|
|
|
Journal of Bacteriology, July 2002, p . 3699-3703, Vol . 184, No . 13 Toxic Waste Disposal in Escherichia coliRobert B . Helling,* Brian K . Janes, Heather Kimball, Timothy Tran, Michael Bundesmann, Pietra Check, Darcy Phelan, and Charles Miller Department of Biology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-1048 Received 22 November 2000/ Accepted 2 April 2002
Resistant mutants of Escherichia coli and of a wide variety of other gram-negative and gram-positive bacteria selected in the laboratory or isolated from clinical settings have been shown to be altered in one or more of the genes encoding components of the two topoisomerases (gyrA, gyrB, parC, and parE in E . coli) (34) . These mutations produce resistance of various levels, and further mutations often increase the resistance (18) . Quinolone-resistant mutants containing mutations in genes other than those for the topoisomerases are also obtained frequently when only a low level of drug is used in selection or when a secondary mutation increases resistance beyond that of the primary mutation . Where the basis for such mutation has been determined, it has usually resulted from the activation of an efflux pump (31, 32) that removes the quinolone during or after entry so it does not reach a toxic level . In E . coli, activation of either the AcrAB-TolC pump (4, 9, 28) or the EmrAB-TolC pump (26) provides resistance . AcrAB-TolC appears to be the main pump providing intrinsic resistance to low levels of many toxic compounds in nature (38) . Three signaling pathways controlling the expression of the acrAB genes and the formation of the AcrAB-TolC pump are known; these involve the MarAB, SoxRS, and RobA proteins (5, 11, 15, 33, 39) . Thus, there are several potential ways of generating low-level resistance to quinolones through the activation of efflux pumps . Screening mutants of E . coli and other bacteria selected on broth plates containing a low level of nalidixic acid revealed that resistance results from mutation at any one of many loci (16, 22) . Unexpectedly, resistance mutations sometimes cause blocks in central biosynthetic pathways and corresponding growth factor requirements . The mutations include those in purB (adenylosuccinate lyase, adenine requirement) (16) and icdA (isocitrate dehydrogenase, glutamate requirement) (17) and others causing requirements for methionine or cysteine (17) . In addition, Nalr mutants stemming from double mutations removing the dual aconitases (acnA acnB) (14) have been found (16, 22) . Why should a block in a biosynthetic pathway confer antibiotic resistance on the cell? Results from analysis of the icdA mutants provide a clue . These mutants accumulate a large quantity of citrate and isocitrate, the intermediate compounds before the block (Fig . 1) . Double mutants lacking citrate synthase as well (gltA icdA) neither form these intermediates nor show the resistance to nalidixic acid of the icdA mutant (23, 24) . Thus, one can hypothesize that the accumulation of the charged intermediate compounds triggers the resistance (23) . purB mutants also accumulate intermediate compounds formed before the block (13); these compounds (SAICAR and adenylosuccinate; Fig . 1) resemble citrate and isocitrate in part . Thus, the resistance in purB mutants may also result from metabolite accumulation . The association of metabolite accumulation and nalidixic acid resistance in icdA and purB mutants suggests a further hypothesis relating the two phenomena: the metabolites activate the formation of an efflux pump that removes nalidixic acid from the cell and thus prevents toxicity . In order to test this hypothesis, we isolated Nalr mutants of E . coli induced by transposon insertion, characterized the mutants, and tested the roles of the AcrAB-TolC and EmrAB-TolC pumps in the resistance .
Characterization of mutants. Mutants were streaked onto minimal glucose medium to identify growth factor requirements . Auxotrophic mutants were used as donors in transduction to RBH1854 with selection for chloramphenicol resistance . Transductants were tested for nalidixic acid resistance and growth factor requirements . Mutants in which those characters cotransduced with chloramphenicol resistance were assumed to be induced by the transposition . Transductants picked for further analysis were shown to be nonlysogenic for the viruses P1 and lambda . The locations of the transposon insertions were determined by PCR with an rTth DNA polymerase XL kit (Applied Biosystems) according to the manufacturer's instructions . Twenty-five-nucleotide primers corresponded to the beginning and end of each open reading frame (ORF), and additional upstream primers corresponding to sequences approximately 100 nucleotides upstream of the ORF were used for insertions that did not map within the ORFs . In order to determine the roles of the well-known AcrAB-TolC and EmrAB-TolC efflux pumps in the development of the Nal resistance, the pumps were knocked out in selected Nalr mutants . Transposon insertions were transduced from the RBH1854 derivatives into RBH1855 (acrAB, but otherwise isogenic with RBH1854) by using selection for chloramphenicol . The mutant genes tolC::Tn10 and emrB::kan were added to mutant derivatives of RBH1854 by transduction by using selection for tetracycline or kanamycin . In the same way, mutations of the signaling pathways (marA::miniTn10kan, rob::kan, and soxS3::Tn10) were transduced into derivatives of RBH1854 with selection for kanamycin or tetracycline . Nalidixic acid resistance. Strains were streaked onto tryptone agar with 0, 1, or 2.5 mg of nalidixic acid/liter and grown overnight at 37°C . The selected mutants grew on all three media, the wild type grew on media with 0 and 1 mg of Nal/liter, and acrAB and tolC strains grew only on medium lacking the antibiotic . For quantitative assays of resistance, diluted samples of strains grown overnight in tryptone broth at 37°C were spread on tryptone agar plates containing various amounts of Nal and plated at 37°C . Plates were counted after 24 to 40 h . acrAB expression. Relative transcription rates from the acrAB promoter were determined from a pacrAB-lacZ fusion in the low-copy-number plasmid pNN602S (27) . This construct includes the acrAB regulator gene acrR . In order to prevent the appearance of LacZ (ß-galactosidase) activity stemming from chromosomal lacZ transcription, the chromosomal lacZ+ gene was replaced with lacZ::Tn5-131 (Kns Tcr) (6) by using P1-mediated transduction with selection for tetracycline resistance . In the expression experiments, 0.15 ml of an overnight culture in L broth (30°C) was subcultured in 20 ml of L broth at 30°C, and growth was continued with shaking at 30°C for approximately 2 h until harvest and LacZ assay essentially as described previously (27) . Supplements (ethanol to 4%, lactose to 0.2%, nalidixic acid to 2 or 5 mg/liter) were added as appropriate 40 min after subculturing .
Single-colony isolates of each mutant were tested for growth on minimal agar medium containing glucose as the sole carbon and energy source . Of the total, 10 required glutamate for growth (icdA mutants), 13 required adenine (purB), 1 required cysteine, and 1 had an unidentified growth factor requirement satisfied by Casamino Acids . None required methionine, although methionine-requiring mutants were isolated in other screens . Thus, a total of 25 mutants exhibited a growth factor requirement (10%), consistent with a previous report of 2 to 40% auxotrophs among spontaneous mutants (16) . None of the mutants showed high-level resistance to nalidixic acid (20 mg/liter) . In order to determine whether the nalidixic acid resistance and growth alterations were caused by a separate mutation rather than by the transposon insertion, we transduced Camr from some original isolates to a wild-type recipient by using selection on tryptone agar containing chloramphenicol . After single-colony isolation, we scored the transductants for Nalr and for growth properties . In summary, 10 of 10 icdA mutations cotransduced with the Camr insertion and with Nalr, and 4 of 6 purB mutations cotransduced with Camr and with Nalr . (In the other two cases, neither purB nor Nalr cotransduced with Camr.) Nalr cotransduced with Camr in 10 of 26 original isolates that showed no growth factor requirement . Thus, most of the Nalr auxotrophs were caused by transposon insertion, but many of the original Nalr isolates showing normal growth were caused by mutation other than the insertion of the transposon . The locations of the transposon insertions were verified by PCR for two icdA and two purB mutants . For each type of mutant (icdA and purB), one insertion was within the ORF and one was immediately upstream . The cysteine-requiring mutant responded to cysteine, sulfide, or sulfite, and so it was blocked in the reduction of sulfate to sulfite (21, 30) . PCR showed that the transposon insertion was within the cysH gene encoding 3'-phosphoadenosine 5'-phosphosulfate (PAPS) sulfotransferase . A methionine-requiring mutant isolated earlier when testing the procedure responded to vitamin B12, as well, but not to homocysteine-thiolactone . This pinpointed the mutational defect to the last step in methionine synthesis, the formation of methionine by homocysteine methyltransferase, which is the product of the gene metE. PCR verified that the transposon insertion was within metE .
Characterizing the role of the AcrAB-TolC and EmrAB-TolC efflux pumps in resistance.
In order to see if the resistance of our mutants to Nal was associated with its efflux through one of these pumps, we modified the Nalr mutants so that they also contained acrAB, tolC, or emrB mutations (see Materials and Methods) . Streaking onto tryptone agar containing nalidixic acid showed that emrB::kan had no obvious effect on the Nal resistance of icdA (five tested), purB (two tested), metE, or cysH mutants . However, each of the same mutants became Nal sensitive when the organism was deficient in the AcrAB-TolC pump because of defective AcrAB (
In order to determine which possibility was correct, we deleted pairs of the signaling pathways from the same icdA and purB mutants to see if resistance was lost . Streaking onto Nal-containing medium showed that for each Nalr mutant, the loss of either MarA and SoxS or Rob and SoxS prevented the development of resistance . Quantitative assays with an icdA derivative show the results clearly (Fig . 2) . Thus, it appears that each signaling pathway (MarAB, Rob, and SoxRS) has a role in the development of resistance to nalidixic acid in the mutants tested . When a single path is inactivated, a small diminution in resistance may be seen via the quantitative assay, but it is too small to detect by streaking . acrAB expression. In order to see whether the activation of the acrAB-tolC pump implied by the above results stemmed from increased transcription, we measured relative transcription rates by using a pacrAB-lacZ fusion . The results (Fig . 3) show clearly that transcription from the acrAB promoter in each Nalr mutant was increased to over twice the level in the wild-type organism . Ethanol is known to induce the acrAB operon (27) and so served as a positive control . As expected, lactose did not affect transcription of the lacZ gene fused to the acrAB promoter . Expression was decreased by nalidixic acid . The lack of a functional chromosomal acrAB locus resulted in greater transcription from the acrAB promoter of the plasmid . The increased acrAB transcription in the icdA mutant was reduced by marA or robA mutation but was still greater than that in the wild type, consistent with the results shown in Fig . 2 .
Comparison of the structures of the intermediate compounds formed before the metabolic block in metE (8, 36), icdA (23), and purB (13) mutants (Fig . 1) shows that each has at least one carboxylate . The well-studied AcrAB-TolC inducer, salicylate, also has a carboxylate (Fig . 1) . Salicylate is known to induce the AcrAB-TolC efflux pump by at least two mechanisms, one of which involves Mar, the other(s) being unknown but not SoxRS (7) . The repressor of marRAB, MarR, binds at the marRAB promoter; binding is antagonized in vitro by salicylate and some other inducers of the Mar pathway but not by inducers such as tetracycline (1, 2, 3, 29) . cysH mutants are thought to accumulate PAPS (21, 30); PAPS does not contain a carboxylate but is highly charged as a consequence of the sulfate and phosphate groups (Fig . 1) . It seems likely that the anionic nature of the compounds is important to their inducing activity . However, structural studies with another multidrug-binding protein, QacR, show that a single regulatory protein can bind structurally diverse inducers in different ways (35) . As noted in the introduction, icdA mutants that also lack citrate synthase (gltA) are Nals . In contrast, mutants deficient in both aconitases and also in citrate synthase remain resistant to the drug (14), contrary to what is expected if citrate is not formed . However, recent work suggests that in these triple mutants, some citrate is formed by an alternative enzyme to citrate synthase, 2-methylcitrate synthase, and then trapped without further metabolism because of a lack of aconitase (12) . Citrate is also formed in small amounts by an unknown pathway (presumably 2-methylcitrate synthase) in icdA gltA double mutants (23) . However, in those strains the citrate does not form a pool large enough to induce AcrAB-TolC, probably because it is converted by aconitase to isocitrate, which then drains through the glyoxylate pathway (24) . This route for further metabolism of citrate is not available in the acnA acnB gltA triple mutants . Why should the internal metabolites induce an efflux pathway? Is it an accident or the product of long-term natural selection? We suggest that the AcrAB-TolC pump provides a means for damping infrequent short-term accumulations of charged metabolites that are inhibitory in high concentrations . By this reasoning, the charged intermediate compounds accumulating in the mutants are inducers of the pump that removes them from the organism if their concentrations become high as the result of temporary surges . The residual activity of the AcrAB-TolC pump would reflect the titration of the sum of the pools of the internal inducers . If true, the affinity or capacity of the pump for some inducers must be relatively low, because the complete blockage of the pathways in icdA and purB mutants results in large internal pools of the metabolites . Fortuitously, nalidixic acid is a substrate for the pump, and so activation by metabolite accumulation provides resistance against the antibiotic . We envisage four roles for efflux pumps . Their best-known role is in the removal of toxins entering from outside . Other pumps remove end products of metabolism, for example, fermentation end products and toxins directed against other organisms . Although the pumps usually require an input of energy, some may conserve or capture potential energy . Finally, as suggested by these studies, pumps may serve to buffer the organism against infrequent surges in pools of potentially toxic normal metabolites . It will be interesting to learn which of these functions is primitive .
The work was supported in part by NIH grant GM47156 .
What Is Protein?,
What Is Molecular Microbiology?,
What Is Biotechnology?,
What Is Growth Medium?,
What Is Bioengineering?,
i,
Microbes,
e,
Bacterium,
e,
Microbe,
n,
Microorganism,
s,
Bacteria,
s,
Escherichia coli,
a,
Bacillus subtilis,
o,
Wastewater,
e,
Enterobacters,
n,
Staphylococcus aureus,
c,
Pseudomonas,
r,
Microorganisms,
c,
Staphylococcus,
c,
Staphylococcus,
n,
Sepsis,
c,
Staphylococcus,
n,
Microorganisms,
e,
Cryptococci,
n,
Escherichia coli,
s,
Bacillus subtilis,
n,
Antibiotic prophylaxis,
i,
Cell suspensions,
e,
Functional genomics,
i,
Schizosaccharomyces,
o,
Sepsis,
e,
Pseudomonas
|
© 2005
Transgalactic Ltd (manufacturer of Bioscreen C software) |
Privacy Statement | P.O. Box
1393, 00101 Helsinki, Finland,
Last modified: May 25, 2005
| ||||||