|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, August 2004, p . 5480-5485, Vol . 186,
No . 16
Tra
Proteins Characteristic of F-Like Type IV Secretion Systems Constitute an
Interaction Group by Yeast Two-Hybrid Analysis
Robin L . Harris and Philip M . Silverman*
Program in Molecular, Cell and Developmental Biology, Oklahoma Medical
Research Foundation, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73104
Received 20 February 2004/ Accepted 13 May 2004
Using yeast two-hybrid screens, we have defined an interaction group
of six Tra proteins encoded by the F plasmid and required by F+
cells to elaborate F pili . The six proteins are TraH, TraF, TraW,
TraU, TrbI, and TrbB . Except for TrbI, these proteins were all
identified as hallmarks of F-like type IV secretion systems (TFSSs),
with no homologues among TFSS genes of P-type or I-type systems (T .
Lawley, W . Klimke, M . Gubbins, and L . Frost, FEMS Microbiol . Lett .
224:1-15, 2003) . Also with the exception of TrbI, which is an inner
membrane protein, the remaining proteins are or are predicted to be
periplasmic . TrbI consists of one membrane-spanning segment near its
N terminus and an 88-residue, hydrophilic domain that extends into
the periplasm . Hence, the proteins of this group probably form a
periplasmic cluster in Escherichia coli . The interaction
network identifies TraH as the most highly connected node, with
two-hybrid links to TrbI, TraU, and TraF . As measured by
transcriptional activation of lacZ, the TrbI-TraH interaction
in Saccharomyces cerevisiae requires the TraH amino acid
segment from residues 193 to 225 . The TraU and TraF interactions are
localized to C-terminal segments of TraH (amino acids 315 to 458 for
TraF and amino acids 341 to 458 for TraU) . The TrbI-TraH interaction
with full-length (less the signal peptide) TraH is weak but increases
40-fold with N-terminal TraH deletions; the first 50 amino acids
appear to be critical for inhibiting TrbI binding in yeast . Previous
studies by others have shown that, with the exception of trbB
mutations, which do not affect the elaboration or function of F
pili under laboratory conditions, a mutation in any of the other
genes in this interaction group alters the number or length
distribution of F pili . We propose a model whereby one function of
the TraH interaction group is to control F-pilus extension and
retraction .
Type IV secretion systems (TFSSs) comprise a broadly distributed
group of molecular machines that function to secrete macromolecules
from gram-negative bacteria into other bacterial or eukaryotic cells
(3, 4) . These systems are responsible for
the pathogenic effects of some bacterial species (4)
and contribute to the dissemination of antibiotic resistance genes to
pathogens of humans and domestic animals (37) .
Several classes of TFSSs are distinguishable by sequence comparisons
(3, 6, 7,
26), and these systems may have arisen more than once during
bacterial evolution .
TFSSs typically mediate DNA transfer (conjugation) (5,
14, 21) . This activity has been
broadly divided into two experimentally separable stages . The first
is the establishment of secure cell-cell contacts, and the second is
DNA transfer per se . These two stages are linked by coupling
proteins, which are membrane or membrane-associated complexes
responsible for substrate recognition and presentation to a channel
or pore complex that spans the cell envelope (4,
27, 35) . Individual functions associated
with the first stage are designated Mpf (mating pair formation)
functions and the corresponding proteins are Mpf proteins; proteins
and functions associated with the second stage are designated Dtr
(donor transfer replication) . Most TFSS genes fall into the Mpf class
(14, 17) . However, these
functional assignments are often based on mutant phenotypes . For
proteins that function at more than one stage, null mutations would
identify only the earliest stage . For this reason, the Mpf
designation does not preclude a function at later stages of conjugal
DNA transfer .
One feature common to all conjugal DNA transfer systems of gram-negative
bacteria is the presence of conjugative pili (21,
32) . These surface filaments function in the
earliest stages of conjugation, when donor and recipient cells make
initial contacts that eventually lead to DNA transfer . Insofar as
they have been examined, conjugative pili are repeats of one
quantitatively predominant subunit (12,
32) . These subunits and the corresponding filaments are
designated according to the conjugal DNA transfer system of which
they are a part, e.g., F pili(n), RP4 pili(n), T pili(n), etc .
Notwithstanding their apparent structural simplicity, the formation
of conjugative pili requires numerous Mpf proteins . For the 25-gene
tra system borne by the F plasmid, a mutation in any of 16
genes abolishes the formation of extended F pili or alters F-pilus
length or number distribution (14) .
After initial contacts, F pili retract (8,
29), such that DNA transfer occurs primarily, if not exclusively,
between cells that are firmly joined at their surfaces (11,
25, 33) . Retraction also occurs
when filamentous DNA bacteriophages bind to the F-pilus tip (22) .
It is unclear how widely distributed retraction is among TFSSs other
than the F-like group .
Type IV Mpf systems typically include core components that are
recognizable by sequence similarities among classes (3,
26) . Other components, however, appear to be class
specific (26) . The TFSSs encoded by F and the
F-like R factors include several such components . Five of the 16
F-plasmid-encoded Tra proteins required for the formation of F pili
or for normal F-pilus number and length distributions appear not to
have homologues in TFSSs outside of the F and F-like families (26) .
These are TraF, TraH, TraW, TrbC, and TraU . There are no data
regarding physical interactions among these proteins, but genetic
data suggest that they have a common function(s) . A mutation in
traF, traH, traW, or trbC abolished the
ability of F+ cells to form extended F pili that were
visible by electron microscopy (14) . However, TraF, TraH,
and TraW mutants retained significant sensitivity to filamentous
bacteriophages that bind to the F-pilus tip (1),
suggesting that these Tra proteins are required for F-pilus
extension . (The trbC mutant could not be tested.) Mutations in
traU also reduced the number of F pili per cell and the mean
F-pilus length, but not as drastically as mutations in the other
genes (31) . (Such mutations reduced DNA donor
activity more than expected from the reduction in F-pili, suggesting
that TraU affects multiple stages of conjugation [31].)
Here we show by yeast two-hybrid analyses that TraH, TraF, TraW,
TraU, and TrbB are components of the same Tra protein interaction
group . An additional member of this group is TrbI . While trbB
mutations had no effect on F-pilus functions in otherwise tra+
cells (24), trbI mutants were reported to
elaborate unusually long F pili (28) . The
properties of mutants with mutations in individual components of this
interaction group suggest a role for the group in regulating F-pilus
retraction and extension .
Strains and plasmids. Saccharomyces cerevisiae strain
Y190 (MATa gal4 gal80 his3 trp1-901 ade2-101
ura3-52 leu2-3,112 Cyhr GAL1::lacZ@URA3
GAL1::HIS3@LYS2) and plasmids pACTII and pAS1CYH2
were originally obtained from Steven Elledge, Baylor University
College of Medicine (10) . Bait and prey libraries
derived from plasmid pTG801 (16) and constructed
in plasmids pAS1CYH2 and pACTII, respectively, were described
previously (18) . Specific bait plasmids were constructed
by PCR amplification of tra segments from JCFL0 (F' lac+
tra+) (traH and traF) or pTG801 (traU,
traW, and trbI), as described by Harris et al . (19) .
The primers used for each such construct are shown in Table
1 . PCR products were purified from agarose gels by
centrifugation of frozen (liquid N2) gel segments (10 min
at 13,000 x g) through siliconized
glass wool, digested with NcoI and BamHI, and cloned into pAS1CYH2
digested with the same two enzymes . All constructs were tested alone
for transcriptional activation; only the traF construct gave
low and variable levels of activation under some conditions (see
Results) .
| TABLE 1 . Primers used to amplify tra sequences of bait plasmids
|
|
pAS1CYH2 traH deletions were isolated from a pAS1CYH2tra fragment
library (18) by colony lift hybridization . Radioactive
traH DNA was obtained by random primer labeling (13)
with [ -32P]CTP .
DNA was obtained by PCR amplification from JCFL0 with the forward
primer 5' GCAAGAATGATGCCACG (tra nucleotides [nt] 18024 to 18040)
and the reverse primer 3' TCATTCACAGCGTGCTG (tra nt 19410 to
19374) . (Numbering of the tra nucleotides was from reference
15.) The pAS1CYH2tra library was plated at
60,000 CFU/plate . Of 360,000 colonies screened, 85 potential positive
colonies were isolated and sequenced . Several of these were selected
based on the extent of the deletions and, where necessary, were
frame shifted to correspond to the GAL4 sequence of pAS1CYH2 by a
fill-in reaction catalyzed by the Klenow fragment of DNA polymerase I
or by mung bean nuclease . In all cases, a polypeptide of the
appropriate size could be detected in yeast extracts analyzed by
Western blotting with antibodies against the hemagglutinin (HA)
epitope included in the GAL4 segment of pAS1CYH2 (18) .
Media and growth conditions. Yeast extract-peptone-dextrose
and synthetic complete dropout media were described previously (23) .
Yeast strains were routinely grown at 30°C with aeration, and growth
was monitored by total cell counts in a hemocytometer or by measuring
the optical density at 600 nm . For interaction screens, yeast
colonies appearing within 5 days at 30°C on Leu– His–
plates containing 40 mM 3-aminotriazole (added to reduce HIS3
[imidazole glycerol phosphate dehydratase] activity) were considered
to be His+, and those yielding a blue color upon colony
lifting within 18 h at 41°C were considered to be LacZ+ .
Escherichia coli was routinely cultured in Luria-Bertani medium
at 37°C with aeration . Growth was monitored by measuring the
optical density at 600 nm . Ampicillin was added, when necessary, at
100 µg/ml .
Methods. Yeast transformations were carried out by the
lithium acetate-polyethylene glycol method, as described previously (23);
transformation frequencies with the pACTtra library were
generally 104 to 105 Leu+ Trp+
colonies/µg of DNA . Plasmid DNAs were prepared from Zymolyase-treated
yeast cells (23) and introduced into E . coli
by electroporation . Otherwise, E . coli cells were transformed
by the CaCl2 method .
Beta-galactosidase activities in yeast were measured with chlorophenyl-red-ß-D-galactopyranoside
(CPRG; Boehringer-Mannheim) essentially as described previously
(10) . Cells in 5 ml of culture at an optical density at 600
nm of 0.6 to 0.8 were collected by sedimentation, suspended in
1 ml of H buffer (10), permeabilized with sodium dodecyl
sulfate and CHCl3, and assayed . Chlorophenyl-red released by
hydrolysis was measured as the absorbance at 574 nm .
Western blot analyses of yeast proteins were performed as described
previously (18) .
TraH and TraF interact in yeast two-hybrid assay. TraH is one
of several periplasmic Tra proteins that are required for the
elaboration of F pili (14) . We used traH as bait in
a two-hybrid screen of a library of tra fragments derived from
plasmid pTG801 which includes all of the F plasmid tra genes
required to elaborate functional F pili and only those genes,
with a few exceptions (16) . The traH gene comprises
458 codons, with a predicted 24-amino-acid leader peptide (15) .
The bait plasmid included traH codons 24 to 458 . Of 250,000
Leu+ Trp+ transformants containing both the bait and prey
plasmids, 45 were His+ LacZ+ as well,
indicating transcriptional activation . Forty-four of these were
sequenced, of which 40 contained traF segments (Table
2) . The remaining prey plasmids contained traC,
traB, or traL . The traC and traB inserts were
in frame with respect to the upstream GAL4 sequence, whereas
the traL insert was not .
| TABLE 2 . TraH-TraF interaction by yeast two-hybrid screen
|
|
TraF is itself a periplasmic protein of 247 amino acids with a
predicted 19-amino-acid leader peptide (15, 38) .
The 5' termini of the traF fragments contained in the 40 prey
plasmids were all within the segment comprising traF codons
R64 to W88 . The segment R64-W88 might border a region required for
protein folding in yeast or might be amino acids that are directly
required for the TraF-TraH interaction .
We next used a traF bait, comprising traF codons 19 to 247,
to screen the tra fragment library . We performed two separate
screens, which combined yielded His+ LacZ+
transformants at a frequency of 5.5 x
10–3, or 30-fold higher than that in the traH
screen (Table 2) . Only two tra genes were identified
in both screens, among 40 total sequences . Twelve contained
traH segments, all in frame, and four contained traC sequences,
with three in frame . Several other tra genes were identified
in one screen or the other, but not both, along with reverse
tra and unidentified, possibly vector, sequences (Table 2) .
The high fraction of questionable positive results in the screen
TraF is unusual in our experience . While we have no definitive
explanation, we observed unusually variable levels of transcriptional
activation in yeast cells containing both the traF bait and
random prey plasmids . In our screens, we selected those with higher
levels, estimated from the intensity of the blue color in colony
lifts for ß-galactosidase activity, but we could easily have chosen a
significant number of false-positive transformants . For this reason,
we are inclined for the time being to credit only the traH
isolates, both because they still constituted nearly a third of the
total sequences and because the traH screen identified
exclusively traF preys . Also note that TraC is a cytoplasmic,
peripheral membrane protein in tra+ cells (34),
whereas TraF is periplasmic (38) . These different
cellular locations make it improbable, though certainly not
impossible, that the TraC interaction is functionally significant .
In contrast to the results with traF preys isolated with the
traH bait, the 5' end points of the 12 traH preys were
distributed throughout the central half of the coding region, from
F135 to T326 . These results suggest that a segment of TraH between
T326 and the C terminus of the molecule, L458, is sufficient
for TraF binding in yeast (Fig . 1) . In a reciprocal
experiment, we found that yeast cells with a bait plasmid containing
traH encoding amino acids 259 to 458 (traH259-458
and a prey plasmid containing traF75-247 were His+
and LacZ+ (data not shown), again suggesting that a
C-terminal segment of TraH contains a TraF binding site .
|
FIG . 1 . Interaction map of TraH . Segments required for two-hybrid
interactions between TraH (458 amino acids) and other Tra proteins were
derived from sequence analyses of prey plasmids and ß-galactosidase
assays . The TraH leader peptide (LP; amino acids 1 to 24) is also shown .
TrbIi, segment required for inhibition of interaction with
TrbI in yeast.
|
|
Interactions involving TrbI. An additional interaction
involving TraH was detected with bait plasmids lacking 5'-terminal
traH codons beyond the 24 codons encoding the TraH signal
peptide . We identified these deletions by colony hybridization with
the bait plasmid library and by DNA sequence analysis, as described
in Materials and Methods . Surprisingly, when these deletions were
used in small-scale screens of the tra fragment prey library,
the predominant prey in His+ LacZ+ yeast
transformants was TrbI, a 128-amino-acid inner membrane protein in
E . coli (28) . A larger-scale screen with one
of these deletions, traH199-458, yielded 16 trbI bait
plasmids of 18 that were sequenced (Table 3) . The
overall frequency of positive transformants was fivefold higher in
this screen than in the traH19-458 screen (Table
2), perhaps explaining why no traF preys
were identified among the 18 that were sequenced from the traH199-458
screen . Most of the trbI segments identified in this screen
contained the entire gene, which at 128 codons is smaller than the
mean fragment length of 1 kb for the prey library (18) .
Four segments of the 16, however, began at codons N32, V35, I39, and
R41 . All of these are within or, in the case of R41, immediately
adjacent to a putative membrane-spanning segment (codons W18 to V40 [15]) .
Hence, the interaction domain of TrbI for TraH is within the segment
from R41 to the C-terminal P128 . This region is relatively
hydrophilic and extends into the periplasm (34) .
| TABLE 3 . TrbI-TraH interaction by yeast two-hybrid screen
|
|
To explain why no trbI preys were identified among the 44 that
were sequenced from the traH24-458 screen (Table
2), we considered the possibility that an N-terminal segment of
TraH inhibits the TrbI-TraH interaction in yeast . To test this, we
measured ß-galactosidase activity in yeast strains containing
different traH bait plasmids and the same trbI5-128
prey . This experiment confirmed that ß-galactosidase activity
increased about 40-fold when an N-terminal segment of TraH,
between A21 and L137, was deleted from TraH (Fig . 2) . A
further deletion of TraH to G193 had no effect on the activity, which
remained at a relatively high level, but deletion to A225 or
further essentially abolished activity . These results indicate that
the TraH segment from G193 to A225 is required for the binding of
TrbI in the yeast two-hybrid assay and that this binding is inhibited
by an N-terminal segment of TraH . Whether or not this also occurs in
E . coli remains to be determined . The putative TrbI binding
segment of TraH is predicted to be very hydrophilic, with 12 charged
and 8 polar amino acids (Fig . 2) . It is therefore,
in all likelihood, solvent exposed and hence available for
protein-protein interactions .
|
FIG . 2 . TrbI interaction domain and inhibitory segment of TraH .
Transcriptional activation (LacZ activity) in cells containing a trbI5-128
prey and the indicated traH bait plasmids shows the inhibitory
effect of the N-terminal segment D24-L137 and the requirement for the
segment G193-A225 . The figure also indicates the five traH preys
isolated with a trbI bait and the predicted amino acid sequence
of the hydrophilic segment containing the TrbI binding site . LP, leader
peptide.
|
|
We also performed a two-hybrid screen with a trbI1-128 bait
plasmid . We sequenced each of the 31 His+ LacZ+
transformants (Table 3) that we obtained .
Twenty-five of these carried trbI, indicating that TrbI
segments interact in yeast . None of the trbI segments of these
prey plasmids lacked more than the first 10 codons . We infer that the
TrbI-TrbI interaction domain lies close to the N terminus of the
molecule and is conceivably the hydrophobic segment beginning at
codon W18 and ending at codon V40 (15) . Thus, TrbI
interacts with other TrbI monomers through an N-terminal putative
membrane-spanning segment (34) and with TraH
through its periplasmic domain .
Five of the 31 preys contained traH (Table 3) . Three
of these contained the same segment, encompassing codons 74 through
233 . One encompassed codons 76 to 225 and one encompassed codons
74 to 230 . Two features of these segments are consistent with
previous results . First, all five lacked N-terminal codons . Given
that codons 1 to 24 encode the TraH signal peptide, the data suggest
that TraH amino acids 25 to 75 are sufficient to inhibit TraH binding
to TrbI in yeast (Fig . 1) . Second, all five traH
isolates included the region encoding G193 to A225, which is
suggested to contain the binding site for TrbI (Fig . 1) .
We were unable to detect any ß-galactosidase activity at all (<0.05
U) in yeast cells containing the trbI5-128 prey and a bait
plasmid with a 3'-terminal traH deletion that still encoded an
intact N-terminal domain (traH15-330) (Fig .
2) . In a LacZ colony lift assay, this segment as well as that
comprising TraH amino acids 253 to 458 still interacted with
TraF (data not shown), suggesting that these segments were not merely
misfolded in yeast .
The differences in activity with different traH bait constructs
cannot be attributed to different GAL4-TraH fusion protein levels .
As measured by Western blotting against the HA epitope common
to all of the fusion proteins, the levels of inactive fusion proteins
(TraH225-458 and TraH15-330) (Fig . 2)
were no less than those of active fusion proteins (TraH193-458
and TraH199-458) (Fig . 3) . Moreover, it
seems unlikely that the different transcriptional activation levels
of cells with GAL4-TraH199-458, which was active in TrbI
binding (Table 3), and cells with GAL4-TraH225-458,
which was inactive (Fig . 2), can be explained by effects
of the 26-amino-acid difference between the two fusion proteins
on folding, nuclear transport, or other factors that are not
directly related to transcriptional activation .
|
FIG . 3 . Levels of GAL4-TraH fusion proteins in yeast . Yeast cells with
segments of traH fused to the GAL4 domain of pAS1CYH2 were
assayed for fusion protein levels by Western blotting with antibodies
against the HA epitope of the GAL4 polypeptide segment (18) .
The range of numbers under each lane denotes the TraH amino acids
contained in the corresponding fusion . Full-length TraH is 458 amino
acids long (13).
|
|
Interactions involving TraU and TraW. We performed additional
two-hybrid screens to define new Tra protein interaction groups .
Unexpectedly, two of these screens expanded the TraH/TraF/TrbI group .
The first utilized traU48-330 as bait (15,
31) . Positives were obtained at a frequency of 5.6
x 10–4 (Table 4) .
Of those that were sequenced, 67% carried in-frame traH
segments; no other tra gene was represented more than once .
The 5' termini of the traH segments were all between codons
T265 and V343 (of 458 codons), indicating that TraU interacts with a
C-terminal segment of TraH, as does TraF (Fig . 1) .
| TABLE 4 . TraU and TraW interactions by yeast two-hybrid screen
|
|
We also performed a screen with a bait plasmid containing traW1-210
(15, 28) . This screen yielded
positive transformants at a frequency of 5.1
x 10–4 (Table 4) .
Of those prey plasmids that were sequenced, 86% carried either of two
tra genes, trbB and traU, at similar frequencies
(Table 4) . While trbB insertion alleles had
no effect on F-pilus-related functions under laboratory conditions (24),
the trbB gene products encoded by the F and R100 plasmids are
90% identical (1), suggesting that there is some
evolutionary pressure for conservation . The data showing that the F
trbB gene product is part of a Tra protein interaction group
also suggest a function for TrbB, albeit one either not required in
routine assays for conjugal DNA transfer or donor-specific
bacteriophage sensitivity or for which another Tra protein is
redundant (24, 26) .
The data presented here establish a new interaction group among
F-plasmid Tra proteins required for the elaboration of F pili . This
group consists of six proteins: they are TraH, TraF, TrbI, TraU,
TraW, and TrbB . Except for TrbI, the other proteins of this group are
or are predicted to be periplasmic (14) . TrbI is
an inner membrane protein but has a large periplasmic domain (34) .
Hence, interactions among the six proteins are consistent with their
cellular localization .
The two-hybrid data identify TraH as the most highly connected
member of the group, with two-hybrid links to TrbI, TraF, and TraU
(Fig . 4) . At 434 amino acids, periplasmic TraH is also
the largest protein in this interaction group . These data suggest
a central role for TraH in the group’s function(s) .
|
FIG . 4 . Protein interactions of the TraV/TraK/TraB and
TraH/TraF/TraW/TraU/TrbI/TrbB interaction groups . Arrows connect
proteins that were shown to interact by yeast two-hybrid assays;
arrowheads point to the prey . The interaction map was overlaid on the
intracellular location of each protein in E . coli, as described
previously (14) . The TraV/TraK/TraB data are from
reference 19; other data are from the present
communication.
|
|
Of the six Tra proteins in the TraH interaction group, five (TraH,
TraF, TraW, TraU, and TrbB) were reported by Lawley et al . (26)
to be characteristic of F-like TFSSs, insofar as sequence database
searches returned no homologues among P-type or I-type TFSSs (26) .
Conversely, using virB query sequences, Cao and Saier found no
homologues among F-plasmid tra genes for virB6-virB9 or
virB11 (3) . They did find tra homologues of
virB2-5 and virB10, but none were among the genes
found by Lawley et al . to be characteristic of F-like tra
systems (3, 26) . Cao and Saier attributed
this to incomplete sequencing of the F tra region (3),
but perhaps a more plausible hypothesis is that gram-negative TFSSs,
at least in part, arose more than once during bacterial evolution .
A mutation in traH, traF, traW, traU, or trbI
altered the F-pilus length or number distribution, suggesting that
there are functional relationships among the corresponding Tra
proteins . (The numbers of F pili per cell and F-pilus length
distribution could amount to the same thing, since factors leading to
shorter F pili might favor filaments that are too short to be visible
by electron microscopy . This would be scored as a reduction in the
number of F pili per cell [2, 9].)
The effects of mutations in traH, traF, and traW
were similar (reference 14 and references therein) .
Each abolished the formation of F pili that were visible by
electron microscopy of negatively stained cells . None affected the
amount of membrane F pilin (30) . All reduced DNA donor
activity by several orders of magnitude and all were resistant to
donor-specific bacteriophages by a plaque assay (14) .
However, by a more sensitive transduction assay, traH, traF,
and traW mutants retained significant levels (1 to 100%) of
sensitivity to a filamentous DNA bacteriophage that binds to the
F-pilus tip (1) . In comparison, an amber mutation
in traA or a mutation in any of several other tra genes reduced
phage sensitivity by at least 6 orders of magnitude, to an undetectable
level (1) . The simplest interpretation of these data is
that traH, traF, and traW mutants are defective
in F-pilus extension, such that mutant cells have unusually short
filaments that are still able to bind bacteriophage at their tips .
Amber and insertion mutations in traU also had the effect of
reducing both the number and length distributions of F pili, though
not as drastically (31), whereas trbI
mutants were reported to have unusually long F pili (28) .
In addition to evolutionary and functional data, the data presented
here add a third line of evidence linking TraH, TraF, TraW, and
TraU: all four proteins are components of a yeast two-hybrid
interaction group, along with TrbI . Three independent lines of
evidence thus converge on the hypothesis that these proteins function
together in F+ strains of E . coli and that the function
of the group is either unique to F-like TFSSs, or if common to
other TFSS classes, arose independently in F-like systems . One
possibility for the main function of the TraH group arose from
conclusions reached by Sowa et al . (36); to account for
the difficulty they encountered in exhausting the pool of membrane
F pilin, they proposed that F-pilus extension and retraction
alternate stochastically . The Tra protein interaction group defined
here could function as a switch to regulate F-pilus extension and
retraction cycles . TraW, TraF, TraH, and to a lesser degree, TraU
would be pro-extension components, since a mutation in any of these
genes leads to the formation of unusually short F pili and/or fewer F
pili per cell (14, 28, 31) .
(TrbB and TraF have been suggested to have overlapping functions [26],
which might explain why trbB mutations had no effect in a traF+
background [24].) TrbI would be pro-retraction, insofar
as trbI mutants have been reported to elaborate unusually long
F pili (28) . Given that two-hybrid data cannot
reveal interaction dynamics, this model will have to be tested in
E . coli, in which the complete F-pilus assembly system can be
analyzed (16) .
A summary of this and our previous work on Tra protein interactions
related to F-pilus formation is shown in Fig . 4 . The
TraB/TraK/TraV interaction group (19) consists of
proteins with homologues, or at least obvious functional equivalents,
among other TFSSs (20, 26) . The
TraH interaction group described here consists of Tra proteins that
are characteristic of F and F-like systems (1,
26) . How these interaction groups function in F-pilus
formation and perhaps other stages of conjugal DNA transfer and
especially whether the TraH and TraV/TraK/TraB groups interact with
each other are topics of immediate interest .
We are indebted to Veronica Hombs for excellent technical assistance .
This work was supported by National Science Foundation grants
MCB-9900533 and MCB-0212365 and by funds provided by the Oklahoma
Medical Research Foundation . P.M.S . acknowledges support from the
Marjorie Nichlos Chair in Medical Research .
* Corresponding author . Mailing address: Program in Molecular,
Cell and Developmental Biology, Oklahoma Medical Research Foundation, Oklahoma
City, OK 73104 . Phone: (405) 271-7663 . Fax: (405) 271-3153 . E-mail: silvermanp@omrf.ouhsc.edu.
- Anthony, K., W . Klimke, J . Manchak, and L . Frost. 1999 .
Comparison of proteins involved in pilus synthesis and mating pair
stabilization from the related plasmids F and R100-1: insights into the
mechanism of conjugation . J . Bacteriol . 181:5149-5159 .
- Biebricher, C., and E.-M . Duker. 1984 . F and type I
piliation of Escherichia coli . J . Gen . Microbiol . 130:951-957.
- Cao, T., and M . Saier. 2001 . Conjugal type IV
macromolecular transfer systems of gram-negative bacteria: organismal
distribution, structural constraints and evolutionary conclusions .
Microbiology 147:3201-3214.
- Cascales, E., and P . Christie. 2003 . The versatile
bacterial type IV secretion systems . Nat . Rev . Microbiol . 1:137-149.
- Christie, P. 1997 . Agrobacterium tumefaciens
T-complex transport apparatus: a paradigm for a new family of multifunctional
transporters in Eubacteria . J . Bacteriol . 179:3085-3094.
- Christie, P., and J . Vogel. 2000 . Bacterial type IV
secretion: conjugation systems adapted to deliver effector molecules to host
cells . Trends Microbiol . 8:354-360.
- Covacci, A., J . Telford, G . Del Giudice, J . Parsonnet, and R .
Rappuoli. 1999 . Helicobacter pylori virulence and genetic
geography . Science 284:1328-1333 .
- Curtiss, R., III. 1969 . Bacterial conjugation . Annu . Rev .
Microbiol . 23:69-127.
- Curtiss, R., III, L . Caro, D . Allison, and D . Stallions.
1969 . Early stages of conjugation in Escherichia coli . J . Bacteriol .
100:1091-1104.
- Durfee, T., K . Becherer, P.-L . Chen, S.-L . Yeh, Y . Yang, A .
Kilburn, W.-H . Lee, and S . Elledge. 1993 . The retinoblastoma protein
associates with the protein phosphatase type 1 catalytic subunit . Genes Dev.
7:555-569.
- Durrenberger, M., W . Villiger, and T . H . Bachi. 1991 .
Conjugational junctions: morphology of specific contacts in conjugating
Escherichia coli bacteria . J . Struct . Biol . 107:146-156.
- Eisenbrandt, R., M . Kalkum, E . Lai, R . Lurz, C . Kado, and E .
Lanka. 1999 . Conjugative pili of IncP plasmids, and the Ti plasmid T pilus
are composed of cyclic subunits . J . Biol . Chem . 274:22548-22555 .
- Feinberg, A., and B . Vogelstein. 1983 . A technique for
radiolabeling DNA restriction fragments to high specific activity . Anal .
Biochem . 132:6-13.
- Firth, N., K . Ippen-Ihler, and R . Skurray. 1996 .
Structure and function of the F factor and mechanism of conjugation, p .
2377-2401 . In F . C . Neidhardt et al . (ed.), Escherichia coli and
Salmonella: cellular and molecular biology, 2nd ed . ASM Press,
Washington, D.C.
- Frost, L., K . Ippen-Ihler, and R . Skurray. 1994 .
Analysis of the sequence and gene products of the transfer region of the F sex
factor . Microbiol . Rev . 58:162-210.
- Grossman, T., and P . Silverman. 1989 . Structure and
function of conjugative pili: inducible synthesis of functional F pili by
Escherichia coli K-12 containing a lac-tra operon fusion . J .
Bacteriol . 171:650-656.
- Haase, J., R . Lurz, A . Grahn, D . Bamford, and E . Lanka.
1995 . Bacterial conjugation mediated by plasmid RP4: RSF1010 mobilization,
donor-specific phage propagation, and pilus production require the same Tra2
core components of a proposed DNA transport complex . J . Bacteriol . 177:4779-4791.
- Harris, R., A . Sholl, M . Conrad, M . Dresser, and P .
Silverman. 1999 . Interaction between the F plasmid TraA (F-pilin) and TraQ
proteins . Mol . Microbiol . 34:780-791.
- Harris, R., V . Hombs, and P . Silverman. 2001 . Evidence
that F-plasmid proteins TraV, TraK, and TraB assemble into an
envelope-spanning structure in Escherichia coli . Mol . Microbiol . 42:757-766.
- Harris, R . L., and P . M . Silverman. 2002 . Role of
internal cysteines in the function, localization, and reactivity of the TraV
outer membrane lipoprotein encoded by the F plasmid . J . Bacteriol . 184:3126-3129 .
- Ippen-Ihler, K., and S . Maneewannakul. 1991 . Conjugation
among enteric bacteria: mating systems dependent on expression of pili, p .
35-69 . In M . Dworkin (ed.), Microbial cell-cell interactions . ASM
Press, Washington, D.C.
- Jacobson, A. 1972 . Role of F pili in the penetration of
bacteriophage f1 . J . Virol . 10:835-843.
- Kaiser, C., S . Michaelis, and A . Mitchell. 1994 . Methods
in yeast genetics . Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor,
N.Y.
- Kathir, P., and K . Ippen-Ihler. 1991 . Construction and
characterization of derivatives carrying insertion mutations in F plasmid
transfer region genes trbA, artA, traQ, and trbB . Plasmid 26:40-54.
- Lawley, T., G . Gordon, A . Wright, and D . Taylor. 2002 .
Bacterial conjugative transfer: visualization of successful mating pairs and
plasmid establishment in live Escherichia coli . Mol . Microbiol . 44:947-956.
- Lawley, T., W . Klimke, M . Gubbins, and L . Frost. 2003 . F
factor conjugation is a true type IV secretion system . FEMS Microbiol . Lett.
224:1-15.
- Llosa, M., F . Gomis-Ruth, M . Coll, and F . de la Cruz.
2002 . Bacterial conjugation: a two-step mechanism for DNA transport . Mol .
Microbiol . 45:1-8.
- Maneewannakul, S., K . Maneewannakul, and K . Ippen-Ihler.
1992 . Characterization, localization, and sequence of F transfer region
products: the pilus assembly gene product TraW and a new product, TrbI . J .
Bacteriol . 174:5567-5574.
- Marvin, D., and B . Hohn. 1969 . Filamentous bacterial
viruses . Bacteriol . Rev . 33:172-209.
- Moore, D., B . Sowa, and K . Ippen-Ihler. 1981 . The effect
of tra mutations on the F-pilin polypeptide . Mol . Gen . Genet . 184:260-264.
- Moore, D., K . Maneewannakul, S . Maneewannakul, J . Wu, K .
Ippen-Ihler, and D . Bradley. 1990 . Characterization of the F-plasmid
transfer gene traU . J . Bacteriol . 172:4263-4270.
- Paranchych, W., and L . Frost. 1988 . The physiology and
biochemistry of pili . Adv . Microb . Physiol . 29:53-114.
- Samuels, A., E . Lanka, and J . Davies. 2000 . Conjugative
junctions in RP4-mediated mating of Escherichia coli . J . Bacteriol .
182:2709-2715 .
- Schandel, K., M . Muller, and R . Webster. 1992 .
Localization of TraC, a protein involved in assembly of the F conjugative
pilus . J . Bacteriol . 174:3800-3806.
- Schroder, G., S . Krause, E . Zechner, B . Traxler, H.-J . Yeo,
R . Lurz, G . Waksman, and E . Lanka. 2002 . TraG-like proteins of DNA
transfer systems and of the Helicobacter pylori type IV secretion
system: inner membrane gate for exported substrates? J . Bacteriol . 184:2767-2779 .
- Sowa, B., D . Moore, and K . Ippen-Ihler. 1983 . Physiology
of F-pilin synthesis and utilization . J . Bacteriol . 153:962-968.
- Teuber, M. 1999 . Spread of antibiotic resistance with
food-borne pathogens . Cell Mol . Life Sci . 56:755-763.
- Wu, J., P . Kathir, and K . Ippen-Ihler. 1988 . The product
of the F plasmid transfer operon gene, traF, is a periplasmic protein .
J. Bacteriol . 170:3633-3639.
Free Online Full-text Article
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
|