|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, December 2003, p . 7160-7168, Vol . 185, No . 24
Formaldehyde-Detoxifying Role of the Tetrahydromethanopterin-Linked Pathway in Methylobacterium extorquens AM1
Christopher J . Marx,1, Ludmila Chistoserdova,2 and Mary E . Lidstrom1,2*
Department
of Microbiology,1
Department of Chemical
Engineering, University of Washington, Seattle,
Washington 981952
Received 17 June 2003/
Accepted 17 September 2003
The
facultative methylotroph Methylobacterium extorquens AM1
possesses two pterin-dependent pathways for C1 transfer
between formaldehyde and formate, the tetrahydrofolate
(H4F)-linked pathway and the tetrahydromethanopterin
(H4MPT)-linked pathway . Both pathways are required for
growth on C1 substrates; however, mutants defective for the
H4MPT pathway reveal a unique phenotype of being inhibited
by methanol during growth on multicarbon compounds such as succinate.
It has been previously proposed that this methanol-sensitive phenotype
is due to the inability to effectively detoxify formaldehyde produced
from methanol . Here we present a comparative physiological
characterization of four mutants defective in the H4MPT
pathway and place them into three different phenotypic classes that are
concordant with the biochemical roles of the respective enzymes . We
demonstrate that the analogous H4F pathway present in M.
extorquens AM1 cannot fulfill the formaldehyde detoxification
function, while a heterologously expressed pathway linked to
glutathione and NAD+ can successfully substitute for
the H4MPT pathway . Additionally, null mutants were generated
in genes previously thought to be essential, indicating that the
H4MPT pathway is not absolutely required during growth on
multicarbon compounds . These results define the role of the
H4MPT pathway as the primary formaldehyde oxidation and
detoxification pathway in M . extorquens
AM1 .
Methylotrophic bacteria growing aerobically on single-carbon
(C1) substrates produce formaldehyde as a central
intermediate . A key challenge for these organisms is how to maximize
the flux through formaldehyde while preventing the intracellular pool
of free formaldehyde from accumulating to toxic levels . It has been
suggested for a typical methylotroph that the cytoplasmic formaldehyde
concentration could rise to 100 mM in less than 1 min if formaldehyde
consumption stopped completely
(3,
33) . Additionally,
methylotrophs utilizing multicarbon compounds need to maintain the
ability to detoxify formaldehyde that may be produced from the
cometabolism of C1 substrates encountered in the
environment . A number of cofactor-dependent formaldehyde oxidation
pathways are present in various methylotrophs that have the potential
to carry out this function, and many organisms possess more than one of
these pathways
(30) .
In the
facultative methylotroph Methylobacterium extorquens AM1,
primary oxidation of C1 substrates such as methanol or
methylamine occurs in the periplasm through the action of methanol
dehydrogenase (1) and
methylamine dehydrogenase
(8) (Fig.
1) . Formaldehyde that enters the cytoplasm condenses with one of two
pterin cofactors, tetrahydrofolate (H4F) or
tetrahydromethanopterin (H4MPT), to form the respective
methylene derivatives . The reaction of formaldehyde with H4F
seems to occur spontaneously
(14), and no enzyme has
been found thus far that is capable of accelerating this reaction
(33).
Methylene-H4F can either be assimilated through the serine
cycle or may be oxidized to methenyl-H4F,
formyl-H4F, and ultimately formate (reviewed in reference
17) . Formate can then be
oxidized to CO2 through the action of formate dehydrogenases
(16; L . Chistoserdova and
M . E . Lidstrom, unpublished data) .
| FIG . 1 . Methylotrophic
metabolism in M . extorquens AM1 . The result of expressing the
glutathione (GSH) pathway from P . denitrificans is indicated
with the dashed arrows . Those reactions that can occur spontaneously or
that are catalyzed by two enzymes are indicated . Arrows pointing in
both directions indicate reversible enzymatic reactions . The thin
arrows leading from methylene-H4F and formyl-H4F
to biomass represent biosynthetic reactions directly involving these
two C1-H4F derivatives . Arrows to the right of
H4MPT indicate biosynthesis reactions for this cofactor;
only the two indicated gene products have been implicated in this
process . MDH, methanol dehydrogenase; MaDH, methylamine dehydrogenase;
MtdA, NADP-dependent
methylene-H4F/methylene-H4MPT dehydrogenase; Fch,
methenyl-H4F cyclohydrolase; FtfL, formate-H4F
ligase; FDHs, formate dehydrogenases; DmrA, putative
dihydromethanopterin reductase; Orf4, putative ß-RFAP synthase;
Fae, formaldehyde-activating enzyme; MtdB, NAD(P)-dependent
methylene-H4MPT dehydrogenase; Mch,
methenyl-H4MPT cyclohydrolase; Fhc,
formyltransferase/hydrolase
complex.
| |
Alternatively,
formaldehyde can be oxidized through a similar C1 transfer
pathway that is linked to the folate analog H4MPT.
H4MPT-dependent C1 transfers were thought to be
unique to methanogenic and sulfate-reducing archaea until their
unexpected discovery in M . extorquens AM1
(6) . Subsequently, this
pathway has been found in most gram-negative methylotrophs with a few
exceptions (32) . In
methylotrophic bacteria the initial step in this pathway is the
reaction of formaldehyde with H4MPT to form
methylene-H4MPT (Fig.
1) . While this reaction
can occur spontaneously, as is apparently the case for H4F,
a specific formaldehyde-activating enzyme (Fae) has been shown to
catalyze this condensation, and this enzyme is required for
methylotrophic growth
(33) . The resulting
methylene-H4MPT is oxidized to methenyl-H4MPT
through the action of one of two methylene-H4MPT
dehydrogenases, MtdA and MtdB . MtdA, which also catalyzes the oxidation
of methylene-H4F, is strictly NADP dependent
(31), whereas MtdB can
use either NAD+ or NADP+ but is
specific for methylene-H4MPT
(10).
Methenyl-H4MPT is converted to formyl-H4MPT by
methenyl-H4MPT cyclohydrolase (Mch)
(24) . Finally, formate is
released from formyl-H4MPT through the action of the
formyltransferase/hydrolase complex (Fhc)
(22,
23) . Formate can then be
oxidized to CO2 by formate dehydrogenase, as for the
H4F-linked pathway . Fhc contains formyltransferase activity
that is active with methanofuran purified from the
methanogen Methanothermobacter marburgensis
(23) . The identity and
function of the methanofuran analog present in M . extorquens
AM1 has not yet been determined, however, and so this pathway simply
will be referred to here as the H4MPT pathway .
A
number of mutants defective for known or suspected H4MPT
pathway functions have been generated and, based on their growth
phenotype, a function in energy generation during methylotrophic growth
has been proposed . Null mutants lacking mtdB
(10), fae
(33), and dmrA
(which encodes a putative dihydromethanopterin reductase
[20]) have been
reported to be both incapable of growth on methanol and inhibited by
either methanol or formaldehyde during growth on succinate . This
methanol-sensitive mutant phenotype is thus far unique to the mutants
of M . extorquens AM1 defective for the H4MPT
pathway and has been proposed to be due to an inability to detoxify the
formaldehyde produced from methanol . Double mutants lacking both MDH
activity and MtdB activity were no longer sensitive to methanol
(10), lending further
support to the concept that methanol sensitivity is a proxy for
formaldehyde detoxification deficiency . A null mutant lacking Orf4, a
homolog of the first enzyme in the H4MPT biosynthesis
pathway, ß-ribofuranosylaminobenzene 5'-phosphate
(ß-RFAP) synthase
(28), has also been
generated and was incapable of growth on methanol
(6) . However, efforts to
obtain null mutants in other genes, such as mtdA
(7), mch, and
fhcBADC (6), have
not been successful . Mutants resulting from an incomplete allelic
exchange event that separated a wild-type copy of the gene from its
native promoter by the integrated vector were obtained for these genes
and, where examined, this led to reduced enzymatic activity
(6,
7) . In all cases, this
class of mutants exhibited defective growth on methanol, indicating a
specific role in methylotrophy in addition to apparent essentiality.
MtdA activity is likely required to produce formyl-H4F for
biosynthetic needs (7) . It
has not been clear, however, why the other genes for which null mutants
could not be obtained and have a known or predicted role in the
H4MPT pathway for formaldehyde oxidation would be required
for growth on a multicarbon substrate such as succinate . Therefore, the
role of the H4MPT pathway has been uncertain, and in this
study we have carried out experiments to define that role .
Here
we present a comparative physiological analysis of H4MPT
pathway mutants, analyzing the methanol-sensitive phenotype in more
detail and demonstrating that it is due to formaldehyde production from
methanol . In addition, through the complementation of H4MPT
pathway mutants with an alternative formaldehyde oxidation system and
by demonstrating that the H4MPT pathway is in fact not
essential, we have defined the role of the H4MPT pathway as
the primary formaldehyde oxidation and detoxification route in M.
extorquens AM1 .
Bacterial strains and growth
conditions.
M.
extorquens AM1 (21)
strains were grown at 30°C on a minimal salts medium
(2) containing carbon
sources at the following concentrations: 35 mM formate, 125 mM
methanol, or 15 mM succinate . Escherichia coli strains were
grown on Luria-Bertani medium
(27) . Antibiotics were
added to the following final concentrations: 50 µg of
ampicillin/ml, 50 µg of kanamycin/ml, 50 µg of
rifamycin/ml, 35 µg of streptomycin/ml, and 10 µg of
tetracycline/ml . Chemicals were obtained from Sigma . Nutrient agar and
Bacto-agar were obtained from
Difco .
Generation of mutant
strains.
M.
extorquens AM1 deletion mutants lacking mxaF,
orf4, mtdB, mch, or the fhcBADC
cluster were generated using the allelic exchange vector pCM184
(18) . Approximately
0.5-kb regions upstream and downstream of these genes or gene clusters
were amplified by PCR and cloned into pCR2.1 (Invitrogen) as follows.
Cloning of the mxaF upstream and downstream flanks resulted in
pCM191 and pCM192, the orf4 flanks resulted in pCM250 and
pCM251, the mtdB flanks resulted in pCM255 and pCM256, the
mch flanks resulted in pCM260 and pCM261, and the flank
downstream of fhcC resulted in pCM264 . The construct to
generate
mxaF::kan
mutants was generated by introducing the 0.5-kb
ApaI-SacI fragment from pCM192 between the
corresponding sites of pCM184 to produce pCM193 and, subsequently, the
0.6-kb EcoRV-Asp718I fragment from pCM191 was ligated
between the PvuII and Asp718I sites of pCM193 to
produce pCM194 . The construct to generate
orf4::kan mutants was
generated by introducing the 0.5-kb EcoRI-Asp718I
fragment from pCM250 into the same sites of pCM184 to produce pCM252
and, subsequently, the 0.7-kb ApaI-SacI fragment from
pCM251 was ligated into the same sites of pCM252 to produce pCM253 . The
construct to generate
mtdB::kan mutants was
generated by introducing the 0.6-kb SacII-SacI
fragment from pCM256 into the same sites of pCM184 to produce pCM257
and, subsequently, the 0.5-kb AatII-Asp718I fragment
from pCM255 was ligated into the same sites of pCM257 to produce
pCM258 . The construct to generate
mch::kan mutants was
generated by introducing the 0.6-kb AatII-Asp718I
fragment from pCM260 into the same sites of pCM184 to produce pCM262
and, subsequently, the 0.7-kb ApaI-SacI fragment from
pCM261 was ligated into the same sites of pCM262 to produce pCM263.
Finally, the construct to generate
fhcBADC::kan mutants was
generated by introducing the 0.5-kb EcoRI-NcoI
fragment from pCM250 into the same sites of pCM184 to produce pCM265
and, subsequently, the 0.5-kb SacII-AgeI fragment
from pCM264 was ligated into the same sites of pCM265 to produce
pCM266 .
Mutant strains of M . extorquens AM1 were
generated by introducing the appropriate donor constructs by
conjugation from E . coli S17-1
(29) as previously
described (4) . Unmarked
deletion strains were generated using the cre-expressing
plasmid pCM157 as described elsewhere
(18), allowing the
generation of double mutant strains . All mutants were confirmed by
diagnostic PCR analysis . All strains and plasmids utilized in this
study are described in Table
1 .
| TABLE 1 . M.
extorquens AM1 strains and plasmids used in this study
| |
Phenotypic analyses of mutant
strains.
In order to
compare the growth of wild-type M . extorquens AM1 with that of
mutants in liquid medium, cultures were grown to mid-exponential phase,
centrifuged, and then resuspended into fresh medium containing the
carbon source described . To test for sensitivity to methanol, methanol
was added to one set of succinate flasks to the reported final
concentration after 2 h . Mutant phenotypes were also assessed
on solid medium by comparing the relative rate of colony formation.
Sensitivity to methanol or formaldehyde was assayed using succinate
medium to which methanol or formaldehyde was added immediately before
pouring plates at the following tested concentrations: 125, 10, and 1
mM and 100, 10, 1, and 0.1 µM for methanol; 1, 0.5, 0.1, 0.05,
0.01, and 0.005 mM for formaldehyde . Because an undetermined fraction
of the methanol will volatilize, the reported MIC for methanol is a
maximum value . All phenotypic analyses were performed at least
twice .
Generation of a plasmid
overexpressing mtdA.
The coding region of mtdA
was amplified by PCR and cloned into pCR2.1 (Invitrogen) to produce
pCM254 . The 1.0-kb HindIII-XbaI fragment of pCM254
was cloned between the same sites of the expression plasmid pCM80
(19) to generate pCM259.
Plasmids were introduced into appropriate strains using the helper
strain pRK2073
(9) .
Construct
for the heterologous expression of the GSH-dependent formaldehyde
oxidation pathway from Paracoccus denitrificans.
The two primary genes comprising the
glutathione (GSH)-dependent formaldehyde oxidation pathway of P.
denitrificans, flhA
(26) and fghA
(11), were amplified by
PCR using pWRxox451 (25)
as a template and cloned into pCR2.1 (Invitrogen) to produce pCM102 and
pCM103 . The 1.0-kb EcoRI fragment of pCM103 was introduced
into the EcoRI site of pCM80 to generate pCM104, into which
the 1.4-kb XbaI fragment from pCM102 was inserted into the
corresponding site to produce
pCM106 .
Enzyme assays.
The activities of MtdA
(31), FlhA
(26), and FghA
(11) were assayed in two
to three replicates as described using cell extracts prepared using a
French press from cell material harvested from exponential-phase
cultures . Variation in enzyme activities between cultures was less than
20% . Total protein concentration in the extracts was assayed
spectrophotometrically
(13,
34) using a Beckmann DU
640B
spectrophotometer .
Mutants
defective for the H4MPT pathway have varying degrees of
sensitivity to methanol and formaldehyde.
M . extorquens AM1 mutants
defective for mtdB
(10), fae
(33), and dmrA
(20) of the
H4MPT pathway are all unable to grow on C1
compounds as their sole source of carbon and energy and exhibit
sensitivity to methanol or formaldehyde during growth on multicarbon
compounds such as succinate . It has been hypothesized that this unique
phenotype is due to an inability to detoxify formaldehyde
(10,
20,
33) . In order to test
this hypothesis and to better understand the role of the
H4MPT pathway in M . extorquens AM1, the phenotypes
of these mutants were examined in more detail . For this work, mutants
were employed in which the genes in question were deleted from the
chromosome . Some of these deletions were subsequently unmarked via
cre-lox-based allelic exchange
(18), and the resulting
strains were used to construct new strains bearing more than one
mutation . In addition to the
fae::kan strain CM198K.1
(18) and the
dmrA::kan strain
CM212K.1 (20) available
from previous studies, new mutants were generated defective for
orf4 (CM253K.1;
orf4::kan) and
mtdB (CM258K.1;
mtdB::kan) so that all
comparisons would involve similar genetic constructions .
All four
mutants in the H4MPT pathway employed in this study grew
with wild-type characteristics in liquid medium containing succinate,
indicating that the respective functions are not required for general
heterotrophic growth (Fig.
2A), but they were unable to grow in medium containing methanol (Fig.
2D) . Analogous results
were observed for growth on solid medium . Additionally, the
H4MPT pathway mutant strains grew like wild type on formate,
indicating that they are not required for the metabolism of the
more-oxidized C1 compound formate . In order to compare the
inhibitory effect of methanol on the growth of mutants defective for
the H4MPT pathway on succinate, methanol was added to a set
of succinate flasks after 2 h to either a 1 or 125 mM final
concentration (Fig . 2B and
C) . Under these conditions, the mtdB mutant
CM258K.1 grew like wild type . However, the three other mutants were
inhibited at both methanol concentrations . Addition of methanol at 1 mM
caused a more severe inhibition of the dmrA and orf4
mutant strains relative to the fae mutant strain, whereas 125
mM methanol caused cessation of growth in all three strains .
| FIG . 2 . Growth
of wild-type M . extorquens AM1 and mutant strains pregrown on
succinate, harvested, and resuspended in medium containing succinate
(A) or succinate with methanol added to 1 mM (B) or
125 mM (C) at 2 h, or 125 mM methanol (D) . The
strains represented are wild type (filled squares), the fae
mutant CM198K.1 (open squares), the dmrA mutant CM212K.1 (open
diamonds), the orf4 mutant CM253K.1 (open triangles), and the
mtdB mutant CM258K.1 (open
circles).
| |
The
MICs of methanol or formaldehyde during growth on succinate plates were
also examined for the four H4MPT pathway mutants . On solid
medium a distinct inhibitory effect of methanol was observed for the
mtdB mutant CM258K.1, with an MIC of 10 mM and an MIC of
formaldehyde of 0.5 mM . In comparison, the wild type had an MIC of
formaldehyde of 1 mM and was not inhibited by 125 mM methanol . The
other mutants were observed to be significantly more sensitive, with
MICs for methanol and formaldehyde, respectively, of 10 and 100
µM for the fae mutant CM198K.1 and 1 and 10 µM
for the dmrA and orf4 mutants CM212K.1 and
CM253K.1 .
Overexpression of mtdA
provides partial complementation of the mtdB mutant
phenotype.
We hypothesized
that the relatively moderate sensitivity of the mtdB mutant
strain CM258K.1 to methanol may be due to the presence of another
enzyme, MtdA, whose substrate specificity overlaps with that of MtdB.
Even though the presence of MtdA is insufficient for wild-type
resistance to methanol, it may contribute to the removal of
formaldehyde by converting methylene-H4MPT to
methenyl-H4MPT . To test this hypothesis, the region encoding
mtdA was cloned and introduced into the expression vector
pCM80 (19) to allow for
overexpressed levels of MtdA . The plasmid containing mtdA
expressed from the strong promoter PmxaF resulted
in an over-sevenfold increase in MtdA activity from 270 to 1,970 mU
during growth on methanol . Neither CM258K.1 bearing the empty vector
pCM80 nor pCM259 was capable of growth on methanol plates . However, the
MIC for methanol in the presence of succinate was 125 mM for CM258K.1
containing pCM259, compared to 10 mM for CM258K.1 with pCM80.
Therefore, a substantial increase in MtdA activity provides partial
complementation of the mtdB mutant
phenotype .
Methanol sensitivity of
H4MPT pathway mutants requires formaldehyde
production.
Previous work
(10) on mtdB
mutants indicated that the sensitivity to methanol could be alleviated
if a mtdB::kan mutant was
generated in a strain that contained a mutation in the gene
(mxaF) encoding the large subunit of MDH
(21) . This demonstrated
that the sensitivity of this strain required the production of
formaldehyde and was not simply a consequence of methanol itself . We
extended this analysis to characterize the other three mutants with
greater sensitivity to methanol . A series of double mutants were
constructed in the
mxaF strain CM194.1 . The resulting
strains were resistant to the addition of 125 mM methanol to succinate
cultures, with only the
mxaF
dmrA::kan and
mxaF
orf4::kan mutants
showing even a slight growth inhibition (Fig.
3) . Similar results were obtained using solid media . The
mxaF
mtdB::kan strain
CM194-258K.1 was not inhibited by 125 mM methanol, compared to an MIC
of 10 mM for the
mtdB::kan strain
CM258K.1 . The
mxaF
fae::kan strain
CM194-198K.1 had an MIC of methanol of 10 mM, compared to 10 µM
for the
fae::kan strain
CM198K.1 . Finally, the
mxaF
dmrA::kan strain
CM194-212K.1 and the
mxaF
orf4::kan strain
CM194-253K.1 exhibited an MIC for methanol of 100 µM, compared
to 1 µM for the corresponding MDH+ strains.
This residual sensitivity to methanol suggests either a low-level
alternate methanol oxidation activity or a direct effect of methanol at
higher levels . However, these data suggest that the extreme sensitivity
to methanol observed in all tested H4MPT pathway mutants is
not due to methanol itself but, rather, requires the production of
formaldehyde .
Methanol sensitivity of
H4MPT pathway mutants is alleviated and growth on
C1 compounds is achieved by expressing a heterologous
GSH-dependent formaldehyde oxidation pathway.
The data presented thus far suggest
that the methanol-sensitive phenotype observed for H4MPT
pathway mutants is due to an inability to detoxify the formaldehyde
produced from methanol, either directly or as one of its derivatives.
As a final test of this hypothesis, a heterologous formaldehyde
oxidation system was cloned and expressed in H4MPT pathway
mutants . The two primary genes of the glutathione (GSH)-dependent
formaldehyde oxidation pathway of P . denitrificans,
flhA (encodes GSH- and NAD-dependent formaldehyde
dehydrogenase
[26]) and
fghA (encodes S-formyl-GSH hydrolase
[11]) were
cloned by PCR amplification and introduced together into the expression
vector pCM80 (19) to
generate the plasmid pCM106 . Introduction of pCM106 resulted in
activities of 2,500 and 2,300 mU for FlhA and FghA, respectively,
whereas these activities were undetectable in wild-type M.
extorquens AM1 carrying pCM80 without an insert . Mutants defective
for mtdB, fae, dmrA, and orf4
bearing pCM106 were insensitive to 125 mM methanol present in succinate
plates . Additionally, the presence of pCM106 allowed the mtdB
mutant to grow like wild type in the presence of 1 mM formaldehyde and
raised the MIC of formaldehyde to 0.5 mM for fae,
dmrA, and orf4 mutant strains . The protective effect
of expressing the GSH-dependent formaldehyde oxidation pathway was also
tested in liquid medium for two representative mutants that lacked
either fae or dmrA . Addition of 125 mM methanol to
succinate growth medium did not inhibit growth in strains bearing
pCM106 (Fig . 4A and
B) . Finally, beyond alleviating methanol sensitivity, the expression of the
GSH pathway in the H4MPT pathway mutants allowed growth in
methanol liquid medium (Fig.
4C) and on methanol
plates, albeit the complementation of the dmrA and
orf4 mutants was less robust than for the other two mutants.
The ability of the heterologous GSH-dependent formaldehyde oxidation
system to alleviate the methanol sensitivity of H4MPT
pathway mutants provides strong evidence that the cause of the
methanol-sensitive phenotype is the inability to detoxify intracellular
formaldehyde produced from methanol .
| FIG . 4 . Growth
of wild-type M . extorquens AM1 and mutant strains with
plasmids pregrown on succinate, harvested, and resuspended in medium
containing succinate (A), succinate with methanol added to 125 mM at
2 h (B), or 125 mM methanol (C) . All media also contained
tetracycline for plasmid maintenance . The strains represented are wild
type (squares), the fae mutant CM198K.1 (diamonds), and the
orf4 mutant CM253K.1 (triangles), with the empty vector pCM80
(open symbols) or the pCM106 plasmid expressing flhA-fghA
(filled
symbols).
| |
Null
mutants lacking mch or fhcBADC can only be obtained
in an H4MPT biosynthesis-negative background.
One important question regarding the
role of the H4MPT pathway in M . extorquens AM1 is
why it has not been possible to obtain null mutations in genes that
encode the two enzymes catalyzing the final reactions of the pathway,
Mch and Fhc (6) . A few
scenarios may be suggested to explain this phenomenon: (i) a
C1-H4MPT intermediate is required for growth on
multicarbon compounds; (ii) these mutants are even more sensitive to
methanol, such that ambient concentrations are lethal; or (iii)
accumulation of an intermediate of the H4MPT pathway causes
a toxic effect or a regulatory problem . To test these hypotheses, we
attempted constructing deletion versions of these mutations in various
backgrounds . No mutants were obtained in the wild type using the
deletion constructs for Mch
( mch::kan) or FhcBADC
( fhcBADC::kan), in
agreement with our laboratory's previous results for
insertion mutants (6).
Likewise, no deletion mutants were obtained in the backgrounds lacking
MDH ( mxaF strain CM194.1), Fae ( fae
strain CM198.1), or MtdB ( mtdB strain CM258.1) . Both
deletions were readily generated, however, in the
orf4 strain CM253.1 . The
orf4
mch::kan strain
CM253-263K.1 and
orf4
fhcBADC::kan strain
CM253-266K.1 grew normally on succinate or formate but exhibited
defective growth on methanol or methylamine, as had been observed for
the orf4 mutant CM253K.1 . Furthermore, the MICs of methanol
and formaldehyde during growth on succinate were the same as those
observed for CM253K.1 . These data indicate that none of the
H4MPT pathway enzymes are essential for metabolism of
multicarbon compounds . The inability to generate
mch
or
fhcBADC mutants in a wild-type background is
discussed
below .
In
order to determine the role of the H4MPT-linked formaldehyde
oxidation pathway in M . extorquens AM1, we have carried out a
physiological analysis of four mutants of M . extorquens AM1
defective for the H4MPT-linked formaldehyde oxidation
pathway . These mutants fall into three phenotypic classes that
correlate with the biochemical roles of the respective enzymes in the
pathway . The most severe defect is found for mutants defective for
dmrA and orf4 . Both mutants are predicted to lack
H4MPT (20,
28) and would thus lack
both the H4MPT cofactor and any C1 intermediates
linked to this cofactor . Therefore, the flux of formaldehyde through
the H4MPT pathway should be zero, and the full burden of
formaldehyde production would fall on these mutants upon exposure to
methanol .
Mutants defective for fae exhibit an
intermediate level of sensitivity to methanol or formaldehyde . Fae
catalyzes the condensation of formaldehyde with H4MPT, but
this reaction also proceeds nonenzymatically at a lower rate
(33) . The fact that the
fae mutant has a less severe phenotype than the
H4MPT biosynthesis mutants is consistent with the
nonenzymatic condensation of formaldehyde with H4MPT
occurring at sufficient levels to allow a low level of formaldehyde
oxidation through this pathway in the absence of Fae activity, but not
enough to handle the full formaldehyde flux of methylotrophic
growth .
Mutants lacking MtdB activity have the least severe
phenotype of the H4MPT pathway mutants investigated in this
work . Two methylene-H4MPT dehydrogenases are present in
M . extorquens AM1, MtdA (NADP dependent, but also utilizes
methylene-H4F) and MtdB (H4MPT specific, but
utilizes either NAD+ or NADP+).
The sensitivity of mtdB mutants to methanol or formaldehyde
and the inability to grow on methanol indicated that this enzyme plays
a critical role in formaldehyde oxidation
(10) . The relatively
moderate sensitivity of the mtdB mutant compared to that of
either the fae or H4MPT biosynthesis mutants
indicates that, despite being insufficient for growth on C1
compounds or complete resistance to methanol or formaldehyde, MtdA
activity can support a moderate formaldehyde flux in the absence of
MtdB . To further address this question, mtdA was cloned and
overexpressed to levels 7.4-fold higher than in the wild type . This
level of MtdA activity was insufficient to allow growth on methanol;
however, it largely alleviated the sensitivity to methanol . These data
suggest that despite the normal high level of MtdA activity in the wild
type, the enzyme level is limiting in the absence of MtdB activity . It
has been suggested that the requirement for MtdA to use
NADP+, rather than NAD+, in
methylene-H4MPT reduction limits its in vivo activity
(31) .
The mutant
phenotypes discussed above are correlated with the magnitude of the
decreased formaldehyde flux through the H4MPT pathway . For
the mutants with the greatest defect, the H4MPT biosynthesis
mutants (dmrA and orf4), the impact is remarkable
considering that the MIC drops at least 5 orders of magnitude compared
to the wild type . Our demonstration that this phenotype can be at least
partially compensated with an alternate NAD- and GSH-linked
formaldehyde oxidation system demonstrates that this H4MPT
pathway not only serves as the main energy-generating pathway during
methylotrophic growth, it also must be the major formaldehyde
detoxification pathway . It is notable that an analogous
methanol-sensitive phenotype has been observed for P.
denitrificans mutants lacking flhA
(26) or fghA
(11), which demonstrates
the widespread importance for methylotrophic bacteria to maintain the
capacity for formaldehyde detoxification . The growth inhibition
observed for M . extorquens AM1 H4MPT pathway
mutants may be due directly to formaldehyde accumulation.
Alternatively, growth inhibition may be caused by a reactive conjugate
of formaldehyde with another compound, analogous to what has been
described previously for GSH-dependent oxidation of dichloromethane
(15), or perhaps even a
regulatory circuit poised to sense an imbalance of formaldehyde
production and utilization .
Our results suggest that in these
mutants, formaldehyde may accumulate in the cytoplasm . The relative
resistance of the wild type to formaldehyde added to the medium, as
well as the ability of a cytoplasmic formaldehyde oxidation system to
alleviate the phenotype, support the idea of cytoplasmic formaldehyde
rather than periplasmic formaldehyde being responsible for toxicity.
However, it is not possible at this time to measure cytoplasmic
formaldehyde distinct from periplasmic formaldehyde . In addition,
proteins and nucleic acids inside the cell will serve as a large sink
for formaldehyde, and it is likely that formaldehyde will damage the
cell substantially before it accumulates internally .
Our
demonstration that it is possible to obtain null mutants in the
H4MPT pathway shows that this pathway is not required for
growth on multicarbon compounds . We suggest that the explanation for
the inability to completely block the H4MPT-dependent
formaldehyde oxidation pathway in wild-type cells is due to the
accumulation of a C1-H4MPT intermediate(s), since
the identical mutations are tolerated in the absence of
H4MPT biosynthesis . This scenario implies that accumulation
of a C1-H4MPT intermediate(s) is either toxic
and/or interferes with normal regulatory circuits . Further work will be
required to test this hypothesis and distinguish between these
possibilities .
The work presented here demonstrates that M.
extorquens AM1 relies on the H4MPT pathway to oxidize
formaldehyde both during growth on C1 substrates and to
detoxify formaldehyde during growth on multicarbon compounds.
Remarkably, the heterologous GSH-dependent pathway from P.
denitrificans is able to largely replace this function . This
result indicates that these pathways comprise analogous metabolic
modules (5,
12) . Although they use
entirely different enzymes and cofactors, they can fulfill the same
cellular function, namely, the NAD(P)-dependent oxidation of
formaldehyde to formate .
We
thank M . Kalyuzhnaya, N . Korotkova, S . Stolyar, R . K . Thauer,
and J . Vorholt for their thoughtful discussion of our work, Y . Okubo
for assistance with growth curves, and N . Harms for providing
pWRxox451 .
This work was supported by a grant from the National
Institutes of Health (GM
36296) .
* Corresponding
author . Mailing address: Department of Chemical Engineering, University
of Washington, Box 352125, Seattle, WA 98195-2125 . Phone: (206)
616-5282 . Fax: (206) 616-5721 . E-mail:
lidstrom{at}u.washington.edu .
Present
address: 2215 Biomedical Physical Sciences, Michigan State University,
East Lansing, MI 48824-4320 .
- Anthony,
C., and L . J . Zatman. 1964 . The microbial
oxidation of methanol . 2 . The methanol-oxidizing enzyme of
Pseudomonas sp . M27 . Biochem . J.
92:614-621.
- Attwood,
M . M., and W . Harder. 1972 . A rapid and
specific enrichment procedure for Hyphomicrobium spp.Antonie Leeuwenhoek
38:369-377.
- Attwood,
M . M., and J . R . Quayle. 1984.
Formaldehyde as a central intermediary metabolite of methylotrophic
metabolism, p . 315-323 . In
R . L . Crawford and R . S . Hanson (ed.), Microbial
growth on C1 compounds . American Society for Microbiology,
Washington,
D.C.
- Chistoserdov,
A . Y., L . V . Chistoserdova, W . S.
McIntire, and M . E . Lidstrom. 1994 . Genetic
organization of the mau gene cluster in Methylobacterium
extorquens AM1: complete nucleotide sequence and generation and
characteristics of mau mutants . J . Bacteriol.
176:4052-4065.
- Chistoserdova,
L., S . W . Chen, A . Lapidus, and M . E . Lidstrom.2003 . Methylotrophy in Methylobacterium
extorquens AM1 from a genomic point of view . J.
Bacteriol.
185:2980-2987.
- Chistoserdova,
L., J . A . Vorholt, R . K . Thauer, and M.
E . Lidstrom. 1998 . C1 transfer enzymes and coenzymes
linking methylotrophic bacteria and methanogenic Archaea.Science
281:99-102.
- Chistoserdova,
L . V., and M . E . Lidstrom. 1994.
Genetics of the serine cycle in Methylobacterium extorquens
AM1: identification of sgaA and mtdA and sequences of
sgaA, hprA, and mtdA. J.
Bacteriol.
176:1957-1968.
- Eady,
R . R., and P . J . Large. 1968.
Purification of an amine dehydrogenase form Pseudomonas AM1
and its role in growth on methylamine . Biochem . J.
106:245-255.
- Figurski,
D . H., and D . R . Helinski. 1979.
Replication of an origin-containing derivative of plasmid RK2 dependent
on a plasmid function provided in trans. Proc . Natl.
Acad . Sci . USA
76:1648-1652.
- Hagemeier,
C . H., L . Chistoserdova, M . E . Lidstrom,
R . K . Thauer, and J . A . Vorholt.2000 . Characterization of a second methylene
tetrahydromethanopterin dehydrogenase from Methylobacterium
extorquens AM1 . Eur . J . Biochem.
267:3762-3769.
- Harms,
N., J . Ras, W . N . Reijnders, R . J . van Spanning,
and A . H . Stouthamer. 1996.
S-Formylglutathione hydrolase of Paracoccus
denitrificans is homologous to human esterase D: a universal
pathway for formaldehyde detoxification? J . Bacteriol.
178:6296-6299.
- Hartwell,
L . H., J . J . Hopfield, S . Leibler, and A.
W . Murray. 1999 . From molecular to modular cell
biology . Nature
402:C47-C52.
- Kalb,
V . F., and R . W . Bernlohr. 1977 . A
new spectrophotometric assay for protein in cell extracts . Anal.
Biochem.
82:362-371.
- Kallen,
R . G., and W . P . Jencks. 1966 . The
mechanism of the condensation of formaldehyde with tetrahydrofolic
acid . J . Biol . Chem.
241:5851-5863.
- Kayser,
M . F., and S . Vuilleumier. 2001.
Dehalogenation of dichloromethane by dichloromethane
dehalogenase/glutathione S-transferase leads to formation of
DNA adducts . J . Bacteriol.
183:5209-5212.
- Laukel,
M., L . Chistoserdova, M . E . Lidstrom, and J . A.
Vorholt. 2003 . The tungsten-containing formate
dehydrogenase from Methylobacterium extorquens AM1:
purification and properties . Eur . J . Biochem.
270:325-333.
- Lidstrom,
M . E. 2 November 2001, posting date . Aerobic
metylotrophic prokaryotes . In M . Dworkin (ed.), Prokaryotes.
[Online.] http://link.springer.de/link/service/books/10125/.
- Marx,
C . J., and M . E . Lidstrom. 2002.
Broad-host-range cre-lox system for antibiotic marker
recycling in gram-negative bacteria . BioTechniques
33:1062-1067.
- Marx,
C . J., and M . E . Lidstrom. 2001.
Development of improved versatile broad-host-range vectors for use in
methylotrophs and other gram-negative bacteria.Microbiology
147:2065-2075.
- Marx,
C . J., B . N . O'Brien, J . Breezee, and
M . E . Lidstrom. 2003 . Novel methylotrophy
genes of Methylobacterium extorquens AM1 identified by using
transposon mutagenesis including a putative dihydromethanopterin
reductase . J . Bacteriol.
185:669-673.
- Nunn,
D . N., and M . E . Lidstrom. 1986.
Isolation and complementation analysis of 10 methanol oxidation mutant
classes and identification of the methanol dehydrogenase structural
gene of Methylobacterium sp . strain AM1 . J.
Bacteriol.
166:581-590.
- Pomper,
B . K., O . Saurel, A . Milon, and J . A . Vorholt.2002 . Generation of formate by the
formyltransferase/hydrolase complex (Fhc) from Methylobacterium
extorquens AM1 . FEBS Lett.
523:133-137.
- Pomper,
B . K., and J . A . Vorholt. 2001.
Characterization of the formyltransferase from Methylobacterium
extorquens AM1 . Eur . J . Biochem.
268:4769-4775.
- Pomper,
B . K., J . A . Vorholt, L . Chistoserdova,
M . E . Lidstrom, and R . K . Thauer.1999 . A methenyl tetrahydromethanopterin cyclohydrolase
and a methenyl tetrahydrofolate cyclohydrolase in Methylobacterium
extorquens AM1 . Eur . J . Biochem.
261:475-480.
- Ras,
J., W . N . Reijnders, R . J . Van Spanning, N . Harms,
L . F . Oltmann, and A . H . Stouthamer.1991 . Isolation, sequencing, and mutagenesis of the gene
encoding cytochrome c553i of Paracoccus
denitrificans and characterization of the mutant strain . J.
Bacteriol.
173:6971-6979.
- Ras,
J., P . W . Van Ophem, W . N . Reijnders, R.
J . Van Spanning, J . A . Duine, A . H . Stouthamer, and
N . Harms. 1995 . Isolation, sequencing, and mutagenesis
of the gene encoding NAD- and glutathione-dependent formaldehyde
dehydrogenase (GD-FALDH) from Paracoccus denitrificans, in
which GD-FALDH is essential for methylotrophic growth . J.
Bacteriol.
177:247-251.
- Sambrook,
J., E . F . Fritsch, and T . Maniatis. 1989.
Molecular cloning: a laboratory manual, 2nd ed . Cold Spring Harbor
Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbor,
N.Y.
- Scott,
J . W., and M . E . Rasche. 2002.
Purification, overproduction, and partial characterization of
ß-RFAP synthase, a key enzyme in the methanopterin biosynthesis
pathway . J . Bacteriol.
184:4442-4448.
- Simon,
R., U . Priefer, and A . Puhler. 1983 . A broad host
range mobilization system for in vivo genetic engineering:
transposon mutagenesis in gram negative bacteria.Bio/Technology
1:784-791.
- Vorholt,
J . A. 2002 . Cofactor-dependent pathways of
formaldehyde oxidation in methylotrophic bacteria . Arch.
Microbiol.
178:239-249.
- Vorholt,
J . A., L . Chistoserdova, M . E . Lidstrom, and
R . K . Thauer. 1998 . The NADP-dependent
methylene tetrahydromethanopterin dehydrogenase in Methylobacterium
extorquens AM1 . J . Bacteriol.
180:5351-5356.
- Vorholt,
J . A., L . Chistoserdova, S . M . Stolyar,
R . K . Thauer, and M . E . Lidstrom.1999 . Distribution of tetrahydromethanopterin-dependent
enzymes in methylotrophic bacteria and phylogeny of methenyl
tetrahydromethanopterin cyclohydrolases . J . Bacteriol.
181:5750-5757.
- Vorholt,
J . A., C . J . Marx, M . E . Lidstrom, and
R . K . Thauer. 2000 . Novel
formaldehyde-activating enzyme in Methylobacterium extorquens
AM1 required for growth on methanol . J . Bacteriol.
182:6645-6650.
- Whitaker,
J . R., and P . E . Granum. 1980 . An
absolute method for protein determination based on the difference at
235 and 280 nm . Anal . Biochem.
109:156-159.
Free Online Full-text Article
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
|