|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, June 2004, p . 3951-3959, Vol . 186,
No . 12
Effects
of Perturbing Nucleoid Structure on Nucleoid Occlusion-Mediated Toporegulation
of FtsZ Ring Assembly
Qin Sun and William Margolin*
Department of Microbiology and Molecular Genetics, University of Texas
Medical School, Houston, Texas 77030
Received 31 January 2004/ Accepted 9 March 2004
In Escherichia coli, assembly of the FtsZ ring (Z ring) at the
cell division site is negatively regulated by the nucleoid in a
phenomenon called nucleoid occlusion (NO) . Previous studies have
indicated that chromosome packing plays a role in NO, as mukB
mutants grown in rich medium often exhibit FtsZ rings on top of
diffuse, unsegregated nucleoids . To address the potential role of
overall nucleoid structure on NO, we investigated the effects of
disrupting chromosome structure on Z-ring positioning . We found that
NO was mostly normal in cells with inactivated DNA gyrase or in
mukB-null mutants lacking topA, although some suppression
of NO was evident in the latter case . Previous reports suggesting
that transcription, translation, and membrane insertion of proteins
("transertion") influence nucleoid structure prompted us to
investigate whether disruption of these activities had effects on NO .
Blocking transcription caused nucleoids to become diffuse, and FtsZ
relocalized to multiple bands on top of these nucleoids, biased
towards midcell . This suggested that these diffuse nucleoids were
defective in NO . Blocking translation with chloramphenicol caused
characteristic nucleoid compaction, but FtsZ rarely assembled on top
of these centrally positioned nucleoids . This suggested that NO
remained active upon translation inhibition . Blocking protein
secretion by thermoinduction of a secA(Ts) strain caused a
chromosome segregation defect similar to that in parC mutants,
and NO was active . Although indirect effects are certainly possible
with these experiments, the above data suggest that optimum NO
activity may require specific organization and structure of the
nucleoid .
When Escherichia coli cells divide by binary fission, they assemble
a septal protein complex at midcell . The first known protein to
localize, FtsZ, forms a ring (the Z ring) between the two segregated
nucleoids at about the time of replication termination (7) .
The Z ring then recruits the rest of the septal complex . The
selection of the site at midcell is remarkably accurate (36,
47), and two global systems have important topological
roles in identifying this site (21, 47) .
One of these, the Min system, prevents unwanted division events at
nucleoid-free cell poles . This is achieved by the continuous
oscillation of an inhibitor of Z-ring formation (MinC), a
membrane-associated ATPase (MinD), and an enhancer of the MinD ATPase
(MinE) between the two cell poles, keeping MinC away from the midcell
site (6, 12, 15-17,
30, 31) . The Min system may be important
for the accuracy of midcell Z-ring placement (18),
or it may simply function to prevent polar divisions, as seems to be
the case in Bacillus subtilis (22) .
The other topological system that regulates Z-ring placement is
the nucleoid itself . By an unknown mechanism, Z-ring assembly on the
membrane is inhibited by the presence of the nucleoid at the same
site . This negative spatial regulation is called "nucleoid occlusion"
(NO) (41, 44) . Under the combined negative
control of both the Min system and NO, the most favorable part
of the cell for assembly of the Z rings occurs at midcell at the time
of chromosome segregation (21) . The nucleoid and Min
system appear to be independent of each other . In mutant cells
lacking a nucleoid, Z rings localize near midcell, presumably because
the Min system remains functional in such anucleate cells (35) .
Conversely, without the Min system, nucleoids can still inhibit
septum formation in their vicinity (34, 47) .
NO was still active after arresting chromosomal DNA replication
by thermoinactivation of dnaA, indicating that chromosome
replication is not required for NO (34) .
The molecular mechanism of NO is not yet known . One possible
obstacle for division is the physical structure or local density of
the nucleoid and/or nucleoid-associated proteins . To maintain the
proper nucleoid structure, E . coli chromosomes need to be
condensed . Disruption of MukB, a homolog of SMC that is involved in
condensation of the nucleoid (32), results in thermosensitive
growth and partial loss of NO (5, 25,
35) . The suppression of NO in turn is thought to
result in guillotining of misplaced nucleoids by septa, producing a
1,000-fold increase in the percentage of anucleate cells (25,
45) .
Another important factor that governs nucleoid structure is DNA
superhelicity . DNA gyrase introduces negative supercoils into DNA,
while topoisomerase I (encoded by topA) removes them (8,
29) . Interestingly, the defects of mukB mutants can be
largely suppressed by inactivating topA, which increases
negative superhelicity and thus local DNA density (32,
33) . This increase in local DNA density appears to
compensate for the lower levels of chromosome packing in mukB
mutants . The suppression of the mukB-associated defects by a
topA mutation suggests that local DNA concentration, and not
some special function of MukB, is a critical factor for NO .
In addition to supercoiling and condensation, proper nucleoid
structure and function also appear to require the process of
transertion, which is defined as the ongoing processes of transcription,
translation, and insertion of membrane and export (42) .
Perturbing transcription or translation causes significant changes in
nucleoid density; blocking transcription expands the nucleoid, while
blocking translation compacts it (26, 43) .
To learn more about the molecular basis of nucleoid occlusion, in
this study we examine the formation and positioning of Z rings in
cells with abnormal nucleoid structure caused by perturbations in
superhelicity and the transertion process . By comparing the relative
positions of FtsZ assembly and nucleoids, the effects of these
various factors on NO were investigated .
Strains and growth conditions. All strains used in this study
are derivatives of E . coli K-12 and are shown in Table
1 . Cells were grown either in Luria-Bertani (LB)
medium or M9 glucose medium supplemented with 0.5% Casamino Acids .
Overnight cultures were diluted 200x in
fresh medium and grown at 30°C until the early logarithmic phase . For
thermosensitive mutants, cells were then shifted to the appropriate
nonpermissive temperature . To study the effects of drugs on
nucleoid occlusion or septation, we used final concentrations of
100-µg/ml rifampin (dissolved in dimethyl sulfoxide), 100-µg/ml
chloramphenicol, 200-µg/ml cephalexin, or 5-µg/ml coumermycin A1 .
Drugs were obtained from Sigma Chemical Co., St . Louis, Mo .
| TABLE 1 . Strains and plasmids used in this study
|
|
Immunostaining and microscopy. Immunofluorescence in
combination with phase-contrast imaging and nucleoid staining with
4', 6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI) was carried out with
methanol-fixed cells as described previously (34)
with a few modifications . For FtsZ staining, we used a 1:200 dilution
of affinity-purified anti-FtsZ, followed by goat anti-rabbit
secondary antibody conjugated with an Alexa 488 (Molecular Probes,
Eugene, Oreg.) . An Olympus BX60 microscope and an Optronics DEI-750
camera were used for photographing images . To overlay images of green
FtsZ and DAPI, the blue DAPI signal was pseudocolored red by
switching the color cables on the Scion CG-7 grabber card . The images
were edited in Adobe Photoshop . FtsZ positions and cell lengths were
measured by pixels in Photoshop and plotted in Microsoft Excel .
Effects of DNA supercoiling on nucleoid occlusion. It was
demonstrated previously that Z rings were almost always excluded from
the nucleoid after inactivation of DnaA and thus replication
initiation (34) . To test the idea that other aspects
of nucleoid structure and dynamics might also be important for
nucleoid occlusion, we first examined Z-ring positioning in mutants
with disrupted DNA supercoiling . DNA gyrase has two subunits, gyrA
and gyrB, and the latter encodes an ATPase that binds DNA (23) .
Disruption of gyrB by mutation or with drugs causes trapping
of gyrase on DNA (2) . We first used a gyrB(Ts)
mutant that inactivates gyrase at 42°C (28) . This
mutant is also defective in DNA replication initiation, probably
because of the reduced level of negative supercoiling (11) .
To avoid potential complications caused by multiple replication
cycles in rapidly growing cells, we grew the gyrB mutant (WM1263)
in M9 glucose medium supplemented with Casamino Acids . Under
such growth conditions, the generation time at 30°C was about 2 h
(data not shown) . After cells were shifted to the nonpermissive
temperature of 42°C for 45 min, fixed, and stained with DAPI, most
cells had only one detectable nucleoid and significant nucleoid-free
zones at the poles (Fig . 1E) . This contrasts with
the presence of two nucleoids in many wild-type MG1655 cells or the
isogenic parent cells (WM1262) grown under the same conditions (Fig.
1D) (data not shown) . This staining pattern is
consistent with arrest of replication and segregation but
continuation of some growth, similar to dnaA mutants grown at
the nonpermissive temperature (34) .
|
FIG . 1 . Effect of DNA supercoiling on FtsZ localization . (A to C) FtsZ
staining . (D to F) DNA stained with DAPI . (G to I) Overlay of DNA and
FtsZ . Panels A, D, and G show wild-type TX3772 cells . Panels B, E, and H
show gyrB mutant cells grown at 28°C in M9 glucose plus Casamino
Acids until the early log phase and then grown at 42°C for another 45
min . Panels C, F, and I show TX3772 cells grown in LB medium at 28°C and
treated with 5-µg/ml coumermycin A1 for 40 min . Vertical
arrows highlight cells containing central Z rings apparently over an
unsegregated nucleoid . Horizontal arrows highlight cells containing
acentral Z rings in anucleate segments or at nucleoid edges . Scale bar,
5 µm.
|
|
We then examined FtsZ positioning in these cells by immunofluorescence .
It was clear that while Z rings were always at midcell in wild-type
cells (Fig . 1A and G), in the gyrB mutant they
tended to assemble away from midcell, often appearing at nucleoid
edges . Such single acentral rings were observed in 50 out of 61 cells
counted (82%) that contained a Z ring (Fig . 1B, E, and
H) (data not shown), reminiscent of the patterns observed with
dnaA mutants (34) . In addition, some cells had
more than one acentral Z ring (Fig . 1B, E, and H) .
In 12 of the 61 cells with Z rings (18%), a Z ring was localized at
midcell, and some of these had no apparent gaps in DAPI staining
(Fig . 1) (data not shown) . One potential
explanation for this last class of cells is that they had already
initiated chromosome replication before gyrB was inactivated
completely by the temperature shift and were in the process of
chromosome segregation when samples were prepared . In addition, the
more relaxed state of the nucleoid might make it more difficult to
detect nucleoid gaps by DAPI staining . Yet another potential
explanation is that NO is suppressed in some cells under these
conditions for reasons that are not yet clear . Nevertheless, it is
clear that Z rings often formed at acentral locations in the gyrB
mutants at the nonpermissive temperature, usually at nucleoid edges .
Some of these rings must have been active, because samples taken at
60 to 80 min after temperature shift exhibited a 15 to 20% frequency
of anucleate cells (data not shown), indicating that the acentral
rings at nucleoid edges had divided the cells into nucleate and
anucleate daughters . As observed previously (35),
nearly all the anucleate cells had Z rings .
To confirm these results, we examined the effects of coumermycin A1,
a drug that inhibits gyrB ATPase activity (13,
23, 29), on NO and Z-ring
placement . Because prolonged drug treatment leads to cell lysis,
cells were grown rapidly in LB medium . Wild-type TX3772 cells were
treated with 5-µg/ml coumermycin A1, and Z-ring positions
were visualized by immunofluorescence (Fig . 1C, F, and
I) . The DAPI staining patterns and FtsZ localization were similar
to those of the gyrB mutant at 42°C, with FtsZ staining in
most cells to the edge of the nucleoid, away from midcell . These
results support the suggestion that relaxation of the chromosome by
reducing its superhelicity does not significantly suppress NO
activity .
FtsZ localization in a mukB topA mutant. Z rings
often localize on top of decondensed nucleoids in a mukB
mutant, indicating that nucleoid occlusion is partially suppressed (35) .
Cells with a defective mukB gene are thermosensitive, forming
colonies in rich medium only at or below 28°C . The reason for this is
not known, but perhaps slowing down the cell cycle helps to
compensate for insufficient chromosomal condensation during
replication (1) . The suppression of anucleate cell production
in a mukB mutant by inactivation of topA indicates that the
nucleoids are properly positioned and condensed and probably
are not cut by Z rings or division septa at a significant frequency .
However, we wondered whether there might still be subtle differences
in Z-ring positioning as compared with wild-type cells, and therefore
we examined Z rings in a topA mukB double mutant (CC4207) .
CC4207 cells were grown at various temperatures (28, 32, 37, and
42°C) before being fixed for immunofluorescence . At all temperatures
examined, Z rings were present in gaps between nucleoids and lone
rings were not present on top of nucleoids (data not shown) .
Interestingly, however, closely spaced double FtsZ bands were present
in gaps between nucleoids at high frequency in cells grown at 28°C
but not at higher temperatures (Fig . 2B) . It was
not possible to determine whether these multiple FtsZ bands
represented multiple Z rings or turns of a continuous FtsZ helix . The
distances between nucleoids were similar to those in wild-type cells
(Fig . 2A), ruling out the possibility that the
unusual FtsZ structures resulted from larger regions that lacked NO
activity . In fact, it appeared that the nucleoid edges were not as
potent at excluding Z rings, because the outer rings in a cluster
appeared to be spread to the DAPI-stained nucleoid region (Fig.
2B) . This pattern of Z-ring clusters on top of
nucleoids but centered at a nucleoid-free gap is reminiscent of the
Z-ring staining in
mukB
min
double mutants (46) . Overall, these results
suggest that the topA mutation, while allowing survival of
mukB mutants and suppression of most of the mukB
phenotypes, does not completely suppress the NO defect . We cannot
explain why we were not able to see a significant frequency of ring
clusters at other growth temperatures .
|
FIG . 2 . Multiple FtsZ bands formed in a mukB topA double mutant .
CC4207 cells were grown at 28°C and fixed for staining . Arrows highlight
clusters of multiple Z rings, sometimes extending to regions occupied by
nucleoids . (A) DAPI plus phase-contrast . (B) FtsZ immunostaining plus
DAPI staining.
|
|
Transcription inhibition suppresses nucleoid occlusion. It has
been proposed that the structure of the E . coli nucleoid is
determined by DNA binding proteins and DNA supercoiling, representing
a compaction force, and by the coupled transcription/translation/translocation
of plasma membrane and cell wall proteins, representing an opposing
expansion force (26, 43) . We were
interested to study the influence of each expansion factor on NO .
To examine the role of transcription, we treated wild-type TX3772
cells with rifampin, which interferes with the ß subunit of
prokaryotic RNA polymerase and blocks transcription initiation (40,
48) . After 10 min of rifampin treatment, nucleoids already
showed some expansion as judged by DAPI staining of fixed cells
compared to untreated cells (data not shown) . After 30 min of
rifampin treatment, the DAPI staining was uniform throughout the
cells, with few detectable nucleoid-free gaps (Fig . 3F)
compared to untreated cells (Fig . 3C) . This nucleoid
expansion effect was much easier to see in filamentous
min
mutant cells, because of the multiple spaces between nucleoids (see
below) .
|
FIG . 3 . Effects of inhibiting transcription and translation on the
nucleoid and FtsZ positioning . Shown are representative fields of
untreated wild-type TX3772 cells (A to C), TX3772 cells 30 min after
addition of 100-µg/ml rifampin (D to F), TX3772 cells 2 h after addition
of 200-µg/ml chloramphenicol (G to I), WM1032 ( min)
cells 30 min after addition of 100-µg/ml rifampin (J to K), or untreated
(L and M) . All cells were grown in LB medium except for those treated
with chloramphenicol, which were grown in M9 glucose plus Casamino
Acids . Panels A, D, G, J, and L show FtsZ immunostaining; panels B, E,
H, K, and M show DAPI staining; and panels C, F, and I show DAPI
staining overlaid with the phase-contrast image . Representative
individual cells of CAG19209 (rpoD800) grown at 45°C for 1 h are
shown either as FtsZ stained (N to P), DAPI stained (T toV), or merged
(Q to S) . Panel W shows a merged image of TX3722 cells for comparison .
Scale bars are 5 µm for panels A to M (under panels L and M) and N to W
(under panel W).
|
|
FtsZ staining patterns changed along with the change in DAPI staining
during the time course . Intense FtsZ staining occurred at a
nucleoid-free gap at midcell in 90% of untreated cells, with little
FtsZ staining elsewhere in the cell (Fig . 3A) . After
10 min of rifampin treatment, FtsZ staining was still predominantly
at midcell, coincident with nucleoid-free gaps, but a significant
amount of staining could be observed in other areas of the cell
(data not shown) . After 30 min of rifampin treatment, FtsZ staining
was now predominantly at locations other than midcell . In more than
35% of these cells, multiple bands of FtsZ staining (two to five)
were detected (Fig . 3D) . As the sizes of most cells
were in the range of 2 to 5 µm, the distances between FtsZ bands were
shorter than normal, averaging 0.8 µm . This compares to 1.3 µm in
min
mutant cells, in which Z rings are present at all nucleoid-free gaps
but not on top of nucleoids (47) . Because the
nucleoid appeared to be distributed throughout the cell (Fig.
3E to F), by definition all of the FtsZ bands were
located on top of nucleoids .
The intensities of different FtsZ bands in each cell varied . By
analysis of the positions of 122 intensely staining bands, we found a
tendency to localize near the cell center, but not always at the
exact midcell site (Fig . 4) . Bright bands at other
acentral positions were also observed . Although we do not know when
these bright bands formed, their presence at regions far from midcell
indicates that most of these structures were not present prior to
drug treatment . Furthermore, premature FtsZ assembly was detected as
fluorescent foci in most cells, even in some cells that did not
contain a clear Z ring . The patterns suggest that more nucleation
sites are available for FtsZ assembly in these cells . Such patterns
are not a result of failure of the Min system to oscillate, because
we observed typical green fluorescent protein (GFP)-MinD oscillation
in rifampin-treated WM1255 cells (data not shown) . Perhaps the weaker
FtsZ accumulations in such cells resulted from ongoing division
inhibition by MinCD .
|
FIG . 4 . Distribution of FtsZ bands in rifampin-treated cells . A total of
122 cells, treated with rifampin as in Fig . 3D to F,
were measured . The x axis represents positions of FtsZ bands
relative to cell length, with 0.5 representing midcell and 0.0
representing a cell pole.
|
|
We next asked whether removing the Min system would alter the pattern
of FtsZ staining in the presence of rifampin . We treated
minCDE::kan
cells (WM1032) with rifampin and stained them for FtsZ and nucleoids .
As expected, after only 30 min of rifampin treatment, nearly all
cells exhibited a diffuse nucleoid stain in the short filamentous
cells that are typical of a
min
mutant (Fig . 3K) . This is in contrast to the
distinct multiple nucleoids visible in untreated
min
cells (Fig . 3M) . While clear Z rings formed only
between well-distributed nucleoids in the untreated cells (Fig.
3L), bands of FtsZ staining were located apparently
randomly in
min
cells treated with rifampin, with the spacing between bands sometimes
as short as 0.5 µm (Fig . 3J) . Moreover, unlike
Min-positive cells, Min-negative cells treated with rifampin
exhibited FtsZ bands throughout the cell length with no bias towards
the cell center, as well as greater uniformity of band intensities
(Fig . 4) (data not shown) . This bias toward the
cell center would be consistent with the Min system being fully
functional in the presence of rifampin .
To confirm independently that blocking transcription relieves
nucleoid occlusion, we examined FtsZ localization in an rpoD800
mutant, in which the major transcription initiation factor,
70,
can be thermoinactivated . After a 1-h inactivation of
70
in cells containing rpoD800 at 45°C, nucleoids stained with
DAPI appeared to be diffuse throughout the whole cell, similar
to those observed after rifampin treatment (Fig . 3T to V) .
Multiple FtsZ bands were positioned on top of nucleoids in a pattern
similar to that in rifampin-treated cells (Fig . 3N to S) .
Wild-type cells grown at the same temperature (Fig . 3W)
or rpoD800 cells grown at 30°C demonstrated normal FtsZ
localization (data not shown) . This result indicates that
transcription inactivation itself interrupts division inhibition by
the nucleoid, possibly by altering local density of the DNA .
Nucleoid occlusion remains active after blocking translation.
To test if preventing protein translation also leads to disrupted
cell division, we treated wild-type TX3772 cells with chloramphenicol,
which inhibits peptidyl transferase activity but leaves mRNA
synthesis unchanged (19, 24) . TX3772 cells
growing exponentially in either M9 glucose or LB medium at 28°C were
treated with chloramphenicol . After treatment for 0.5 to 2 h,
nucleoids appeared to be fused and compact (Fig . 3H and
I) (data not shown) as reported previously (38,
39) . Z rings were often acentral, with a high
proportion of FtsZ staining at the cell poles (Fig . 3G)
(data not shown) . Frequently abnormal FtsZ structures (foci and
tilted bands) were visualized at the cell poles . However, we did not
detect FtsZ staining on top of the condensed nucleoids in these
cells, and rarely were there multiple FtsZ bands or helices visible .
These results indicate that after chloramphenicol treatment, polar
division sites are available for FtsZ assembly and compacted
nucleoids retain their function to inhibit Z-ring assembly . As the
Min proteins oscillate normally in the presence of chloramphenicol (31),
the availability of polar sites for FtsZ assembly must be either a
result of an unstable component of the Min system, such as MinC, or
some other unknown factor .
Effects of inhibiting protein translocation on NO. The major
route for protein export or insertion into the membrane in bacteria
occurs via the Sec-dependent transport apparatus . The core complex of
this apparatus, consisting of SecYEG, forms a protein-conducting
channel in the inner membrane, while the ATPase SecA drives
translocation of substrate across the membrane (3) .
We tested whether SecA-mediated protein translocation and export had
any effects on nucleoid occlusion . A mutant with a thermosensitivity
mutation in secA (secA51) (27) was grown
at the nonpermissive temperature of 42°C for 2 h and stained
for FtsZ . These mutant cells appear to have a defect in chromosome
segregation as well as cell division (Fig . 5C) . Large
nucleoids, presumably carrying multiple chromosomes, were visible in
short filaments . Z rings localized between segregated nucleoids in
many cells, but in cells with one central nucleoid or in filaments
with large unsegregated nucleoids, FtsZ almost always localized
away from the nucleoids at nucleoid edges . Septation from these rings
occasionally resulted in anucleate cells, some of which had a Z ring
at midcell (vertical arrows) . This phenotype is very similar to that
of chromosome segregation mutants like parC or parE (35) .
These results suggest that unpartitioned nucleoids produced in a
secA mutant still exclude FtsZ from assembling in their vicinity
and that disruption of Sec-mediated translocation does not abolish NO
activity . The reasons for the nucleoid segregation defect after
inactivation of secA are not apparent and will require further
study .
|
FIG . 5 . Nucleoid and FtsZ distribution in a protein secretion mutant .
The secA51 mutant was grown at 42°C for 2 h to inhibit sec-mediated
protein translocation, and cells were fixed and stained . (A) FtsZ
immunofluorescence staining . (B) Overlay of DAPI and FtsZ staining . (C)
Overlay of DAPI staining and phase-contrast image . Vertical arrows
highlight anucleate regions or anucleate cells containing Z rings, while
horizontal arrows highlight acentral FtsZ staining in cells with a
central nucleoid.
|
|
Many factors influence nucleoid structure, directly or indirectly . To
understand how nucleoid structure might influence NO, we investigated
the effects of altering DNA supercoiling levels or blocking
transcription, translation, or protein translocation on NO activity .
Our results demonstrated that superhelical relaxation of nucleoids
does not affect NO, resulting in abnormal placement of Z rings at
nucleoid edges, distal from midcell . This supports earlier work that
showed abnormal placement of septa when gyrase is thermoinactivated (28) .
The active NO in gyrB mutants stands in contrast to that in
mukB mutants, in which Z rings often form on top of the
decondensed nucleoids . One possible explanation is that in the
gyrB mutant at the nonpermissive temperature of 42°C, the
activity of MukB maintains a sufficiently high level of local
nucleoid density that is capable of blocking most Z rings from
assembling over the nucleoid .
Our results also showed that in the absence of MukB, the nucleoid
regains its ability to inhibit Z-ring assembly when topoisomerase I
is inactivated in the topA mukB double mutant . This was not
surprising, given that the double mutant cells grow and divide fairly
normally (32), and supports the notion that increased
local DNA concentration is sufficient to activate NO . However,
many topA mukB cells at 28°C displayed multiple Z rings, with
the ring cluster centered about a gap between nucleoids but often
extending into the nucleoid region . This suggests that NO is
partially suppressed under these conditions near the nucleoid edges .
Nucleoid edges were also less active in NO than more central parts of
the nucleoid in
mukB
min
double mutants (46) . This effect might reflect a
gradient of NO, which might be in excess throughout normal nucleoids
but is unmasked in mukB mutants under certain conditions .
Another possibility is that nucleoids in a mukB mutant are not
decondensed uniformly and have a higher local density towards their
centers, resulting in more complete NO there than near nucleoid
edges .
Importantly, we found that division inhibition by nucleoids was
compromised in cells in which transcription was inhibited . Multiple
FtsZ structures, possibly Z rings and possibly a continuous helix of
FtsZ, assemble on top of the nucleoid . This is suggestive of relief
of NO such that more potential division sites are available for FtsZ
assembly . This FtsZ localization phenotype was also observed in
rifampin-treated cells when grown in M9 glucose medium (data not
shown) . This was not seen in mukB cells, possibly because
there is some residual NO in mukB cells that tends to shunt
most unassembled FtsZ to cooperative assembly at a few Z rings . When
transcription was inhibited by thermoinactivation of
70,
the nucleoid and FtsZ staining patterns were similar to those with
rifampin, indicating that the effects were not artifacts specific to
the drug .
In contrast, chloramphenicol treatment resulted in a clearly
different effect on FtsZ localization . While FtsZ often still
localized at midcell after rifampin treatment, midcell Z rings were
extremely rare after chloramphenicol treatment . Although many
indirect effects could be involved, one possible explanation for this
difference is the distinct difference in nucleoid structure after
treatment with rifampin versus chloramphenicol . It is generally
accepted that chloramphenicol treatment leads to nucleoid fusion and
compaction, while the rifampin does not (9, 10,
20, 38, 39) .
The diffusion of the nucleoid throughout the cell after rifampin
treatment is very clear, particularly in the
min
mutant because of the ease of visualizing multiple nucleoids in the
filamentous cells characteristic of this mutant . The mechanism
behind this apparent decompaction of nucleoids after transcription
inhibition is unknown, but the effect is similar to that of
inhibiting MukB . Likewise, the nucleoid compaction by chloramphenicol
treatment might mimic the topA suppression of the mukB defect .
The effects of blocking either transcription or translation are
likely to be highly complex . However, one possible explanation for
the absence of Z rings at midcell after chloramphenicol treatment is
that the resulting compact nucleoid occludes assembly of new Z rings .
If so, this would be surprising given the assumption that the
nucleoid retracts from the membrane when transertion is blocked . The
disappearance of midcell Z rings in the first place may be caused by
the need for continuous protein synthesis to maintain Z rings or
perhaps by some type of interference by the nucleoid undergoing
compaction . We favor the latter idea, only because chloramphenicol
treatment does not prevent FtsZ from assembling into structures; they
are present, but just not at midcell . Another possible explanation
for the different effects of blocking translation versus
transcription is that NO might be mediated by a specific RNA .
What might cause FtsZ to localize preferentially away from midcell
after chloramphenicol treatment? One possibility is that the Min
system is inactivated, allowing Z rings to form in nucleoid-free
spaces, which are larger because of nucleoid compaction . As the Min
proteins continue to oscillate after chloramphenicol treatment,
perhaps some other aspect of Min protein function is inactivated . It
is also possible that another unknown factor that is important for
negatively regulating Z-ring assembly is destabilized during
chloramphenicol treatment, allowing extra Z rings to form in
nucleoid-free spaces . It is clear, however, that after extended
blocking of translation, FtsZ protein remains sufficiently abundant
and stable to be able to assemble into structures .
A model that summarizes the results in this study is shown in Fig.
6 . The results are all consistent with the idea that a
compact unsegregated nucleoid, either in normal cells (Fig .
6A) or in cells treated with chloramphenicol (Fig.
6B), will exclude Z-ring assembly via NO, while a
diffuse nucleoid, either because of transcription inhibition (Fig.
6C) or decompaction resulting from the loss of MukB
or SMC, will suppress NO and allow FtsZ to assemble in areas occupied
by the nucleoid . An important caveat to the present study is that it
is possible that the effects we attribute to NO are actually direct
effects of the drugs or mutations on FtsZ assembly and positioning,
independent of NO or at least not completely dependent on NO .
Unfortunately, this caveat will persist until a more specific
mechanism for NO is found, such that more specific alterations in NO
can be constructed that will minimize the potential for indirect and
nonspecific effects .
|
FIG . 6 . Summary diagram of the observed effects of transcription and
translation inhibition on NO.
|
|
We thank Lynn Zechiedrich for the gyrB mutant strain, Alicia
Dombroski for the rpoD800 strain, Jim Sawitzke for CC4207, and
the E . coli Genetic Stock Center for the secA51 strain .
This work was supported by a grant (GM61074) from the National
Institutes of Health .
* Corresponding author: Department of Microbiology and
Molecular Genetics, University of Texas Medical School, 6431 Fannin, Houston, TX
77030 . Phone: (713) 500-5452 . Fax: (713) 500-5499 . E-mail: William.Margolin@uth.tmc.edu.
- Britton, R . A., B . S . Powell, S . Dasgupta, Q . Sun, W .
Margolin, J . R . Lupski, and D . L . Court. 1998 . Cell cycle arrest in Era
GTPase mutants: a potential growth rate regulated checkpoint in Escherichia
coli. Mol . Microbiol . 27:739-750.
- Chen, C . R., M . Malik, M . Snyder, and K . Drlica. 1996 .
DNA gyrase and topoisomerase IV on the bacterial chromosome: quinolone-induced
DNA cleavage . J . Mol . Biol . 258:627-637.
- Collinson, I., C . Breyton, F . Duong, C . Tziatzios, D .
Schubert, E . Or, T . Rapoport, and W . Kuhlbrandt. 2001 . Projection
structure and oligomeric properties of a bacterial core protein translocase .
EMBO J . 20:2462-2471 .
- Corbin, B . D., X.-C . Yu, and W . Margolin. 2002 . Exploring
intracellular space: function of the Min system in round-shaped Escherichia
coli. EMBO J . 21:1988-2008.
- Dasgupta, S., S . Maisnier-Patin, and K . Nordstrom. 2000 .
New genes with old modus operandi . The connection between supercoiling and
partitioning of DNA in Escherichia coli. EMBO Rep . 1:323-327 .
- de Boer, P . A . J., R . E . Crossley, and L . I . Rothfield.
1989 . A division inhibitor and a topological specificity factor coded for by
the minicell locus determine the proper placement of the division site in
Escherichia coli. Cell 56:641-649.
- Den Blaauwen, T., N . Buddelmeijer, M . E . G . Aarsman, C . M .
Hameete, and N . Nanninga. 1999 . Timing of FtsZ assembly in Escherichia
coli. J . Bacteriol . 181:5167-5175 .
- DiNardo, S., K . A . Voelkel, R . Sternglanz, A . E . Reynolds,
and A . Wright. 1982 . Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I mutants have
compensatory mutations in DNA gyrase genes . Cell 31:43-51.
- Dworsky, P. 1975 . Unfolding of the chromosome of
Escherichia coli after treatment with rifampicin . Z . Allg . Mikrobiol .
15:243-247.
- Dworsky, P., and M . Schaechter. 1973 . Effect of rifampin
on the structure and membrane attachment of the nucleoid of Escherichia
coli. J . Bacteriol . 116:1364-1374.
- Filutowicz, M. 1980 . Requirement of DNA gyrase for the
initiation of chromosome replication in Escherichia coli K-12 . Mol .
Gen . Genet . 177:301-309.
- Fu, X., Y . L . Shih, Y . Zhang, and L . I . Rothfield. 2001 .
The MinE ring required for proper placement of the division site is a mobile
structure that changes its cellular location during the Escherichia coli
division cycle . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 98:980-985 .
- Gellert, M., M . H . O'Dea, T . Itoh, and J . Tomizawa.
1976 . Novobiocin and coumermycin inhibit DNA supercoiling catalyzed by DNA
gyrase . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 73:4474-4478.
- Gross, C . A., A . D . Grossman, H . Liebke, W . Walter, and R .
R . Burgess. 1984 . Effects of the mutant sigma allele rpoD800 on the
synthesis of specific macromolecular components of the Escherichia coli
K12 cell . J . Mol . Biol . 172:283-300.
- Hale, C . A., H . Meinhardt, and P . A . de Boer. 2001 .
Dynamic localization cycle of the cell division regulator MinE in
Escherichia coli. EMBO J . 20:1563-1572 .
- Hu, Z., and J . Lutkenhaus. 2001 . Topological regulation
of cell division in E . coli. spatiotemporal oscillation of MinD
requires stimulation of Its ATPase by MinE and phospholipid . Mol . Cell 7:1337-1343.
- Hu, Z., A . Mukherjee, S . Pichoff, and J . Lutkenhaus.
1999 . The MinC component of the division site selection system in
Escherichia coli interacts with FtsZ to prevent polymerization . Proc .
Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 96:14819-14824 .
- Huang, K . C., Y . Meir, and N . S . Wingreen. 2003 . Dynamic
structures in Escherichia coli: spontaneous formation of MinE rings and
MinD polar zones . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 100:12724-12728 .
- Imamoto, F. 1973 . Diversity of regulation of genetic
transcription . I . Effect of antibiotics which inhibit the process of
translation on RNA metabolism in Escherichia coli. J . Mol . Biol . 74:113-136.
- Lin, C . G., O . Kovalsky, and L . Grossman. 1998 .
Transcription coupled nucleotide excision repair by isolated Escherichia
coli membrane-associated nucleoids . Nucleic Acids Res . 26:1466-1472 .
- Margolin, W. 2001 . Spatial regulation of cytokinesis in
bacteria . Curr . Opin . Microbiol . 4:647-652.
- Migocki, M . D., M . K . Freeman, R . G . Wake, and E . J . Harry.
2002 . The Min system is not required for precise placement of the midcell Z
ring in Bacillus subtilis . EMBO Rep . 3:1163-1167 .
- Mizuuchi, K., M . H . O'Dea, and M . Gellert. 1978 . DNA
gyrase: subunit structure and ATPase activity of the purified enzyme . Proc .
Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 75:5960-5963.
- Moazed, D., and H . F . Noller. 1987 . Chloramphenicol,
erythromycin, carbomycin and vernamycin B protect overlapping sites in the
peptidyl transferase region of 23S ribosomal RNA . Biochimie 69:879-884.
- Niki, H., A . Jaffé, R . Imamura, T . Ogura, and S . Hiraga.
1991 . The new gene mukB codes for a 177-kD protein with coiled-coil
domains involved in chromosome partitioning of Escherichia coli. EMBO
J . 10:183-194.
- Norris, V. 1995 . Hypothesis: chromosome separation in
Escherichia coli involves autocatalytic gene expression, transertion and
membrane-domain formation . Mol . Microbiol . 16:1051-1057.
- Oliver, D . B., and J . Beckwith. 1981 . E . coli mutant
pleiotropically defective in the export of secreted proteins . Cell 25:765-772.
- Orr, E., N . F . Fairweather, I . B . Holland, and R . H .
Pritchard. 1979 . Isolation and characterisation of a strain carrying a
conditional lethal mutation in the cou gene of Escherichia coli K12 .
Mol . Gen . Genet . 177:103-112.
- Pruss, G . J., S . H . Manes, and K . Drlica. 1982 .
Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I mutants: increased supercoiling is
corrected by mutations near gyrase genes . Cell 31:35-42.
- Raskin, D . M., and P . A . J . de Boer. 1999 .
MinDE-dependent pole-to-pole oscillation of division inhibitor MinC in
Escherichia coli. J . Bacteriol . 181:6419-6424 .
- Raskin, D . M., and P . A . de Boer. 1999 . Rapid
pole-to-pole oscillation of a protein required for directing division to the
middle of Escherichia coli. Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 96:4971-4976 .
- Sawitzke, J . A., and S . Austin. 2000 . Suppression of
chromosome segregation defects of Escherichia coli muk mutants by
mutations in topoisomerase I . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 97:1671-1676 .
- Sternglanz, R., S . DiNardo, K . A . Voelkel, Y . Nishimura, Y .
Hirota, K . Becherer, L . Zumstein, and J . C . Wang. 1981 . Mutations in the
gene coding for Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I affect
transcription and transposition . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 78:2747-2751.
- Sun, Q., and W . Margolin. 2001 . Influence of the
nucleoid on placement of FtsZ and MinE rings in Escherichia coli. J .
Bacteriol . 183:1413-1422 .
- Sun, Q., X.-C . Yu, and W . Margolin. 1998 . Assembly of
the FtsZ ring at the central division site in the absence of the chromosome .
Mol . Microbiol . 29:491-504.
- Trueba, F . J. 1982 . On the precision and accuracy
achieved by Escherichia coli cells at fission about their middle . Arch .
Microbiol . 131:55-59.
- Tsui, H.-C . T., G . Feng, and M . E . Winkler. 1997 .
Negative regulation of mutS and mutH repair gene expression by
the Hfq and RpoS global regulators of Escherichia coli K-12 . J .
Bacteriol . 179:7476-7487.
- Van Helvoort, J . M., P . G . Huls, N . O . Vischer, and C . L .
Woldringh. 1998 . Fused nucleoids resegregate faster than cell elongation
in Escherichia coli pbpB(Ts) filaments after release from
chloramphenicol inhibition . Microbiology 144:1309-1317.
- van Helvoort, J . M . L . M., J . Kool, and C . L . Woldringh.
1996 . Chloramphenicol causes fusion of separated nucleoids in Escherichia
coli K-12 cells and filaments . J . Bacteriol . 178:4289-4293.
- Wehrli, W., F . Knusel, K . Schmid, and M . Staehelin.
1968 . Interaction of rifamycin with bacterial RNA polymerase . Proc . Natl .
Acad . Sci . USA 61:667-673.
- Woldringh, C., E . Mulder, J . Valkenburg, F . Wientjes, A .
Zaritsky, and N . Nanninga. 1990 . Role of the nucleoid in the
toporegulation of division . Res . Microbiol . 141:39-49.
- Woldringh, C . L. 2002 . The role of co-transcriptional
translation and protein translocation (transertion) in bacterial chromosome
segregation . Mol . Microbiol . 45:17-29.
- Woldringh, C . L., P . R . Jensen, and H . V . Westerhoff.
1995 . Structure and partitioning of bacterial DNA: determined by a balance of
compaction and expansion forces? FEMS Microbiol . Lett . 131:235-242.
- Woldringh, C . L., E . Mulder, P . G . Huls, and N . Vischer.
1991 . Toporegulation of bacterial division according to the nucleoid occlusion
model . Res . Microbiol . 142:309-320.
- Yamanaka, K., T . Mitani, J . Feng, T . Ogura, H . Niki, and S .
Hiraga. 1994 . Two mutant alleles of mukB, a gene essential for
chromosome partition in Escherichia coli. FEMS Microbiol . Lett . 123:27-31.
- Yu, X., Q . Sun, and W . Margolin. 2001 . FtsZ rings in
mukB mutants with or without the Min system . Biochimie 83:125-129.
- Yu, X.-C., and W . Margolin. 1999 . FtsZ ring clusters in
min and partition mutants: role of both the Min system and the nucleoid
in regulating FtsZ ring localization . Mol . Microbiol . 32:315-326.
- Yura, T., and A . Ishihama. 1979 . Genetics of bacterial
RNA polymerases . Annu . Rev . Genet . 13:59-97.
Free Online Full-text Article
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
|