|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, June 2004, p . 3525-3530, Vol . 186,
No . 11
Structure of the DNA-SspC Complex: Implications for DNA Packaging, Protection,
and Repair in Bacterial Spores
Daphna Frenkiel-Krispin,1 Rinat Sack,1 Joseph
Englander,1 Eyal Shimoni,1 Miriam Eisenstein,2
Esther Bullitt,3 Rachel Horowitz-Scherer,4 Christopher S .
Hayes,5,
Peter Setlow,5 Abraham Minsky,1 and Sharon Grayer Wolf2*
Organic Chemistry,1 Chemical Research Support, The Weizmann
Institute of Science, Rehovot 76100, Israel,2 Department of
Physiology & Biophysics, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston,
Massachusetts 02118,3 Department of Biology, University of
Massachusetts, Amherst, Massachusetts 01003,4 Department of
Biochemistry, University of Connecticut Health Center, Farmington, Connecticut
060325
Received 21 December 2003/ Accepted 20 February 2004
Bacterial spores have long been recognized as the sturdiest known
life forms on earth, revealing extraordinary resistance to a broad
range of environmental assaults . A family of highly conserved
spore-specific DNA-binding proteins, termed
/ß-type
small, acid-soluble spore proteins (SASP), plays a major role
in mediating spore resistance . The mechanism by which these proteins
exert their protective activity remains poorly understood, in part
due to the lack of structural data on the DNA-SASP complex . By using
cryoelectron microscopy, we have determined the structure of the
helical complex formed between DNA and SspC, a characteristic member
of the
/ß-type
SASP family . The protein is found to fully coat the DNA, forming
distinct protruding domains, and to modify DNA structure such that it
adopts a 3.2-nm pitch . The protruding SspC motifs allow for
interdigitation of adjacent DNA-SspC filaments into a tightly packed
assembly of nucleoprotein helices . By effectively sequestering DNA
molecules, this dense assembly of filaments is proposed to enhance
and complement DNA protection obtained by DNA saturation with the
/ß-type
SASP .
Bacterial spores have recently been brought to public attention,
following the use of these organisms for warfare purposes and the
exciting report of viable 250-million-year-old spores (35) .
Both developments highlight the unmatched ability of dormant
spores to endure highly adverse environments and to remain viable for
extremely long periods . Because spores may well be able to survive
the loss of practically the entire complement of any specific enzyme
(32), their unique survival properties primarily
reflect their ability to preserve their DNA in an undamaged form .
Such effective long-term DNA preservation is intriguing, because
spores usually carry only one copy of their genome (2)
and hence are unable to promote DNA repair based on homologous
recombination . Efficient repair processes are also precluded in
dormant spores by the absence of high-energy compounds such as
nucleoside triphosphates and the virtually complete inactivation of
enzymes within the spore core (32) . Evidently, spore DNA
durability relies mainly upon a passive, physical, and continuous
protection, rather than on ongoing enzymatic repair processes,
although DNA repair during spore germination can be important in
spore survival in some conditions (28) .
Spore DNA protection from damaging effects of desiccation, heat,
oxidizing agents, and UV irradiation has been shown to derive
primarily from a group of
/ß-type
small acid-soluble proteins (SASPs) (60 to 75 residues), termed
/ß-type
SASP, which bind DNA in a nonspecific manner (5,
20, 29, 32) .
These
/ß-type
SASPs accumulate during sporulation of Bacillus and
Clostridium species to levels that are high enough to saturate
spore DNA, and in all Bacillus species yet examined two
proteins make up
80%
of the
/ß-type
SASP pool (32) . The critical role of
/ß-type
SASP in mediating spore DNA protection has been indicated by in vitro
studies, as well as by the finding that spores lacking these
proteins (termed
–ß–
spores) are much more sensitive to DNA damage than are wild-type
spores (16, 32) . The attenuated
resistance of
–ß–
spores can be restored if these spores are provided with sufficient
levels of any major or minor
/ß-type
SASP, thus indicating that these proteins can complement each other .
Indeed, amino acid sequences of all
/ß-type
SASPs are highly conserved both within and between species (32,
33) .
Although
/ß-type
SASPs and their DNA-binding properties have been extensively studied,
the actual mechanism by which these proteins confer DNA resistance
remains poorly understood, mainly due to the lack of detailed
structural data on DNA-SASP complexes . Circular dichroism
spectroscopy of
/ß-type
SASPs indicated that although these proteins adopt a random
coil configuration in the absence of DNA, their secondary structure
is dominated by
-helices
upon binding to double-stranded DNA (10) .
High-resolution structural studies of the resulting complexes have
heretofore been hampered by the large cooperative nature of the
binding, as well as by the tendency of the nucleoprotein complexes to
form massive aggregates (8) .
Previous electron microscopy studies have shown a helical complex
formed between DNA and SspC, a well-characterized representative
member of the highly conserved
/ß-type
SASP family (32), in which SspC binds
cooperatively along the DNA (8) . Such helical
filaments are amenable to structural analysis by cryoelectron
microscopy (cryoEM) techniques . Here we present the three-dimensional
(3D) structure of the DNA-SspC complex determined by a modified
version of the iterative helical real-space reconstruction (IHRSR)
method that combines single-particle and helical-reconstruction
techniques (3) . A novel mode of nucleoprotein organization is
identified, in which tight packaging of DNA-SspC filaments is
mediated by interdigitation of protein domains from adjacent helices .
By promoting DNA dehydration and enabling efficient DNA
sequestration, this tight toroid-like assembly is proposed to extend
protection of spore DNA beyond the level achieved by DNA saturation
with SspC, as well as to facilitate DNA repair .
DNA-SspC complex formation and cryoEM. SspC, an
/ß-type
SASP from Bacillus subtilis (32), was
purified as described previously (9) from Escherichia coli
BL21(DE3) containing plasmid pET11d that carries the sspC gene
under control of the T7 promoter . DNA-SspC complexes were formed
at a 10:1 (wt/wt) ratio (protein/DNA) in 10 mM Tris-maleate (pH
7.0), using pBluescript plasmid DNA (0.5 mg/ml) linearized with
EcoRI . The protein/DNA ratio used in these experiments was
approximately twofold higher than that needed for theoretical
saturation of DNA with SASP, in order to ensure that DNA was
saturated with the protein . Samples were incubated for 5 to 10 min at
room temperature and deposited on glow-discharged Quantifoil grids .
Specimens were embedded in 16% ammonium molybdate for cryonegative
staining (1) and vitrified by plunging into liquid
ethane . Images were recorded using low-dose cryo-conditions on Kodak
SO163 plates either on a CM12 microscope operating at 100 kV and a
magnification of x60,000 or on an FEI Tecnai
12 (T12) microscope operating at 120 kV and a magnification of
x67,000 .
Image reconstruction. Electron micrographs were digitized
with an Imacon FlexTightII scanner, at 16-bit dynamic range and 1,800
dpi (corresponding to 0.235 or 0.221 nm/pixel for images recorded on
the CM12 or T12 microscope, respectively) . Images from the T12
microscope were interpolated to 0.235 nm/pixel to allow data merging
with images taken on the CM12 microscope . Electron micrographs were
acquired at a defocus range of –500 nm to –3 µm, and prior to
reconstruction, their phases were CTF (contrast transfer function)
corrected . Image processing was conducted using the Spider software
package (version 7.01) (6), except for the
real-space helical search and reconstruction (IHRSR) method (3)
that was performed with Fortran routines provided by E . Egelman and
revised for application to DNA-SspC helical filaments . Helical
segments (i.e., "particles") 16 nm in length were picked from 22
electron micrographs with 70% overlap, while preserving information
on filament polarity and membership within filament groups . Particles
were subsequently aligned to an initial smooth bipolar model with
uniform densities that was constructed by assuming a 3.4-nm helical
pitch and 5.5-nm filament width . No additional structural features
were introduced .
Multireference alignment to this model was performed without
restriction of rotational search . Subsequently, a search for helical
symmetry was performed on the reconstruction, and an improved
symmetrized 3D model served as reference for the next iteration . A
stable solution converged after
60
iterations . At this point, a polarity was observed to have evolved in
the model, so this solution was used as a reference for 10 further
iterations, which established the explicit polarity of the filaments .
This was performed by a "voting" procedure: after multireference
alignment to the reference model projections, particles from
each filament were grouped according to their polarity, compared to
the model . The majority vote was checked for divergence from a
binomial distribution, and only those groups with 90% confidence of
divergence were added to the reconstruction . The final reconstruction
included 2,224 particles, corresponding to
13,500
protein subunits and the length (25 µm) of the helical fiber . The
resolution, as determined by Fourier shell correlation with a cutoff
of 0.5 (27, 34), reached 1.1
nm . The computed transform of a projection from the final
reconstruction exhibited layerline reflections up to 0.94 nm . The
errors in the pitch and subunit/turn (= 211.75° ± 0.04° and z
= 1.872 ± 0.03 nm, respectively) were calculated from the baseline
noise in the refinement plots of helical parameters versus refinement
cycle . The isosurface level of the reconstruction in all figures was
chosen to be 0.5 standard deviation (SD) above the average background
intensity .
The significance of the polarity observed in the final model was
assessed in the following way . Two independent reconstructions (each
using half of the data) were made after the last cycle of refinement .
The reconstructions were helically symmetrized, and projections were
calculated . The program HLXFIT from the Brandeis Helical Package (22)
was used to compare the best phase matching obtained when the two
reconstructions were oriented one to the other either in parallel or
antiparallel orientations . Comparison of the four possible
permutations (front and back sides of one reconstruction compared to
those of the other) showed a highly significant preference for polar
orientations (phase residual = 20.4° ± 2.6°) versus nonpolar
orientations (62.9° ± 3.4°) .
Docking of adjacent filaments. The program MolFit (4,
11) was used for docking analysis . An atomic
representation of the electron microscopy-reconstructed electron
density map was obtained by packing spheres into a 21.85-nm-long
fragment of the DNA-SspC filament at the isosurface level described
above . The electron density map for this fragment was calculated on a
cubic grid with a 0.235-nm interval and converted to a list of
"virtual atoms" whose centers were at the positions of the grid
points .
Two search procedures were performed, starting with identical
filaments either parallel or antiparallel to each other . During the
search, one fiber was kept fixed while the other was allowed to
rotate and translate about three perpendicular axes (the z
axis coincided with the long axis of the filament) in steps of 10° .
The translation interval was 0.1 nm in all search procedures . A full
range of rotations was allowed for the z axis, but for the
x and y axes only rotations of ±30° were allowed,
producing 1,764 relative orientations . For each relative orientation,
five docking solutions with the highest geometric complementarity
score were saved . A high complementarity score indicates that
surfaces align with minimal gaps and clashes . The mean score and SD
were derived by fitting the observed distribution of scores to an
extreme value distribution function (14) . Local
searches, at 1° intervals, were performed around the best parallel
and antiparallel solutions . A third filament was then docked to the
best two-filament antiparallel solution, employing identical
translation and rotation intervals . This procedure resulted in the
formation of 3D assemblies of filaments with both parallel and
antiparallel contacts .
Thin-section transmission electron microscopy of bacterial spores.
B . subtilis cultures were grown in Luria-Bertani medium at 30°C
for 72 h . The resulting spores were harvested and transferred
to cellulose capillaries (inner diameter, 200 µm) . The samples were
frozen in liquid nitrogen in a Balzers HPM 010 apparatus under a
pressure of 2.1 x 108 Pa for 500
ms (estimated freezing time, 20 ms) . Following cryofixation samples
were cryo-substituted with anhydrous acetone containing1% OsO4 .
Samples were then embedded in Epon; thin sections were stained with
1% uranyl acetate and examined on a Philips CM12 electron microscope
operating at 100 kV . Intracellular localization of DNA was performed
with the DNA-specific stain osmium ammine-SO2 (36) .
Grid-mounted thin sections of Epon-embedded bacteria were floated on
5 N HCl for 30 min at room temperature, washed with distilled water,
and treated with osmium ammine-B (Polysciences) in 8 N acetic
acid and 40 mM sodium metabisulfite for 1 h at 37°C . Sections were
then thoroughly rinsed with distilled water, dried, and studied
without additional staining . Three independent experiments were
conducted for each set of staining conditions, and in each experiment
more than 1,000 cell slices were screened .
3D reconstruction of DNA-SspC helical complex. The 3D structure
of the DNA-SspC helical filament was determined using cryoEM . The
relatively small diameter ( 5.5
nm) and curved morphology of the ice-embedded DNA-SspC filaments
imaged under low-dose conditions lead to particularly noisy images .
In order to improve the signal-to-noise ratio, DNA-SspC filaments
were imaged using the cryonegative staining technique (1) .
Filaments tended to aggregate into massive bundles and swirls (Fig.
1), as previously reported (8) .
Although the DNA-SspC complex is substantially stiffer than naked
DNA, the filaments exhibited a highly curved morphology, thus
preventing helical processing of segments longer than
95
nm . Collectively, these characteristics hampered the use of a
classical helical-reconstruction approach . Therefore, we employed the
IHRSR method (3) . This method involves iterative
cycles of a two-step process: multireference-based 3D reconstruction
of helical segments (such as in Fig . 2A) using
single-particle image-processing methods (with no symmetry imposed)
followed by a search for helical symmetry in the resulting 3D model
(see Materials and Methods) .
|
FIG . 1 . Transmission electron microscopy of DNA-SspC complex . (A) Image
of a typical toroidal aggregate formed by DNA-SspC filaments . Arrowheads
point toward single filaments spreading out of the circle . (B) High
magnification of a region from panel A, highlighting the tight packing
of adjacent filaments . Scale bars are 50 nm (A) and 10 nm (B).
|
|
|
FIG . 2 . DNA-SspC 3D reconstruction . (A) Gallery of raw "particles"
(helix sections) that have been aligned by rotation and translation . The
last frame shows the average of all aligned particles belonging to one
representative class from the reconstruction . (B and C) Surface
representations of the initial model (B) and final reconstruction (C) .
(D) Slices through the reconstruction (perpendicular to the helical
axis) . Consecutive slices are separated by 0.235 nm and range over one
helical subunit . Density values are contoured every 0.5 SD, where the
outermost contour is 0.5 SD above the average background intensity.
|
|
The initial model was a smooth helix where all density values were
identical (Fig . 2B) . The initial structural features were
the value for the pitch (rise per turn), which was taken as the
pitch of B-form DNA (3.4 nm), and the filament width (5.5 nm), as
measured in the raw images . The final reconstructed volume (Fig.
2C and D) contains 1.7 helical subunits (the unique
volume that is repeated along the helical filament) per turn with a
pitch of 3.18 nm, leading to a 1.87-nm rise and 211.8° rotation per
helical subunit . These values for pitch and rise per subunit could be
observed in the Fourier transform of the averages of aligned
filaments . The reconstructed 3D map showed two protrusions for each
helical subunit . The protrusions vary in size and radial distance
from the filament axis, each apparently corresponding to an SspC
molecule . The resolution of the map was 1.1 nm, as measured by
Fourier shell correlation (see Materials and Methods) . The handedness
of the helical DNA-SspC complex could not be determined
independently, and was assumed to adopt the DNA right-handed
conformation . It was not possible to locate the placement of DNA
within the reconstructed volume, due to lack of sufficient detail in
the internal density variation .
Geometric docking of DNA-SASP filaments. DNA-SspC helical
filaments were previously shown to form bundles and swirls in
solution (8) (Fig . 1) . In vivo, bundles must
consist of both parallel and antiparallel orientations, because of
the circular nature of the bacterial chromatin . We therefore
investigated packaging of adjacent DNA-SspC filaments by geometrical
docking (11) in both parallel and antiparallel
orientations . The maximal score for parallel fitting was at 56°
rotation about the filament (z) axis, 1° rotation about the
perpendicular x axis, and no rotation around the y axis
(Fig . 3C) . The score of the best antiparallel
solution was at 56° rotation about the filament (z) axis, and
no rotation about the perpendicular (x and y) axes
(Fig . 3D) .
|
FIG . 3 . Geometrical docking of DNA-SspC filaments: 3D packaging of four
adjacent DNA-SspC filaments . (A) Top view of the filaments . The purple
filament forms antiparallel contacts with the other three . (B) Schematic
top view showing how multiple filaments form a hexagon-like packing
arrangement, with both antiparallel and parallel contacts between
neighbors . (C) Shown are the same four filaments from panel A, where the
orange, yellow, and green filaments make parallel contacts . (D) The
purple filament makes antiparallel contacts with the green and orange
filaments . (E) Contour plots of parallel (left) and antiparallel (right)
geometrical docking score results . The color bar represents the
complementarity score (arbitrary scale) in the range of the parallel and
antiparallel solutions, where contour levels of 1 SD from the best
solution are plotted every 0.25 SD.
|
|
The fitting of antiparallel pairs of filaments resulted in tight
docking (Fig . 3D), leaving essentially no gaps between the
filaments . The best complementarity score was 9.1 SDs above the mean,
in the distribution of solutions . It is a highly unique solution
as well, since small rotations about the z axis (±3°
from optimum geometry), or ±1° about one of the x or y
axes, reduced the complementarity score by 1 SD (Fig . 3E,
right) . In contrast, fitting of parallel pairs of filaments
resulted in significant gaps and a relatively low complementarity
(Fig . 3C) . The best score, at only 6.2 SDs above the mean, is
also less unique, as small rotations of the parallel-packed
filaments do not significantly affect the complementarity score (Fig.
3E, left) . The addition of additional filaments in the
fitting reveals a plausible model for 3D packaging of DNA-SASP
filaments (Fig . 3A) . The additional filament is found to form
good antiparallel contacts with one fiber and additional, considerably
less extensive parallel contacts with the other fiber . The overall
packing resembles close hexagonal, with each filament surrounded
by six other fibers, three parallel and three antiparallel, on
average (Fig . 3B) .
DNA packaging in bacterial spores. Previous studies
indicated that chromatin in developing forespores, as well as in
germinating spores of B . subtilis, adopts a tightly packed
ring-shaped morphology (24, 25) . Although
the nucleoid structure in dormant spores was not determined due to
the impermeability of the spore core to fixative and stains, it has
been suggested that this tight toroidal organization is also present
in dormant spores . We used cryofixation techniques and specific DNA
staining methods in order to assess DNA structure in mature spores .
Cryofixed B . subtilis spores exhibit layers consisting of
thick lamellar coat, cortex, and inner membrane that engulf the inner
core . Within this core, ribosomes that appear as darkly stained
particles, as well as chromatin demarcated as ribosome-free regions,
are detected (Fig . 4A and B) . As indicated by a
specific DNA staining method that was previously shown to be
particularly effective for labeling condensed DNA regions (36),
spore chromatin is localized in the periphery of the core, forming a
tightly packed toroidal structure . Notably, a complete DNA toroid was
observed in
15%
of the spores . The other specimens revealed incomplete toroidal
structures, as a portion of the toroid was sliced out in the thin
sections probed in transmission electron microscopy .
|
FIG . 4 . Electron microscopy of dormant B . subtilis spores . (A)
B . subtilis spore stained with uranyl acetate . The densely stained
particles are ribosomes; ribosome-free spaces in the periphery of the
spore core are indicated by arrows and contain chromatin . (B) Specific
DNA staining of a dormant spore, which results in darkly stained DNA,
highlights the toroid morphology of the chromatin . Since the sections
probed are
70
nm thick, only a segment of the toroid can be detected . Scale bars, 200
nm . Dormant spores were prepared for transmission electron microscopy as
described in Materials and Methods.
|
|
A major determinant of spore DNA protection against heat, desiccation,
oxidizing agents and UV irradiation is the saturation of spore
DNA with
/ß-type
SASP that are expressed in large amounts during spore formation (30) .
Due to the lack of structural data on the resulting DNA-SASP complex,
many aspects of the mechanisms by which these conserved DNA-binding
proteins promote DNA protection remain enigmatic .
Previous circular dichroism and Fourier transform infrared studies
implied that binding of DNA to SspC, a characteristic member of the
/ß-type
SASP family, promotes a conformational transition of DNA molecules
from a B form to an A-like structure (19,
31) . It was proposed that this major conformational
modification underlies the ability of
/ß-type
SASP to protect spore DNA, by substantially modulating DNA
photochemistry (19, 31) . It was
also suggested that the change in DNA supercoiling detected following
the interaction with SspC in vitro (20), as well as
by DNA in spores (21), derives from the large
alteration in the number of base pairs per helical turn that
accompanies B-to-A DNA transition (31) . Subsequent
electron microscopy studies of DNA-SspC filaments indicated, however,
that the length of DNA molecules, and hence the rise per base pair,
are not significantly altered upon SspC binding, thus implying that
DNA conformational state within the DNA-SspC complex remains similar
to the canonical B form (8) . Moreover, it has been
shown that the altered photochemical properties of DNA molecules
within DNA-SspC filaments cannot be straightforwardly ascribed to an
A-like DNA conformation, but, at least partially, to DNA dehydration
(23) .
The structural analysis presented here indicates that DNA helical
parameters sustain only minor conformational changes upon binding to
SspC . The final structure reveals that the pitch (3.18 nm) remains
close to that of canonical B-form DNA . These results raise the
following question: what are the mechanisms responsible for DNA
protection and the alteration of DNA supercoiling (20,
21)?
On the basis of our structural analysis, we propose that the
quaternary organization of the DNA-SspC filaments plays an important
role in mediating both DNA protection and the increased DNA
supercoiling . Within this tight packaging, which derives from a
near-to-perfect interdigitation of adjacent filaments, water content
is substantially reduced . The attenuated water activity is likely to
result in a decreased probability of formation of reactive oxidizing
radicals as well as in altered DNA photochemical properties (23),
whereby UV-induced production of thymine dimers is restricted . DNA
molecules saturated with SspC appear to preferentially adopt a
tightly packed toroidal conformation both in vitro (8)
(Fig . 1) and in dormant spores (Fig . 4) .
This particular conformation is significant in light of the recent
proposal according to which the exceptional resistance of the
bacterium Deinococcus radiodurans towards irradiation and
desiccation is promoted by the tight toroidal packaging of its genome
(12) . Within this rigid matrix, free DNA ends
generated by double-stranded breaks are kept firmly together as a
result of restricted diffusion, thus allowing for error-free repair
through template-independent joining of DNA fragments through
nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) . Notably, DNA repair through
homologous recombination cannot occur in germinating spores because
they regularly carry only one copy of their genome (2) .
As the ring-shaped organization of chromatin has been shown to
persist upon spore germination for several hours (25),
it is tempting to suggest that this tight morphology contributes to
spore resistance by facilitating repair of double-stranded DNA
breaks . Indeed, it has recently been proposed that NHEJ represents an
important repair pathway of double-stranded DNA breaks in B .
subtilis (36) .
Within the 3D toroidal structure, both antiparallel and parallel
contacts between adjacent DNA-SspC filaments are necessarily present
because of the circularly closed conformation of bacterial
chromosomes . Our geometric docking analysis indicates that the
filaments pack in a particularly tight conformation when juxtaposed
in an antiparallel geometry, whereas in the parallel configuration,
lower spatial complementarity between adjacent filaments is observed
(Fig . 3) . The tight antiparallel contacts stabilize
the assembly, thus compensating for the weaker parallel contacts . Due
to the nonoptimal complementarity between adjacent DNA-SspC filaments
that is imposed by the contribution of parallel contacts, it could be
expected that DNA protection against small DNA-modifying agents would
be less effective than that achieved against relatively bulky species
such as nucleases . Indeed, the DNA-SspC complex has been shown to be
as susceptible to small alkylating reagents as naked DNA (29,
30) . The mechanism by which SspC protects DNA
against formaldehyde (15) remains, however, enigmatic .
Our structural analysis further demonstrates that parallel interfilament
contacts are less specific than antiparallel contacts, allowing
for flexibility and a relatively large angular distribution (±4°) of
packed DNA-SspC filaments . This larger conformational freedom may
result in rearrangements of the filaments such that a higher spatial
complementarity and hence a tighter, near-to-hexagonal packaging are
obtained . These rearrangements, which are likely to entail winding of
filaments around each other, would lead to DNA superhelical density
within the complex by generating an overall twist . Notably, it has
been previously shown that the supercoiling handedness exhibited by
aggregates of closely packed chiral filaments is dictated by the
chirality of these filaments (26) . The
unidirectional winding of DNA-SspC filaments, which is required to
explain the SspC-induced effects on DNA supercoiling, is thus
proposed to represent a direct outcome of the chiral nature of the
filaments, combined with the drive to achieve the highest possible
chromatin compactness .
We have previously shown that starved nonsporulating bacteria, as
well as bacteria exposed to severe and prolonged DNA-damaging agents,
protect their DNA complement through physical sequestration within
tightly packed structures (7, 13,
37) . In this study we demonstrate that the
structure of sporal DNA-SspC filaments, in conjunction with their
tight spatial organization, provides an effective means for a
continuous protection of the spore chromosome . This protection is
promoted by DNA saturation with SspC and the tight packaging of the
resulting DNA-SspC filaments, as well as by the toroidal conformation
of the spore genome . The toroidal structure may facilitate and
promote DNA repair through NHEJ (36), by creating
a relatively rigid matrix in which DNA fragments are kept together (12) .
The results support the notion that a protection and survival
strategy that depends upon structural features is widespread among
prokaryotes when exposed to prolonged periods of starvation and
stress (17, 18) .
This work was supported by the Israel Science Foundation, funded by
the Academy of Sciences and Humanities, and by the Minerva
Foundation, Germany .
We thank Ed Egelman for the IHRSR source code and David Morgan for
his help in implementing the helical-reconstruction techniques .
* Corresponding author . Mailing address: Chemical Research
Support, The Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot 76100, Israel . Phone:
972-8-934-4421 . Fax: 972-8-934-4161 . E-mail: Sharon.Wolf@weizmann.ac.il.
Present address: Department of Biology, Massachusetts Institute of
Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139 .
- Adrian, M., J . Dubochet, S . D . Fuller, and J . R . Harris.
1998 . Cryo-negative staining . Micron 29:145-160.
- Belliveau, B . H., T . C . Beaman, and P . Gerhardt. 1990 .
Heat-resistance correlated with DNA content in Bacillus megaterium
spores . Appl . Environ . Microbiol . 56:2919-2921.
- Egelman, E . H. 2000 . A robust algorithm for the
reconstruction of helical filaments using single-particle methods .
Ultramicroscopy 85:225-234.
- Eisenstein, M., I . Shariv, G . Koren, A . A . Friesem, and E .
Katchalski-Katzir. 1997 . Modeling supra-molecular helices: extension of
the molecular surface recognition algorithm and application to the protein
coat of the tobacco mosaic virus . J . Mol . Biol . 266:135-143.
- Francesconi, S . C., T . J . Macalister, B . Setlow, and P .
Setlow. 1988 . Immunoelectron microscopic localization of small,
acid-soluble spore proteins in sporulating cells of Bacillus-Subtilis .
J . Bacteriol . 170:5963-5967.
- Frank, J., M . Radermacher, P . Penczek, J . Zhu, Y . Li, M .
Ladjadj, and A . Leith. 1996 . SPIDER and WEB: processing and visualization
of images in 3D electron microscopy and related fields . J . Struct . Biol .
116:190-199.
- Frenkiel-Krispin, D., S . Levin-Zaidman, E . Shimoni, S . G .
Wolf, E . J . Wachtel, T . Arad, S . E . Finkel, R . Kolter, and A . Minsky.
2001 . Regulated phase transitions of bacterial chromatin: a non-enzymatic
pathway for generic DNA protection . EMBO J . 20:1184-1191 .
- Griffith, J., A . Makhov, L . Santiago-Lara, and P . Setlow.
1994 . Electron microscopic studies of the interaction between a Bacillus
subtilis
/ß-type
small, acid-soluble spore protein with DNA: protein binding is cooperative,
stiffens the DNA, and induces negative supercoiling . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci .
USA 91:8224-8228.
- Hayes, C . S., E . Alarcon-Hernandez, and P . Setlow. 2001 .
N-terminal amino acid residues mediate protein-protein interactions between
DNA-bound
/ß-type
small, acid-soluble spore proteins from Bacillus species . J . Biol .
Chem . 276:2267-2275 .
- Hayes, C . S., Z . Y . Peng, and P . Setlow. 2000 .
Equilibrium and kinetic binding interactions between DNA and a group of novel,
nonspecific DNA-binding proteins from spores of Bacillus and
Clostridium species . J . Biol . Chem . 275:35040-35050 .
- Katchalski-Katzir, E., I . Shariv, M . Eisenstein, A . Friesem,
C . Aflalo, and I . Vakser. 1992 . Molecular surface recognition:
determination of geometric fit between proteins and their ligands by
correlation techniques . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 89:2195-2199.
- Levin-Zaidman, S., J . Englander, E . Shimoni, A . K . Sharma,
K . W . Minton, and A . Minsky. 2003 . Ringlike structure of the
Deinococcus radiodurans genome: a key to radioresistance? Science 299:254-256 .
- Levin-Zaidman, S., D . Frenkiel-Krispin, E . Shimoni, I .
Sabanay, S . G . Wolf, and A . Minsky. 2000 . Ordered intracellular RecA-DNA
assemblies: a potential site of in vivo RecA-mediated activities . Proc . Natl .
Acad . Sci . USA 97:6791-6796 .
- Levitt, M., and M . Gerstein. 1998 . A unified statistical
framework for sequence comparison and structure comparison . Proc . Natl . Acad .
Sci . USA 95:5913-5920 .
- Loshon, C . A., P . C . Genest, B . Setlow, and P . Setlow.
1999 . Formaldehyde kills spores of Bacillus subtilis by DNA damage and
small, acid-soluble spore proteins of the
/ß-type
protect spores against this DNA damage . J . Appl . Microbiol . 87:8-14.
- Mason, J . M., and P . Setlow. 1986 . Essential role of
small, acid-soluble spore proteins in resistance of Bacillus subtilis
spores to UV light . J . Bacteriol . 167:174-178.
- Minsky, A. 2003 . Structural aspects of DNA repair: the
role of restricted diffusion . Mol . Microbiol . 50:367-376.
- Minsky, A., E . Shimoni, and D . Frenkiel-Krispin. 2002 .
Stress, order and survival . Nat . Rev . Mol . Cell Biol . 3:50-60.
- Mohr, S . C., N . V . Sokolov, C . M . He, and P . Setlow.
1991 . Binding of small acid-soluble spore proteins from Bacillus subtilis
changes the conformation of DNA from B to A . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 88:77-81.
- Nicholson, W . L., B . Setlow, and P . Setlow. 1990 .
Binding of DNA in vitro by a small, acid-soluble spore protein from
Bacillus subtilis and the effect of this binding on DNA topology . J .
Bacteriol . 172:6900-6906.
- Nicholson, W . L., and P . Setlow. 1990 . Dramatic increase
in negative superhelicity of plasmid DNA in the forespore compartment of
sporulating cells of Bacillus subtilis . J . Bacteriol . 172:7-14.
- Owen, C . H., D . G . Morgan, and D . J . DeRosier. 1996 .
Image analysis of helical objects: the Brandeis Helical Package . J . Struct .
Biol . 116:167-175.
- Patrick, M . H., and D . M . Gray. 1976 . Photochem .
Photobiol . 24:507-513.
- Pogliano, K., E . Harry, and R . Losick. 1995 .
Visualization of the subcellular location of sporulation proteins in
Bacillus subtilis using immunofluorescence microscopy . Mol . Microbiol .
18:459-470.
- Ragkousi, K., A . E . Cowan, M . A . Ross, and P . Setlow.
2000 . Analysis of nucleoid morphology during germination and outgrowth of
spores of Bacillus species . J . Bacteriol . 182:5556-5562 .
- Reich, Z., Z . S . Levin, S . B . Gutman, T . Arad, and A .
Minsky. 1994 . Supercoiling-regulated liquid-crystalline packaging of
topologically-constrained, nucleosome-free DNA molecules . Biochemistry 33:14177-14184.
- Saxton, W . O., and W . Baumeister. 1982 . The correlation
averaging of a regularly arranged bacterial cell envelope protein . J . Microsc.
127:127-138.
- Setlow, B., and P . Setlow. 1996 . Role of DNA repair in
Bacillus subtilis spore resistance . J . Bacteriol . 178:3486-3495.
- Setlow, B., D . Sun, and P . Setlow. 1992 . Interaction
between DNA and
/ß-type
small, acid-soluble spore proteins: a new class of DNA-binding protein . J .
Bacteriol . 174:2312-2322.
- Setlow, B., K . J . Tautvydas, and P . Setlow. 1998 . Small,
acid-soluble spore proteins of the
/ß
type do not protect the DNA in Bacillus subtilis spores against base
alkylation . Appl . Environ . Microbiol . 64:1958-1962 .
- Setlow, P. 1992 . DNA in dormant spores of Bacillus
species is in an A-like conformation . Mol . Microbiol . 6:563-567.
- Setlow, P. 1995 . Mechanisms for the prevention of damage
to DNA in spores of Bacillus species . Annu . Rev . Microbiol . 49:29-54.
- Setlow, P. 1988 . Small, acid-soluble spore proteins of
Bacillus species: structure, synthesis, genetics, function, and
degradation . Annu . Rev . Microbiol . 42:319-338.
- Van Heel, M. 1987 . Similarity measures between images .
Ultramicroscopy 21:95-100.
- Vreeland, R . H., W . D . Rosenzweig, and D . W . Powers.
2000 . Isolation of a 250 million-year-old halotolerant bacterium from a
primary salt crystal . Nature 407:897-900.
- Weller, G . R., B . Kysela, R . Roy, L . M . Tonkin, E . Scanlan,
M . Della, S . K . Devine, J . P . Day, A . Wilkinson, F . D . di Fagagna, K . M .
Devine, R . P . Bowater, P . A . Jeggo, S . P . Jackson, and A . J . Doherty.
2002 . Identification of a DNA nonhomologous end-joining complex in bacteria .
Science 297:1686-1689 .
- Wolf, S . G., D . Frenkiel, T . Arad, S . E . Finkel, R . Kolter,
and A . Minsky. 1999 . DNA protection by stress-induced biocrystallization .
Nature 400:83-85.
Free Online Full-text Article
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
|