|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, June 2003, p . 3325-3332, Vol . 185,
No . 11
Genomic
Sequence of C1, the First Streptococcal Phage
Daniel Nelson,* Raymond Schuch, Shiwei
Zhu, Donna M . Tscherne, and Vincent A . Fischetti
Laboratory of Bacterial Pathogenesis and Immunology, The Rockefeller
University, New York, New York 10021
Received 6 January 2003/ Accepted 21 March 2003
C1, a lytic bacteriophage infecting group C streptococci, is
one of the earliest-isolated phages, and the method of bacterial
classification known as phage typing was defined by using this
bacteriophage . We present for the first time a detailed analysis of
this phage by use of electron microscopy, protein profiling, and
complete nucleotide sequencing . This virus belongs to the
Podoviridae family of phages, all of which are characterized by
short, noncontractile tails . The C1 genome consists of a
linear double-stranded DNA molecule of 16,687 nucleotides with 143-bp
inverted terminal repeats . We have assigned functions to 9 of 20
putative open reading frames based on experimental substantiation or
bioinformatic analysis . Their products include DNA polymerase, holin,
lysin, major capsid, head-tail connector, neck appendage, and major
tail proteins . Additionally, we found one intron belonging to the HNH
endonuclease family interrupting the apparent lysin gene, suggesting
a potential splicing event yielding a functional lytic enzyme .
Examination of the C1 DNA polymerase suggests that this
phage utilizes a protein-primed mechanism of replication, which is
prominent in the
29-like
members of Podoviridae . Consistent with this evidence, we
experimentally determined that terminal proteins are covalently
attached to both 5' termini, despite the fact that no homology to
known terminal proteins could be elucidated in any of our open
reading frames . Likewise, comparative genomics revealed no close
evolutionary matches, suggesting that the C1 bacteriophage
is a unique member of the Podoviridae .
Tailed bacteriophages are the most populous organism on Earth, with
roughly 1030 inhabitants in the biosphere (9) .
However, we are just beginning to appreciate the role they play in
bacterial diversity (24) and, as reported more
recently, bacterial pathogenesis (8,
46) . Indeed, whole-genome sequencing of two different strains of
group A streptococci (Streptococcus pyogenes) revealed that
polylysogenic phage represents the only diversity between the two
strains (3, 19) . Recent advances have
allowed whole bacteriophage genomes of evolutionary or biological
interest to be rapidly sequenced for comparison with known genomes .
The streptococcal C1 bacteriophage has roots at the forefront
of bacteriophage research . In 1925, shortly after the discovery
of bacteriophages by Twort and d'Herelle (12,
42), the C1 bacteriophage was isolated from a sewage
plant in Milwaukee, Wis., by Clark and Clark and represents the first
documented bacteriophage found to be active on any type of
streptococci (10) . Initially known as the "sludge"
phage or "Clark" phage, it infected streptococci isolated from
animals (which we now know to be group C streptococci) but not
streptococci found in humans (now known to be group A streptococci) (26,
39) . In a hallmark 1934 paper, Alice Evans, using
the Clark phage which she renamed B563, was the first person to
utilize a phage to classify bacterial strains, thus founding the
analytical field of phage typing (15) . Additionally,
Evans noticed that phage lysates had lytic activity on streptococci
that were not sensitive to the phage itself . She called this
phenomenon "nascent lysis" and attributed it to a lysin activity
originally defined by Twort (43) . In 1957, Krause renamed the
Evans B563 phage, calling it "C1" to imply an exquisite
specificity for group C streptococci (25) . Krause
also noted that the C1 cell wall hydrolase, or lysin, had
a less restrictive range given that group A, C, and E streptococci
were rapidly lysed by this enzyme .
On the genetic level, the C1 phage has not been studied in detail .
Two published restriction maps of this genome exist (34,
41), but to date, no sequence data are available .
The majority of interest in this phage involves its lysin, which has
been used extensively as a tool to dissolve the streptococcal cell
wall in order to make protoplasts (48), extract
genomic DNA, or study surface proteins (44) . More
recently, Nelson et al . have shown that the lytic properties of the C1
lysin have therapeutic potential to eliminate streptococcal
colonization (31) .
The C1 phage is currently classified as a member of the
Podoviridae family of bacteriophage based on its physical
characteristic of short, noncontractile tails (30) .
This designation makes the C1 phage a tempting choice for
the study of sequence for several reasons . First, the Podoviridae
represent a diverse set of phages for which only a few sequenced
genomes exist and even fewer have been studied in detail .
Additionally, both the historical interest of the C1 phage
and the current medical implications of its lysin warrant further
investigation .
Unless otherwise stated, all reagents were obtained from Sigma and
were of the highest purity available .
Preparation and purification of phage. The lytic
bacteriophage C1 and its host bacterium, group C streptococcus
26RP66, are both part of The Rockefeller University collection .
For preparation of the C1 bacteriophage, 26RP66 was grown at
37°C in chemically defined medium for streptococci (JRH
Biosciences) (27.13 g/liter) supplemented with 2.5 g of sodium
bicarbonate/liter and 0.5 g of cysteine/liter . During early log phase
(optical density at 650 nm,
0.25),
1/10 to 1/2 (vol/vol) of the prewarmed C1 phage was added
and allowed to incubate until complete lysis occurred (approximately
40 min) . The lysate was clarified by centrifugation (10,000
x g, 10 min) and passed
through a 0.45-µm-pore-size filter (Amicon), and final phage
purification was achieved by ultracentrifugation (100,000
x g, 2 h), with the phage pellet
resuspended in phosphate-buffered saline and stored at 4°C .
Purification of phage DNA. To purify phage particles, RNase
and DNase (10 µg each) were added and allowed to incubate for 30 min
at 37°C, after which 50 µl of 0.5 M EDTA was supplemented to inhibit
the endonucleases . Protease K (200 µg) and sodium dodecyl
sulfate (SDS; 0.5% final concentration) were added, and the mixture
was incubated for 1 h at 65°C . Final DNA purification was achieved
through common phenol-chloroform extraction protocols as previously
described (37) .
Terminal protein studies. To purify the DNA-protein complex,
the same procedure used to purify the phage DNA (see above) was
followed, except that a phenol extraction step with gentle shaking
was used instead of multiple phenol-chloroform extractions . The
DNA-protein complex, found at the interface between the aqueous and
phenol layers, was extracted and precipitated by ethanol . Half of the
DNA-protein complex was digested with protease K (10 µg) for 30 min
at 37°C and repurified by ethanol precipitation . Aliquots (10
µg each) of the DNA-protein complex or protease K-digested DNA
(PK-DNA) were treated with either 2 µl (130 U) of exonuclease III or
2 µl (11 U) of lambda exonuclease (both from Gibco/BRL) at 37°C
according to the manufacturer's instructions . Reactions were stopped
with the addition of 10 mM EDTA at the indicated times prior to
electrophoresis . Alternatively, PK-DNA (10 µg) was pretreated with
0.5 M piperidine for 2 h at 37°C and then subjected to lambda
exonuclease treatment .
DNA sequencing. For the library construction, genomic DNA
was hydrodynamically sheared using high-pressure liquid
chromatography and separated on a 1% agarose gel . Fragments of 3,000
to 3,500 bp were excised, purified by the GeneClean procedure (Bio
101, Inc.), blunt ended using T4 DNA polymerase, and ligated to
unique BstXI linker adapters . The linker-adapted inserts were
separated from the unincorporated linkers by a second gel
purification using GeneClean and ligated to BstXI-cut pGTC
vector to form subclone libraries, which were transformed into DH10ß
competent cells (DH5
transformation protocol [Gibco/BRL]) . DNA was purified from positive
transformants by using the PerfectPrep384 system (Brinkmann
Instruments) and then sequenced using ABI dye terminator chemistry on
automated MegaBace 1000 (Amersham) machines (Genome Therapeutics
Corporation, Waltham, Mass.) . Base calls and quality scores were
determined using the PHRED program (17, 18) .
Reads were assembled by using PHRAP with default program parameters
and quality scores . Closure of gaps was accomplished by using
primer-directed sequencing directly from purified phage DNA .
Bioinformatics. The Lasergene suite of programs from DNASTAR
was used for analysis, annotation, and assembly of the nucleotide and
amino acid sequences . Putative open reading frames (ORFs) were
identified either by ORF Finder, available through the National
Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI; www.ncbi/nlm.nih.gov), or
the heuristic approach of gene prediction (GeneMark) (4) .
The BLAST algorithms (2), also available through
the NCBI, were used for similarity searches of putative ORFs .
Sequence alignments were performed with CLUSTAL W and visualized with
BOXSHADE .
Electron microscopy. Purified phage was applied to a carbon
film and fixed to a copper grid before being negatively stained with
1% uranyl acetate . Electron micrographs of the phage were taken using
a JEOL 100 CXII transmission electron microscope with a final
magnification as noted in the figure legends . For phage infection
images, C1 bacteriophage was incubated with early log
phase group C streptococcus 26RP66 for 20 min, pelleted by
centrifugation, and suspended in 2.5% glutaraldehyde in 0.1 M
cacodylate buffer (pH 7.4) . The samples were then postfixed in 1%
osmium tetroxide, block stained with uranyl acetate, and processed
according to standard procedures . All microscopy was performed by The
Rockefeller University Bio-Imaging Resource Center or in
collaboration with John Swanson .
Receptor studies. For C1 infection studies, phage
was added to an exponential growth of group C streptococci or group
A-variant streptococci and monitored for either the clearing of a
liquid culture as described above or plaque formation in a soft agar
overlay . Alternatively, group C streptococci were pretreated with
pronase (100 µg/ml) or trypsin and chymotrypsin (100 µg/ml
each) for 30 min prior to exposure to the C1 phage . For adsorption
studies, group C streptococcal cell walls were isolated as described
previously (21) and the group C streptococcal
carbohydrate was isolated by the nitrous acid extraction method as
described previously (40) . Briefly, 100 µl of C1
phage (at 108 PFU/ml) was mixed with isolated group C
streptococcal cell walls (5 mg/ml), group C streptococcal
carbohydrate (5 mg/ml), or 20 mM N-acetylgalactosamine
(GalNAc) in a final volume of 0.5 ml . After 10 min of incubation at
37°C, log phase group C streptococci were added to a final volume of
1.0 ml, incubated for 5 min, and centrifuged to pellet the
streptococci, and the cell pellet was plated according to the soft
agar layer technique to enumerate any phage in the supernatant .
Adsorption was quantified as a corresponding decrease in the number
of residual PFU per milliliter compared to buffer control .
Nucleotide sequence accession number. The DNA sequences of
the genome reported here appear in GenBank under accession no.
AY212251 .
C1 bacteriophage characterization. In agreement with
the findings of a previously published report (30),
the C1 phage was found to have a small polyhedral head ( 50
by 50 nm) and a very short tail and tail fibers (Fig . 1A
and 2) . A small collar or base plate with three
protruding appendages was noted . The wider and longer central
appendage is presumed to be the tail, but it is not clear whether the
side appendages are minor tail fibers similar to those seen in phage
T7 or P22 or are collar spikes as observed in the
29
phage (1) . Upon infection, complete lysis of
susceptible group C streptococci was achieved by 40 min; however,
mature phage particles could be observed by electron microscopy to be
emerging from infected streptococci as soon as 10 min postinfection
(data not shown) . We were able to manually count >100 progeny
particles in one thin-section micrograph of an infected streptococcus
(Fig . 1B), which is consistent with the relatively
high burst size noted previously (20) .
|
FIG . 1 . Thin-section electron microscopy of the C1
bacteriophage . (A) C1 bacteriophage binding to the cell wall
of a group C streptococcus . The electron-opaque capsid indicates that
the phage DNA has not been injected . Bars, 50 nm . (B) Group C
streptococcus at 15 min postinfection with C1 bacteriophage .
The honeycomb structure shows the progeny virions during phage assembly.
|
|
|
FIG . 2 . Characterization of C1 structural proteins . Shown at
left is an electron micrograph of C1, showing its polyhedral
head, base plate, and three tail fibers (magnification,
x100,000) . Shown at right is the
protein profile of the C1 phage obtained by SDS-PAGE .
N-terminal sequencing of the two most prominent bands revealed that the
44- and 36-kDa bands correspond to ORF16 and -15, respectively . Whereas
ORF15 is consistent with head-tail connector base plate proteins from
several phage systems, ORF16 does not share homology with any known
proteins . Because ORF16 is the most prevalent structural protein in the
C1 proteome, we speculate that it may represent the major
capsid protein.
|
|
Organization of the C1 genome and identification of ORFs.
A double-stranded, linear sequence of 16,687 bp was established with
a mean redundancy of six, with each region being sequenced at least
once on each strand . The G+C content of 34.6% is similar to that of
the group C streptococcal genome as well as other low-GC
streptococci . Also present were 143-bp inverted terminal repeats,
which are characteristic of the
29-like
Podoviridae (1) .
The criteria for the characterization of a potential ORF were the
existence of a start codon (ATG, GTG, or TTG) and a minimum coding
size of 50 amino acids . Based on this, 20 predicted ORFs were
identified by both ORF Finder and GeneMark and were labeled 1 to 20
from the left end of transcription (Table 1) . The first
11 ORFs are on the positive strand, and the remaining 9 ORFs
are on the negative strand . Unexpectedly, the majority of the
ORF-encoded proteins were not only dissimilar to known phage proteins
but had no homology to any proteins contained in GenBank . Therefore,
we assigned putative functions only to ORF proteins with significant
homology or experimental proof . Included in this group are the
following: (i) ORF6, (ii) ORF7, (iii) ORF8, (iv) ORF9, -10, and -11,
(v) ORF12, (vi) ORF15, and (vii) ORF16 .
| TABLE 1 . Features of C1 ORFs and the putative functions of
their products
|
|
(i) ORF6. Although ORF6 did not have a high E value (1.2), it
did have
20%
identity to neck appendage proteins (late protein GP12) from
Bacillus phages
29
and PZA .
(ii) ORF7. ORF7 had high homology to DNA polymerases from
Bacillus phages
29
and GA-1 . Significantly, these phage polymerases utilize a
protein-primed mechanism of replication (see below for evidence of a
terminal protein) .
(iii) ORF8. ORF8 is a putative holin with similarity to a
Listeria prophage holin and the Bacillus
105
phage holin . Additionally, with 108 amino acids and three predicted
transmembrane domains, this sequence fits the classic type I holin,
as do holins from the
29,
105,
and Cp-1 Podoviridae (47) .
(iv) ORF9, -10, and -11. The 72-amino-acid ORF9 has no
homology to any known protein, yet sequencing of the purified C1
lysin yielded an N-terminal sequence that corresponded to ORF9 (data
not shown) . However, the native C1 lysin has a predicted
molecular mass of
60
kDa, which is significantly larger than that of ORF9 (31) .
This may be explained by investigation of ORF10 and -11 . ORF10 has
noteworthy homology to the HNH family of homing endonucleases found
in many phages (specifically, LambdaSa2 from Streptococcus
agalactiae and bIL170 from Lactococcus spp.) . These
endonucleases are often part of bacteriophage intron systems that
give rise to modular enzymes . ORF11 has the highest identity with a
putative amidase (lysin) from the LambdaSa1 phage infecting group B
streptococci . However, the LambdaSa1 protein consists of over 1,200
amino acids and the amidase region comprises less than 100 amino
acids, none of which share identity with the orf11 gene
product . The remaining 1,100 amino acids of the LambdaSa1 protein
resemble a phage tail protein . As such, C1 ORF11 also has
high homology to a putative tail protein from phage 315.5 infecting
group A streptococci . Although no typical lysin or amidase regions
are present on either ORF9 or -11, it is inviting to speculate
that if orf10 is an intron, then gene products of orf9 and -11
could be spliced together to form an active lysin . Significantly,
introns have been found in the middle of modular lysin genes
for multiple streptococcal phages (22) . Work is in progress
to elucidate the exact interactions between ORF9, -10, and -11
that yield a functional lysin .
(v) ORF12. ORF12 is the major tail protein based on homology
to the GP9 protein from Bacillus phages in the Podoviridae
family (B103,
29,
and GA-1) .
(vi) ORF15. ORF15 is a head-tail connector (collar) protein
based on homology to the GP10 protein from Bacillus phages
(GA-1 and
29) .
(vii) ORF16. ORF16 does not have homology to known proteins,
yet we experimentally determined this 44-kDa protein to be the major
structural protein (see below) and believe that it is the head or
capsid protein .
C1 phage structural proteins. To examine C1
structural proteins, purified phage particles were subjected to
SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) (Fig . 2) .
Although several bands could be distinguished, two notable bands
comprised >90% of the visualized protein . N-terminal sequencing of
the smaller, 36-kDa band gave the sequence MQITSGIK, which
corresponds to ORF15 (Table 1), a putative 35.9-kDa protein
with significant homology to the upper collar proteins (GP-10)
from Bacillus phages GA-1, B103, and
29 .
The larger and more abundant 44-kDa protein had an N-terminal
sequence of ADETTNVA . This sequence corresponds to ORF16, a putative
43.7-kDa protein that does not share similarity with any known
protein in GenBank . Because this band accounts for
75%
of the total phage structural proteins by scanning densitometry, we
believe that it represents the major capsid or head protein despite
any homology with similar proteins . This is partially supported by
the lack of an identified capsid protein (Table 1)
and the presence of other expected structural proteins, such as neck
appendage (ORF6), major tail (ORF12), and collar (ORF15) proteins .
Evidence of a TP. Bacteriophages that utilize a
protein-primed mechanism of replication have a terminal protein (TP)
covalently linked to the 5' terminus of the DNA . One characteristic
of this DNA-protein complex is a noted lack of migration in a
standard agarose gel (23) . We observed this trait
for the C1 bacteriophage DNA (Fig . 3A, lane
1) . The migrating band presumably represents DNA that had the
TP sheared off during the phenol step in purification . Protease K
treatment of the complex results in complete conversion of the
nonmigrating complex to migrating DNA with a size of
17
kb (Fig . 3A, lane 4) . Exonuclease III, which is specific
for unblocked 3' termini, degrades both the DNA-protein complex
and PK-DNA (Fig . 3A, lanes 2 and 3 and lanes 5 and 6,
respectively) . Although we demonstrate that the 3' termini are free
in both the DNA-protein complex and PK-DNA, exonuclease III has
slower activity on the complex, most likely due to steric hindrance
of the TP near the 3' termini .
|
FIG . 3 . Evidence of a covalently linked 5' TP . (A) DNA-protein complex
(lane 1), complex treated with exonuclease III for 15 min (lane 2),
complex treated with exonuclease III for 30 min (lane 3), PK-DNA (lane
4), PK-DNA treated with exonuclease III for 15 min (lane 5), and PK-DNA
treated with exonuclease III for 30 min (lane 6) . (B) DNA-protein
complex (lane 1), complex treated with
exonuclease for 15 min (lane 2), complex treated with
exonuclease for 30 min (lane 3), PK-DNA (lane 4), PK-DNA treated with
exonuclease for 30 min (lane 5), PK-DNA treated with 0.5 M piperidine
(lane 6), PK-DNA treated with piperidine and
exonuclease for 30 min (lane 7) . The amounts used are indicated in
Materials and Methods.
|
|
In contrast to exonuclease III, both the DNA-protein complex and
PK-DNA are insensitive to the effects of the 5'-specific lambda
exonuclease (Fig . 3B, lanes 1 to 5) . However, pretreatment
of PK-DNA with 0.5 M piperidine, which has been shown to specifically
hydrolyze the bond between the DNA and TP in the
29
bacteriophage (33), renders the 5' termini
unprotected (Fig . 3B, lane 7), thus proving a
covalent linkage at the 5' termini .
Analysis of the DNA polymerase. The data presented above
confirm that C1 bacteriophage DNA contains a TP . Further
supporting evidence can be found by examination of the putative C1
DNA polymerase (ORF7) . Bioinformatic analysis suggests that the C1
polymerase belongs to family B of the DNA polymerases (also referred
to as eukaryotic or
-like),
which comprises eukaryotic, viral, and protein-primed polymerases
(Fig . 4) . This family has consensus sequences known to
be vital for proofreading and strand displacement functions (ExoI,
ExoII, and ExoIII), a cross-talk region important for coordination
between 3'-to-5' exonuclease and 5'-to-3' polymerization events,
and several consensus motifs (A, B, and C) involved in initiation
and polymerization (for a review, see reference 5) .
Significantly, polymerases that utilize a protein-primed mechanism of
replication have two additional motifs, called terminal protein
regions (TPRs) (6) . These structures are known to
interact with TPs covalently linked to DNA (14) .
While the TPRs do not contain conserved sequence motifs, they are
apparent as sequence insertions between motifs A and B (TPR-1) or
motifs B and C (TPR-2) when aligned against family B polymerases that
do not utilize the protein-primed mechanism (7) .
The C1 polymerase contains all necessary conserved
elements, as well as two TPR insertion regions . For TPR-1, the C1
insertion is 64 amino acids, compared to 59 and 58 amino acids for
the
29
and Cp-1 DNA polymerases, respectively .
|
FIG . 4 . Structural and functional map of type B ( -like)
phage DNA polymerases that utilize a protein-primed mechanism of
replication . Alignments of important residues from the Bacillus
29
(NP_040719), pneumococcal Cp-1 (NP_044817), and streptococcal C1
phage DNA polymerases are shown . The N-terminal domain of type B DNA
polymerases contain conserved exonuclease I, exonuclease II, and
exonuclease III sequences separated from the C-terminal domain by a
cross-talk (CT) region . The C-terminal domain also has several conserved
consensus motifs, A, B, and C . The three Asp residues, noted by
asterisks, constitute the polymerization active site . See the text for
further details on these regions . Consensus sequences were taken from
references 5 and 29 . All three of
these polymerases have TPRs of 30 to 60 amino acids inserted between
motifs A and B (TPR-1) or motifs B and C (TPR-2) . These regions are
thought to interact with the TP covalently attached to the phage DNA,
which initiates replication.
|
|
Investigation of the putative C1 phage receptor.
Consistent with the findings of a previous report (25), we
found that group C, but not group A, streptococci were susceptible
to infection by the C1 bacteriophage . However, we also found
that group A-variant streptococci were resistant to infection
(data not shown) . Furthermore, group C streptococci treated with
pronase or trypsin and chymotrypsin remained susceptible to
infection . This was expected, as most phages are believed to bind to
carbohydrate, not protein, epitopes . Significantly, nuclear magnetic
resonance structures of the carbohydrate from these three
streptococcal groups have been elucidated (11) . A
polyrhamnose backbone is common to the surface carbohydrate of group
C streptococci and the nonhost strains of group A and group A-variant
streptococci; distinguishing these structures are side chains of two
GalNAc residues in group C streptococci, one N-acetylglucosamine
(GlcNAc) residue in group A streptococci, and a lack of side chains
in group A-variant streptococci . Since the C1 phage does
not infect group A or A-variant streptococci, the GalNAc moiety is
likely an important element of the phage receptor .
In additional adsorption studies, we found that purified group C
streptococcal cell walls were very efficient in adsorbing the C1
phage, reducing a phage titer from 107 PFU/ml to less than
102 PFU/ml . This same effect was not seen with purified
group A streptococcal cell walls . Moreover, we found that the
chemically extracted group C streptococcal carbohydrate also retained
the ability to adsorb C1 phage . This is in contrast to
Fischetti and Zabriskie's earlier findings (21); however,
we used a method involving nitrous acid extraction of the carbohydrate
layer, which is more efficient in retaining the integrity of
the extracted carbohydrate than is the hot formamide method utilized
by the aforementioned authors . While this further supports a
potential role for GalNAc as a component of the receptor, we do not
believe that the GalNAc monosaccharide itself is sufficient for
binding . When the C1 phage was pretreated with 20 mM GalNAc,
it retained its full capacity to infect group C streptococci
(data not shown) . Whether the receptor is ultimately determined to be
the disaccharide form of GalNAc, a combination of the GalNAc and
rhamnose, or some other combination will require further
experimentation .
In the first example of phage typing, Evans used the C1 bacteriophage
to distinguish streptococci isolated from animals from those
isolated from humans (15, 16) . It was
speculated that this "race" of phage recognized something common
among the animal streptococci and absent from the human streptococci .
We know today that the majority of human infections are caused by
group A streptococci and those of animals are caused by group C
streptococci . Here we report that the receptor for the C1
phage is contained within the chemically extracted carbohydrate
unique to group C streptococci .
An additional finding of Clark was that the C1 phage had the
ability to lyse cultures that were not susceptible to infection
with the phage itself . Seventy years later, this potent enzyme, the C1
lysin, may represent a new method to control streptococcal infections
in humans because of its activity on both group A and group C
streptococci (31) . It is noteworthy that in phage
infecting gram-positive bacteria, the binding domains of lysins and
tail fibers from the same virion appear to recognize identical
epitopes on their hosts due to the shared specificities of these
proteins . We, along with others, have shown this for pneumococcal and
Bacillus anthracis systems (13, 28,
38) . However, based on the adsorption and
infection data, the C1 phage has a more limited host range
than the C1 lysin, indicating that the binding domains for
the tail and the lysin recognize two different epitopes . Considering
that the C1 phage has one of the smallest Podoviridae
genomes, the evolutionary pressure to create separate binding
domains when one suffices in other systems is not readily evident .
Moreover, our finding that the C1 lysin is interrupted by an
apparent intron adds further complexity to the already compact
genome . Although introns are known to exist in phage, and to be
specifically embedded in the lysin gene (22), this is usually
seen in the larger-genome phages of Myoviridae and Siphoviridae .
To our knowledge, this is the first potential intron or intron-like
sequence in the genome of a Podoviridae family member .
The Podoviridae family of bacteriophages contains phages with
short, noncontractile tails and represents one of the most diverse
groups of phages known . With only 16 genomes sequenced and deposited
in GenBank, these family members vary in size from under 12 to
over 47 kb, and the host range includes gram-positive bacteria,
gram-negative bacteria, and mycoplasma . However, a genus of the
Podoviridae, known as the
29-like
phages, shows several common characteristics . All phages in this
class are lytic, have double-stranded linear DNA genomes of
20
kb, and contain a TP that is used as the primer for initiation of
translation (for a full review, see reference 29) .
As such, they also possess a unique type B DNA polymerase that
contains TPRs, which bind the TP (36) . According
to the taxonomic placement chart developed by the International
Committee on Taxonomy of Viruses (ICTV) (45), the
C1 bacteriophage clearly belongs to the
29-like
family based on physical morphology, genome size, and the presence
of a TP . Likewise, the ICTV also classifies the pneumococcal
Cp-1 phage in this genus . Nonetheless, some groups contend that only
Bacillus-infecting phages ( 29,
GA-1, and B103) belong to the
29-like
genus (29), due in part to a shared genome organization
and an evolution that can be traced to common ancestors (32) .
Attempts to model the C1 phage against
29-like
phage, as well as other members of the Podoviridae, by using
comparative genomic methods yielded no successful alignments, which
was confirmed independently (Harald Brüssow, personal communication) .
This is not too surprising considering only 2 of the 20 putative
ORFs had an E value greater than 1.00E-10 when a BLAST search
was performed . Notably, to assign function to a majority of our ORFs,
we had to rely on techniques other than significant BLAST scores . For
the DNA polymerase (ORF7), we aligned conserved motifs from known DNA
polymerases that utilized a protein-primed mechanism of replication;
for the holin (ORF8), we had to perform transmembrane modeling; for
the lysin (ORF9 and -11), we had to purify the native protein and
perform N-terminal sequencing; and for the structural proteins,
head-tail connector (ORF15), and capsid (ORF16), we had to
N-terminally sequence the dominant proteins from purified phage
particles . Nonetheless, the C1 lysin and capsid proteins
do not share homology to known proteins with similar functions .
Furthermore, no gene coding for a TP has been identified despite
overwhelming evidence that such a gene must exist . This could be
anticipated, since TPs are not only utilized by the
29-like
Podoviridae but also by the PDR1 phage of the Tectiviridae
family and by adenoviruses, thus representing an early evolutionary
divergence . Taken together, these data suggest that the C1
bacteriophage is a unique member of the
29-like
genus in the Podoviridae family .
It should be pointed out that controversy about the taxonomic
classification of bacteriophages currently exists . Because there are
no ribosomal sequences in phages and a recent analysis showed that
there are no single protein markers or DNA sequence motifs shared
between phages (35), any classification scheme is dubious
at best . Nonetheless, the ICTV classification does attempt a
hierarchical approach based initially on the physical appearance of
tail fibers, which does not consider any potential genetic
relatedness between species . Some authors have suggested that it may
be impossible to apply any type of hierarchal approach to taxonomy
due to genomic mosaicism exhibited by bacteriophages (27) .
However, others have had success with forming a phage proteomic tree,
a hierarchal taxonomic approach based on BLAST scores of near protein
neighbors (35) . Indeed, this approach does resolve
several apparent limitations with the ICTV method . For example, the
PDR1 phage of the Tectiviridae family is now joined with other
protein-primed phages such as the Bacillus GA-1 phage and the
pneumococcal Cp-1 phage in a new group known as PZA-like Podophage .
While the taxonomic debate continues, the C1 bacteriophage
shares morphological, biological, and genetic relatedness to
protein-primed members of the Podoviridae or Podophage
family . As more phage genomes are made available, it is hoped that
the evolutionary relationships between the C1
bacteriophage and its relatives can be further appreciated .
We are grateful to Harald Brüssow for his analysis and observations
regarding the comparative genomics of the C1 bacteriophage
sequence . We are indebted to Maclyn McCarty and Richard Krause for
their knowledge of and commentary on the history of the C1
bacteriophage and early experiments to elucidate the streptococcal
carbohydrate structure . Finally, we thank Eleana Sphicas at the
Bio-Imaging Resource Center at The Rockefeller University for help
with electron microscopy and members of V.A.F.'s laboratory for
reviewing the manuscript .
This work was supported by a grant from the Defense Advanced
Research Projects Agency to V.A.F . and a fellowship from the Charles
H . Revson Biomedical Research Foundation to D.N .
* Corresponding author . Mailing address: Laboratory of
Bacterial Pathogenesis and Immunology, The Rockefeller University, 1230 York
Ave., Box 172, New York, NY 10021 . Phone: (212) 327-8167 . Fax: (212) 327-7584 .
E-mail: nelsond@rockefeller.edu.
- Ackermann, H.-W. 1999 . Tailed bacteriophages: the order
Caudovirales . Adv . Virus Res . 51:135-201.
- Altschul, S . F., T . L . Madden, A . A . Schäffer, J . Zhang, Z .
Zhang, W . Miller, and D . J . Lipman. 1997 . Gapped BLAST and PSI-BLAST: a
new generation of protein database search programs . Nucleic Acids Res . 25:3389-3402 .
- Beres, S . B., G . L . Sylva, K . D . Barbian, B . Lei, J . S . Hoff,
N . D . Mammarella, M.-Y . Liu, J . C . Smoot, S . F . Porcella, L . D . Parkins, D . S .
Campbell, T . M . Smith, J . K . McCormick, D . Y . M . Leung, P . M . Schlievert, and
J . M . Musser. 2002 . Genome sequence of a serotype M3 strain of group A
Streptococcus: phage-encoded toxins, the high-virulence phenotype, and
clone emergence . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 99:10078-10083 .
- Besemer, J., and M . Borodovsky. 1999 . Heuristic approach
to deriving models for gene finding . Nucleic Acids Res . 27:3911-3920 .
- Blanco, L., and M . Salas. 1996 . Relating structure to
function in
29
DNA polymerase . J . Biol . Chem . 271:8509-8512.
- Blasco, M . A., L . Blanco, E . Pares, M . Salas, and A . Bernad.
1990 . Structural and functional analysis of temperature-sensitive mutants of
the phage
29
DNA polymerase . Nucleic Acids Res . 18:4763-4770.
- Braithwaite, D . K., and J . Ito. 1993 . Compilation,
alignment, and phylogenetic relationships of DNA polymerases . Nucleic Acids
Res . 21:787-802.
- Broudy, T . B., and V . A . Fischetti. In vivo lysogenic
conversion of Tox- S . pyogenes to Tox+ with
lysogenic streptococci or free phage . Infect . Immun., in press.
- Brüssow, H., and R . W . Hendrix. 2002 . Phage genomics:
small is beautiful . Cell 108:13-16.
- Clark, P . F., and A . S . Clark. 1926 . A "bacteriophage"
active against a hemolytic streptococcus . J . Bacteriol . 11:89.
- Coligan, J . E., T . J . Kindt, and R . M . Krause. 1978 .
Structure of the streptococcal groups A, A-variant and C carbohydrates .
Immunochemistry 15:755-760.
- d'Herelle, F . H. 1917 . Sur un microbe invisible
antagoniste des bacilles dysenteriques . C . R . Acad . Sci . (Paris) 165:<
/OTHER-REF>373-375.
- Diaz, E., R . Lopez, and J . L . Garcia. 1990 . Chimeric
phage-bacterial enzymes: a clue to the modular evolution of genes . Proc . Natl .
Acad . Sci . USA 87:8125-8129.
- Dufour, E., J . Mendez, J . M . Lazaro, M . de Vega, L . Blanco,
and M . Salas. 2000 . An aspartic acid residue in TPR-1, a specific region
of protein-priming DNA polymerases, is required for the functional interaction
with primer terminal protein . J . Mol . Biol . 304:289-300.
- Evans, A . C. 1934 . Streptococcus bacteriophage: a study
of four serological types . Public Health Rep . 49:1386-1401.
- Evans, A . C. 1936 . Studies on hemolytic streptococci . I .
Methods of classification . J . Bacteriol . 31:423-437.
- Ewing, B., and P . Green. 1998 . Base-calling of automated
sequencer traces using Phred . II . Error probabilities . Genome Res .
8:186-194.
- Ewing, B., L . Hillier, M . C . Wendl, and P . Green. 1998 .
Base-calling of automated sequencer traces using Phred . I . Accuracy
assessment . Genome Res . 8:175-185.
- Ferretti, J . J., W . M . McShan, D . Ajdic, D . J . Savic, G .
Savic, K . Lyon, C . Primeaux, S . Sezate, A . N . Suvorov, S . Kenton, H . S . Lai,
S . P . Lin, Y . Qian, H . G . Jia, F . Z . Najar, Q . Ren, H . Zhu, L . Song, J . White,
X . Yuan, S . W . Clifton, B . A . Roe, and R . McLaughlin. 2001 . Complete
genome sequence of an M1 strain of Streptococcus pyogenes . Proc . Natl .
Acad . Sci . USA 98:4658-4663 .
- Fischetti, V . A., B . Barron, and J . B . Zabriskie. 1968 .
Studies on streptococcal bacteriophages . I . Burst size and intracellular
growth of group A and group C streptococcal bacteriophages . J . Exp . Med .
127:475-488.
- Fischetti, V . A., and J . B . Zabriskie. 1968 . Studies on
streptococcal bacteriophages . II . Adsorption studies on group A and group C
streptococcal bacteriophages . J . Exp . Med . 127:489-505.
- Foley, S., A . Bruttin, and H . Brüssow. 2000 . Widespread
distribution of a group I intron and its three deletion derivatives in the
lysin gene of Streptococcus thermophilus bacteriophages . J . Virol .
74:611-618 .
- Garcia, E., A . Gomez, C . Ronda, C . Escarmis, and R . Lopez.
1983 . Pneumococcal bacteriophage Cp-1 contains a protein bound to the 5'
termini of its DNA . Virology 128:92-104.
- Hendrix, R . W., M . C . M . Smith, R . N . Burns, M . E . Ford, and
G . F . Hatfull. 1999 . Evolutionary relationships among bacteriophages and
prophages: all the world's a phage . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 96:2192-2197 .
- Krause, R . M. 1957 . Studies on bacteriophages of
hemolytic streptococci . I . Factors influencing the interaction of phage and
susceptible host cells . J . Exp . Med . 106:365-384.
- Lancefield, R . C. 1932 . Note on the susceptibility of
certain strains of hemolytic streptococcus to a streptococcus bacteriophage .
Proc . Soc . Exp . Biol . Med . 30:169-171.
- Lawrence, J . G., G . F . Hatfull, and R . W . Hendrix. 2002 .
Imbroglios of viral taxonomy: genetic exchange and failings of phenetic
approaches . J . Bacteriol . 184:4891-4905 .
- Loeffler, J . M., D . Nelson, and V . A . Fischetti. 2001 .
Rapid killing of Streptococcus pneumoniae with a bacteriophage cell
wall hydrolase . Science 294:2170-2172 .
- Meijer, W . J . J., J . A . Horcajadas, and M . Salas. 2001.
29
family of phages . Microbiol . Mol . Biol . Rev . 65:261-287 .
- Moynet, D . J., A . E . Colon-Whitt, G . B . Calandra, and R . M .
Cole. 1985 . Structure of eight streptococcal bacteriophages . Virology
142:263-269.
- Nelson, D., L . Loomis, and V . A . Fischetti. 2001 .
Prevention and elimination of upper respiratory colonization of mice by group
A streptococci using a bacteriophage lytic enzyme . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA
98:4107-4112 .
- Pecenkova, T., and V . Paces. 1999 . Molecular phylogeny
of
29-like
phages and their evolutionary relatedness to other protein-primed replicating
phages and other phages hosted by gram-positive bacteria . J . Mol . Evol . 48:197-208.
- Penalva, M . A., and M . Salas. 1982 . Initiation of phage
29
DNA replication in vitro: formation of a covalent complex between the
terminal protein, p3, and 5'-dAMP . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 79:5522-5526.
- Pomrenke, M . E., and J . J . Ferretti. 1989 . Physical maps
of the streptococcal bacteriophage A25 and C1 genomes . J . Basic Microbiol .
6:395-398.
- Rohwer, F., and R . Edwards. 2002 . The phage proteomic
tree: a genome-based taxonomy for phage . J . Bacteriol . 184:4529-4535 .
- Salas, M. 1991 . Protein-priming of DNA replication .
Annu . Rev . Biochem . 60:39-71.
- Sambrook, J., E . F . Fritsch, and T . Maniatis. 1989 .
Molecular cloning: a laboratory manual, 2nd ed . Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
Press, Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y.
- Schuch, R., D . Nelson, and V . A . Fischetti. 2002 . A
bacteriolytic agent that detects and kills Bacillus anthracis . Nature
418:884-889.
- Shwartzman, G. 1927 . Studies on streptococcus
bacteriophage . I . A powerful lytic principle against hemolytic streptococci of
erysipelas origin . J . Exp . Med . 46:497-509.
- Swanson, J., K . Hsu, and E . C . Gotschlich. 1969 .
Electron microscopic studies on streptococci . I . M antigen . J . Exp . Med .
130:1063-1091.
- Totolian, A . A., T . Gupalova, J . Coll, A . Suvorov, A .
Boitsov, and V . I . Golubkov. 1981 . Introduction to the molecular biology
of virulent streptococcal bacteriophages, p . 231-233 . In S . Holm and P .
Christensen (ed.), Basic concepts of streptococci and streptococcal diseases .
Reedbooks Ltd., Surrey, England.
- Twort, F . W. 1915 . An investigation on the nature of
ultra-microscopic viruses . Lancet ii:1241-1243.
- Twort, F . W. 1925 . The transmissible bacterial lysin and
its action on dead bacteria . Lancet ii:642-644.
- van de Rijn, I., and V . A . Fischetti. 1981 .
Immunochemical analysis of intact M protein secreted from cell wall-less
streptococci . Infect . Immun . 32:86-91.
- van Regenmortel, M . H . V., C . M . Fauquet, D . H . L . Bishop,
E . B . Carstens, M . K . Estes, S . M . Lemon, J . Maniloff, M . A . Mayo, D . J .
McGeoch, C . R . Pringle, and R . B . Wickner (ed.). 2000 . Virus taxonomy:
seventh report of the International Committee on Taxonomy of Viruses . Academic
Press, San Diego, Calif.
- Wagner, P . L., and M . K . Waldor. 2002 . Bacteriophage
control of bacterial virulence . Infect . Immun . 70:3985-3993.
- Wang, I.-N., D . L . Smith, and R . Young. 2000 . Holins:
the protein clocks of bacteriophage infections . Annu . Rev . Microbiol . 54:799-825.
- Wheeler, J., J . Holland, J . M . Terry, and J . D . Blainey.
1980 . Production of group C streptococcus phage-associated lysin and the
preparation of Streptococcus pyogenes protoplast membranes . J . Gen .
Microbiol . 120:27-33.
Free Online Full-text Article
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
|