|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, January 2004, p . 122-135, Vol . 186,
No . 1
Growth
Phase-Dependent Regulation and Stringent Control of fis Are Conserved
Processes in Enteric Bacteria and Involve a Single Promoter (fis P) in
Escherichia coli
Prabhat Mallik, Timothy S . Pratt, Michael B . Beach,
Meranda D . Bradley, Jayanthi Undamatla,
and Robert Osuna*
Department of Biological Sciences, University at Albany, SUNY, Albany, New
York 12222
Received 24 July 2003/ Accepted 1 October 2003
The intracellular concentration of the Escherichia coli factor
for inversion stimulation (Fis), a global regulator of transcription
and a facilitator of certain site-specific DNA recombination events,
varies substantially in response to changes in the nutritional
environment and growth phase . Under conditions of nutritional
upshift, fis is transiently expressed at very high levels, whereas
under induced starvation conditions, fis is repressed by stringent
control . We show that both of these regulatory processes operate
on the chromosomal fis genes of the enterobacteria Klebsiella
pneumoniae, Serratia marcescens, Erwinia carotovora, and
Proteus vulgaris, strongly suggesting that the physiological
role of Fis is closely tied to its transcriptional regulation in
response to the nutritional environment . These transcriptional
regulatory processes were previously shown to involve a single
promoter (fis P) preceding the fis operon in E . coli .
Recent work challenged this notion by presenting evidence from primer
extension assays which appeared to indicate that there are multiple
promoters upstream of fis P that contribute significantly to
the expression and regulation of fis in E . coli . Thus,
a rigorous analysis of the fis promoter region was conducted
to assess the contribution of such additional promoters . However, our
data from primer extension analysis, S1 nuclease mapping,
ß-galactosidase assays, and in vitro transcription analysis all
indicate that fis P is the sole E . coli fis promoter in
vivo and in vitro . We further show how certain conditions used in the
primer extension reactions can generate artifacts resulting from
secondary annealing events that are the likely source of incorrect
assignment of additional fis promoters .
Gene regulatory proteins in bacteria are generally controlled in
response to environmental changes in order to generate a suitable
cellular response (9, 12, 20,
36) . A common strategy is to exert allosteric
regulation of specific transcription regulators by methods such as
ligand binding (7, 14, 47)
and covalent modification (16, 17,
37, 48) . Another strategy is to
control the availability of transcriptional regulators, which can
rely on molecular processes such as sequestration (39,
40), proteolysis (18), and
control of synthesis at transcriptional or posttranscriptional levels
(15, 19, 23,
29, 30) . The Escherichia
coli DNA binding protein Fis (factor for inversion stimulation)
serves as a transcription regulator of numerous genes, including
ribosomal and tRNA genes (5, 11,
21, 34, 45,
52, 53), and its activity
appears to be controlled largely by drastic changes in its
intracellular level, which, in turn, is affected by changes in the
nutritional environment (2, 35,
38, 49) .
When saturated cultures of E . coli are diluted in rich media,
the amounts of Fis protein and mRNA rapidly increase from undetectable
to very high levels during the early logarithmic growth phase .
The levels then decrease during late logarithmic growth and again
become undetectable during the stationary phase (2,
35, 38) . The magnitude of this
regulation is emphasized by the finding that Fis is the most abundant
DNA binding protein during the early logarithmic growth phase in
cells grown in rich media (1) . If, on the other
hand, E . coli cells are starved for amino acids, fis
expression becomes inhibited by stringent control (38,
50) . It is therefore tempting to speculate that the level
of Fis may serve as a way for cells to monitor and rapidly respond
to changes in the nutritional quality of the environment .
Growth phase-dependent regulation and stringent control are
distinct transcriptional regulatory mechanisms that act upon the
fis promoter (fis P) to regulate fis expression (2,
50) . This is the only promoter that was previously
identified to be responsible for expression of the fis operon,
which is comprised of yhdG (encoding a tRNA-dihydrouridine
synthase) and fis (2, 4,
38, 44, 50,
51) . In Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium,
a very similar promoter sequence was found that precedes the
fis operon and is similarly expressed in a growth phase-dependent
fashion (42) . Very similar fis promoter
sequences have also been found in Klebsiella pneumoniae,
Serratia marcescens, Erwinia carotovora, and Proteus
vulgaris, which are capable of initiating transcription from a
multicopy plasmid placed in an E . coli host (3) .
In recent work, however, it was reported that there are at least four
promoters, designated P1, P2, P3, and P4, that precede the E . coli
fis operon and contribute to its expression and regulation (31) .
Moreover, results of primer extension assays have suggested that P2
(and not the previously identified fis P or P1) is the
predominant promoter in vivo . Thus, we wished to further investigate
the contribution of these promoters to the expression and regulation
of fis .
In this study we examined the pattern of expression of fis within
its natural chromosomal loci in K . pneumoniae, S . marcescens,
E . carotovora, and P . vulgaris in response to a nutrient
upshift or induced starvation . We found that the corresponding
regulatory processes are very strongly conserved in these bacteria,
thus emphasizing their importance in controlling the activity of
Fis in response to sudden changes in the nutritional environment .
In addition, we conducted a rigorous examination of the E . coli
fis promoter region and concluded that a single promoter (fis
P) is involved in the expression and growth phase-dependent
regulation of fis . Given the strong conservation of this promoter
sequence, it is also likely to play a unique role in fis expression
and regulation in other bacteria .
Chemicals and enzymes. All chemicals were obtained from Sigma
Chemical Co., Fisher Scientific Co., VWR Scientific, or Life
Technologies Inc . (GIBCO BRL) . E . coli RNA polymerase
holoenzyme (E 70)
was purchased from EPICENTRE . S1 nuclease, Taq polymerase, and
avian myeloblastosis virus (AMV) reverse transcriptase (RT) were
obtained from Roche Molecular Biochemicals . Superscript II RT (a
modified form of moloney murine leukemia virus RT) and Thermoscript
(a modified version of AMV RT) were obtained from Invitrogen Corp.,
DNA Sequenase was obtained from U.S . Biochemical Corp., and all
other enzymes were obtained from New England BioLabs Inc., unless
otherwise indicated . An RNeasy RNA purification kit was obtained
from Qiagen, Inc . A MICROBExpress kit was obtained from Ambion,
Inc . Deoxyribonucleotides, ribonucleotides, and the radioisotopes
[ -32P]dATP
and [ -32P]ATP
were purchased from Amersham Biosciences Corp . Dideoxynucleotides
were obtained from Invitrogen Corp . or U.S . Biochemical Corp .
Oligonucleotides were synthesized with a Perkin-Elmer automatic DNA
synthesizer at the Department of Biological Sciences, University at
Albany, SUNY, or were obtained from The Center for Comparative
Functional Genomics at The University at Albany, SUNY, or from Operon
Technologies Inc . (Alameda, Calif.) .
Plasmids, bacterial strains, and growth conditions. All
plasmids used in this work are briefly described in Table
1 . E . coli strains MG1655 (F-
-
prototroph) and RJ1880 (MG1665 relA 1251
spoT 1207)
were obtained from R . L . Gourse (University of Wisconsin, Madison).
E . coli strains CSH50 [ara
(lac
pro) thi rpsL], RJ1800 (MG1655 fis::kan),
RZ211 (CSH26 recA56 srl str), and RJ1561 (RZ211 fis::kan)
were obtained from R . C . Johnson (University of California, Los
Angeles) . K . pneumoniae strain KC2668 [hutC515
(bla-2)]
was obtained from R . A . Bender (University of Michigan, Ann Arbor).
E . carotovora subsp . carotovora Ecc71 (lac) was
obtained from A . K . Chatterjee (University of Missouri) . S .
marcescens Bizio and P . vulgaris Hauser were obtained from
the American Type Culture Collection (Manassas, Va.) .
| TABLE 1 . Plasmids used in this study
|
|
Bacterial culture media were obtained from Difco Laboratories . E .
coli strains were grown in Luria-Bertani (LB) medium (24)
or in 2X YT medium (16 g of tryptone per liter, 10 g of yeast
extract per liter, 5 g of NaCl per liter; pH 7.4) at 37°C with
shaking . K . pneumoniae and S . marcescens were grown in
LB medium at 37°C, P . vulgaris was grown in tryptic soy broth
(17 g of tryptone per liter, 3 g of Bacto Soytone [Difco] per liter,
2.5 g of dextrose per liter, 5 g of NaCl per liter, 2.5 g of K2HPO4
per liter; pH 7.4) at 37°C, and E . carotovora was grown in
brain heart infusion (200 g of calf brain infusion per liter, 250 g
of beef heart infusion per liter, 10 g of Bacto Proteose Peptone
[Difco] per liter, 2 g of dextrose per liter, 5 g of NaCl per liter,
2.5 g of Na2HPO4 per liter; pH 7.4) at 32°C
(which was a more favorable growth temperature for this organism) .
Plasmid-containing cells were selected by addition of 100 µg of
ampicillin per ml (for E . coli and K . pneumoniae), 400
µg of ampicillin per ml (for S . marcescens), or 750 µg of
ampicillin per ml (for E . carotovora) to the medium . E .
coli, K . pneumoniae, and E . carotovora were made competent
and transformed with pRJ800-based plasmids by using the CaCl2
treatment described previously for E . coli (26).
S . marcescens was transformed by electroporation by using a
Bio-Rad bacterial transformation apparatus under the conditions
described previously for E . coli (25) . We
were unable to transform P . vulgaris by either method .
Stringent control assays were performed as described previously (43) .
Saturated cell cultures were diluted in rich medium to an optical
density at 600 nm (OD600) of 0.05 and grown to an OD600
of 0.15 (or 0.20 for S . marcescens and E . carotovora) .
At these stages of growth, a portion of each cell culture was
collected for preparation of total RNA . One half of the remainder of
the culture was treated with 1 mg of serine hydroxamate (SeOH) per
ml, and the other half received an equivalent volume of sterile H2O
as a control . After 30 min of treatment, both cultures were harvested
for preparation of total RNA . All three RNA samples were subjected to
Northern blot analysis by using the corresponding fis gene as
the 32P-labeled DNA probe .
ß-Galactosidase assays. ß-Galactosidase assays were
performed as described previously (24) . Generally,
saturated cultures of bacterial strains carrying pRJ800-based
plasmids were diluted 50-fold in rich medium, grown for 75 min with
shaking (or for 90 min in the case of E . carotovora), and
analyzed for ß-galactosidase activity, unless otherwise indicated .
The values are given as averages and standard deviations for three
independent assays .
RNA preparation. Total RNA was generally prepared by using
the hot acid phenol extraction method (8), which in
our hands gives consistent RNA yields (within 10%) from equivalent
quantities of cells . In some cases a Qiagen RNeasy total RNA
isolation kit was used to isolate total RNA from E . coli
strains by following the supplier's recommended procedures (Qiagen,
Inc.) . The two methods resulted in comparable RNA quality, as judged
by an OD260/OD280 ratio of about 1.75 . E .
coli 16S and 23S rRNA were separated from total RNA with a MICROBExpress
kit (Ambion, Inc.) by using the recommended procedure . The rRNA was
recovered from the magnetic beads by heating the beads at 65°C for 15
min in 20 µl of RNase-free TE buffer (10 mM Tris [pH 7.5], 1 mM
EDTA), followed by magnetic separation of the beads .
Northern blots. Saturated cell cultures were diluted
100-fold in appropriate rich medium and grown with shaking at 37°C
(or 32°C for E . carotovora) . At various times during growth of
the cultures, comparable quantities of cells (as determined by OD600
values) were withdrawn for preparation of total RNA by the hot acid
phenol method . The entire RNA contents were electrophoresed in
1% agarose gels containing 7% formaldehyde and transferred to
nitrocellulose filters as described previously (46) .
Hybridizations were performed at 42°C in a 50% formamide
hybridization solution . The fis gene corresponding to the
bacterium analyzed was used as a probe and was labeled with [ -32P]dATP
by extension of random primers, as described previously (46) .
The fis mRNA signals were detected by autoradiography and were
quantified by using a Storm 860 PhosphorImager and the ImageQuant
software (Molecular Dynamics, Inc., Sunnyvale, Calif.) .
S1 nuclease mapping. S1 nuclease mapping was performed as
described previously (46) . A single-stranded DNA
probe that was end labeled with 32P was made by subjecting
primer oRO109 (5'-GCTGATATTGTCCGATG) that was 5' end labeled with
32P to 30 cycles of denaturation, annealing, and extension
by using Taq polymerase and pRJ1071 cleaved with EcoRI
and HindIII as the template . The resulting antisense DNA
strand extended from position 54 to position -168 (5' to 3'
direction) relative to the fis promoter (fis P) . Approximately
40,000 cpm of the DNA probe was mixed with 10 µg of total
cellular RNA in 30 µl of hybridization buffer [40 mM piperazine-N,N'-bis(2-ethanesulfonic
acid) (PIPES) (pH 6.4), 1 mM EDTA, 0.4 M NaCl, 80% formamide],
heated at 85°C for 10 min, and then allowed to hybridize at 30°C for
16 h . The sample was then mixed with 300 µl of an S1 nuclease
solution (0.28 M NaCl, 50 mM sodium acetate, 4.5 mM ZnSO4,
20 µg of sonicated denatured salmon sperm DNA per ml, 200 U of S1
nuclease) and incubated at 37°C for 90 min . The reaction was stopped
by addition of 80 µl of a solution containing 4 M ammonium acetate,
50 mM EDTA, and 50 µg of yeast tRNA per ml . The mixture was extracted
with 1 volume of buffer-equilibrated 1:1 phenol-chloroform (46)
and then again with 1 volume of chloroform . The nucleic acids
in the aqueous layer were precipitated by addition of 2.5 volumes of
cold ethanol and incubation at -20°C for 2 h . The precipitate was
collected by centrifugation at 12,000 x g,
dried, resuspended in formamide loading buffer (10 mM Tris [pH 8.0],
1 mM EDTA, 50% formamide, 0.2% bromophenol blue, 0.2% xylene cyanol),
and analyzed by electrophoresis on 8% polyacrylamide-7 M urea gels
with TBE (90 mM Tris-borate [pH 8.0], 2 mM EDTA) as the running
buffer .
Primer extension. Primer extension reactions were conducted
by using 10 µg of total RNA under different conditions depending on
the RT used . Reactions with AMV RT were performed at 47°C with
1 to 2 U of enzyme, as previously described (13,
51) except where otherwise indicaed . Reactions
with Thermoscript RT were performed at temperatures indicated below
with 2 U of enzyme by using the supplier's recommended procedures
(Invitrogen Corp.) . Reactions with SuperScript II RT were performed
at 42°C with 200 U of enzyme according to the suppliers recommended
procedure (Invitrogen Corp.) or with 20 U of enzyme . Reactions
were performed with the following primers that were 5' end labeled
with 32P: oRO109 (5'-GCTGATATTGTCCGATG), which anneals to a
region downstream of the fis promoter from position 54 to position
38; oRO446 (5'-CGCTGCGATCAGGCGATTTCT), which is complementary
to the region from position 77 to position 57 relative to the fis
promoter start site; and oRO447 (5'-AGGTCTGTCTGTAATGCCAG), which is
complementary to the region from position 104 to position 85 .
In vitro transcription. Transcription reactions were
performed either with a 283-bp linear DNA fragment containing the
fis promoter region from position -168 to position 83 relative to
the predominant fis promoter start site or with supercoiled
plasmid pRO362 containing the same fis promoter region and a
rho-independent transcription terminator that is expected to
terminate transcription approximately 345 bp downstream of the fis
P transcription start site . The reactions were performed in 20-µl
mixtures (final volume) by combining 0.1 pmol of linear DNA or 0.01
pmol of supercoiled DNA with 0.5 pmol of RNA polymerase in
transcription buffer (30 mM Tris-HCl [pH 7.9], 10 mM MgCl2,
1 mM EDTA, 100 µg of bovine serum albumin per ml, 100 µM
dithiothreitol) and 25 mM potassium glutamate (when linear templates
were used) or 200 mM KCl (when supercoiled DNA templates were used) .
The mixtures were incubated at 37°C for 5 min to allow formation
of open complexes . RNA synthesis was then initiated from Tinear
templates by addition of 10 µg of heparin per ml, 80 µM CTP, 80 µM
GTP, 80 µM UTP, 4 µM ATP, and 2.5 µCi of [ -32P]ATP
(3,000 Ci/mmol) . For supercoiled templates, the same nucleotide
mixture was added without the heparin . Transcripts were also
synthesized in the presence of 80 µM ATP, 80 µM CTP, 80 µM GTP, 4 µM
UTP, and 2.5 µCi of [ -32P]UTP
to verify that the transcripts observed were not affected by the
overall purine concentrations . The mixtures were incubated at 37°C
for 30 min, and the reactions were stopped by addition of 2.4 µl of
stop buffer (5% sodium dodecyl sulfate, 0.25 M EDTA) and 12 µl of
formamide containing 0.05% bromophenol blue and 0.05% xylene cyanol .
The samples were heated at 92°C for 2 min and separated on 6%
polyacrylamide-7 M urea gels in TBE buffer . The gels were then
subjected to autoradiography .
Nucleic acid sequencing. DNA sequencing was performed with
alkali-denatured double-stranded plasmid DNA by using Sequenase,
version 2.0 (U.S . Biochemical Corp.) as specified by the supplier .
RNA sequencing was performed in two steps . First, 20 µg of total
cellular RNA was denatured at 65°C for 5 min in the presence of 7
pmol of primer labeled at the 5' end with 32P, 400 µM
dATP, 400 µM dCTP, 400 µM dGTP, and 400 µM dTTP in a 40-µl mixture
and quickly frozen in a dry ice-ethanol bath . The extension and
termination reactions were then performed together by combining 8 µl
of the thawed RNA mixture with 1x
SuperScript II buffer (Invitrogen Corp.), 8 mM dithiothreitol, 14 U
of RNaseOUT (Invitrogen Corp.), 160 U of SuperScript II RT, and
either 600 µM ddATP, 600 µM ddCTP, 600 µM ddGTP, or 600 µM
ddTTP in 14 µl and incubating the preparation at 42°C for 30 min . The
reactions were stopped by addition of 11.5 µl of a solution
containing 90% formamide, 0.05% bromophenol blue, and 0.05% xylene
cyanol, heated at 90°C for 3 min, and loaded on a 8% polyacrylamide-7
M urea gel for electrophoresis with TBE buffer . The gel was subjected
to autoradiography .
fis expression in enteric bacteria. In order to explore
the generality of the fis regulation pattern previously
observed in E . coli and S . enterica serovar Typhimurium
(2, 38, 42), we examined
the fis mRNA expression patterns generated from chromosomal
fis genes of four additional enteric bacteria . Saturated cultures
of K . pneumoniae, S . marcescens, E . carotovora,
and P . vulgaris were diluted 100-fold in rich medium and grown
for various lengths of time, after which cells were harvested and
used for preparation of total RNA . Northern blot analysis, performed
with RNA from comparable quantities of cells and the fis gene
corresponding to the gene from each bacterium as the 32P-labeled DNA
probe, showed that all four bacteria indeed exhibit a growth
phase-dependent fis mRNA expression pattern (Fig.
1) . The maximum mRNA levels occurred during the early
logarithmic growth phase, and then the levels decreased as the
cells proceeded through mid-logarithmic and late logarithmic growth
phases . During stationary phase, fis mRNA was not detected .
|
FIG . 1 . Patterns of expression of fis mRNA in several enteric
bacteria . Saturated cultures of K . pneumoniae, S . marcescens,
E . carotovora, and P . vulgaris were diluted 100-fold in
rich medium and grown at 37°C (or 32°C in the case of E . carotovora)
with continuous shaking . Total RNA obtained from comparable quantities
of cells (as determined by OD600) during the growth of the
cultures was subjected to Northern blot analysis by using the
corresponding bacterial fis genes as 32P-labeled
probes . The relative fis mRNA levels (•) were measured by using a
Storm 860 PhosphorImager and the ImageQuant software and are expressed
relative to the maximum value in each set, which was assigned a value of
100% . Cell growth ( )
was monitored by determining OD600.
|
|
Northern blot and primer extension analyses previously demonstrated
that the E . coli fis gene is also subject to negative regulation
by stringent control (38, 50) .
Mutations in the -35 promoter region and in the G+C-rich
discriminator DNA sequence located between the -10 region and the
transcription start site altered stringent control of the promoter .
To assess the general importance of this control mechanism in K .
pneumoniae, S . marcescens, E . carotovora, and P .
vulgaris, these bacteria were grown to early logarithmic growth
phase in rich medium and then treated with 1 mg SeOH per ml, which
was shown to induce starvation in E . coli (43) .
Northern blotting was performed as described above to compare the
fis mRNA levels in SeOH-treated and nontreated cells (Fig.
2) . Two transcripts were observed in the Northern
blots that have been shown previously to be about 1,400 and 860 bases
long (2) . The size of the larger transcript corresponds
to the distance from the fis promoter region to the end of the
fis operon (Fig . 3A); the smaller transcript most
likely results from processing of the larger transcript since
significant promoter activity has not been identified in the yhdG
regions that could account for this prominent signal (see below) .
SeOH treatment of E . coli cells (MG1655) resulted in a notable
reduction in the fis mRNA level (Fig . 2,
lane 2) compared to the level in the nontreated control (lane 3) .
However, in the relA spoT strain RJ1880, SeOH treatment did
not result in an appreciable decrease in the fis mRNA level
(lane 2) compared to the level in the nontreated culture (lane 3), as
expected for a regulatory effect mediated by the stringent response .
Curiously, only the larger transcript was observed in RJ1880 under
SeOH-induced starvation conditions, suggesting that the putative mRNA
processing event is prevented under these conditions . Treatment of
K . pneumoniae, S . marcescens, E . carotovora, and
P . vulgaris with SeOH resulted in considerable reductions in
fis mRNA levels (lanes 2) compared to the levels in the
nontreated controls (lanes 3), demonstrating that the expression of
fis mRNA in these four enteric bacteria is subject to negative
regulation by stringent control .
|
FIG . 2 . Effect of stringent control on fis mRNA levels in several
enteric bacteria . Saturated cell cultures were diluted to an OD600
of 0.05 and grown to an OD600 between 0.15 and 0.20 . Cell
samples were removed for total RNA preparation (lanes 1), and the
remainders of the cultures were divided in two parts . SeOH (1 mg/ml) was
added to one half of each remaining culture, which was harvested after
30 min of growth for total RNA preparation (lanes 2) . The other half of
each culture received an equivalent volume of sterile H2O (as
control) and was also harvested after 30 min of growth for total RNA
preparation (lanes 3) . Each lane was loaded with 10 µg of RNA . Northern
blotting was performed by using 32P-labeled fis
corresponding to each bacterium . The sources of bacterial RNA are
indicated above the gels.
|
|
|
FIG . 3 . fis promoter region . (A) Schematic diagram of the fis
operon . The rectangles represent open reading frames for fis and
yhdG . The arrow represents the previously identified fis
promoter (fis P) . (B) DNA sequence of the E . coli fis
promoter region from position -200 to position 40 relative to the
predominant start site at position 1 . The -35 and -10 promoter regions
for fis P are enclosed in boxes, andthe solid arrows indicate the
predominant and secondary transcription start sites for fis P .
The dashed arrows indicate the positions of additional start sites that
have also been reported for this region (31) . The
dashed boxes indicate the proposed -10 and -35 regions of these other
promoters . The yhdG initiation codon is underlined, and the
nucleotide position numbers relative to the fis P start site are
indicated above the sequence both with numbers every 20 bp and with
asterisks every 10 bp . (C) Comparison of fis promoter sequences
of various bacteria . National Center for Biotechnology Information
translated blastx was used to generate candidate fis operon
sequences . Sequences preceding the fis operons were subjected to
multiple-sequence alignment (10) and refined by hand .
The DNA sequences shown are of E . coli (Ec) (GenBank accession
no.
NC000913), S . enterica serovar Typhimurium (St) (NC003197),
K . pneumoniae (Kp) (AF040380), S . marcescens (Sm)
(AF040378), E . carotovora (Eca) (AF040381), P . vulgaris
(Pv) (AF040379), Y . pestis (Yp) (NC004088), V . cholerae
(Vc) (AE003852), S . oneidensis (So) (NC004347), P . multocida
(Pm) (AE004439), P . aeruginosa (Pa) (AE004091), H . influenzae
(Hi) (L42023), and B . aphidicola (Ba) (NC004061) . The dots
represent nucleotide matches with the E . coli sequence . Regions
corresponding to the E . coli fis P -10 and -35 regions and its
start site position (+1) are enclosed in solid boxes; regions
corresponding to the putative P2, P3, and P4 promoters are enclosed in
dashed boxes . A sequence pertaining to an ihf site is indicated
by boldface type.
|
|
fis promoter region. fis, yhdG, and DNA
regions upstream of yhdG in K . pneumoniae, S .
marcescens, E . carotovora, and P . vulgaris were previously
cloned and sequenced (3) . Sequences preceding the
yhdG genes showed significant similarities with corresponding
promoter sequences in E . coli, and transcriptional activity
from these DNA regions could be detected when they were cloned in a
plasmid and placed in an E . coli host . To verify that these
sequences also displayed promoter function in their natural hosts and
to determine if additional downstream promoters might contribute
to the fis expression, we sought to transform the four bacterial
species with plasmids carrying trp-lac fusions to their putative
fis promoter regions or to the intervening DNA between the putative
promoter region and fis . We succeeded in transforming K .
pneumoniae, S . marcescens, and E . carotovora but
were unable to obtain P . vulgaris transformants . Hence,
plasmids carrying the P . vulgaris fis operon regions were
maintained and examined in E . coli strain RZ211 . The results
of ß-galactosidase assays indicate that the DNA regions containing
the entire yhdG gene and the initial eight codons of fis
from E . coli, K . pneumoniae, and E . carotovora
exhibited no transcriptional activity above the background levels
observed with the pRJ800 vector alone, and negligible levels were
detected from the corresponding regions from S . marcescens and
P . vulgaris (Fig . 4) . However, transcription
activity was readily detected in the DNA regions containing 205 bp or
less upstream of yhdG . These observations indicate that
yhdG and fis are cotranscribed as an operon in all these
bacteria from a promoter region that precedes yhdG (Fig . 3A) .
|
FIG . 4 . Localization of the fis promoter region in several
enteric bacteria . The plasmids indicated on the left were transformed
into E . coli (RZ211), K . pneumoniae (K.p.), E .
carotovora (E.c.), or S . marcescens (S.m.) . The diagram at
the top shows the fis operon that includes fis, yhdG,
and DNA sequences upstream of yhdG . It is used as a reference to
indicate the DNA regions of each bacterium (relative to yhdG and
fis) that are fused to trp-lac in each plasmid . The
restriction sites refer to sites in the E . coli sequence .
Saturated cultures of cells carrying the plasmids were diluted 75-fold
in rich medium, grown at 37°C (or 32°C in the case of E . carotovora)
for 75 min, and used to measure ß-galactosidase activity . The growth
rates at the times that these measurements were taken were 2.4
doublings/h for E . coli and K . pneumoniae, 2.3 doublings/h
for S . marcescens, and 2 doublings/h for E . carotovora .
The values are averages ± standard deviations of three independent
assays.
|
|
Single versus multiple fis promoters. Primer extension
analysis of the fis promoter regions in E . coli and
S . enterica serovar Typhimurium previously identified a single
promoter that initiated transcription approximately 33 nucleotides
upstream of yhdG (2, 38,
42) . A signal corresponding to transcription
initiating at the same promoter was also identified in the analogous
DNA regions of K . pneumoniae, S . marcescens, E .
carotovora, and P . vulgaris when they were cloned on a plasmid
and transformed in an E . coli strain (3) . No
other transcripts were detected from the DNA region preceding yhdG
by as much as 300 bp . However, a recent report indicated that, on the
basis of primer extension analysis and ß-galactosidase assays,
at least three additional promoters (referred to as P2, P3, and
P4) were present upstream of the originally identified E . coli fis
promoter (Fig . 3B) that contributed significantly to
the fis expression, with P2 serving as a prominent promoter
in vivo (31) . Given the importance of these findings
and the potential roles that such promoters might have in fis
expression, we sought to examine more closely the activity of these
promoters in vivo and in vitro, their contributions to fis
expression, and the conservation of their sequences in other
bacteria .
A comparison of the DNA sequence of the E . coli fis promoter
region to the sequences of the corresponding regions in 12 other
bacteria revealed a limited region of conservation from position
-53 to position 21 relative to the E . coli fis P start site
(Fig . 3C) . This region is strongly conserved in S .
enterica serovar Typhimurium (99%), K . pneumoniae (99%),
S . marcescens (88%), E . carotovora (89%), P .
vulgaris (86%), and Yersinia pestis (84%) . Although the
levels of conservation in this region decrease to between 40 and 60%
when several other bacteria are considered (Vibrio cholerae,
Shewanella oneidensis, Pasteurella multocida,
Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Haemophilus influenzae, and
Buchnera aphidicola), the sequences representing the -35 and -10
promoter regions for fis P and the transcription initiation
site are reasonably well conserved . However, the DNA region upstream
of position -53, which includes the sequences proposed to serve as
promoters P2, P3, and P4, shows a marked reduction in sequence
conservation . The limited sequence conservation observed in the
region designated the P3 -10 promoter region may reflect the position
of an ihf binding site previously identified in E . coli
and shown to be required for transcription stimulation of fis
P (44) . The higher percent conservation of fis P when
compared to the designated upstream promoter sequences suggests
that the latter are not essential to the conserved growth phase-dependent
regulation and stringent control of fis observed among enteric
bacteria .
Primer extension and S1 nuclease mapping. Concerned that our
previous characterizations of the E . coli fis promoter region
may have failed to identify salient promoters in addition to fis
P, we sought to increase the rigor of our analysis . Primer extension
analysis performed with total RNA from MG1655 cells grown to the
early logarithmic phase reproducibly revealed only two transcription
signals initiating at fis P (Fig . 5, lane
1) . A primary signal initiated with CTP 33 nucleotides upstream of
yhdG (designated position 1C), and a secondary signal initiated
with GTP 2 nucleotides upstream of the primary signal (designated
position -2G) . To increase the sensitivity of detection of
transcripts initiating in this region, we performed an identical
primer extension analysis using RNA from MG1655 carrying the
multicopy plasmid pRJ804 (Fig . 5, lane 2) . This pUC18-based
plasmid contains DNA sequences from position -762 to position
860 relative to the fis P transcription start site . The results
show that the signals corresponding to the fis P transcripts
initiating at positions 1C and -2G are greatly enhanced in the
presence of this plasmid . However, we detected no additional signals
that corresponded to transcription initiating from the previously
designated P2, P3, and P4 promoters or any other promoter upstream of
fis P . Such additional upstream promoter signals were not
detected at any time during growth of the bacterial culture (data not
shown) .
|
FIG . 5 . Primer extension analysis of the fis promoter region .
Primer extension reactions were performed with primer oRO109 and 10 µg
of total RNA from MG1655 (lane 1) or from MG1655 (lane 2) transformed
with pRJ804 that was diluted 20-fold in LB medium from overnight
cultures and grown at 37°C for 60 min . DNA sequencing reaction mixtures
containing 32P-labeled oRO109 and pRJ804 as the template were
electrophoresed in parallel in lanes A, C, G, and T (corresponding to
the dideoxynucleotide used in each lane) . The nucleotide sequence of the
fis P transcription initiation region is indicated on the left .
The lowercase letters indicate the nucleotides of the antisense strand
read directly from the gel, and the uppercase letters indicate the
sequence of the complementary sense strand . The positions of the fis
P position 1 and -2 transcription initiation sites are indicated by
black arrows, and the expected positions for the transcription
initiation sites for promoters designated P2, P3, and P4 are indicated
by gray arrows.
|
|
Two general concerns associated with the use of primer extension
assays to map the positions of 5' ends of transcripts are the
potential for stable secondary RNA structures that may obstruct
polymerization by the RT and the potential for secondary annealing
sites for the short oligonucleotides used in these reactions that
could yield false signals, a phenomenon often observed during PCR .
The S1 nuclease mapping method (46), which does
not rely on processive polymerization and utilizes a DNA probe that
is considerably larger than the probes used for primer extension,
overcomes these concerns . Thus, we performed S1 nuclease mapping
using a single-stranded antisense DNA probe extending from position
54 to position -168 relative to the fis P transcription start
site, in order to allow detection of RNA signals initiating at fis
P, as well as promoters P2, P3, and P4 (Fig . 6A) . Total
RNA was isolated from MG1655 at various times after saturated
cultures were diluted in LB medium and grown at 37°C, and the RNA was
then subjected to S1 nuclease mapping (Fig . 6B) .
The results showed that there were two prominent sets of signals that
exhibited a growth phase-dependent expression pattern (Fig .
6B, lanes 3 to 9) . Their levels rapidly increased during the
first 15 min of growth, decreased by 60 min, and continued to
decrease thereafter . One set of signals mapped to positions 1 and 2
of the fis P transcription initiation region, and the other
set of signals corresponded to positions -2 through -5 of the same
promoter . The former set of signals was more intense than the latter
set . These results are in very good agreement with the results of our
primer extension analysis . Clusters of bands that differ by
increments of one nucleotide are commonly observed when the S1
nuclease mapping method is used (6, 22,
27, 28) . No additional signals were
observed upstream of fis P that corresponded to transcripts
initiating from the promoters designated P2, P3, and P4, even after
long periods of X-ray film exposure .
|
FIG . 6 . S1 nuclease mapping of the fis promoter transcripts . (A)
Schematic diagram of the single-stranded DNA probe used in S1 nuclease
mapping . The horizontal line represents the DNA probe extending from
position -168 to position 54 relative to fis P . The arrow below
this line represents the oRO109 primer used to generate the DNA probe .
The positions of the 5' 32P label in both the primer and the
resulting probe are indicated by asterisks . The relative position of the
transcription start site for fis P is indicated above the line by
a solid arrow, and the start site positions for the additional putative
promoters P2, P3, and P4 are represented by dashed arrows . (B) S1
nuclease mapping of transcripts arising from the fis promoter
region . A saturated culture of MG1665 was diluted 75-fold in LB medium,
grown at 37°C, and harvested at various times for total RNA preparation .
S1 nuclease mapping was performed with the DNA probe shown in panel A
and 10 µg of total RNA . The resulting products were separated on an 8%
polyacrylamide-7 M urea gel and subjected to autoradiography . Lanes A,
C, G, and T contained the products of dideoxy DNA sequencing reactions
for the fis promoter region performed with pRJ1028 as the
template and primer oRO109 that was labeled at the 5' end with 32P .
Lane 1, untreated DNA probe; lane 2, DNA probe treated with S1 nuclease
in the absence of RNA; lanes 3 through 9, S1 nuclease mapping performed
with total RNA from MG1655 after growth at 37°C in LB medium for 0 min
(lane 3), 5 min (lane 4), 15 min (lane 5), 60 min (lane 6), 150 min
(lane 7), 300 min (lane 8), and 22 h (lane 9) . The fis P start
site positions identified based on primer extension assays and the start
site positions of previously reported promoters P2, P3, and P4 are
indicated on the left by arrows . (C) Comparison of S1 nuclease mapping
results by using total RNA from strains CSH50 and MG1655 grown in either
LB or 2X YT medium . Saturated cultures of each strain were diluted
75-fold in either LB or 2X YT medium and grown at 37°C . Cells were
harvested at various times for total RNA preparation . The strains and
growth media used are indicated above the lanes . S1 nuclease treatment
was performed as described above . Lane 1, untreated DNA probe; lane 2,
S1 nuclease-treated DNA probe in the absence of RNA; lanes 3 through 22,
S1 nuclease mapping performed with total RNA from cells grown for 1 min
(lanes 3, 8, 13, and 18), 15 min (lanes 4, 9, 14, and 19), 40 min (lanes
5, 10, 15, and 20), 60 min (lanes 6, 11, 16, and 21), or 150 min (lanes
7, 12, 17, and 22).
|
|
We considered whether strain differences, the growth medium used, or
the methods of RNA preparation used may have accounted for our
inability to detect transcripts initiating at P2 through P4 . Thus, we
performed S1 nuclease mapping of fis mRNA in CSH50 strains
grown in 2X YT medium, as previously described for identification of
promoters P2 through P4 (31), and compared the results with
those obtained for CSH50 grown in LB medium or for MG1655 grown
in 2X YT or LB medium . The results showed that the same set of
transcripts corresponding to fis P were made in both strains,
whether they were grown in LB or 2X YT medium (Fig . 6C) . In
addition, the method of RNA preparation (hot acid phenol versus
Qiagen RNeasy RNA purification method) made no difference in the
results (data not shown) . A growth phase-dependent expression pattern
was exhibited by these transcripts in all cases, and there were only
small variations in the timing of the expression pattern . Thus, our
results clearly show that fis P is the sole promoter for which
transcription activity can be detected in vivo by either primer
extension or S1 nuclease mapping assay .
In vitro transcription from the fis promoter region.
In vitro transcription was used to detect 32P-labeled RNA synthesized
from the fis promoter region from position -168 to position
83, which contained the complete sequences for fis P and the
putative P2 and P3 promoters (Fig . 7) . A 283-bp linear
DNA template was used, so that the expected sizes for transcripts
initiating at fis P, P2, and P3 were 103, 172, and 219 bases,
respectively . A prominent 103-nucleotide signal was observed, whereas
signals corresponding to 172 and 219 nucleotides were not discerned
among a number of very-low-intensity signals (Fig . 7A) .
When the same DNA region was transcribed from a supercoiled DNA
template (pRO362), a noticeable signal was observed at an approximate
size expected for transcripts initiating at fis P and terminating
at a rho-independent terminator located about 345 bases downstream
from fis P (Fig . 7B, lane 2) . This signal was not
observed when the vector lacking the fis promoter region was
used as the template (lane 1) . In order to more confidently identify
this transcript, we cloned a similar fis promoter region
containing an up-promoter mutation in the fis P -10 region
that created a perfect match with the consensus sequence (TATAAT) in
pRO468 . Transcription from equivalent quantities of this template
gave a much higher signal intensity for the same transcript produced
from the wild-type fis P region (lane 3), demonstrating that
this signal originated from the fis promoter . Signals whose
sizes corresponded to the sizes of transcripts originating from P2
(409 bases) and P3 (456 bases) were not observed . Thus, the results
of our in vitro transcription experiments in which linear or
supercoiled templates were used indicate that fis P is the
predominant or sole promoter in the region from position -168 to
position 83 .
|
FIG . 7 . In vitro transcription of the fis promoter . (A) Runoff
transcription reactions with a 283-bp DNA fragment containing the DNA
sequences from position -168 to position 83 relative to the fis P
transcription start site and an additional 20 bp downstream of position
83 originating from the vector DNA . This fragment contains the sequences
attributed to fis P, as well as promoters P2 and P3 . Transcripts
from duplicate reaction mixtures were separated on a 6% polyacrylamide-7
M urea denaturing gel (lanes 1 and 2) and subjected to autoradiography .
Lane 3 contained denatured DNA size standards, whose sizes (in numbers
of nucleotides) are indicated on the right . The position of the
103-nucleotide transcript signal corresponding to fis P is
indicated on the left by an arrow . The expected positions of transcripts
originating from the putative promoters P2 and P3, based on their
expected sizes (172 and 219 nucleotides, respectively), are also
indicated . (B) In vitro transcription from fis P on a supercoiled
plasmid . Gel electrophoresis was performed as described above . Lane 1,
results with pTP435 (vector only); lane 2, results with pRO362 carrying
the wild-type fis promoter region from position -168 to position
83; lane 3, results with pRO468 carrying a perfect match with the -10
promoter region in fis P; lane 4, DNA size standards . The
position of the signal corresponding to the transcript originating from
fis P and terminating at the primary rho-independent terminator
is indicated on the left by an arrow . The expected positions of
transcripts originating from promoters P2 and P3 are also indicated . The
asterisk on the right indicates the position of a signal from pRO468
corresponding to a fraction of fis P transcripts terminating at a
second rho-independent terminator on the vector.
|
|
Deletion of fis P abolishes transcription from the fis
promoter region. Deletion of the fis promoter (or P1) was
reported to result in a prominent increase in transcription from the
putative upstream promoters P2 through P4 on the basis of
ß-galactosidase assays, presumably because their expression is
partially occluded by fis P (31) . To
examine this effect, we cloned the DNA region from position -194 to
position -42 next to the (trp-lac)W200 fusion in
pTP439, such that expression of trp-lac would be under control
of the putative promoters P2, P3, and P4 in the absence of fis
P . We compared the transcriptional activity in vivo to that generated
from pTP438 and pRJ1028, which contain a similar trp-lac
fusion to the fis P region from position -194 to position 83
and from position -375 to position 83, respectively (Fig .
8) . Plasmids pRJ1028 and pTP438 produced 1,149 and 1,158
ß-galactosidase units, respectively, in fis strain RJ1561,
demonstrating that there was a significant level of transcriptional
activity in these DNA constructs compared to the level in the vector
control . The levels in RZ211 cells were lower, 271 and 329 U,
respectively, which is consistent with an effect attributed to Fis
repression (2, 38,
44) . The deletion of fis P in pTP439, which leaves the
sequences for P2, P3, and P4 intact, caused transcription activity
to decrease to levels comparable to those of the promoterless
plasmid pRJ800 in both RZ211 and RJ1561 cells . No transcription was
detected from this construct irrespective of the growth medium used
(2X YT or LB medium) or the growth phase chosen to measure
ß-galactosidase activity (data not shown) . We also cloned the fis
P region from position -194 to position -42 within pTP455 in the
orientation opposite that in pTP439 to examine if transcription could
be detected from a divergent promoter (Fig . 8) . A
very low level of transcription was detected above the level of
transcription of the pRJ800 control in both RZ211 and RJ1561,
suggesting that the region from position -194 to position -42 harbors
a weak divergent promoter .
|
FIG . 8 . Deletion analysis of the fis promoter region . The fis
promoter regions preceding the trp-lac fusion in pRJ1028, pTP438,
pTP439, and pTP455 are shown, and their upstream and downstream end
points are indicated relative to the fis P transcription start
site . Plasmid pRJ800, which lacks the fis promoter region, was
used as a control . Saturated cultures of RZ211 or RJ1561 cells carrying
these plasmids were diluted 50-fold in 2X YT medium, grown at 37°C for
75 min, and assayed for ß-galactosidase (ß-Gal) activity . The results,
shown on the right, are averages ± standard deviations of three
independent assays.
|
|
Effect of reaction conditions on primer extended signals. Given
the striking discrepancy between our observations regarding the
existence of a single promoter (fis P) and the previously
reported observations regarding the existence of multiple promoters
P1, P2, P3, and P4 involved in fis expression (31), we
examined the possibility that differences in the conditions used in
the primer extension reactions could account for the conflicting
observations . Transcripts corresponding to P2, P3, and P4 were
detected in primer extension assays by using SuperScript II RT
according to the manufacturer's recommendations . We also employed
this enzyme together with primer oRO109 and 10 µg of total RNA from
MG1655 grown for 40 min in LB medium at 37°C . Under these conditions
we observed the signals previously identified as fis P
initiation signals at positions +1 and -2 . In addition, two prominent
larger-size signals were observed (Fig . 9A, compare
lanes 1 and 2) . The sizes of these additional signals, however, did
not correspond to the sizes of any of the transcripts previously
reported for P2, P3, or P4 . Rather, they corresponded to an
initiation event somewhere upstream of position -180 relative to the
fis P start site . We noticed that the procedure recommended by
the supplier (Invitrogen Corp.) called for a large amount of
SuperScript II RT (200 U) in the reaction mixture, and we
hypothesized that such conditions might facilitate extension of
secondary priming events produced by the 17-mer oRO109 . Indeed, when
the amount of SuperScript II RT in the reaction mixture was reduced
by as much as 10-fold (to 20 U), we detected only the fis P
position +1 and -2 transcript signals (Fig . 9, lane
3) . We also used Thermoscript RT, which is a modified version of AMV
RT that exhibits increased activity at higher temperatures and can
potentially reduce artifacts caused by secondary priming events . When
2 U of Thermoscript RT was used to extend oRO109 at 42, 47, and 52°C
(lanes 4 to 6), we detected only the fis P signals for
positions +1 and -2 at all temperatures, and the more prominent
signals were detected at 52°C (lane 6) . Thus, comparable results were
obtained with three versions of the RT enzyme provided that their
concentrations were not excessively high .
|
FIG . 9 . Examination of primer extension assay conditions . (A) Effects of
reaction conditions and primers on the results of primer extension
analysis of the fis promoter transcripts . Lanes 1 through 16
contained the products of primer extension reactions performed with 10
µg of total cellular RNA isolated from MG1655 which had been grown for
40 min in LB medium at 37°C following 75-fold dilution from a saturated
culture . Reactions were performed with the following primers that were
labeled at the 5' end with 32P: oRO109 (lanes 1 through 6),
oRO446 (lanes 7 through 12), and oRO447 (lanes 13 through 16) . The
reactions were performed with 2 U of AMV RT at 47°C (lanes 1, 7, and
13), 20 U of AMV RT at 47°C (lane 14), 200 U of SuperScript II RT at
42°C (lanes 2, 8, and 16), 20 U of SuperScript II RT at 42°C (lanes 3,
9, and 15), and 2 U of AMV Thermoscript RT at either 42°C (lanes 4 and
10), 47°C (lanes 5 and 11), or 52°C (lanes 6 and 12) . The arrowheads
labeled +1 indicate the positions of the fis P signals based on
their gel migration relative to that of DNA sequencing products from the
fis promoter region electrophoresed in parallel on the same gel
(data not shown) . The presumed start site positions of additional
signals observed (relative to fis P) are also indicated on the
sides of the gel according to the primers used in each set of reactions .
Abbreviations: Oligo, oligonucleotide; A, AMV RT; SS, SuperScript II RT;
TS, Thermoscript RT . (B) Dideoxy DNA sequence synthesized from RNA by
using SuperScript II RT and primers oRO446 or oRO447 . The sequencing
reaction mixtures loaded in lanes A, C, G, and T contained the A, C, G,
and T dideoxynucleotides, respectively . A portion of the sequence is
shown in uppercase boldface letters on each side of the gel, and
lowercase letters indicate 23S RNA and 16S RNA sequences that perfectly
complemented the sequences obtained with oRO446 or oRO447, respectively .
The underlined sequences (near the bottom) are regions of 23S and 16S
rRNA that complement the 3' regions of primers oRO446 and oRO447,
respectively . (C) Primer extension signals obtained with rRNA . Primer
extension reactions were performed with 5 µg of total RNA obtained from
MG1655 grown and harvested as described above (lanes 1, 2, 4, and 5) or
with 4 µg of purified rRNA (lanes 3 and 6) by using primer oRO109 (lanes
1, 2, and 3) or oRO447 (lanes 4, 5 and 6) and either 20 U (lanes 1 and
4) or 200 U (lanes 2, 3, 5, and 6) of SuperScript II RT . The arrowheads
indicate the position of the fis P transcript signal.
|
|
We tested two additional primers, oRO446 and oRO447, that annealed to
different positions on the fis mRNA . When 2 U of AMV RT was
used together with oRO446, the two transcript signals initiating from
fis P at positions +1 and -2 were observed, as was one other
weak signal whose size corresponded to the size of a transcript
initiating at position -32 (Fig . 9A, lane 7) . When 200 U of
SuperScript II RT was used, the same signals were observed together
with several strong signals that were much larger (lane 8) .
Again, none of these signals corresponded to a transcript initiating
at P2, P3, or P4 . The strongest signals corresponded to a transcript
initiating at position -168 . When only 20 U of SuperScript II RT was
used, there were large decreases in the intensities of these larger
signals, and there were no appreciable decreases in the intensities
of the signals that mapped to positions +1 and -2 or to position -32
(lane 9), which is consistent with the notion that the larger signals
might have resulted from secondary primer-annealing events that were
efficiently extended when very high concentrations of RT were used .
When Thermoscript RT was used together with primer oRO446, the
signals for positions +1 and -2 were observed for extension reactions
performed at 42, 47, and 52°C . The position -32 signal was observed
for reactions performed at 42 and 47°C but not for reactions
performed at 52°C (lanes 10, 11, and 12), suggesting that the
position -32 signal resulted from an oRO446 annealing event whose
specificity was lower than that of the position +1 and -2 signals .
Primer oRO447 also gave the signals corresponding to initiation at
fis P under all conditions tested (lanes 13 to 16) . With 2 U of
AMV RT, the signals corresponding to fis P were the most
prevalent signals (lane 13) . When 20 U of AMV RT or 20 U of
SuperScript II RT was used, a prominent signal corresponding to
initiation at position -69 and several additional signals for
initiation at positions -17, -133, -143, and -194 were also detected
(lanes 14 and 15) . The size of the signal for position -69 resembled
the size of the signal previously reported for initiation at P2 when
the same primer was used (31) . When 200 U of
SuperScript II RT was used, the five additional signals became even
more intense, and several additional weak signals also appeared (lane
16) . Thus, we consistently observed signals corresponding to fis
P when we used three different primers and different RT
concentrations, while multiple additional signals mapping to variable
positions appeared when high concentrations of RT were used .
To gain further insight into the identities of some of the signals
obtained with primers oRO446 and oRO447 when high RT concentrations
were used, we performed RNA sequencing reactions using 10 µg of total
mRNA from MG1665 grown to the early logarithmic growth phase in LB
medium (Fig . 9A) and 160 U of SuperScript II RT .
Much of the sequence information obtained was scrambled, suggesting
that several different RNA sequences were simultaneously detected
with the same primer . Nevertheless, certain regions of the sequencing
gel allowed us to decipher a clear sequence (Fig . 9B) . The
oRO446 primer gave a sequence that perfectly complemented a region
of the 23S rRNA, while the oRO447 primer gave a sequence that
perfectly complemented a region of the 16S rRNA . A short stretch of
six or seven bases was identified on the 23S or 16S rRNA that
complemented the 3' end of the corresponding primer used in each
case . This demonstrated that oRO446 and oRO447 partially annealed to
certain regions of 23S and 16S rRNA, respectively, serving as primers
in the reactions . To confirm these observations, purified rRNA was
also used in primer extension reactions with 200 U of SuperScript II
RT and primer oRO109 or oRO447 . The results showed that most of the
prominent signals detected when total cellular RNA was used were also
detected in reactions with purified rRNA (Fig . 9C,
compare lanes 2, 3, 5, and 6) . However, the signals corresponding to
initiation at fis P were detected only when total cellular RNA
was used in the primer extension reactions with either 20 or 200 U of
SuperScript II RT (lanes 1, 2, 4, and 5) . Together, these results
indicate that prominent signals, other than those for fis P,
obtained by this assay when high concentrations of RT were used were
the result of secondary priming events at rRNAs and possibly
other RNA targets .
Conservation of growth phase-dependent regulation and stringent control
of fis. We have shown that the growth phase-dependent fis
expression pattern previously observed in E . coli and S .
enterica serovar Typhimurium (2,
35, 38, 42) in response to a nutrient
upshift is also observed in four other enteric bacteria, K .
pneumoniae, S . marcescens, E . carotovora, and P .
vulgaris . In each of the four enteric bacteria, the relative
fis mRNA levels originating from the chromosomal fis genes
rapidly increased in response to a nutrient upshift, reached a peak
during early logarithmic growth phase, decreased to low values during
mid-logarithmic and late logarithmic growth, and became undetectable
during stationary phase . The results of Western blot analysis showed
that the Fis protein levels exhibited a similar growth phase-dependent
pattern of expression in each of these bacteria (data not shown) .
Under induced starvation conditions, E . coli fis is negatively
regulated by stringent control (38, 50) .
We obtained evidence that the same fis regulatory mechanism
also operates in K . pneumoniae, S . marcescens, E .
carotovora, and P . vulgaris . Thus, the cis- and
trans-acting factors involved in these two regulatory processes
are likely to be preserved in these bacteria . The conserved tight
connection between the nutritional state of the cells and the control
of fis expression suggests that an important function of Fis
is to rapidly regulate cellular processes in response to abrupt
changes in the nutritional environment . The role of Fis in
stimulating transcription of ribosomal and tRNA genes (33,
34, 45) illustrates its involvement in
optimizing the translational machinery in response to a nutritional
upshift, a function that is probably conserved in all these bacteria,
particularly since their Fis protein sequences are
98%
identical (3) . The ability of Fis to interact with its
various DNA targets depends on both its changing intracellular
concentration and the precise DNA sequence of each Fis binding site .
Thus, Fis-dependent processes involving low-affinity binding sites
are more likely to be highly sensitized to the nutritional quality
of the environment .
The yhdG-fis operon structure is preserved in all four enteric
bacteria examined . Little or no transcription activity was detected
within the DNA region that includes yhdG and the intergenic
region between yhdG and fis in K . pneumoniae, S .
marcescens, E . carotovora, or P . vulgaris, while
significant promoter activity was detected in the DNA regions
preceding yhdG in all four species . A sequence comparison of
the regions preceding yhdG showed that the E . coli fis
promoter region from about position -53 to position 20 is very highly
conserved among seven enteric bacteria . More specifically, the -35
and -10 promoter regions, the transcription start site, and the
GC-rich discriminator region, which were shown to be required for
either growth phase-dependent regulation of fis or its
response to stringent control in E . coli (38,
50), are preserved in these bacteria, suggesting that
the same promoter elements contribute similarly to regulation of
fis expression in enteric bacteria . These elements are also
generally conserved, albeit to a smaller extent, among six additional
nonenteric bacteria, and it will be interesting to determine
how fis is regulated in these organisms .
A single promoter (fis P) is responsible for expression and
regulation of the fis operon in E . coli. Results of
ß-galactosidase assays demonstrated that the E . coli fis
promoter region is located upstream of yhdG (Fig.
4) (2) . Because multiple promoters were
identified recently in this region that contribute substantially to
fis expression (31), we sought to detect
these promoters in order to weigh their contributions to fis
expression and regulation . However, the results of the primer
extension analysis of both chromosomal and multicopy plasmid-derived
transcripts in vivo, S1 nuclease mapping of chromosomally derived
transcripts, and in vitro transcription of linear or supercoiled
templates all clearly identified fis P as the only promoter
contributing to the expression of fis in E . coli . We
also examined the notion that the expression of putative upstream
promoters may be repressed by fis P . However, in our hands,
the complete deletion of fis P, which leaves the fis
promoter region from position -42 to position -194 intact, resulted
in no detectable promoter activity in vivo (on the basis of
ß-galactosidase assays) that could contribute to fis
expression . Therefore, our results led us to conclude that in the
region upstream of yhdG there is only one promoter, fis
P, that significantly contributes to expression of the fis
operon in E . coli .
The striking discrepancy between our detection of a single fis
promoter and the detection of multiple fis promoters reported
previously (31) deserved further attention . Our
investigation of the primer extension conditions employed in the
previous studies revealed that a large amount of SuperScript II RT in
the reaction mixtures (as recommended by the manufacturer) is
not suitable for reliable mapping of transcription initiation sites .
Such conditions result in misleading multiple signals with various
intensities that arise from extension of primers annealed to RNA
targets with reduced specificity . In particular, we demonstrated that
these conditions result in prominent signals originating from
secondary primer annealing to 16S or 23S rRNA in addition to the
signals originating at fis P . On the other hand, a substantial
reduction in the RT concentration prevented detection of signals
arising from reduced annealing specificity, while it allowed
detection of the transcripts initiating at fis P . rRNAs are
easy targets of partial annealing events because of their very high
concentrations in the total cellular RNA . However, secondary
annealing events at mRNAs might also be detected if the interactions
are sufficiently stable . The problem of secondary annealing events
can also be encountered when the primer extension procedure is used
as the method of identifying transcripts generated in vitro .
Therefore, confirmation by the more direct method of synthesizing
labeled transcripts is essential .
When lower levels of enzyme are used (e.g., 1 U per 10 µg of total
RNA), the kinetics of ternary complex formation (involving the
primer, RNA, and enzyme) may be more strongly dependent upon the
availability of longer-lived primer-RNA hybrids, as expected for the
completely annealed primer . Thus, care should be taken to optimize
the enzyme concentration in primer extension assays aimed at mapping
specific transcription start sites, despite the manufacturer's
recommendations . Even the choice of primers can be critical for
identification of specific transcripts . Use of RT variants that are
active at higher temperatures can assist in destabilizing incomplete
hybrids . Finally, S1 nuclease mapping should be employed as an
independent confirmatory approach . Our primer extension conditions,
in which low concentrations of RT were used, were found to be much
more reliable for mapping specific transcription initiation sites
than the conditions used to detect multiple promoters in the fis
promoter region (31), and the results were in
excellent agreement with the results of our S1 nuclease mapping, in
vitro transcription, and ß-galactosidase assay experiments . Thus, we
firmly concluded that fis P is the only promoter in the region
preceding yhdG that significantly contributes to the
transcription of fis .
We detected a low level of divergent transcription activity that
originates somewhere upstream of fis P, since we observed it
in a promoter region lacking fis P . Previously, an RNA polymerase
binding site upstream of fis P from position -137 to position
-68 was detected (2) that was subsequently reported to
serve as a divergent promoter designated Pdiv (32) .
However, we have not been able to detect an in vivo transcript that
maps to this putative promoter when either primer extension or S1
nuclease mapping is used with RNA obtained from cells in either the
logarithmic or stationary growth phase (data not shown) . The very low
level of divergent transcription detected by the ß-galactosidase
assay suggests that the contribution of this transcription in
vivo has little significance, especially since there are no open
reading frames that can be expressed from this promoter in over 6 kb
of DNA . It has previously been observed that, while deletion or
mutation of an ihf binding site centered at position -114
resulted in a three- to fourfold reduction in fis P transcription,
deletion of the putative divergent promoter had no additional
effect on the transcription of fis P (44) .
The strong conservation of the fis promoter sequence among enteric
bacteria, which contrasts with the poor conservation of upstream
sequences that include P2, P3, P4, and Pdiv, suggests that fis
P is probably the principal if not the sole promoter responsible
for fis expression and regulation in the other species studied .
The fis P transcription initiation region is largely comprised
of C and U in the promoters examined, suggesting that transcription
initiation with a pyrimidine is a conserved property of this
promoter . This is significant because it has been observed that the
growth phase-dependent regulation of fis P in E . coli is
strongly linked to the use of CTP or UTP as the primary initiation
nucleotide (50, 51) . The GC-rich
discriminator region between the -10 promoter region and the
transcription start site, which has been observed to be linked to the
response to stringent control (38,
50), is also strongly conserved in these bacteria . Thus, a
comprehensive understanding of the regulation of fis
expression in response to changes in the nutritional state must focus
on the properties of the unique fis promoter .
We thank R . C . Johnson, R . L . Gourse, A . K . Chatterjee, and R . A .
Bender for providing strains used in this work .
This work was supported by funds from Public Health Service grant
GM52051 .
* Corresponding author . Mailing address: Department of
Biological Sciences, University at Albany, SUNY, 1400 Washington Avenue, Albany,
NY 12222 . Phone: (518) 437-4492 . Fax: (518) 442-4767 . E-mail: osuna@albany.edu .
Present address: Department of Biology, Chemistry and Physics,
Southern Polytechnic State University, Marietta, GA 30060 .
Present address: Department of Molecular Medicine, Apollo Hospitals,
Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad 500 033, India .
- Ali Azam, T., A . Iwata, A . Nishimura, S . Ueda, and A .
Ishihama. 1999 . Growth phase-dependent variation in protein composition of
the Escherichia coli nucleoid . J . Bacteriol . 181:6361-6370 .
- Ball, C . A., R . Osuna, K . C . Ferguson, and R . C . Johnson.
1992 . Dramatic changes in Fis levels upon nutrient upshift in Escherichia
coli. J . Bacteriol.174:8043-8056.
- Beach, M . B., and R . Osuna. 1998 . Identification and
characterization of the fis operon in enteric bacteria . J . Bacteriol.
180:5932-5946 .
- Bishop, A . C., J . Xu, R . C . Johnson, P . Schimmel, and V . de
Crecy-Lagard. 2002 . Identification of the tRNA-dihydrouridine synthase
family . J . Biol . Chem . 277:25090-25095 .
- Bosch, L., L . Nilsson, E . Vijgenboom, and H . Verbeek.
1990 . FIS-dependent trans-activation of tRNA and rRNA operons of
Escherichia coli. Biochim . Biophys . Acta 1050:293-301.
- Boyd, C . H., and J . W . Gober. 2001 . Temporal regulation
of genes encoding the flagellar proximal rod in Caulobacter crescentus.
J . Bacteriol . 183:725-735 .
- Bustos, S . A., and R . F . Schleif. 1993 . Functional
domains of the AraC protein . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . 90:5638-5642.
- Case, C . C., S . M . Roels, J . E . Gonzalez, E . Simons, and R .
Simons. 1988 . Analysis of the promoters and transcripts involved in IS10
anti-sense transcriptional RNA control . Gene 72:219-236.
- Chuang, S . E., D . L . Daniels, and F . R . Blattner. 1993 .
Global regulation of gene expression in Escherichia coli. J . Bacteriol.
175:2026-2036.
- Corpet, F. 1988 . Multiple sequence alignment with
hierarchical clustering . Nucleic Acids Res . 16:10881-10890.
- Gonzalez-Gil, G., P . Bringmann, and R . Kahmann. 1996 .
FIS is a regulator of metabolism in Escherichia coli. Mol . Microbiol.
22:21-29.
- Gottesman, S. 1984 . Bacterial regulation: global
regulatory networks . Annu . Rev . Genet . 18:415-441.
- Hartz, D., D . S . McPheeters, R . Traut, and L . Gold.
1988 . Extension inhibition analysis of translation initiation complexes .
Methods Enzymol . 164:419-425.
- Kolb, A., S . Busby, H . Buc, S . Garges, and S . Adhya.
1993 . Transcriptional regulation by cAMP and its receptor protein . Annu . Rev .
Biochem . 62:749-795.
- Kucherer, C., H . Lother, R . Kolling, M . A . Schauzu, and W .
Messer. 1986 . Regulation of transcription of the chromosomal dnaA
gene of Escherichia coli. Mol . Gen . Genet . 205:115-121.
- Landini, P., L . I . Hajec, and M . R . Volkert. 1994 .
Structure and transcriptional regulation of the Escherichia coli
adaptive response gene aidB. J . Bacteriol . 176:6583-6589.
- Lindahl, T., B . Sedgwick, M . Sekiguchi, and Y . Nakabeppu.
1988 . Regulation and expression of the adaptive response to alkylating agents .
Annu . Rev . Biochem . 57:133-157.
- Little, J . W. 1993 . LexA cleavage and other
self-processing reactions . J . Bacteriol . 175:4943-4950.
- Loewen, P . C., I . von Ossowski, J . Switala, and M . R .
Mulvey. 1993 . KatF (sigma S) synthesis in Escherichia coli is
subject to posttranscriptional regulation . J . Bacteriol . 175:2150-2153.
- Magasanik, B. 2000 . Global regulation of gene
expression . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . 97:14044-14045.
- Martin, R . G., and J . L . Rosner. 1997 . Fis, an
accessorial factor for transcriptional activation of the mar (multiple
antibiotic resistance) promoter of Escherichia coli in the presence of
the activator MarA, SoxS, or Rob . J . Bacteriol . 179:7410-7419.
- Master, S., T . C . Zahrt, J . Song, and V . Deretic. 2001 .
Mapping of Mycobacterium tuberculosis katG promoters and their
differential expression in infected macrophages . J . Bacteriol . 183:4033-4039 .
- McCann, M . P., C . D . Fraley, and A . Matin. 1993 . The
putative sigma factor KatF is regulated posttranscriptionally during carbon
starvation . J . Bacteriol . 175:2143-2149.
- Miller, J . F. 1972 . Experiments in molecular genetics .
Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y.
- Miller, J . F., W . J . Dower, and L . S . Tompkins. 1988 .
High-voltage electroporation of bacteria: genetic transformation of
Campylobacter jejuni with plasmid DNA . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . 85:856-860.
- Miller, J . H. 1992 . A short course in bacterial
genetics . Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y.
- Minagawa, S., H . Ogasawara, A . Kato, K . Yamamoto, Y . Eguchi,
T . Oshima, H . Mori, A . Ishihama, and R . Utsumi. 2003 . Identification and
molecular characterization of the Mg2+ stimulon of Escherichia
coli. J . Bacteriol . 185:3696-3702 .
- Mohr, C . D., J . K . MacKichan, and L . Shapiro. 1998 . A
membrane-associated protein, FliX, is required for an early step in
Caulobacter flagellar assembly . J . Bacteriol . 180:2175-2185 .
- Morigen, E . Boye, K . Skarstad, and A . Lobner-Olesen.
2001 . Regulation of chromosomal replication by DnaA protein availability in
Escherichia coli: effects of the datA region . Biochim . Biophys .
Acta 1521:73-80.
- Nagai, H., H . Yuzawa, and T . Yura. 1991 . Interplay of
two cis-acting mRNA regions in translational control of sigma 32
synthesis during the heat shock response of Escherichia coli. Proc .
Natl . Acad . Sci . 88:10515-10519.
- Nasser, W., M . Rochman, and G . Muskhelishvili. 2002 .
Transcriptional regulation of fis operon involves a module of multiple
coupled promoters . EMBO J . 21:715-724 .
- Nasser, W., R . Schneider, A . Travers, and G . Muskhelishvili.
2001 . CRP modulates fis transcription by alternate formation of
activating and repressing nucleoprotein complexes . J . Biol . Chem . 276:17878-17886 .
- Nilsson, L., and V . Emilsson. 1994 . Factor for inversion
stimulation-dependent growth rate regulation of individual tRNA species in
Escherichia coli. J . Biol . Chem . 269:9460-9465 .
- Nilsson, L., A . Vanet, E . Vijgenboom, and L . Bosch.
1990 . The role of FIS in trans activation of stable RNA operons of E . coli.
EMBO J . 9:727-734.
- Nilsson, L., H . Verbeek, E . Vijgenboom, C . van Drunen, A .
Vanet, and L . Bosch. 1992 . FIS-dependent trans activation of stable
RNA operons of Escherichia coli under various growth conditions . J .
Bacteriol . 174:921-929.
- Ninfa, A . J. 1996 . Regulation of gene transcription by
extracellular stimuli, p . 1246-1262 . In F . C . Neidhardt, J . L .
Ingraham, K . B . Low, B . Magasanik, M . Schaechter, and H . E . Umbarger (ed.),
Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium: cellular and molecular
biology, 2nd ed., vol . 1 . American Society for Microbiology Press, Washington,
D.C.
- Ninfa, A . J., and B . Magasanik. 1986 . Covalent
modification of the glnG product, NRI, by the glnL product,
NRII, regulates the transcription of the glnALG operon in
Escherichia coli. Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . 83:5909-5913.
- Ninnemann, O., C . Koch, and R . Kahmann. 1992 . The E .
coli fis promoter is subject to stringent control and autoregulation . EMBO
J . 11:1075-1083.
- Ohnishi, K., K . Kutsukake, H . Suzuki, and T . Lino. 1992 .
A novel transcriptional regulation mechanism in the flagellar regulon of
Salmonella typhimurium: an antisigma factor inhibits the activity of the
flagellum-specific sigma factor, sigma F . Mol . Microbiol . 6:3149-3157.
- Orsini, G., M . Ouhammouch, J . P . Le Caer, and E . N . Brody.
1993 . The asiA gene of bacteriophage T4 codes for the anti-sigma 70
protein . J . Bacteriol . 175:85-93.
- Osuna, R., S . E . Finkel, and R . C . Johnson. 1991 .
Identification of two functional regions in Fis: the N-terminus is required to
promote Hin-mediated DNA inversion but not lambda excision . EMBO J . 10:1593-1603.
- Osuna, R., D . Lienau, K . T . Hughes, and R . C . Johnson.
1995 . Sequence, regulation, and functions of fis in Salmonella
typhimurium. J . Bacteriol . 177:2021-2032.
- Pokholok, D . K., M . Redlak, C . L . Turnbough, Jr., S . Dylla,
and W . M . Holmes. 1999 . Multiple mechanisms are used for growth rate and
stringent control of leuV transcriptional initiation in Escherichia
coli. J . Bacteriol . 181:5771-5782 .
- Pratt, T . S., T . Steiner, L . S . Feldman, K . A . Walker, and
R . Osuna. 1997 . Deletion analysis of the fis promoter region in
Escherichia coli: antagonistic effects of integration host factor and Fis .
J . Bacteriol . 179:6367-6377.
- Ross, W., J . F . Thompson, J . T . Newlands, and R . L . Gourse.
1990 . E . coli Fis protein activates ribosomal RNA transcription in
vitro and in vivo . EMBO J . 9:3733-3742.
- Sambrook, J . E., E . F . Fritsch, and T . Maniatis. 1989 .
Molecular cloning: a laboratory manual, 2nd ed . Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
Press, Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y.
- Schell, M . A. 1993 . Molecular biology of the LysR family
of transcriptional regulators . Annu . Rev . Microbiol . 47:597-626.
- Stock, J . B., A . J . Ninfa, and A . M . Stock. 1989 .
Protein phosphorylation and regulation of adaptive responses in bacteria .
Microbiol . Rev . 53:450-490.
- Thompson, J . F., L . Moitoso de Vargas, C . Koch, R . Kahmann,
and A . Landy. 1987 . Cellular factors couple recombination with growth
phase: characterization of a new component in the lambda site-specific
recombination pathway . Cell 50:901-908.
- Walker, K . A., C . L . Atkins, and R . Osuna. 1999 .
Functional determinants of the Escherichia coli fis promoter: roles of
-35, -10, and transcription initiation regions in the response to stringent
control and growth phase-dependent regulation . J . Bacteriol . 181:1269-1280 .
- Walker, K . A., and R . Osuna. 2002 . Factors affecting
start site selection at the Escherichia coli fis promoter . J .
Bacteriol . 184:4783-4791 .
- Xu, J., and R . C . Johnson. 1995 . Fis activates the
RpoS-dependent stationary-phase expression of proP in Escherichia
coli. J . Bacteriol . 177:5222-5231.
- Xu, J., and R . C . Johnson. 1995 . Identification of genes
negatively regulated by Fis: Fis and RpoS comodulate growth-phase-dependent
gene expression in Escherichia coli. J . Bacteriol . 177:938-947.
Free Online Full-text Article
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
|