|
|
|
Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy, September 2004, p . 3536-3542, Vol . 48, No . 9 ß-Lactamase-Producing Nontypeable Haemophilus influenzae Fails To Protect Streptococcus pneumoniae from Amoxicillin during Experimental Acute Otitis MediaEva Westman,1* Susanne Lundin,2 Ann Hermansson,3 and Åsa Melhus2 Department of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology, Umeå University Hospital, Umeå,1 Department of Medical Microbiology, Malmö University Hospital, Malmö,2 Department of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology, Lund University Hospital, Lund, Sweden3 Received 8 July 2003/ Returned for modification 26 November 2003/ Accepted 24 May 2004
Hitherto, amoxicillin has been the first-line therapeutic choice in several countries (10, 14) . Its pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic profiles are attractive, but its utility is sometimes compromised by an increasing proportion of ß-lactam-resistant isolates . About 14 to 65% of the nontypeable (NT) H . influenzae isolates from the middle ear produce ß-lactamase (16, 20, 22, 24) . For M . catarrhalis isolates the frequency is virtually 100% (20, 22, 24) . Because of the high rate of ß-lactamase production in these two species, the use of ß-lactamase-resistant drugs such as macrolides and trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole is often recommended (9) . However, many of these antibiotics are not entirely effective as empirical treatment for AOM, especially macrolides for the treatment of infections caused by NT H . influenzae, and they may increase the rates of nasopharyngeal carriage of resistant organisms and promote their spread (7, 8, 28) . It has been suggested that ß-lactamases not only protect the producing bacteria themselves but also frustrate the therapy of concomitant infections caused by penicillin-susceptible respiratory tract pathogens with penicillins, resulting in a sheltering effect . There is experimental evidence for such a sheltering effect for Staphylococcus aureus in group A beta-hemolytic streptococcal abscesses (3) and M . catarrhalis in pneumococcal pneumonia (21) . S . pneumoniae and NT H . influenzae coexist in up to 10% of the samples of middle ear fluid (16) . The activity of amoxicillin against the pneumococcus in a mixed infection could thereby be threatened . In order to explore a possible sheltering effect for ß-lactamase-producing NT H . influenzae in amoxicillin-treated pneumococcal AOM, a well-established rat model of AOM was used . Apart from the clinical and bacteriological outcomes, protection against reinfection, morphological changes, and expression of transforming growth factor beta (TGF-ß) were also analyzed .
Bacteria and media. Two bacterial strains isolated at the Department of Medical Microbiology at Malmö University Hospital were used: S . pneumoniae type 3 (amoxicillin MIC and minimal bactericidal concentration [MBC], 0.032 and 0.125 mg/liter, respectively; ampicillin MIC and MBC, 0.016 and 0.064 mg/liter, respectively) and H . influenzae strain 3144 biotype II (amoxicillin MIC and MBC, 128 and >256 mg/liter, respectively; ampicillin MIC and MBC, 32 and >256 mg/liter, respectively) . The MICs and MBCs were determined by Etest, according to the instructions of the manufacturer (Biodisk AB, Solna, Sweden), and ß-lactamase production in strain 3144 was detected with the chromogenic cephalosporin nitrocefin (Biodisk AB, Solna, Sweden) . A PCR was carried out by the method described by Falla et al . (13) to screen for encapsulation of the H . influenzae strain . The strain was found to be genetically NT . The bacteria were stored at 70°C, and all cultures were initially inoculated from these frozen stocks onto solid medium . The media used were chocolate and blood agars and brain heart infusion broth (Difco Laboratories, Detroit, Mich.) supplemented with NAD and hemin (Sigma, St . Louis, Mo.), each at 10 mg/liter . The inocula for middle ear challenge were prepared as described earlier (30) . Early-stationary-phase NT H . influenzae was used at a concentration of 108 CFU/ml, and S . pneumoniae was used at a concentration of 107 CFU/ml . The viable counts of the bacterial suspensions were determined at the time of challenge . All cultures were grown at 37°C in an atmosphere with 5% CO2 . Experimental design. A total of 78 animals were challenged with S . pneumoniae, NT H . influenzae, or a combination of both bacteria . See Table 1 for details of the experimental design . Forty-four animals were treated, while the remaining 34 animals served as controls .
From day 0 to day 56 after challenge the animals were repeatedly inspected under an otomicroscope (see Table 1 for the exact days) . The status of the tympanic membrane and the quantity and quality of the effusion behind the membrane were evaluated . The otomicroscopic findings were categorized as follows: opaque effusion, turbid effusion behind the entire tympanic membrane, turbid effusion behind the pars flaccida, and clear or no effusion . A team member blinded to the identity of each animal carried out the inspections . The diagnosis of AOM required direct visualization of opaque fluid behind the tympanic membrane with or without a vascular reaction . Bacterial samples were collected from the external ear canals of animals with either spontaneously perforated tympanic membranes or bilateral infections (day 3; n = 25) or by inserting a swab directly into the middle ear cavity after the bulla was opened (day 8; n = 40) . The swab was streaked directly onto chocolate agar . All cultures of specimens from middle ears with mixed infections with no visible growth of pneumococci but with abundant or moderate growth of NT H . influenzae were subcultured on blood agar . For histological studies the animals were killed on day 3 (groups A and B; n = 3 animals each), day 8 (groups A to C; n = 3 animals each), and day 56 (groups A to C; n = 6, 4, and 5 animals, respectively) . The bullae were removed and transferred to vials for fixation in 3% glutaraldehyde solution in 0.1 M sodium cacodylate buffer supplemented with 4% polyvinylpyrrolidone . Animals with mixed infections were also killed on day 56 (groups B and C; n = 8 animals each) to study TGF-ß gene expression . The middle ear tissues were removed unilaterally from the right ear, and the samples were immediately frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at 70°C until analysis . Treatment and pharmacokinetic studies. Treatment with amoxicillin (Amimox; Tika Läkemedel AB, Lund, Sweden) was introduced on day 3 after the first challenge via the drinking water (250 mg/500 ml, the recommended dose for rats by veterinary standards) . Water consumption was measured on a daily basis until day 8, when the antibiotic treatment was discontinued . Water consumption and serum amoxicillin concentrations were monitored more closely in two animals, for which water consumption was registered every hour for a 4-h period . Blood samples were then collected whenever an animal consumed water . The amoxicillin concentrations were measured by the agar disk diffusion method with Sarcina lutea (ATCC 9341) as the test strain, and the antibiotic levels were calculated from duplicate assays . Morphological examination. Tissue samples were collected from two well-defined areas in the middle ear . The areas represented the fossa nasalis and the pars flaccida . After a brief rinse in buffer, the specimens were postfixed for 2 h with 1% OsO4 in the same buffer and, after another rinse, were dehydrated in increasing concentrations of acetone and embedded in an Epon mixture (POLYBED; Polysciences Inc., Warrington, Pa.) . The specimens were sectioned (thickness, 1 µm) for light microscopy and stained with toluidine blue . They were examined under a light microscope at an objective magnification of x40 . A team member who was unaware of the challenge and treatment procedures performed the examination . The degree of inflammation, with emphasis on inflammatory cells, vascular reaction, metaplasia, and epithelial proliferation, was recorded; and the three following categories were defined: no or minor changes, moderate changes, and major changes . Reverse transcription-PCR. To detect expression of the gene for TGF-ß, an anti-inflammatory cytokine which facilitates the anabolic effects of growth factors on tissue repair and whose expression is more pronounced during pneumococcal AOM than during NT H . influenzae AOM (32), mRNA was extracted from the frozen middle ear tissue samples with Dynabeads Oligo (dT)25 (Dynal A.S, Oslo, Norway) . After elution of the mRNA from the beads, it was reverse transcribed and amplified as described previously (32) . The sequences of the primers used to detect the TGF-ß gene were 5'-AGCTCCACAGAGAAGAACTGC-3' (sense) and 5'-TCATGTTGGACAACTGCTCC-3' (antisense) . The PCR products were subjected to electrophoresis, and all samples were further analyzed in a competitive PCR assay (32) . The PCR products were quantified by using two different competitors, one for the housekeeping ß-actin gene by use of primers with the sequences 5'-TGGAGAAGAGCTATGAGCTGC-3' (sense) and 5'-TCCACACAGAGTACTTGCGC-3' (antisense) and one for the TGF-ß gene . The ß-actin served as an internal control for total cell mass and mRNA recovery, and the levels of TGF-ß expressed were corrected for the ß-actin transcript levels in each sample . Statistical analysis. Fisher's exact test was used for statistical analysis of the rat model studies, and Student's t test was used to compare the TGF-ß mRNA levels between treated and untreated animals . A difference was considered statistically significant when P was <0.05 .
The otomicroscopic aspects of untreated and amoxicillin-treated AOM are shown in Fig . 1 . The treatment accelerated the resolution of the infection . The most rapid clearance took place in group A (treated pneumococcal infections), which was significantly faster than that observed in the groups with mixed infections, groups B (treated) and C (untreated), on treatment days 3 to 5, i.e., on days 6 to 8 postinoculation (P = 0.00001 to 0.02) . On day 8, the last day of treatment, 94% of the infections in group A, 60% of the infections in group B (P = 0.02), and 45% of the infections in group C (P = 0.0002) had cleared, as determined by otomicroscopy . At no time point were there any statistically significant differences between the groups with mixed infections, groups B (treated) and C (untreated) . The only group in which all animals had a normal status on day 8 was untreated group E, challenged with NT H . influenzae . There was, however, no substantial difference between this group and groups B (P = 0.06) and C (P = 0.08) . Opaque effusions could be observed only in animals in group B (treated mixed infections) and group D (untreated pneumococcal infections) after day 7 .
The frequencies of positive middle ear fluid cultures on days 3 and 8 in the various groups are shown in Table 2 . On day 3, 96% of the middle ear fluid cultures were positive, and for 56% of the animals with mixed infections, NT H . influenzae overgrew the pneumococci . The effect of amoxicillin on pneumococcal growth was significant in both animals with mixed infections and animals with pure pneumococcal infections . None of the specimens from animals in treatment groups A and B yielded growth of pneumococci on day 8, whereas the values for untreated groups C and D were 40% (P = 0.04) and 100% (P = 0.003), respectively . In contrast to the pneumococci, the ß-lactamase-producing NT H . influenzae exhibited a slight tendency to persist at the infection site during treatment (Table 2, groups B and C) . This tendency was not statistically significant (P = 0.08) . Structural observations and expression of TGF-ß. The structural changes are summarized in Table 3 . On day 3, the specimens were categorized into two groups . In the group with major changes, specimens exhibited a massive inflammatory response with abundant inflammatory cells (Fig . 2a) . The degree of epithelial proliferation could not be determined due to the inflammatory changes . Sclerosis occurred in one specimen . On day 8, the degree of inflammation had decreased in three animals treated with amoxicillin . All but one of the specimens with mixed infections were assigned to the category with major changes, with numerous inflammatory cells still present . Gland-like formations and polyps in the fossa nasalis extended into the middle ear cavity in some specimens, and sclerosis occurred . Ciliated cells and goblet cells were increased in number and were also present in the inner epithelium of the pars flaccida . After 56 days, the middle ears of treated animals challenged with S . pneumoniae had no or minor changes (Fig . 2b) or moderate changes, whereas the specimens from the groups with mixed infections exhibited moderate changes (Fig . 2c) or major changes (Fig . 2d) . The major changes were characterized by extensive alterations in the epithelium in the fossa nasalis, with several newly formed layers of epithelial cells and connective tissue and increased numbers of ciliated and secretory cells . Islands of epithelial cells were observed in subepithelial tissue, and polyps extended into the middle ear cavity . The pars flaccida was thickened, and ciliated cells were present in the inner epithelium . Three of four specimens from the animals with amoxicillin-treated mixed infections (group B) and three of five specimens from the animals with untreated mixed infections (group C) were assigned to this category .
Although H . influenzae did not frustrate the amoxicillin treatment of S . pneumoniae infections, the inadequate antibiotic coverage against this microorganism resulted in moderate to major structural changes in the middle ear mucosa . These changes did not affect the protective rate, but in the majority of the group B animals with treated mixed infections the changes were more extensive than those usually observed after untreated AOM induced by NT H . influenzae (31) . The substantial myringosclerotic-like changes found in all animals with mixed infections, independent of treatment, also indicate that considerable injury to the tympanic membrane was caused by the combination of gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria . The development of white plaques in both the pars flaccida and the pars tensa in 100% of the animals has not previously been observed in this model of AOM . The fact that the first case of sclerosis was recorded on day 3 and the fact that the antibiotic treatment did not reduce the frequency of white plaques in the tympanic membrane, their distributions, or the morphological alterations to the mucosa suggest that the initial tissue injury was established early during the course of AOM and was probably established prior to the introduction of antibiotic treatment . How the two bacterial species may interact with each other in the middle ear cavity is not known, but Elliott and coworkers (11) have shown that the relationship can be close and of a parasitic or symbiotic nature . In the present study, the overgrowth of NT H . influenzae in the middle ear tissue cultures on day 3 and the shift from early to late deaths when NT H . influenzae was added to the inoculum support the idea of a bacterial interaction or local competition . Despite a possibly competitive situation that might limit bacterial expansion to some extent, a mixed infection in the middle ear appeared to increase the strain on host tissues and defenses . Mixed infections are most common in AOM patients with treatment failure (16) . To avoid long-standing mixed infections, measures in the form of tympanocentesis and a change of treatment to an antibiotic with a broader spectrum of activity should probably be taken without delay in suspected cases . The widespread use of antibiotics for the treatment of AOM has lately led to prevalent ß-lactamase production among the leading gram-negative pathogens of the middle ear, so why insist on using amoxicillin and not amoxicillin-clavulanate (AMC) as the first-line drug? Apart from differences in virulence and spontaneous recovery rates between gram-positive and gram-negative pathogens, ecological issues must be considered . The impact of AMC on the gastrointestinal flora is not negligible (15, 29), but of more concern is its effect on the nasopharyngeal flora . A wider spectrum of bacteria is eradicated by AMC than amoxicillin (5), and the competitive balance between pneumococci and commensal organisms could thereby be disturbed (17) . Cultures of nasopharyngeal specimens from otitis-prone children show low numbers of alpha-hemolytic streptococci with activity that interferes with common pathogens that cause otitis (34), and significantly fewer children recently treated with amoxicillin than those treated with AMC have been shown to be prone to otitis (2) . Furthermore, in the work of Joki-Erkkilä et al . (23), the presence of ß-lactamase-producing M . catarrhalis, but not ß-lactamase-producing H . influenzae, appeared to prevent the development of penicillin resistance among pneumococcal isolates in the nasopharynx, presumably by reducing the selection pressure . In this context, it is interesting to compare the remarkably low frequency of isolation of M . catarrhalis and the high frequency of isolation of penicillin-resistant pneumococcus in Spain with the corresponding frequencies found in northern Europe and the United States (6, 9, 24) . In an era with a high prevalence of resistance among pathogens of the middle ear, the potential benefit to the individual who is treated with antibiotics must be weighed against the public health risk for the emergence of resistant microorganisms . In Scandinavia the frequency of isolation of pneumococci with reduced susceptibilities to penicillin is lower than that in most European countries (12, 26, 27), and penicillin V is still, after more than 45 years, the drug of choice for the treatment of AOM, with S . pneumoniae as the primary target . The step from treatment with penicillin V and amoxicillin to AMC might appear to be short, but it requires consideration and should probably not be taken unless it is called for .
What Is Biofilter?,
What Is Molecular Microbiology?,
What Is Molecular Biology?,
What Is Pcr?,
What Is Biotechnology?,
s,
Microbiology,
r,
Bacterium,
r,
Microbes,
a,
Microorganisms,
a,
Bacteria,
s,
Agrobacterium,
o,
Microorganisms,
e,
Fermentations,
s,
Meningococcus,
s,
Enterobacteriacea,
i,
S. cerevisiae,
i,
Rhodotorula,
n,
Streptococcal,
s,
Escherichia coli,
c,
Staphylococcus aureus,
i,
Escherichia coli,
s,
Pichia,
a,
Streptococci,
o,
Erythromycin,
e,
Microorganism,
e,
Bacillus,
r,
Salmonella,
e,
Gram negative,
e,
Escherichia coli,
r,
Streptococcal,
c,
Denitrifying
|
© 2005
Transgalactic Ltd (manufacturer of Bioscreen C software) |
Privacy Statement | P.O. Box
1393, 00101 Helsinki, Finland,
Last modified: May 25, 2005
| ||||||