As predicted by the model, we found
genetic evidence for interaction of R355 of
A
with glutamine at position 221 of Spo0A . These results appear to
define the surfaces of Spo0A and
A
that directly interact during activation of the spoIIG
promoter .
Spo0A from Bacillus subtilis is a member of the response regulator
class of two-component signal transducing systems (reviewed in
reference 13) . Activation of Spo0A by phosphorylation
triggers the onset of endospore development . Active Spo0A binds to
DNA at a 7-bp sequence, referred to as the 0A box (2,
26), to positively or negatively regulate the
expression of a large number of genes (7) . Spo0A
activates transcription from two classes of promoters, those used by
RNA polymerase containing the primary sigma factor,
A
(e.g., spoIIG and spoIIE promoters [22,
30]), and those used by RNA polymerase containing
the secondary sigma factor,
H
(e.g., the spoIIA promoter [19,
29]) . Spo0A may activate the
A-dependent
promoters by interacting directly with the
A
subunit of the RNA polymerase . Baldus et al . (1)
found that spoIIG and spoIIE promoter activity was
reduced in mutants of B . subtilis in which
A
contained one of two single amino acid substitutions in region 4,
with the lysine at position 356 replaced by glutamate (K356E) or the
histidine at 359 replaced by arginine (H359R) . However, these
substitutions did not affect the utilization of
A-dependent,
Spo0A-independent promoters or
H-dependent,
Spo0A-dependent promoters . Alanine substitutions at these sites in
A
produced similar effects (1) . Therefore, these
substitutions define positions in region 4 of
A
that are essential specifically for Spo0A-dependent activation of the
spoIIG and spoIIE promoters .
A specific region of Spo0A is required to activate the
A-dependent
promoters, such as spoIIG . This region has been defined by several
single amino acid substitutions (4, 11,
14) . For example, substitution of alanine for
isoleucine at position 229 of Spo0A (4) or for
threonine at position 239 (14) reduces activation of the
A-dependent
spoIIG promoter, but does not severely affect activation of
the
H-dependent
spoIIA promoter . The structure of the Spo0A DNA binding domain
has been determined by X-ray crystallography for both free Spo0A and
Spo0A in complex with DNA (15, 31) .
Interestingly, all mutations in Spo0A specifically affecting
the ability of
A-dependent
RNA polymerase to activate transcription cluster in
-helix
E, a flexible helix in the C terminus of the protein that is
positioned away from the core structure of the protein .
A simple model to account for the requirements for specific amino
acids in region 4 of
A
and amino acids of
-helix
E of Spo0A suggests that these surfaces interact directly during
Spo0A-dependent promoter activation . Some support for this model
comes from the finding that a single amino acid substitution in
-helix
E of Spo0A, with a serine at position 231 replaced by phenylalanine
(S231F), partially suppresses the effect of the
A
H359R substitution (4) . However, the Spo0A S231F mutation
also partially suppresses the effects of the H359A and K356E
substitutions in
A
and the S231F Spo0A mutant efficiently stimulates wild-type
A
RNA polymerase . Because the Spo0A suppressor mutation S231F does not
display an allele-specific suppression of the sporulation defect
caused by the H359R mutation in
A,
it is unlikely that the phenylalanine at position 231 in the mutant
Spo0A interacts directly with the arginine at 359 in the mutant
A .
Perhaps the Spo0A S231F mutant creates a form of Spo0A that interacts
with another position of
A
or in another subunit of RNA polymerase . Therefore, whether region 4
of
A
interacts directly with
-helix
E of Spo0A is unknown .
Here we report genetic evidence for an interaction between region
4 of
A
and Spo0A . We found an intragenic sigA suppressor mutation
resulting in substitution of tryptophan for arginine at position 355
(R355W) that almost fully suppresses the sporulation defect due to
both the H359R and H359A substitutions in sigA . We used the
coordinates of structures for the C-terminal domain of Spo0A
(C-Spo0A) (15) and C-Spo0A bound to DNA (31)
and for
region 4 from Thermus aquaticus bound to DNA (5)
to model the interactions of Spo0A and
A
at the spoIIG promoter . The resulting model predicts that R355
in region 4 of
A
interacts with the glutamine at position 221 of Spo0A . The effects of
alanine substitutions in
A
and Spo0A on spoIIG promoter activity were consistent with
this model .
Bacterial strains and culture media. Routine microbiological
manipulations and procedures were carried out by standard techniques
as described previously (6) . The concentrations of
antibiotics used for selection in Luria-Bertani (LB) broth or Difco
sporulation medium (DSM) were 5 µg/ml for chloramphenicol, 100 µg/ml
for spectinomycin, 100 µg/ml for ampicillin, and 10 µg/ml for
kanamycin . Cultures were in grown in Luria-Bertani broth, and
sporulation was induced by nutrient exhaustion in DSM . Competent
cells were prepared and transformed by the two-step method as
described previously (6) .
The B . subtilis strains used are listed in Table 1 .
Plasmids derived from pCB2 (4) were used for
inserting various mutations at the wild-type spo0A locus as
described by Kumar et al . (14) . Plasmids derived
from pJB2 (1) were used for inserting various
mutations at the wild-type sigA locus . For creating substitutions
at the sigA locus, pJB2-derived plasmids were digested with
ScaI and transformed into strain JH642 . Chromosomal DNA was
prepared from kanamycin-resistant colonies and subjected to PCR
with primer sets SA104AFOR-Kan60REV and SA3REV-Kan741FOR to indicate
that recombination occurred at the correct location on the
chromosome . The resulting PCR fragment was then sequenced with primer
SA2REV to confirm the presence of the desired mutation .
| TABLE 1 . B . subtilis strains and bacteriophages used for this
study
|
|
The Quick Change site-directed mutagenesis kit (Stratagene, La Jolla,
Calif.) was used to create mutations in spo0A or sigA
that resulted in single alanine substitutions . The combinations of
forward and reverse primers listed in Table 2 were used to
make the single amino acid substitutions in pCB2 or pJB2 . The
resulting new plasmid for each mutation was subjected to sequencing
(Emory University DNA Sequencing Facility) to confirm the presence of
the mutations .
| TABLE 2 . Oligonucleotides used for PCR, sequencing, and mutagenesis
|
|
Sporulation assay. Sporulation was induced by medium exhaustion
in DSM (24) as described previously (6) .
Sporulation efficiency was determined in 36-h cultures as the total
number of heat-resistant (80°C for 20 min) CFU compared with the
total number of CFU before heat treatment . Data presented are
averages of two independent experiments .
EMS mutagenesis and suppressor screen. The mutagenesis
procedure was adapted from the procedure described by Green et al . (9) .
Strain EUB9401 (sigAH359R) was grown in 50 ml of LB liquid
with 10 µg of kanamycin per ml until reaching an optical density at
600 nm of 0.6 . The cells were spun down and resuspended in 1 ml of LB
broth, and various dilutions were plated onto DSM agar and allowed to
dry . A paper disk, to which 3 drops of ethyl methane sulfonate (EMS)
(1.7 g/ml; Sigma) were added, was placed in the center of the plate,
and the cells were incubated at 42°C for 2 days . At that time,
the plates were inverted twice over 400-µl pools of chloroform
for 20 min and then removed from the chloroform exposure for 20 min .
The cells were returned to growing at 42°C overnight . Six
sporulation-proficient (Spo+) survivors, which were able
to form colonies by using nutrients released from the lysed,
nonsporulating cells, were picked off the plates and restreaked, and
single colonies were used to inoculate 10 ml of LB broth . These
cultures were harvested at an optical density at 600 nm of 0.8, and
chromosomal DNA was extracted by use of the Quick Procedure kit (6) .
We determined the nucleotide sequences of the spo0A and
sigA regions for these six strains and found a single base pair
substitution, a transition, that changed codon 355 (TGG) of the
sigA gene, encoding arginine, to CGG, which encodes tryptophan .
This allele was reconstructed in vitro by site-directed PCR
mutagenesis, with either pJB2wtsigA, pJB2sigAH359R, or
pJB2sigAH359A as template (1, 4,
25) . The presence of the single or double
mutations was confirmed by sequencing of the sigA allele in
each plasmid with a Sequenase kit from Amersham . The DNA polymerase
used in all of the above cloning reactions was the high-fidelity
Pfu enzyme from Stratagene . The pJB2sigAR355W, pJB2sigAR355W,H359R,
and pJB2sigAR355W,H359A plasmids were transformed into
JH642 and spore production was measured for each strain by the
sporulation assay .
Structural modeling. To determine if the surface of
A
defined by R355 interacts directly with Spo0A, we used the
coordinates derived from crystal structures of a Spo0A-DNA complex (31)
and region 4 of T . aquaticus
A
in complex with its cognate -35 DNA sequence (5) to
model potential interactions between Spo0A and
A
region 4 at the spoIIG promoter . To align the two structures,
we superimposed the template strand of the -35 DNA element
(5'-TTGACA-3') from the 1.8-Å resolution crystal structure of the
A-DNA
complex (protein database [PDB] no . 1KU7) on the nontemplate strand
of the Spo0A recognition sequence (5'-TTCGACA-3') from the 2.3-Å
resolution crystal structure of the C-Spo0A-DNA complex (PDB no .
1LQ1) and then examined the predicted positions of the two proteins .
Additional models were tested by moving the -35 DNA element
(5'-TTGACA-3') from the
A-DNA
complex (PDB no . 1KU7) downstream at 1-bp intervals from the Spo0A
recognition sequence (5'-TCGACA-3') in the C-Spo0A-DNA complex (PDB
no . 1LQ1) . The DNA in the final model was extended with B-form DNA
such that the final model comprises B-form DNA (-63 to -46), DNA from
sequence 1LQ1 (-45 to -33), with the Spo0A binding sequence centered
at -37 (as in spoIIG), DNA from sequence 1KU7 (-32 to -28),
and further downstream B-form double-stranded DNA (-27 to + 1) . All
modeling was done with the molecular modeling program Sybyl 6.1
(Tripos, Inc.) .
ß-Galactosidase activity. Cultures were grown in duplicate
in DSM with antibiotic (5 mg of chloramphenicol per ml) to initiate
sporulation (t0) . Two 300-µl aliquots of each
culture were collected, one to measure the optical density and the
other to assay ß-galactosidase activity . Enzymatic activity was
averaged from three independent experiments and expressed in Miller
units (12) .
An intragenic suppressor of the sporulation-defective phenotype caused
by the H359R substitution in
A.
During a search for suppressors of the sporulation defect observed in
the strain encoding the
A
H359R substitution, we found an intragenic suppressor . This allele
contained a second site mutation in the sigA gene, resulting
in replacement of the arginine at 355 with a tryptophan (R355W) . We
examined the effect of the R355W substitution on the efficiency of
endospore formation in strains in which the sigA allele
contained, in addition to the R355W substitution, the H359R or H359A
substitution or an otherwise wild-type sigA allele . Strains
EUB9401 and EUC9604 express the H359R and H359A forms of
A,
respectively, and produced <50 or 1.6 x
103 spores per ml, respectively . Strains EUC9703 (sigAR355W
H359R) and EUC9704 (sigAR355W H359A) both produced
approximately 107 spores per ml . Strain EUC9702, with the singly
substituted R355W allele of sigA, also produced approximately
107 spores per ml . These results indicate that R355 may lie
in close proximity to Spo0A and, like K356 and H359 of
A,
may play an important role in Spo0A-dependent promoter activation .
The role of R355 was investigated as described below .
A structure-based model of
A
region 4-Spo0A interaction predicts a role for
A
R355. To determine if the surface of
A
defined by R355 interacts directly with Spo0A, we used the published
coordinates derived from crystal structures of a Spo0A-DNA complex (31)
and region 4 of T . aquaticus
A
in complex with its cognate -35 DNA sequence (5) to model
potential interactions between Spo0A and
A
region 4 on the spoIIG promoter . We made several assumptions
in building the model . We expected that
A
region 4 from T . aquaticus would be a good model for
A
region 4 of B . subtilis because their amino acid sequences are
66% identical over the 73 amino acid residues present in the crystal
structure . We also expected that Spo0A bound at the site centered at
position -37 of the spoIIG promoter would interact with
A .
The sites on the spoIIG promoter at which Spo0A binds are
known (Fig . 1) (22) . Moreover, we know that
position -38 in the spoIIG promoter corresponds to the C in
the Spo0A target sequence TTCGNCA (oriented 5' to 3' on the
nontranscribed strand of spoIIG) because a substitution of C
at this position in the spoIIG promoter increases the affinity
of Spo0A for this site and increases spoIIG promoter activity
(2, 23) . There are also additional Spo0A
binding sites near position -90 of the spoIIG promoter .
However, since binding to the site at position -37 determines the
level of spoIIG promoter activity (2,
23), we ignored the upstream site in our modeling .
Therefore, all models examined included Spo0A positioned at the site
centered at -37 . Finally, we assumed that
A
region 4 is positioned near the DNA helix at the spoIIG
promoter in a manner similar to that of
A
at Spo0A-independent promoters .
|
FIG . 1 . Anatomy of the spoIIG promoter . Shown is the DNA sequence
of the nontranscribed strand from +1 to -63 (with respect to the
transcription start site) . The -10 DNA element recognized by
A
is boxed . A sequence that is identical to the consensus for the -35 DNA
element (5'-TTGACA-3') recognized by
A
is also boxed . The Spo0A binding sites are indicated by arrows over the
sequences, and the bases that are identical to the consensus
(5'-TTCGNCA-3') are in bold.
|
|
We began by examining a model in which
A
region 4 interacts with the TTGACA sequence centered between
positions -37 and -36 on the spoIIG promoter (Fig.
1) . However, the model showed that Spo0A and
A
region 4 could not simultaneously occupy this site due to steric
hindrance (data not shown) . Subsequently, we examined models in which
A
region 4 was moved by 1-bp intervals to various positions on the
promoter DNA, keeping the position of Spo0A centered at -37 . The
-helix
E of Spo0A and region 4 of
A
appeared to lie in close proximity without steric hindrance at only
one position, with region 4 of
A
positioned at the sequence centered between positions -33 and -32 of
spoIIG .
Before we examined the model for putative interactions between
Spo0A and region 4 of
A,
one additional modeling step was necessary . The structure of the
Spo0A-DNA complex produced by Zhao et al . (31)
does not include all amino acyl residues of
-helix
E, presumably because of disorder in the crystal . However, the
structure of Bacillus stearothermophilus C-Spo0A produced
without DNA by Lewis et al . (15) includes all of
-helix
E . Superimposition of the two Spo0A structures revealed that the two
structures are nearly identical, with a root mean square deviation of
0.43 Å (31) . Therefore, we superimposed the
structure of Spo0A from the work of Lewis et al . onto our model to
estimate the position of all residues in
-helix
E .
Allele-specific interaction of sigA (R355A) and spo0A
(E221A). Examination of our model for the interacting surfaces of Spo0A
and
A
revealed that the side chain of R355 in
A
may lie in close proximity to the side chain of glutamate at position
221 in Spo0A (Fig . 2) . We hypothesized that the
opposite charges on these residues may form the basis for an
important interaction between the surfaces of these proteins at the
spoIIG promoter . To test this hypothesis and to screen for
other interacting residues, we examined the effects of several single
alanine substitutions in Spo0A and in
A
on utilization of the spoIIG promoter in vivo . We examined the
effects of the amino acid substitutions, both singly and in pair-wise
combinations, on expression of a spoIIG promoter-lacZ
fusion . The mutant alleles of sigA tested included those
encoding single substitutions R355A, R358A, S361A, and R362A . We
examined the effect of these alleles on spoIIG-lacZ expression
in strains that contained the wild-type spo0A allele and in
strains encoding Spo0A derivatives in which alanine is substituted
for glutamate at position 221 (E221A), which we predicted to interact
with R355 of
A,
or in which alanine was substituted for isoleucine at position 229,
which was previously shown to affect spoIIG promoter activation
(4) .
|
FIG . 2 . Model of Spo0A and
A
bound to the spoIIG promoter . Shown is a view of the
A
region 4-promoter DNA-C-Spo0A complex generated with Sybyl 6.1, as
described in Materials and Methods . The DNA backbone is shown as a wire
frame . C-Spo0A is shown in green, and
A
region 4 is shown in blue . Also indicated are amino acyl side chains of
Spo0A (E221) and
A
(R355) that are predicted to interact during spoIIG promoter
activation.
|
|
We harvested samples from cultures of each strain at hourly intervals
after the end of the exponential-growth phase (i.e., the onset of
sporulation) and measured the level of ß-galactosidase activity
(reporter of spoIIG-lacZ expression) . We compared the level of
spoIIG-lacZ expression of each strain to that of the isogenic
strain containing the wild-type allele of sigA, the structural
gene for
A .
Except for S361A, which had little effect, each amino acid
substitution in
A
resulted in reduced expression of spoIIG-lacZ in strains
containing the wild-type allele of spo0A (Fig . 3
and data not shown) . In most cases, the amino acid substitutions in
A
also resulted in reduced expression of spoIIG-lacZ in strains
containing the mutant alleles of spo0A . The greatest exception
was seen for the strain in which the E221A substitution in Spo0A was
combined with the R355A substitution in
A .
In this case, the levels of ß-galactosidase accumulation indicated
that in the strains containing the E221A mutant of Spo0A the
spoIIG promoter was used more efficiently by RNA polymerase
containing the R355A mutant
A
than by RNA polymerase containing wild-type
A .
|
FIG . 3 . Effects of amino acid substitutions in
A
and Spo0A on spoIIG-lacZ expression . Strains containing various
alleles of sigA in combination with different alleles of spo0A
were cultured in DSM . Each strain also contained a transcriptional
spoIIG-lacZ fusion . Samples of the cultures were harvested at hourly
intervals after the end of exponential growth, and the levels of
ß-galactosidase activity (Miller units) were measured . The data
presented represent the ratios of ß-galactosidase activity accumulated 2
hours after the end of exponential growth in isogenic sigA mutant
and sigA wild-type strains (ß-galactosidase activity in
A
mutant/ß-galactosidase activity in wild-type
A) .
The allele of spo0A in each set of sigA strains is
indicated . Qualitatively similar ratios were observed in samples
harvested 3 and 4 h after the end of the exponential growth phase (data
not shown).
|
|
We used structure-based molecular modeling in an attempt to define
the interacting surfaces of Spo0A and
A
during activation of the spoIIG promoter . Our model predicts
interaction of glutamate at position 221 of Spo0A with arginine at
position 355 of
A .
We tested this model by examination of the effects of amino
acid substitutions in Spo0A and
A
on spoIIG promoter activity in vivo . One problem with this
type of analysis is that regulation of Spo0A synthesis and activity
is complex; Spo0A synthesis is autoregulated (27)
and Spo0A regulates synthesis of proteins that control Spo0A activity
by controlling its phosphorylation (28) . Amino
acid substitutions in Spo0A may also reduce its stability or prevent
DNA binding . To circumvent the complications of indirect effects on
Spo0A activity, we compared the ratio of spoIIG promoter
activities produced by wild-type and mutant forms of
A
in the presence of a single form of Spo0A to the ratio of these
activities in strains containing a different form of Spo0A . In these
genetic experiments, activation of the spoIIG promoter by
E221A mutant Spo0A was more efficient in combination with the R355A
mutant
A
than with the wild-type or R358A, R362A, or S361A mutant forms of
A
(Fig . 3) . Therefore, regardless of any indirect
effects that the E221A substitution in Spo0A may have had on its
function, the allele specificity of this effect is consistent with
the model that R355 of
A
interacts directly with E221 of Spo0A during spoIIG promoter
activation .
To explain the effects of the E221A and R355A substitutions, we
note that an amino acid substitution in a position that normally
interacts directly with a ligand may have two types of effects .
First, the substitution may remove a favorable interaction with the
ligand, and second, the substitution may introduce, directly or
indirectly, an interfering or unfavorable interaction . We suggest
that the E221 substitution in Spo0A does both . It eliminates a
favorable interaction with R355 in
A .
In addition, the E221A substitution in Spo0A produces an unfavorable
or interfering effect on Spo0A- A
interaction because the positive charge of R355 in
A
cannot be neutralized . Substitution of alanine for R355 in
A
eliminates the interfering effect created by the E221A substitution
in Spo0A, partially restoring Spo0A- A
interaction at the spoIIG promoter . However, the R355A
substitution does not restore the favorable interaction found between
R355 of wild-type
A
and E221 of wild-type Spo0A . Comparison of the absolute values of
spoIIG promoter activity in mutant and wild-type cells shows that
the R355A substitution does not fully suppress the effect of the
E221A substitution on promoter activity because it results in only
40% of the promoter activity in wild-type cells (not shown) .
Therefore, we suggest that the negative charge of E221 in wild-type
Spo0A is neutralized by R355 in wild-type
A
during their interaction at the spoIIG promoter . There appears
to be little or no interaction of Spo0A E221 and the residues R358,
R362, and S361 of
A .
These genetic results support our structure-based model for the
interacting surfaces of Spo0A and
A
at the spoIIG promoter .
Our discovery of a role for E221 of Spo0A in promoter activation
is somewhat surprising . All amino acid substitutions in Spo0A that
had previously been shown to play a role in spoIIG promoter
activation lie within
-helix
E of Spo0A . E221 is located near but outside of
-helix
E in the C terminus of the DNA recognition helix . The recognition
helix of the helix-turn-helix region in Spo0A is unusually long (3,
15) . The N-terminal amino acids of the recognition
helix bind in the major groove of the DNA (31) .
The C-terminal end of the helix, including position 221, extends away
from the DNA where it could interact with region 4 of
A .
Therefore, this position of E221 makes it unlikely that the E221A
substitution affects DNA binding by Spo0A . Furthermore, the E221A
mutant Spo0A repressed expression of an abrB-lacZ fusion (data
not shown), an activity that requires DNA binding by Spo0A .
The glutamate at position 221 in Spo0A is strictly conserved among
other spore-forming gram-positive bacteria (data not shown),
suggesting that this acidic residue plays a critical role in these
organisms . Acidic regions also comprise the activation regions of
several bacterial and eukaryotic transcription factors . These include
charge interactions between activators and region 4 of
.
For example, R596 (homologous to R355 in B . subtilis
A)
and R588 in
70
are thought to interact with D38 and E34, respectively, of lambda
cI (16, 18) .
Our identification of the interacting surfaces of Spo0A and
A
during activation of the spoIIG promoter may have revealed
important insights into the mechanism of spoIIG promoter activation .
The spoIIG promoter contains a consensus -35-like promoter element
centered between positions -37 and -36 (Fig . 1) . Binding
of
A
region 4 to this element would separate region 4 from the -10
promoter element by 22 bp (Fig . 4A), whereas 17 to 18 bp
is the optimal spacing between -35 and -10 promoter elements in
A-dependent,
Spo0A-independent promoters (17) . This -35-like
sequence is overlapped by a Spo0A binding site (Fig . 1) (2) .
Our modeling showed that Spo0A and
A
region 4 are not likely to simultaneously occupy these sites (data
not shown) . Therefore, one aspect of the mechanism of spoIIG
promoter activation by Spo0A may be occlusion of this inappropriately
spaced -35-like element by Spo0A to prevent interaction of
A
region 4 with this DNA (Fig . 4B) . However, this
cannot be the only or most important role for Spo0A because most base
substitutions that change this -35-like element to look less similar
to a consensus -35 element reduce spoIIG promoter activity (22)
rather than relieving dependence of promoter activity on Spo0A, as
predicted by a simple occlusion model . A more important role for
Spo0A binding to the spoIIG promoter is illuminated by our
model's prediction that the specific interactions between Spo0A and
A
that have been demonstrated genetically occur when
A
region 4 is located near a sequence centered between positions -33
and -32 of the spoIIG promoter (Fig . 4B) .
This sequence centered at -33 and-32 is only 50% identical to the
consensus
A
region 4 recognition sequence (Fig . 1 and
4), and there is no evidence that the sigma factor binds
in a sequence-specific manner to this region . Therefore, it is
likely that positioning of
A
region 4 at this site would require stabilizing, specific
interactions with Spo0A . This interaction between Spo0A and
A
places region 4 of
A
18 bp upstream from the -10 region of the spoIIG promoter .
Therefore, an important aspect of the mechanism of spoIIG
promoter activation by Spo0A may include stabilization of
A
region 4 binding to the promoter at a position that optimizes spacing
between
A
region 4 and the -10 element of the promoter . This model requires
further investigation; however, the model seems consistent with the
conclusions of Spiegelman and his colleagues that showed that
Spo0A stimulates spoIIG promoter DNA strand separation, a step
that follows the initial binding of the promoter by RNA polymerase (21) .
Our suggestion that Spo0A interacts with region 4 of
A
during spoIIG promoter activation does not exclude the possibility
that Spo0A interacts with other subunits of RNA polymerase at
the spoIIG promoter . However, results from the Spiegelman laboratory
suggest that the carboxy-terminal domain of the alpha subunit,
which interacts with other activators, is not important for spoIIG
promoter activation (20) .
|
FIG . 4 . Model of Spo0A-mediated activation of the spoIIG
promoter . spoIIG promoter DNA is indicated as a horizontal line;
positions -10 and -33 relative to the transcription start point are
indicated . Also shown is the sequence of the nontranscribed strand
centered at positions -37 and -36 that is identical to the consensus
-35-like DNA sequence (TTGACA) . RNA polymerase is represented as a gray
oval.
A
and regions 2 and 4 are labeled . Spo0A is indicated in panel B . (A) In
the absence of Spo0A, interaction of
A
region 4 with the consensus -35-like DNA sequence of the spoIIG
promoter element would be expected to prevent interaction of
A
with the -10 element of the promoter . (B) Upon binding of Spo0A, the
interaction between
A
region 4 and the consensus -35-like sequence is prevented . Moreover,
specific interactions between
A
region 4 and Spo0A may stabilize
A
in a position that allows it to interact with the -10 element of the
spoIIG promoter.
|
|
It is likely that Spo0A activates other
A-dependent
promoters by a similar mechanism . The sequence of another
Spo0A-activated promoter, spoIIE, is similar to spoIIG
in that it contains a -35-like sequence separated by 21 bp from the
-10 region sequence (10) . Moreover, its -35-like
sequence overlaps with a Spo0A binding site (30) .
Other
A-dependent,
Spo0A-dependent promoters have not been thoroughly characterized;
therefore, we cannot speculate on the mechanism of their activation
by Spo0A . Spo0A also activates
H-dependent
promoters; however, this mechanism is even less well understood (14) .
We gratefully acknowledge Kim Gernert of Emory University's
Biomolecular Computing Resource Center for instruction and advice on
molecular modeling and Gordon Churchward for suggestions on the
manuscript .
This work was supported by Public Health Services grant GM54395
from the National Institute of General Medical Sciences and by grant
MCB-0131020 from the National Science Foundation .
* Corresponding author . Mailing address: Department of
Microbiology and Immunology, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, GA
30322 . Phone: (404) 727-5969 . Fax: (404) 727-3659 . E-mail: moran@microbio.emory.edu.
- Baldus, J . M., C . M . Buckner, and C . P . Moran, Jr. 1995 .
Evidence that the transcriptional activator Spo0A interacts with two sigma
factors in Bacillus subtilis . Mol . Microbiol . 17:281-290.
- Baldus, J . M., B . D . Green, P . Youngman, and C . P . Moran, Jr.
1994 . Phosphorylation of Bacillus subtilis transcription factor Spo0A
stimulates transcription from the spoIIG promoter by enhancing binding
to weak 0A boxes . J . Bacteriol . 176:296-306.
- Brown, D . P., L . Ganova-Raeva, B . D . Green, S . R . Wilkinson,
M . Young, and P . Youngman. 1994 . Characterization of spo0A homologues in
diverse Bacillus and Clostridium species identifies a probable DNA-binding
domain . Mol . Microbiol . 14:411-426.
- Buckner, C . M., G . Schyns, and C . P . Moran, Jr. 1998 . A
region in the Bacillus subtilis transcription factor Spo0A that is
important for spoIIG promoter activation . J . Bacteriol . 180:3578-3583 .
- Campbell, E . A., O . Muzzin, M . Chlenov, J . L . Sun, C . A .
Olson, O . Weinman, M . L . Trester-Zedlitz, and S . A . Darst. 2002 . Structure
of the bacterial RNA polymerase promoter specificity sigma subunit . Mol . Cell
9:527-539.
- Cutting, S . M., and P . B . Vander Horn. 1990 . Genetic
analysis, p . 27-74 . In C . R . Harwood and S . Cutting (ed.), Molecular
biological methods for Bacillus . John Wiley and Sons, New York, N.Y.
- Fawcett, P., P . Eichenberger, R . Losick, and P . Youngman.
2000 . The transcriptional profile of early to middle sporulation in Bacillus
subtilis . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 97:8063-8068 .
- Ferrari, E., S . M . Howard, and J . A . Hoch. 1986 . Effect
of stage 0 sporulation mutations on subtilisin expression . J . Bacteriol .
166:173-179.
- Green, B . D., G . Olmedo, and P . Youngman. 1991 . A genetic
analysis of Spo0A structure and function . Res . Microbiol . 142:825-830.
- Guzman, P., J . Westpheling, and P . Youngman. 1988 .
Characterization of the promoter region of the Bacillus subtilis spoIIE
operon . J . Bacteriol . 170:1598-1609.
- Hatt, J . K., and P . Youngman. 1998 . Spo0A mutants of
Bacillus subtilis with sigma factor-specific defects in transcription
activation . J . Bacteriol . 180:3584-3591 .
- Henriques, A . O., B . W . Beall, K . Roland, and C . P . Moran,
Jr. 1995 . Characterization of cotJ, a sigma E-controlled operon
affecting the polypeptide composition of the coat of Bacillus subtilis
spores . J . Bacteriol . 177:3394-3406.
- Hoch, J . A. 2000 . Two-component and phosphorelay signal
transduction . Curr . Opin . Microbiol . 3:165-170.
- Kumar, A., J . A . Brannigan, and C . P . Moran, Jr.
-Helix
E of Spo0A is required for the
A-
but not for
H-dependent
promoter activation in Bacillus subtilis. J . Bacteriol., in press.
- Lewis, R . J., S . Krzywda, J . A . Brannigan, J . P . Turkenburg,
K . Muchova, E . J . Dodson, I . Barak, and A . J . Wilkinson. 2000 . The
trans-activation domain of the sporulation response regulator Spo0A revealed
by X-ray crystallography . Mol . Microbiol . 38:198-212.
- Li, M., H . Moyle, and M . M . Susskind. 1994 . Target of
the transcriptional activation function of phage lambda cI protein . Science
263:75-77.
- Moran, C . P., Jr., N . Lang, S . F . LeGrice, G . Lee, M .
Stephens, A . L . Sonenshein, J . Pero, and R . Losick. 1982 . Nucleotide
sequences that signal the initiation of transcription and translation in
Bacillus subtilis . Mol . Gen . Genet . 186:339-346.
- Nickels, B . E., S . L . Dove, K . S . Murakami, S . A . Darst, and
A . Hochschild. 2002 . Protein-protein and protein-DNA interactions of
sigma70 region 4 involved in transcription activation by lambda cI . J . Mol .
Biol . 324:17-34.
- Perego, M., J . J . Wu, G . B . Spiegelman, and J . A . Hoch.
1991 . Mutational dissociation of the positive and negative regulatory
properties of the Spo0A sporulation transcription factor of Bacillus subtilis .
Gene 100:207-212.
- Rowe-Magnus, D . A., M . Mencia, F . Rojo, M . Salas, and G . B .
Spiegelman. 1998 . Transcriptional activation of the Bacillus subtilis
spoIIG promoter by the response regulator Spo0A is independent of the
C-terminal domain of the RNA polymerase alpha subunit . J . Bacteriol . 180:4760-4763 .
- Rowe-Magnus, D . A., and G . B . Spiegelman. 1998 . DNA
strand separation during activation of a developmental promoter by the
Bacillus subtilis response regulator Spo0A . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 95:5305-5310 .
- Satola, S., P . A . Kirchman, and C . P . Moran, Jr. 1991 .
Spo0A binds to a promoter used by sigma A RNA polymerase during sporulation in
Bacillus subtilis . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 88:4533-4537.
- Satola, S . W., J . M . Baldus, and C . P . Moran, Jr. 1992 .
Binding of Spo0A stimulates spoIIG promoter activity in Bacillus
subtilis . J . Bacteriol . 174:1448-1453.
- Schaeffer, P., J . Millet, and J.-P . Augbert. 1965 .
Catabolic repression of bacterial sporulation . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA
54:704-710.
- Schyns, G., C . M . Buckner, and C . P . Moran, Jr. 1997 .
Activation of the Bacillus subtilis spoIIG promoter requires
interaction of Spo0A and the sigma subunit of RNA polymerase . J . Bacteriol .
179:5605-5608.
- Strauch, M., V . Webb, G . Spiegelman, and J . A . Hoch.
1990 . The Spo0A protein of Bacillus subtilis is a repressor of the abrB gene .
Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 87:1801-1805.
- Strauch, M . A., K . A . Trach, J . Day, and J . A . Hoch.
1992 . Spo0A activates and represses its own synthesis by binding at its dual
promoters . Biochimie 74:619-626.
- Strauch, M . A., J . J . Wu, R . H . Jonas, and J . A . Hoch.
1993 . A positive feedback loop controls transcription of the spo0F gene, a
component of the sporulation phosphorelay in Bacillus subtilis . Mol .
Microbiol . 7:967-974.
- Wu, J . J., P . J . Piggot, K . M . Tatti, and C . P . Moran, Jr.
1991 . Transcription of the Bacillus subtilis spoIIA locus . Gene 101:113-116.
- York, K., T . J . Kenney, S . Satola, C . P . Moran, Jr., H .
Poth, and P . Youngman. 1992 . Spo0A controls the sigma A-dependent
activation of Bacillus subtilis sporulation-specific transcription unit
spoIIE . J . Bacteriol . 174:2648-2658.
- Zhao, H., T . Msadek, J . Zapf, J . Madhusudan, A . Hoch, and K .
I . Varughese. 2002 . DNA complexed structure of the key transcription
factor initiating development in sporulating bacteria . Structure (Cambridge)
10:1041-1050.
- Zuber, P., and R . Losick. 1987 . Role of AbrB in Spo0A-
and Spo0B-dependent utilization of a sporulation promoter in Bacillus
subtilis . J . Bacteriol . 169:2223-2230.
Free Online Full-text Article
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
|