|








| |
Applied and Environmental Microbiology, November 2003, p . 6370-6379, Vol . 69, No . 11
Multilocus Sequence Typing for Comparison of Veterinary and Human Isolates of Campylobacter jejuni
Georgina Manning,1 Christopher G . Dowson,2 Mary C . Bagnall,1 If H . Ahmed,1 Malcolm West,3 and Diane G . Newell1*
Veterinary
Laboratories Agency (Weybridge), New Haw, Addlestone, Surrey KT15
3NB,1
Department of Biological
Sciences, University of Warwick, Coventry CV4
7AL,2
Queen's Hospital,
Burton-on-Trent, Staffordshire, United
Kingdom3
Received 22 January 2003/
Accepted 27 August 2003
Multilocus
sequence typing (MLST) has been applied to 266 Campylobacter
jejuni isolates, mainly from veterinary sources, including cattle,
sheep, poultry, pigs, pets, and the environment, as well as isolates
from human cases of campylobacteriosis . The populations of veterinary
and human isolates overlap, suggesting that most veterinary sources
should be considered reservoirs of pathogenic campylobacters . There
were some associations between source and sequence type complex,
indicating that host or source adaptation may exist . The pig isolates
formed a distinct group by MLST and may well represent a potential
pig-adapted clone of C . jejuni . A subset
(n = 82) of isolates was reanalyzed with a second MLST
scheme which provided a unique set of isolates that had been analyzed
at a total of 12 loci . The distribution of isolates among the complexes
in each of the two schemes was similar but not identical . In addition
to isolates from human outbreaks, one group of isolates that were not
epidemiologically linked was also identical at all 12 loci . This group
of isolates is believed to represent another stable strain of C.
jejuni .
Campylobacter jejuni and C . coli are major causes of
acute bacterial enteritis in humans worldwide . In 2001, there were
56,420 reported cases in England and Wales (Communicable Disease
Surveillance Centre), which, according to a recent
intestinal infectious diseases survey, is an underestimate of about
eightfold (29).
Campylobacters colonize many animals but appear to have evolved for
optimal growth in the avian gut as a commensal . Many poultry flocks
worldwide are colonized with these organisms
(9) . A major human risk
factor for the acquisition of campylobacter infection is thought to be
the handling or consumption of contaminated poultry meat . Despite this,
previous studies using typing methods have suggested that the ranges of
campylobacter types found in humans and chickens do not totally
overlap . These studies concluded that some isolates infecting humans do
not colonize chickens, and conversely, some isolates colonizing
chickens do not infect humans
(4,
15,
16) . The implications
from these findings are that other sources of campylobacter infection
may be important in human disease and possibly that not all
campylobacters are pathogenic to humans . Other food-producing animals
such as cattle, sheep, and pigs carry this organism in their guts;
however, the relative risk of human infection associated with these
potential sources is unclear .
C . jejuni is known to be a
highly diverse species . This is exemplified by the wide range of
phenotypes and genotypes detectable by a number of techniques, such as
serotyping, pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE), and amplified
fragment length polymorphism (AFLP)
(32) . The recent
application of multilocus sequence typing (MLST) to C . jejuni,
in agreement with previous studies, has shown that the organism is
genetically diverse, yet it has a weakly clonal population structure.
This means that there is evidence of frequent recombination within a
clonal framework (5,
6,
20,
28) . MLST is similar to
multilocus enzyme electrophoresis (MLEE) in that it measures variation
in housekeeping genes located around the genome . The advantage of MLST
is that this variation is determined at the level of DNA sequence, thus
making the technique both highly reproducible and portable
(17) . These previous MLST
studies on C . jejuni concentrated mainly on isolates of human
origin, and there is a general paucity of information regarding where
strains isolated from veterinary sources fit into the overall
population structure of this organism .
For this study, MLST was
applied to study the genetic relationships of 266 isolates of
veterinary and human origin . Veterinary isolates were obtained from
poultry, cattle, sheep, pigs, and pets as well as from the environment
in and around broiler houses .
Campylobacter
isolates.
C.
jejuni isolates (n = 266) were selected to
represent a wide range of veterinary sources, some of which may act as
reservoirs of potentially pathogenic organisms . The majority of
isolates were from the United Kingdom (n = 231);
however, isolates were also included that were from Denmark (n
= 13), Czech Republic (n = 9), The Netherlands
(n = 8), South Africa (n = 3), France
(n = 1), and Sweden (n = 1) . Isolates
were selected from poultry (n = 70), cattle
(n = 63), sheep (n = 40), pigs
(n = 22), and pets (n = 8) as well as
from the environment in and around broiler houses (n =
9) . Human isolates were included for comparison (n =
51) . The three remaining isolates were from diverse origins, including
an ostrich (n = 1), a giraffe (n =
1), and a water source (n = 1) . The poultry isolates
were obtained from cloacal swabs of live broiler chickens, whereas the
cattle, sheep, and pig isolates were obtained from fecal samples taken
from animals at slaughter during a national abattoir survey in the
United Kingdom . The pet isolates were obtained from fecal samples taken
at a pet boarding facility in the United Kingdom, and the human
isolates were mainly from fecal samples, predominantly from sporadic
cases, although some human outbreak isolates were also
included .
Bacterial growth and
preparation of genomic DNA.
All C . jejuni isolates were
grown on 10% (vol/vol) sheep blood agar plates with actidione
(250 µg/ml) and Skirrow's supplement (10 µg of
vancomycin per ml, 2.5 IU of polymyxin B per ml, 5 µg of
trimethoprim per ml) at 42°C in a microaerobic environment
(7.5% [vol/vol] CO2, 7.5%
[vol/vol] O2, 85% [vol/vol]
N2) for 24 to 48 h . Genomic DNA was extracted by
the cetyltrimethylammonium bromide-NaCl method
(2) . DNA pellets were
resuspended in 100 µl of distilled water and stored at
4°C .
Loci and primers
used.
All PCR products were
amplified by use of previously described primers
(6), referred to as scheme
A . A subset of isolates (n = 82) were also analyzed by
a second MLST scheme, scheme B . The loci for scheme B were selected
prior to completion of the genome sequence of C . jejuni
NCTC11168 and before the scheme A loci were made accessible . Figure
1 shows the positions of these loci compared to scheme A in the now
completed genome of NCTC11168
(24) . The loci were as
follows: dihydroxy acid dehydratase (ilvD), adenylate kinase
(adk), citrate synthase (gltA), D-lactate
dehydrogenase (Cj1585c; reannotated as putative oxidoreductase),
glucose-6-phosphate isomerase (pgi), and malate dehydrogenase
(mdh) . Initially, the MLST scheme consisted of seven loci, as
that was deemed to be the minimum number of loci required to provide
sufficient discrimination for an MLST scheme
(8) . The katA
locus was removed at an early stage, as it was found to be very
variable, apparently with evidence of evolution being driven by a
strong selective pressure (R . J . Meinersmann, personal
communication) . The region of the gltA locus sequenced was the
same for both schemes . The primer sequences for scheme B are given in
Table
1 . Each primer was used for both amplification and sequencing reactions.
Alternative primer sequences are given and were used when
necessary .
|
FIG . 1 . Positions
of the loci for both scheme A (filled circles) and scheme B (open
circles) in the genome of C . jejuni strain
NCTC11168.
|
|
|
TABLE 1 . Primer
sequences used for PCR amplification and sequence determination of the
loci for MLST scheme B
|
|
Amplification and nucleotide
sequence determination.
PCRs were carried out in
25-µl reaction volumes, with a typical reaction comprising the
following:
10 ng of C . jejuni chromosomal DNA, 175 ng
of each PCR primer, 1x PCR buffer (Invitrogen), 1.5 mM
MgCl2, 200 µM deoxynucleoside triphosphates, and
1.25 U of Taq DNA polymerase (Invitrogen) . The reaction
conditions were an initial denaturation at 95°C for 5 min,
followed by 25 cycles of the following: 94°C for 45
s, primer annealing at 55 or 60°C for 45 s, and
extension at 72°C for 1 min 30 s . The PCR products
were purified either by precipitation with 20% (wt/vol)
polyethylene glycol-2.5 M NaCl
(2) or by use of the
Qiaquick multiwell PCR purification kit (Qiagen), and the concentration
was estimated by agarose gel electrophoresis . Sequence reactions were
carried out in BigDye Ready reaction mix (Applied Biosystems) used in
accordance with the manufacturer's instructions or by use of the
CEQ DTCS sequencing system (Beckman Coulter) . Unincorporated dye
terminators were removed by precipitation with 95% ethanol, and
the sequenced products were separated and detected with an ABI Prism
3700, ABI 377 automated DNA sequencer (Applied Biosystems) or a CEQ
2000 DNA sequencer (Beckman Coulter) . Sequences were assembled and
edited by use of Seqman (DNASTAR;
Lasergene) .
Allele and ST
assignment.
For scheme A,
alleles and sequence types (STs) were assigned by submitting the DNA
sequence to the Campylobacter MLST database
(http://campylobacter.mlst.net).
For scheme B, the loci and STs were assigned arbitrary numbers in the
order of identification . The organization of isolates into clonal
complexes was carried out by use of the program BURST (based upon
related STs), which is part of the START (Sequence Type Assignment
Recombination Tests) group of programs (E . J . Feil and
M . C . Chan; http://campylobacter.mlst.net)
(14) . Isolates were
grouped together if they shared five, six, or seven of the seven total
scheme A loci or four, five, or six of the six total scheme B loci.
Only one member of each outbreak was included in these analyses . To
avoid artifacts in complex assignment due to chaining effects, the
clonal complexes were verified by cross-checking with the Campylobacter
MLST database, in the case of scheme A, and by UPGMA(unweighted pair group method with arithmetic means) analysis, in the
case of scheme B .
Linkage
analysis.
Linkage analysis
was carried out by using the index of association
(IA), as defined previously
(14,
27) . We examined whether
alleles were randomly associated, that is, at linkage equilibrium,
indicating a freely recombining population, or nonrandomly associated,
that is, at linkage disequilibrium, implying a clonal population
structure . If there is linkage equilibrium, i.e., a random association
between alleles of different loci, IA = 0.
If IA is significantly different from 0, it
indicates that recombination has been rare or absent and that the
population has a clonal structure
(19) .
Statistical
analysis.
The tests for
association were carried out by use of Pearson's chi-square test.
A two-way frequency table of sample source by ST complex was created,
and the observed number of isolates from each source within the ST
complex was compared with that expected on the assumption of
independence of the row and column categories . The expected value was
obtained by assuming that the isolates from each source are distributed
among the clonal complexes according to the proportion of the total
number of isolates occupied by each complex, e.g., since 30.8%
of the data set constitutes the ST21 complex, the assumption is that
30.8% of the isolates from each source would be part of the ST21
complex . Only one representative of each of the outbreaks was included
in this analysis . StatXact software was used to calculate the exact
significance probabilities .
Invasion
assay.
The invasion assay
used was a gentamicin protection assay based on the method of
Elsinghorst (7), with some
modifications (10).
Briefly, a monolayer of INT407 cells (ca . 5 x 105
cells per ml) was inoculated with broth-grown bacteria at a ratio of 50
to 200 bacteria per INT407 cell . To avoid variation in invasiveness due
to motility, the bacteria were centrifuged onto the monolayer at room
temperature for 15 min at 800 x g . Invasion was
allowed to occur for 3 h at 37°C in 5%
CO2, after which nonassociated bacteria were removed by
washing three times with Hanks balanced salt solution (Sigma).
Associated bacteria were removed during a 2-h incubation at
37°C in 5% CO2 with 2 ml of a
250-µg/ml solution of gentamicin (Sigma) . Finally, the
monolayer was washed three more times, and the internalized bacteria
were then released by lysis of the INT407 cells with 1% Triton
X-100 (Sigma) and were enumerated by plate count . Due to variations
between assays, all isolates to be compared were included in the same
assay, within which each isolate was assayed in triplicate . Each assay
was repeated at least three times to verify the results . For each
assay, a one-way analysis of variance followed by the Newman-Keuls
multiple comparison test was carried out by use of GraphPad Prism
software .
Genetic
relatedness of isolates.
Overall, the 266 isolates were grouped
into 19 clonal complexes, based on the fact that the isolates within
one complex are identical at five, six, or all of the seven MLST loci
(Table
2) . There are highly significant associations among STs of bovine
(P < 0.001), pig (P < 0.001), sheep
(P < 0.001), and poultry (P < 0.001)
samples, and by comparing the observed and expected sample frequencies,
we can see which complexes are associated with particular sources . The
ST21 complex contains isolates from most sources, whereas some of the
other main complexes have over- or under-representations of isolates
from particular sources . The most obvious example of this is the ST403
complex, which consists of a total of 18 isolates, 16 of which are from
pigs . There were also more than expected bovine isolates in the ST61
complex, sheep isolates in the ST42 and ST206 complexes, and poultry
isolates in the ST45 complex .
|
TABLE 2 . Distribution
of all 266 isolates among ST complexes when MLST scheme A was used
|
|
Confirmation
of genetic stability by using MLST.
An investigation of epidemiologically
linked isolates provides an opportunity to investigate the robustness
of the MLST technique in an organism known to be prone to genetic
instability (31) . As
expected, the human outbreak isolates within this study had identical
MLST types within each outbreak (Table
2) . These isolates were
also identical by a range of other genotyping schemes, such as PFGE,
AFLP, phage typing, and ribotyping (data not shown) . One set of
outbreak isolates, originally isolated in 1981 (human O/B4)
(23), was found to be
divided into two groups according to Penner serotype
(25) . This observation
was confirmed more recently by other genotyping methods
(18) . In this study, this
group of isolates was also divided into two groups by MLST: human
O/B4a and human O/B4b (ST267 and ST563,
respectively; the former is part of the ST283 complex and the latter is
part of the ST177 complex) . The outbreak 4a group of isolates was
previously found to be highly similar (with a level of homology of
95% by AFLP) to a group of isolates from a broiler house
environment almost 20 years later and was thought to represent a stable
strain of C . jejuni
(18) . The group of
isolates from the broiler house environment, comprising isolates EX524,
EX497, EX543, and EX496, are all in the group ST564 (Table
2) . Interestingly, ST267
and ST564, both within the ST283 complex, differ at just one locus,
glyA, by MLST, which in fact is represented by a single
nucleotide change, probably having arisen by point mutation . The second
outbreak group (O/B4b), as expected, was very different by
MLST (ST563) . ST563 is part of the ST177 complex, as defined previously
(6), which contains
isolates from wild birds and the sand of bathing
beaches .
Reanalysis of a subset of
isolates by use of a second MLST scheme.
A subset of the isolates (n
= 82) included in this study was reanalyzed with a second MLST
scheme, utilizing five more unique loci, as gltA was shared by
both schemes . Comparison of the complex assignment for each scheme,
using just these 82 isolates, revealed that the isolates were grouped
into seven complexes with scheme A and five complexes with scheme B
(Table
3) . The IA increased to 2.50 when 68 unique STs using
12 loci from both schemes were analyzed . The human outbreak isolates
remained identical at all 12 loci, as expected (Table
4) . Interestingly, another
group of isolates were also identical at all 12 loci (Table
5) . This group comprised six isolates of human, bovine, and poultry origin,
from the United Kingdom, Denmark, and The Netherlands, from three
different years within a 12-year period . Since this group appeared to
be so highly related, the phenotypes of the isolates were analyzed in
more detail . The serotype of each isolate was determined by use of the
Laboratory of Enteric Pathogens (LEP; Health Protection Agency,
Colindale, United Kingdom) method
(11), and their invasion
potentials were determined by use of an in vitro gentamicin protection
assay (7) . The results are
given in Table 5 . Two of
the isolates were nontypeable by the LEP method, but of the remaining
four, two different serotypes, serotypes 1 and 50, were obtained . Three
of the five isolates tested in the invasion assay had similar levels of
invasion, whereas isolates 88/238 and 99/118 had significantly greater
invasion potentials than the other isolates within this group
(P <
0.001) .
|
TABLE 3 . Comparison
of the main ST complexes for scheme A and scheme B
|
|
|
TABLE 4 . ST
complexes for the isolates analyzed at all 12 loci
|
|
|
TABLE 5 . Highly
related group of isolates
|
|
Previous
investigations of the population structure of C . jejuni have
indicated that the population is weakly clonal, consisting of large
clonal complexes, some of which may be associated with certain sources,
such as the sand of bathing beaches
(6) . These studies used a
database comprising largely human isolates (61%)
(5), with some isolates
from food sources . For this study, the MLST scheme developed by Dingle
et al . (6) was applied to
215 isolates from veterinary and veterinary-related sources . These were
then compared with 51 human isolates in an attempt to identify
potential overlaps between the veterinary and human populations and to
investigate the presence of host specificity among C . jejuni
strains . A subset of the isolates was also analyzed by a
second MLST scheme which contributed 5 additional loci, providing a
unique set of isolates that were analyzed at a total of 12
loci .
The population analyzed, as described previously
(5,
6,
20), appears to have a
weakly clonal structure, that is, there is clonal structure as well as
some evidence of recombination . The data from this study also clearly
show that campylobacters from veterinary and human populations do
overlap . Each complex detected contained isolates of human and
veterinary origin, apart from the ST403 complex, which contained only
pig and bovine isolates . The distribution of STs among isolates from
cattle, sheep, poultry, pets, and humans has been reported previously
(5,
6) and indicates that
these isolates have perhaps adapted to infect a number of hosts,
supporting the hypothesis that each animal isolate is a potential human
pathogen . This is also in agreement with a previous study in which MLEE
was used to investigate the relationship between animal and human
isolates (1) . In that
study, both human and animal isolates shared electrophoretic types,
with very little distinction between the two populations .
The
association of source with ST complex may indicate that isolates within
ST complexes have adapted to a particular niche or type of niche . The
presence of clonal complexes within an otherwise recombining population
suggests that there must be some selective pressure to maintain this
structure, which may be provided by niche adaptation
(5) . Other mechanisms that
may have influenced this structure include clonal expansion,
geographical or ecological isolation, host immune selection, or
barriers to genetic exchange
(19) .
The
associations with source observed in this study are similar to those
reported previously (5).
The ST45 and ST257 complexes were found to predominantly contain
isolates of human and poultry origin, with significantly more than the
expected number of poultry isolates in the ST45 complex in this study.
There also appears to be a strong association between the ST61 and ST42
complexes and bovine and sheep isolates, respectively, which may be a
reflection of the number of isolates from these sources included in the
study . The presence of host, source, or niche adaptation contradicts
the hypothesis that all campylobacters are potential human pathogens
and instead indicates that nonpathogenic campylobacters may exist
(4,
15,
16) .
There was a
very strong association between the ST403 complex and isolates from
pigs . When compared to the Campylobacter MLST database
(http://campylobacter.mlst.net),
the ST403 complex was found to contain isolates from other food
products as well as from infected humans, indicating that isolates
within this complex do have the capacity to cause disease in humans.
Interestingly, a large number of these human isolates are from the
Dutch Caribbean island of Curaçao (B . Duim, personal
communication) . The reason that a large number of human isolates from a
distinct geographical location are clonally related to C.
jejuni isolates from pigs in the United Kingdom is unclear and
warrants further investigation . In spite of this, a number of the STs
were unique to pigs and may themselves represent pig-adapted isolates.
In a recent report, subtypes of both C . jejuni and C.
coli isolated from pigs were found to be clustered into one of
only four genotypes by ribotyping and flaA restriction
fragment length polymorphism, demonstrating the persistence of clonal
types within this host
(22) . Moreover,
subspecies of both C . jejuni and C . coli isolated
from pigs were identified by MLEE
(21) . Further
identification to the species level of the pig isolates in our study
revealed that they were hippurate-negative C . jejuni isolates
(Stephen On, personal communication) and may represent an unusual
pig-associated clone of C . jejuni .
Interestingly, the
pig isolates had been serotyped by the LEP method
(11) prior to inclusion
in this study . The majority were nontypeable (9 of 16; 56%);
however, four different serotypes (HS23, -35, -29, and -22) were
present among the remaining isolates, confirming that isolates with
identical or very similar genotypes can express different antigens, in
this case detected by LEP serotyping . Moreover, it is unlikely that
this clonal group of pig isolates would have been detected if
serotyping alone had been used . Serotype does not appear to be a good
indicator of clonal complex
(5) . Most clonal complexes
were found to contain multiple serotypes; however, there were
exceptions, as in the case of the ST22 complex, which contained
isolates of HS serotype 19 only
(5) .
One group of
human outbreak isolates within this study was found to be part of the
ST177 complex when compared to the available database . This complex was
previously thought to be associated with isolates from the sand of
bathing beaches and from wild bird feces and thus was presumed to
represent a potentially nonpathogenic group of isolates
(6) . Despite the presence
of human isolates within this ST complex, the association with wild
bird feces might still be plausible, given that the source of the human
outbreak was a water source which was contaminated with fecal matter
from wild birds or bats
(23) . It is possible that
these isolates are more adapted to colonize the intestines of wild
birds and to survive in a particular environment but that when the
opportunity arises, they are capable of causing human disease .
A
number of the isolates from this study were reanalyzed by use of a
second MLST scheme . The largest clonal complex in each scheme shared
similar isolates; however, there were some differences in the exact
clustering which were probably due to the different levels of
discrimination between the two schemes . Most of the variation in scheme
B seemed to be accounted for by two loci, D-lactate
dehydrogenase and adenylate kinase . Adenylate kinase was the most
variable of all the scheme B loci, with 8.9% variable sites
across the 401-bp length . The putative oxidoreductase was the least
variable, but difficulties in amplification were faced for a number of
isolates and alternative primers had to be used .
Isolates which
were epidemiologically linked, such as those from outbreaks, were
clustered together by both schemes, confirming their identities as
clonally related isolates . In contrast, apparently unrelated isolates
differed in their organization within each scheme, which is supported
by the observation that C . jejuni subtyping results generally
only correlate if isolates are clonally related (T . M.
Wassenaar and D . G . Newell, Abstr . 11th Int . Workshop
Campylobacter Helicobacter Related Organisms, abstr . H39, 2001).
Nevertheless, one other interesting group of isolates that shared all
12 loci was also identified . This group of apparently epidemiologically
unlinked isolates were from different geographical locations, sources,
and times, yet they were genotypically highly related . It is
hypothesized, therefore, that this group of isolates represents another
clonal strain of C . jejuni that is similar to the one
previously reported
(18) .
Despite their
genetic relatedness, these isolates were found to vary in serotype as
well as virulence potential, as determined by in vitro assays of
invasion . This is not too surprising, given that it is well established
for other bacteria that identity or similarity of serotype, biotype, or
other phenotypic character does not indicate genetic identity
(26) . The genotypic and
phenotypic diversity that exists within C . jejuni is not due
only to point mutations, horizontal DNA transfer, and genomic
rearrangements detected by MLST
(5,
6) and other genotyping
methods such as fla typing
(12,
13,
30) and PFGE
(31) . It may also be due
to polymorphisms within homonucleotide stretches throughout the genome
(24) that may rapidly
alter the phenotype of the organism
(33) through variation in
gene expression or posttranslational modification .
Of those
isolates whose STs were not yet assigned to a complex, the majority (9
of 18; 50%) were of poultry origin . Poultry isolates were
previously found to have a broader distribution among the clonal
complexes than human isolates
(6), and it is possible
that these isolates are more genetically diverse than those from other
sources . This has also been observed in a previous study
(3) in which many more
fla types were present among poultry isolates than among human
isolates . This genetic diversity among poultry isolates fits with the
theory of bottleneck selection, in which it is proposed that C.
jejuni undergoes variation only during growth inside the host
(Wassenaar and Newell, Abstr . 11th Int . Workshop Campylobacter
Helicobacter Related Organisms) . Such diversity is believed to increase
the chance of a subset of bacteria to survive the environmental
stresses to which they are exposed outside the host . Since C.
jejuni has fastidious growth requirements and appears to be
adapted for growth in the avian gut, it is likely that most of the
variation occurs within this environment, resulting in a greater
diversity of types isolated from poultry . With the addition of more
poultry isolates into this MLST study, most of these so far unassigned
isolates would most likely become part of larger complexes .
This
study set out to investigate whether the populations of veterinary and
human isolates overlap and whether other potential sources of C.
jejuni infections in humans could be identified . It appears that
the populations do overlap, with STs shared between human isolates and
those from various other sources . There are, however, STs that appear
to be associated with a single source only and some complexes that are
more associated with isolates of a particular source . It will only be
possible to determine whether some of these STs are host specific by
conducting a similar study on a much larger scale . In conclusion, it
appears that isolates from cattle, sheep, poultry, pets, the
environment, and even some from pigs may all have the potential to
cause disease in humans, given the opportunity, and so should all be
considered potential sources of human infection .
The most common complex was the ST21 complex,
which comprised 82 isolates (30.8% of the data set) divided
among 33 STs, followed by the ST61 complex, which comprised 29 isolates
(10.9% of the data set) divided among 14 STs, and the ST45
complex, with 28 isolates (10.5% of the data set) divided among
13 STs . The ST21 and ST45 complexes were reported previously
(5,
6) as the largest among
the population of C . jejuni analyzed, which comprised mainly
human isolates .
Six of the 19 complexes contained three or fewer
members . These STs were assigned to a complex based on the data in the
Campylobacter MLST database
(http://campylobacter.mlst.net).
In some cases, no founder was identified within this set of isolates,
even when the complex consisted of more than three members (ST433,
ST443, ST460, ST573, ST22, ST283, and ST177 complexes) . Again, the
founders of these complexes were identified by comparison with the
larger database of isolates . Eighteen STs remain unassigned to a
complex (last database query, June 2003) .
The
IA for 149 unique STs within the whole data set
using the seven loci from scheme A was 1.29, indicating significant
linkage disequilibrium or that there is a certain degree of clonality
within the population . This compares to an IA of
-0.37 for unique STs within the dominant clonal complex
typified by ST21, which suggests that recombination within the clonal
complex is high . This indicates, as previously proposed
(6,
20), that the C.
jejuni population is weakly
clonal .
|
Association between clonal complex
and source of isolation.
|
|---|
The
distribution of isolates from the various sources in the nine largest
clonal complexes is given in Fig.
2.
The largest complex for scheme A was the ST21
complex, which contained 34 of 82 (42%) of the isolates, with
ST21 as the founder member . For scheme B, the ST1 complex was the
largest, containing 52 of 82 (63%) of the isolates, with ST1 as
the founder member . In total, 61 isolates were present in both the ST21
and ST1 complexes . Seventeen isolates were present in the ST1 complex
(scheme B) but absent from the ST21 complex (scheme A) (isolates 99/27,
99/96, 00/015, 99/215, 99/209, 00/022, 93/563, EX2200, 99/201, 93/562,
88/139, 88/34, 88/3, 88/5, 88/6, 91/29, and 00/048) . In contrast, all
of the isolates that form the ST21 complex (scheme A) were present in
the ST1 complex of scheme B . An IA of 0.51 was
obtained when 59 unique STs identified for the panel of isolates using
the six loci from scheme B were analyzed . This compares to an
IA of 0.93 when any six loci selected from scheme A
(the example given shows data excluding uncA) were analyzed.
Both values again indicate that the population has some degree of
clonality and that individual clonal complexes are sufficiently stable
to be clearly identified by use of sequence data from six or seven
loci .
|
Reanalysis of the subset of isolates
at 12 unique loci.
|
|---|
When
analyzed at all 12 loci (10, 11, or 12 loci in common), the isolates
were grouped into seven complexes (Table
4) .
We thank Lise Petersen,
Mogens Madsen, Birgitta Duim, Iva Steinhauserova, Al Lastovica, Exeter
Public Health Laboratory, and CAMPYNET for providing some of the
isolates that were used in this study . We also thank Kate Dingle,
Frances Colles, Martin Maiden, and Lynne Richardson for helpful advice
and DNA sequencing . Thanks also go to Robin Sayers for help with
statistical analysis, Adrian Whatmore for useful discussions, Stephen
On for further characterization of the pig isolates, and Jenny Frost
(HPA, Colindale, United Kingdom) for LEP serotyping .
This work
was funded by Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, United
Kingdom, project number
OZO602 .
* Corresponding
author . Mailing address: Veterinary Laboratories Agency (Weybridge),
New Haw, Addlestone, Surrey KT15 3NB, United Kingdom . Phone: 44 (0)1932
357 547 . Fax: 44 (0)1932 357 268 . E-mail:
d.newell{at}vla.defra.gsi.gov.uk .
- Aeschbacher,
M., and J.-C . Piffaretti. 1989 . Population genetics of
human and animal enteric Campylobacter strains . Infect.
Immun.
57:1432-1437.
- Ausubel,
S . F., R . Brent, R . E . Kingston, D . D.
Moore, J . G . Seidman, J . A . Smith, K . Struhl,
L . M . Albright, D . M . Coen, and A . Varki (ed.).1994 . Current protocols in molecular biology . John Wiley
and Sons, Inc., New York,
N.Y.
- Clow, K.2000 . The genotypic and phenotypic comparison of
Campylobacter jejuni isolates from humans and poultry . Ph.D.
thesis . University of Reading, Reading, United
Kingdom.
- Clow,
K., S . Park, P . Hawtin, and D . Newell. 1998 . The
genotypic comparison of Campylobacter jejuni strains from humans and
poultry, p . 25-32 . In A.
Aspan and R . Mulder (ed.), COST Action 97 . Development of monitoring
procedures, rapid detection methods and techniques . Molecular
epidemiology of Campylobacter and Salmonella, vol . 4 . Office for
Official Publications of the European Communities, Gare,
Luxembourg.
- Dingle,
K . E., F . M . Colles, R . Ure, J . A.
Wagenaar, B . Duim, F . J . Bolton, A . J . Fox,
D . R . A . Wareing, and M . C . J.
Maiden. 2002 . Molecular characterization of
Campylobacter jejuni clones: a basis for epidemiologic
investigation . Emerg . Infect . Dis.
8:949-955.
- Dingle,
K . E., F . M . Colles, D . R . Wareing, R.
Ure, A . J . Fox, F . E . Bolton, H . J.
Bootsma, R . J . Willems, R . Urwin, and M . C.
Maiden. 2001 . Multilocus sequence typing system for
Campylobacter jejuni . J . Clin.
Microbiol.
39:14-23.
- Elsinghorst,
E. 1994 . Measurement of invasion by gentamicin
resistance . Methods Enzymol.
236:405-420.
- Enright,
M . C., and B . G . Spratt. 1999.
Multilocus sequence typing . Trends Microbiol.
7:482-487.
- Evans,
S. 1997 . Epidemiological studies of Salmonella and
Campylobacter in poultry . Ph.D . thesis . University of London, London,
United
Kingdom.
- Fearnley,
C. 2002 . The variations in virulence of
Campylobacter jejuni strains associated with poultry . PhD
thesis . University of Birmingham, Birmingham, United
Kingdom.
- Frost,
J . A., A . N . Oza, R . T . Thwaites, and B.
Rowe. 1998 . Serotyping scheme for Campylobacter
jejuni and Campylobacter coli based on direct
agglutination of heat-stable antigens . J . Clin.
Microbiol.
36:335-339.
- Hanninen,
M . L., M . Hakkinen, and H . Rautelin. 1999.
Stability of related human and chicken Campylobacter jejuni
genotypes after passage through chick intestine studied by pulsed-field
gel electrophoresis . Appl . Environ . Microbiol.
65:2272-2275.
- Harrington,
C . S., F . M . Thomson-Carter, and P . E.
Carter. 1997 . Evidence for recombination in the
flagellin locus of Campylobacter jejuni: implications for the
flagellin gene typing scheme . J . Clin.
Microbiol.
35:2386-2392.
- Jolley,
K . A., E . J . Feil, M . S . Chan, and
M . C . Maiden. 2001 . Sequence type analysis
and recombinational tests (START) . Bioinformatics
17:1230-1231.
- Koenraad,
P., R . Ayling, W . Hazeleger, and D . Newell. 1995 . The
speciation and subtyping of Campylobacter isolates from sewage plants
and waste water from a connected poultry abattoir using molecular
techniques . Epidemiol . Infect.
115:485-494.
- Korolik,
V., L . Moorthy, and P . J . Coloe. 1995.
Differentiation of Campylobacter jejuni and Campylobacter
coli strains by using restriction endonuclease DNA profiles and
DNA fragment polymorphisms . J . Clin.
Microbiol.
3:1136-1140.
- Maiden,
M . C . J., J . A . Bygraves, E . Feil, G.
Morelli, J . E . Russell, R . Urwin, Q . Zhang, J . Zhou, K.
Zurth, D . A . Caugant, I . M . Feavers, M . Achtman,
and B . G . Spratt. 1998 . Multilocus sequence
typing: a portable approach to the identification of clones within
populations of pathogenic microorganisms . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci.
USA
95:3140-3145.
- Manning,
G., B . Duim, T . Wassenaar, J . A . Wagenaar, A . Ridley, and
D . G . Newell. 2001 . Evidence for a
genetically stable strain of Campylobacter jejuni.Appl . Environ . Microbiol.
67:1185-1189.
- Maynard-Smith,
J . M., N . H . Smith, M . O'Rourke, and
B . G . Spratt. 1993 . How clonal are bacteria?Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA
90:4384-4388.
- Meinersmann,
R . J., C . M . Patton, G . M . Evins,
I . K . Wachsmuth, and P . I . Fields.2002 . Genetic diversity and relationships of
Campylobacter species and subspecies . Int . J . Syst.
Evol . Microbiol.
52:1789-1797.
- Moore,
J . E., M . M . Garcia, and R . H.
Madden. 2002 . Subspecies characterisation of porcine
Campylobacter coli and Campylobacter jejuni by
multilocus enzyme electrophoresis typing . Vet . Res.
Commun.
26:1-9.
- Moore,
J . E., J . Lanser, M . Heuzenroeder, R . M . Ratcliff,
B . C . Millar, and R . H . Madden.2002 . Molecular diversity of Campylobacter coli
and C . jejuni isolated from pigs at slaughter by flaA-RFLP
analysis and ribotyping . J . Vet . Med . B
49:388-393.
- Palmer,
S . R., P . R . Gully, J . M . White,
A . D . Pearson, W . G . Suckling, D . M.
Jones, J . C . Rawes, and J . L . Penner.1983 . Water-borne outbreak of campylobacter
gastroenteritis . Lancet
i:287-290.
- Parkhill,
J., B . W . Wren, K . Mungall, J . M . Ketley, C.
Churcher, D . Basham, T . Chillingworth, R . M . Davies, T.
Feltwell, S . Holroyd, K . Jagels, A . V . Karlyshev, S . Moule,
M . J . Pallen, C . W . Penn, M . A . Quail,
M . A . Rajandream, K . M . Rutherford, A . H.
van Vliet, S . Whitehead, and B . G . Barrell.2000 . The genome sequence of the food-borne pathogen
Campylobacter jejuni reveals hypervariable sequences.Nature
403:665-668.
- Penner,
J . L., A . D . Pearson, and J . N.
Hennessey. 1983 . Investigation of a waterborne
outbreak of . Campylobacter jejuni enteritis with a serotyping
scheme based on thermostable antigens . J . Clin.
Microbiol.
18:1362-1365.
- Selander,
R . K., and J . M . Musser. 1990.
Population genetics of bacterial pathogens, p.11
-36 . In B . H.
Iglewski and V . L . Clark (ed.), Molecular basis of bacterial
pathogenesis . Academic Press, San Diego,
Calif.
- Souza,
V., T . T . Nguyen, R . R . Hudson, D . Pinero, and
R . E . Lenski. 1992 . Hierarchical analysis of
linkage disequilibrium in Rhizobium populations: evidence for sex?Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA
89:8389-8393.
- Suerbaum,
S., M . Lohrengel, A . Sonnevend, F . Ruberg, and M . Kist.2001 . Allelic diversity and recombination in
Campylobacter jejuni. J . Bacteriol.
183:2553-2559.
- Tompkins,
D . S., M . J . Hudson, H . R . Smith,
R . P . Eglin, J . G . Wheeler, M . M . Brett,
R . J . Owen, J . S . Brazier, P . Cumberland, V . King,
and P . E . Cook. 1999 . A study of infectious
intestinal disease in England: microbiological findings in cases and
controls . Commun . Dis . Public Health
2:77-152.
- Wassenaar,
T . M., B . N . Fry, and B . A . van der
Zeijst. 1995 . Variation of the flagellin gene locus of
Campylobacter jejuni by recombination and horizontal gene transfer.Microbiology
141:95-101.
- Wassenaar,
T . M., B . Geilhausen, and D . G . Newell.1998 . Evidence of genomic instability in Campylobacter
jejuni isolated from poultry . Appl . Environ.
Microbiol.
64:1816-1821.
- Wassenaar,
T . M., and D . G . Newell. 2000.
Genotyping of Campylobacter spp . Appl . Environ.
Microbiol.
66:1-9.
- Wassenaar,
T . M., J . A . Wagenaar, A . Rigter, C . Fearnley,
D . G . Newell, and B . Duim. 2002.
Homonucleotide stretches in chromosomal DNA of Campylobacter
jejuni display high frequency polymorphism as detected by direct
PCR analysis . FEMS Microbiol . Lett.
212:77-85.
Free Online Full-text Article
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
|