|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, July 2004, p . 4307-4314, Vol . 186,
No . 13
Group I
Intron Homing in Bacillus Phages SPO1 and SP82: a Gene Conversion Event
Initiated by a Nicking Homing Endonuclease
Markus Landthaler,
Nelson C . Lau,
and David . A . Shub*
Department of Biological Sciences and Center for Molecular Genetics,
University at Albany, State University of New York, Albany, New York 12222
Received 16 December 2003/ Accepted 24 March 2004
Many group I introns encode endonucleases that promote intron homing
by initiating a double-stranded break-mediated homologous
recombination event . In this work we describe intron homing in
Bacillus subtilis phages SPO1 and SP82 . The introns encode the
DNA endonucleases I-HmuI and I-HmuII, respectively, which belong to
the H-N-H endonuclease family and possess nicking activity in vitro .
Coinfections of B . subtilis with intron-minus and intron-plus
phages indicate that I-HmuI and I-HmuII are required for homing of
the SPO1 and SP82 introns, respectively . The homing process is a gene
conversion event that does not require the major B . subtilis
recombination pathways, suggesting that the necessary functions are
provided by phage-encoded factors . Our results provide the first
examples of H-N-H endonuclease-mediated intron homing and the first
demonstration of intron homing initiated by a nicking endonuclease .
Group I introns constitute a phylogenetically widespread class of
self-splicing intervening RNA sequences that share a common secondary
structure and splicing pathway . In many cases these introns encode
site-specific DNA endonucleases . Rather than being involved in the
splicing process, these endonucleases promote the transfer of the
intron from an intron-plus gene to an intron-minus gene, in a process
known as homing (9) . Therefore, the intron-encoded
endonucleases that mediate this process are referred to as homing
endonucleases .
Group I intron homing was first described for the
intron (LSU-1) of the mitochondrial large ribosomal rRNA gene of
Saccharomyces cerevisiae (reviewed in reference 9) .
Genetic analyses showed that LSU-1 intron propagation is by
unidirectional gene conversion that depends on expression of the
intronic open reading frame (19), whose protein
product was subsequently shown to be a site-specific DNA endonuclease
(7) . Genetic similarities between homing of the
LSU-1 intron and other gene conversion events in yeast suggested that
group I intron homing occurs via the double-stranded break (DSB)
repair mechanism (33, 35) . Homing has been
experimentally demonstrated in other biological systems, such as
those of bacteriophages, protist nuclei, and algal chloroplasts (4,
26, 28) .
Typically, a DSB is generated by the intron-encoded endonuclease
at a specific site in the intronless gene, close to the site of
intron insertion . The DSB in the recipient allele is resected by
host-encoded exonucleases, leaving single-stranded 3' ends that
invade the homologous region of the intron-containing donor duplex .
After D-loop formation the 3' ends function as primers in a repair
process that uses the complementary intron-containing DNA strands as
template . Distance-dependent coconversion of flanking exon sequences
observed with intron homing is due to exonucleolytic degradation of
the cleaved recipient DNA and possibly to branch migration during
recombination . The homing process is completed by cleavage and
ligation of the two Holliday junctions resulting in resolution of the
two intron-containing alleles (2) .
Homing endonucleases have been classified into four major families
based on conserved amino acid sequence motifs, denoted LAGLIDADG,
GIY-YIG, His-Cys box, and H-N-H, respectively (3) . The H-N-H
endonucleases I-HmuI and I-HmuII, encoded by group I introns in
the DNA polymerase genes of Bacillus subtilis phages SPO1 and
SP82, respectively, are distinct from typical intron-encoded
endonucleases in that they cut only one strand of their DNA substrate
(14) . Furthermore, both enzymes cleave intron-containing
substrates in addition to intronless versions of their cognate
genes, and each enzyme prefers the DNA of the heterologous phage as a
substrate . I-HmuII is required to exclude the SPO1 intron and
flanking genetic markers from the progeny of mixed infections, a
process that was interpreted as an intron replacement event but that
proceeded by the same mechanism as intron homing (14) .
However, it has not been directly demonstrated that intron replacement
or homing can be initiated by a nicking endonuclease . Furthermore,
rather than resulting from a gene conversion event, the observed
exclusion of the SPO1 intron and flanking markers during coinfection
with SP82 could have been due to general phage exclusion mediated
by I-HmuII .
In this work we demonstrate homing of the group I introns in
phages SPO1 and SP82 into intronless target sites . As is the case
with events that are initiated at DSBs in phage T4 (4),
homing is shown to be a unidirectional, nonreciprocal gene conversion
event . Intron homing is dependent on the function of the intronic
H-N-H DNA endonucleases I-HmuI and I-HmuII and does not require
the major B . subtilis recombination pathways .
Bacterial and bacteriophage strains and growth conditions.
B . subtilis CB312 was used for propagation of phages SPO1 and
SP82 in Luria-Bertani (LB) medium . SPO1sus14 mutants were propagated
on CB313 (sup3), a lysine-inserting ochre suppressor strain
(14) . B . subtilis YB886 and
recombination-defective derivatives recA (YB1015), recF15
addA5 (BG143), recF15 recH342 (BG137), recO1 recH342
(BG443), recU1 recH342 (BG437), and recS1 recH342
(BG435) were obtained from Juan C . Alonso, Universidad Autonoma de
Madrid, Spain, and are described in reference 11 .
SPO1I-HmuIoc and SP82I-HmuIIoc contain
ochre (UAA) in place of lysine (AAG) at the fourth codon of the SPO1
and SP82 intron endonuclease genes, respectively (14) .
To construct the intronless phage SPO1 I,
a lysate of SPO1I-HmuIoc was serially diluted and
spotted onto a top agar lawn of B . subtilis CB312 containing
plasmid pWO1 I .
The area corresponding to the highest dilution that exhibited
continuous lysis was excised, crushed, and washed with buffered
saline, and the supernatant was collected . Phages with an intron
deletion were identified by plaque hybridization using
oligonucleotide SPpol I,
spanning the intron insertion site, as a probe . Phages were plated
out overnight and transferred to Hybond-N nylon membrane (Amersham) .
Membranes were placed on a series of solution-saturated (solution was
either 0.5 M NaOH, 1.5 M NaCl; 1 M Tris-HCl [pH 7.5], 1.5 M NaCl; or
2x SSC [1x
SSC is 0.15 M NaCl plus 0.015 M sodium citrate]) Whatman 3MM filter
papers for 5 min each . Dried and UV-irradiated membranes were
prehybridized in a solution containing 3x
Denhardt's, 3x SCC, 0.1% sodium
dodecyl sulfate (SDS), and 50 µg of salmon sperm DNA/ml at 65°C for 1
h and were hybridized overnight at 50°C in a solution of 3x
Denhardt's, 6x SCC, 0.1% SDS
using 32P-end-labeled SPpol I
(5 x 106 cpm) . Membranes were
washed twice in 6x SSC at 60°C
and once in 1x SSC at 50°C and
were exposed to BIOMAX film (Kodak) . Phages from positive plaques
were isolated, diluted, and checked for purity by plaque hybridization .
SPO1(sus14,I-HmuIoc) was obtained from a cross of
SPO1I-HmuIoc with SPO1sus14 . SPO1(sus14, I)
was obtained by crossing SPO1(sus14,I-HmuIoc)
with SPO1 I .
Plasmids. pWO1 I
was constructed to have a longer target for homologous recombination
than the intronless sequence in plasmid pHGO1 I
(14) . The 284-bp fragment of the intronless DNA
polymerase gene in pHGO1 I
was amplified by PCR with primers S2819 and S2835, and the PCR
product was digested with EcoRI and SnaBI . The intron-containing
EcoRI/SnaBI fragment of plasmid pH EP1
(13) was replaced by the intronless EcoRI/SnaBI
fragment of pHGO1 I
to create pH EP1 I .
A 1.0-kb EcoRI/HindIII fragment was excised from pH EP1 I
and ligated into the corresponding sites of the Escherichia
coli-B . subtilis shuttle vector pMS1 (29) to
generate pWO1 I .
Phage crosses. B . subtilis CB312 or CB313 cells were
grown at 37°C to an optical density at 540 nm of 0.4 in LB broth and
were infected with a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 4 for each
phage . After 15 min, SPO1 antiserum (which is also effective against
SP82) was added to inactivate unabsorbed phage . Twenty minutes
postinfection the culture was diluted 10–4 into prewarmed
LB and was incubated for 3 h at 37°C . For infection with sus14
mutants, phage progeny were plated on CB313 to allow growth of all
phages . Plaques were picked onto lawns of either CB312 or CB313 to
determine the frequency of wild-type phages . sus14 mutants are
able to form plaques on CB313 but not CB312 . Intron-minus and
intron-plus phages were distinguished by plating phages on a CB313
lawn and subsequent plaque hybridization with oligonucleotide SPpol I
(complementary to the intron insertion site) and K4O (complementary
to the ochre mutation in the endonuclease) . Because
oligonucleotide K4O has a 2-nucleotide mismatch with the wild-type
sequence, it also permits discrimination between wild-type and ochre
alleles of the intron-encoded endonuclease genes (Fig .
1) .
|
FIG . 1 . Exclusion of intron-minus allele in progeny of SPO1 and SPO1 I
coinfections . Plaques from progeny of mixed infections of SPO1 I
and either wild-type SPO1 (A) or SPO1I-HmuIoc (B) on
B . subtilis CB312 (Sup–) or CB313 (Sup+)
were replicated, lifted onto nylon membranes, and probed with
end-labeled oligonucleotides specific for the intron-minus (SPpolI I)
and intron-plus (K4O) DNA polymerase gene . Note that the
oligonucleotide, although having two mismatches with the wild-type
sequence, still exhibits specific hybridization to wild-type introns
under these conditions.
|
|
Plaque hybridization. Phages from mixed infections were plated
out overnight, and plaques were transferred to Hybond-N nylon
membranes (Amersham) . Membranes were placed on a series of
solution-saturated (with one of the following solutions: 0.5 M NaOH,
1.5 M NaCl; 1 M Tris-HCl [pH 7.5], 1.5 M NaCl; or 2x
SSC) 3MM filter papers for 5 min each . DNA on air-dried membranes was
fixed by UV cross-linking . Membranes were prehybridized for an hour
at 60°C in a solution containing 3x
SSC, 1x Denhardt's reagent, 0.1% SDS, and 50
µg of denatured salmon sperm DNA/ml . Hybridization was carried
out for 12 h at 45°C in a solution of 3x
SSC, 1x Denhardt's reagent, 0.1%
SDS, and end-labeled oligonucleotide . Membranes were washed three
times in 3x SSC and 0.1% SDS at 45°C and
once in 1x SSC and 0.1% SDS at 36°C,
and then they were exposed to X-ray film .
Oligonucleotides. The following oligonucleotides were used:
82c1, 5'-TCTCTTTCAGTATAATCACGAG; K4O, 5'-GAATATGGAATGGTAAGACATTAAAGG;
S2819, 5'-CAGACAAGTATACGTAACTCTAACTG; S2835,
5'-CATGGAATTCCGTAAGGCAAACC; SPpol I,
5'-AGTAGTAATAGAGCCTAACGCTCA(A/G)CAATTC .
To study homing of introns encoding DNA endonucleases that cut only
one DNA strand, an intronless gene 31 (DNA polymerase) of
bacteriophage SPO1 was generated by plasmid-to-phage transfer . Plaque
morphology of intronless phage SPO1 I
was indistinguishable from the wild type, and the burst sizes of both
phages were comparable (data not shown) .
Homing of the SPO1 intron was examined by coinfecting B . subtilis
with SPO1 I
and wild-type SPO1 or with SPO1I-HmuIoc (a phage
with a suppressible nonsense mutation in the intron-encoded
endonuclease I-HmuI), each at an MOI of 4 . Progeny phages and the
input phage mixtures used for these coinfections were plated and
analyzed by plaque hybridization for the presence or absence of the
intron (Fig . 1), as summarized in Table 1 .
In the progeny of crosses between SPO1 and SPO1 I
the intron-plus allele was observed with a frequency of about 95%,
regardless of the bacterial host used . In contrast, coinfection of
B . subtilis CB312 (Sup–) with SPO1I-HmuIoc
and SPO1 I
resulted in a transmission of intron-plus and intron-minus markers
near the input ratio . However, when the nonsense mutation in the gene
for I-HmuI was suppressed (and the endonuclease activity was
restored), the frequency of the intron-plus gene in the progeny was
comparable to that obtained for coinfections with wild-type SPO1 .
These results demonstrated that the change in frequency of
intron-plus versus intron-minus phages in the progeny was dependent
on I-HmuI .
| TABLE 1 . Dependence of intron inheritance on I-HmuI
|
|
Intron homing versus phage exclusion. The similarities in burst
sizes and plaque morphologies of SPO1 and SPO1 I
argued against a selective growth advantage for the intron-containing
phage . However, the high frequency of intron-plus alleles in the
progeny of mixed infections might be the result of exclusion of the
SPO1 I
phage caused by I-HmuI rather than intron homing . This issue was
addressed by using phages with a suppressible nonsense mutation (sus14-1)
in gene 14 (27), which provided a traceable
genetic marker in mixed infections (Table 2) . Gene
14 is about 40 kb away from gene 31 (30) and
is not likely to be influenced by marker exclusion events originating
at the intron insertion site in gene 31 (14,
31) .
| TABLE 2 . SPO1 intron homing is a gene conversion event
|
|
Progeny were plated on B . subtilis CB313 (Sup+), which can
support the growth of all phages, and were analyzed by plaque
hybridization for the presence or absence of the intron . The
proportion of sus14 mutants in the burst was determined by the
ability of individual plaques to replicate on a Sup– lawn .
For each experiment the mixture of phages used for infection was
analyzed to determine the ratio of input phages .
When B . subtilis CB312 or CB313 was coinfected with approximately
equal multiplicities of SPO1sus14 and SPO1 I,
intron-containing phages dominated the burst . While the frequency of
the intron-plus allele increased from about 50% in the input phages
to 90 to 95% in the progeny, the frequency of the sus14 mutant
allele in the progeny remained largely unchanged compared to that of
the input phage mixture (Table 2, columns 5 to 8) . The
increase in the intron frequency was mostly due to the appearance of
intron-containing phages with the wild-type gene 14 (column
3), while the frequency of intronless SPO1 phages decreased
compared to that of the input mixture (column 2) .
Mixed infections of the Sup– host with SPO1(sus14,I-HmuIoc)
and SPO1 I
resulted in essentially equal transmission frequencies for the intron
and sus14 alleles (Table 2, columns 5 to 8) .
When endonuclease activity was restored on the Sup+ host, the
frequency of the intron approached 95% (columns 5 and 6) with
most of the increase coming, once again, from intron-containing
phages with wild-type gene 14 (columns 2 and 3) .
Similar results were obtained in reciprocal crosses in which the
intronless phage carried the sus14 mutation (Table 2) .
The predominance of the intron in the burst was dependent on a
functional intron-encoded endonuclease, and the frequency of the
sus14 allele in the burst was comparable to that of the input
phages . The inheritance of the intron and the sus14 mutation
are not linked in these crosses .
Homing of the SP82 intron into the intronless SPO1 DNA polymerase
gene. The intron endonuclease-dependent exclusion of SPO1 markers
in the progeny coinfections with SP82 (14) suggested
that the SP82 intron is likely to be capable of homing into the
intronless SPO1 homologue . Homing of the SP82 intron was examined by
mixed infection of B . subtilis CB312 and CB313 with the
intronless phage SPO1(sus14, I)
and SP82 wild-type or SP82I-HmuIIoc, a phage with a
suppressor-sensitive nonsense mutation in the intronic endonuclease
I-HmuII (14) .
As in crosses with wild-type SPO1 (Table 2), the progeny of
mixed infections of SPO1(sus14, I)
and SP82 showed a predominance of intron-containing phages (Table
3, columns 5 and 6) . The frequency of the sus14
mutant allele in the burst was largely unchanged compared to that of
the input (columns 7 and 8) . With the exception of the SP82I-HmuIoc
x SPO1(sus14, I)
cross on the Sup+ host, the high transmission frequency of
the intron was due to the appearance of intron-containing SPO1sus14
(column 3), while the frequency of SPO1(sus14, I)
declined compared to that in the input phages (column 2) . The
high-frequency transmission of the intron in mixed infections of the
Sup+ host with SP82I-HmuIIoc and SPO1sus14
compared to that on the Sup– host showed that the
predominance of the intron-containing phages in the burst is
dependent on the activity of the endonuclease (columns 2, 3, 5, and
6) . The predominance of phages with wild-type gene 14 in
infections of the Sup– host was likely due to lack of
progeny from cells that were singly infected with sus14 phages,
which require complementation by the wild-type allele .
| TABLE 3 . SP82 intron homing is a gene conversion event
|
|
In summary, the data suggest that the SP82 intron was transferred
into the SPO1 intronless DNA polymerase gene by a gene conversion
event analogous to homing of the SPO1 intron . Furthermore, the
unidirectional and nonreciprocal transfer of the intron is dependent
on the intronic endonuclease .
Gene conversion at the cleavage site. The sequence
differences of the DNA polymerase genes of SPO1 and SP82 around the
cleavage site of I-HmuII permitted determination of the
directionality of conversion in SPO1 . Intron-containing phages with
the sus14 mutation from the burst of a coinfection with SP82
and SPO1(sus14, I)
(Table 3, Sup–, cross 2) were probed
with an end-labeled oligonucleotide complementary to the SP82
sequence spanning the I-HmuII cleavage site (Fig . 2) .
The hybridization result showed that 41 out of 42 phages carried
the SP82-specific sequence (data not shown) . With the exception
of recombinant phages that were the result of homologous recombination
[estimated to be about 5, based on the recombination frequency
of about 12.5% in crosses of SP82I-HmuIIoc and SPO1(sus14, I)
in Sup– cells (Table 3), where there is no
functional intron endonuclease], the remaining recombinants likely
arose from intron homing events . The presence of the SP82 sequence
in these phages suggests that in almost all cases of intron
acquisition by SPO1(sus14, I)
the SPO1 sequence, immediately upstream and downstream of the I-HmuII
cleavage site, had been converted .
|
FIG . 2 . Nucleotide sequence alignment around the I-HmuII cleavage site .
The sequence of the top (coding) strand is shown, with the cleavage site
of I-HmuII on the bottom strand indicated by an arrow . Differences from
the SP82 sequence are highlighted . Oligonucleotide SP82c1 has eight
mismatches to the SPO1 sequence, four on each side of the cleavage site,
requiring bidirectional conversion to hybridize with SPO1 DNA.
|
|
Homing is independent of major host recombination pathways. The
mobile introns of E . coli bacteriophage T4 provided a useful
system to thoroughly analyze the functional cis and trans
requirements for intron homing (6) . Genetic and
biochemical analyses allowed for elucidation of a precise definition
of the recombination events that result in intron inheritance and the
determination of host and phage functions required for intron
mobility (18, 25) . In
comparison to phage T4, genes of SPO1 involved in replication and
recombination have been poorly or not at all studied . In B .
subtilis, several recombination and repair genes, belonging to
five epistatic groups, have been genetically characterized (11) .
The following single and double mutants were used to study homing
requirements based on their capacity to impair homologous
recombination and recombinational repair in B . subtilis: recA,
recF15 addA5, recF15 recH342, recO1 recH342, recU1
recH342, and recS1 recH342 .
The six B . subtilis recombination mutants and their parental
strain, YB886, were coinfected with SPO1(sus14, I)
and SPO1 or SPO1I-HmuIoc (Table 4) .
Intron-containing phages dominated the progeny of mixed infections
with SPO1, whereas the high transmission frequency of the intron
allele was not observed in crosses with SPO1I-HmuIoc
(columns 5 and 6) . In comparison, the frequency of sus14 in
the progeny remained largely unchanged compared to that of the input
phages (columns 7 and 8) . The slight increase of wild-type gene 14
in SPO1I-HmuIoc crosses with wild-type SPO1 was
likely due to a relatively high proportion of singly infected cells
in this experiment . Because the six B . subtilis recombination
mutants and their parental strain are Sup–, sus14
phage would produce no progeny in the absence of complementation by
the wild-type gene .
TABLE 4 . Intron homing into SPO1(sus14, I)
in recombination-deficient B . subtilis
|
|
Crosses with wild-type SPO1 resulted in a larger number of intron-containing
recombinant phages than did crosses with SPO1I-HmuIoc
(Table 4, column 3), suggesting that, analogous to
T4 intron mobility, intron homing in SPO1 is independent of the major
host recombination pathways . Appearance of recombinant phages in the
progeny of crosses with SPO1I-HmuIoc (columns 3 and
4) further suggests that none of the Rec– strains impaired
general recombination during mixed infections . This implies that, as
is also the case for homing in T4, phage-encoded factors are mainly
involved in SPO1 intron homing .
This work showed that in coinfections of B . subtilis with intronless
SPO1 and intron-containing phage SP82 or SPO1, both introns
exhibit homing into the intronless DNA polymerase gene . Crosses with
phages carrying suppressor-sensitive mutations in gene 14
further indicated that intron homing is a gene conversion event
likely involving a DNA repair process . The endonuclease-dependent
predominance of the intron in the progeny, with the sus14 allele
remaining at about the same frequency as in the parent phages,
argues for homing of the intron by unidirectional conversion of the
intron-minus DNA polymerase gene . The high proportion of recombinant
intron-containing phages containing the gene 14 marker of the
recipient further supports this duplicative nonreciprocal process .
I-HmuII has previously been shown to be responsible for exclusion
of the SPO1 intron and flanking genetic markers from the progeny of
mixed infections of B . subtilis with SPO1 and SP82, a process
that was suggested to involve recombinational repair (14) .
Because marker exclusion and intron homing are both initiated by
single-stranded cleavage by I-HmuII, these events probably share the
same mechanism . In both cases cleavage of the DNA of one phage by the
intron-encoded endonuclease of the other likely results in
replacement of sequences surrounding the cut site by sequences of the
intact phage genome . The directionality of the transfer of sequences
would be dependent on the cleavage specificity of the intron-encoded
endonuclease . Although capable of cleaving intron-containing
substrates in vitro, I-HmuI has a preference for the SP82 intronless
gene, whereas I-HmuII prefers the SPO1 sequence, regardless of the
presence or absence of an intron (14) . The ability of
I-HmuII to promote marker exclusion (intron replacement) and intron
homing suggests that the endonuclease is a highly versatile
mobile element .
Our experimental data indicate that in homing and marker exclusion
the conversion process radiates in both directions from the cut site .
The bidirectional conversion of the I-HmuII cleavage site in crosses
of SPO1 I
and SP82 is consistent with results obtained by Stewart and Franck (31) .
In their study of the predominance of SP82 over SPO1 in mixed
infections, the exclusion was clustered around gene 31 (DNA
polymerase gene), reaching from genes 29 to 32 . It
remains to be seen whether there is directional bias in the
coconversion over this interval .
Intron homing in these phages is a puzzling result . Although in
this work the nature of the break in vivo was not established, I-HmuI
and I-HmuII have a nicking activity in vitro (14) . Unlike
DNase I and protein gpII of bacteriophage f1, which are both
nicking endonucleases in reactions with Mg2+ but which generate
DSBs in the presence of Mn2+ (5,
16, 23), I-HmuII retains nicking
activity even in the presence of divalent transition metal ions
(M . Landthaler and D . A . Shub, unpublished data) .
Conversely, homing initiated by group I intron-encoded endonucleases
has been shown to involve a DSB of the intron-minus allele close
to the intron insertion site (9) . This is thought to
promote DSB repair resulting in the transfer of the intron, which is
accompanied by coconversion of flanking genetic markers (2) .
In the case of I-HmuI and I-HmuII, either a nick is sufficient
to initiate the mobility of these introns in vivo or second-strand
cleavage is achieved by some intron endonuclease-independent
component . For group II introns, in which homing is mechanistically
different from that of group I introns, the excised intron RNA
cleaves the coding strand by reverse splicing into the DNA and the
endonuclease subsequently nicks the template strand (34) .
The similarity of group I and group II intron endonucleases,
sharing the H-N-H nuclease motif (15), suggested that
second-strand cleavage by group I intron RNA might also be involved
in the mobility of these phage introns . However, the nicking H-N-H
endonuclease I-TwoI, in the nrdE-I2 intron of staphylococcal
phage Twort, cleaves the coding strand, arguing against involvement
of intron RNA in second-strand cleavage (22) .
Single-strand breaks have been suggested to initiate recombination
processes, and Strathern and coworkers (32) observed a
stimulation of recombination when they expressed the gene II product
of bacteriophage f1, which has a strand-specific nicking activity,
in yeast . However, the authors could not rule out the possibility
that a small fraction of DSBs actually promoted the increase in
recombination . It has been shown that single-strand breaks generated
by restriction endonucleases are repaired by a RecA- and
RecB-dependent pathway in E . coli (17) .
However, a nick in DNA can result in a DSB even in the absence of
another nucleolytic activity . Single-strand interruptions could lead
to a collapse of the replication fork during DNA replication,
creating a DSB (20, 21) . In
Saccharomyces pombe a recombination event is induced during
mating-type switching when the replication fork encounters a
chromosomal imprint in one of the sister chromatids at the mat1
locus . Biochemical characterization suggests that the imprint is a
single-strand break (1) or an alkali-labile
modification (8) in the DNA . Interestingly,
Glassberg and coworkers (12) mapped an origin of replication
in gene 32, the gene downstream of the SPO1 DNA polymerase gene .
The incision by I-HmuI and I-HmuII on the coding strand would
interrupt the template for lagging-strand synthesis .
Regardless of the detailed mechanism of the initiation event,
intron homing occurred in host backgrounds with deficiencies in the
major recombination genes . In addition to genes involved in general
DNA metabolism, 14 B . subtilis recombination genes have been
characterized and classified into five epistatic groups, with recA
being the central player . Except in recA-deficient strains,
homologous recombination does not change more than fourfold relative
to the wild type when cells have single recombination functions
impaired (11) . Mutations in recA and double mutations
in recF addA (addAB is the E . coli recBC homolog),
recF recH, recO recH, recU recH, and recS recH
were shown to have drastic effects on homologous recombination . Using
these strains as hosts for coinfections of wild-type SPO1 and SPO1(sus14, I)
impaired neither intron homing nor general recombination between
phage genes . Though crosses in these strains indicate that the
respective Bacillus rec genes are not required for intron
homing, redundancy in the recombination machinery and the potential
presence of previously uncharacterized rec genes leave open
possible participation of Bacillus gene products in intron
homing .
On the other hand, the data favor the view that the genes involved
in intron homing and general recombination may be encoded by the
phages SPO1 and SP82 . In the case of phage T4, intron homing has been
shown to occur in the context of phage recombination-dependent DNA
replication, which requires a number of phage replication and
recombination functions . These include the strand transferase (UvsX),
single-strand DNA binding protein (gp32), DNA polymerase (gp43),
helicase (gp41), DNA ligase (gp30), and a putative exonuclease
complex (gp46/gp47) (6, 18,
25) . According to the model, the DSB is processed by exonucleases
producing a double-strand gap with single-stranded 3' tails for
strand invasion of the homologous intron-plus allele . Repair
synthesis using an intron-plus strand as a template results in intron
inheritance in which two processes have been implicated, the classic
DSB repair pathway and the synthesis-dependent strand annealing
pathway (24) .
Intron homing in SPO1 and SP82 presents an experimental system to
study the genes and processes involved in recombination of these
phages and would allow an interesting comparison between intron
homing in phages of gram-positive and that of gram-negative bacteria .
Perhaps such a comparison would offer insights into why group I
introns are seemingly more successful in phages infecting
gram-positive hosts, as suggested by their relative abundance in
these genomes (10) . Furthermore, DNA endonucleases
with nicking activity, like I-HmuI and I-HmuII, could provide a
useful tool to study the role of DNA single-strand breaks as
recombinogenic hot spots in bacterial and eukaryotic genomes .
We thank J . C . Alonso for providing bacterial strains and David
Edgell for critical reading of the manuscript .
This work was supported by a grant from the National Institutes of
Health (GM-37746) .
* Corresponding author . Mailing address: Department of
Biological Sciences and Center for Molecular Genetics, University at Albany,
State University of New York, Albany, NY 12222 . Phone: (518) 442-4324 . Fax:
(518) 442-4767 . E-mail: shub@albany.edu.
Laboratory of RNA Molecular Biology, The Rockefeller University, New
York, NY 10021 .
Whitehead Institute for Biomedical Research, Massachusetts Institute
of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02142 .
- Arcangioli, B. 1998 . A site– and strand-specific DNA
break confers asymmetric switching potential in fission yeast . EMBO J . 17:4503-4510 .
- Belfort, M., and P . S . Perlman. 1995 . Mechanisms of
intron mobility . J . Biol . Chem . 270:30237-30240.
- Belfort, M., and R . J . Roberts. 1997 . Homing
endonucleases: keeping the house in order . Nucleic Acids Res . 25:3379-3388 .
- Bell-Pedersen, D., S . M . Quirk, M . Aubrey, and M . Belfort.
1989 . A site-specific endonuclease and co-conversion of flanking exons
associated with the mobile td intron of phage T4 . Gene 82:119-126.
- Campbell, V . W., and D . A . Jackson. 1980 . The effect of
divalent cations on the mode of action of DNase I . The initial reaction
products produced from covalently closed circular DNA . J . Biol . Chem . 255:3726-3735 .
- Clyman, J., and M . Belfort. 1992 . Trans and cis
requirements for intron mobility in a prokaryotic system . Genes Dev . 6:1269-1279.
- Colleaux, L., L . d'Auriol, M . Betermier, G . Cottarel, A .
Jacquier, F . Galibert, and B . Dujon. 1986 . Universal code equivalent of a
yeast mitochondrial intron reading frame is expressed into E . coli as a
specific double strand endonuclease . Cell 44:521-533.
- Dalgaard, J . Z., and A . J . Klar. 1999 . Orientation of DNA
replication establishes mating-type switching pattern in S . pombe . Nature
400:181-184.
- Dujon, B. 1989 . Group I introns as mobile genetic
elements: facts and mechanistic speculations . Gene 82:91-113.
- Edgell, D . R., M . Belfort, and D . A . Shub. 2000 .
Barriers to intron promiscuity in bacteria . J . Bacteriol . 182:5281-5289.
- Fernández, S., S . Ayora, and J . C . Alonso. 2000 .
Bacillus subtilis homologous recombination: genes and products . Res .
Microbiol . 151:481-486.
- Glassberg, J., M . Franck, and C . R . Stewart. 1977 .
Multiple origins of replication for Bacillus subtilis phage SPO1 .
Virology 78:433-441.
- Goodrich-Blair, H., V . Scarlato, J . M . Gott, M . Q . Xu, and
D . A . Shub. 1990 . A self-splicing group I intron in the DNA polymerase
gene of Bacillus subtilis bacteriophage SPO1 . Cell 63:417-424.
- Goodrich-Blair, H., and D . A . Shub. 1996 . Beyond homing:
competition between intron endonucleases confers a selective advantage on
flanking genetic markers . Cell 84:211-221.
- Gorbalenya, A . E. 1994 . Self-splicing group I and group
II introns encode homologous (putative) DNA endonucleases of a new family .
Protein Sci . 3:1117-1120 .
- Greenstein, D., and K . Horiuchi. 1989 . Double-strand
cleavage and strand joining by the replication initiator protein of
filamentous phage f1 . J . Biol . Chem . 264:12627-12632 .
- Heitman, J., T . Ivanenko, and A . Kiss. 1999 . DNA nicks
inflicted by restriction endonucleases are repaired by a RecA- and
RecB-dependent pathway in Escherichia coli . Mol . Microbiol . 33:1141-1151.
- Huang, Y . J., M . M . Parker, and M . Belfort. 1999 . Role
of exonucleolytic degradation in group I intron homing in phage T4 . Genetics
153:1501-1512 .
- Jacquier, A., and B . Dujon. 1985 . An intron-encoded
protein is active in a gene conversion process that spreads an intron into a
mitochondrial gene . Cell 41:383-394.
- Kuzminov, A. 1995 . Collapse and repair of replication
forks in Escherichia coli . Mol . Microbiol . 16:373-384.
- Kuzminov, A. 2001 . Single-strand interruptions in
replicating chromosomes cause double-strand breaks . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA
98:8241-8246 .
- Landthaler, M., U . Begley, N . C . Lau, and D . A . Shub.
2002 . Two self-splicing group I introns in the ribonucleotide reductase large
subunit gene of Staphylococcus aureus phage Twort . Nucleic Acids Res.
30:1935-1943 .
- Melgar, E., and D . A . Goldthwait. 1968 . Deoxyribonucleic
acid nucleases . II . The effects of metals on the mechanism of action of
deoxyribonuclease I . J . Biol . Chem . 243:4409-4416 .
- Mueller, J . E., J . Clyman, Y.-J . Huang, M . M . Parker, and M .
Belfort. 1996 . Intron mobility in phage T4 occurs in the context of
recombination-dependent DNA replication by way of multiple pathways . Genes
Dev . 10:351-364.
- Mueller, J . E., D . Smith, and M . Belfort. 1996 . Exon
coconversion biases accompanying intron homing: battle of the nucleases . Genes
Dev . 10:2158-2166.
- Muscarella, D . E., and V . M . Vogt. 1989 . A mobile group
I intron in the nuclear rDNA of Physarum polycephalum . Cell 56:443-454.
- Okubo, S., T . Yanagida, D . J . Fujita, and B . M .
Olsson-Wilhelm. 1972 . The genetics of bacteriophage SPO1 . Biken J . 15:81-97.
- Remacle, C., and R . F . Matagne. 1993 . Transmission,
recombination and conversion of mitochondrial markers in relation to the
mobility of a group I intron in Chlamydomonas . Curr . Genet . 23:518-525.
- Sayre, M . H., and E . P . Geiduschek. 1988 . TF1, the
bacteriophage SPO1-encoded type II DNA-binding protein, is essential for viral
multiplication . J . Virol . 62:3455-3462.
- Stewart, C . R. 1988 . Bacteriophage SPO1, p . 477-515 .
In R . Calendar (ed.), The bacteriophages, vol . I . Plenum Press, New York,
N.Y.
- Stewart, C . R., and M . Franck. 1981 . Predominance of
bacteriophage SP82 over bacteriophage SPO1 in mixed infections of Bacillus
subtilis . J . Virol . 38:1081-1083.
- Strathern, J . N., K . G . Weinstock, D . R . Higgins, and C . B .
McGill. 1991 . A novel recombinator in yeast based on gene II protein from
bacteriophage f1 . Genetics 127:61-73 .
- Szostak, J . W., T . L . Orr-Weaver, R . J . Rothstein, and F . W .
Stahl. 1983 . The double-strand-break repair model for recombination . Cell
33:25-35.
- Yang, J., S . Zimmerly, P . S . Perlman, and A . M . Lambowitz.
1996 . Efficient integration of an intron RNA into double-stranded DNA by
reverse splicing . Nature 381:332-335.
- Zinn, A . R., and R . A . Butow. 1985 . Nonreciprocal
exchange between alleles of the yeast mitochondrial 21S rRNA gene: kinetics
and the involvement of a double-strand break . Cell 40:887-895.
Free Online Full-text Article
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
|