|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, May 2003, p . 3111-3117, Vol . 185,
No . 10
Swarm-Cell Differentiation in Salmonella enterica Serovar
Typhimurium Results in Elevated Resistance to Multiple Antibiotics
Wook Kim,1 Teresa Killam,1 Vandana Sood,1,
and Michael G . Surette1,2*
Department of Microbiology and Infectious Diseases,1 Department of
Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta,
Canada2
Received 10 January 2003/ Accepted 10 March 2003
Although a wealth of knowledge exists about the molecular and
biochemical mechanisms governing the swimming motility of Salmonella
enterica serovar Typhimurium, its surface swarming behavior
has not been extensively characterized . When inoculated onto a
semisolid agar medium supplemented with appropriate nutrients,
serovar Typhimurium undergoes a morphological differentiation whereby
single cells hyperflagellate and elongate into nonseptate,
multinucleate swarm cells . Swarm migration is a collective behavior
of groups of cells . We have isolated a MudJ insertion mutant
of serovar Typhimurium 14028 that failed to swarm under any
conditions . The site of the MudJ insertion was determined to
be in the pmrK locus within the pmrHFIJKLM operon, which was
previously demonstrated to confer resistance to cationic antimicrobial
peptides . ß-Galactosidase assays, using the pmrK::lacZ
transcriptional fusion, showed increased expression of the pmr
operon in swarm cells compared to that in vegetative cells . In
concurrence with the expression data, swarm cells exhibited greater
tolerance to polymyxin . To compare the profiles of vegetative and
swarm-cell resistance to other antibiotics, E-test strips
representing a wide range of antibiotic classes were used . Swarm
cells exhibited elevated resistance to a variety of antibiotics,
including those that target the cell envelope, protein translation,
DNA replication, and transcription . These observations, in addition
to the dramatic morphological changes associated with the swarming
phenotype, provide an intriguing model for examining global
differences between the physiological states of vegetative and swarm
cells of serovar Typhimurium .
Swarming motility is a coordinated multicellular behavior promoting
rapid colony migration and expansion on semisolid surfaces (10) .
Swarming is preceded by differentiation of short, motile, vegetative
(i.e., swimmer) cells into elongated, hyperflagellated, and
multinucleate swarm cells . The mechanisms that drive chemotaxis and
swimming motility in Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium
have been extensively studied (1, 2,
7, 9, 27,
28) . However, its surface swarming behavior is largely
uncharacterized . In addition to inoculum density, specific medium
composition triggers swarm-cell differentiation in serovar
Typhimurium (15) . However, the specific intra- and
extracellular signals and the mechanisms that drive swarm-cell
differentiation remain to be elucidated at both the physiological and
molecular levels .
Although an intact chemotaxis phosphorelay system is essential,
chemotaxis is dispensable for swarm-cell differentiation and
migration . Swarming is abolished in cheA, cheW, cheR, and
cheY mutants of serovar Typhimurium (15),
but fliM and fliG flagellar motor switch mutants
maintain their ability to swarm (5) . It is believed
that the flagellum senses an increase in the viscosity of the growth
medium, which subsequently triggers swarm-cell differentiation in
Vibrio parahaemolyticus (16) . However, changes
in the viscosity of the growth medium do not seem to trigger
swarm-cell differentiation in serovar Typhimurium (31) .
Lipopolysaccharide (LPS) plays a pivotal role in the surface
migration of serovar Typhimurium, as transposon mutations at a
variety of loci associated with LPS biosynthesis or modification
result in a defective swarming phenotype (31) . LPS
and other extracellular components may improve the wettability of the
swarm medium, decreasing surface friction, thus allowing
differentiated swarm cells to migrate outward .
Activation of the two-component regulatory system PmrAB results in
a variety of modifications of LPS and cell envelope components of
serovar Typhimurium (34) . PmrA is activated either by PmrB,
under conditions of moderate acidity or high Fe3+ (6,
24), or by PmrD, under Mg2+-limiting
conditions via PhoPQ (17) . PmrA regulates the
transcription of the pmrHFIJKLM operon, which in turn adds
4-aminoarabinose (L-Ara4N) residues to the lipid
A portion of LPS (14, 32,
33) . This modification adds an extra positive
charge to the LPS, reducing the binding potential of cationic
antimicrobial peptides like polymyxin and azurocidin . Although
indistinguishable by intraperitoneal challenge, the virulence of
serovar Typhimurium with mutations in the pmrHFIJKLM operon
was reduced compared to that of the wild type when mice were orally
challenged (14) . These results suggest that the
pmr operon products may be important for resistance to antimicrobial
peptides that are present within the intestinal environment .
In this paper, we report that the pmrK mutation in serovar Typhimurium
results in loss of swarming motility . We demonstrate that pmrK
expression is up-regulated under conditions that promote swarm-cell
differentiation and, accordingly, swarm cells of serovar Typhimurium
exhibit increased resistance to polymyxin in comparison to cells
in the vegetative state . Intriguingly, swarm cells also displayed
various degrees of increased resistance to a wide variety of
antibiotics . The increased resistance of swarm cells to antibiotics
arises because of an altered phenotypic state of the cells, not
through genetic selection . This adaptive antibiotic resistance
response may play a role in the survival and spread of Salmonella
spp . in both the environment and hosts .
Bacterial strains. S . enterica serovar
Typhimurium 14028 is a wild-type virulent strain (ATCC 14028) . Strain
7953s is a phoPQ::Tn10 mutant of serovar Typhimurium
LT2 obtained from the Salmonella Genetic Stock Centre (University of
Calgary) . Strain CS031 is a pmrK::MudJ mutant, and
strain CS004 is an STM2532::MudJ mutant, both of which were
constructed in this study from parent strain 14028 (see Fig.
1A) .
|
FIG . 1 . Characterization of swarm mutants of serovar Typhimurium 14028 .
(A) Schematic representation of MudJ insertion sites in swarm
mutants CS031 and CS004.
indicates an insertion site, and the arrow represents the orientation of
the lacZ fusion . (B) Comparison of swarming and swimming motility
between wild-type and mutant strains . Strain 7953s is a phoPQ::Tn10
mutant of serovar Typhimurium LT2 . All strains were inoculated onto
swarm and swim plates and incubated at 37°C for 5 h.
|
|
Swarm and swim motility assays. One microliter of an overnight
culture was spotted in the middle of a swarm plate (Difco Nutrient
Broth [NB], 0.5% [wt/vol] glucose, 0.5% agar [Difco]) or a swim plate
(NB, 0.5% glucose, 0.25% agar) and allowed to dry for 1 h at room
temperature . All plates were incubated at 37°C for 10 h or as noted
otherwise . For phase-contrast microscopic analysis, swarm or swim
cells were scraped from their respective fronts and then visualized
in NB or saline on a glass slide .
MudJ mutagenesis and isolation of mutants defective in
swarming motility. Random MudJ insertion mutants of serovar
Typhimurium LT2 were generated by using the phage P22 delivery system
as previously described (19) . MudJ
recombinants were spotted onto swarm and swim plates, and only those
that exhibited the swarm-negative and swim-positive phenotypes were
subjected to further analyses . Mutants with obvious defects in the
O-antigen component of LPS were first removed from the screen on the
basis of the absence of P22 sensitivity, and the MudJ
insertions in the remaining mutants were transferred to serovar
Typhimurium 14028 by using the phage P22 delivery system . The mutants
were spotted onto swarm plates containing various basal media
(Luria-Bertani [LB; Difco], brain heart infusion, M9, and
Mueller-Hinton II) and carbon sources (glucose, arabinose, fructose,
and gluconate [0.5%, wt/vol]) . Only those mutants that failed to
swarm under all growth conditions were selected, and the sites of
MudJ insertion were identified by arbitrary primed PCR as
previously described (29) .
pmrK expression analysis. The pmrK::lacZ
transcriptional fusion generated by the MudJ insertion was
used to monitor the expression of the pmr operon . Four
microliters of CS031, grown overnight in NB (0.5% glucose), was
spread onto swarm plates containing 0, 0.3, 0.45, 0.7, 1.0, or 1.5%
agar . Following 6 h of incubation at 37°C, the plate cultures were
harvested by gentle scraping with a plastic coverslip and the optical
densities at 600 nm of all samples were equilibrated in 0.5 to 1.5 ml
of Z buffer . The ß-galactosidase activity in the cell preparations
was assayed as described by Miller (21) . All
assays were repeated three times to ensure reproducibility .
Antibiotic resistance profiling. To compare the polymyxin
sensitivities of strains 14028 and CS031 in broth, overnight LB broth
cultures were diluted in fresh LB medium and 104 to 105
CFU were inoculated into 96-well plates containing 100 µl of LB
medium with a series of twofold dilutions of polymyxin in
concentrations ranging from 500 to 0.000125 µg ml-1 . The
minimum concentration of polymyxin that inhibited visible growth was
declared the MIC . E-test strips (AB Biodisk, Solna, Sweden) were used
to compare the relative resistances of swarm and vegetative cells of
serovar Typhimurium 14028 to a wide variety of antibiotics .
Vegetative cells were analyzed on either solid (NB, 0.5% glucose,
1.5% agar) or swim plates . On solid plates, 100 µl containing
104 to 105 cells of 14028 was evenly spread and
incubated at room temperature for 20 min and the E-test strip was
placed in the middle of each plate . On swim plates, 1 µl of the
seed culture was inoculated at two spots and the E-test strip
was placed in the middle of the plate between the two inocula . Swarm
plates were inoculated in the same manner as the swim plates . All
plates were incubated overnight at 37°C, and the E-test results were
interpreted in accordance with the manufacturer's instructions . All
assays were repeated at least two times to ensure reproducibility .
pmrK and STM2532 mutations result in loss of swarming motility.
Strain CS031, harboring a pmrK::MudJ insertion mutation, failed
to exhibit swarming motility when inoculated onto a swarm plate
(Fig . 1) . Toguchi et al . (31) previously
reported that a variety of LPS biosynthesis or modification mutants
of serovar Typhimurium failed to exhibit swarming motility . All LPS
mutants, however, retained the ability to swim and became
hyperflagellated when grown on swarm plates . Similarly, growth in the
swim plates at 37°C revealed that CS031 was still motile (Fig.
1B), and under growth conditions that promote
swarm-cell differentiation, a heterogeneous mixture of short and
elongated (i.e., 2 to 3 cell lengths) cells were observed by
phase-contrast microscopic analysis (data not shown) . Thus, CS031
maintains its ability to differentiate into swarm cells and the
pmrK mutation exerts a nonflagellar physical defect that prevents
the differentiated swarm cells from migrating outward . No swarming or
swimming defect was observed in phoPQ mutant strain 7953s
(Fig . 1B), indicating that PhoPQ-dependent
expression of pmrK is not required under our experimental
conditions .
The site of MudJ insertion in strain CS004, another unconditional
swarm-negative, swim-positive mutant of 14028, was determined
to be in STM2532, an uncharacterized open reading frame that exists
in an operon upstream of pbpC encoding an Escherichia
coli homolog of penicillin-binding protein 1C (Fig . 1A) .
Albeit with a reduced colony diameter, CS004 maintained its ability
to swim (Fig . 1B) . When propagated on swarm media, CS004
also differentiated into swarm cells, whose average length (n
= 50) was determined to be slightly greater than that of 14028 and
CS031 cells (data not shown) . All of the strains exhibited cell
elongation on swarm plates, regardless of the basal media, given that
they were supplemented with glucose, fructose, or arabinose (see
Materials and Methods) . Gluconate did not support swarm-cell
differentiation of strains 14028, CS004, and CS031 (data not shown) .
Up-regulation of pmrHFIJKLM operon expression confers
increased polymyxin resistance to swarm cells. The pmrK gene was
recently shown to encode an inner membrane enzyme that transfers
L-Ara4N residues to lipid A (32), a
modification that confers increased resistance to polymyxin and other
cationic antimicrobial peptides (14) . To determine
whether pmrK expression is differentially regulated under
swarming conditions, the chromosomal pmrK::lacZ fusion,
generated by the MudJ insertion in CS031, was used to compare
expression under swim, swarm, and nonmotile conditions . Although
pmrK expression did not differ dramatically among the different
agar concentrations, pmrK expression was consistently higher
under conditions that promote swarming motility in wild-type 14028
(Fig . 2) . The lack of dramatic differences in
pmrK expression between the different growth conditions may be
due largely to the fact that CS031 was spread plated onto swarm
plates . Since CS031 fails to migrate on swarm plates, the entire
plate was harvested for the expression assay, which contains a
heterogeneous population of short and elongated cell types .
Nonetheless, the expression results suggested that serovar
Typhimurium could exhibit increased resistance to polymyxin in the
swarm state compared to the cells in the vegetative state .
Previously, McCoy et al . (20) demonstrated that an LPS mutant
of Proteus mirabilis that lacked the L-Ara4N
modification was severely defective in swarming motility and
exhibited increased sensitivity to polymyxin and other antimicrobial
peptides .
|
FIG . 2 . Transcriptional analysis of pmrK in serovar Typhimurium
CS031 grown in various agar concentrations . ß-Galactosidase assays of
cells in the vegetative state (swim and solid) and cells grown under
conditions that promote swarm-cell differentiation were performed . All
cells were grown in NB with 0.5% glucose supplemented with agar at the
concentrations indicated.
|
|
Since swarm cells dedifferentiate into vegetative cells when grown in
liquid media, resistance to polymyxin was compared between the two
states by using polymyxin E-test strips on swarm, swim, and solid
plates . E-test strips (AB Biodisk) are plastic strips containing a
predefined immobilized antibiotic gradient that provide a continuous
antibiotic gradient when transferred to an agar surface . The efficacy
of E-test strips has been successfully compared to that of the
standard agar dilution MIC methods and demonstrated to be highly
reproducible against a wide variety of microorganisms (4) .
As predicted, swarm cells of wild-type strain 14028 exhibited an
eightfold increase in resistance to polymyxin compared to vegetative
cells (Fig . 3; Table 1) . Unlike
P . mirabilis, serovar Typhimurium does not differentiate into
swarm cells when grown on media containing >1% (wt/vol) agar
(our unpublished observations; 15) . Thus, only vegetative
cells are produced when serovar Typhimurium is propagated on swim
or solid plates . There was virtually no difference in the polymyxin
MICs on the solid and swim plates, indicating that the relative
differences in the agar concentrations did not significantly alter
the efficacy of the E-test strips in our assays . This notion is
further supported by the fact that when the cells were spread plated
onto LB medium containing 0.5% agar, the same MIC was obtained as
with the NB-based vegetative plates (Fig . 3) . LB
medium (0.5% agar) does not promote swarm-cell differentiation; thus,
serovar Typhimurium remained in the vegetative state . The observed
phenotype was a consequence of swarm-cell differentiation and not the
result of an effect of agar concentration on the function of the
E-test strip .
|
FIG . 3 . E-test strip comparison of polymyxin resistance of strain 14028
in the vegetative and swarm states . Cells were plated on NB containing
either 0.25 or 1.5% agar (vegetative cells) or 0.5% agar (swarm cells) .
In addition, cells were also spread plated on LB plates containing 0.5%
agar because this growth condition does not promote swarming.
|
|
| TABLE 1 . Comparison of antibiotic resistance profiles of vegetative and
swarm cells of serovar Typhimurium 14028
|
|
CS031 was more susceptible to polymyxin (MIC, 0.5 µg ml-1)
than was 14028 (MIC, 8 µg ml-1) in broth, consistent with
previous reports of pmrK mutants (14) . However,
compared with that obtained with polymyxin E-test strips on solid
media, the MIC was higher, at 24 µg ml-1, for both 14028
and CS031 (Table 2) . In addition to the
L-Ara4N modification of lipid A, the mig-14
gene product was recently shown to confer resistance to polymyxin by
an unknown mechanism that is independent of PhoPQ or PmrAB (3),
and four additional genes have been implicated in polymyxin
resistance that are independent of the L-Ara4N
modification (30) . Therefore, other factors may have also
contributed to the observed increase in resistance in both CS031 and
14028 under the growth conditions associated with the E-test assay .
There was virtually no differences in STM2532::lacZ activity
in CS004 under growth conditions that promote vegetative growth
or swarm-cell differentiation (data not shown) . It is unclear whether
the loss of swarming motility in CS004 is the result of the
inactivation of the STM2532 gene or due to polar effects on the
downstream pbpC gene . PbpC is a bifunctional enzyme with both
transpeptidase and transglycosylase activities in E . coli
(22) . The potential loss of pbpC regulation may
have altered some aspect of cell division and other associated
events, leading to a swarm-negative phenotype .
| TABLE 2 . Comparison of antibiotic resistance profiles of swarm mutant
strains CS031 and CS004 on solid plates
|
|
Swarm-cell differentiation is linked to elevated resistance to a wide
variety of antibiotics. On the basis of the observation that mutations
in genes that had been previously implicated in antibiotic resistance
result in loss of swarming motility, we questioned whether swarm-cell
differentiation in serovar Typhimurium is coupled with increased
resistance to other antibiotics . E-test strips representing a
wide variety of antibiotics were used in the same manner as in the
polymyxin resistance assay to compare vegetative and swarm cells of
strain 14028 . As summarized in Table 1, swarm cells
exhibited an antibiotic resistance profile different from that of
cells in the vegetative state . Swarm cells were more resistant to
three of the nine ß-lactam antibiotics tested . The dramatic
morphological changes associated with swarm-cell differentiation may
be indicative of an altered cell wall structure with increased
resistance to disruption, consequently decreasing the effectiveness
of these cell wall-targeting antibiotics . The mechanism(s) underlying
the increased resistance of swarm cells to colistin is most likely
the same as those described for polymyxin (i.e., LPS modification),
since it too is a cationic polypeptide .
The elevated antibiotic resistance phenotype of swarm cells
extended beyond antibiotics that target the cell envelope to
antibiotics that target the components within the cytoplasm,
including protein translation, DNA replication, and transcription
(Table 1) . Dramatic differences were observed with all
aminoglycosides, as the swarm fronts migrated beyond the strips'
maximum MIC of 256 µg/ml (Fig . 4) . The general
mechanism of bacterial resistance to aminoglycosides is based on
enzymatic modifications of the drug (8) that reduce
both the influx rate and activity within the cytoplasm . These
specific enzymes are not present in strain 14028; thus, swarm cells
may exhibit elevated resistance to aminoglycosides either by
increasing the activity of other preexisting enzymes or up-regulating
the expression of novel proteins . The influx rate of aminoglycosides
can be significantly increased by using cell wall-targeting
antibiotics that act synergistically, such as penicillin (8) .
In an inverse fashion, the cell envelope (and LPS) of swarm cells may
already be physically distinct from that of the vegetative cells,
which may indirectly, yet effectively, block the entry of the
aminoglycosides and other antibiotics by a nonenzymatic mechanism . In
support of this view, Macfarlane et al . (18)
demonstrated that mutations in Pseudomonas aeruginosa
that may increase outer membrane stability decrease the permeability
of the outer membrane to aminoglycosides . Furthermore,
membrane-associated LPS and other released exopolysaccharides that
are essential for swarming in serovar Typhimurium (31)
may initially bind and restrict the penetration of aminoglycosides,
as demonstrated with tobramycin in P . aeruginosa (13,
23) .
|
FIG . 4 . Representative E-test strip analyses of vegetative and swarm
cells of strain 14028 . Swarm cells exhibit either no difference
(imipenem) or elevated resistance (ciprofloxacin, tobramycin, and
nalidixic acid) compared to vegetative cells (solid and swim) . Note the
formation of a secondary swarm front in response to ciprofloxacin . All
of the E-test strip results obtained are summarized in Table
1.
|
|
Distinct waves of swarm fronts were associated with heightened
resistance to piperacillin, ceftazidime, ciprofloxacin, and rifampin .
As shown in Fig . 4, an initial swarm front formed
in the presence of ciprofloxacin at 0.25 µg/ml and a secondary swarm
front formed at 6 µg/ml . These distinct fronts are similar in
appearance to the concentric rings generated by Proteus spp.,
representing phases of consolidation, where swarm cells
dedifferentiate into vegetative cells and subsequently redifferentiate
into swarm cells (10) . Although Salmonella spp .
do not normally exhibit phases of consolidation (15),
the observed fronts may represent phases of adaptation and/or
selection in response to increasing levels of antibiotics .
The observed increased resistance of swarm cells to antibiotics
was the result of a transient physiological state . Dedifferentiated
swarm cells (i.e., swarm cells growing at the elevated antibiotic
concentrations inoculated and incubated overnight in fresh liquid NB
[0.5% glucose]) exhibited the same sensitivity to the respective
antibiotics as the primary vegetative cells (Table 3),
confirming that the E-test swarm plate assay did not simply select
for antibiotic-resistant mutants . The altered antibiotic resistance
of swarm cells therefore represents an adaptive change in the
cells . When swarm cells of 14028 were inoculated into LB broth, the
cells were completely killed within 150 min of incubation with lethal
doses of polymyxin and kanamycin (data not shown) . The reversion to
more sensitive states upon dedifferentiation suggests that changes in
gene expression associated with the swarm-cell differentiation and/or
the dilution of the modified LPS upon dedifferentiation are
responsible for the observed phenotypic changes . Interestingly, it
was recently shown that dramatic global transcriptome changes occur
in serovar Typhimurium when it is exposed to sublethal concentrations
of a variety of antibiotics (12) . Since the swarm
cells physically migrate from a region that lacks antibiotics toward
an increasing antibiotic gradient in our assay, they would be
preexposed to subinhibitory concentrations of antibiotics . However,
if such preexposure alone were responsible for the observed elevated
resistance, the vegetative swim cells should have exhibited a similar
phenotype . The antibiotic resistance profiles of mutant strains CS031
and CS004 were much like that of wild-type strain 14028 in the
vegetative state (Table 2) . The resistance profiles
of the strains in the swarm state could not be compared conclusively
because CS031 and CS004 cannot migrate on swarm plates . When the
mutant strains were spread plated onto swarm plates, the resistance
profiles were virtually the same as those observed on solid plates
(data not shown) . This was most likely due to the fact that the
initial inocula were rapidly destroyed in the kill zone before the
cells could properly differentiate into swarm cells .
| TABLE 3 . Comparison of antibiotic resistance profiles of vegetative
cells of serovar Typhimurium 14028 prior to swarm-cell differentiation
and following dedifferentiation from swarm cells that had been exposed
to an antibiotic
|
|
Discussion of global experimental approaches by which to elucidate the
regulatory mechanisms underlying swarming motility and associated phenotypes.
Elevated resistance to a broad spectrum of antibiotics would provide
distinct advantages to Salmonella spp . in a clinical setting .
Although swarming behavior has been demonstrated to play a
significant role in the pathogenesis of numerous organisms (10),
the biological significance of the swarm phenomenon in Salmonella
spp . remains elusive . Construction of isogenic constitutive
swarm-positive and phenotypically nonpleiotropic swarm-negative
mutants may shed light on this issue . All of the clinical isolates of
Salmonella spp . and many of the E . coli isolates that we
have examined to date possess the ability to swarm, and interestingly,
E . coli O157:H7 has exhibited the most prolific swarming
phenotype (V . Sood and M . Surette, unpublished observations) .
Initiation of swarm-cell differentiation is intimately associated
with the nutrient composition of the growth medium and the population
density (10, 15) . Thus, multiple sensory
and regulatory pathways are likely integrated to coordinate the
appropriate expression of genes and/or modification of proteins to
drive swarm-cell differentiation and colony migration in serovar
Typhimurium . Extensive transposon mutagenesis of serovar Typhimurium
generated a large list of candidate genes that may be involved in
swarm-cell differentiation and migration (31) .
However, it is difficult to elucidate the roles of these genetic
elements in swarm-cell differentiation, since all of the reported
mutations resulting in the swarm-negative phenotype were rescued by
simply changing the source of the agar (31) . A
reductive approach, such as random transposon mutagenesis, can
identify key factors required for a cell to go from one state to
another . Antithetically, systemic global approaches can provide
information on the changes that occur as wild-type cells are exposed
to various growth conditions, resulting in distinct physiological
states . In combination with the utility of readily available genomic
information, a global approach may generate more comprehensible data
to aid in the elucidation of mechanisms underlying complex phenomena
such as the swarming behavior of serovar Typhimurium . The phenotypic
increase in resistance to multiple antibiotics observed in swarm
cells is not likely coupled to the mechanisms of swarm-cell
differentiation but rather reflects the unique physiological state of
the swarm cells .
Transcriptomic and proteomic profiling may provide insight into
other physiological phenomena that may be linked to swarming,
including elevated antibiotic resistance . Intriguingly, expression of
numerous virulence factors has been shown to be coregulated with
swarm-cell differentiation in P . mirabilis (11) .
Proteomic comparison of serovar Typhimurium in the swarm and
vegetative states revealed numerous readily detectable differences
(W . Kim and M . G . Surette, unpublished results) . Experiments are
currently in progress to identify these differentially expressed
and modified proteins . This should provide insight not only
into the molecular and biochemical mechanisms that govern swarming
but also into the physiological basis underlying the coregulation of
other linked phenotypes .
Although the specific mechanisms of elevated antibiotic resistance
remain to be elucidated, it is tempting to speculate that some common
traits may be associated with the increased antibiotic resistance
observed in biofilm cells . As reviewed by Stewart (26),
the mechanisms of antibiotic resistance in biofilms are believed to
be quite distinct from the conventional antibiotic resistance
mechanisms . Multiple factors are believed to confer increased
antibiotic resistance in biofilms, including their innate
refractoriness to penetrating antibiotics, coupled with the formation
of persister cells around the perimeters of a growing biofilm, which
are believed to be specifically differentiated to elicit an elevated
protective phenotype . Although Spoering and Lewis (25)
provided convincing evidence that planktonic cells in the stationary
phase of growth exhibit levels of antibiotic resistance comparable to
those of biofilm cells, they also attributed the mechanism of
elevated antibiotic resistance to the presence of persister cells in
the stationary-phase planktonic population . Similarly, the formation
of distinct swarm fronts may be indicative of adaptively
differentiating swarm cells, resulting in a persister-like phenotype .
Moreover, the adaptive resistant state observed in swarm cells does
not appear to be confined to a subset of cells but is observed in the
entire population . This will greatly facilitate the analysis of the
mechanism(s) of this behavior by proteomic approaches . The adaptive
resistance response described here likely plays a significant role in
the successful expansion of a migrating colony, both in and outside a
clinical setting .
We thank D . Woods and J . Davies for providing the E-test strips and
J . Davies for reviewing the manuscript .
This work was supported by a grant from the Canadian Institutes of
Health Research (CIHR) . M.G.S . is also an Alberta Heritage Foundation
for Medical Research Senior Scholar and Canada Research Chair in
Microbial Gene Expression .
* Corresponding author . Mailing address: Department of
Microbiology and Infectious Diseases, University of Calgary, 3330 Hospital Dr .
NW, Calgary, AB, Canada T2N 4N1 . Phone: (403) 220-2744 . Fax: (403) 270-2772 .
E-mail: surette@ucalgary.ca.
Present address: Protiva Biotherapeutics Inc., Burnaby, British
Columbia, Canada .
- Berry, R . M., and J . P . Armitage. 1999 . The bacterial
flagella motor . Adv . Microb . Physiol . 41:291-337.
- Bouret, R . B., and A . M . Stock. 2002 . Molecular
information processing: lessons from bacterial chemotaxis . J . Biol . Chem .
277:9625-9628.
- Brodsky, I . E., R . K . Ernst, S . I . Miller, and S . Falkow.
2002 . mig-14 is a Salmonella gene that plays a role in
bacterial resistance to antimicrobial peptides . J . Bacteriol . 184:3203-3213 .
- Brown, D . F., and L . Brown. 1991 . Evaluation of the E
test, a novel method of quantifying antimicrobial activity . J . Antimicrob .
Chemother . 27:185-190.
- Burkart, M., A . Toguchi, and R . M . Harshey. 1998 . The
chemotaxis system, but not chemotaxis, is essential for swarming motility in
Escherichia coli . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 95:2568-2573 .
- Chamnongpol, S., W . Dodson, M . J . Cromie, Z . L . Harris, and
E . A . Groisman. 2002 . Fe(III)-mediated cellular toxicity . Mol . Microbiol.
45:711-719.
- Chilcott, G . S., and K . T . Hughes. 2000 . Coupling of
flagellar gene expression to flagellar assembly in Salmonella
enterica serovar Typhimurium and Escherichia coli .
Microbiol . Mol . Biol . Rev . 64:694-708 .
- Chow, J . W. 2000 . Aminoglycoside resistance in
enterococci . Clin . Infect . Dis . 31:586-689.
- Dahlquist, F . W. 2002 . Amplification of signaling events
in bacteria . Sci . STKE 2002:PE24.
- Fraser, G . M., and C . Hughes. 1999 . Swarming motility .
Curr . Opin . Microbiol . 2:630-635.
- Fraser, G . M., L . Claret, R . Furness, S . Gupta, and C .
Hughes. 2002 . Swarming-coupled expression of the Proteus
mirabilis hpmBA haemolysin operon . Microbiology 148:2191-2201 .
- Goh, E.-B., G . Yim, W . Tsui, J . McClure, M . G . Surette, and
J . Davies. 2002 . Transcriptional modulation of bacterial gene expression
by subinhibitory concentrations of antibiotics . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA
99:17025-17030 .
- Gordon, C . A., N . A . Hodges, and C . Marriott. 1988 .
Antibiotic interaction and diffusion through alginate and exopolysaccharide or
cystic fibrosis-derived Pseudomonas aeruginosa . J . Antimicrob .
Chemother . 22:667-674.
- Gunn, J . S., S . S . Ryan, J . C . Van Velkinburgh, R . K . Ernst,
and S . I . Miller. 2000 . Genetic and functional analysis of a
PmrA-PmrB-regulated locus necessary for lipopolysaccharide modification,
antimicrobial peptide resistance, and oral virulence of Salmonella
enterica serovar Typhimurium . Infect . Immun . 68:6139-6146 .
- Harshey, R . M., and T . Matsuyama. 1994 . Dimorphic
transition in Escherichia coli and Salmonella
typhimurium: surface-induced differentiation into hyperflagellate swarmer
cells . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 91:8631-8635.
- Kawagashi, I., M . Imagawa, Y . Imae, L . L . McCarter, and M .
Homma. 1996 . The sodium-driven polar flagellar motor of marine Vibrio
as the mechanosensor that regulates lateral flagellar expression . Mol .
Microbiol . 20:693-699.
- Kox, L . F., M . M . Wosten, and E . A . Groisman. 2000 . A
small protein that mediates the activation of a two-component system by
another two-component system . EMBO J . 19:1861-1872 .
- Macfarlane, E . L . A., A . Kwasnicka, and R . E . W . Hancock.
2000 . Role of Pseudomonas aeruginosa PhoP-PhoQ in resistance to
antimicrobial cationic peptides and aminoglycosides . Microbiology 146:2543-2554 .
- Maloy, S . R., V . J . Stewart, and R . K . Taylor. 1996 .
Genetic analysis of pathogenic bacteria: a laboratory manual . Cold Spring
Harbor Laboratory Press, Plainview, N.Y.
- McCoy, A . J., H . Liu, T . J . Falla, and J . S . Gunn. 2001 .
Identification of Proteus mirabilis mutants with increased
sensitivity to antimicrobial peptides . Antimicrob . Agents Chemother . 45:2030-2037 .
- Miller, J . H. 1972 . Experiments in molecular genetics .
Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y.
- Nanninga, N. 1998 . Morphogenesis of Escherichia
coli . Microbiol . Mol . Biol . Rev . 62:110-129 .
- Nichols, W . W., S . M . Dorrington, M . P . Slack, and H . L .
Walmsley. 1988 . Inhibition of tobramycin diffusion by binding to alginate .
Antimicrob . Agents Chemother . 32:518-523.
- Soncini, F . C., and E . A . Groisman. 1996 . Two-component
regulatory systems can interact to process multiple environmental signals . J .
Bacteriol . 178:6796-6801.
- Spoering, A . L., and K . Lewis. 2001 . Biofilms and
planktonic cells of Pseudomonas aeruginosa have similar
resistance to killing by antimicrobials . J . Bacteriol . 183:6746-6751 .
- Stewart, P . S. 2002 . Mechanisms of antibiotic resistance
in bacterial biofilms . Int . J . Med . Microbiol . 292:107-113.
- Stock, J . B., and M . G . Surette. 1996 . Chemotaxis, p .
1103-1129 . In F . C . Neidhardt, R . Curtis III, J . L . Ingraham, E . C . C .
Lin, K . B . Low, B . Magasanik, W . S . Reznikoff, M . Riley, M . Schaechter, and H .
E . Umbarger (ed.), Escherichia coli and Salmonella:
cellular and molecular biology, 2nd ed . ASM Press, Washington, D.C.
- Stock, J . B., M . N . Levit, and P . M . Wolanin. 2002 .
Information processing in bacterial chemotaxis . Sci . STKE 2002:PE25.
- Surette, M . G., M . B . Miller, and B . L . Bassler. 1999 .
Quorum sensing in Escherichia coli, Salmonella
typhimurium, and Vibrio harveyi: a new family of genes
responsible for autoinducer production . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 96:1639-1644 .
- Tamayo, R., S . S . Ryan, A . J . McCoy, and J . S . Gunn.
2002 . Identification and genetic characterization of PmrA-regulated genes
involved in polymyxin B resistance in Salmonella enterica
serovar Typhimurium . Infect . Immun . 70:6770-6778 .
- Toguchi, A., M . Siano, M . Burkart, and R . M . Harshey.
2000 . Genetics of swarming motility in Salmonella enterica
serovar Typhimurium: critical role for lipopolysaccharide . J . Bacteriol .
182:6308-6321 .
- Trent, M . S., A . A . Ribeiro, S . Lin, R . J . Cotter, and C . R .
Raetz. 2001 . An inner membrane enzyme in Salmonella and
Escherichia coli that transfers 4-amino-4-deoxy-L-arabinose
to lipid A: induction on polymyxin-resistant mutants and role of a novel
lipid-linked donor . J . Biol . Chem . 276:43122-43131 .
- Wosten, M . M., and E . A . Groisman. 1999 . Molecular
characterization of the PmrA regulon . J . Biol . Chem . 274:27185-27190 .
- Zhou, Z., A . A . Ribeiro, S . Lin, R . J . Cotter, S . I . Miller,
and C . R . Raetz. 2001 . Lipid A modifications in polymyxin-resistant
Salmonella typhimurium: PmrA-dependent 4-amino-4-deoxy-L-arabinose
and phosphoethanolamine incorporation . J . Biol . Chem . 276:43111-43121 .
Free Online Full-text Article
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
|