|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, February 2004, p . 850-857, Vol . 186,
No . 3
Transferrin-Binding Protein B of Neisseria meningitidis: Sequence-Based
Identification of the Transferrin-Binding Site Confirmed by Site-Directed
Mutagenesis
Geneviève Renauld-Mongénie,1* Laurence
Lins,2 Tino Krell,1 Laure Laffly,1 Michèle
Mignon,1 Monique Dupuy,1 Rose-May Delrue,1,
Françoise Guinet-Morlot,1 Robert Brasseur,2 and Ling
Lissolo1
Aventis Pasteur, 69280 Marcy l'Etoile, France,1 Centre de
Biophysique Moleculaire Numerique, Faculté des Sciences Agronomiques de
Gembloux, Gembloux, Belgium2
Received 29 August 2003/ Accepted 24 October 2003
A sequence-based prediction method was employed to identify three
ligand-binding domains in transferrin-binding protein B (TbpB) of
Neisseria meningitidis strain B16B6 . Site-directed mutagenesis of
residues located in these domains has led to the identification of
two domains, amino acids 53 to 57 and 240 to 245, which are involved
in binding to human transferrin (htf) . These two domains are
conserved in an alignment of different TbpB sequences from N .
meningitidis and Neisseria gonorrhoeae, indicating a
general functional role of the domains . Western blot analysis and
BIAcore and isothermal titration calorimetry experiments demonstrated
that site-directed mutations in both binding domains led to a
decrease or abolition of htf binding . Analysis of mutated proteins by
circular dichroism did not provide any evidence for structural
alterations due to the amino acid replacements . The TbpB mutant R243N
was devoid of any htf-binding activity, and antibodies elicited by
the mutant showed strong bactericidal activity against the homologous
strain, as well as against several heterologous tbpB isotype I
strains .
Through the action of a receptor specific for human transferrin
(htf), meningococci are able to acquire iron ions . This transferrin
receptor of Neisseria meningitidis is composed of two subunits,
TbpA and TbpB (for transferrin-binding proteins A and B) (29),
which are associated in a noncovalent manner (1) . There
is mounting evidence that the receptor consists of one molecule of
TbpA associated with two molecules of TbpB (13,
27) .
TbpA (100 kDa) is thought to be a porin-like integral membrane
protein that is proposed to serve as a channel for the transport of
iron across the outer membrane . Based on significant sequence
similarities with FepA and FhuA (14), TbpA is proposed to
adopt an antiparallel ß-barrel structure (28) .
TbpB (65 to 90 kDa) is considered to be an outer membrane protein
that is anchored to the membrane via the lipidated N-terminal part of
the protein (11) . There is evidence which indicates
that TbpB consists of two globular domains which correspond to
the N- and C-terminal halves of the protein (23) . It has
been shown in vitro that htf binds primarily to the TbpA part
of the receptor and with a lower affinity to TbpB (13) . The
presence of TbpB, however, increases the affinity of TbpA for
the iron-loaded form of htf (13), which thus allows the
bacterial receptor to compete successfully with the htf receptor .
TbpB has been shown to be a potential candidate for an antimeningococcal
vaccine (17) . Meningococcal infections represent a
major worldwide health problem (2), and there is no
vaccine available against serogroup B N . meningitidis . There
is no universal vaccine to control and stop this disease .
Immunization with TbpB has been shown to elicit a protective immune
response in laboratory animals, which has been related to the
production of bactericidal antibodies (17,
24) . Based on genomic and antigenic features of TbpB,
meningococcal strains have been classified into two major families:
isotype I, containing TbpB with a mass of
68
kDa, and isotype II, harboring TbpB with a mass between 80 and 90 kDa
(26) .
The study of this protein has largely been hampered by the absence
of any three-dimensional structural information about TbpB or related
proteins that would allow the generation of a model . According to the
present knowledge of the protein, TbpB interacts with two types of
ligands . First, it has been demonstrated that TbpA and TbpB form a
complex in solution . This association has been shown to be conserved
among different human pathogens (9) . Recent studies
have revealed that both globular domains of TbpB are involved in this
interaction (13) . Secondly, TbpB interacts with
htf . This interaction is restricted to the iron-loaded form of the
protein (holo-htf), since the iron-free form (apo-htf) has only a
negligible binding affinity (22) . Available data
on this holo-htf-binding site are not very consistent . It has been
demonstrated that htf binding occurs primarily on the N-terminal
domain of TbpB (13, 33), but the
participation of the C-terminal domain in ligand binding has also
been demonstrated (21, 23) .
Here, we report the identification of the holo-htf-binding site on
TbpB of a representative tbpB isotype I meningococcal strain,
N . meningitidis B16B6, using a novel approach based on the prediction
of ligand-binding sites from a protein sequence . A recently
described prediction method was shown to identify ligand-binding
sites from a diverse range of protein database entries with a
satisfactory score (10) . We have used this method to identify
the transferrin-binding site on TbpB . As mentioned above, TbpB
binds to two different ligands (TbpA and htf), and the output of the
prediction method corresponds to an overall prediction of binding
sites for both ligands without being able to differentiate between
ligand types . Site-directed mutants were thus prepared in order to
verify the implication of the predicted regions in transferrin
binding . Immunization experiments were carried out with TbpB mutants
devoid of transferrin-binding activity to assess the immunogenicities
of these proteins .
Site-directed mutagenesis, protein expression, and purification of
MBP-TbpB fusion proteins. The construction of a recombinant plasmid
corresponding to the expression vector pMAL-c2 (Biolabs) containing a
DNA fragment coding for amino acids 2 to 579 of TbpB from N .
meningitidis B16B6 (the full-length mature protein devoid of the
N-terminal cysteine) in fusion with the maltose-binding protein (MBP)
has been described previously (22) . Site-directed
mutations were introduced into this plasmid using the Quick Change
site-directed mutagenesis kit (Stratagene) following the
manufacturer's instructions . Lysine (K) or arginine (R) residues were
replaced by asparagine (N) or glutamate (E) using pairs of mutagenic
oligonucleotides, which are listed in Table 1 .
Escherichia coli XL-2 Blue (Stratagene) was transformed with the
resulting plasmids, and bacterial cultures were grown on Luria broth
medium supplemented with 100 µg of ampicillin ml-1 . In all
cases, the introduction of the desired point mutations was verified
by DNA sequencing of the entire tbpB insert .
| TABLE 1 . Primers used for site-directed mutagenesis of MBP-TbpB of N .
meningitidis strain B16B6
|
|
Protein expression was induced by the addition of 0.3 mM isopropyl-ß-D-thiogalactopyranoside,
and MBP-TbpB fusion proteins were purified by affinity chromatography
as reported previously (21) .
Meningococcal strains. N . meningitidis strains B16B6
(B:2a:P1.2), 2713 (B:NT:P1.2), 2717 (B:NT:P1.2), N106/NK (B:NT:P1.5),
and 64/92 (B:2b:NST) were kindly provided by D . Caugant (NIPH, Oslo,
Norway) via B . Rokbi (Aventis Pasteur) . Each strain was grown in
Mueller-Hinton broth medium with the chelator ethylene diamine di-O-hydroxyphenyl-acetic
acid (Sigma) for 4 h to allow the expression of the meningococcal
transferrin receptor .
Secondary-structure prediction. The possibility of changes
to the secondary structure as a consequence of an amino acid
replacement was assessed using the consensus secondary-structure
prediction tool of the NPS@ software (3) .
Analysis of MBP-TbpB proteins by far-UV CD spectroscopy.
Far-UV circular-dichroism (CD) measurements were made at 25°C with a
Jasco (Tokyo, Japan) J-810 spectropolarimeter using cuvettes with a
path length of 0.1 mm . The proteins were exhaustively dialyzed
against 10 mM Na2HPO4-NaH2PO4 and
150 mM NaCl, pH 7.0 . All spectra were corrected using the spectra of
the dialysis buffer . The procedure of Taylor and Kaiser (31)
was used to determine the
-helix
content .
Study of the interaction of MBP-TbpB with holo-htf . (i) Western blot
analysis. The ability of purified MBP-TbpB to bind horseradish
peroxidase-conjugated htf (HRP-htf) (Jackson Immuno-Research
Laboratories) was evaluated by Western blot analysis as described
previously (21) . HRP-htf binding was revealed with
a colorimetric substrate and quantified by densitometric analysis .
(ii) Surface plasmon resonance (BIAcore) studies. Surface
plasmon resonance studies were carried out using the BIAcore
(Uppsala, Sweden) 2000 system . The sensor chip CM5 and the amine
coupling kit (containing N-hydroxysuccinimide, N-ethyl-N'-[3-diethylamino-propyl]-carbodiimide,
and 1 M ethanolamine-hydrochloride, pH 8.5) were also from BIAcore .
The buffer used for sample dilution and analysis was 10 mM HEPES-
150 mM NaCl-3.4 mM EDTA-0.005% BIAcore surfactant, pH 7.4 (HBS
buffer) . Holo-htf was immobilized on activated carboxylated dextran
by a covalent linkage involving the amino groups of the protein using
the protocol provided by the manufacturer . MBP-TbpB solutions at 1 µM
(diluted in HBS buffer) were passed over the sensor chip at a flow
rate of 10 µl min-1 for 9 min . The TbpB-htf ligand complex was then
washed for 6 min with HBS buffer, and the increase in resonance units
with respect to the initial baseline was determined . Data were
corrected using the resonance unit change observed for the binding of
MBP, and the reported data are the means of three experiments .
The sensor chip was regenerated by exposure to 50 mM Tris-HCl-2 M
guanidinium hydrochloride-2 M NaCl, pH 8.0 . The results of multiple
analyses of the same antigen were very similar, indicating that this
regeneration procedure does not alter the immobilized ligand .
(iii) ITC. Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC)
measurements were performed on a VP-Microcalorimeter (MicroCal,
Northampton, Mass.) . MBP-TbpB samples were exhaustively dialyzed into
10 mM Na2HPO4-NaH2PO4 and
150 mM NaCl, pH 7.0 . A solution of 5 mg of holo-htf/ml was made up in
dialysis buffer . Heat changes following a series of injections of
holo-htf into MBP-TbpB were measured . The ligand concentration was
determined using the Micro BCA protein reagent kit (Pierce, Rockford,
Ill.) .
Preparation of hyperimmune rabbit antisera and IgG.
Hyperimmune sera were raised in rabbits by a first administration of
100 µg of purified MBP-TbpB in Freund's adjuvant and two boosts of
100 µg of purified MBP-TbpB in incomplete Freund's adjuvant, and
immunoglobulin G (IgG) was purified from the sera by chromatography
on protein A-Sepharose, as described previously (25) .
Bactericidal assay. The bactericidal activities of purified
rabbit IgGs specific for the various MBP-TbpB fusions have been
determined, as reported earlier (5,
24) . The bactericidal titers were expressed as the last dilution
of purified IgG in which at least 50% killing compared to the
complement control was achieved .
Prediction of binding domains within TbpB from N . meningitidis
B16B6. The prediction of ligand-binding sites in the absence of any
three-dimensional structural information remains a challenge .
However, a recently described method (10) has been shown to
identify binding domains with satisfactory reliability . The
method is based on the determination of the mean hydrophobicity (<H>)
and the mean hydrophobic moment (<µ>) of each residue of the protein
by moving a five-residue window along the sequence . In the resulting
plot of µ = f(H) (Fig . 1), different
regions which provide information on the location of an amino acid in
a protein can be identified . This method has been pioneered by
Eisenberg et al . (7, 8), who defined
three regions, namely, G (globular), S (surface), and M (membrane)
(Fig . 1) . The scope of this method has been improved by
the introduction of a fourth zone called RBD, for receptor binding
domain (Fig . 1) (10) . The authors
demonstrated that amino acid residues present in this zone have an
elevated probability of being part of a ligand-binding site . It has
also been shown that this technique is a universally applicable
method that can be used to define binding sites for a diverse range
of ligands . Indeed, this sequence-based method has already been
successfully applied in the definition of protein-protein interaction
sites for which there is experimental evidence (6,
10, 18) . The term RBD was
introduced by Gallet et al . (10) and is used here in
the sense of a ligand-binding site on a receptor protein, TbpB .
|
FIG . 1 . Plots of <µH> (10-1 kcal/mol)
versus <H> (10-1 kcal/mol) of residues 42SGAAYGFAVKLPRRNAHFNP61
(annotated residues, K51 to A57) of TbpB of N . meningitidis
strain B16B6 . (A) Residues 53PRRNA57 were found to
lie within the RBD zone . (B to D) Evaluation of effects of
single-amino-acid replacements on the positions of the residues in the
RDB zone, indicating changes in binding potential . K51N has no
significant effect on the RBD zone (B); R54N (C) and R55N (D) abolish
the binding potential (the RBD zone is almost empty).
|
|
The sequence of TbpB B16B6 has been submitted to this ligand-binding
prediction method (10), and amino acids with some degree of
binding potential are highlighted in Fig . 2 . Based on
this initial analysis, three clusters of amino acids with detectable
binding potential could be distinguished and were called RBD1, -2,
and -3 . The identification of RBD1 is illustrated in Fig.
1, which shows the plot of <µH>
versus <H> for peptide 42SGAAYGFAVKLPRRNAHFNP61,
which contains RBD1 (in boldface) . In this plot, it is clear that
residues 53 to 57 are found inside the RBD zone, indicating an
elevated possibility of forming part of a ligand-binding site, which
is referred to here as binding potential . Interestingly, all three
RBDs were found to be located in the N-terminal half of TbpB (Fig.
2) .
|
FIG . 2 . Sequence of mature TbpB of N . meningitidis strain B16B6 .
Amino acids predicted to have a strong (red), moderate (blue), or weak
(green) binding potential are highlighted . The three major
receptor-binding domains are boxed.
|
|
Identification of amino acids within the three RBDs with a major impact
on the binding potential. The potential implication of the three
binding domains in htf binding was assessed by site-directed
mutagenesis . The choice of amino acid residues to be mutated was
based on the prediction of the binding potential (Table
2) . The predicted impacts of several amino acid substitutions on
the binding potential of RBD1 are shown in Fig . 1 .
The plot of the unmutated peptide containing RBD1, 42SGAAYGFAVKLPRRNAHFNP61,
is shown in Fig . 1A . A similar plot of the same
peptide in which K51 (in italics) has been replaced with N is shown
in Fig . 1B . It may be noted that the positions of
amino acids within the RBD zone have been only slightly altered, and
consequently, only a slight decrease in the binding potential of RBD1
can be predicted (Table 2) . However, when the two
arginine residues located within RBD1 (R54 and R55) are replaced with
N, the RBD zone of the resulting plot (Fig . 1C and D)
is virtually empty, indicating suppression of the binding potential
of this domain (Table 2) . Peptides containing RBD2
and -3 were submitted to a similar analysis, and the impacts of amino
acid replacements on the receptor binding potential are given in
Table 2 .
| TABLE 2 . Predicted binding potential and qualitative evaluation of
binding of point-mutated MBP-TbpB to HRP-htf
|
|
Based on these results, a series of TbpB point mutants, which are
listed in Table 2, were prepared . The amino acid substitutions
were predicted to have no impact on the secondary structure of
TbpB, as determined by the NPS@ consensus secondary-structure
prediction method (3) . This prediction was confirmed by CD
spectroscopy (see below) .
Binding of wild-type and point-mutated MBP-TbpB to holo-htf.
The binding potentials of wild-type and mutated TbpB to htf have been
evaluated using Western blotting, BIAcore, and ITC . A densitometric
analysis of the reactivity detected after Western blotting revealed
with peroxidase-conjugated htf (Fig . 3) is given in
Table 2 . It is noted that the R55N (RBD1) and R243N
(RBD2) mutants, containing substitutions predicted to suppress htf
binding, have lost their affinity for htf . The implication of both
amino acids in htf binding is confirmed by a reduction in htf binding
seen for the neighboring R54N and R240N mutants . Interestingly,
almost no change in htf binding has been noted for point mutants in
RBD2 (Table 2) .
|
FIG . 3 . Western blot analysis of wild-type and point-mutated MBP-TbpB
with HRP-htf . Crude extracts with equivalent amounts of expressed
wild-type or mutated MBP-TbpB were analyzed for their reactivities to
HRP-hTf at 10 µg/ml.
|
|
Quantification of ligand binding by Western blotting has to be
interpreted with caution, since electrophoretic separation is carried
out in the presence of a denaturing agent . Therefore, several TbpB
mutants have been analyzed by BIAcore, and the binding of different
mutated MBP-TbpB proteins to immobilized holo-htf has been studied .
As for the Western blot study, mutation of R55 and R243 with N either
strongly reduced or abolished htf binding (Table 3) .
No affinity was detected for an additionally prepared mutant, R55E,
containing an amino acid replacement resulting in an opposite charge .
The binding behavior of R80N was similar to that of the wild-type
protein .
| TABLE 3 . Studies of holo-htf binding to wild-type and point-mutated
MBP-TbpB using BIAcore and ITC analyses
|
|
BIAcore analysis involves ligand immobilization, which could
potentially lead to a distortion of the binding parameter . To avoid
any impact of ligand immobilization on binding behavior, ITC has been
used to study the binding affinities to holo-htf (Table
3) . In an ITC experiment, both ligands are unmodified and in
solution (12) . Wild-type MBP-TbpB binds with nanomolar
affinity to htf . This binding affinity is reduced for R55N, and
no binding is observed for R55E and R243N . R80N binds htf in a
fashion similar to that of wild-type TbpB .
In summary, the analyses of point-mutated MBP-TbpBs by three
different techniques converge on the conclusion that mutation of R55
and R243 results in a strong reduction of htf binding for TbpB from
N . meningitidis B16B6 . In contrast, data demonstrate that the
R80N mutant has htf-binding characteristics similar to those of the
wild-type protein .
CD studies of wild-type and point-mutated MBP-TbpB. It has
been demonstrated in the past that the introduction of single point
mutations can result in major structural alterations of the protein,
as shown by far-UV CD spectroscopy (20) . Under
these circumstances, functional changes observed for the mutated
protein cannot be attributed only to the amino acid replaced, and the
data are generally difficult to interpret . In a previous study (13),
it was shown that full-length TbpB has a larger amount of secondary
structure than the individual domains .
Wild-type and point-mutated MBP-TbpB proteins have been analyzed
equally by CD spectroscopy (Fig . 4) . The traces are closely
superimposable, and minor differences can be attributed to the
error associated with the determination of the protein concentration .
Using the procedure of Taylor and Kaiser (31), a
-helix
content of 29 ± 1% has been determined for all fusion proteins .
It can be concluded that all the amino acid substitutions carried
out did not result in major structural alterations of the fusion
protein . However, we cannot exclude the possibility that mutations
gave rise to small conformational rearrangements which did not
affect the secondary structure of the protein .
|
FIG . 4 . Far-UV CD spectra of wild-type and mutated MBP-TbpB proteins .
———, wild-type MBP-TbpB; ———, R55N; - - - - - - - -, R80N; — - - — - -
—, R243N . The CD spectrum of mutant R55E, which for clarity is not
shown, is superimposable on these spectra . Control, MBP alone (— · — ·
—).
|
|
Determination of the bactericidal titer of antibodies elicited with
mutated MBP-TbpB within each RBD region from TbpB B16B6. TbpB is a
potential candidate for inclusion in an antimeningococcal vaccine . In
animal experiments, the protein has been shown to induce bactericidal
antibodies (17) . The influences of amino acid
substitutions on the potential of TbpB to induce bactericidal
antibodies against the homologous strain B16B6 have been determined
(Table 4) . Wild-type MBP-TbpB has been shown to induce a
bactericidal titer of 1,024, whereas MBP alone did not induce any
detectable level of functional antibodies . Point-mutated MBP-TbpB
R55N and R80N conserve their capacities to induce bactericidal
antibodies, although to a lesser extent . In contrast, point-mutated
MBP-TbpB R243N devoid of any htf binding preserves its capacity to
induce a strong bactericidal response compared to the wild type .
| TABLE 4 . Western blot reactivities and bactericidal titers against N .
meningitidis strain B16B6 of rabbit TbpB-specific IgG preparations
elicited with wild-type or point-mutated MBP-TbpB
|
|
Evaluation of the extents of cross-bactericidal activity displayed by
antibodies generated with the MBP-TbpB R243N mutant devoid of htf-binding
activity. The TbpB mutant R243N, shown above to induce a high
bactericidal antibody titer similar to that of the wild type, was
chosen in order to evaluate the cross-bactericidal activity of this
immune response to other tbpB isotype I strains . The difficulty
of achieving broad cross-bactericidal activity is frequently an
obstacle in the development of a protein-based vaccine (24) .
The bactericidal activities of rabbit IgG raised with the MBP-TbpB
R243N mutant toward N . meningitidis strains 2713, 64/92, 106/NK,
and 2717 have been determined (Table 5) . Strong
cross-bactericidal activity against the four heterologous tbpB
isotype I strains was obtained with IgG elicited with the TbpB mutant
R243N . This high cross-bactericidal immune response is comparable to
that observed for the wild-type protein (Table 5) .
| TABLE 5 . Bactericidal titers of rabbit IgG elicited with wild-type or
point-mutated MBP-TbpB R243N toward a range of different tbpB
isotype I meningococcal strains
|
|
Due to numerous genome-sequencing projects, the amount of available
protein sequence information is growing with breathtaking speed .
However, the functions associated with a very large number of
sequences are unknown, and their discovery is a major challenge of
life sciences in this century . Furthermore, the study of a fair
number of proteins with known functions is hampered by the absence of
any three-dimensional structural information .
In this article, we describe the sequence-based prediction and
experimental confirmation of transferrin-binding sites in TbpB . Our
data confirm previous successful predictions, such as for the PBP3
protein from E . coli (18) . This approach might be a
useful tool to obtain information from a sequence about potential
ligand-binding sites, which, combined with mutagenesis studies,
could lead to the identification or better understanding of protein
function .
Two domains, RBD1 and RBD3, are shown to be involved in transferrin
binding of TbpB from the meningococcal strain B16B6 . In particular
R55 and R243, located in these binding domains, are of crucial
importance in htf binding . The importance of arginine residues in
transferrin binding is also consistent with the fact that this amino
acid residue is by far the most frequently found in binding sites (10) .
Three binding domains were initially predicted, of which only RBD1
and -3 were confirmed to be involved in transferrin binding . Here, we
have studied the binding of wild-type and mutant TbpB to htf .
Therefore, the possibility that the presence of TbpA in the receptor
complex masks or distorts binding sites identified in this study
cannot be ruled out . This hypothesis could be verified by studies of
htf binding to N . meningitidis producing mutant protein .
Mutation of residues K76, K77, and R80 in RBD2 had only a marginal
impact on htf-binding capacity . As mentioned above, the prediction
method employed identifies binding domains for both of the TbpB
ligands, TbpA and htf . It is therefore likely that RBD2 corresponds
to a domain which is involved in an interaction with TbpA . It has
been shown (13) that the recombinant N-terminal domain of
TbpB binds to TbpA . However, further analysis is needed to verify
this hypothesis .
All of the experiments were carried out using TbpB strain B16B6,
which raises the question of whether the data obtained are specific
for this tbpB isotype I protein or whether a generalization of
findings with respect to other neisserial tbpB isotype II
strains of N . meningitidis or Neisseria gonorrhoeae is possible .
A sequence alignment of RBD1 and -3 of TbpB derived from tbpB
isotype I and II strains of N . meningitidis and N . gonorrhoeae
is shown in Table 6 . The four major arginine residues
within both RBD1 and RBD3, R54, R55, R240, and R243, are fully
conserved among the five TbpB sequences from tbpB isotype I
strains . This observation clearly indicates that these htf-binding
sites are common in these isotype I proteins .
| TABLE 6 . Sequence alignment of RBD1 and -3a
|
|
The TbpB sequences of N . meningitidis tbpB isotype II strains
and of N . gonorrhoeae strains show 37 to 45% sequence identity
with the B16B6 sequence . However, both RBDs are generally conserved
in the sequence alignment . R54 and R55 are entirely conserved,
whereas R240 and R243 are partially conserved . Interestingly, RBD3 is
fully conserved for the five strains BZ83, 90/94, SB22, 32/94, and
NGPB24, which form part of the previously identified BZ83-like
subisotype (24) . For the amino acid residues in RBD3s
from other tbpB isotype II strains, conservation of the positive
charge is frequently observed (K instead of R) .
An analogous prediction of RBDs using the tbpB isotype II strain
M982 has identified amino acids with ligand-binding potential
in both N- and C-terminal domains of TbpB (data not shown) . This
preliminary result was in agreement with previous observations
indicating that the C-terminal domain could also be involved in
binding to either TbpA or htf (4, 21,
23) .
The two htf-binding sites of B16B6 TbpB are located within the
N-terminal domain of TbpB, described previously as the minimal
htf-binding domain (13, 33) . Recent
studies of the TbpB protein of Moraxella catarrhalis (30)
have led to the identification of six different regions in the
N-terminal half which are implicated in htf binding . It has been
proposed that these six regions interact with the six previously
identified (23) sequence fragments present on the
C-terminal lobe of htf . Both M . catarrhalis and N .
meningitidis TbpBs use htf as a ligand . The TbpB studied here is
isotype I, whereas the Moraxella protein resembles isotype II
proteins, which are characterized by larger size . A sequence
alignment of both proteins shows that the N-terminal domain of the
Neisseria protein is
90
amino acids shorter than its Moraxella counterpart (data not
shown) . However, this alignment also shows that RBD1 and RBD3
described in this article correspond to two of the binding regions
reported for Moraxella TbpB, htf-binding regions 1 and 5,
respectively (30) . We have predicted additional
amino acid sequences with moderate or weak binding potential (Fig.
2); however, they have not been further studied by
mutagenesis . Several of these additional sites, namely, 155EPS157,
250ENKQIK255, and 270FK271,
were found to align with binding regions identified for Moraxella
TbpB . Only two of the six binding regions in the Moraxella
TbpB, namely, regions 3 and 4 (30), were shown to
have Neisseria counterparts, which were not predicted in our
study to be involved in htf binding . Furthermore, the six htf-binding
regions identified for Moraxella TbpB did not align with RBD2 .
This is consistent with our data, which show that RBD2 is not
involved in htf binding . A high binding potential has been predicted
for this domain (Fig . 2) . We propose the implication of this
domain in binding to TbpA, which remains to be studied in detail .
Furthermore, our data are consistent with a report by Gorringe
et al . (A . R . Gorringe, L . I . Irons, P . Aisen, P . Zak, and A .
Robinson, Proc . Ninth Int . Pathog . Neisseria Conf., Winchester,
England, p . 140-141, 1994) who demonstrated that antibodies generated
by immunization with the peptide corresponding to amino acids 43 to
56 (comprising RBD1) of the tbpB isotype II strain M982
inhibit the binding of holo-htf to TbpB . Taken together, these data
point to a general role for RBD1 and RBD3 in htf binding for a
diverse range of different TbpB proteins .
The overall aim of this study, apart from its contribution to the
general knowledge of the protein, is to explore the possibility of
TbpB as a vaccine candidate against meningococcal disease . However,
vaccination with TbpB implies that the antigen may, immediately after
injection, form a complex with holo-htf present in human body fluids .
This may mask certain epitopes and may cause conformational
alterations to the antigen . To avoid a postinjection modification of
TbpB, attempts are made to alter the transferrin-binding site in a
manner that prevents htf from binding without perturbing the overall
structure or reducing its capacity to induce bactericidal antibodies .
This goal has clearly been achieved here . Western blot analysis and
BIAcore and ITC studies (Tables 2 and
3) provide evidence that TbpB R243N is devoid of any htf-binding
activity, and CD spectroscopy (Fig . 4) shows that
this mutation did not perturb the overall structure of TbpB . Rabbit
sera derived from immunization experiments with this TbpB mutant had
similarly strong cross-bactericidal activities compared to that of
the wild-type against other tbpB isotype I strains . The TbpB
mutant R243N described in this study can thus be regarded as a
vaccine candidate .
We thank Luc Aujame for critical reading of the manuscript . We are
grateful to Sophie Fraysse, Sophie Naville, Marie-Claire Nicolai, and
Frédéric Gréco for technical assistance . We also thank Michel
Chevalier, Mireille Latour, and Marie-José Quentin-Millet for helpful
discussions .
* Corresponding author . Mailing address: Aventis Pasteur, 1541
Ave . Marcel Mérieux, 69280 Marcy l'Etoile, France . Phone: (33) 4 37 37 35 05 .
Fax: (33) 4 37 37 36 39 . E-mail:
genevieve.renauld@aventis.com .
Present address: Unité de Recherche en Biologie Moléculaire, FUNDP,
Namur, Belgium .
- Boulton, I . C., A . R . Gorringe, R . J . Carr, B . Gorinsky, C .
L . Joannou, and R . W . Evans. 1997 . Characterisation of the meningococcal
transferrin-binding protein complex by photon correlation spectroscopy . FEBS
Lett . 414:409-413.
- Caugant, D . A., L . O . Froholm, K . Bovre, E . Holten, C . E .
Frasch, L . F . Mocca, W . D . Zollinger, and R . K . Selander. 1986 .
Intercontinental spread of a genetically distinctive complex of clones of
Neisseria menigitidis causing epidemic disease . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA
83:4927-4931.
- Combet, C., C . Blanchet, C . Geourjon, and G . Deléage.
2000 . NPS@: Network Protein Sequence Analysis . Trends Biochem . Sci . 25:147-150.
- Cornelissen, C . N., J . E . Anderson, and P . F . Sparling.
1997 . Characterization of the diversity and the transferrin-binding domain of
gonococcal transferrin-binding protein 2 . Infect . Immun . 65:822-828.
- Danve, B., L . Lissolo, M . Mignon, P . Dumas, S . Colombani, A .
B . Schryvers, and M.-J . Quentin-Millet. 1993 . Transferrin-binding proteins
isolated from Neisseria meningitidis elicit protective and bactericidal
antibodies in laboratory animals . Vaccine 11:1214-1220.
- De Loof, H., M . Rossenau, R . Brasseur, and J . M . Ruysschaert.
1986 . Use of hydrophobicity profiles to predict receptor binding domains on
apolipoprotein E and the low-density lipoprotein apolipoprotein B-E receptor .
Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 83:2295-2299.
- Eisenberg, D., R . M . Weiss, and T . C . Terwilliger. 1982 .
The helical hydrophobic moment: a measure of the amphiphilicity of a helix .
Nature 299:371-374.
- Eisenberg, D., E . Schwarz, M . Komaromy, and R . Wall.
1984 . Analysis of membrane and surface protein sequences with the hydrophobic
moment plot . J . Mol . Biol . 179:125-142.
- Fuller, C . A., R . Yu, S . W . Irwin, and A . B . Schryvers.
1998 . Biochemical evidence for a conserved interaction between bacterial
transferrin-binding protein A and transferrin-binding protein B . Microb .
Pathog . 24:75-87.
- Gallet, X., B . Charloteaux, A . Thomas, and R . Brasseur.
2000 . A fast method to predict protein interaction sites from sequences . J .
Mol . Biol . 302:917-926.
- Gray-Owen, S . D., and A . B . Schryvers. 1996 . Bacterial
transferrin and lactoferrin receptors . Trends Microbiol . 14:843-850.
- Holdgate, G . A. 2001 . Making cool drugs hot: the use of
isothermal titration calorimetry as a tool to study binding energetics .
BioTechniques 31:164-184.
- Krell, T., G . Renauld-Mongenie, M.-C . Nicolai, S . Fraysse,
M . Chevalier, Y . Berard, J . Oakhill, R . W . Evans, A . Gorringe, and L . Lissolo.
2003 . Insight into the structure and function of the transferrin receptor from
Neisseria meningitidis using microcalorimetric techniques . J . Biol .
Chem . 278:14712-14722 .
- Legrain, M., V . Mazarin, S . W . Irwin, B . Bouchon, M.-J .
Quentin-Millet, E . Jacobs, and A . B . Schryvers. 1993 . Cloning and
characterization of Neisseria meningitidis genes encoding the
transferrin-binding proteins Tbp1 and Tbp2 . Gene 130:73-80.
- Legrain, M., A . Findeli, D . Villeval, M.-J . Quentin-Millet,
and E . Jacobs. 1996 . Molecular characterization of hybrid Tbp2 proteins
from Neisseria meningitidis . Mol . Microbiol . 19:159-169.
- Legrain, M., B . Rokbi, D . Villeval, and E . Jacobs. 1998 .
Characterization of genetic exchanges between various highly divergent tbpBs
having occurred in Neisseria meningitidis . Gene 208:51-59.
- Lissolo, L., G . Maitre-Wilmotte, P . Dumas, S . Colombani, A .
B . Schryvers, and M.-J . Quentin-Millet. 1995 . Evaluation of
transferrin-binding protein 2 within the transferrin-binding protein complex
as a potential antigen for future meningococcal vaccines . Infect . Immun .
63:884-890.
- Marrec-Fairley, M., A . Piette, X . Gallet, R . Brasseur, H .
Hara, C . Faipont, J.-M . Ghysen and J.-M . Nguyen-Distèche. 2000 .
Differential functionalities of amphiphilic peptide segments of the
cell-septation penicillin-binding protein 3 of Escherichia coli . Mol .
Microbiol . 37:1019-1031.
- Mazarin, V., B . Rokbi, and M.-J . Quentin-Millet. 1995 .
Diversity of the transferrin-binding protein Tbp2 of Neisseria meningitidis .
Gene 158:145-146.
- Nairn, J., N . C . Price, S . M . Kelly, D . Rigden, L . A .
Fothergill-Gilmore, and T . Krell. 1996 . Phosphoglycerate mutase from
Schizosccharomyces pombe: development of an expression system and
characterization of three histidine mutants of the enzyme . Biochim . Biophys .
Acta 1296:69-75.
- Renauld-Mongenie, G., D . Poncet, L . von Olleschik-Elbheim,
T . Cournez, M . Mignon, M . A . Schmidt, and M.-J . Quentin-Millet. 1997 .
Identification of human transferrin-binding sites within meningococcal
transferrin-binding protein B . J . Bacteriol . 179:6400-6407.
- Renauld-Mongénie, G., M . Latour, D . Poncet, S . Naville, and
M.-J . Quentin-Millet. 1998 . Both the full-length and the N-terminal domain
of the meningococcal transferrin-binding protein B discriminate between human
iron-loaded and apo-transferrin . FEMS Microbiol . Lett . 169:171-177.
- Retzer, M . D., R . Yu, and A . B . Schryvers. 1999 .
Identification of sequences in human transferrin that bind to the bacterial
receptor protein, transferrin-binding protein B . Mol . Microbiol . 32:111-121.
- Rokbi, B., G . Renauld-Mongenie, M . Mignon, B . Danve, D .
Poncet, C . Chabanel, D . A . Caugant, and M . J . Quentin-Millet. 2000 .
Allelic diversity of the two transferrin binding protein B gene isotypes among
a collection of Neisseria meningitidis strains representative of
serogroup B disease: implication for the composition of a recombinant
TbpB-based vaccine . Infect . Immun . 68:4938-4947 .
- Rokbi, B., M . Mignon, G . Maitre-Wilmott, L . Lissolo, B .
Danve, D . A . Caugant, and M . J . Quentin-Millet. 1997 . Evaluation of
recombinant transferrin-binding protein B variants from Neisseria
meningitidis for their ability to induce cross-reactive and bactericidal
antibodies against a genetically diverse collection of serogroup B strains .
Infect . Immun . 65:55-63.
- Rokbi, B., V . Mazarin, G . Maitre-Willmotte, and M . J .
Quentin-Millet. 1993 . Identification of two major families of transferrin
receptors among Neisseria meningitidis strains based on antigenic and
genomic features . FEMS Microbiol . Lett . 110:51-58.
- Ronpirin, C., A . E . Jerse, and C . N . Cornelisson. 2001 .
Gonococcal genes encoding transferrin-binding proteins A and B are arranged in
a bicistronic operon but are subject to differential expression . Infect .
Immun . 69:6336-6347 .
- Schryvers, A . B., and I . I . Stojilkovic. 1999 . Iron
acquisition systems in the pathogenic Neisseria . Mol . Microbiol . 32:1117-1123.
- Schryvers, A . B., and L . J . Morris. 1988 . Identification
and characterization of the transferrin receptor from Neisseria
meningitidis . Mol . Microbiol . 2:281-288.
- Sims, K . L., and A . B . Schryvers. 2003 . Peptide-peptide
interactions between human transferrin and transferrin-binding protein B from
Moraxella catarrhalis . J . Bacteriol . 185:2603-2610 .
- Taylor, J . W., and E . T . Kaiser. 1987 .
Structure-function analysis of proteins through the design, synthesis, and
study of peptide models . Methods Enzymol . 154:473-498.
- Tettelin, H., N . J., Saunders, J . Heidelberg, A . C .
Jeffries, K . E . Nelson, J . A . Eisen, K . A . Ketchum, D . W . Hood, J . F . Peden,
R . J . Dodson, W . C . Nelson, M . L . Gwinn, R . DeBoy, J . D . Peterson, E . K .
Hickey, D . H . Haft, S . L . Salzberg, O . White, R . D . Fleischmann, B . A .
Dougherty, T . Mason, A . Ciecko, D . S . Parksey, E . Blair, H . Cittone, E . B .
Clark, M . D . Cotton, T . R . Utterback, H . Khouri, H . Qin, J . Vamathevan, J .
Gill, V . Scarlato, V . Masignani, M . Pizza, G . Grandi, L . Sun, H . O . Smith, C .
M . Fraser, E . R . Moxon, R . Rappuoli, and J . C . Venter. 2000 . Complete
genome sequence of Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B strain MC58 .
Science 287:1809-1815 .
- Vonder Haar, R . A., M . Legrain, H . V . J . Kolbe, and E .
Jacobs. 1994 . Characterization of a highly structured domain in Tbp2 from
Neisseria meningitidis involved in binding to human transferrin . J .
Bacteriol . 176:6207-6213.
Free Online Full-text Article
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
|