|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, August 2004, p . 5267-5280, Vol . 186,
No . 16
Identification of sarV (SA2062), a New Transcriptional Regulator, Is
Repressed by SarA and MgrA (SA0641) and Involved in the Regulation of Autolysis
in Staphylococcus aureus
Adhar C . Manna,1* Susham S . Ingavale,1
MaryBeth Maloney,1 Willem van Wamel,2 and Ambrose L .
Cheung1
Department of Microbiology, Dartmouth Medical School, Hanover, New Hampshire
03755,1 Department of Medical Microbiology, University of Utrecht,
Utrecht, The Netherlands2
Received 24 March 2004/ Accepted 18 May 2004
The expression of genes involved in the pathogenesis of Staphylococcus
aureus is known to be controlled by global regulatory loci,
including agr, sarA, sae, arlRS, lytSR, and
sarA-like genes . Here we described a novel transcriptional
regulator called sarV of the SarA protein family . The
transcription of sarV is low or undetectable under in vitro
conditions but is significantly augmented in sarA and mgrA
(norR or rat) (SA0641) mutants . The sarA and
mgrA genes act as repressors of sarV expression, as
confirmed by transcriptional fusion and Northern analysis data .
Purified SarA and MgrA proteins bound specifically to separate
regions of the sarV promoter as determined by gel shift and
DNase I footprinting assays . The expression of 19 potential target
genes involved in autolysis and virulence, phenotypes affected by
sarA and mgrA, was evaluated in an isogenic sarV
mutant pair . Our data indicated that the sarV gene product played
a role regulating some virulence genes and more genes involved
in autolysis . The sarV mutant was more resistant to Triton X-100
and penicillin-induced lysis compared to the wild type and the
sarA mutant, whereas hyperexpression of sarV in the parental
strain or the sarV mutant rendered the resultant strain highly
susceptible to lysis . Zymographic analysis of murein hydrolase
activity revealed that inactivation of the sarV gene results
in decreased extracellular murein hydrolase activity compared to that
of wild-type S . aureus . We propose that sarV may be
part of the common pathway by which mgrA and sarA gene products
control autolysis in S . aureus .
Staphylococcus aureus is an important human pathogen that has
become a growing public health concern, primarily due to the
emergence of antibiotic-resistant strains within the hospital
environment (4, 5, 25) .
The spectrum of infections caused by this organism is extremely
broad, ranging from cutaneous infections such as impetigo,
folliculitis, and carbuncles to deep-seated infections such as
pneumonia, endocarditis, septicemia, osteomyelitis, and other
metastatic complications . Besides invasion syndromes, S . aureus
can also cause toxin-mediated diseases such as food poisoning, toxic
shock syndrome, and scalded skin syndrome . The primary site of
infection is generally the skin or a wound from which the organism
can spread to the bloodstream and subsequently disseminate into
various host tissues . Once S . aureus establishes its presence
in the tissue, it produces a large number of bacterial components and
secreted products that include surface-associated protein adhesins,
enzymes, exotoxins, and capsular polysaccharides, gene products that
facilitate tissue colonization, tissue destruction, and immune
evasion . The expression of many of these genes is coordinately
controlled by regulatory loci (2, 5,
33, 35) . These regulatory loci
include agr, sarA, saeRS, sigB, lytSR,
arlRS, and sarA-like genes .
The agr locus consists of two divergent transcripts, RNAII and
RNAIII, which encode agrDBCA and hld, respectively (19,
20, 33) . It is also a complex
quorum-sensing two-component regulatory system in S . aureus .
The RNAII transcriptional unit codes for four genes, of which
agrBD are involved in the generation and secretion of an
autoinducing octapeptide . As the autoinducing peptide reaches a
threshold concentration in the growth medium during the transition
from exponential to postexponential phase, activation of agrC
and agrA, encoding the two-component regulatory system, would
occur, leading to the transcription of RNAII and RNAIII, the agr
regulatory molecule responsible for the up-regulation of exoproteins
and down-regulation of cell wall-associated proteins (20,
33) . The sarA locus comprises a major open reading
frame (ORF), sarA, driven by three distinct promoters,
resulting in three overlapping transcripts with a common terminating
end (8, 29) . The sarA
locus up-modulates the expression of selected cell wall proteins and
exoproteins (e.g.,
-
and ß-hemolysins) . DNA binding studies have revealed that SarA, the
major sarA effector molecule, binds to several target gene
promoters (e.g., agr, hla, and spa) to modulate
gene transcription (10), thus implicating both
agr-dependent and agr-independent pathways for
SarA-mediated regulation .
Using affinity chromatography and genomic scan, we and others have
identified several SarA homologs that are involved directly or
indirectly in gene regulation . SarR, a 115-residue-long polypeptide (30),
represses SarA expression during the postexponential phase by binding
to the sarA promoter region . SarS (also called SarH1) is a
250-residue protein (9, 44) repressed by
agr to activate spa expression and, to a lesser extent, to
down-regulate hla expression . rot, also a sarA
homolog, is a negative regulator for hemolysins (hla and
hlb), lipase (geh), and serine proteases (sspB and
splA) as well as a positive regulator for cell surface
proteins (clfB/clumping factor, spa/protein A, sdrC/putative
cell surface adhesin) (32, 39) . SarT
is a repressor of hla and RNAIII transcription (41) .
Contiguous to sarT, but transcribed in the opposite
orientation, is sarU (sarH2), whose expression is
negatively controlled by SarT . Phenotypic and transcriptional
analysis revealed that sarU is a positive regulator of RNAIII
and contributes to the expression of virulence genes controlled by
agr (31) . More recently, mgrA (also called rat
or norR), a homolog of marR and also sarA, has
been found to negatively regulate autolysis genes without
significantly affecting sarA and agr expression (17) .
The mgrA gene also impacts upon the expression of type 8
capsular polysaccharide (cap8),
-hemolysin
(hla), protein A (spa), norA, lipase, protease, and
coagulase (27, 45) .
Besides regulating virulence genes, the agr and sarA loci are
also involved in the regulation of genes involved in the autolysis
process, but the exact mechanism (e.g., direct versus indirect)
is not known . Two-component regulatory systems such as ArlRS and
LytSR have been shown to participate in the regulation of autolysis
genes (6, 12, 13,
16) . Downstream of the dicistronic lytSR
operon is the lrgAB locus, the expression of which is
dependent on activation by LytSR . Based on homology alone, it has
been speculated that LrgA may function as an antiholin to inhibit
murein hydrolase activity, presumably by interfering with the holin
molecule that has been postulated to form a pore for the transport of
murein hydrolases across the cell membrane (4,
7, 14) . Although the exact mechanism of
autolysis and their mode of regulation are not well defined, it is
hypothesized that a diminution in transport of autolysins across the
cell membrane would reduce the autolytic process .
We have identified another homolog of SarA, a 116-residue-long
polypeptide called SarV (SA2062 and protein GI13702067) (21) .
The expression of sarV is repressed by sarA and mgrA
(SA0641 and protein GI 13700577), known to be involved in the control
of virulence and autolysis genes . Inactivation of sarV did not
affect the expression of regulatory genes such as sarU, sarR,
sarS, sarT, sarA, rot, and sae but had
discernible effects on the expression of agr RNAII and RNAIII,
lytSR, and arlRS . As sarA and mgrA are
involved in the regulation of autolysis and virulence genes, we also
evaluated the expression of 19 potential target genes involved in
these phenotypes (33) (spa, coa, clfA,
fnbA, fnbB, hla, atl, lytM, lytN,
lrgAB, geh, scdA, abcA, pbp4, splA,
scp, aur, norA, and cap8) by Northern blotting and
transcriptional fusions in sarV mutants . Importantly, the
sarV gene product is involved in the regulation of autolysin and
protease genes (scdA, lrgB, atl, splA,
and aur) . Lytic assays with Triton X-100 and penicillin
indicated that the sarV mutant, contrary to the effect of
mgrA and sarA mutants, is more resistant to lysis than the
parent, while hyperexpression of sarV renders the strain
sensitive . Analysis of the sarV mutant indicated that this gene
regulates extracellular and intracellular murein hydrolase activity,
possibly by regulating selective genes involved for autolysis .
Because sarV likely does not regulate mgrA or sarA, we
propose that sarV constitutes an important "hub" for the
control of autolysis by mgrA and sarA .
Bacterial strains and growth conditions. The bacterial strains
and plasmids used in this study are listed in Table 1 .
Phage
11
was used as a generalized transducing phage for S . aureus
strains . S . aureus strain RN4220, a restriction-deficient
derivative of strain 8325-4, was used as the initial recipient for
the transformation of plasmid constructs . S . aureus cells were
grown at 37°C with aeration in Trypticase soy broth (TSB) or 03GL
agar medium supplemented with antibiotics when necessary .
Luria-Bertani medium was used for growing Escherichia coli .
Antibiotics were used at the following concentrations: for S .
aureus, erythromycin at 5 µg/ml, kanamycin at 50 µg/ml,
tetracycline at 5 µg/ml, and chloramphenicol at 10 µg/ml; for E .
coli, ampicillin at 50 µg/ml, chloramphenicol at 30 µg/ml,
erythromycin at 200 µg/ml, and spectinomycin at 75 µg/ml .
| TABLE 1 . Strains and plasmids used
|
|
Genetic manipulations in E . coli and S . aureus.
Based on homology with SarA, the sarV gene product was initially
identified in the S . aureus N315 genome database (21; www.tigr.org/ and www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/genomics) .
To construct a sarV mutant, the sarV gene together with
flanking sequences on both sides were amplified by PCR with the
primers 5'-AACTGTCGATGGATTTAACGTTA-3' and
5'-AGTTTAGTATTAGGTACAGCGA-3', using chromosomal DNA from strain
RN6390 as the template . The 2.2-kb PCR fragment was cloned into
cloning vector pCR 2.1 (Invitrogen, San Diego, Calif.) in E . coli .
The HindIII-EcoRV DNA fragment containing the 2.2-kb fragment was
then cloned into the HindIII and HincII sites of pUC19 . A 565-bp
fragment, comprising the sarV coding region as well as 137 and
78 bp of the respective upstream and downstream regions, was deleted
by restricting with BsaBI and SphI and then replacing the deleted
fragment with a
1.2-kb
ermC gene at these sites . The fragment containing the ermC
replacement of the deleted sarV gene was cloned into the
temperature-sensitive shuttle vector pCL52.2 . Construction and
selection of the putative sarV mutant (tetracycline-sensitive
and erythromycin-resistant colonies) were performed as described
elsewhere (30, 31) . A phage
11
lysate of the putative sarV mutant was then prepared to infect
fresh strain RN6390 cells to reconstruct the sarV mutant, in
an attempt to avoid any putative genomic mutations that might have
occurred during the temperature shift to promote homologous
recombination . The correct mutation was confirmed by PCR, Northern,
and Southern hybridization with sarV and ermC probes as
described previously (28, 30) . One clone,
designated ALC2319, was selected for further study .
To complement the sarV mutation, a 1.5-kb fragment encompassing
the sarV gene and 295 bp upstream of the sarV translation
start site were cloned into shuttle plasmid pSK236 . The recombinant
plasmid was electroporated into RN4220, selecting for
chloramphenicol-resistant colonies . The correct transformant was
verified by restriction analysis of the recombinant plasmid . The
plasmid from RN4220 was then electroporated into parental strain
RN6390 and the sarV mutant (ALC2319) to construct strains
ALC2375 and ALC2376, respectively .
Isolation of RNA and Northern blot hybridization. Total RNA
from S . aureus was prepared by using a TRIzol isolation kit
(Gibco BRL, Gaithersburg, Md.) and a reciprocating shaker as
described elsewhere (8, 30,
31) . The optical density at 650 nm OD650 of various
cultures was determined with a spectrophotometer (Spectronic 20) . The
concentration of total RNA was determined by measuring the absorbance
at 260 nm, and 10 µg of each total RNA sample was analyzed by
Northern blotting as described previously (30) .
The genes coding for agr RNAII, agr RNAIII, sarA,
sarR, sarT, sarS, sarU, rot, mgrA,
sae, lytS, lytR, arlS, arlR, spa,
coa, clfA, fnbA, fnbB, hla, lytM and -N,
atl, lrgB, geh, scdA, abcA,
pbp4, splA, scp, aur, norA, and cap8 were
either amplified by PCR or excised from the plasmids containing the
desired genes with restriction endonucleases . An internal fragment
of the 16S rRNA gene (nucleotides [nt]777 to 1500; GenBank accession
no.
X68417) was used as a loading control . For detection of specific
transcripts, gel-purified DNA probes were radiolabeled with [ -32P]dCTP
by using the random-primed DNA labeling kit (Roche Diagnostics GmbH)
and hybridized under aqueous-phase conditions at 65°C . The blots were
subsequently washed and autoradiographed .
Transcriptional fusion studies of agr RNAII, agr
RNAIII, hla, sarA, sarV, arlR, and lytS
promoters linked to the gfpuvr reporter gene
Construction of the plasmid pALC1743, -1742, and -1740 containing
agr RNAIII, agr RNAII, and hla promoter fragments linked to
the gfpuvr reporter gene were described earlier (18,
31) . A 268-bp sarV promoter fragment
(position 21 to 288 nt upstream from the start ATG codon) was
amplified by PCR using chromosomal DNA of S . aureus strain
RN6390 and primers with flanking EcoRI or XbaI sites . An EcoRI and
XbaI fragment containing the sarV promoter was cloned into
shuttle plasmid pALC1484, generating plasmid pALC2489 containing the
transcriptional fusion of the sarV promoter to the gfpuvr
reporter gene . The construction of plasmid pALC1484 and modification
of gfpuv (Clontech, Palo Alto, Calif.) to gfpuvr
with an S65T mutation to yield a red shift (excitation maxima from
395 to 488 nm) were described earlier (18) .
Similarly, DNA fragments containing arlS, lytR, and
mgrA P1 promoters were cloned into shuttle plasmid pALC1484,
generating plasmids containing transcriptional fusions to the gfpuvr
reporter gene (17) . Restriction analysis and DNA sequencing
confirmed the orientation and authenticity of the promoter reporter
gene constructs . The recombinant plasmids, containing the respective
promoter regions, were first introduced into S . aureus strain
RN4220 by electroporation . Plasmids purified from RN4220 transformants
were then electroporated into RN6390, its isogenic sarV::ermC
(ALC2319), sarA::ermC (ALC1342), mgrA::ermC
(ALC2530), mgrA::ermC/sarA::kan (ALC2535)
mutants, and single-copy complemented mgrA (ALC2531) and
sarA (ALC1629) strains as required .
After overnight culture, S . aureus strains harboring the recombinant
plasmids were diluted 1:100 in TSB containing chloramphenicol
(10 µg/ml) and grown at 37°C with shaking at 250 rpm . Aliquots (200
µl) were transferred hourly to microtiter plates to assay for OD650
and fluorescence for 10 h in an FL600 fluorescence reader (BioTek
Instrument, Winooski, Vt.) . Promoter activation was plotted as mean
fluorescence per OD650 over time, using the average values
from triplicate readings .
Purification of SarA and MgrA proteins. The cloning and
purification of the His6 tagged fusion SarA protein were
described earlier (10) . The 444-bp DNA fragments
containing the full-length mgrA gene (SA0641of S . aureus N315)
were amplified by PCR using chromosomal DNA from S . aureus RN6390
as the template and primers containing flanking restriction
sites (NdeI and BamHI) to facilitate in-frame cloning into the
expression vector pET14b (Novagen, Madison, Wis.) . The recombinant
plasmids containing the full-length mgrA coding region were
confirmed by restriction digestion and DNA sequencing . The recombinant
plasmids were then transformed into E . coli BL21(DE3)pLysS .
The recombinant His6-MgrA protein expression and purification
were done in a manner similar to that for the SarA protein as
described elsewhere (10) . The authenticity and purity of the
purified His6-tagged MgrA fusion protein were confirmed by
sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) gels stained with Brilliant Blue R-250
and microsequenced for the first 20 residues from the N terminus .
The purified His6-tagged SarA and MgrA proteins were found to
be more than 98% pure in an SDS-12% polyacrylamide gel . The
concentration of the purified proteins was determined by the Bradford
protein assay (Bio-Rad, Hercules, Calif.), using bovine serum albumin
as the standard .
Gel shift analysis and DNase I footprinting. To determine if
the recombinant SarA or MgrA proteins bind to the sarV
promoter region, a 191- or 268-bp fragment (positions 21 to 211 or
288), representing the sarV promoter region, was end labeled
with [ -32P]ATP
by using T4 polynucleotide kinase . Labeled fragment (0.1 ng or 0.5
fmol) was incubated at room temperature (RT) for 20 min with various
amounts of purified SarA or MgrA protein in 25 µl of binding buffer
(25 mM Tris-Cl [pH 7.5], 0.1 mM EDTA, 75 mM NaCl, 1 mM
dithiothreitol, and 10% glycerol) containing 0.5 µg of calf thymus
DNA (Amersham Pharmacia Biotech) . The reaction mixtures were analyzed
in an 8.0% nondenaturing polyacrylamide gel . The band shifts
were detected by exposing dried gels to X-ray films .
Footprinting assays with template DNA fragment and DNase I were
performed as previously described (3, 10,
30) . To label PCR products, only one of the
primers was labeled at one end . For the assay, the binding reactions
were carried out in a 100-µl reaction volume containing 20 mM Tris-Cl
(pH 8.0), 100 mM NaCl, 5 mM MgCl2, 1 mM CaCl2,
2 mM dithiothreitol, 10 µg of bovine serum albumin, 0.4 µg of calf
thymus DNA, radiolabeled template DNA (20,000 cpm), and various
amounts of the purified SarA or MgrA proteins at RT for 30 min . DNase
I (0.02 U; Boehringer, Mannheim, Germany) was added and allowed to
incubate for 1 min at RT . The reaction mixtures were extracted with
phenol-chloroform, ethanol precipitated, washed with 70% ethanol,
dried, and resuspended in loading buffer (98% deionized formamide, 10
mM EDTA [pH 8.0], 0.025% [wt/vol] xylene cyanol FF, 0.025% [wt/vol]
bromophenol blue) . DNA samples were denatured at 95°C for 5 min and
analyzed on a 6% denaturing polyacrylamide sequence gel . The
positions of the protected region were derived by comparing the
footprint with the A+G sequencing ladder of the same fragment (28) .
Primer extension analysis. Mapping of the 5' end of the
sarV transcript by primer extension was performed using the
primer 5'-CTTCAATTGAAATCTTATGTGTTG-3', complementary to the sarV
coding strand and located from nt positions 94 to 71 downstream from
the putative start codon ATG . Reverse transcription was carried out
as described elsewhere by using total RNA isolated from wild-type
RN6390 or the sarA mutant as described previously (3,
30) .
Lytic assays with Triton X-100 and penicillin. These assays
were performed as described elsewhere (12, 17,
27) . In brief, overnight-grown bacteria were diluted to
an OD650 of 0.05 in TSB containing 1 M NaCl and allowed to
grow at 37°C with shaking till the OD650 reached 0.7 to
1.2 . Cells were harvested, washed twice with ice-cold water, and then
resuspended in 0.05 M Tris-Cl (pH 7.2) in the original volume with or
without 0.05% Triton X-100 . Cells were incubated at 30°C with shaking
and checked for lysis by measuring the progressive decrease in
absorbance (OD650) at 30-min intervals . To assess the sensitivity
of the sarV mutant to penicillin, inoculations were done in
TSB from overnight cultures to yield a starting OD650 of 0.05 .
Cultures were grown at 37°C with shaking to reach exponential
phase (OD650
0.5) .
Penicillin G was added to a concentration of 0.4 µg/ml . Cultures were
incubated further, and the OD650 was measured every hour
for 7 to 8 h .
Zymographic analysis. For the detection of extracellular and
intracellular murein hydrolases, SDS-polyacrylamide gel
electrophoresis-based zymographic analysis was performed as described
by Groicher et al . (16) . In brief, various strains
were grown in TSB medium for 16 h at 37°C and 250 rpm . Extracellular
murein hydrolases were isolated by pelleting 16-h cultures at 6,000
x g for 20 min at 4°C . The
supernatant was filter sterilized and concentrated 100-fold by using
polyethylene glycol 8000, followed by dialysis in phosphate-buffered
saline . To obtain intracellular and cell wall-associated murein
hydrolases, the cell pellets were extracted as essentially described
by Groicher et al . (16), and final fractions were
dialyzed against phosphate-buffered saline buffer .
The concentrations of total proteins in each sample were determined
by using the Bradford assay (Bio-Rad) according to the manufacturer's
procedures . Various protein fractions were resolved on an SDS-12%
polyacrylamide gel containing either Micrococcus luteus (Sigma
Chemical Co.) or autoclaved and lyophilized S . aureus RN6390
cells (1 mg [dry weight] of cells per ml of gel) . After electrophoresis,
gels were washed with water and incubated overnight in 25 mM
Tris-Cl, pH 8.0, containing 1% Triton X-100 at 37°C to allow
hydrolysis of the embedded bacterial cells . After incubation, gels
were stained with 1% methylene blue (Sigma Chemical Co.) and
destained in water . Following destaining the gels were scanned in a
scanner, and the white bands in the gels (zones of hydrolysis)
indicated regions of murein hydrolase activity . Quantitative cell
wall hydrolysis assays were performed as described by Rice et al . (38)
as the turbidity of the samples was determined by measuring the
absorbance at 580 nm with a spectrophotometer .
Identification of the sarV gene. Searching for
additional SarA homologs in the recently published S . aureus
N315 genome, we found at least 12 proteins homologous to SarA
(SA0573, protein GI 13700508), using a default setting of 30 as the
cutoff for the BLAST search (21;
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/genomes/staphylococcus) . Some of these
homologs included SarT (SA2286 or SarH3, protein GI 13702448; e-value
of 9e–17) (41), SarS (also called SarH1
or SA0108, protein GI 13700028; e-value of 1e–16) (9,
44), SarU (also called SarH2 or SA2287, protein GI 13702449;
e-value of 2e–15) (31), SarR (SA2089,
protein GI 13702095; e-value of 9e–12) (30),
and Rot (SA1583, protein GI 13701558; e-value of 0.003) (32) .
MgrA (also called Rat, NorR, or SA0641; protein GI 13700577; e-value
of 4e–04), more homologous to MarR than to SarA, has been
shown to play a role in the regulation of genes involved in autolysis
and virulence (17, 26, 45) .
The remaining homologs of unknown function were SA0668 (protein
GI13700559; e-value of 1e–04 and 46% homology), SA2174
(protein GI13702335; e-value of 0.002 and 53% homology), and
two more proteins (protein GI 1301144 and 13700062; e-values of 0.003
and 0.030 and homologies of 48 and 48% within a small region of
proteins, respectively) . SarV (SA2062 and protein GI 13702067) is the
seventh protein that came up in our homology search, with SarT, -S,
-U, and -R, SA0668, and MgrA being the first six hits (21) .
SarV is a 116-residue polypeptide (13,985 Da) that shares 52, 48, 44,
52, 51, 45, 49, and 60% homology to SarR, SarA, SarU1 (residues 1 to
124), SarU2 (residues 125 to 247), SarS1 (residues 1 to 125 of SarS),
SarS2 (residues 126 to 250 of SarS), SarT, and MgrA, respectively .
Based on sequence alignment, it can be observed that specific
residues of SarV are conserved within the SarA protein family,
including K23, L36, K48, K80, R82, D86, E87, R88, Q98, L101, and I109
of SarV (data not shown) . In a BLAST comparison of SarV against
other microbial genomes with the same default setting, we found a
number of putative transcriptional regulators with unknown functions
(e-values of 2e–06 to 9.0) . Apart from S . aureus,
significant homologs include Bacillus subtilis hypothetical
protein ybfA (Z99105; e-value of 2 e–04 with 29% identity
and 52% similarity) and a probable transcriptional regulator of
Clostridium perfringens (AP003188; e-value of 0.001 with 23%
identity and 50% similarity) .
Expression of sarV in RN6390 and an assortment of isogenic
mutants. To determine the phenotypic effects of sarV, we
constructed a sarV mutant in RN6390 by allelic replacement,
essentially replacing the sarV gene with an ermC
cassette (see Materials and Methods) . A Northern blot assay with a
sarV probe (350 bp) encompassing the coding region disclosed that
sarV was poorly transcribed or undetectable in parental
strains RN6390 and SH1000 (S . aureus 8325-4 rsbU+
strain; kindly provided by S . J . Foster) . As expected,
complementation of the wild type or the sarV mutant with a
plasmid carrying the sarV gene (ALC2375 or ALC2376) increased
the level of transcript of the sarV gene . Interestingly, the
sarV transcript, sizing at
500
nt, was significantly enhanced in two sarA mutants (ALC488
sarA::ermC and ALC1342
orf3sarA::ermC)
and the rat/mgrA mutant ( mgrA::ermC),
but not in the sarR, sarS, sarT, sarU, or
agr mutants (Fig . 1, top panel) . The size of
the transcript also hinted at the monocistronic nature of the sarV
locus . Upon introducing a single copy of the mgrA gene or of
the entire sarB locus into the lipase gene (geh) of the
respective mgrA or sarA mutant (ALC2531 and ALC1629,
respectively), the expression of sarV transcript returned to
near the parental level, suggesting that the expression of sarV
is truly repressed by sarA or the mgrA gene product . To
determine whether the expression of mgrA was affected in these
assorted mutants, we performed Northern analysis with the mgrA
probe (450 bp) and found no significant changes in the expression of
mgrA transcript in agr, sarT, sarU,
sarV, sarS, and sarA mutants (Fig . 1,
middle panel) . The expression of mgrA gene transcript was
slightly elevated in the sarR mutant . Notably, the mgrA
transcript level was more elevated in strains (ALC2375 and ALC2376)
harboring a multicopy plasmid carrying the sarV gene . Thus,
besides repression by mgrA, it would seem that increased
expression of sarV transcript also enhances mgrA
expression, suggesting that sarV may act as an activator for
the expression of mgrA transcript . However, the significance
of this finding remains unclear, since we do not know the physiologic
relevance of increased gene dosage in vivo (Fig . 1,
top panel) . There are no significant growth differences in the growth
curves for the sarV mutant compared with those for the wild
type and various mutants (data not shown) . Growth phase variation of
various mutants did not make any difference in the data presented
above for the expression of sarV transcript when Northern blot
hybridization was performed with total RNA isolated in the early
phase of growth of various mutants (data not shown) .
|
FIG . 1 . Northern analysis of the sarV and mgrA transcripts
in the wild type, various isogenic mutants, and complemented strains at
postexponential phases (OD650,
1.7)
of growth . A total of 15 µg of cellular RNA was loaded onto each lane .
The blots were probed with 360-bp sarV (upper panel), 565-bp
mgrA (middle panel), and 724-bp (lower panel) fragments containing
the entire ORF of the sarV and mgrA genes and internal
region of 16S rDNA, respectively . cp indicates complementation with
respective genes . The OD650 was determined with a
spectrophotometer (Spectronic 20).
|
|
Transcriptional start sites and promoter structure of the sarV
gene. To determine the transcriptional start site and the promoter
sequence, primer extension was performed with total RNA isolated
from the wild-type strain RN6390 and its isogenic sarA mutant
(data not shown) . The transcriptional start site was mapped to
an A or T which was located 62 or 63 bp upstream of the initiation
codon ATG . Based upon the transcriptional start site, the predicted
putative promoter boxes are TAGATA(–35)-N17-TATAAT(–10),
which has close homology with the –10 and –35 consensus sequences of
A-dependent
promoters (Fig . 2A; see also Fig . 4D) .
A strong ribosome binding site, AGGAGG, was located 9 bp upstream
of the ATG translational start codon . Analysis of the downstream
sequence of the sarV gene disclosed the presence of a rho-independent
transcriptional terminator sequence from the position 1 to 91
bp immediately after the stop codon (TAA) . Within this region, a
23-bp inverted repeat sequence from positions 1 to 23 and 68 to 91
after the stop codon of the sarV gene (AAAAATAAAAAGCATGCCAATCT-N45-AGATTGGCATGCTTTTTAAGTTTTT)
could form a potential hairpin structure with a 24-nt-long heteroduplex .
|
FIG . 2 . Promoter activation of the sarV promoter fused to a
gfpuvr reporter gene . (A) Graphical representation of the
268-bp sarV promoter fragment fused to a promoterless gfpuvr
gene with an S . aureus ribosome binding site . The translational
start site, labeled as +1, was identified by primer extension, and the
putative promoter –10 and –35 boxed sequences are also indicated . The
numbers at the line (both top and bottom) are marked according to the
transcriptional start site and the translation start codon of the
sarV gene, respectively . (B) The recombinant shuttle construct
pALC2489 containing the 268-bp sarV promoter fragment driving the
GFPuvr reporter gene was introduced into the wild type, its
isogenic mutant strains, and complemented strains . Lane 1, wild-type
RN6390; lane 2, sarV mutant ALC2319; lane 3, sarA mutant
ALC1342; lane 4, the sarB fragment (28)
integrated into the geh locus of the sarA mutant
designated ALC1629; lane 5, mgrA mutant ALC2530; lane 6, the
1.5-kb DNA fragment containing the mgrA gene integrated into the
geh locus of the mgrA mutant designated ALC2531; lane 7,
mgrA sarA double mutant ALC2539 . To minimize variations in
fluorescence attributable to cell density, the data are presented as the
average of reported fluorescence unit per OD650 in triplicate
samples obtained at different growth points.
|
|
|
FIG . 4 . DNase I protection footprint analysis of SarA and MgrA binding
to the sarV promoter region of S . aureus. (A) Footprint
analysis of SarA binding to the sarV promoter region . The 191-bp
fragment (nt positions –21 to –211 from the start codon ATG) was end
labeled (top or coding strand) with [ -32P]ATP .
Lanes 1 and 6, no protein added; lanes 2 to 5, 1, 2, 3, and 4 µg of
SarA, respectively . Lane M represents chemical cleavage at purine
residues (A/G ladder) . (B and C) Footprinting analysis of the MgrA
protein binding to the 268-bp sarV promoter region (nt positions
21 to 288 from the ATG start codon) . The 268-bp fragment was end labeled
for top strand (B) and bottom strand (C) and incubated with DNase I in
the presence or absence of proteins, as described above . No protein was
added for lanes 1 and 6 in panel B or for lanes 1 and 7 in panel C .
Lanes 2 to 5 (B) and 4 to 6 (C), 0.2, 0.5, 1.0, and 2.0 µg of protein
was added; lane 3 of panel C, 0.3 µg of protein was added . Protected
regions are marked by solid lines . (D) Nucleotide sequence of the 293-bp
fragment upstream of the sarV gene was shown and marked with the
putative promoter region and start site as derived from primer extension
data . The putative protected regions for SarA and MgrA proteins on the
promoter are marked.
|
|
sarV promoter-gfpuvr fusion studies in isogenic
sarA and mgrA strains. To confirm the repression of
sarV by mgrA and sarA, we constructed a
transcriptional fusion containing a 268-bp sarV promoter fragment
upstream of the gfpuvr reporter gene (Fig .
2A) . The construct pALC2489 was introduced into the wild-type
strain RN6390, sarA mutant (ALC1342), mgrA mutant
(ALC2530), sarV mutant (ALC2319), sarA/mgrA
double mutant (ALC2535), complemented mgrA mutant (ALC2531),
and complemented sarA mutant (ALC1629) . Promoter activities,
assayed as GFPuvr fluorescence (Fig . 2B), were
5-,
13- to 17-, and 18- to 28-fold higher at the three time points
for sarA (lane 3), mgrA (lane 5), and sarA/mgrA (lane 7)
mutants, respectively, compared with that of the parental strain
RN6390 (lane 1) . Complemented sarA and mgrA mutant
strains (Fig . 2B, lanes 4 and 6) had reduced GFPuvr
values compared to the parental strain . These data are consistent
with the notion that the expression of sarV gene transcript is
repressed by sarA and mgrA gene products . In the double
sarA/mgrA mutant (Fig . 2B, lane 7), the mean GFPuvr
value was higher than that for the single mutant, indicating
that SarA and MgrA may repress sarV gene expression via divergent
mechanisms . Collectively, these data concur with those of Northern
analysis, essentially demonstrating that the expression of sarV
gene transcript was undetectable in the wild type, moderately
elevated in the sarA mutant, and highly expressed in the mgrA
mutant . The expression of sarV is probably not dependent on
its own gene product, as the mean GFPuvr value (228 to 407 ±
75 U) in the sarV mutant was comparable to that for the parental
strain RN6390 (176 to 322 ± 50 U) .
Binding of SarA and MgrA proteins to the sarV promoter region.
As the level of transcript of sarV was increased in sarA and
mgrA mutants (Fig . 1), we speculated that SarA
and MgrA may bind to the sarV promoter region to modulate
sarV expression . In previous studies, we reported that members of
the SarA protein family (e.g., SarA, -R, -S, and -T) have a conserved
helix-turn-helix motif commonly found in DNA binding proteins (10,
30, 31) . The MgrA protein, as a
MarR homolog and to a lesser extent SarA, likely possesses a
helix-turn-helix motif and hence is predicted to be a DNA binding
protein . To verify this, we employed a 268-bp or a 191-bp sarV
promoter fragment (position 21 to 288 or 21 to 211 nt upstream of the
initiation codon) upstream of the ribosomal binding site for DNA
binding assays . The DNA fragment (0.1 ng or 0.56 fmol per reaction
mixture) was end labeled with [ -32P]ATP
and used in gel shift assays with various amounts of purified SarA
and MgrA proteins (Fig . 3) . Retarded protein-DNA
complex could be detected with as little as 0.1 to 0.2 µg of MgrA
(2.8 to 5.7 nM, assuming that MgrA is a dimeric protein like SarA or
SarR) and
0.3
µg (10 nM) of SarA . As the concentrations of these proteins
increased, the retarded protein-DNA complex became the predominant
band, with complete conversion at
1.0
µg for both proteins . Hence, SarA and MgrA proteins can bind to the
sarV promoter region, presumably acting as a repressor to
sarV transcription . To verify the DNA binding specificity and to
map the binding sites, we performed DNase I protection assays with
the same 268- or 191-bp sarV promoter fragment labeled with
-32P
at one end in the presence of SarA or MgrA (Fig . 4) .
As shown in Fig . 4A, protection from DNase I digestion
with SarA was mapped to a region +2 to –42 bp from the +1
transcription start in Fig . 4D . A close analysis of
this sequence revealed that the protected regions (box I, –21 to –42
bp from the transcription start; box II, +2 to –19 bp from
transcription start in Fig . 4D) closely resemble the SarA
consensus DNA binding motif (ATTTGTATTTAATATTTATATAATTG) previously
reported by our investigators (10) . Box I and II
have 15 of 26 and 19 of 26 matches to the SarA consensus binding
sequence, respectively, thus verifying that the DNA binding site of
SarA on the sarV promoter is likely specific and further
confirming our group's earlier studies on the predicted SarA binding
consensus sequence . We also mapped the DNA binding site of the MgrA
protein on the sarV promoter . Using the same end-labeled
191-bp promoter fragment, we initially failed to identify any
protected region with both strands (data not shown) . However, when
the assays were repeated with the larger 268-bp sarV promoter
fragment that we have used for the gfpuvr fusion
assay (position –21 to –288 bp from the start codon), we found two
closely associated protected regions (Fig . 4B and C) .
The putative protected regions of MgrA are from positions –84 to –115
bp, –132 to –147 bp (Fig . 4B, top strand of DNA),
and –81 to –108 bp upstream of the transcriptional start site (Fig .
4C, bottom strand of DNA, and D) . DNA sequence analyses
of these regions disclosed a 6-bp conserved sequence (t/aGTTGT) that
was repeated four times in the top and bottom strands of the
protected sequence (Fig . 4D) . The sequence encompassing –84
to –115 bp upstream of the initiation codon was of interest as
it contained the sequence t/aGTTGT thrice and was protected in both
strands . This led us to speculate that MgrA may bind to this region
to facilitate binding to other areas via conformational changes
(e.g., by cooperating interaction, bending, or other means of
regulation) . Whether the conserved 6-bp binding region of MgrA
applies to other target loci regulated by MgrA requires additional
confirmation . Nevertheless, the results presented in Fig.
3 and 4 clearly demonstrated that SarA and
MgrA proteins are likely to bind to different sites on the sarV
promoter region with a high degree of specificity . The SarA binding
sites overlap with the –10 and –35 promoter boxes, whereas the
MgrA binding sites are upstream of the sarV promoter boxes .
|
FIG . 3 . Autoradiogram of an 8.0% nondenaturing polyacrylamide gel
showing gel shifts for purified MgrA and SarA proteins with a 268-bp
sarV promoter fragment . Mobility of the DNA band in the presence of
increasing amounts of either MgrA or SarA protein is indicated on the
top . Cold competition lanes with a 10-fold excess (molar ratio) of the
unlabeled 268-bp sarV fragment are indicated and contained 1.0 µg
of the purified MgrA or SarA protein.
|
|
Transcription and transcriptional fusion assays for regulatory genes in
a sarV mutant and various other isogenic strains. To determine
whether inactivation of sarV affects other regulatory genes
involved in virulence, we performed Northern blot analysis with 11
other regulatory loci (agr RNAII, agr RNAIII, sarA,
sarR, sarS, sarT, sarU, mgrA, rot,
sae, lytS, lytR, arlR, and arlS) .
The functions of many SarA homologs have previously been described,
including SarR as a regulator of SarA and agr expression, SarS
as an activator of protein A expression, SarT as a repressor of
-hemolysin
expression, and SarU as an activator of RNAIII that is repressible by
SarT (9, 30, 31,
41) . The lytSR locus is a two-component
regulatory system that negatively controls extracellular murein
hydrolase activity via positive regulation of the lrgAB operon
(6, 16) . An arlRS mutant
up-regulates the expression of autolysis genes while augmenting
transcription of agr and other exoprotein genes, including
those of extracellular serine protease activity and the multidrug
resistance transporter gene norA (12,
13) . The saeRS locus encodes another two-component
regulatory system that positively regulates the expression of
-
and ß-hemolysins, DNase I, coagulase, and protein A (15) .
As shown in Fig . 5A, there was a partial reduction in
RNAII and, to a lesser extent, RNAIII expression during the
postexponential phase in the sarV mutant . Likewise, the levels
of transcripts of lytSR and arlRS were also reduced in the sarV
mutant . In contrast, the transcription levels of sarR, saeRS,
sarA, sarS, sarT, rot, and sarU were not
significantly altered in the sarV mutant (data not shown) .
However, it should be stressed that the expression of sarS,
sarT, and sarU was difficult to detect even in the
parental strain under routine laboratory culture conditions .
Complementation of the parent and sarV mutant with a plasmid
carrying the sarV gene either augmented or restored agr
RNAII, agr RNAIII, lytSR, and arlRS transcripts to near
or above parental levels in the recipient strain . Collectively,
these data suggested that sarV might act as an activator either
directly or indirectly for the expression of agr, lytSR, and
arlRS .
|
FIG . 5 . Analysis of assorted regulatory genes in a sarV mutant .
(A) Northern blots of agr RNAII and RNAIII, lytR, arlS,
and 16S rRNA transcripts in the wild-type RN6390, sarV (ALC2319),
trans-complemented strains (ALC2375, ALC2376), and sarA
(ALC1342) and agr (RN6911) mutants . A total of 10 µg of RNA from
the postexponential phase (OD650,
1.7)
was applied to each lane, and the blots were probed with the respective
gene fragment containing the coding region . (B to D) GFPuvr
expression as driven by agr RNAII (B), agr RNAIII (C), and
arlS-gfpuv and lytR-gfpuv (D)
promoters in the wild-type RN6390 and sarV mutant ALC2319 . Bar
diagrams in panels B and C represent various time points, whereas in
panel D the diagram represents the
8-h
time point . The experiments were repeated at least thrice; one
representative experiment is shown.
|
|
To verify reduction of agr RNAII, agr RNAIII, arlS, and
lytR transcripts in the sarV mutant (ALC2319), we
introduced into the isogenic sarV strains plasmids containing
the agr RNAII, agr RNAIII, arlS, or lytR
promoter linked to the gfpuvr gene for promoter
fusion analysis . Upon monitoring bacterial growth and serial GFP
expression over a 10-h period, we found that the growth rates were
comparable between the two strains containing each of the constructs,
with early stationary phase appearing after
6
h of growth . The expression of RNAII and RNAIII during the stationary
phase was slightly lower in the sarV mutant than in the
parental strain (Fig . 5B and C) . Thus, both Northern
blotting and transcriptional fusion assays were consistent with
the slight reduction of levels of transcripts in agr RNAII and
RNAIII expression in the sarV mutant relative to that in the
parental strain . Similarly, the expression of arlS promoter-gfpuv
and lytR promoter-gfpuv was found to be reduced
approximately threefold in the sarV mutant compared to the
wild-type strain after
8
h of growth (Fig . 5D) . Hence, Northern and transcriptional
fusion studies suggested that the sarV gene product possibly
acts as an activator for the expression of agr, arlRS, and
lytSR transcripts . These results were consistent in several
repeated experiments . Whether this effect is direct or indirect and
also physiologically relevant remains to be determined .
Northern blot analysis for the expression of target genes
The data presented above clearly indicated that the expression of
sarV, normally undetectable in the parental strain, was elevated
moderately in the sarA mutant and highly in the mgrA mutant .
SarA and MgrA, as DNA binding proteins, bind to the sarV promoter
region, presumably to repress sarV transcription . As sarA
and mgrA participate in the control of autolysis as well as
virulence genes (4, 8,
10, 12, 17,
26, 45), we determined the expression
of target genes known to be involved in autolysis or virulence
in the sarV mutant . We tested the expression of 19 potential
target genes (33), with 11 genes implicated in virulence
(e.g., hla, coa, geh, splA, scp,
norA, aur, spa, clfA, fnbA, and fnbB)
and 8 involved in autolysis (lytN, lytM, atl, lrgB,
scdA, abcA, pbp2, and pbp4) . The transcript
levels of genes encoding many cell surface-associated proteins (fnbA,
fnbB, clfA, and spa) were not markedly altered
by the sarV mutation during exponential and postexponential
phases of growth (data not shown) . The expression levels of geh
(glycerol ester hydrolase) and coa (coagulase) were also not
significantly affected in the sarV mutant (data not shown) .
The transcript level of the hla gene was lower in the sarV
mutant compared with that in the parental strain but was restored
upon complementation (Fig . 6) . Transcriptional
fusion of hla-gfpuvr also supported the Northern blotting data
(1,185 ± 250 versus 2,278 ± 500 mean fluorescence units per OD
at 6 h of growth for the sarV mutant and parent strain,
respectively) . A significant reduction in transcripts levels of
splA, encoding a putative serine protease-like gene product,
aur, encoding a zinc metalloprotease, and scp, encoding
staphopain (protease II) (19, 39) was
observed in the sarV mutant, while transcripts levels of these
genes were substantially elevated in the parental strain or returned
to a near-normal level in the mutant harboring trans-complementation
of the sarV gene in multicopy (Fig . 6) . As
predicted from earlier findings, the agr mutant also displayed
a significant reduction in these proteases, while a sarA
mutation led to an increase in the expression of these transcripts (19,
39) .
|
FIG . 6 . Northern blot analysis for assorted target genes in the wild
type, sarV mutant (ALC2319), trans-supplemented strains
ALC2375 and ALC2376, sarA mutant ALC1342, and agr mutant
RN6911 . Northern blots were hybridized with hla, splA,
aur, scdA, lrgB, atl, abcA, and 16S rRNA
DNA fragments containing the coding regions of the respective genes . A
total of 10 µg of RNA from the postexponential phase (OD650,
1.7)
was applied to each lane, and the OD650 was determined with a
spectrophotometer (Spectronic 20).
|
|
The level of transcript of scdA, a gene positively associated
with decreasing peptidoglycan cross-linking and increased autolysis (7),
and the autolysin gene atl, which encodes major autolysin (34,
36, 40), was found to be decreased in the
sarV mutant, thus suggesting positive regulation of scdA
and atl by sarV gene; complementation of the sarV
mutant with a multicopy plasmid (ALC2376) increased the expression of
scdA or atl in the mutant, but the effect was only partial,
thus suggesting that regulation of these genes by sarV may
possibly be indirect or via some unknown factor . Interestingly, a
sarA mutation increased scdA and atl transcripts,
while agr inactivation did not have any significant change
(Fig . 6) . The abcA gene, encoding an ATP
binding cassette transporter, is divergently transcribed from pbp4
(encoding penicillin binding protein 4) and is associated with cell
autolysis (42) . Interestingly, inactivation of sarV
augmented the lrgB transcript level (Fig . 6),
while a sarA mutant also increased lrgB transcription,
consistent with S . aureus gene array analysis (DNA chip) data
(11) . Northern analysis revealed little or no
impact effect of sarV on abcA expression . In contrast,
an agr mutant, but not a sarA mutant, displayed a
significant reduction in abcA transcript level, in concordance
with the data of Schrader-Fischer and Berger-Bachi (42) .
Under our experimental conditions, the pbp4 transcript was
found to be undetectable in the isogenic sarV strains .
Additionally, there was no significant difference in norA,
pbp2, lytN, and lytM transcript levels attributable
to the sarV mutation (data not shown) . Thus, a mutation in
sarV led to a reduction in transcript level of atl, the
major autolysin, as well as an alteration in scdA and lrgB
expression profiles consistent with an autolysis-resistant phenotype .
Phenotypic characterization of the sarV gene. The
alteration in atl, lrgB, and scdA expression levels of
transcripts in the sarV mutant, coupled with the repressive
effect on sarV by mgrA and sarA, suggested that
sarV may play an important role in controlling autolysis
mediated by mgrA and sarA in S . aureus .
Accordingly, we tested the sarV mutant for susceptibility to
lysis in the presence of a detergent and an antibiotic . As shown in
Fig . 7A, the sarV mutant was more resistant to Triton
X-100-induced lysis in 50 mM Tris-Cl buffer, pH 7.2, than the
wild-type RN6390 strain . The buffer alone also induced lysis of the
wild type, and this effect was amplified by 0.05% Triton X-100 . In
contrast, the sarV mutant strain remained less susceptible in
the buffer . Interestingly, the parental strain carrying the sarV
gene on multicopy plasmid (ALC2375) became slightly more lytic than
the wild-type strain in the presence of Triton X-100 . Similarly, the
sarV mutant carrying the sarV gene on multicopy plasmid
(ALC2376) was more susceptible to lysis, but slightly less than its
wild-type counterpart (data not shown) . We also tested the effect of
sarV on penicillin-induced lysis . Penicillin G (0.4 µg/ml) was
added to a growing culture at early exponential phase (OD650
= 0.5), and changes in optical density (OD650), as a
percentage of initial absorbance (OD), were monitored over a 7-h
period . As shown in Fig . 7B, the parental strain
RN6390 exhibited sensitivity to penicillin-induced lysis while the
sarV mutant was resistant, resulting in an OD higher than that of
the starting culture even at 6 h after the addition of penicillin . As
a positive control, the sarA and agr mutants displayed
high and low sensitivities, respectively, to penicillin-induced
lysis, consistent with previously published data (14,
27) .
|
FIG . 7 . Phenotypic and trans-functional analysis of the sarV
gene . (A) Effect of the sarV mutation on Triton X-100-induced
autolysis.
and
,
wild-type S . aureus strain RN6390;
and
,
sarV mutant ALC2319;
and
,
wild-type strain containing trans-supplemented sarV gene
in multicopy plasmid pSK236, ALC2375;
and •, sarA mutant strain ALC488 . Strains were grown as described
in Materials and Methods, with 0.05% Triton X-100 (open symbols) and
without Triton X-100 (filled symbols), following the decline of A650
as an indicator of lysis . (B) Effect of sarV on
penicillin-induced autolysis . Penicillin G-induced autolysis of
wild-type RN6390 ( ),
sarV mutant ALC2319 ( ),
RN6390 containing trans-supplemented sarV gene, ALC2375 ( ),
agr mutant RN6911 ( ),
and sarA mutant ALC1342 (•) was measured as the decline in
culture turbidity versus time . Autolysis is expressed as the percent of
the initial OD650 reading immediately before penicillin was
added . The experiments were repeated at least thrice; one representative
experiment is shown.
|
|
To determine whether the lytic resistance phenotype was attributable
to variations in murein hydrolase activity, possibly due to decreased
expression of atl or scdA and/or enhanced expression of
lrgB, zymographic analyses of culture supernatants and intracellular
proteins of various strains were performed using gels containing
M . luteus or S . aureus cells to detect glucosaminidase (GL)
(Fig . 8A and B) and amidase (AM) (Fig . 8C
and D) activities, respectively . It is known that atl
(autolysin) is expressed as a 138-kDa precursor protein that is
processed by protease to yield GL and AM domains of 54 and 63 kDa,
respectively (34) . Comparison between various
strains revealed that the culture supernatant of the sarV
mutant (ALC2319) displayed decreased GL (Fig . 8A)
and AM (Fig . 8C) activities compared to the wild-type
RN6390 strain . Significantly, no GL and AM activities were detected
in supernatant of an atl mutant, JC1413 (Fig . 8,
lanes 6) . The intracellular proteins of the sarV mutant showed
no significant variation of GL activity in the 54-kDa-size region
(Fig . 8B) or AM activity in the 63-kDa-size region
(Fig . 9D), but there was an extra zone of
hydrolysis for both activities in the >97-kDa-size region compared to
results with RN6390 . We speculated that the appearance of this band
was due to the unprocessed autolysin, which is yet to be confirmed .
The cell wall-associated proteins of the sarV mutant also
showed similar types of variation of the GL and AM activities as were
found for intracellular proteins (data not shown) . The variation in
autolytic activity of autolysin is controlled by multiple factors
that include SspA/V8 serine protease, SspB/cysteine protease,
lrgAB operon/speculated holin and antiholin, another regulatory
locus, and or an undefined regulatory mechanism (37) .
We also speculated that various other proteases, like aur,
splA, and scp, which are decreased in a sarV
mutant, might be involved in the resistance of autolysis .
|
FIG . 8 . Zymographic analysis of various fractions of different S .
aureus strains . Extracellular proteins (A and C) and intracellular
proteins (B and D) were isolated, and various amounts were loaded onto
an SDS-12% polyacrylamide gel containing 1.0 mg of either M . luteus
(A and B) or heat-killed RN6390 cells/ml, resolved, and treated with a
buffer containing 1% Triton X-100, followed by staining with 1%
methylene blue . Lanes 1 and 2, 2 and 4 µg of extra- or intracellular
proteins of RN6390 strain; lanes 3 to 5, 2, 4, and 6 µg of extra- or
intracellular proteins of the sarV mutant (ALC2319); lane 6, 4 µg
of extra- or intracellular proteins of the atl mutant (JC1413) .
Molecular size markers in kilodaltons are indicated to the left of each
gel.
|
|
|
FIG . 9 . Quantitative murein hydrolase assays of the sarV mutant .
Aliquots of 100 µg of the extracellular proteins of various strains were
added to a suspension of M . luteus cells (1.0 mg per ml), and
turbidity was monitored for 8 h . Strains used for quantitative hydrolase
analysis were the wild-type RN6390 ( ),
sarV mutant ALC2319 ( ),
and the wild-type strain containing trans-supplemented sarV
in multicopy plasmid pSK236, ALC2375 ( ).
x, control in which no extracellular
protein was added to the cell suspension . These data are from a single
representative experiment and were reproduced several times . OD was
determined at 580 nm with a spectrophotometer (Spectronic 20).
|
|
To quantify the zymographic analysis, cell wall hydrolysis assays
were performed as described by Rice et al . (38) . Culture
supernatants (100 µg) were added to a suspension of M . luteus
cells (1.0 mg per ml) in 100 mM Tris-Cl (pH 8.0) and incubated at
37°C with shaking, and the turbidity of the samples was
monitored at 580 nm . As shown in Fig . 9, the extracellular
murein hydrolases of ALC2319 caused no significant decrease in
turbidity of M . luteus cells after 8 h of incubation, compared
to about a 35% decrease in turbidity with the wild-type RN6390
extracellular murein hydrolases . In contrast, the presence of the
sarV gene in multicopy plasmid in the wild-type RN6390 caused
about a 40% decrease in turbidity after 8 h . These results, along
with the zymographic analysis, demonstrate that inactivation of the
sarV gene results in a reduction in the extracellular murein
hydrolase activity produced by S . aureus .
In prior studies, we and others have characterized SarA-like
proteins, including SarA (SA0573), SarR (SA2089), SarS (SA0108;
SarH1), Rot (SA1583), SarT (SA2286; SarH2), and SarU (SA2287; SarH3),
that are involved in the regulation of virulence genes in S .
aureus . Similar to SarA, SarV has sequence similarity to other
SarA homologs, such as SarA, SarR, SarT, and Rot, and also to those
with two homologous halves, such as SarS and SarU (data not shown) .
Unlike MgrA, SarV has a lower degree of sequence similarity to
MarR-like proteins (e.g.,
20%
identities with MarR-like proteins of B . subtilis and
Xanthomonas axonopodis) . Despite this finding, there are specific
residues with the protein sequence that are conserved, similar to
those found with members of the SarA protein family (see below) .
We recently solved the winged-helix structure of SarR, a member of
the SarA protein family (24) . The dimeric wing-helix
structure of SarR is a three-domain structure containing a central
helical core and two winged-helix motifs . Each of the winged-helix
motifs encompasses a helix-turn-helix motif (residues 52 to 73) and
a ß-hairpin turn (residues 80 to 95), with both predicted to be
DNA binding domains, based upon sequence alignment (23) .
Interestingly, many of the basic residues are conserved within
members of the SarA protein family, consistent with the notion that
the DNA binding domains might be highly conserved within this protein
family . Indeed, detailed mutational analysis of SarR indicates that
many of the conserved residues (e.g., K52, K80, R82, R88, etc.) are
involved in DNA binding (A . C . Manna et al., unpublished data) . The
structures of MarR in E . coli and SarS in S . aureus
were recently solved and were found to be variants of the dimeric
winged-helix structure, both containing features that are distinct
from SarR (1, 23) . Based on structures
and sequence alignment, we propose to classify the SarA protein
family into three subfamilies: (i) the single-domain proteins (e.g.,
SarR and SarV); (ii) the two-domain proteins (e.g., SarS and SarU);
and (iii) single-domain proteins that are homologous to MarR (e.g.,
MgrA and its homologs) . We predict that members within the same
subfamily likely posses similar structures with common DNA binding
domains and a divergent activation or repression domain .
The transcription of sarA-like genes is highly variable in strain
RN6390 . For instance, sarA, sarR, and mgrA
transcripts are highly expressed in the parental strain, whereas the
transcription of sarU, sarT, and sarS is not
readily detectable under normal laboratory growth conditions . We also
found the sarV gene to be poorly transcribed in the parental
strain . Northern analyses of agr, sarR, sarT,
sarU, and sarS mutants revealed transcription of the
sarV gene to be low in these mutants but at a high level in the
sarA mutant and more so in the mgrA mutant . The effect
of a sarA mutation on sarV transcription was also supported
by similarly increased mean GFPuvr values in the sarV
promoter-gfpuvr fusion analysis in three different
sarA mutant strains in our laboratory (data not shown) . The
finding that the mgrA transcript was elevated in the sarV-supplemented
parent and sarV mutant strains (Fig . 1)
suggested the plausibility of a feedback loop on mgrA
expression by the sarV gene, possibly to fine-tune mgrA
expression . This result was also supported by promoter fusion studies
(mgrA P1 promoter-gfpuvr) in a pair of isogenic sarV
strains, documenting a substantial reduction in mean GFPuvr
fluorescence in the sarV mutant ALC2319 (7,996 ± 750
units per OD650) compared the wild-type RN6390 (11,775 ±
1,000 units per OD650) . However, the applicability of this magnitude
of increased sarV gene dosage to augment mgrA transcription
under in vivo conditions was not defined in this study .
In gel shift studies (Fig . 3), we found that purified SarA
and MgrA proteins formed complexes with the sarV promoter with
fairly high affinity . As protein-DNA complexes are shifted
substantially, we speculate that multiple SarA or MgrA dimers might
interact with each other to bind to the sarV promoter region .
This is based on our modeling data, showing that three SarA dimers
are needed to bind to a single 135-bp agr promoter fragment
(unpublished data) . The specificity of the SarA and MgrA proteins was
determined by DNase I footprinting . Two SarA binding regions (box I
and II) were found within the 268-bp sarV promoter sequence,
locating and overlapping with the –10 and –35 region of the
sarV promoter . Interestingly, each of these two binding regions
resembles the SarA consensus binding motif or the SarA box,
previously reported by our group (10) . In contrast, the MgrA
protein has binding regions outside of the promoter boxes that
are distinct from the SarA binding site . These findings are
consistent with the notion that MgrA and SarA may repress sarV
via divergent mechanisms .
Using DNA gene chip technology, Dunman et al . (11) have
demonstrated that agr and sarA regulate the expression
of over 100 genes, including known virulence factors as well as other
genes involved in metabolism and/or autolysis . Many of the known
virulence genes are controlled by regulators like agr, sarA,
sarA homologs, sae, and arlRS . Inactivation of
the sarV gene has a partial effect on the expression of agr,
lytSR, arlRS, and mgrA, while the effects on
sae, sarA, sarR, sarT, sarS, rot, and
sarU are minimal . However, the physiological relevance and the
mechanism by which the sarV gene product, normally
undetectable or at a very low level in the wild type under laboratory
conditions, acts as a positive regulator (e.g., agr) are not
clear from these studies .
Interestingly, sarV does not have any significant effect on
cell surface proteins such as protein A (spa), FnbA and -B,
and clumping factor A . The regulation of secreted proteins by sarV
entails up-regulation of hla, splA, and aur, concordant
with the notion that sarV regulates agr . The repression of
the sarV gene by mgrA and sarA suggests that the
sarV gene product may play a regulatory role in cell lysis,
since both mgrA and sarA negatively control genes
involved in autolysis, presumably by up-regulating murein hydrolase
activity in respective mutants . Remarkably, lytic assays revealed
that the sarV mutant was more resistant to the lytic effect of
Triton X-100 and penicillin G . Surprisingly, an examination of
regulatory genes (i.e., lytSR and arlRS) known to
repress murein hydrolase activity disclosed down-regulation of these
genes in the sarV mutant (Fig . 5 and
6) . However, other genes (i.e., scdA and atl
[Fig . 6]), positively linked to increase autolysis,
were down-regulated in the sarV mutant, exactly what one would
expect in a strain less prone to autolysis . The expression of lrgB,
a part of the lrgAB operon, which negatively controls the
autolysis process, was substantially higher in the sarV mutant
than in the parent . Whether lrgB may be directly involved in
the lytic-resistant phenotype of the sarV mutant was not
clearly defined in our study . Because atl, scdA, aur,
splA, and scp expression levels are altered in the sarV
mutant, we speculate that sarV might, at least in part, render
S . aureus cells more susceptible to cell lysis via a mechanism
distinct from mgrA or sarA . Recently, a two-component
system, vraSR, has been shown to positively regulate the cell
wall-associated biosynthesis genes . DNA microarray analysis of S .
aureus N315 and a vraSR mutant treated with vancomycin
revealed that vancomycin induces transcription of 139 genes, and
SA2062 (sarV) is one of them, up-regulated about 4.2-fold in
both strains (22) . These data supported our finding that
sarV is an important transcriptional regulator and is involved
in the regulation of the virulence and autolysis genes . Collectively,
these data indicate that sarV impacts negatively upon the
expression of proteases (aur, splA, and scp), an
autolysin (atl), and a gene involved in peptidoglycan
cross-linking (scdA) . These phenotypic alterations would
account for the autolysis-resistant phenotype of the sarV
mutant and the sensitivity of the sarV-hyperexpressing strains
to autolysis . Interestingly, zymogram analysis revealed that the
sarV mutant has a different profile from that of an atl
mutant (Fig . 8), thus indicating that reduced atl
expression alone cannot account for the autolysis-resistant phenotype
of the sarV mutant . The facts that sarV is repressed by
negative regulators of autolysis such as MgrA and SarA and that the
sarV mutant displays a divergent autolytic phenotype from
mgrA and sarA mutants indicate that SarV is likely an
important regulator controlled by mgrA and sarA to
modulate cell lysis .
To further define the precise function of the sarV gene product,
we are in the process of constructing various knockouts of sarV
with other regulatory genes, particularly with sarA and mgrA,
and investigating the molecular interaction of SarV with the
upstream region of its target genes . Analysis of a sarV knockout
in combination with mutations in sarA, mgrA, and other
regulatory genes, coupled with our studies on the structure-function
relationship of these proteins, may provide a clearer understanding
of the mechanism of gene regulation by SarV and other SarA homologs .
By unveiling the precise knowledge of these mechanisms and how
they control virulence gene expression, this might open up new
perspectives for antimicrobial chemotherapy using key inhibitors of
these systems .
The contribution of the S . aureus genome database at The Institute
for Genomic Research, the National Institutes of Health, and at
the University of Oklahoma to this work is gratefully acknowledged .
We thank Brian Bateman for his technical help . We also thank other
members of our lab for their support and encouragement . We thank
Karen Skorupski for critical reading and insightful comments on the
manuscript . We also thank Simon Foster and M . Sugai for providing
strains SH1000 and JC1413, respectively .
This work was supported in part by NIH grants AI37142 and AI50678
to A.L.C .
* Corresponding author . Mailing address: Room No . 205,
Department of Microbiology and Immunology, Dartmouth Medical School, Hanover, NH
03755 . Phone: (603) 650-1310 . Fax: (603) 650-1362 . E-mail: Adhar.C.Manna@Dartmouth.EDU.
- Alekshun, M . N., S . B . Levy, T . R . Mealy, B . A . Seaton, and
J . F . Head. 2001 . The crystal structure of MarR, a regulator of multiple
antibiotic resistance, at 2.3 Å resolution . Nat . Struct . Biol . 8:710-714.
- Arvidson, S., and K . Tegmark. 2001 . Regulation of
virulence determinants in Staphycoccus aureus . Int . J . Med . Microbiol.
291:159-170.
- Ausubel, F . M., R . Brent, R . E . Kingston, D . D . Moore, J . G .
Seidman, J . A . Smith, and K . Struhl. 2000 . Current protocols in molecular
biology . John Wiley & Sons, New York, N.Y.
- Bayles, K . W. 2000 . The bactericidal action of
penicillin: new clues to an unsolved mystery . Trends Microbiol . 8:274-278.
- Boyce, J . M. 1997 . Epidemiology and prevention of
nosocomial infections, p . 309-329 . In K . B . Crossley and G . L . Archer
(ed.), The staphylococci in human diseases, vol . 12 . Churchill Livingston, New
York, N.Y.
- Brunskill, E . W., and K . W . Bayles. 1996 . Identification
of LytSR-regulated genes from Staphylococcus aureus . J . Bacteriol .
178:5810-5812 .
- Brunskill, E . W., B . L . M . de Jonge, and K . W . Bayles.
1997 . The Staphylococcus aureus scdA gene: a novel locus that affects
cell division and morphogenesis . Microbiology 143:2877-2882.
- Cheung, A . L., J . M . Koomey, C . A . Butler, S . J . Projan, and
V . A . Fischetti. 1992 . Regulation of exoprotein expression in
Staphylococcus aureus by a locus (sar) distinct from agr .
Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 89:6462-6466.
- Cheung, A . L., K . A . Schmidt, B . Bateman, and A . C . Manna.
2001 . SarS, a SarA homolog repressible by agr, is an activator of
protein A synthesis in Staphylococcus aureus . Infect . Immun . 69:2448-2455 .
- Chien, Y.-T., A . C . Manna, S . J . Projan, and A . L . Cheung.
1999 . SarA, a global regulator of virulence determinants in Staphylococcus
aureus, binds to a conserved motif essential for sar-dependent gene
regulation . J . Biol . Chem . 274:37169-37176 .
- Dunman, P . M., E . Murphy, S . Haney, D . Palacios, G .
Tucker-Kellogg, S . Wu, E . L . Brown, R . J . Zagursky, D . Shlaes, and S . J .
Projan. 2001 . Transcriptional profiling-based identification of
Staphylococcus aureus genes regulated by agr and/ or sarA
loci . J . Bacteriol . 183:7341-7353 .
- Fournier, B., and D . C . Hooper. 2000 . A new
two-component regulatory system involved in adhesion, autolysis, and
extracellular proteolytic activity of Staphylococcus aureus . J .
Bacteriol . 182:3955-3964 .
- Fournier, B., A . Klier, and G . Rapoport. 2001 . The
two-component system ArlS-ArlR is a regulator of virulence gene expression in
Staphylococcus aureus . Mol . Microbiol . 41:247-261.
- Fujimoto, D . F., and K . W . Bayles. 1998 . Opposing roles
of the Staphylococcus aureus virulence regulators, Agr and Sar, in
Triton X-100- and penicillin-induced autolysis . J . Bacteriol . 180:3724-3726 .
- Giraudo, A . T., A . L . Cheung, and R . Nagel. 1997 . The
sae locus of Staphylococcus aureus controls exoprotein synthesis at
the transcriptional level . Arch . Microbiol . 168:53-58.
- Groicher, K . H., B . A . Firek, D . F . Fujimoto, and K . W .
Bayles. 2000 . The Staphylococcus aureus lrgAB operon modulates
murein hydrolase activity and penicillin tolerance . J . Bacteriol . 182:1794-1801 .
- Ingavale, S . S., W . van Wamel, and A . L . Cheung. 2003 .
Characterization of RAT, an autolysis regulator in Staphylococcus aureus .
Mol . Microbiol . 48:1451-1466.
- Kahl, B., M . Goulian, W . Van Wamel, M . Herrmann, S . Simon,
G . Kaplan, G . Peters, and A . L . Cheung. 2000 . Staphylococcus aureus
RN6390 replicates and induces apoptosis in a pulmonary epithelial cell line .
Infect . Immun . 68:5385-5392 .
- Karlsson, A., and S . Arvidson. 2002 . Variation in
extracellular protease production among clinical isolates of Staphylococcus
aureus due to different levels of expression of the protease repressor
SarA . Infect . Immun . 70:4239-4246 .
- Kornblum, J., B . Kreiswirth, S . J . Projan, H . Ross, and R .
P . Novick. 1990 . Agr: a polycistronic locus regulating exoprotein
synthesis in Staphylococcus aureus, p . 403-420 . In R . P . Novick
(ed.), Molecular biology of the staphylococci . VCH Publishers, New York, N.Y.
- Kuroda, M., T .
|