|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, June 2004, p . 3749-3759, Vol . 186,
No . 12
Characterization and Functional Analysis of the poxB Gene, Which Encodes
Pyruvate Oxidase in Lactobacillus plantarum
Frédérique Lorquet,1,
Philippe Goffin,1 Lidia Muscariello,2 Jean-Bernard Baudry,1,
Victor Ladero,1,
Margherita Sacco,2 Michiel Kleerebezem,3 and Pascal Hols1*
Unité de Génétique, Institut des Sciences de la Vie, Université catholique de
Louvain, B-1348 Louvain-La-Neuve, Belgium,1 Dipartimento di Scienze
Ambientali, Seconda Universitŕ di Napoli, 81100 Caserta, Italy,2
Wageningen Centre for Food Sciences, NIZO Food Research, 6710 BA Ede, The
Netherlands3
Received 12 November 2003/ Accepted 1 March 2004
The pyruvate oxidase gene (poxB) from Lactobacillus plantarum
Lp80 was cloned and characterized . Northern blot and primer
extension analyses revealed that transcription of poxB is monocistronic
and under the control of a vegetative promoter . poxB mRNA
expression was strongly induced by aeration and was repressed by
glucose . Moreover, Northern blotting performed at different stages of
growth showed that poxB expression is maximal in the early
stationary phase when glucose is exhausted . Primer extension and in
vivo footprint analyses revealed that glucose repression of poxB
is mediated by CcpA binding to the cre site identified in the
promoter region . The functional role of the PoxB enzyme was
studied by using gene overexpression and knockout in order to
evaluate its implications for acetate production . Constitutive
overproduction of PoxB in L . plantarum revealed the predominant
role of pyruvate oxidase in the control of acetate production
under aerobic conditions . The
poxB
mutant strain exhibited a moderate (20 to 25%) decrease in acetate
production when it was grown on glucose as the carbon source, and
residual pyruvate oxidase activity that was between 20 and 85% of the
wild-type activity was observed with glucose limitation (0.2%
glucose) . In contrast, when the organism was grown on maltose, the
poxB mutation resulted in a large (60 to 80%) decrease in acetate
production . In agreement with the latter observation, the level
of residual pyruvate oxidase activity with maltose limitation (0.2%
maltose) was less than 10% of the wild-type level of activity .
Lactobacillus plantarum is a facultative heterofermentative
bacterium (24) . Under anaerobic conditions with excess
glucose, lactate is the major fermentation end product . Glucose is
transported through the membrane by a phosphotransferase system (PTS)
and then used by the Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas pathway to produce
pyruvate . This pathway generates energy and consumes NAD+ .
Pyruvate is then converted into L- and
D-lactate by the stereospecific NAD-dependent
lactate dehydrogenases (LDHs), LdhL and LdhD (7), which
regenerates NAD+ and maintains the redox balance (Fig.
1) . However, pyruvate dissipation by different
metabolic pathways that result in a mixed acid fermentation has also
been observed (7) . Acetate is the second major
fermentation product in L . plantarum (7,
31, 43) . Various pathways for acetate
production from pyruvate have been identified in this species (Fig.
1) . Pyruvate can be metabolized anaerobically into
acetate via pyruvate formate lyase, phosphotransacetylase, and
acetate kinase (ACK) (Fig . 1) (27) .
A second possible pathway for acetate production is via the pyruvate
dehydrogenase complex (PDH), phosphotransacetylase, and ACK (Fig.
1) . This pathway is thought to be mainly active
under aerobic conditions since PDH is strongly inhibited under
anaerobic conditions by the relatively high NADH level (3) .
Although putative pdh genes were recently identified in the
genome sequence, it was reported that L . plantarum had no
detectable PDH activity under various growth conditions (6,
18, 25, 30) .
Previous physiological studies of L . plantarum indicated that
acetate production is maximal under aerobic conditions with glucose
limitation . Under these conditions, acetate originates from lactate
utilization (14, 31) . The proposed pathway
for conversion of lactate to acetate is via two stereospecific
lactate oxidases (LoxL and LoxD), pyruvate oxidase (POX), and ACK (14,
31) (Fig . 1) . It has been proposed
that POX plays a key role in this pathway (43) .
This enzyme uses oxygen to convert pyruvate into acetyl-phosphate,
which results in the production of CO2 and H2O2
(Fig . 1); H2O2 detoxification can
subsequently take place via the NADH peroxidase (14,
15) .
|
FIG . 1 . Lactate and acetate production pathways in L . plantarum .
EMP, Embden-Meyerhof Parnas pathway; LOX, lactate oxidases; PFL,
pyruvate formate lyase; PTA, phosphotransacetylase; CoA, coenzyme A; X,
electron acceptor.
|
|
POX activity in L . plantarum is induced by oxygen or hydrogen
peroxide and is repressed by glucose (30, 31,
43) . These effects have been observed at the
enzymatic level, but the regulation mechanisms have not been
elucidated . Glucose repression in gram-positive bacteria mainly
involves catabolite control protein A (CcpA), whose role in L .
plantarum was recently established (32) . The
molecular mechanisms of oxygen regulation in lactic acid bacteria are
not known since transcriptional regulators directly involved have not
been identified yet .
Acetate production via ACK in L . plantarum is accompanied by
ATP production . It has been observed that aerobic growth leads
to increased production of biomass compared to the production of
biomass under anaerobic growth conditions, and it has been
hypothesized that the additional ATP produced by ACK contributes to
the greater biomass (3, 31,
47) . Acetate is an important flavor compound of fermented
products in which L . plantarum plays a major role (8,
45) . At low pH, acetate functions as a
membrane-uncoupling agent, inhibiting the growth of competing
microorganisms (2, 9, 40) .
Due to these properties, a better understanding of the role of the
POX involved in acetate production could contribute to improvement of
fermentation processes .
An L . plantarum POX (PoxB), which is present in the cytoplasm
as a homotetramer (262 kDa), has previously been purified and
characterized, and its three-dimensional structure has been
determined (28, 29, 39,
42) . Recent examination of the genome sequence
revealed four putative proteins (lp_0849, lp_0852, lp_2629, and
lp_3587) that exhibit levels of identity of between 40 and 44% with
the PoxB enzyme (25) . In this paper we describe
the expression pattern of the poxB gene with respect to glucose
and oxygen regulation . In order to elucidate the functional
role of PoxB, the poxB gene was constitutively overexpressed,
and a stable knockout mutant was constructed . The two mutant strains
were analyzed with respect to POX activity and acetate production .
Bacterial strains, plasmids, and growth conditions. The
bacterial strains and plasmids used in this study are listed in Table
1 . Escherichia coli was grown in Luria broth with
aeration at 37°C (41) . L . plantarum was
grown in MRS medium (Becton Dickinson, Cockeysville, Md.) at 28°C .
Fermentation experiments were performed in modified MRS broth (MRS-CA
medium) (1% tryptone, 0.8% beef extract, 0.4% yeast extract, 0.2% K2HPO4,
0.1% Tween 80, 0.041% MgSO4 · 7H2O, 0.0066%
MnCl2) supplemented with 2 or 0.2% (wt/vol) glucose or
maltose . Citrate and acetate were omitted from the original medium as
both of these compounds inhibit acetate production or POX activity.
L . plantarum aerated cultures were grown in baffled flasks
with shaking, whereas anaerobic cultures were grown in containers by
using the GasPak system (Becton Dickinson) . Antibiotics were used at
the following concentrations: erythromycin, 250 µg/ml for E . coli
and 10 µg/ml for L . plantarum; and chloramphenicol, 20 µg/ml
for E . coli and 5 µg/ml for L . plantarum .
| TABLE 1 . Bacterial strains, plasmids, and oligonucleotides
|
|
DNA techniques and transformation. L . plantarum
chromosomal DNA was prepared as described previously (13).
L . plantarum was electroporated as reported previously (23) .
All DNA manipulations were performed by using established procedures
(41) . The primers used in this study are listed in
Table 1 . In order to perform an in vivo footprint analysis of
the poxB regulatory region, cultures of strains LM3 and LM3-2
were treated with dimethyl sulfate (Aldrich, Bornem, Belgium)
at the onset of the stationary phase . The in vivo footprinting
experiments were performed as previously described by using primer
pox5 to probe the top strand (32) .
Primer extension analysis and RNA hybridization. Total RNA
was extracted from L . plantarum Lp80 by mechanical lysis with
glass beads as described previously (5) . Primer extension
and sequencing reactions were performed by using nested primers
pox4 and pox5 as described previously (13) . The pox5 primer
was designed to be highly specific for poxB since it contained
at least eight mismatches in 22 nucleotides (including one mismatch
in the last two nucleotides at the 3' end) with the corresponding
regions of the four other putative pox genes . The DNA template
used in the sequencing reaction was plasmid pGIF004 containing
the promoter region of poxB . Total RNA from L . plantarum LM3
and LM3-2 (ccpA1) cells grown to the early stationary phase
were isolated, and primer extension products of poxB transcripts
were obtained by using primer pox5, as described previously (32) .
Northern blot experiments were performed as previously described (5) .
A central fragment of the poxB gene was used as a probe for
the Northern blot experiments . This fragment was PCR amplified with
primers pox7 and pox8 and was radiolabeled with [ -32P]dATP
by using a Random Primer labeling kit (Invitrogen Corporation,
Carlsbad, Calif.) . This probe was specific for poxB since it
did not exhibit more than 50% identity with the corresponding
fragments of the four other putative pox genes .
Construction of plasmids for knockout and overexpression of poxB.
The pJIM2374 plasmid was used as a suicide vector ( repA)
for the poxB gene knockout in L . plantarum . This
plasmid was maintained in E . coli EC1000, which contained a
functional chromosomal copy of the repA gene required for its
replication (21) . An internal fragment of poxB
was amplified by PCR with primers pox7 and pox8 and cloned into the
SmaI site of pJDC9 (1) . This fragment was recovered
from the resulting plasmid as a 0.6-kb KpnI-HindIII fragment and was
cloned into similarly digested pJIM2374, yielding pGIF003 . A second
poxB fragment was amplified by PCR with primers pox2 and pox6
and was cloned into NcoI-KpnI-digested pGIF003, yielding pGIF010 . In
order to overexpress the poxB gene in L . plantarum, a
1.8-kb poxB fragment was amplified by PCR by using primers
pox10 and pox11 containing a PstI restriction site and an XbaI
restriction site, respectively . The resulting fragment containing the
complete poxB open reading frame (ORF) was cloned into
NsiI-XbaI-digested pGIZ906, yielding pGIF101 . In pGIF101, the poxB
coding region was translationally fused to the expression signals
from the ldhL gene of L . plantarum . This plasmid was
then transformed into L . plantarum Lp80 .
Cloning of the 5' and 3' regions of poxB. The suicide
plasmid pGIF003, which contained an internal fragment of the poxB
gene, was integrated by a single crossover into the chromosome of
L . plantarum Lp80 . Chromosomal DNA from one selected integrant
was extracted and digested with KpnI and with NdeI in order to
recover the 5' and 3' regions, respectively . Two plasmids, designated
pGIF004 and pGIF009, respectively, were obtained following
self-ligation of the restriction products and transformation in E .
coli EC1000 . pGIF004 contained a 0.9-kb fragment of the upstream
region of poxB (KpnI restriction), and pGIF009 contained a
9.0-kb fragment of the downstream region of poxB (NdeI
restriction) . The 0.9-kb fragment and 690 bp of the 9-kb fragment
were sequenced on both strands .
Stable knockout of poxB. In order to construct a
stable poxB mutant, the gene was deleted from the L .
plantarum chromosome by two successive crossover events . The
suicide plasmid pGIF010 contained a poxB gene fragment with a
0.6-kb in-frame deletion, which removed most of the core domain and
one-third of the flavin adenine dinucleotide binding domain (28,
29) . Single-crossover pGIF010 integrants were selected
on the basis of erythromycin resistance, and the anticipated
poxB locus genotype was confirmed by PCR by using primers pox3
and pox8, which amplified the complete poxB gene, as well as
the deleted version . Excision of the plasmid leading to the mutant
genotype was performed by successive culture cycles without
antibiotics for 200 generations and subsequent screening for the loss
of erythromycin resistance . The anticipated poxB deletion in
mutant strain FL104 ( poxB)
was confirmed by PCR performed with primers pox1 and pox9 (data not
shown) .
POX assay. Crude cell extracts were prepared from a 50-ml
culture pellet . The pellet was washed once with 1 volume of 50 mM
sodium phosphate buffer (pH 6.5) and was resuspended in the same
buffer . The cells were lysed with glass beads (diameter, 0.17 µm)
by using a Braun homogenizer (Braun, Melsungen, Germany) (5) .
The lysate was centrifuged, and the POX activity in the freshly
prepared supernatant was measured . Pyruvate decarboxylation was
determined by oxidative coupling of the reaction product, H2O2,
with 4-aminoantipyrine ( 546
= 16.2 mmol–1 liter–1 cm–1) in the presence of
horseradish peroxidase and sodium 2-hydroxy-3,5-dichlorobenzene
sulfonate (39) . Production of H2O2
in the POX assay was strictly dependent on the presence of pyruvate,
but a possible coupling between PDH and NADH oxidase H2O2-forming
activities could also result in H2O2 production .
This interference in the assay was excluded since addition of
NAD+ in the presence of pyruvate to activate a possible PDH
activity had no effect on H2O2 production . A very
low level of NADH oxidase H2O2-forming activity
was detected in some samples after addition of NADH alone, but a
combination of NADH and pyruvate had no detectable effect on H2O2
production . Specific POX activity was expressed in units; 1 U was
defined as 1 µmol of pyruvate consumed per min per mg of protein . The
total protein concentration was measured by the Bio-Rad protein assay
method (Bio-Rad, Munich, Germany) .
LDH assay. Aliquots (1 ml) of a culture were withdrawn at
various times, cells were removed by centrifugation at 12,000
x g for 5 min, and the
supernatants were stored immediately at –20°C until enzyme assays
were performed . The LDH activity in the supernatants was determined
by using pyruvate as the substrate as previously reported (13) .
One unit of activity corresponded to oxidation of 1 µmol of NADH ( 340
= 6.3 mmol–1 liter–1 cm–1) per min .
SDS-PAGE and Western blotting. Sodium dodecyl
sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) was performed
as described previously (20) . Proteins were
electrophoretically blotted on a Hybond-C nitrocellulose membrane
(Amersham, Buckinghamshire, England) by using the Mini transblot
system (Bio-Rad, Hercules, Calif.) . The subsequent steps were carried
out as specified by the supplier of the Western blot AP system
(Promega, Madison, Wis.) . Immunoblotting was performed with anti-POX
polyclonal antibodies (1/100 dilution) as the primary antibodies,
which were kindly provided by Lucie Frey (9) .
Cell suspensions and fermentation end product analysis. Cell
suspensions were prepared as described previously (20) .
Cells were grown under anaerobic conditions on 2% glucose until
the mid-exponential phase (optical density at 600 nm [OD600],
2.5), harvested by centrifugation, washed twice with 1 volume
of 100 mM sodium phosphate buffer (pH 6.5), and resuspended in 1/10
the initial culture volume with the same buffer containing 50 mM
glucose . Cell suspensions were incubated with aeration at 30°C for 24
h, and supernatant samples were taken at different times during
incubation . Glucose, maltose, lactate, and acetate contents were
analyzed by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) by using
the method of Starrenburg and Hugenholtz (44) .
Nucleotide sequence accession number. The nucleotide
sequence of the poxB gene of L . plantarum Lp80 has been
deposited in the DDJB, EMBL, and GenBank databases under accession
number
AY458428 .
Characterization of the poxB gene from L . plantarum Lp80.
The sequence of the poxB ORF from L . plantarum has been determined
previously (G . Schumacher, 2 May 1990, European Patent Office) .
In order to identify poxB transcription signals and to determine
the organization of the locus, the 5' and 3' regions surrounding
the poxB ORF were cloned . The nucleotide sequence of the poxB
coding sequence from Lp80 was 99% identical to the previously
reported poxB sequence (EMBL accession no.
A07753) . Fifteen substitutions were identified; one of these
substitutions led to an amino acid modification (Ala247 Val247)
in the PoxB protein sequence from Lp80 . This residue has not been
reported to be involved in catalysis, cofactor binding, or subunit
association (28, 29,
46) . The complete nucleotide sequence of the poxB
locus (2,880 bp) from Lp80 exhibited 98% identity (29 substitutions)
to the corresponding locus in the genome sequence of L . plantarum
WCFS1 (25) .
The transcription initiation site of the poxB gene was mapped
by primer extension analysis in Lp80 (data not shown) and LM3
(Fig . 2E) . The 5' regions of poxB from the two strains
were identical up to 100 bp upstream of the ATG start codon (data
not shown) . The nucleotide at position 1 was located 46 nucleotides
upstream of the ATG start codon in both L . plantarum strains
(Fig . 3A) . A putative
A
vegetative promoter was identified, and this promoter was composed of
a potential –35 box (TTGAAT) and an extended –10 box (TGNTAATAT)
(conserved nucleotides are underlined) (16) . A
potential Shine-Dalgarno sequence was also identified, and it had a
free energy ( Gf)
of –11.8 kcal/mol, which is similar to values obtained for
L . plantarum (19) . A putative hairpin ( Gf
= –16.4 kcal/mol) that may act as a transcription terminator was
identified downstream of the poxB ORF .
|
FIG . 2 . Transcriptional regulation of L . plantarum poxB . (A)
Northern blot analysis of poxB in Lp80 and FL104 total RNA
performed with an internal poxB fragment as the probe . Cells were
grown under anaerobic conditions (–) or under aerobic conditions (+) on
2% glucose or 0.2% glucose and were harvested in the early stationary
phase . (B) RNA electrophoresis of the Northern blot in panel A . (C)
Northern blot analysis of poxB in Lp80 RNA prepared at different
growth stages . Aerated cells grown on 0.2% glucose were harvested, and
the total RNA was extracted at various times (as indicated at the top) .
(D) RNA electrophoresis of the Northern blot in panel C . (E) Primer
extension analysis of poxB mRNA . Primer extension products were
obtained by using primer pox5 and total RNA extracted from LM3 and LM3-2
cells grown with aeration on 2 or 0.2% glucose . The transcription start
is indicated by an asterisk . As a reference, sequencing reactions were
performed with plasmid pGIF004 and the same primer . (F) In vivo
footprinting analysis of the poxB regulatory region . The analysis
was performed with methylated DNA extracted from LM3 and LM3-2 cells
grown on 2 or 0.2% glucose . G, A, T, and C indicate the nucleotide
sequencing reactions for the top strand . G residues in the methylated
strand correspond to C residues in the sequencing lane . The arrow
indicates the G residue protected from dimethyl sulfate attack, and the
asterisk indicates the relative position of this residue in the cre
sequence.
|
|
|
FIG . 3 . Genetic characteristics of the poxB gene . (A) Nucleotide
sequence of the 5' and 3' regions of the poxB gene . The facing
arrows indicate the putative transcription terminator . –35 and –10,
vegetative promoters; +1, transcription start site mapped by primer
extension; cre, CcpA binding site identified by in vivo
footprinting; ohrR, putative OhrR binding site including direct
repeats (arrows); SD, Shine-Dalgarno sequence . (B) Alignment of the
cre site from poxB with the consensus sequence for CcpA
binding (20) and alignment of the putative OhrR
binding site with the B . subtilis OhrR binding site found in the
promoter region of ohrA (10, 11).
|
|
In order to identify putative oxygen-dependent (or oxygen derivative-dependent)
and glucose-dependent regulator binding sites, the 5' region of
the poxB ORF was examined . Between the –35 and –10 boxes, a
cre-like sequence element was identified (21), which
may bind the CcpA protein involved in carbon catabolite repression
in gram-positive bacteria (Fig . 3) . A set of direct
repeats was found between the –10 box and the Shine-Dalgarno
sequence, and they exhibited a high level of identity to the operator
site for the Bacillus subtilis OhrR regulator (20 of 30 nucleotides
were conserved) (Fig . 3), which represses the ohrA
gene involved in peroxide detoxification (10,
11) . This finding suggests that an OhrR-like
regulator is involved in the reported induction of PoxB activity by H2O2
(30) .
Northern blot analyses were performed with total RNA isolated from
L . plantarum Lp80 in the early stationary phase by using an
internal poxB fragment as the probe . A major band corresponding
to a 1.9-kb transcript was observed, showing that poxB is
monocistronic (Fig . 2A) . The additional
low-intensity bands below the 1.9-kb mRNA band most probably
represent degradation products of the poxB transcript that
comigrated with the rRNA (12) . A similar analysis
of RNA extracted from a poxB mutant (strain FL104) resulted in
detection of a single 1.3-kb band whose size corresponded to the
anticipated size of the deleted poxB transcript, which
confirmed both the mutant genotype of FL104 and identification of the
poxB mRNA .
Transcriptional regulation of poxB. Oxygen and
glucose regulation of poxB at the transcriptional level was
then investigated, as were the regulatory mechanisms involved . Total
RNA was extracted from strain Lp80 grown under aerobic or anaerobic
conditions and with excess glucose (2% glucose) or a limiting
concentration of glucose (0.2% glucose) . Northern blot analysis
revealed that the poxB transcript was hardly detected under
anaerobic conditions and that the amount of poxB mRNA
increased substantially under aerobic conditions and with glucose
exhaustion (Fig . 2A) . In order to examine the
kinetics of poxB expression during growth, Northern blot analyses
were performed with RNA extracted at various times during growth
(3, 5, 7, 9, and 11 h) under aerobic conditions with 0.2% glucose
(Fig . 2C) . During the exponential phase (3 h), the
poxB transcript could not be detected . At the end of exponential
growth (5 h), corresponding to complete exhaustion of glucose (Fig.
4B), a strong 1.9-kb band corresponding to the
poxB mRNA was observed . Subsequently, the poxB transcript
appeared to occur at the same level during the stationary phase for
up to 7 h before a sharp decrease was observed after 11 h of growth
(Fig . 2C) .
|
FIG . 4 . Growth curves, POX activities, fermentation profiles, and LDH
release for strains Lp80 and FL104 grown on MRS-CA medium supplemented
with 0.2% glucose or 0.2% maltose . Aerated cultures were harvested at
various times during growth . POX specific activity was measured by using
crude extracts . LDH activity was measured by using culture supernatants .
Glucose, maltose, acetate, and lactate concentrations were determined by
HPLC by using culture supernatants . The values are final concentrations
from which the initial concentrations measured in MRS-CA medium were
subtracted . (A) Growth and POX activity on 0.2% glucose . (B)
Fermentation end products on 0.2% glucose . (C) LDH release into culture
supernatants on 0.2% glucose . (D) Growth and POX activity on 0.2%
maltose . (E) Fermentation end products on 0.2% maltose . (F) LDH release
into culture supernatants on 0.2% maltose . Black bars, Lp80 POX
activity; gray bars, FL104 POX activity; solid line, Lp80; dotted line,
FL104;
,
growth (OD600);
,
LDH activity;
,
sugar (glucose or maltose); •, lactate;
,
acetate . prot., protein.
|
|
Since it was observed that the amount of the poxB mRNA decreased
at a high glucose concentration (Fig . 2A) and a cre-like
element overlapping the –35 sequence was found by sequence analysis
(Fig . 3), the role of CcpA in mediating glucose
repression of the poxB gene was investigated . Primer extension
and in vivo footprinting experiments were performed with the L .
plantarum LM3-2 strain carrying a null mutation in ccpA
and with the isogenic wild-type strain LM3 grown under aerobic
conditions and with glucose exhaustion or excess glucose . Primer
extension analysis demonstrated that poxB transcription was
repressed approximately 20-fold in LM3 cells grown with excess
glucose compared with the transcription in cells grown with glucose
exhaustion, while no significant difference in the levels of poxB
transcription was found for the ccpA mutant strain grown under
the two conditions (Fig . 2E) . In order to further
examine whether the cre-like sequence overlapping the –35
sequence is involved in CcpA-mediated regulation of poxB
expression, an in vivo footprinting analysis was performed for this
region . Chromosomal DNA of LM3 and LM3-2 cells grown on 2% glucose or
on 0.2% glucose were methylated with dimethyl sulfate at the onset of
the stationary phase . Figure 2F (lanes LM3) shows
that protection of the G residue of the top strand in the presence of
2% glucose corresponds to position 2 of the 14-bp cre
sequence . Protection of this G residue was observed in LM3 cells
grown on 2% glucose but not in LM3 cells grown on 0.2% glucose, while
no protection was observed in LM3-2 cells grown with excess glucose .
Constitutive overexpression of poxB in L . plantarum.
The poxB gene was constitutively overexpressed in order to evaluate
its potential control of acetate production in L . plantarum .
A translational fusion between the strong expression signals
from the ldhL gene and the poxB coding region was constructed
(pGIF101) and introduced into L . plantarum Lp80 . Under aerobic
conditions, growth of the recombinant strain, strain Lp80(pGIF101),
appeared to be severely inhibited, which could have been due to
production of a high level of hydrogen peroxide by the PoxB enzyme
(data not shown) . In Lp80(pGIF101) grown anaerobically with excess
glucose (2% glucose), PoxB overproduction was verified by SDS-PAGE
(data not shown) . Moreover, the level of POX activity in crude
extracts of these cells was 2.1 U/mg, while the control strain
[Lp80(pGIZ906)] had no detectable POX activity under these
conditions . Finally, this POX activity was 10-fold higher than the
maximum activity (0.23 U/mg) observed with Lp80 grown with maltose
limitation and under aerobic conditions (Fig . 4D),
thereby establishing the functional overproduction of PoxB in L .
plantarum Lp80 .
The impact of PoxB overproduction on fermentation products was
also studied . Since the recombinant strain could not grow under
aerobic conditions, the fermentation profile was examined with
aerated cell suspensions . Cell biomass was prepared by using the
conditions described above in order to avoid any POX activity in the
wild-type control . Cells were resuspended in phosphate buffer
containing glucose and then incubated with a high level of aeration
for 24 h . The amounts of glucose, lactate, and acetate in the
supernatant were determined by HPLC (Fig . 5) . During
the first phase of fermentation, both the control [Lp80(pGIZ906)]
and the overproducing strain [Lp80(pGIF101)] displayed rapid
conversion of glucose to lactate exclusively . Following this first
phase, a major difference in the metabolic profiles of the two
strains was observed . The lactate concentration in the cell
suspension of the control remained stable between 4 and 24 h, while
lactate was rapidly converted to acetate by the overproducing strain
and acetate eventually became the only fermentation end product (Fig.
5) . Since acetate could not be separated easily
from acetyl-phosphate by HPLC, 31P nuclear magnetic
resonance was used to confirm the exclusive production of acetate
(data not shown) .
|
FIG . 5 . Fermentation profiles obtained from aerated cell suspensions of
Lp80(pGIZ906) (control strain) and Lp80(pGIF101) (PoxB-overproducing
strain) . Cells were collected in the mid-exponential growth phase from
cultures grown under anaerobic conditions and with 2% glucose and were
resuspended in phosphate buffer containing glucose (50 mM) . Glucose,
acetate, and lactate concentrations were determined by HPLC of cell
suspension supernatants . Solid line, Lp80(pGIZ906); dotted lines,
Lp80(pGIF101);
,
glucose; •, lactate;
,
acetate.
|
|
Characterization of a stable poxB mutant. In order to
study the importance of acetate production under aerobic conditions
for L . plantarum metabolism and physiology, a stable poxB
mutant (FL104,
poxB)
was constructed . Cells were grown with aeration and glucose
limitation in order to maximize poxB expression, and the POX
activities of Lp80 and FL104 crude extracts were determined (Fig.
4A) . In Lp80, the activity increased dramatically
at the end of exponential growth and decreased only during later
stages of the stationary phase . POX activity was also observed in
FL104, although the level was reduced compared to the level observed
for the wild-type strain . During the exponential phase, no POX
activity was detected in FL104 until after 6 h of growth . At the end
of exponential growth, the POX activity in FL104 increased and
exhibited the same pattern as the Lp80 POX activity, but the POX
activity always was lower than the activity in Lp80 . The POX activity
in FL104 was between 20% (exponential phase and late stationary
phase) and 85% (early stationary phase) of the activity detected in
the wild type . These observations show that one or more additional
POXs are active in the early stationary phase . A Western blot
experiment was performed by using polyclonal antibodies raised
against a purified POX preparation from L . plantarum . A band
corresponding to the PoxB molecular mass (66 kDa) was observed with
Lp80 crude extracts, but a weak band was visible at a similar
position with the FL104 extracts (data not shown) . The calculated
molecular masses (between 63.5 and 64.2 kDa) of the four other
putative POXs are close to the apparent molecular mass of the band
observed for FL104 . These results indicate that one or more POXs
coexist in L . plantarum .
Effect of glucose limitation on the FL104 fermentation profile.
The first analysis of the impact of poxB inactivation on fermentation
products was performed with batch cultures grown under aerobic
conditions and with a low glucose concentration (0.2%) (Fig .
4A and B and Table 2) . The amounts of
glucose, lactate, and acetate in the supernatant were determined by
HPLC . In analogy with the cell suspension experiment, uncoupling
between the glucose consumption phase and the conversion of lactate
to acetate was observed . The glucose consumption phase resulted in
production of lactate as the major fermentation product . This phase
took place during exponential growth when the total POX activity
was very low (Fig . 4A and B) . The conversion of lactate
to acetate started at the onset of the stationary phase, when glucose
was completely exhausted and the total POX activity reached the
maximum value . In the late stationary growth phase, the conversion
process slowed down and finally stopped, although lactate was
still available . During this phase, decreases in the OD600 and
POX activity were observed . At the end of the conversion process
with 0.2% glucose, acetate accounted for 85 and 60% of total
fermentation products in Lp80 and FL104, respectively (Table
2) . The limited decrease in acetate production in FL104 (25%)
can probably be explained by the high residual POX activity .
Surprisingly, the calculated carbon balance for the conversion of
lactate to acetate was greater than 1 for both strains (approximately
1.3), suggesting that acetate is produced at the expense of one or
more compounds in addition to lactate (Table 2) . As neither
ethanol, acetoin, nor pyruvate was produced during growth, we
hypothesized that one or more growth medium compounds could be used
by the cells for this lactate-independent acetate production .
| TABLE 2 . Concentrations of lactate, acetate, glucose, and maltose in
culture supernatants of L . plantarum Lp80 and FL104 grown in
MRS-CA medium under aerobic conditions and with sugar limitation (0.2%
[wt/vol] sugar)a
|
|
Effect of maltose limitation on POX activity and the FL104 fermentation
profile. Since glucose repression of poxB is due to catabolite
repression, maltose was used as an alternative carbon source as it
has been reported to be a non-PTS sugar in Lactobacillus
species closely related to L . plantarum (34,
48) . Cultures were grown with aeration on 0.2%
maltose .
The POX activity in FL104 was remarkably low in the presence of
0.2% maltose compared to the activity in the presence of 0.2% glucose
up to 10 h of growth, and the residual activity accounted for 3 to 4%
of the total POX activity in Lp80 (Fig . 4D) . After
this, the POX activities were similar under the two culture
conditions . These findings indicate that PoxB contributes
significantly to the total POX activity in the presence of 0.2%
maltose . In Lp80, in contrast to what was observed in the presence of
0.2% glucose, the total POX activity increased at an earlier stage of
exponential growth when maltose was still present, showing that there
was partial relief of the glucose repression effect when maltose was
a carbon source . In analogy with the experiments performed with cells
grown on 0.2% glucose, the total POX activity for maltose-grown Lp80
was maximal in the early stationary phase and then decreased during
the late stationary phase .
The fermentation profile in the presence of 0.2% maltose was
analyzed (Fig . 4E and Table 2) . During the
sugar consumption phase, maltose was fermented mainly into lactate .
However, concomitant acetate production starting at 5 h was observed
for Lp80 with 0.2% maltose (Table 2) . At the end of
this phase, the acetate production in FL104 was fivefold lower than
that in Lp80, suggesting that PoxB made a large contribution to
acetate production during growth of the wild type (Table
2) . These results contrast with the data obtained
with cell suspensions and cells growing on 0.2% glucose, in which a
strong uncoupling between glucose consumption and acetate production
was observed . Nevertheless, the two strains started converting
lactate to acetate at approximately the same time during growth . This
conversion represented only a minor pathway in FL104 compared to the
pathway in Lp80 and appeared to be reduced compared to the conversion
in FL104 cells grown with 0.2% glucose . In the late stationary phase
(28 h), acetate accounted for 41% of the total end products in FL104,
compared to 100% of the total end products for Lp80 . The final
lactate concentration for the wild-type strain was even lower than
the initial background concentration measured in the growth medium .
Remarkably, a decrease in the OD600 of the Lp80 culture grown
on 0.2% maltose was observed when acetate production stopped,
while during this time the OD600 of FL104 remained stable . This
decrease in OD600 suggested that a lytic process was taking
place . In order to confirm this hypothesis, lysis was monitored
by determining the release of cytoplasmic LDHs (LDHL and LDHD) . The
global LDH activities in culture supernatants were measured during
growth of Lp80 and FL104 with a low sugar concentration (Fig.
4C and F) . The activity in culture supernatants after
28 h of growth was 10-fold higher for Lp80 than for FL104 with
0.2% maltose, while a twofold increase was observed with 0.2%
glucose .
Effect of excess glucose or maltose on the FL104 fermentation
profile. Lp80 and FL104 were grown under aerobic conditions on 2%
glucose and 2% maltose (Fig . 6 and Table
3) . Under these conditions, sugar exhaustion did
not occur at the onset of the stationary phase . POX activities were
measured in the exponential and late stationary growth phases (Fig.
6A and C) . In Lp80, the total POX activity was not
fully repressed by a high glucose concentration (fivefold decrease
compared to the activity with 0.2% glucose), and a higher level of
POX activity was observed with 2% maltose than with excess glucose .
In FL104, the residual POX activity in the exponential phase was 35
to 40% of the wild-type activity with 2% glucose and 3 to 5% of the
wild-type activity with 2% maltose . These results confirmed previous
observations that PoxB contributes substantially to the total POX
activity on maltose . At a high sugar concentration, the levels of
production of lactate and acetate were similar for the two strains
(Fig . 6) . On 2% glucose, the acetate production in
Lp80 was twofold higher than that in FL104 (Fig . 6B and
D) . In Lp80, acetate accounted for 11% of the fermentation
products after 30 h of fermentation, whereas the level was reduced
approximately twofold (6%) in FL104 (Table 3) . On
2% maltose, acetate production in Lp80 accounted for 24% of the total
metabolites, which was twice the level observed with 2% glucose (Fig.
6D and Table 3) . Under these
conditions, the acetate production observed for FL104 was fivefold
lower (5%) than that observed for Lp80 . The residual acetate
production (5 to 6%) in FL104 suggests that other POX enzymes that
are not fully repressed by high sugar concentrations contributed .
|
FIG . 6 . Growth curves, POX activities, and fermentation profiles for
strains Lp80 and FL104 grown on MRS-CA medium supplemented with 2%
glucose or 2% maltose . The experimental conditions were the same as
those described in the legend to Fig . 4 . (A) Growth
and POX activity on 2% glucose . (B) Fermentation end products on 2%
glucose . (C) Growth and POX activity on 2% maltose . (D) Fermentation end
products on 2% maltose . Black bars, Lp80 POX activity; gray bars, FL104
POX activity; solid line, Lp80; dotted line, FL104;
,
growth (OD600);
,
sugar (glucose or maltose); •, lactate;
,
acetate . prot., protein.
|
|
| TABLE 3 . Concentrations of lactate, acetate, glucose, and maltose in
culture supernatants of L . plantarum Lp80 and FL104 grown in
MRS-CA medium under aerobic conditions and with excess sugar (2%
[wt/vol] sugar)a
|
|
Here we describe cloning of the poxB gene from L . plantarum
Lp80 and characterization of its transcriptional regulation by
glucose repression, growth phase, and aeration . Our results elucidate
some of the poxB expression regulatory mechanisms . Glucose
repression was confirmed at the genetic level in two L . plantarum
strains (Lp80 and LM3) by Northern blot and primer extension
experiments, which demonstrated that poxB transcription was
repressed by excess glucose . Involvement of the CcpA protein in this
regulatory mechanism was demonstrated by the relief of catabolite
repression in a strain carrying a ccpA null mutation (a LM3
derivative) . Moreover, an in vivo footprinting analysis which showed
that there was CcpA-dependent protection of a cre sequence
overlapping the poxB –35 sequence corroborated the role of
CcpA in poxB transcription regulation . Another aspect of
poxB regulation concerns oxygen and hydrogen peroxide induction .
Both of these compounds have been reported previously to induce POX
activity in L . plantarum (30) . The Northern blot
experiment demonstrated that oxygen induction takes place at the
transcriptional level, but a direct role of oxygen has not been
clarified . In silico searches for putative binding sites of
regulators (FNR, ResD, PerR, OhrR) known to be involved in oxygen or
hydrogen/organic peroxide regulation in gram-positive bacteria
revealed the presence of a strongly conserved putative binding site
for OhrR (10, 11,
17, 33, 37) . The
position of this site between the promoter –10 box and the
Shine-Dalgarno sequence of poxB is consistent with the
repressor role of OhrR (10) . Furthermore, two OhrR
homologues displaying 42 and 38% identity with OhrR of B . subtilis
(lp_1360 and lp_0889) were identified in the genome sequence of
L . plantarum WCFS1 (25) . The OhrR regulator is
involved in oxidative stress in B . subtilis, acting as a
repressor that is inactivated by organic peroxides . The organic
peroxides are produced by hydrogen peroxide attack on fatty acids (10) .
Therefore, an indirect effect of oxygen on poxB regulation
could be postulated .
The present study demonstrated that PoxB is not the only active
POX of L . plantarum since the poxB knockout did not completely
eliminate POX activity . With a high level of aeration and glucose
limitation, the POX activity in the mutant still was equivalent
to 85% of the wild-type activity at the onset of the stationary
phase . The comparison of the kinetics of POX induction in the wild
type and the mutant suggested that one or more additional POX
proteins are regulated by glucose since a sharp peak of activity was
observed in the early stationary phase for the mutant strain when
glucose was completely exhausted . Surprisingly, an impressive
decrease in POX activity (>90%) was observed in the mutant strain
when there was excess maltose and when there was maltose limitation .
Maltose behaves like a non-PTS sugar since relief of catabolite
repression of total POX activity occurs during the exponential growth
phase of the wild-type strain . However, there is no obvious
hypothesis to explain why maltose seems to repress POX activity in
the mutant strain . To our knowledge, no such maltose repression
effect has been reported previously .
This study showed that the PoxB enzyme plays a key role in acetate
production from maltose in L . plantarum under aerobic conditions .
With a high level of aeration and excess sugar, acetate and
lactate were produced concomitantly during sugar fermentation .
Acetate could account for up to 24% of the total end products when
there was excess maltose . Inactivation of PoxB reduced the amount of
acetate by 20 and 80% in the presence of excess glucose and excess
maltose, respectively . This suggests that PoxB competes with LDHs for
the pyruvate pool . Previously, it has been shown that the NADH
oxidase and the NADH peroxidase of L . plantarum are strongly
induced by aeration (30) . These two enzymes
contribute to the NADH/NAD+ balance through regeneration
of the NAD+ necessary for glycolysis (3) . The
consequence of activation of these enzymes is a reduction in the NADH
pool, which results in reorientation of pyruvate towards
NADH-independent enzymes, such as PoxB . The results of the cell
suspension experiment performed with the PoxB-overproducing strain
are consistent with this hypothesis . The cell biomass was prepared
from cultures grown under anaerobic conditions and with excess
glucose . The fact that anaerobic conditions strongly reduce NADH
oxidase and NADH peroxidase activities could explain the absence of
acetate in the supernatants of cell suspensions during the glucose
consumption phase .
With high levels of aeration and sugar exhaustion, conversion of
lactate to acetate takes place . The conversion process is extremely
efficient in the wild-type strain and could result in homoacetic
fermentation, such as that observed with cells growing with maltose
limitation . Under these conditions, the PoxB contribution to acetate
production is very important since the PoxB-deficient strain
displayed very limited conversion of lactate to acetate and there was
a 60% reduction in the final amount of acetate produced . With glucose
exhaustion, the conversion of lactate to acetate was slowed down in
the poxB mutant, and there was a moderate effect on the final
amount of acetate produced . Additionally, the data obtained with
resting cells of the PoxB-overproducing strain demonstrated that a
POX activity was absolutely required in this conversion process .
Moreover, if the other enzymes (lactate oxidase, ACK) anticipated to
be involved in this metabolic pathway are regulated, they do not
strongly control the conversion process .
Although the acetate production in both the wild type and the
mutant strain could be explained by the relative POX activity
measured under all conditions tested, we cannot exclude the
possibility that there is an alternative pathway for acetate
production under aerobic conditions . Pyruvate formate lyase cannot be
involved since this enzyme is oxygen sensitive and formate production
was not detected in our experiments (27) . An
alternative route for acetate production under aerobic conditions is
a coupling between PDH and NADH oxidase . Such a coupling was invoked
to explain a high level of acetate production in Lactococcus
lactis when the NADH oxidase was overexpressed (35) .
Although an NADH oxidase activity was clearly induced at similar
levels in both Lp80 and the PoxB-deficient strain under aerobic
conditions, we were unable to detect any PDH activity under the
different growth conditions, confirming previous observations that a
POX enzyme(s) plays the major role in acetate production under
aerobic conditions (6, 18,
30; data not shown) .
The energy produced by substrate phosphorylation generated via the
acetate kinase during acetate production has been reported to
increase biomass production in L . plantarum (3,
31, 47) . Although this aspect
was not examined in detail here, the OD600 reached in the
stationary phase by the PoxB-deficient strain was clearly reduced
with maltose limitation, and acetate production and POX activity were
affected most . Interestingly, when the conversion of lactate to
acetate stops in the stationary phase, a decrease in the OD600
resulting from a lytic process was observed . A possible explanation
for these observations involves the coupling between acetate and ATP
production; in the absence of ATP production, protons can no longer
be extruded by ATPases, which results in dissipation of the proton
motive force . Dissipation of the proton motive force has been shown
to be one of the mechanisms that trigger autolysis of gram-positive
bacteria (22, 38) . Altogether,
these results suggest that the coupling between acetate and ATP
production via the POX enzyme could play an important role in L .
plantarum survival when sugar is limiting . Similarly, it has been
shown recently that the ATP pool is more rapidly dissipated in a
POX-deficient strain of Streptococcus pneumoniae (36) .
Although no lysis was reported, the ATP pool depletion was associated
with a dramatic decrease in the viability of the mutant strain (36) .
In future work we will try to elucidate the molecular mechanisms
of oxygen regulation of poxB . The possible involvement of the
two OhrR homologues identified in the L . plantarum genome will
be studied by using gene knockouts . In order to clarify the
functional role of the four additional pox genes identified in
the genome sequence, experiments involving single inactivation and
multiple inactivation, as well as individual overproduction, are in
progress .
This research was carried out with the financial support from FNRS
and MIUR-PRIN 2002 . F.L and P.G . hold a doctoral fellowship from
FRIA, and V.L . holds a Marie Curie postdoctoral fellowship from the
EU . P.H . is scientific collaborator at FNRS .
We are grateful to K . Schanck and A . Schanck for their skillful
help with HPLC and nuclear magnetic resonance analyses . We warmly
thank J . Delcour and D . Prozzi for critically reading the manuscript .
We thank L . Frey, P . Renault, and K . Leenhouts for providing
polyclonal antibodies, plasmid pJIM2374, and strain EC1000,
respectively .
* Corresponding author . Mailing address: Unité de Génétique,
Institut des Sciences de la Vie, Université catholique de Louvain, 5 Place Croix
du Sud, B-1348 Louvain-La-Neuve, Belgium . Phone: 32 10 47 88 96 . Fax: 32 10 47
31 09 . E-mail: hols@gene.ucl.ac.be.
Present address: Unité de Biochimie et Structure des Protéines, INRA,
78352 Jouy en Josas cedex, France .
Present address: Unité hormones et métabolisme, ICP, Université
catholique de Louvain, B-1200 Brussels, Belgium .
Present address: Instituto de Productos Lácteos de Asturias, 33300
Villaviciosa, Spain .
- Chen, J.-D., and D . A . Morrison. 1988 . Construction and
properties of a new insertion vector, pJDC9, that is protected by
transcriptional terminators and useful for cloning of DNA from
Streptococcus pneumoniae. Gene 64:155-164.
- Cherrington, C . A., M . Hinton, G . C . Mead, and I . Chopra.
1991 . Organic acids: chemistry, antibacterial activity and practical
applications . Adv . Microb . Physiol . 32:87-108.
- Condon, S. 1987 . Responses of lactic acid bacteria to
oxygen . FEMS Microbiol . Rev . 46:269-280.
- Delorme, C., S . D . Ehrlich, and P . Renault. 1999 .
Regulation of expression of the Lactococcus lactis histidine operon . J .
Bacteriol . 181:2026-2037 .
- Derzelle, S., B . Hallet, K . P . Francis, T . Ferain, J .
Delcour, and P . Hols. 2000 . Changes in cspL, cspP, and
cspC mRNA abundance as a function of cold shock and growth phase in
Lactobacillus plantarum. J . Bacteriol . 182:5105-5113 .
- Dirar, H., and E . B . Collins. 1973 . Aerobic utilization
of low concentration of galactose by Lactobacillus plantarum. J . Gen .
Microbiol . 78:211-215.
- Ferain, T., K . Schanck, and J . Delcour. 1996 . 13C
nuclear magnetic resonance analysis of glucose and citrate end products in an
ldhL-ldhD double-knockout strain of Lactobacillus plantarum. J .
Bacteriol . 178:7211-7315.
- Flemming, H . P., R . F . McFeeters, and M . A . Daeschel.
1985 . The lactobacilli, pediococci, and leuconostocs: vegetable products, p .
97-118 . In S . E . Gilliland (ed.), Bacterial starters cultures in foods .
CRC Press Inc., Boca Raton, Fla.
- Frey, L., and J . C . Hubert. 1993 . Lactobacilles, oxygčne,
métabolisme et antagonisme . Lait 73:133-144.
- Fuanthong, M., S . Atichartpongkul, S . Mongkolsuk, and J . D .
Helmann. 2001 . OrhR is a repressor of ohrA, a key organic
hydroperoxide resistance determinant in Bacillus subtilis. J .
Bacteriol . 183:4134-4141 .
- Fuangthong, M., and J . D . Helmann. 2002 . The OhrR
repressor senses organic hydroperoxides by reversible formation of a
cysteine-sulfenic acid derivative . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 99:6690-6695 .
- Garault, P., C . Letort, V . Juillard, and V . Monnet.
2000 . Branched-chain amino acid biosynthesis is essential for optimal growth
of Streptococcus thermophilus in milk . Appl . Environ . Microbiol . 66:5128-5133 .
- Garmyn, D., T . Ferain, N . Bernard, P . Hols, and J . Delcour.
1995 . Cloning, nucleotide sequence, and transcriptional analysis of the
Pediococcus acidilactici L-(+)-lactate
dehydrogenase gene . Appl . Environ . Microbiol . 61:266-272.
- Götz, F., B . Sedewitz, and E . F . Elstner. 1980 . Oxygen
utilization by Lactobacillus plantarum. I . Oxygen consuming reactions .
Arch . Microbiol . 125:209-214.
- Götz, F., B . Sedewitz, and E . F . Elstner. 1980 . Oxygen
utilization by Lactobacillus plantarum. II . Superoxide and superoxide
dismutation . Arch . Microbiol . 125:215-220.
- Helmann, J . D. 1995 . Compilation and analysis of
Bacillus subtilis
A-dependent
promoter sequences: evidence for extended contact between RNA polymerase and
upstream promoter DNA . Nucleic Acids Res . 23:2351-2360.
- Herbig, A . F., and J . D . Helmann. 2001 . Roles of metal
ions and hydrogen peroxide in modulating the interaction of the Bacillus
subtilis PerR peroxide regulon repressor with operator DNA . Mol .
Microbiol . 41:849-859.
- Hickey, M . W., A . J . Hillier, and G . R . Jago. 1983 .
Metabolism of pyruvate and citrate in lactobacilli . Aust . J . Biol . Sci . 36:487-496.
- Hols, P., T . Ferain, D . Garmyn, N . Bernard, and J . Delcour.
1994 . Use of homologous expression-secretion signals and vector-free stable
chromosomal integration in engineering of Lactobacillus plantarum for
-amylase
and levanase expression . Appl . Environ . Microbiol . 60:1401-1413.
- Hols, P., M . Kleerebezem, A . N . Schanck, T . Ferain, J .
Hugenholtz, J . Delcour, and W . M . de Vos WM. 1999 . Conversion of
Lactococcus lactis from homolactic to homoalanine fermentation through
metabolic engineering . Nat . Biotechnol . 17:588-592.
- Hueck, C . J., W . Hillen, and M . H . Saier, Jr. 1994 .
Analysis of cis-active sequence mediating catabolite repression in
Gram-positive bacteria . Res . Microbiol . 145:503-518.
- Jolliffe, L . K., R . J . Doyle, and U . N . Streips. 1981 .
The energized membrane and cellular autolysis in Bacillus subtilis.
Cell 25:753-763.
- Josson, K., T . Scheirlink, F . Michiel, C . Platteeuw, P .
Stanssens, H . Joos, P . Dhaese, M . Zabeau, and J . Mahillon. 1989 .
Characterization of a Gram positive broad-host range plasmid isolated from
Lactobacillus hilgardii. Plasmid . 21:9-20.
- Kandler, O., and N . Weiss. 1986 . Regular, nonsporing
Gram-positive rods, p . 1208-1260 . In P . H . A . Sneath, N . S . Mair, M . E .
Sharpe, and J . G . Holt (ed.), Bergey's manual of systematic bacteriology, vol .
2 . Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, Md.
- Kleerebezem, M., J . Boekhorst, R . van Kranenburg, D .
Molenaar, O . Kuipers, R . Leer, R . Tarchini, S . A . Peters, H . M . Sandbrink, M .
W . E . J . Fiers, W . Stiekema, R . M . K . Lankhorst, P . A . Bron, S . M . Hoffer, M .
N . Nierop Groot, R . Kerkhoven, M . de Vries, B . Ursing, W . M . de Vos, and R . J .
Siezen. 2003 . Complete genome sequence of Lactobacillus plantarum
WCFS1 . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 100:1990-1995 .
- Leenhouts, K., G . Buist, A . Bolhuis, A . ten Berge, J . Kiel,
I . Mierau, M . Dabrowska, G . Venema, and J . Kok. 1996 . A general system for
generating unlabelled gene replacements in bacterial chromosomes . Mol . Gen .
Genet . 253:217-224.
- Lindgren, S . E., L . T . Axelsson, and R . F . McFeeters.
1990 . Anaerobic L-lactate degradation by
Lactobacillus plantarum. FEMS Microbiol . Lett . 66:209-213.
- Muller, Y . A., and G . E . Schulz. 1993 . Structure of the
thiamine- and flavin-dependent enzyme pyruvate oxidase . Science 259:965-967.
- Muller, Y . A., G . Schumaker, R . Rudolph, and G . E Schulz.
1994 . The refined structure of stabilized mutant and of wild-type pyruvate
oxidase from Lactobacillus plantarum. J . Mol . Biol . 237:315-335.
- Murphy, M . G., and S . Condon. 1984 . Correlation of
oxygen utilisation and hydrogen peroxide accumulation with oxygen induced
enzymes in Lactobacillus plantarum cultures . Arch . Microbiol . 138:44-48.
- Murphy, M . G., L . O'Connor, D . Walsh, and S . Condon.
1985 . Oxygen dependent lactate utilization by Lactobacillus plantarum.
Arch . Microbiol . 141:75-79.
- Muscariello, L., R . Marasco, M . De Felice, and M . Sacco.
2001 . The functional ccpA gene is required for carbon catabolite
repression in Lactobacillus plantarum. Appl . Environ . Microbiol . 67:2903-2907 .
- Nakano, M . M., Y . Zhu, M . Lacelle, X . Zhang, and M . F .
Hulett. 2000 . Interaction of ResD with regulatory regions of anaerobically
induced genes in Bacillus subtilis. Mol . Microbiol . 37:1198-1207.
- Neubauer, H., E . Glaasker, W . P . Hammes, B . Poolman, and W .
N . Konings. 1994 . Mechanism of maltose uptake and glucose excretion in
Lactobacillus sanfrancisco. J . Bacteriol . 176:3007-3012.
- Neves, A . R., A . Ramos, H . Costa, I . I . van Swam, J .
Hugenholtz, M . Kleerebezem, W . de Vos, and H . Santos. 2002 . Effect of
different NADH oxidase levels on glucose metabolism by Lactococcus lactis:
kinetics of intracellular metabolite pools determined by in vivo nuclear
magnetic resonance . Appl . Environ . Microbiol . 68:6332-6342 .
- Pericone, C . D., S . Park, J . A . Imlay, and J . N . Weiser.
2003 . Factors contributing to hydrogen peroxide resistance in Streptococcus
pneumoniae include pyruvate oxidase (SpxB) and avoidance of the toxic
effects of the Fenton reaction . J . Bacteriol . 185:6815-6825 .
- Ramos, C . H., L . Boursier, I . Moszer, F . Kunst, A . Danchin,
and P . Glaser. 1995 . Anaerobic transcription activation in Bacillus
subtilis: identification of distinct FNR-dependent and -independent
regulatory mechanisms . EMBO J . 14:5984-5994.
- Riepe, H . R., C . J . Pillidge, P . K . Gopal, and L . L . McKay.
1997 . Characterization of the highly autolytic Lactococcus lactis
subsp . cremoris strains CO and 2250 . Appl . Environ . Microbiol . 63:3757-3763.
- Risse, B., G . Stempfer, R . Rudolph, H . Möllering, and R .
Jaenicke. 1992 . Stability and reconstitution of pyruvate oxidase from
Lactobacillus plantarum: dissection of the stabilising effects of coenzyme
binding and subunit interaction . Protein Sci . 1:1699-1709 .
- Russel, J . B., and F . Diez-Gonzales. 1998 . The effects
of fermentation acids on bacterial growth . Adv . Microb . Physiol . 39:205-234.
- Sambrook, J., and D . W . Russell. 2001 . Molecular
cloning: a laboratory manual, 3rd ed . Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold
Spring Harbor, N.Y.
- Sedewitz, B., K . H . Schleifer, and F . Götz. 1984 .
Purification and biochemical characterization of pyruvate oxidase from
Lactobacillus plantarum. J . Bacteriol . 160:273-278.
- Sedewitz, B., K . H . Schleifer, and F . Götz. 1984 .
Physiological role of pyruvate oxidase in the aerobic metabolism of
Lactobacillus plantarum. J . Bacteriol . 160:462-465.
- Starrenburg, M . J . C., and J . Hugenholtz. 1991 . Citrate
fermentation by Lactococcus lactis and Leuconostoc spp . Appl .
Environ . Microbiol . 57:3535-3540.
- Sugihara, T . F. 1985 . The lactobacilli and streprococci:
bakery products, p . 119-125 . In S . E . Gilliland (ed.), Bacterial
starters cultures in foods . CRC Press Inc., Boca Raton, Fla.
- Tittmann, K., D . Proske, M . Spinka, S . Ghisla, R . Rudolph,
G . Hübner, and G . Kern. 1998 . Activation of thiamine diphosphate and FAD
in the phosphate-dependent pyruvate oxidase from Lactobacillus plantarum.
J . Biol . Chem . 273:12929-12934 .
- Tseng, C.-P., and T . J . Montville. 1990 . Enzyme
activities affecting end-product distribution by Lactobacillus plantarum
in response to changes in pH and O2 . Appl . Microbiol . Biotechnol.
56:2761-2763.
- Viana, R., V . Monedero, V . Dossonnet, C . Vadeboncoeur, G .
Perez-Martinez, and J . Deutscher. 2000 . Enzyme I and HPr from
Lactobacillus casei: their role in sugar transport, carbon catabolite
repression and inducer exclusion . Mol . Microbiol . 36:570-584.
Free Online Full-text Article
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
|