|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, August 2004, p . 5003-5016, Vol . 186,
No . 15
Replication of Enterococcus faecalis Pheromone-Responding Plasmid pAD1:
Location of the Minimal Replicon and oriV Site and RepA Involvement in
Initiation of Replication
Maria Victoria Francia,1,2 Shuhei Fujimoto,1,
Patricia Tille,3 Keith E . Weaver,3 and Don B . Clewell1,4*
Department of Biologic and Materials Sciences, School of Dentistry,1
Department of Microbiology and Immunology, School of Medicine, The University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109,4 Servicio de Microbiología,
Hospital Universitario Marqués de Valdecilla, 39008 Santander, Cantabria, Spain,2
Department of Microbiology, University of South Dakota School of Medicine,
Vermillion, South Dakota 570693
Received 14 April 2004/ Accepted 23 April 2004
The hemolysin-determining plasmid pAD1 is a member of a widely
disseminated family of highly conjugative elements commonly present
in clinical isolates of Enterococcus faecalis . The determinants
repA, repB, and repC, as well as adjacent iteron
sequences, are believed to play important roles in pAD1 replication
and maintenance . The repA gene encodes an initiator protein,
whereas repB and repC encode proteins related to
stability and copy number . The present study focuses specifically on
repA and identifies a replication origin (oriV) within
a central region of the repA determinant . A small segment of
repA carrying oriV was able to support replication in
cis of a plasmid vector otherwise unable to replicate, if an
intact RepA was supplied in trans . We demonstrate that under
conditions in which RepA is expressed from an artificial promoter, a
segment of DNA carrying only repA is sufficient for stable
replication in E . faecalis . We also show that RepA binds
specifically to oriV DNA at several sites containing inverted
repeat sequences (i.e., IR-1) and nonspecifically to single-stranded
DNA, and related genetic analyses confirm that these sequences play
an important role in replication . Finally, we reveal a relationship
between the internal structure of RepA and its ability to recognize
oriV . An in-frame deletion within repA resulting in
loss of 105 nucleotides, including at least part of oriV, did
not eliminate the ability of the altered RepA protein to initiate
replication using an intact origin provided in trans . The
relationship of RepA to other known initiator proteins is also
discussed .
pAD1 is a 60-kb, conjugative plasmid originally identified in
Enterococcus faecalis DS16 (12, 23,
49) . It encodes a cytolysin
(hemolysin/bacteriocin) that contributes to virulence in animal
models (8, 37, 40) and
is one of numerous plasmids in E . faecalis that facilitate a
response to peptide sex pheromones secreted by plasmid-free
(recipient) bacteria . pAD1 responds to the pheromone cAD1 and
represents a widely disseminated family of cytolysin plasmids
commonly associated with clinical infections in humans (38)
and which, for the most part, are members of the same incompatibility
group (13, 34) . (For recent reviews, see
references 9 and 10.)
Nucleotide sequence data relating to plasmids from different
incompatibility groups (e.g., pAD1, pAM373, pCF10, and pPD1) and
responding to four different pheromones have shown that the regions
associated with replication and maintenance are organized similarly;
in all cases, this region is located adjacent to that involved in
regulation of the pheromone response (9,
10) . In the case of pAD1 the key determinants associated with
plasmid maintenance are repA, repB, and repC (Fig.
1A) . On the basis of sequence homology, repA
is believed to encode the initiator of vegetative replication,
whereas repB and repC most likely represent a partition
system (50, 54) . When a segment carrying
these three determinants was cloned on an E . coli plasmid vector,
it enabled the chimera to replicate in E . faecalis (52) .
Transposon insertion mutations within repA were unable to
replicate in E . faecalis, whereas insertions within repB
and repC affected stability and copy number . Two series of
octanucleotide iterons are located between the divergently oriented
repA and repB and, like iteron sequences associated
with other plasmid replicons, are believed to play a role in
replication and/or maintenance (17) . The iterons
are a series of 12 and 13 repeats separated by 78 nucleotides (52) .
|
FIG . 1 . (A) pAD1 genetic map (not to scale) showing the replication and
maintenance region, along with the adjacent pheromone response
regulation region . Putative promoters are indicated by a "P"
above the map, and the adjacent arrow indicates the direction of
transcription . Transcriptional terminators are represented by t1/t2 .
Iterons and repA internal direct repeats are represented by
"thick" black arrows . Thick gray arrows (above and below) represent the
positions and orientations of the traB, repA, and repB
primers . Different DNA fragments specifically analyzed are indicated by
various lines named accordingly . (B) Nucleotide sequence of the RepA
coding sequence showing the internal array of repeats . The numbers above
are shown to indicate the nucleotide or amino acid position inside
repA . MfeI, RsaI, and DraI restriction sites are indicated . Thin
arrows correspond to the RepA internal direct repeats . Thick arrows
represent the RepA internal invert repeats . The name of each repeat is
also indicated as described previously (3) . The
asterisk indicates the location of the generated frameshift mutation in
repA . Vertical arrows indicate the ends of the repA
in-frame deletion obtained . The small gray arrows represent the specific
primers used for the construction of clones.
|
|
Among the pheromone-responding plasmids, the corresponding repA
and repB gene products exhibit significant similarity, and RepA
resembles a family of initiator proteins encoded by several
low-copy plasmids from Staphylococcus, Lactobacillus,
Lactococcus, and Bacillus species (5,
19, 28, 41,
48) . For some related plasmids, the replication
origin (oriV) has been located within the coding sequences of
the initiator proteins (19, 28,
48); however, in the case of the related
lactococcal plasmid pCI2000 the oriV appears to be located
outside of the initiator determinant (41) .
Interestingly, the pCI2000 replication region is organized similarly
to that of pAD1, with an active partition system transcribed
divergently from the initiator determinant . The 70-kb Bacillus
natto plasmid pLS32, which has an oriV within the initiator
determinant (repN), utilizes a theta replication mechanism,
and is the best characterized of the nonenterococcal members of
this group (48) .
Genes encoding the RepA family of proteins noted here bear interesting,
centrally located, directly repeated nucleotide sequences . For
example, in the case of repA of pAD1 a 33-bp sequence (DR1) is
repeated twice (only one mismatch) and separated by about 75 bp (see
Fig . 1B) . Similar repeats within the repN of pLS32,
but involving different nucleotides, have been suggested to
contain the oriV site of that plasmid (48) .
pAD1 has two transfer (conjugation) origins, oriT1 and oriT2,
that are located about 180° apart on the circular map (3,
11, 23) . The oriT2 site is
located adjacent to a relaxase (TraX) determinant and is believed to
be the preferred site for conjugative transfer (22),
whereas oriT1 operates several orders of magnitude less
efficiently and is located within repA (3) . In addition
to the location of oriT1 with respect to repA, another
interesting feature that seems to "associate" genes for vegetative
replication and transfer functions is a phase variation phenomenon
involving transfer functions . This involves the reversible switching
on and off of conjugation genes by way of changes in the number
of iterons (generally an increase in four iterons [32 nucleotides])
between repA and repB (32,
46) . The mechanism by which this phase variation affects
conjugation functions remains unknown .
The close physical association of sequences involved in both
vegetative replication and regulation of conjugative transfer
prompted us to further characterize the pAD1 region associated with
plasmid replication . Here we present data showing that RepA is the
only pAD1-encoded protein required to initiate replication and that
oriV is located within a small segment of the repA
determinant . RepA is shown to bind to small inverted repeat
structures (i.e., IR-1) within oriV, and these structures are
shown genetically to play an important role in replication . In
addition, we identify an intriguing relationship between the internal
structure of RepA protein and the recognition of oriV .
Bacterial strains, plasmids, and oligonucleotides. The
Escherichia coli K-12 and E . faecalis strains, plasmids,
and synthetic oligonucleotides used in this study are listed in Table
1 . E . faecalis strains were grown in Todd-Hewitt broth
(THB; Difco Laboratories, Detroit, Mich.) at 37°C . E . coli
strains were grown in Luria-Bertani (LB) broth (47) .
Plating was on THB or LB agar . The following antibiotics were used at
the indicated concentrations with E . faecalis: erythromycin
at 20 µg/ml, chloramphenicol at 20 µg/ml, rifampin at 25 µg/ml,
and fusidic acid at 25 µg/ml . With E . coli, the concentrations
were ampicillin 100 µg/ml, kanamycin at 50 µg/ml, chloramphenicol at
25 µg/ml, erythromycin at 200 µg/ml, and nalidixic acid at 20 µg/ml .
All antibiotics were obtained from Sigma Chemical Co . X-Gal
(5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl-ß-D-galactopyranoside)
and IPTG (isopropyl-ß-D-thiogalactopyranoside) were
from Invitrogen and were used at a concentrations of 40 µg/ml
and 1 mM, respectively . Synthetic cAD1 peptide was prepared at the
University of Michigan peptide synthesis core facility .
| TABLE 1 . Bacterial strains, plasmids, and oligonucleotides used in this
study
|
|
Standard molecular techniques. Recombinant plasmids were
generated in E . coli DH5 .
Introduction of plasmid DNA into bacterial cells was done by
transformation as previously described (16,
31) . Electrotransformation of E . faecalis
was done as described by Flannagan and Clewell (20) .
Plasmid DNA was purified from E . coli by using established
techniques described elsewhere (47) . Isolation of
plasmid DNA from E . faecalis was also as previously described
(51) . When necessary, DNA fragments were purified
with silica gel as described by Boyle and Lew (6) .
Recombinant DNA methodology, as well as analyses of plasmid DNA by
using restriction enzymes, agarose gel electrophoresis, and Southern
hybridization, involved procedures described by Sambrook et al . (47) .
Restriction enzymes were purchased from Invitrogen, and reactions
were carried out under the conditions recommended . PCR was performed
with a Perkin-Elmer Cetus apparatus under conditions recommended by
the manufacturer . Specific primers were purchased from Invitrogen,
and Taq DNA polymerase was from Roche . PCR-generated fragments
were purified by using QIAquick-spin columns (Qiagen) . Ligations made
use of T4 DNA ligase from New England Biolabs . Nucleotide sequence
analyses were carried at the University of Michigan sequencing core
facility or using the "fmol DNA Cycle Sequencing System" as specified
by the manufacturer (Promega) .
Plasmid constructions. The vector pSU18bac represents a
pSU18 (4) derivative in which the bacteriocin (bac)
promoter (27) has been cloned as an EcoRI
fragment . pSU18bac* contains a point mutation in the promoter –10
box, which results in the sequence CATAAT . From here the SalI/KpnI
fragment that contains the bac promoter was subcloned into
pAM434 (21), yielding pAM434b* .
Different segments of pAD1 included in the replication-maintenance
region were amplified by PCR from template pAM714 (35) or
pAM3314, pAM3316, and pAM3318 (3) by using the
oligonucleotides indicated in Table 1 and cloned
into pTAd via TA cloning . The corresponding clone containing repA
was partially MfeI digested and filled with Klenow to obtain a
frameshift mutation . From here, XbaI/HindIII fragments were subcloned
into the E . faecalis suicide plasmid pAM88 (22),
generating the plasmids pAM88A*, pAM88It, pAM88-3314, pAM88-3316,
pAM88-3318, and pAM88oriV . The clones containing repA or
repA 9
coding sequences in pAM434 were cloned in several steps . The
fragments repA or repA 9
contained in pTAd were obtained by digestion with the restriction
enzymes EagI/NruI, purified, and cloned into the BsaI and Eco47III
sites of pSU18b* . The SalI/KpnI fragments, which contained genes
behind the bac promoter, were subcloned into pAM434,
generating the plasmids pAM434brepA and pAM434brepA 9 .
The repA derivatives with point mutations were picked up as
"unexpected" variants noticed upon sequencing PCR products, as was
the deletion relating to pAM330 9and
pAM434brepA 9 .
Fragments of DNA containing sequences from the repA and repB
genes were amplified by PCR from pAM714 with the primer pairs
ETrepA.1 and ETrepA.2, ETrepA.1 and ETrepA.3, ETrepA.4 and ETrepA.2,
ASK60repA.1 and ASK60repA.2, or ASK60repB.1 and ASK60repB.2,
respectively (Table 1); digested with BglII and HindIII (repA)
or EagI and NruI (repA and repB); and cloned into the same
sites of pET30a or pASK60, as indicated, to construct the plasmids
pET30aRepA, pET30aRepA5', pET30RepA3', pASK60RepA, and pASK60RepB,
respectively . In the expression vector pET30, RepA is under the
control of the T7 promoter . In pASK60, RepA and RepB are under the
control of the lac promoter .
Fragments of DNA containing the iteron sequences were amplified by
PCR with the primers It1 and It2 or It3 and RepB with the plasmid
pAM714 as a template and cloned into pTAd plasmid vector to construct
the plasmids pTAdIt5' and pTAdIt3' . The complete It region was
amplified by PCR with the primers RepA and RepB by using the plasmid
pAM714 as a template and then cloned into pTAd plasmid vector to
construct the plasmid pTAdIt . The putative oriV site was
obtained on a digestion product of MfeI and RsaI and cloned into
pBluescript to produce the plasmid pBlueScriptoriV . Plasmids pTAdIR1,
pTAdIR1*, and pTAdItC were obtained by annealing the corresponding
sense and antisense oligonucleotides (Table 1) and
direct ligation into the EcoRI site of the pTAd cloning vector . All
of the constructions were confirmed by DNA sequencing .
Stability and incompatibility assays. Stability assays were
performed as previously described by Wirth et al . (55) .
Incompatibility experiments were performed from single colonies of
OG1X strains containing either plasmids pDAK246 E
and pAM3314 or plasmids pDAK246 E
and pAM401 . Loss of pDAK246 E
was monitored in the presence of selection for the other plasmid
as previously described (52) .
Protein purification. The His-tagged fusion proteins (RepA,
RepA5', and RepA3') were purified from recombinant E . coli
BL21(DE3) induced with 1 mM isopropyl-ß-D-thiogalactoside
by using an Ni-agarose column as described in the manufacturer's
instructions (Qiagen GmbH) . The Strep-tagged fusion proteins (RepA
and RepB) were purified from recombinant E . coli JM83 induced
with 1 mM isopropyl-ß-D-thiogalactoside by
using a streptavidin-immobilized column as described in the
manufacturer's instructions (Boehringer Mannheim) . All protein
preparations used in DNA binding studies were at least 90% pure based
on polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis estimates .
Protein analysis. Proteins were boiled in sample buffer
containing sodium dodecyl sulfate and ß-mercaptoethanol and then
subjected to sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel
electrophoresis on a 12% gel according to the method of Laemmli (42) .
Gels were stained with Coomassie brilliant blue R-250 . Western
blotting was performed as described elsewhere (47),
and the His-tagged fusion protein (RepA) was detected by using
polyclonal anti-His antibody (Santa Cruz Biotechnology), whereas the
Strep-tagged fusion proteins (RepA and RepB) were detected by using
the polyclonal anti-Strep antibody (Pierce) and the ECL Western
blotting analysis system (Amersham Pharmacia Biotech) .
DPAC assays. DNA-protein tag affinity chromatography was
carried out under the conditions described by Fujimoto and Clewell (26) .
Restriction enzyme-digested DNA plasmid pAM2603 was extracted with
phenol-chloroform and precipitated with ethanol . Then, 4 µl
corresponding to ca . 2 µg of cleaved DNA in 10 mM Tris (pH 8.0) was
used .
Preparation of DNA substrates. Double-stranded DNA (dsDNA)
containing iteron repeat fragments for binding assays were generated
by PCR by using the plasmids pTAdIt5' and pTAdIt3' as templates . The
primers used are indicated in Table 1 . dsDNA
containing oriV fragment was obtained by digestion from
pBlueScriptoriV plasmid . The fragments were labeled with [ -32P]dATP
(Amersham) included in the PCR or by filling by Klenow in the oriV-containing
fragment . PCR products or digestion bands were separated in an
agarose gel, and excised bands were eluted with a QiaQuick gel
extraction kit (Qiagen) . The DNA samples were loaded on an agarose
gel for quantification . S1 digestion and boiling and/or denaturation
assays were performed in order to demonstrate the nature of the DNA
bands tested (24) .
Gel mobility shift assays. Labeled DNA fragments (1 pmol)
were incubated with either RepA (or its putative N- and C-terminal
domains), RepB, or control (vector derived) protein fractions (0.1
and 0.5 µg) for 15 min at 30°C in a 20-µl volume containing 50 mM
Tris (pH 7.5), 100 mM NaCl, 0.2 mM EDTA, 5% glycerol, 1 mM dithiothreitol,
1.5 µg of poly(dI-dC) DNA, and 0.7 µg of bovine serum albumin .
After this incubation period, the binding reaction mixtures were
placed on ice, loaded onto a 5% prerun polyacrylamide gel, and
electrophoresed at room temperature in 0.5x
Tris-borate-EDTA buffer . After electrophoresis, the gel was dried on
Whatman 3MM paper and exposed to X-ray film at –70°C with
an intensifying screen .
Construction of clones representing the mutated IR-1 sites.
The 525-bp PCR fragment containing the pAD1 oriV site that included
modifications in IR3 and IR4 was generated with primers M2 and
ETrepA.2 and pAM88A* as a template DNA . The 528-bp PCR fragment also
containing the mutated repeats IR3 and IR4 was generated by using M3
and ETrepA.1 as primers and pAM88A* as a template DNA . Both fragments
were purified by using QIAquick spin columns (Qiagen), diluted
1:1,000, mixed, and used as a template for a new PCR with ETrepA.1
and ETrepA.2 primers . The resulting 1-kb band contained repA*
with the repeats IR3 and IR4 mutated (IR3+4) . The 588-bp PCR fragment
containing the pAD1 oriV site, including the mutated repeats
IR1 and IR2, was generated by using primers M4 and ETrepA.2 and
pAM88A* as template DNA . The 465-bp PCR fragment also containing the
mutated repeats IR1 and IR2 was generated by using M5 and ETrepA.1 as
primers and pAM88A* as template DNA . Again, both fragments were
purified (as described above), diluted 1:1,000, mixed, and used as a
template for a new PCR by using ETrepA.1 and ETrepA.2 as primers .
The resulting 1-kb band contained repA* with the repeats IR1
and IR2 mutated (IR1+2) . The 588-bp PCR fragment containing the
pAD1 oriV site that included the mutated repeats IR1 and IR2
was generated by using primers M4 and ETrepA.2 and band IR3+4 as
template DNA . The 465-bp PCR fragment containing the mutated repeats
IR1 and IR2 was generated by using M5 and EtrepA.1 as primers and
band IR1+2 as template DNA . Both fragments were purified and diluted
(as described above), mixed, and used as template for a new PCR with
ETrepA.1 and ETrepA.2 primers . The resulting 1-kb band contained
repA* with the repeats IR1, IR2, IR3, and IR4 mutated
(IR1+2+3+4) . The 501-bp PCR fragment containing the pAD1 oriV
site that included the mutated repeat IR5 was generated by using
primers M1s and ETrepA.2 and band IR1+2+3+4 as template DNA . The
563-bp PCR fragment containing the mutated repeats IR1, IR2, IR3,
IR4, and IR5 was generated by using M1as and ETrepA.1 as primers and
band IR1+2+3+4 as template DNA . Both fragments were purified,
diluted, mixed (as described above), and used as a template for a new
PCR with ETrepA.1 and ETrepA.2 as primers . The resulting 1-kb band
contained repA* with all IR-1 repeats mutated (5xIR) . The
resulting DNA products were purified and ligated to pTAd, and the
1.1-kb XbaI-HindIII fragments were cloned into pAM88 obtaining
pAM88A*-IR3+4, pAM88A*-IR1+2, pAM88A*-IR1+2+3+4, and pAM88A*-5xIR,
respectively . All clones were confirmed by DNA sequencing .
The oriV of pAD1 is within the repA coding
sequence. Although it was previously reported that the pAD1 replicon
was located on an
3-kb
segment of pAD1 carrying repA, repB, and repC
and a series of iterons (52), the precise location of oriV
was not determined . Although the presence of an array of iterons
suggested involvement in replication initiation, recent reports
of oriV sequences being located within determinants of repA-like
sequences raised the possibility that the origin might be located
within repA . Identification of an oriV sequence is generally
based on its ability to facilitate replication when present on
a plasmid that could otherwise not replicate, if we assume that
appropriate replication factors (e.g., initiator protein) are
provided in trans . To locate the oriV of pAD1, we cloned
specific segments of DNA (either an internal region of repA
or the iteron region located between the repA and repB
determinants) into a plasmid (pAM88) that is incapable of autonomous
replication in E . faecalis .
pAM88 is an E . coli vector carrying a cat determinant able to
express in E . faecalis (22) and therefore useful
for testing replication . A 1.01-kb segment of pAD1 DNA carrying
repA with a frameshift mutation and devoid of a ribosome-binding
site was cloned in pAM88, and the resulting chimera, pAM88A* (Table
1 and Fig . 1), was introduced by
electroporation into an E . faecalis JH2-2 host harboring a
pAD1::pAD2 cointegrate derivative pAM330 (12) .
(The frameshift mutation in the cloned segment was to assure that
there was no expression of RepA from the resulting chimera.) We
utilized the cointegrate because it should not be totally dependent
on the pAD1 replication origin; that is, it should be able to make
use of the pAD2 origin for replication . Selection with
chloramphenicol resulted in transformants at a frequency of 3.1
x 10–7 transformants per number
of cells per µg of DNA (Table 2) . In contrast, a
pAM88 chimera designated pAM88It carrying the iteron sequences
located between repA and repB (0.5 kb, Table
1 and Fig . 1), as well as the empty
vector (pAM88), could not be maintained in (i.e., transform)
JH2-2/pAM330 cells (Table 2) . Homologous recombination was not
involved in the process, as judged by an inability to detect
PCR products with primers designed to amplify either of the joint
regions that would be expected (Fig . 2A) . In addition,
restriction bands appropriate for separate (not recombined)
plasmids were observed by agarose gel analysis (data not shown) . The
data imply that a replication origin (oriV) is located within
repA and that, since RepA could not be produced by pAM88A* (i.e.,
because of the frameshift mutation), it responds to RepA supplied
in trans from pAM330 . Furthermore, the iterons are not part
of the pAD1 oriV, since they are not essential for replication .
| TABLE 2 . Transformation frequencies of several plasmids in different
E . faecalis strains
|
|
|
FIG . 2 . Analysis of the replication ability of an E . faecalis
suicide vector carrying appropriate fragments of pAD1 DNA . (A) Schematic
representation of the process envisioned for cointegrate formation by
homologous recombination between the two plasmids pAM330 and pAM88A*
carrying the pAD1 repA coding sequence . The related primers used
to generate PCR products demonstrating no recovery of the cointegrate
plasmid from the chloramphenicol-resistant E . faecalis
JH2-2/pAM330 transformants are indicated . The positions of the relevant
BamHI and EcoRI sites are also shown . The sizes of the PCR fragments
obtained are listed below . N.O., no PCR fragment observed in the assay .
(B) Agarose gel electrophoresis representing the BamHI (lanes 2 to 6)
and EcoRI (lanes 8 to 12) restriction fragments of the plasmid DNA
content of the chloramphenicol-resistant E . faecalis JH2-2/pAM330
transformants containing pAM88oriV plasmid (lanes 2 to 5 and lanes 8 to
11) or the E . coli DH5 /pAM88oriV
cells used as a positive control (lanes 6 and 12) . Plasmid DNA was
obtained in both cases from alkaline lysis preparations as described in
Materials and Methods . The molecular mass ladder 1-Kb-Plus (Invitrogen)
is shown in lanes 1 and 7, and selected bands or sizes are noted on the
left and right . (C) Southern blot analysis of the DNA restriction
profiles shown in panel B . The EcoRI restriction fragments of pAM88oriV
plasmid DNA were labeled and used as a probe . Black arrowheads indicate
the BamHI or EcoRI restriction fragments corresponding to pAM88oriV, and
band sizes are noted on the left (BamHI) and right (EcoRI) . The
asterisks indicate the corresponding pAM330 fragments carrying oriV
sequences . (D) The sizes of the restriction fragments that would have
been obtained from cointegration events are indicated.
|
|
The minimal size of oriV. To estimate the size of the
minimal cis-acting, replication-enabling region within repA,
we constructed and examined (as described above) several clones
containing different internal fragments of repA designated in
Fig . 1A as segments 3324, 3316, and 3318 . The
smallest replicating fragment was that of pAM88-3314, which
corresponded to a 504-bp segment (Table 2) . As seen in Fig .
1B, this fragment is the only one containing both DR-1
repeats inside repA, suggesting an involvement for these
repeats in replication .
Of likely relevance to the DR-1 sequences is an observation made
relating to the earlier-noted experiments involving E . faecalis
JH2-2/pAM330 cells transformed with pAM88A* . In the course of
examining these transformants we noticed that selected colonies fell
into two categories . Approximately 10% of the colonies were
"relatively large" while 90% were "small." Interestingly, when we
generated PCR products by using primers flanking repA (primer
sequences not located on pAM88A*; see Fig . 2A), we observed
that the small colonies gave rise to a product of the expected
size (1.5 kb), whereas the large colonies gave rise to a smaller
product (1.4 kb) . Sequence analysis of the 1.5-kb PCR fragment showed
a wild-type repA sequence; however, the 1.4-kb fragment
contained a 105-bp in-frame deletion within repA . The deletion
removed the region between the two large direct repeats (DR-1), as
indicated by the vertical arrows in Fig . 1B . The data indicate
that in the large colonies pAM330 had undergone a recombination
between the two 33-bp direct repeats (DR-1), leading to a deletion
that resulted in the loss of 35 amino acids from an internal portion
of RepA . The deletion (pAM330 9)
did not affect the ability to facilitate replication of pAM88A* .
Indeed, pAM88A* replication efficiency may be enhanced under the
circumstances since the cells appeared to grow better (i.e., larger
colonies) with the deletion . Furthermore, pAM88A* could transform
JH2-2/pAM330 9
cells at a frequency almost 2 orders of magnitude higher than
JH2-2/pAM330 cells (Table 2) . A widely used shuttle plasmid
pAM401 (55) was able to transform both strains equally
well, suggesting that the deletion in pAM330 9
decreased incompatibility with pAM88A*, although at this point an
elevated expression of the altered RepA also cannot be ruled out .
To determine whether the origin within repA on pAM88A* contributes
to incompatibility against pAD1, the ability of a cloned origin
fragment to displace a resident pAD1 replicon was tested . For this
purpose we used pDAK246 E
(53) as the resident plasmid and pAM3314 (3)
as the pAD1 oriV-containing plasmid . pDAK246 E
is a pAD1 minireplicon (Table 1) encoding
erythromycin resistance and deleted for the par-encoded
postsegregational killing system (located downstream of repC) .
pAM3314 is a pAM401 clone containing an internal portion (the 3314
segment; Fig . 1A) of repA including the
entire putative oriV . (The E . coli-E . faecalis shuttle vector
pAM401 replicates independently of pAD1.) Under selection for
the pAM3314-encoded chloramphenicol resistance, pDAK246 E
was consistently lost from
80%
of cells within 40 generations . In the presence of the empty vector
(pAM401), no loss of pDAK246 E
was observed (the two plasmids are compatible); this is consistent
with the view that oriV acts as an incompatibility determinant .
A reasonable interpretation of the above data is that oriV is
located, at least in part, in the region between the 33-bp direct
repeats (DR-1) in repA and that deletion of this segment
eliminated, or greatly reduced, competition between the two plasmids .
To further explore this notion, we cloned into pAM88 a 173-bp
restriction fragment (MfeI/RsaI) from within repA that
contained both repeats (Fig . 1) and introduced it
into JH2-2/pAM330; replication was assayed as described above . The
chimera (pAM88oriV) was able to transform (selection on
chloramphenicol) at a frequency of
10–7
(Table 2) . (pAM88oriV DNA was not maintained in JH2-2
cells that did not harbor pAM330.) Plasmid isolation from several
independently obtained transformants, restriction analyses, and
Southern hybridizations (Fig . 2B and C) confirmed the presence
of the intact plasmid (pAM88oriV) in JH2-2/pAM330 . The data
indicate that the cloned 173-bp DNA fragment present in pAM88oriV
approximates the minimal segment required in cis to support
pAD1 replication .
RepA is the only pAD1-encoded protein necessary for plasmid
replication. We have shown above that pAM330 supplies a "replication
factor" able to facilitate in trans the establishment of a
chimera carrying the oriV sequence (i.e., the RsaI/MfeI
segment) . To test the hypothesis that this factor was RepA, we
attempted to clone an intact repA gene under a gram-positive
bacteriocin promoter (27) in the E . coli
vector pAM434b to determine whether autonomous replication occurred
in E . faecalis (see Materials and Methods and Table
1) . We were not able to clone the repA fragment without
generating various mutations in repA; conceivably, expression
of repA under these conditions was detrimental to E . coli .
However, when we used a vector in which the promoter was altered via
mutation in the –10 box (TATAAT changed to CATAAT), we
recovered a clone with an intact repA . Assuming that the promoter
still functions but is probably less active, we attempted to
introduce this derivative, designated pAM434brepA, into E . faecalis
JH2-2 cells . Erythromycin-resistant transformants were generated
at a frequency of 5.1 x 10–5
(Table 2) and, as shown in Fig . 3,
they contained the plasmid . A similarly generated chimera containing
the repA 9
coding sequence (repA gene derived from pAM330 9)
was constructed with the same altered –10 box, but this chimera,
called pAM434brepA 9,
was not able to transform E . faecalis cells (Table
2) . The data indicate that repA alone
comprises the pAD1 minimal replicon and the repA product recognizes
an oriV located within its own reading frame . The inability
of the repA 9
DNA to facilitate replication, despite the apparent ability of RepA 9
to recognize an intact oriV (described in the previous
section) is again consistent with oriV being located between
the two DR-1 repeats in repA . For comparison, transformation
values associated with the entire repABC region of pAD1 are
also included in Table 2 . pAM88ABC (carries the wild-type
repABC region) transforms JH2-2 cells, as well as pAM434brepA;
however, if a similarly generated clone contains the deletion (pAM88A 9BC),
the transformation frequency is 2 orders of magnitude lower .
This is consistent with the iteron repeats not being a component of
the replication origin, since they are present in both plasmids .
However, the low level of transformants that does appear with pAM88A 9BC
may in some way relate to marginal replication enabled by stability
functions provided by RepB, RepC, and perhaps the iterons .
|
FIG . 3 . Analysis of the pAD1 minimal replicon . (A) Schematic diagram
showing the construction of pAM434brepA and unique restriction sites are
indicated (21); (B) agarose gel electrophoresis
representing the BamHI/NsiI (lanes 2 and 3) restriction fragments (black
arrowheads) of the DNA plasmid content (pAM434brepA) of two
independently obtained erythromycin-resistant E . faecalis JH2-2
transformants . The molecular mass ladder 1-Kb-Plus (Invitrogen) is shown
in lane 1 . Representative sizes are indicated on the left and right . *,
Per Flannagan and Clewell (21).
|
|
We were able to detect pAM434brepA DNA from enterococcal transformants
as a supercoiled structure and could not detect ssDNA by Southern
blot hybridization (not shown), a finding consistent with replication
occurring via a theta mechanism (i.e., not a rolling-circle
mechanism), as otherwise suggested based on the similarity of repA
with replication gene determinants on certain other theta-replicating
plasmids (48) . pAM434brepA appears at a relatively high copy
number (at least 20 to 30 copies per chromosome) based on the
amount of DNA detectable in gels compared to the high-copy-number
pAM401 (observed in extracts prepared in parallel from similar
numbers of cells [results not shown]) . This is not surprising since
the regulatory machinery normally involved in initiation of the
low-copy pAD1 is not present, and RepA is being expressed from an
artificial promoter .
The relative stability of pAM434brepA, its small size ( 4.65
kb), and its multiple cloning site (see Fig . 3) make it
a good candidate for an E . coli-Enterococcus shuttle plasmid .
It appeared at least as stable, if not more stable, than the pAM401 ( 10.4-kb)
shuttle plasmid . After unselected growth in THB for 30 generations,
the percentage of pAM434brepA-containing cells was 40% compared
to 15% for pAM401-containing cells .
RepA binds to its own coding sequence. If RepA is the
replication initiator, it should bind to the oriV within
repA . To investigate such behavior, we purified RepA by using an
E . coli system that expressed His tag or Strep tag fusions to
RepA as described in Materials and Methods . In initial experiments
using a previously reported DNA-protein tag affinity chromatography
technique (26), we observed that purified
Strep-tagged RepA bound specifically to a 0.9-kb DraI restriction
fragment generated by cleavage of pAM2603 (which contains 7.9 kb of
pAD1 that includes repA cloned in pBluescript [1;
data not shown]) . As anticipated, this DraI fragment included the
region within repA believed to contain oriV (Fig . 1) .
Since the
170-bp
MfeI/RsaI DNA fragment within repA (Fig . 1A
and 2B) was sufficient in cis to allow replication in
vivo, we used this segment (designated oriV) in mobility shift
assays to examine RepA binding . Comparisons were also made by using
segments of DNA containing the set of 12 iterons located adjacent
to repB, designated It3' (see Fig . 1A) . As shown
in Fig . 4A, purified His-tagged RepA was able to
form complexes with the oriV-containing DNA fragment (lane 2)
but did not show similar complexes in the case of the iteron It3' DNA
(lanes 12 to 16) or unrelated DNA fragments, such as a 200-bp
fragment containing the polylinker of pBlueScript (not shown) . A
protein preparation generated in the same way as for His-tagged RepA
but with E . coli BL21 cells containing an empty expression
vector (pET30a) showed no binding activity (not shown), implying that
the RepA protein specifically binds to oriV DNA . Confirmation
was obtained with competition experiments . As shown in Fig.
4A, the unlabeled oriV DNA fragment greatly
reduced RepA interaction with the labeled oriV DNA (lanes 3 to 6),
whereas cold It3' DNA did not compete (lanes 7 to 10), indicating
sequence specificity in the binding of RepA . Experiments shown in
Fig . 4B suggested this specificity was associated
with the N-terminal domain of RepA (RepA5'; see Fig . 1A) .
Purified His-tagged RepA5' was able to retard the mobility of the
oriV-containing DNA fragment (lane 2) but did not retard an
iteron-containing fragment (It5'; lane 5) . In contrast to the case
observed with the intact ("wild-type") His-tagged RepA, the
DNA-protein complexes remained in the well . Although the nature of
these aggregates is currently unknown, the fact that a similar
binding did not occur with the iteron-containing fragment (lane 5) or
a purified C-terminal (His-tagged RepA3'; lane 3) preparation
suggests that this interaction is specific .
|
FIG . 4 . Gel mobility shift assays showing in vitro RepA-DNA-binding
properties . PCR or end-labeled dsDNA or ssDNA fragments containing the
oriV or iteron repeats were incubated with 0.5 µg of purified
RepA, purified RepB, or empty vector (pASK60)-derived control protein
extracts in the absence or presence of increasing concentrations of
unlabeled competitor DNA fragments . (A) Mobility shift assays showing
RepA-specific binding to dsDNA . The substrate DNA used was as follows:
lanes 1 to 10, dsDNA corresponding to the repA MfeI/RsaI internal
sequence (oriV); lanes 11 to 16, dsDNA corresponding to the
iteron repeats upstream of the repB coding sequence (It3') .
Purified protein added in each lane is indicated at the top of the
figure . The addition of a 1-, 10-, 50-, or 100-fold excess of unlabeled
dsDNA fragments (competitor DNA) is also indicated at the top of the
figure . (B) Mobility shift assays showing RepA N-terminal domain
specific binding to dsDNA . Lanes 1 to 3, dsDNA corresponding to oriV
(MfeI/RsaI repA internal fragment); lanes 4 and 5, dsDNA
corresponding to the iteron repeats upstream of the repA coding sequence
(It5' PCR product) . Purified protein domains (N and C terminal) added in
each lane are indicated at the top of the figure . (C) Mobility shift
assays showing RepA nonspecific binding to ssDNA . Lanes 1 to 4 represent
It3' PCR product containing both dsDNA and ssDNA forms . In contrast to
panels A and B, the DNA used in panel C had not been exposed to S1
nuclease . Lanes 5 to 8 represent oriV PCR product containing both
dsDNA and ssDNA forms . Purified protein fractions in each lane are also
indicated at the top of the figure . Free DNA forms and RepA-DNA
complexes are indicated.
|
|
Although RepA was observed to bind to oriV dsDNA, it also bound
to ssDNA, but without any sequence specificity . Figure 4C
shows RepA binding to both single-stranded oriV DNA (lane 7)
and single-stranded It3' DNA (lane 3) . In contrast to the case shown
in Fig . 4A and B, the DNA preparations of Fig.
4C were not previously treated with S1 nuclease and
thus had a significant amount of ssDNA in the PCR preparations . We
also observed that ssDNA of the vector pBluescript and even
eukaryotic (human) DNA bound equally well to RepA (not shown),
confirming the absence of sequence specificity . The fact that no
binding to ssDNA was observed for other protein preparations,
including the pAD1-encoded RepB (lanes 4 and 8) or a similar protein
preparation derived from E . coli cells containing the empty
vector pASK60 (lanes 2 and 6), indicates RepA presence in the
protein-DNA complexes . (In addition to not binding to ssDNA, RepB was
also not observed to bind to double-stranded DNA (dsDNA)
corresponding to It3' or oriV [not shown].) RepA was able to
bind to ssDNA containing oriV sequence with relatively higher
affinity compared to the binding to dsDNA, because when both DNA
forms were present, RepA showed a preference for the ssDNA (lane 7) .
(Interestingly, RepA appears to have some preference for one of the
two single strands; see lanes 3 and 7.)
IR-1 sequences in oriV are critical for replication.
The mobility shift assays suggested the formation of at least five
RepA/oriV complexes . Inspection of the oriV region reveals
the octanucleotide sequence AGGGTATG, noted as IR-1 in Fig .
5A, present as five copies (two with one mismatch) . Four of
these represent two paired inverted repeat sequences . To determine
whether this sequence was involved in RepA binding, two synthetic
DNA fragments were prepared as described in Materials and Methods .
The first one contains the sequence AATCAAGAGGGTATGAAAATCATACCCTGCCAAAA
and corresponds to the region that includes the two central
IR-1 repeats (representing sequences 3 and 4 in Fig . 5A); it
was cloned in pTAd yielding pTAdIR1 . A 155-bp XbaI/HindIII fragment
containing the sequence of note was then used in mobility shift
experiments . A second chimera, pTAdIR1*, containing the same sequence
but with four altered positions in each one of the IR-1 repeats
(IR1*),AATCAAGAGCCTTTCAAAATGAAAGGCTGCCAAAA,was
also generated in the same way and was designed to conserve
both the dyad structure and the G+C percentage . As shown in Fig.
5B, RepA bound to the segment carrying the wild-type (IR1)
sequence but did not bind to the DNA carrying the mutated (IR1*)
sequence . An additional control DNA representing three iteron
sequences cloned in the same way, giving rise to pTAdItC, also did
not bind RepA . The data suggest that the IR1 sequence is part of the
oriV site to which RepA binds . However, we observed that an
excess of unlabeled IR1 DNA did not compete with RepA binding to the
larger oriV fragment containing all five IR1 sequences nor did
IR1* (Fig . 5C) . This suggests that cooperativity or
conformation dictated by the presence of more than two IR-1 sequences
may play an important role in RepA binding to oriV .
|
FIG . 5 . Gel mobility shift assays showing the importance of the IR-1
repeats in the putative RepA recognition site . (A) Nucleotide sequence
of the repA MfeI/RsaI segment containing the oriV site .
IR-1 repeats are indicated by the arrows above the sequence and are
numbered 1 through 5 (correlating with specific mutations generated) .
(B) Gel mobility shift assays with end-labeled dsDNA fragments
containing the IR-1 (wild type) (lanes 1 and 2), IR-1* (four point
mutations) (lanes 3 and 4), or iteron (ItC) (lanes 5 and 6) repeats .
Lanes 1, 3, and 5 represent control dsDNA fragments . Lanes 2, 4, and 6
represent dsDNA plus purified RepA protein . (C) Competition of RepA
binding to the MfeI/RsaI oriV dsDNA fragment with increasing
concentrations (same as Fig . 4) of unlabeled IR-1
(lanes 3 to 6) or IR-1* (lanes 7 to 10) dsDNA fragments . Lane 1, control
oriV DNA; lane 2, RepA control binding reaction to oriV
dsDNA; lanes 3 to 10, competition reactions as indicated at the top of
the figure.
|
|
To further examine the role of IR-1 sequences, we introduced the
above modifications (mutations) of IR-1 into plasmid pAM88A* (see
Materials and Methods) and generated derivatives with alterations in
the first pair (sequences 1 and 2 in Fig . 5A) of IR-1
sequences (pAM88*-IR1+2), the second pair (pAM88A*-IR3+4), the first
and second pair (pAM88A*-IR1+2+3+4), and finally with modifications
in all five IR-1 sequences (pAM88A*-5xIR) . These derivatives
were introduced into E . faecalis JH2-2/pAM330 9
by electroporation with pAM88A* and pAM401 serving as positive
controls . (In contrast to the strain harboring pAM330, this strain
was shown above to be much more efficiently transformable by
pAM88A*.) The transformation frequencies are shown in Table
3 . PCR experiments were done to confirm the
presence of autonomously replicating plasmids as per the experiments
shown in Fig . 2 . Only pAM88A*-IR1+2 and
pAM88A*-IR3+4 could be observed as independent plasmids; whereas,
transformants deriving from pAM88A*-IR1+2+3+4 and pAM88*-5xIR were
the results of cointegration of pAM330 9
and the pAM88A* derivative . The much higher transformation frequency
exhibited by pAM88A*-IR3+4 (similar to that of the wild-type pAM88A*)
compared to pAM88A*-IR1+2 (reduced by 2 orders of magnitude)
suggests a more important cis-acting role in replication for
the repeats related to the latter derivative . However, substitution
of both pairs of IR-1 sequences resulted in complete loss of ability
to replicate autonomously . The data are consistent with the in vitro
binding studies and show a dependence on IR-1 sequences in cis
for replication .
TABLE 3 . Transformation frequencies of E . faecalis JH2-2/pAM330 9
by IR-1 mutant plasmids
|
|
The data presented here demonstrate that the RepA protein of pAD1 is
necessary and sufficient for initiation of plasmid DNA replication at
an oriV located within its own coding sequence . The oriV
region was narrowed down to ca . 170 bp, based on its ability to
support replication when RepA was supplied in trans . This
segment contains both direct (DR-1 and DR-2) and inverted (IR-1)
repeat sequences, and a pair of IR-1 repeats was shown to be
essential in cis for oriV function . A segment of DNA containing
an intact repA only, and expressing a functional RepA under
an artificial promoter, enabled autonomous replication in E .
faecalis . The plasmid construct (pAM434brepA) was quite stable;
and because of its small size and the presence of a useful polylinker
site, it may prove to be a useful E . coli-E . faecalis shuttle
plasmid .
Of additional significance was our observation that a spontaneous
recombinational event between the two 33-bp DR-1 repeats within
repA resulted in an in-frame deletion giving rise to a protein
(RepA 9)
that, despite the absence of 35 centrally located amino acids,
remained able to facilitate (in trans) replication of DNA
(plasmid suicide vector) containing an intact oriV . The
sequence deleted in repA 9
contained a significant portion of the oriV sequence; thus, it
was not surprising to find that, in contrast to the above-noted
pAM434brepA that was able to replicate stably in E . faecalis,
a variant containing the repA 9
sequence (pAM434brepA 9)
was not able to generate transformants . When the same deletion (repA 9)
was present, together with repB, repC, and the iterons
(i.e., in the case of pAM88A 9BC),
however, some degree of replication occurred, presumably owing to
stabilizing effects conferred by RepB, RepC, and possibly the
iterons, on a remaining portion of oriV . (An analysis of the
RepB and RepC roles will be reported elsewhere.)
Our earlier analyses of the pAD1 replicon suggested that RepA was
likely to bind to the extensive iterons upstream of the repA
coding sequence (32, 52) . However, the
data of the current study show that RepA targets DNA outside of the
iterons . Our in vitro studies showed that RepA (but not a protein
[RepB] suspected of functioning in stable inheritance [52])
bound at multiple sites within oriV (inside the repA
coding sequence) and indirectly suggested recognition of the five
IR-1 sequences . Indeed, an artificially constructed fragment
containing one pair of IR-1 sequences bound to RepA, whereas a
similar segment containing alterations in the IR-1 did not bind .
Subsequent genetic analyses with plasmid constructs with altered IR-1
pairs supported the notion that these sequences play an important
cis-acting role in plasmid replication . The likelihood that
some degree of cooperativity is involved in RepA binding was
apparent from the inability of a DNA fragment containing two copies
(inverted) of IR-1 to compete with the
170-bp
oriV fragment which contained five copies of the repeat . The
data would also be consistent with a preferential role for one of the
IR-1 pairs, as was indeed suggested from the genetic analyses .
Another explanation, also consistent with the in vivo data, could
relate to recognition of a specific DNA structure in addition to the
IR-1 sequences . We note that numerous attempts at DNase I
footprinting experiments under different conditions (unpublished)
were not able to identify a region occupied by RepA . Certain
DNA-binding proteins that bind within the minor groove of B-type DNA
are known to yield poor footprinting data (18);
indeed, several replication initiator proteins have been shown to
contact DNA via the minor groove (29,
57) . Whether RepA is such a protein is not currently known .
Our in vitro DNA retardation data showing binding to repeat
sequences within repA is to our knowledge the first such evidence
for this family of initiator proteins .
The initiation of replication has been widely studied in gram-negative
bacteria, in which plasmids utilizing a theta mechanism frequently
carry a series of iterons to which the initiator binds (14,
17, 33) . A well-known exception is
the R1 plasmid, in which the initiator binds to inverted repeat
sequences (30) . This is also the case for
coliphage lambda (15) . Interestingly, in the case
of lambda phage, as well as several bacteriophages from gram-positive
bacteria, oriV sequences are located within the coding
sequence of their respective initiator proteins (44,
45, 57) . These initiation proteins,
however, are not related to those addressed in the present study,
despite the fact that certain RepA homologues are associated with
bacteriophages . In addition, certain linear plasmids from
Streptomyces species have been shown to contain origins within a
rep determinant (7) .
Initiator proteins of a wide variety of plasmids create a localized
melting in an AT-rich region close to their DNA-binding site in
the origin (14, 17) . It is noteworthy that
in the case of pAD1 one of the IR-1 sequences within oriV
believed to bind RepA actually overlaps a highly GC-rich sequence
(CCCACCCCCC) that only appears once in the entire plasmid and
resembles a transfer origin "nick site" of IncF-like plasmids (gram
negative) (3) . Interestingly, this site is
immediately adjacent to a highly AT-rich sequence (AAAGAAAAACAAA),
but whether or not this junction of high and low GC content plays a
key role in initiation remains to be determined . In addition to
binding specifically and facilitating melting within the replication
origin, the ability of RepA to strongly bind nonspecifically to ssDNA
suggests a possible role in stabilizing a "melted" conformation
important in assembly of the replisome . Such a process has been
proposed with respect to the E . faecalis plasmid pAMß1
initiator protein RepE, which has also been shown to bind to ssDNA (43) .
RepA of pAD1 is member of a recently described family of replication
proteins initially found encoded by the B . natto plasmid pLS32
(48) . Generally associated with a theta-type
replication mechanism, these "Rep proteins" are encoded by plasmids
in gram-positive genera, including Enterococcus,
Lactococcus, Lactobacillus, Bacillus, and
Staphylococcus and are also associated with the genomes of a
number of bacteriophages from Streptococcus spp . (5,
19, 28, 41,
48) . Only one sequence in the family relates to a
gram-negative bacterium (Fusobacterium nucleatum [EAA24086]) .
Another member of this family, interferon response binding factor 1
(IREBF-1), appears to have a nonbacterial origin (56);
however, Berg et al . (5) have suggested that
IREBF-1 may actually represent a contaminant of bacterial origin that
was present in the mouse cDNA library .
RepA (pAD1) consists of 336 amino acids, and most members of the
related family are similar in size . There are no recognizable motifs
such as those representative of ATPase, helicase, or specific
HTH-binding domains . There is strong conservation of a number of
residues in the N-terminal region, and five amino acids—Y41, D58,
L90, L95, and Y116—are absolutely conserved in all of 38 RepA
homologues compared (see Fig . 6) . These conserved
amino acids may relate to a key function and/or represent parts of an
active center . (It is worth noting that the spontaneous mutations
generated when we attempted to clone repA under the wild-type
bacteriocin promoter involved this 5' region [data not shown].) It
has been suggested (56) that this region contains
the DNA-binding domain, and binding experiments carried out with the
N-terminal domain of RepA were in agreement with this notion . The
central region of the RepA homologues shows a conserved presence and
organization of repeats, whereas the corresponding amino acid
sequences are highly variable (Fig . 6) . This is
true even among the E . faecalis pheromone-responding plasmids .
In the C-terminal part of the RepA family proteins, at least three
subgroups are distinguishable, with a number of amino acids uniquely
conserved in each group (Fig . 6) . These subgroups (Enterococcus,
Staphylococcus, and Lactococcus or Lactobacillus)
conceivably reflect the different hosts in which the plasmids were
originally isolated and may relate to specific functions shared by
closely related bacterial species . Although direct evidence for this
is not yet available, comparison of the amino acid sequences of
different initiator proteins is suggestive of such a possibility . For
example, the corresponding Rep proteins from the E . faecalis
plasmids pAD1 (A47092) and pCF10 (A53309) exhibit 43% identity in the
N-terminal region and 80% in the C-terminal region; whereas, in
contrast, a "RepA" protein from E . faecium (ZP_00037682)
exhibited 72% identity to that of pAD1 in the N terminus but only 30%
identity in the C terminus . Importantly, the greater identity
observed in the N-terminal domains of the latter two proteins also
correlated with a high conservation in DNA sequence of the direct
repeats in the central (oriV) region, which are 92% identical
(only 17 differences over 155 bp, and 16 of the 17 differences are
outside the DR-1 and IR-1 repeats), pointing again to a DNA-binding
function for the N-terminal domain . One might expect that highly
conserved DNA-binding domains would share an affinity for DNA
sites that are highly homologous; indeed, one can easily envision
these two features evolving together . It has been suggested
previously (28, 48) for several plasmids
(e.g., pLS32 and pSX267), albeit without direct evidence, that the
centrally located repeats corresponds to part of the replication
origin . Our in vitro and in vivo data, however, represent strong
evidence that this is indeed the case for pAD1 and probably the
related E . faecium system noted above .
|
FIG . 6 . Map of RepA indicating strongly conserved amino acids among the
related family of replication proteins . Identical and similar amino
acids conserved in the N-terminal region of all proteins (38 proteins in
the database compared) are noted in capital letters . (Similar residues
are according to conservative substitutions [V/I/L, T/S, D/E, N/Q, Y/F,
and R/K].) Positions of putative motifs reflecting conserved residues
are noted by the hashed boxes below the N terminus . Amino acid residues
that are strongly conserved among RepA homologues of Enterococcus,
Staphylococcus, and Lactococcus spp . are indicated by
lowercase letters above the C-terminal region . The "u" denotes
hydrophobic amino acids in the noted position . The repeats present in
the central region are noted in gray . The white box under the N terminus
indicates the fragment shown to have specific DNA-binding properties.
|
|
Finally, related to the physical association of sequences involved in
replication (oriV) and conjugation (oriT1), it is noteworthy
that the DNA fragment marked as 3316 in Fig . 1A provides
an origin of transfer (3) when cloned in pAM401
(pAM3316), whereas it did not provide a functional replication origin
when cloned in pAM88 (pAM88-3316) . Although it is conceivable that
there still may be some overlap between the two sites, and therefore
possibly some common machinery utilized in the initiation of
replication at oriV and conjugation involving oriT1, related
processes or their regulation remain the subject of future studies .
This study was supported by National Institutes of Health grants
GM33956 to D.B.C . and GM55544 to K.E.W . and grant FIS 02/3029 from
the Spanish Fondo de Investigación Sanitaria to M.V.F . M.V.F . was
also supported in part by grant from NATO .
We thank all members of our laboratories for helpful discussions .
* Corresponding author . Mailing address: Biologic and Materials
Sciences, School of Dentistry, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109-1078 .
Phone: (734) 763-0117 . Fax: (734) 763-9905 . E-mail: dclewell@umich.edu .
Present address: Department of Microbiology, Gunma University School
of Medicine, Maebashi, Gunma, Japan .
- An, F . Y., and D . B . Clewell. 1994 . Characterization of
the determinant (traB) encoding sex pheromone shutdown by the
hemolysin/bacteriocin plasmid pAD1 in Enterococcus faecalis . Plasmid
31:215-221.
- An, F . Y., and D . B . Clewell. 2002 . Identification of the
cAD1 sex pheromone precursor in Enterococcus faecalis . J . Bacteriol .
184:1880-1887 .
- An, F . Y., and D . B . Clewell. 1997 . The origin of
transfer (oriT) of the enterococcal, pheromone-responding, cytolysin
plasmid pAD1 is located within the repA determinant . Plasmid 37:87-94.
- Bartolome, B., Y . Jubete, E . Martinez, and F . de la Cruz.
1991 . Construction and properties of a family of pACYC184-derived cloning
vectors compatible with pBR322 and its derivatives . Gene 102:75-78.
- Berg, T., N . Firth, S . Apisiridej, A . Hettiaratchi, A .
Leelaporn, and R . A . Skurray. 1998 . Complete nucleotide sequence of pSK41:
evolution of staphylococcal conjugative multiresistance plasmids . J .
Bacteriol . 180:4350-4359 .
- Boyle, J . S., and A . M . Lew. 1995 . An inexpensive
alternative to glassmilk for DNA purification . Trends Genet . 11:8.
- Chang, P . C., E . S . Kim, and S . N . Cohen. 1996 .
Streptomyces linear plasmids that contain a phage-like, centrally located,
replication origin . Mol . Microbiol . 22:789-800.
- Chow, J . W., L . A . Thal, M . B . Perri, J . A . Vazquez, S . M .
Donabedian, D . B . Clewell, and M . J . Zervos. 1993 . Plasmid-associated
hemolysin and aggregation substance production contribute to virulence in
experimental enterococcal endocarditis . Antimicrob . Agents Chemother . 37:2474-2477.
- Clewell, D . B. 1999 . Sex pheromone systems in
enterococci, p . 47-65 . In G . M . Dunny and S . C . Winans (ed.), Cell-cell
signaling in bacteria . ASM Press, Washington, D.C.
- Clewell, D . B., and G . M . Dunny. 2002 . Conjugation and
genetic exchange in enterococci, p . 265-300 . In S . Gilmore (ed.), The
enterococci: pathogenesis, molecular biology, and antibiotic resistance . ASM
Press, Washington, D.C.
- Clewell, D . B., M . V . Francia, S . E . Flannagan, and F . Y .
An. 2002 . Enterococcal plasmid transfer: sex pheromones, transfer origins,
relaxases, and the Staphylococcus aureus issue . Plasmid 48:265-300.
- Clewell, D . B., P . K . Tomich, M . C . Gawron-Burke, A . E .
Franke, Y . Yagi, and F . Y . An. 1982 . Mapping of Streptococcus faecalis
plasmids pAD1 and pAD2 and studies relating to transposition of Tn917 .
J . Bacteriol . 152:1220-1230.
- Colmar, I., and T . Horaud. 1987 . Enterococcus
faecalis hemolysin-bacteriocin plasmids belong to the same incompatibility
group . Appl . Environ . Microbiol . 53:567-570.
- del Solar, G., R . Giraldo, M . J . Ruiz-Echevarria, M .
Espinosa, and R . Diaz-Orejas. 1998 . Replication and control of circular
bacterial plasmids . Microbiol . Mol . Biol . Rev . 62:434-464 .
- Dodson, M., J . Roberts, R . McMacken, and H . Echols.
1985 . Specialized nucleoprotein structures at the origin of replication of
bacteriophage lambda: complexes with lambda O protein and with lambda O,
lambda P, and Escherichia coli DnaB proteins . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci .
USA 82:4678-4682.
- Dower, W . J., J . F . Miller, and C . W . Ragsdale. 1988 .
High efficiency transformation of Escherichia coli by high-voltage
electroporation . Nucleic Acids Res . 16:6127-6145.
- Espinosa, M., S . Cohen, M . Couturier, G . del Solar, R .
Diaz-Orejas, R . Giraldo, L . Jánniere, C . Miller, M . Osborn, and C . M . Thomas.
2000 . Plasmid replication and copy number control, p . 1-47 . In C . M .
Thomas (ed.), The horizontal gene pool: bacterial plasmids and gene spread .
Harwood Academic Publishers, London, England.
- Feng, L., B . Wang, B . Driscoll, and A . Jong. 2000 .
Identification and characterization of Saccharomyces cerevisiae Cdc6
DNA-binding properties . Mol . Biol . Cell 11:1673-1685 .
- Firth, N., S . Apisiridej, T . Berg, B . A . O'Rourke, S .
Curnock, K . G . Dyke, and R . A . Skurray. 2000 . Replication of
staphylococcal multiresistance plasmids . J . Bacteriol . 182:2170-2178 .
- Flannagan, S . E., and D . B . Clewell. 1991 . Conjugative
transfer of Tn916 in Enterococcus faecalis: transactivation of
homologous transposons . J . Bacteriol . 173:7136-7141.
- Flannagan, S . E., and D . B . Clewell. 2002 .
Identification and characterization of genes encoding sex pheromone cAM373
activity in Enterococcus faecalis and Staphylococcus aureus .
Mol . Microbiol . 44:803-817.
- Francia, M . V., and D . B . Clewell. 2002 . Transfer
origins in the conjugative Enterococcus faecalis plasmids pAD1 and
pAM373: identification of the pAD1 nic site, a specific relaxase and a
possible TraG-like protein . Mol . Microbiol . 45:375-395.
- Francia, M . V., W . Haas, R . Wirth, E . Samberger, A .
Muscholl-Silberhorn, M . S . Gilmore, Y . Ike, K . E . Weaver, F . Y . An, and D . B .
Clewell. 2001 . Completion of the nucleotide sequence of the
Enterococcus faecalis conjugative virulence plasmid pAD1 and
identification of a second transfer origin . Plasmid 46:117-127.
- Francia, M . V., J . C . Zabala, F . de la Cruz, and J . M .
Garcia Lobo. 1999 . The IntI1 integron integrase preferentially binds
single-stranded DNA of the attC site . J . Bacteriol . 181:6844-6849 .
- Franke, A . E., and D . B . Clewell. 1981 . Evidence for
conjugal transfer of a Streptococcus faecalis transposon (Tn916)
from a chromosomal site in the absence of plasmid DNA . Cold Spring Harbor
Symp . Quant . Biol . 45(Pt . 1):77-80.
- Fujimoto, S., and D . B . Clewell. 1998 . Regulation of the
pAD1 sex pheromone response of Enterococcus faecalis by direct
interaction between the cAD1 peptide mating signal and the negatively
regulating, DNA-binding TraA protein . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 95:6430-6435 .
- Fujimoto, S., and Y . Ike. 2001 . pAM401-based shuttle
vectors that enable overexpression of promoterless genes and one-step
purification of tag fusion proteins directly from Enterococcus faecalis .
Appl . Environ . Microbiol . 67:1262-1267 .
- Gering, M., F . Gotz, and R . Bruckner. 1996 . Sequence and
analysis of the replication region of the Staphylococcus xylosus
plasmid pSX267 . Gene 182:117-122.
- Giraldo, R., J . M . Andreu, and R . Diaz-Orejas. 1998 .
Protein domains and conformational changes in the activation of RepA, a DNA
replication initiator . EMBO J . 17:4511-4526 .
- Giraldo, R., and R . Diaz. 1992 . Differential binding of
wild-type and a mutant RepA protein to oriR sequence suggests a model
for the initiation of plasmid R1 replication . J . Mol . Biol . 228:787-802.
- Hanahan, D. 1983 . Studies on transformation of
Escherichia coli with plasmids . J . Mol . Biol . 166:557-580.
- Heath, D . G., F . Y . An, K . E . Weaver, and D . B . Clewell.
1995 . Phase variation of Enterococcus faecalis pAD1 conjugation
functions relates to changes in iteron sequence region . J . Bacteriol . 177:5453-5459.
- Helinski, D . R., A . E . Toukdarian, and R . P . Novick.
1996 . Replication control and other stable maintenance mechanisms of plasmids,
p . 2295-2324 . In F . C . Neidhardt, R . Curtiss III, J . L . Ingraham, E . C .
C . Lin, K . B . Low, B . Magasanik, W . S . Reznikoff, M . Riley, M . Schaechter, and
H . E . Umbarger (ed.), Escherichia coli and Salmonella: cellular
and molecular biology, 2nd ed . ASM Press, Washington, D.C.
- Ike, Y., and D . B . Clewell. 1992 . Evidence that the
hemolysin/bacteriocin phenotype of Enterococcus faecalis subsp .
zymogenes can be determined by plasmids in different incompatibility
groups as well as by the chromosome . J . Bacteriol . 174:8172-8177.
- Ike, Y., and D . B . Clewell. 1984 . Genetic analysis of
the pAD1 pheromone response in Streptococcus faecalis, using transposon
Tn917 as an insertional mutagen . J . Bacteriol . 158:777-783.
- Ike, Y., R . A . Craig, B . A . White, Y . Yagi, and D . B .
Clewell. 1983 . Modification of Streptococcus faecalis sex
pheromones after acquisition of plasmid DNA . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 80:5369-5373.
- Ike, Y., H . Hashimoto, and D . B . Clewell. 1984 .
Hemolysin of Streptococcus faecalis subspecies zymogenes
contributes to virulence in mice . Infect . Immun . 45:528-530.
- Ike, Y., H . Hashimoto, and D . B . Clewell. 1987 . High
incidence of hemolysin production by Enterococcus (Streptococcus)
faecalis strains associated with human parenteral infections . J . Clin .
Microbiol . 25:1524-1528.
- Jacob, A . E., and S . J . Hobbs. 1974 . Conjugal transfer
of plasmid-borne multiple antibiotic resistance in Streptococcus faecalis
var . zymogenes . J . Bacteriol . 117:360-372.
- Jett, B . D., H . G . Jensen, R . E . Nordquist, and M . S .
Gilmore. 1992 . Contribution of the pAD1-encoded cytolysin to the severity
of experimental Enterococcus faecalis endophthalmitis . Infect . Immun.
60:2445-2452.
- Kearney, K., G . F . Fitzgerald, and J . F . Seegers. 2000 .
Identification and characterization of an active plasmid partition mechanism
for the novel Lactococcus lactis plasmid pCI2000 . J . Bacteriol . 182:30-37 .
- Laemmli, U . K. 1970 . Cleavage of structural proteins
during the assembly of the head of bacteriophage T4 . Nature 227:680-685.
- Le Chatelier, E., L . Janniere, S . D . Ehrlich, and D .
Canceill. 2001 . The RepE initiator is a double-stranded and
single-stranded DNA-binding protein that forms an atypical open complex at the
onset of replication of plasmid pAMß1 from gram-positive bacteria . J . Biol .
Chem . 276:10234-10246 .
- Missich, R., F . Weise, S . Chai, R . Lurz, X . Pedre, and J . C .
Alonso. 1997
|