|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, September 2004, p . 6186-6197, Vol .
186, No . 18
New
Protein-Protein Interactions Identified for the Regulatory and Structural
Components and Substrates of the Type III Secretion System of the Phytopathogen
Xanthomonas axonopodis Pathovar citri
Marcos C . Alegria,1 Cassia Docena,1 Leticia
Khater,2,3 Carlos H . I . Ramos,2,3 Ana C . R . da Silva,1
and Chuck S . Farah1*
Departamento de Bioquímica, Instituto de Química, Universidade de São Paulo,
São Paulo,1 Centro de Biologia Molecular Estrutural, Laboratório
Nacional de Luz Síncrotron,2 Departamento de Bioquímica, Instituto de
Biologia, Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Campinas, Brazil3
Received 12 March 2004/ Accepted 11 June 2004
We have initiated a project to identify protein-protein interactions
involved in the pathogenicity of the bacterial plant pathogen
Xanthomonas axonopodis pv . citri . Using a yeast two-hybrid system
based on Gal4 DNA-binding and activation domains, we have focusedon
identifying interactions involving subunits, regulators,and
substrates of the type III secretion system coded by thehrp
[for hypersensitive response and pathogenicity], hrc [for
hrp conserved], and hpa [for hrp associated] genes . We have
identified several previously uncharacterized interactions involving
[i] HrpG, a two-component system response regulator responsible
for the expression of X . axonopodis pv . citri hrp operons, and
XAC0095, a previously uncharacterized protein encountered only
in Xanthomonas spp.; [ii] HpaA, a protein secreted by the type
III secretion system, HpaB, and the C-terminal domain of HrcV;[iii]
HrpB1, HrpD6, and HrpW; and [iv] HrpB2 and HrcU . Homotropic
interactions were also identified for the ATPase HrcN . Thesenewly
identified protein-protein interactions increase our understandingof
the functional integration of phytopathogen-specific typeIII
secretion system components and suggest new hypotheses regardingthe
molecular mechanisms underlying Xanthomonas pathogenicity.
A number of species of gram-negative bacteria are able to infectand
cause disease in, or establish symbiotic relationships with,specific
plant hosts [2] . These phytopathogenic bacteria use
a full barrage of molecular strategies by which to enter andcolonize
host tissues . This invasion eventually modifies, andin many cases
compromises, plant homeostasis at the tissue levelor at the level of
the entire plant . Biochemical, genetic, andcellular studies of
phytopathogenic bacteria have revealed thatthese mechanisms involve
a variety of factors such as adhesins,pili, bacterial signaling
factors, receptors of external andplant-derived factors, proteins
involved in signal transduction,specialized transcription factors,
alternate sigma factors,and proteins which generate, assemble, and
regulate specificmacromolecular secretion systems that transport
bacterial macromolecularpathogenicity factors [1,
2, 8, 15,
25, 32, 53, 67] .
Only afew of these processes are understood fully at the molecular
level and, in the few cases where they have been elucidatedfor
more than one system, significant differences have beenobserved [32,
39]—differences that must eventually beattributed
to the specific biologies of the interacting bacterium-plantpair.
During the infective process, a large variety of pathogenic
gram-negative bacteria inject macromolecular pathogenic factorsinto
their animal or plant host cells . Bacteria may use oneof two systems
to accomplish this: the type III [6, 12,
20,25, 26,
32, 46] and type IV [3,
10, 11, 14,
18, 19, 60,
65,69] secretion systems .
Recently, the genomes of a number ofbacterial phytopathogens have
been sequenced, including Xylellaspp . [52,
58], Ralstonia solanacearum [49],
Xanthomonas spp.[21], Agrobacterium
tumefaciens [66], and Pseudomonas syringae
[9] . These sequences have revealed the existence of
severalgene clusters that code for putative macromolecule secretion
systems that are demonstrably or possibly involved in pathogenesis.
The type III secretion system [TTSS] is coded for by a groupof
ca . 25 genes, most of which are localized to a single chromosomal
locus [hrp] . A subgroup of products encoded by these genes consists
of homologues of the core flagellar secretory components, which
has led to the conclusion that the TTSS and flagellar machinesare
evolutionarily related [6, 42,
57] . In contrast, the typeIV secretion systems
[TFSS] responsible for secreting pathogenicityfactors are related to
the machines responsible for transferof nucleic acid-protein
complexes during bacterial conjugation[19].
We identify here new protein-protein interactions involving
components, substrates, and regulators of the TTSS of the phytopathogen
Xanthomonas axonopodis pv . citri, the causal agent of citrus
canker . In the plant pathogens Xanthomonas, Ralstonia,
Erwinia,and Pseudomonas spp., a subset of hrp
genes are induced uponcontact with the plant in response to a
variety of diffusibleor nondiffusible plant-derived factors [8,
25, 32, 51] . Beyond
their requirement for pathogenicity, the mechanisms of action
of most of the components of this secretion machine are notwell
understood at the molecular level . This is especially truefor
phytopathogen-specific components with no homologs in animalTTSS or
in flagella . Interactions among some components of TTSSfrom several
bacterial pathogens have been elucidated, and inmany cases these
interactions have revealed possible functionalroles of specific
components [34] . However, the fact that severalof
the gene products of these clusters are only distantly related,if at
all, to other proteins of known function places limitson the
homology-based approach for deduction of function . Thislimitation is
further highlighted by the fact that the X . axonopodispv .
citri hrp cluster [Fig . 1] possesses open reading
frames[ORFs] that code for previously uncharacterized proteins, in
several cases specific to xanthomonads and in some cases specific
to X . axonopodis pv . citri . To understand the specific mechanisms
by which X . axonopodis pv . citri uses its TTSS to interact with
and modify the metabolism of its host, it is of utmost importance
to delimit the protein-protein interactions involving X . axonopodis
pv . citri TTSS components and associated proteins . To this end,
we have used a yeast two-hybrid system [17] to perform
genome-scaleprotein-protein interaction screens by using specific
X . axonopodispv . citri hrp, hrc, and hpa
proteins as baits . Our results reveala number of previously
uncharacterized interactions involvingthese proteins that may be of
importance to the processes ofhrp gene expression and TTSS
function.
|
FIG . 1 . hrp locus of X . axonopodis pv . citri [21] .
Arrows:
,
hrp [for hypersensitive response and pathogenicity] genes;
,
hrc [for hrp conserved] genes;
,
hpa [for hrp-associated] genes;
,
genes coding for hypothetical proteins.
|
|
X . axonopodis pv . citri [strain 306] genomic DNA library.
X . axonopodis pv . citri strain 306 genomic DNA was nebulized
under nitrogen, repaired, and size separated in agarose gels.
Fragments of 500 to 1,500 bp and 1,500 to 3,000 bp were purifiedand
cloned into the plasmid vector pOAD [56] previously
linearizedwith PvuII and dephosphorylated with calf intestine
alkalinephosphatase . Then, 1-µl aliquots of the ligation reactions
were used to transform competent Escherichia coli DH10B cells
by electroporation . Cells from each set of 10 transformations
were pooled and, after the addition of 1 volume of 50% glycerol,
stored at –70°C . Before freezing, 20-µl aliquotswere separated,
frozen at –70°C, thawed, and platedto determine the total number of
independent clones in thatpool, which varied from 2,000 to 20,000 .
Transformations wereperformed until each library [500 to 1,500 bp
and 1,500 to 3,000bp] contained >106 independent clones.
Transformants were thawed and pooled into groups containing
between 100,000 and 200,000 independent clones . These were diluted
into 16 2-liter flasks containing a total of ca . 10 liters of2xTY
medium supplemented with 200 µg of carbenicillin/ml.After growth at
37°C for 8 h, 10-ml aliquots were removedfrom each flask, combined,
diluted with 1 volume of 50% glycerol,and stored at –70°C . The rest
of the culture was incubatedat 37° until it reached an optical
density at 600 nm of1.2, at which point the cells were collection by
centrifugation,and the plasmid DNA was purified [50] .
HindIII digests of eachpreparation were analyzed by agarose gel
electrophoresis . DNAconcentrations were determined, and preparations
from all ofthe libraries were pooled in amounts proportional to the
numberof independent clones per unit mass of DNA . This pOAD-library
mixture was used to transform yeast cells in two-hybrid screens.
Cloning of baits for two-hybrid screens. X . axonopodis
pv . citri DNA sequences coding proteins for useas baits were
amplified by PCR by using X . axonopodis pv . citrigenomic DNA
and primers designed based on the X . axonopodispv . citri
genome sequence [21] . The primers also contained unique
restriction sites [usually NcoI and XhoI] to facilitate cloning
into the NcoI and SalI sites of the pOBD vector [56]
downstreamof and in frame with the Gal4 DNA-binding domain . After
transformationinto DH10B E . coli cells, individual colonies
were picked forplasmid isolation and confirmation by DNA sequencing .
Most baitscorresponded to the full-length proteins as annotated in
theX . axonopodis pv . citri genome sequence [21] .
In some cases,analysis of the protein sequence by using the PSORT
algorithm[43] indicated the presence of domains
containing one or moreputative transmembrane helices and protein
fragments lackingthe transmembrane helices were used . These cases
are describedin the text and in Table 1 . In the
case of XAC0095, the baitused contained a 12-amino-acid N-terminal
extension encodedby the 36 nucleotides upstream of the annotated
start codon.This 85-amino-acid bait is therefore coded for by
nucleotides111185 to 111442 of the X . axonopodis pv . citri
chromosome.
| TABLE 1 . Summary of protein-protein interactions involving X TTSS
components observed in this studya
|
|
Growth of yeast strains and transformation. Saccharomyces
cerevisae strain PJ694-a [MATa trp1-901 leu2-3
112 ura3-52 his3-200 gal4
gal80
LYS2::GAL1-HIS3 GAL2-ADE2 met2::GAL7-lacZ][35]
was grown at 30°C in YAPD medium [1% yeast extract,2% peptone, 2%
glucose, 0.008% adenine] or in SC medium [0.66%nitrogen base
[without amino acids], 2% glucose, 0.008% adenine,0.8% amino acid
mixture adjusted to pH 5.6] as described previously[45] .
Where indicated, SC medium was prepared lacking one ormore specific
components: adenine [–Ade], histidine [–His],tryptophan [–Trp], and
leucine [–Leu] . In the caseof growth on solid media, 1.6% Bacto Agar
and 3-aminotriazole[3AT] [see below] was added . Rapid
transformations with pOBD-baitplasmids were carried out by using the
PEG3350-lithium acetateprotocol described by Gietz et al . [28]
and selected on SC–Trpplates at 30°C for 2 to 4 days . These cells
were then usedin high-efficiency transformations with the
pOAD-library using30 µg of plasmid DNA and the 30x
scale-up procedure describedby Gietz and Woods [27],
which resulted in, on average, 0.5x
107 to 1 x 107
transformants on SC–Trp–Leu plates.
Tests for autoactivation and false-positive results. To
determine the amount of 3AT to be used for each bait, ca.1,000 yeast
cells transformed with the pOBD-bait plasmid wereplated on
SC–Trp–His medium containing 0, 1, 5,10, 25, or 50 mM 3AT and
incubated for 5 days at 30°C . Similarly,the small number of baits
that autoactivate the GAL2-ADE2 reporterwere identified by
growth on SC–Trp–Ade plates.The pOAD-library was shown to lack any
clones that autoactivatethe His or Ade gene reporters on their own
or simultaneously.On the other hand, when transformed into PJ694-a
cells previouslytransformed with the pOBD vector [lacking a bait
insert], ca.1,000 colonies were found to grow in the presence of up
to 3mM 3AT . Sequencing of the preys in 66 of these colonies
subsequentlyshowed them to be derived from only a few specific X .
axonopodispv . citri genes [see Results].
Yeast two-hybrid assays and DNA sequencing. After
transformation with the pOAD-library, cells were resuspendedin 5 ml
of sterile water and spread on 10 plates with SC–Trp–Leu–His–Adeplus
3AT [150 by 15 mm] . The amount of 3AT used varied between5 and 50
mM, depending on the bait: 5 mM for all baits exceptfor HpaA [10 mM]
and HrcN [50 mM] . Plates were incubated at30°C for up to 14 days .
Colonies that grew in the absenceof His and Ade were transferred to
fresh plates with SC–Trp–Leu–His–Adeplus 3AT . Plasmid DNA was
isolated from yeast colonies thatwere able to grow under the
selection of both reporters by usinga method [50]
scaled up and modified for execution in 96-wellplates . Purified
plasmid DNA mixtures were used to transformDH10B E . coli
cells . After overnight growth at 37°C, plasmidDNA [a mixture of
pOAD- and pOBD-derived vectors] was purified.The prey or bait DNA
sequences were sequenced by using pOAD-or pOBD-specific primers,
respectively . Sequences were analyzedby comparison with the X .
axonopodis pv . citri genome database[21].
X . axonopodis pv . citri two-hybrid library construction.
We constructed a X . axonopodis pv . citri total genomic DNA library
[X . axonopodis pv . citri chromosome plus plasmids] containing
fragments of 500 to 3,000 bp cloned into the PvuII site of the
vector pOAD [56] . The quality of the library was tested in a
number of independent ways . [i] HindIII digests of the sublibraries
after amplification but before pooling revealed a broad population
of inserts of the expected sizes [500 to 1,500 bp or 1,500 to
3,000 bp] . [ii] Initial sequencing of ca . 1,000 independentlychosen
clones did not reveal any obvious bias in the libraryand that, of
the 3.0 million independent clones in the combinedlibrary, 78% [2.35
million] contained X . axonopodis pv . citrigenomic DNA
inserts . In the final pooled library, fragmentsin the size ranges of
500 to 1,500 bp and 1,500 to 3,000 bpwere present in about equal
proportions [1.2 and 1.15 million,respectively] . If we assume a
random distribution of fragmentationsites in the genome, the library
contains fragments initiatingevery 2.2 bp or every 13 bp in a
correct reading frame . Althoughsome in-frame clones code for
full-length proteins with N-terminalextensions, most fragments code
a protein with an N-terminaldeletion . [iii] Subsequent analysis of
two-hybrid results revealedthat, except for some special cases due
to yeast-based recombinationevents [see below], clones of preys
derived from a specificgene initiated at many unique sites within
that gene . [iv] TheX . axonopodis pv . citri genomic library in
pOAD does not containany clones that on their own activate the
HIS3 and ADE2 reportergenes individually . However, in the
presence of the empty pOBDvector, some library clones did lead to
activation . In an experimentof a total of 2
x 107 transformations, ca . 1,000
colonies wereobserved to grow on plates with SC–Trp–Leu–His–Ade
plus 3AT . Sequencing of the pOAD-derived vector from 62 of these
colonies revealed that all contained DNA inserts derived from
only a small number of X . axonopodis pv . citri genes: 89% of
the preys coded for fragments of the TolC protein, 6.5% of thepreys
coded for fragments of the RibA protein, and single cloneswere found
that were derived from the phoQ, glnA, and piuB genes.
TolC-derived fragments seem to be promiscuous interactors in
two-hybrid assays and should be considered false positives,as shown
below . RibA preys have thus far only been detectedwhen empty pOBD is
used as bait.
Identification of false positives. In using this X .
axonopodis pv . citri genomic DNA library, weidentified two
classes of prey that we consider to be falsepositives . One class is
composed of specific preys that appearto interact with a great
number of apparently unrelated baitswith a frequency that does not
appear to be of physiologicalrelevance, at least in the context of
the physiological roleof the baits . Of more than 100 baits tested
thus far with thislibrary [data not shown],
40%
interacted with at least one preyderived from the TolC protein and,
for several baits, the majorfraction of interactors was derived from
TolC . Due to the ubiquityof these sequences in the two-hybrid
screens, these sequenceswere considered to be false positives and
therefore disregarded.TolC tends to interact with the Gal4
DNA-binding domain [seeabove], and this tendency may be inhibited or
enhanced by baitfusions . In addition to TolC, several other proteins
were detectedas preys at a frequency to warrant suspicion of their
physiologicalsignificance . These proteins included [i] members of
the largeTonB-dependent receptor family, [ii] products of the two
wapAgenes [XAC1866 and XAC1305], [iii] the XAC3515 protein, and
[iv] the plasmid-encoded PthA and KfrA proteins . For this reason,
these preys were also considered to be false positives and are
not considered further.
The majority of baits interacted with a large number of preys,
most of which were derived from a small number of X . axonopodis
pv . citri proteins [Table 1] . In the case of some baits,
however[for example, HrpF, Hpa2, and the N-terminal fragment of
HpaB],no clear preference for any specific X . axonopodis pv .
citriprotein was observed, and almost all of the preys sequenced
were derived from a different protein [data not shown] . The
apparent lack of specificity of these baits suggests that the
majority of their preys do not reflect physiologically relevant
interactions . In such a case, even if a small number of thepreys of
such a bait do in fact represent a true interactor,this fact is not
immediately apparent from these data aloneand must be confirmed by
other experimental approaches.
Positive controls. Three proteins known to participate in
well-characterized protein-proteininteractions were initially used
as positive controls for thetwo-hybrid screen itself, as well as to
further test the qualityof the library . All three baits
tested—GroES, the
'
subunitof DNA polymerase III, and FtsZ—were found to interact
with previously identified interacting partners: GroES with
itself in 22 of 24 clones sequenced, the
'
subunit of DNA polymeraseIII [36] with the
product of the gene coding for the
and
subunitsof the polymerase in one of four clones sequenced, and FtsZ
[29] with itself in 11 of 13 preys sequenced [Table
1].
Prey-bait vector recombination events. Detailed sequencing
analysis of the Gal4 activation domain-preyjunction in the prey
vector could demonstrate that for somebaits, including FtsZ and
GroES controls, a fraction of thepreys were derived from
recombination events in which the baitgene was transferred into the
pOAD vector [3 of 11 for FtsZand 21 of 22 for GroES] . Recombination
is facilitated by thefact that pOBD and pOAD vectors [56]
have identical sequencesbefore [ 60
bp] and after [ 2,840
bp] their multiple cloning sites.To test whether these in vivo
recombinations necessitate a specificlibrary clone or could occur
even with the empty pOAD vector,we transformed PJ694-a cells with
both the empty pOAD plasmidand the pOBD-XAC0095 plasmid . XAC0095 is
an X . axonopodis pv.citri conserved hypothetical protein that
was observed to sufferthe same type of recombination event [see
below] . Of a totalof 5 x 106
transformants, 25 colonies were observed to growon plates with
SC–Trp–Leu–Hi–Ade plus3AT . Sequencing of the pOAD vector in 16 of
these clones revealedthat they all now contained the full-length
XACb0095 bait inthe specific site in which it was cloned in the pOBD
vector[distinct from the PvuII site in which the genomic DNA library
was cloned in pOAD] . Therefore, full-length copies of the bait
in both vectors can be obtained via recombination of the full-length
bait with, in principle, any library clone, including the emptypOAD
vector if the bait protein can interact with itself formingdimers or
higher-order complexes [as is in fact known to bethe case for FtsZ
and GroES] . This phenomenon was observed fora few other TTSS-related
proteins [see below].
Two-hybrid assays of proteins involved in the type III secretory
pathways. Two-hybrid assays were performed by using simultaneous
screeningof two reporter genes under the control of different
induciblepromoters [GAL1-HIS3 and GAL2-ADE2] . This
simultaneous screeningin combination with the high stringency of the
GAL2-ADE2 reportersignificantly reduced the number of false
positives [35] . Onlybaits that did not
simultaneously autoactivate these two reporterswere tested in
screens against the prey library . Table 1 liststhe
TTSS-related proteins analyzed and summarizes the resultsobtained in
two-hybrid assays in which they were used as baits.The table
presents the total number of positive interactionsin which each prey
was identified . False positives, as definedabove, are not indicated .
For some baits capable of homotropicinteractions, the number of
preys derived from recombinationof the bait gene into the pOAD
vector is indicated . In assaysnecessitating the simultaneous
activation of the GAL1-HIS3 andGAL2-ADE2 gene
reporters, interactions observed at least twotimes with preys
derived from the same X . axonopodis pv . citriprotein were
considered to be of potential significance, especiallyif the
physiological significance of the interaction was apparent.What
follows is a detailed description of these results andtheir
significance.
Interactions involving HrpG. HrpG is a DNA-binding
transcriptional regulatory protein thatfunctions at the top of the
hrp gene cluster regulatory cascade,controlling the
expression of the hrpA gene in X . campestrispv .
vesicatoria [hrcC in X . axonopodis pv . citri], as well as
the gene for the downstream transcription regulator HrpX [62,
63] . HrpX in turn activates expression of the hrpB-F
loci, aswell as of a number of Xanthomonas outer protein [xop]
genesin X . campestris pv . vesicatoria [61] .
The 263-residue HrpGprotein of X . axonopodis pv . citri, which
belongs to the OmpRfamily of two-component system response
regulators, containsan N-terminal response regulator receiver [RR]
domain and aC-terminal DNA-binding motif [62] .
Although the means by whichthe Xanthomonas HrpG protein is
regulated remains unknown, itshomolog in R . solanacearum has
been shown to be regulated bya cell-contact signal transduction
cascade involving PrhA [aprobable receptor for insoluble host
factors], PrhR [a transmembraneprotein that receives the signal from
PrhA], PrhI [an ECF sigmafactor], and PrhJ [a LuxR/UhpA family
transcription regulator][1, 7,
8] . PrhA, -R, and -I are homologues of the FecA, -R,
and -I proteins, which interact in the signaling pathway that
controls genes involved in ferric citrate transport in E . coli
[22, 54] . In spite of this, no direct
protein-protein interactionsinvolving HrpG in Xanthomonas or
Ralstonia spp . have as yetbeen identified . Furthermore, no
candidate two-component systemhistidine kinase has been identified
which could in principleregulate HrpG via phosphorylation of its RR
domain.
When the full-length HrpG protein was used as bait, all preyswere
derived from one of four proteins [Table 1 and Fig.
2].Just over half of the preys [48 of 90] were
derived from identicalclones that code for the full-length HrpG
protein . Sequencinganalysis of the sequence coding for the junction
between theGal4 activation domain and the HrpG coding sequence
demonstratedthat all of these clones were derived from recombination
eventsbetween the pOBD-HrpG bait plasmid and pOAD in which the
full-lengthHrpG gene plus 25 nucleotides of the pOBD polylinker was
transferredto the pOAD vector . HrpG-HrpG interactions have not been
observedbefore . However, OmpR family proteins are known to bind to
DNAas dimers, although dimerization has not been observed in
solution[31, 37].
|
FIG . 2 . Summary of interactions observed in yeast two-hybrid assays
involving HrpG, XAC0095, XAC0524, HrcU, HrpD6, HrpB2, and HrpB1 . [A]
Preys derived from HrpG that interacted with baits derived from HrpG and
XAC0095; [B] preys derived from XAC0095 that interacted with baits
derived from XAC0095 and HrpG [the XAC0095 bait used had a 12-amino-acid
N terminus extension as described in the text]; [C] preys derived from
XAC0524 that interacted with the XAC0095 bait; [D] preys derived from
HrcU that interacted with the bait derived from HrpB2; [E] preys derived
from HrpD6 that interacted with the HrpB1 bait . Shaded trapezoids or
rectangles indicate the maximum and minimum fragments within the set of
preys that interacted with a specific bait . Numbers to the left of the
trapezoid indicate the maximum and minimum positions of the N-terminal
boundaries of the preys . The specific bait used is indicated within the
trapezoid . Also indicated is the number of clones sequenced derived from
that particular prey . The full-length prey is represented as a solid
black line above.
|
|
The second largest set of preys [36 of 90] obtained using HrpGas
bait were derived from the hypothetical protein [XAC0095],whose only
known homologs are coded by three ORFs in the X.campestris
pv . campestris genome [Fig . 3] [21] .
XAC0095 is a73-residue protein [Fig . 3], and all
of these clones coded forat least residues 4 to 73 [Fig.
2B] . The HrpG-XAC0095 interactionwas confirmed
when we used the XAC0095 protein with a 12-residueN-terminal
extension as bait: 3 of 71 prey clones coded fora fragment of either
the full-length HrpG protein or a nearfull-length fragment
beginning at amino acid residue 6 [Fig.2A] . Two
factors may contribute to the relatively low fractionof preys
mapping to HrpG: [i] the HrpG RR domain is locatedin the N-terminal
portion of the protein [residues 11 to 130]and may be required for
interaction with XAC0095, and [ii] thepresence of an in-frame stop
codon immediately upstream fromthe start codon [TAAATG] eliminates
all clones containing insertsthat begin upstream from the start
codon . If HrpG-HrpG interactionsare also mediated through N-terminal
domain contacts, this secondfactor could also explain the
predominance of recombination-derivedfull-length HrpG preys when
HrpG is used as bait [above].
|
FIG . 3 . Primary structure alignment of XAC0095 with its homologs in
X . axonopodis pv . citri [XAC0095b and XAC0095c] and in X .
campestris pv . campestris [XCC0067, XCC1070, and XCC2900] . Amino
acid positions with identical [*], highly conserved [:], and
less-well-conserved [.] residues are indicated . Two blocks of
particularly well conserved residues are indicated by thin horizontal
lines . Both blocks contain conserved heptad pseudorepeats [abcdefg]
in which each a and d position is almost invariably a
hydrophobic residue . The two heptad repeats are delimited with thick
black horizontal lines . The C-terminal block has two hydrophobic heptad
repeats superimposed on one another.
|
|
Five HrpG preys were derived from XAC1568, a 157-residue conserved
hypothetical protein [Table 1] . All five preys began at either
residue 64 or 65, indicating that the C-terminal domain of XAC1568
mediates its interactions with HrpG . Interestingly, the N-terminal
domain contains several well-conserved cysteine residues found
in all homologs from a large number of bacteria, whereas the
C-terminal domain is present in only a much smaller group ofproteins
found in X . campestris pv . campestris, A . tumefaciens,
Mesorhizobium spp., Sinorhizobium spp., Caulobacter crescentus,
Bradyrhizobium japonicum, Rhodopseudomonas palustris,
Rhodospirillumrubrum, Rhodobacter sphaeroides, and P .
aeruginosa . None ofthese homologs, however, have known
functions.
Finally, HrpG was also found to interact with a single prey
derived from the XAC3683 gene that encodes a two-component system
composite sensor-histidine kinase/response regulator [Table
1] . This result is consistent with a probable interaction
betweenHrpG and a two-component system histidine kinase
phosphoacceptordomain . The domain structure of XAC3683 includes a
N-terminalPAS and PAC motifs frequently associated with signal
sensordomains [47], central histidine kinase and
phosphoacceptor domains,and a C-terminal RR receiver domain [44,
55] . The fragment ofXAC3683 detected as a
positive prey begins at residue 96 locatedjust before the first PAS
domain [residues 110 to 172] . Thisis the first time that HrpG has
been shown to interact witha specific sensor protein and opens up
the way to our understandingof the complete transmission pathway
from external effectorto hrp gene expression . Since only 1 of
90 HrpG preys was derivedfrom XAC3683, the significance of this
interaction will haveto be confirmed in other biochemical tests.
Since 40% of HrpG preys were derived from XAC0095, we decidedto
use this protein as a bait in two-hybrid screens againstthe X .
axonopodis pv . citri genomic prey library . The bait weused
contains a 12-amino-acid N-terminal extension [Fig . 2B].
The vast majority [62 of 72] of XAC0095 preys were mapped to
the XAC0095 gene [Table 1 and Fig . 2] . Of
these, all clonescoded for the whole XAC0095 ORF . Sequencing
analysis could demonstratethat all but one of these preys are
derived from recombinationevents in which the XAC0095 bait gene was
transferred into thepOAD vector [Table 1 and see
above] and that a single prey wasderived from the library . This
library-derived clone codes forthe full-length XAC0095 protein plus
a 23-residue N-terminusextension.
The XAC0095 bait also interacted with a single prey that iscoded
for by a previously unannotated ORF that has 45% identitywith
XAC0095 . This ORF, which we name XAC0095b, is located between
nucleotides 1331630 and 1331896 of the X . axonopodis pv . citri
chromosome and codes for an 88-amino-acid protein [Fig . 3],
residues 8 to 88 of which are coded by the XAC0095 prey . Interestingly,
further analysis of the X . axonopodis pv . citri genome sequence
allowed us to identify a third, also previously unidentified,
X . axonopodis pv . citri ORF [which we name XAC0095c] between
nucleotides 5030863 and 5031120 that codes for an 85-residuehomolog
with 35% identity with XAC0095 and 40% identity withXAC0095b [Fig.
3] . Thus, both X . axonopodis pv . citri and X.
campestris pv . campestris [see above] seem to have three XAC0095
homologs . An alignment of these three putative X . axonopodis
pv . citri proteins and their corresponding homologs in X . campestris
pv . campestris is shown in Fig . 3 . Some specific
features ofthe alignment are of interest . [i] There appear to be two
blocksof particularly well conserved residues: one 29-residue block
in the N-terminal half of the protein and one 23-residue block
in the C-terminal half [indicated by thin horizontal lines inFig.
3] . Within these two blocks, 19 residues are absolutely
conserved in all six homologs . [ii] Each N-terminal block is
flanked by proline residues on both sides . The C-terminal blocksin
all six proteins are also flanked by prolines on their N-terminal
sides, and three are flanked by prolines on their C-terminalsides as
well [Fig . 3] . These conserved prolines may correspond
to turns in specific structural features in these homologs.
[iii] All six homologs have a conserved cysteine residue intheir
C-terminal block . [iv] Both blocks contain conserved heptad
pseudo-repeats [abcdefg] in which each a and d position is
almostinvariably a hydrophobic residue [Fig . 3] .
In fact, the C-terminalblock has two hydrophobic heptad repeats
superimposed on oneanother [Fig . 3] . Such heptad
repeats mediate side-by-side hydrophobicinteractions between
amphipathic alpha-helices in coiled-coilproteins [41].
Finally, XAC0095 baits interacted with six preys derived fromthe
XAC0524 protein [Table 1 and Fig . 2C] . This
uncharacterized125-residue protein contains a helix-turn-helix
DNA-bindingdomain in its N-terminal [residues 8 to 60] that is found
ina number of transcription regulators, including the bacteriophage
repressor proteins Cro, C1, and C2 . The C-terminal half of the
protein, however, has only a few homologs in the public databases.Of
these, only the E . coli DicA protein [30% identity with XAC0524],
derived from a cryptic prophage, has been characterized [5].
The minimal XAC0524 domain observed to interact with XAC0095is
delimited by residues 63 to 125, the C-terminal half of theprotein
that follows the putative DNA-binding domain [Fig . 2C].
The function of the XAC0095 protein and its homologs is notknown
at the moment, but its interaction with HrpG and XAC0524strongly
suggest a role in the control of gene expression, particularlyhrp
gene expression . Since HrpG is a bifunctional protein withboth a
receiver/response regulator and DNA-binding domains,its interaction
with XAC0095 could serve to modulate its interactionswith downstream
factors associated with the hrpX and hrcC/hrpAgene
promoters, as observed in X . campestris pv . vesicatoria[62],
or with upstream effectors such as a two-component systemsensor or
histidine kinase domains . XAC0095 could stabilizeHrpG or stabilize
the phosphoryated or dephosphorylated stateof specific aspartic acid
residues in its RR receiver domain[Asp60 in X . axonopodis pv .
citri HrpG] . Phosphorylation ofRR receiver domain Asp residues is
known to modulate the functionsof neighboring effector domains in
two-component signal transductionpathways [44,
55].
HrpB2 interacts with a C-terminal domain of HrcU that is
proteolytically cleaved in HrcU homologs. HrpB2 is a substrate of the
type III secretion system: in X.campestris pv . vesicatoria,
it is secreted to the exterior ofthe bacterial cell and is necessary
for secretion of other proteinsvia the TTSS [48] .
HrpB2 homologs are found only in Xanthomonasspp . and R .
solanacearum and are essential for pathogenesisin X .
campestris pv . vesicatoria [48] . When HrpB2 was used as
bait in the two-hybrid assay, 4 of 10 clones sequenced were
found to map to HrcU, a conserved member of the TTSS superfamily
associated with the bacterial inner membrane [Table 1] . All
four clones code for HrcU fragments beginning between residues
222 and 256, and all terminate downstream of the terminationcodon
[Fig . 2D] . Interestingly, the HrcU paralog FlhB has been
shown to have a direct role [along with FliK] in the switch
that determines which substrates [hook versus filament subunits]are
secreted by the type III secretion systems responsible forflagellar
assembly [64] . Another HrcU paralog, YscU is necessary
for the secretion of Yersinia anti-host factors [Yops] [40].
Both FlhB and YscU undergo site-specific proteolytic cleavage
at a conserved Asn-Pro-Thr-His sequence, also found in X . axonopodis
pv . citri HrcU [residues 264 to 267] . In fact, three of fourof
the preys found to interact with HrpB2 map almost perfectlyto this
putative C-terminal cleavage fragment in HrcU [Fig.2D] .
In Yersinia, overexpression of a full-length uncleavableform
of YscU inhibits growth, whereas overexpression of theC-terminal
cleavage fragment results in increased Yop secretion[40] .
It is therefore intriguing that a HrcU fragment possiblyinvolved in
the control of type III secretion system substratespecificity
interacts physically with a known substrate [HrpB2]that, in turn, is
required for the secretion of other proteinsby this pathway [48] .
This direct physical interaction has notbeen demonstrated
previously.
Interactions between HrpB1, HrpD6, and HrpW. Preys obtained
when HrpB1 is used as bait mapped to a numberof different X .
axonopodis pv . citri proteins [Table 1 and data
not shown] . Of 29 sequenced preys, 10 were derived from theHrpD6
protein, also coded for by the hrp locus . Both HrpB1 andHrpD6
are small [130 and 80 residues, respectively] cytoplasmicproteins
whose homologs are essential for pathogenicity in X.campestris
pv . vesicatoria [48] . However, neither of the proteins
has homologs in the flagellar apparatus or in the TTSSs of animal
pathogens, and no functional analyses of these two proteinsare
available in the literature . In fact, HrpD6 homologs havebeen
identified thus far only in Xanthomonas spp., whereas HrpB1
homologs are only found in Xanthomonas spp., as well as in R.
solanacearum and Burkholderia pseudomallei . The smallest HrpD6
fragment found to interact with HrpB1 corresponded to residues
3 to 80 [Fig . 2E] . The interactions between these two
proteins,identified here for the first time, may indicate that they
acttogether in a common function . Unfortunately, when HrpD6 was
used as a bait in two-hybrid screens, all eight preys were derived
from the false-positive TolC protein [data not shown].
Two other HrpB1 preys were derived from clones coding for a
full-length X . axonopodis pv . citri HrpW protein [XAC2922] [Table
1] . In spite of its name, the X . axonopodis pv .
citri hrpW geneis not situated in the hrp locus .
However, in X . campestrispv . campestris, the hrpW gene
is located within the hrp locus,adjacent to the hpaB
gene [21] . In P . syringae and Erwinia amylovora,
the >41-kDa HrpW protein binds to pectate, and its TTSS-dependent
secretion can elicit the plant hypersensitive response [16,
38] . The harpin domain in HrpW of P . syringae
has seven glycine-richrepeats between residues 119 and 188 . However,
HrpW from X.axonopodis pv . citri [33 kDa] and X .
campestris pv . campestris[36 kDa], which share 46% identity and
59% similarity, do notpossess complete harpin domains and contain
fewer glycine-richrepeats . The pectate lyase domain in X .
axonopodis pv . citriand X . campestris pv . campestris HrpW
seem complete howeverand shows >30% identity with the corresponding
domain inthe Pseudomonas and Erwinia HrpW proteins, as
well as with pectatelyase of Bacillus spp . The interaction
between HrpB1, a cytosolicprotein, and HrpW, a homolog of known TTSS
substrates, may indicatethat HrpB1 [and perhaps HrpD6] are involved
in directing HrpWand other substrates to the TTSS apparatus [see
Fig . 5, below].Finally, we note that six of the
HrpB1 preys were derived froma protein [XAC2047, 407 amino acids]
with only very little identity[23% identity, 40% similarity] with a
putative polyhydroxyalkanoatesynthase subunit PhaE from
Ectothiorhodospira shaposhnikovii[unpublished, gi|11096253]
[Table 1 and see below].
|
FIG . 5 . Summary of the interactions observed in the present study and
their integration into a functional model of the Xanthomonas spp .
TTSS derived from the work from several laboratories [2,
6, 12, 13,
32, 33, 48] .
Proteins involved in interactions identified in the present study are
represented by shaded objects, whereas white objects represent proteins
not studied here . HpaA secretion may be mediated via interactions with
HpaB, which in turn interacts with the pore-forming component HrcV .
HrpB2 secretion may be mediated via interactions with the C-terminal
domain of HrcU . HrcU homologs in flagella and Yersinia TTSSs
suffer proteolysis in which the C-terminal domain is released . Specific
interactions between HrpB1, HrpD6, the pectate lysase harpin homolog
HrpW, and XAC2047 are shown . Also shown are interactions with between
HrpB4 and XAC2054, a two-component system sensor/histidine
kinase/response regulator . Note that XAC2047 and XAC2054 are near
neighbors on the X . axonopodis pv . citri chromosome . See the text
for details . Legend: A, HpaA; B, HpaB; B1, HrpB1; B2, HrpB2; B4, HrpB4;
B5, HrpB5; B7, HrpB7; D5, HrpD5; D6, HrpD6; E, HrpE; J, HrcJ; N, HrcN;
Q, HrcQ; R, HrcR; S, HrcS; T, HrcT; U, full-length HrcU; U*, C-terminal
proteolytic fragment of HrcU; V, HrcV; IM, inner membrane; OM, outer
membrane.
|
|
HrpB4. HrpB4 is a 209-residue protein highly conserved [>90%
identity]in Xanthomonas spp . Its only other known homolog is
the HrpHprotein of R . solanacearum . HrpB4 has been shown to
fractionatemostly to the soluble fraction of X . campestris
pv . vesicatorialysates [48], although primary
structure analysis has detectedputative transmembrane helices [13] .
When used as bait, HrpB4was found to interact six times [out of a
total of ten] withXAC2054 . XAC2054 is a two-component system
composite sensor/histidinekinase/response regulator . The domain
architecture of XAC2054includes multiple N-terminal PAS, PAC, and
GAF domains frequentlyassociated with signal sensors, central
histidine kinase, andphosphoacceptor domains and a C-terminal RR
receiver domain.The smallest HrpB4-interacting fragment begins at
residue 313of this 1,127-amino-acid protein . Interestingly, the
XAC2054gene is located 3.6 kb from the XAC2047 gene whose
product wasobserved to interact with HrpB1 [see above] . These
observationspoint to the involvement of HrpB4 and HrpB1 in
interactionsthat may be integrating the TTSS with other X .
axonopodis pv.citri proteins.
HrcN. HrcN is a conserved component of all type III
secretion systems,localized to the bacterial cytoplasm, and possibly
associatedwith inner membrane components of the TTSS [46] .
HrcN is highlysimilar to FliI, which is essential for bacterial
flagellarassembly [64] . HrcN is also similar to
InvC, Spa47 [MxiB], HrpB6,and YscN, all components of the type III
protein secretion systemsin Salmonella spp., Shigella
flexneri, X . campestris, and Yersinia,respectively
[6, 46] . All of these proteins are homologs
ofthe catalytic beta [and alpha] subunit of the F0F1-ATPase .
WhenHrcN is used as a bait, four of the six preys sequenced were
derived from the HrcN protein itself, the minimal prey fragment
corresponding to residues 30 to 442 . [Interestingly, in thiscase, no
preys were derived from recombination events from thebait plasmid.]
This may reflect a hexameric ring state for theHrcN protein in vivo
similar to the a3b3 ring structure in theF0F1-ATPase,
as proposed recently for the HrcN homolog Spa47in Shigella
sp . by Blocker et al . [6].
HpaA-HpaB-HrcV interactions. HpaA and HpaB are two proteins
coded by genes located withinthe Xanthomonas hrp locus [Fig.
1] . HpaA homologs are foundonly in Xanthomonas
spp . and R . solanacearum, and HpaA has beenshown to be
secreted by X . campestris pv . vesicatoria [33].
HpaA may function as an effector molecule in X . campestris pv.
vesicatoria as disruptions of the hpaA gene eliminate disease
symptoms in tomato and pepper plants without affecting the ability
to elicit hypersensitive response [33] . Furthermore,
the HpaAprimary sequence contains two nuclear localization signals,
one in the N-terminal and one in the C-terminal half of the
protein, and HpaA protein, transiently expressed in onion cells,has
been shown to localize to the nucleus [33] . Less is known
about the putative function of HpaB, except that it may be localized
to the bacterial inner membrane due to a single putative transmembrane
helix [43] . Tn3-gus insertion mutagenesis
of the hpaB gene ofX . axonopodis pv . glycines reduced
bacterial pathogenicity [39].HpaB homologs have
been found only in Xanthomonas spp., R . solanacearum,
and B . pseudomallei.
Both HpaA and HpaB were used as baits in two-hybrid screens.When
HpaA [271 amino acids] was used as a bait, 100% of the40 preys
sequenced were found to be HpaB [Table 1] . Interestingly,
all of these clones coded for polypeptides containing at least
all except the first six amino acids of HpaB, suggesting thatthe
HpaA-HpaB interaction requires an almost complete N-terminalregion
of the HpaB polypeptide chain [Fig . 4] . We also tested
two baits derived from the hpaB gene: one coding for the
full-lengthsequence of 156 residues and a second coding for residues
1to 92 . This N-terminal fragment was used since residues 92 to
108 are predicted to form a transmembrane helix by the PSORT
algorithm [43] . Each of the 16 preys sequenced when the HpaB
N-terminal fragment was used was derived from a different gene
in the X . axonopodis pv . citri genome . This result indicates
that this fragment, on its own, does not make specific interactions
with other peptides in the X . axonopodis pv . citri proteome.
On the other hand, the results obtained with the full-lengthHpaB
sequence were much more specific . Of 49 clones sequenced,37 were
derived from the hpaA gene [Fig . 4] . The smallest HpaA
fragment found to interact with HpaB corresponded to residues
126 to 271, the C-terminal half of the protein . Other than the
presence of one of the nuclear localization signals, no functional
information is available regarding this or any other regionof HpaA.
|
FIG . 4 . Summary of interactions observed in yeast two-hybrid assays
involving HpaA, HpaB, and HrcV . [A] Preys derived from HpaA that
interacted with the full-length HpaB bait; [B] preys derived from HpaB
that interacted with baits derived from full-length HpaA and from the
C-terminal domain of HrcV [residues 325 to 645]; [C] preys derived from
HrcV that interacted with baits derived from full-length HpaB and from
the C-terminal domain of HrcV [residues 325 to 645] . Shaded trapezoids
or rectangles indicate the maximum and minimum fragments within the set
of preys that interacted with a specific bait . Numbers to the left of
the trapezoid indicate the maximum and minimum positions of the
N-terminal boundaries of the preys . The specific bait used is indicated
within the trapezoid . Also indicated is the number of clones sequenced
derived from that particular prey . The full-length prey is represented
as a solid black line above.
|
|
The remaining 12 preys obtained when the full-length HpaB proteinwas
used as bait were derived from the HrcV protein, a componentof the
type-III secretion machinery . The minimal fragment ofHrcV found to
interact with full-length HpaB corresponded toresidues 360 to 645
[Fig . 4] . This observation is consistentwith the
prediction that the N-terminal domain of HrcV [up toresidue 316]
codes for at least six transmembrane segments [43],
whereas the C-terminal half of the protein forms a soluble cytosolic
domain . When the HrcV C-terminal domain [residues 325 to 646]
was used as a bait, 14 of 18 preys were derived from the HrcV
protein . All of these preys were derived from recombinationevents
with the bait vector; therefore, the minimal domain necessaryfor
this interaction could not be determined . Furthermore, oneprey was
derived from the full-length HpaB protein, confirmingthe HpaB-HrcV
interaction observed when HpaB was used as bait.A summary of the
interactions observed between HpaA, HpaB, andHrcV is shown in Fig.
4 . Since HrcV [and possibly HpaB] is localizedto
the inner membrane, whereas HpaA is a soluble protein withdomains
indicative of activity in the host cell nucleus [seeabove], a
functional role for these interactions becomes immediatelyapparent:
HpaA, HpaB, and the C-terminal cytosolic domain ofHrcV may interact
in a manner that results in the targetingof HpaA to the type III
secretion machinery and its subsequenttranslocation into the host
cell [Fig . 5] . The above resultsseem to point to
HpaB possibly functioning as a chaperone orprotein usher for HpaA,
perhaps facilitating its interactionwith HrcV at the cytoplasmic
entrance of the TTSS channel [Fig.5].
Concluding remarks. The yeast two-hybrid system has been
used to identify protein-proteininteractions in protein complexes
such as the yeast pheromone-responsepathway complex [23]
and yeast RNA polymerase III [24] and between
Drosophila cyclin-dependent protein kinase interactors and cyclin-dependent
kinases involved in cell cycle regulation [30] . It has
alsobeen used to elucidate an interaction map of proteins involved
in Caenorhabditis elegans vulval development [59],
to screenan oligopeptide expression library [68],
and to identify protein-proteininteractions on the proteome-scale [4,
56] . Ward et al . [60]recently
used this methodology to delimit interactions betweencomponents of
the type IV secretion system of A . tumefaciens.The two-hybrid
system has only been used in one other studyto investigate
interactions between TTSS components in Yersiniapestis [34],
responsible for the export of 12 Yersinia outerproteins . In
that study, specific interactions were observedfor YscQ with YscK
and YscL and for YscL with YscQ and YscN.Those authors suggested
that YscKQLN may form a complex peripherallyassociated with the
inner membrane in a manner similar to theF1 and V1
multiprotein complexes of the F0F1 and V0V1
proton-translocatingATPases . YscQ and YscN are homologs of X .
axonopodis pv . citriproteins HrcQ and HrcN, whereas YscK and
YscL have no X . axonopodispv . citri homologs . The interactors
and interactions observedin the Yersinia study [34]
were therefore different from thoseobserved in the present study.
In the present study, we have identified a number of potentially
physiologically relevant interactions between subunits, regulators,
and substrates of the X . axonopodis pv . citri type III secretion
system . We have identified interactions involving proteins previously
known or suspected to be involved in X . axonopodis pv . citri
pathogenicity, including HrpG, HpaA, HpaB, HrcV, HrpB1, HrpD6,
HrpB2, HrcU, HrpW, HrpB4, and HrcN . The fact that our prey library
consists of whole genomic X . axonopodis pv . citri DNA significantly
increased the possibility of observing so-called "false-positive"
interactions . In spite of this, relatively few and in many cases
easily identifiable false-positives were observed, and it is
highly significant that the majority of the interactions observedin
these assays "make sense" physiologically . In fact, the multiple
interactions observed between known Hrp proteins when a wholegenomic
DNA prey library was used is a strong confirmation ofthe
physiological relevance of these interactions . A similarhigh degree
of internal consistency has been observed by usin two-hybrid assays
in which the baits were derived from X.axonopodis pv . citri
type IV secretion system components [M.C . Alegria et al.,
unpublished data].
The protein-protein interactions identified here have clear
implications for our understanding of the molecular mechanisms
underlying Xanthomonas pathogenicity in general and the workings
and regulation of the TTSS in particular . Figure 5
presentsa summary of the interactions observed in the present study
and their integration into a functional model of the Xanthomonas
spp . TTSS that has emerged from the important contributionsof
many other laboratories . What is particularly interestingis that we
now have subsets of protein-protein interactionsthat point to a
relationship between specific TTSS substrates[HpaA and HrpB2] and
specific conserved components of the TTSSmachinery [HrcV and HrcU,
respectively] . In the case of HpaAand HrcV, their association
appears to be mediated via HpaB.These results point to more specific
studies that should becarried out in the near future, including
investigations into[i] the molecular interactions important for HpaA
secretion,including those involving HpaB and HrcV; [ii] the possible
occurrenceand role of HrcU proteolytic cleavage in TTSS assembly and
regulationof TTSS substrate specificity, in particular the secretion
ofHrpB2; and [iii] specific interactions between HrpB1, HrpD6,
and the pectate lysase harpin homolog HrpW and the possibility
of their functional integration with HrpB4 and the conserved
hypothetical proteins XAC2047 and XAC2054 . Finally, of special
interest for future studies are the specific molecular interactions
between HrpG and its upstream and downstream regulators, including
members of the newly identified XAC0095 family of proteins,
transcription factors, and two-component system sensor histidine
kinases.
We are deeply grateful for the excellent technical assistanceof
Izaura Nabuko Toma, Ilda de Souza Costa, and Elizabeth S.N.Mandetta .
We thank Stanley Fields for kindly providing the pOBDand pOAD
plasmids . We also thank Phillip James for kindly providingthe
PJ694-a yeast cells.
This study was supported by the Fundação de Amparoà Pesquisa do
Estado de São Paulo [FAPESP] andthe Conselho Nacional de Pesquisa of
Brazil . M.C.A., C.D., andL.K . are graduate fellows of FAPESP.
* Corresponding author . Mailing address: Departamento de
Bioquímica, Instituto de Química, Universidade de São Paulo, Av . Prof . Lineu
Prestes, 748, CEP 05599-970 São Paulo-SP, Brazil . Phone: 55-11-3091-3312 . Fax:
55-11-3815-5579 . E-mail: chsfarah@iq.usp.br.
- Aldon, D., B . Brito, C . Boucher, and S . Genin. 2000 . A
bacterial sensor of plant cell contact controls the transcriptional induction
of Ralstonia solanacearum pathogenicity genes . EMBO J . 19:2304-2314 .
- Alfano, J . R., and A . Collmer. 2001 . Mechanisms of
bacterial pathogenesis in plants: familiar foes in a foreign kingdom, p .
179-226 . In E . A . Groisman [ed.], Principles of bacterial pathogenesis .
Academic Press, Inc., New York, N.Y.
- Baron, C., D . O'Callaghan, and E . Lanka. 2002 . Bacterial
secrets of secretion: EuroConference on the biology of type IV secretion
processes . Mol . Microbiol . 43:1359-1365.
- Bartel, P . L., J . A . Roecklein, D . SenGupta, and S . Fields.
1996 . A protein linkage map of Escherichia coli bacteriophage T7 . Nat .
Genet . 12:72-77.
- Bejar, S., K . Cam, and J . P . Bouche. 1986 . Control of
cell division in Escherichia coli: DNA sequence of dicA and of a
second gene complementing mutation dicA1, dicC . Nucleic Acids
Res . 14:6821-6833.
- Blocker, A., K . Komoriya, and S . Aizawa. 2003 . Type III
secretion systems and bacterial flagella: insights into their function from
structural similarities . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 100:3027-3030 .
- Brito, B., M . Marenda, P . Barberis, C . Boucher, and S . Genin.
1999 . prhJ and hrpG, two new components of the plant
signal-dependent regulatory cascade controlled by PrhA in Ralstonia
solanacearum . Mol . Microbiol . 31:237-251.
- Brito, B., D . Aldon, P . Barberis, C . Boucher, and S . Genin.
2002 . A signal transfer system through three compartments transduces the plant
cell contact-dependent signal controlling Ralstonia solanacearum hrp
genes . Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 15:109-119.
- Buell, C . R., V . Joardar, M . Lindeberg, J . Selengut, I . T .
Paulsen, M . L . Gwinn, R . J . Dodson, R . T . Deboy, A . S . Durkin, J . F . Kolonay,
R . Madupu, S . Daugherty, L . Brinkac, M . J . Beanan, D . H . Haft, W . C . Nelson,
T . Davidsen, N . Zafar, L . Zhou, J . Liu, Q . Yuan, H . Khouri, N . Fedorova, B .
Tran, D . Russell, K . Berry, T . Utterback, S . E . Van Aken, T . V . Feldblyum, M .
D'Ascenzo, W . L . Deng, A . R . Ramos, J . R . Alfano, S . Cartinhour, A . K .
Chatterjee, T . P . Delaney, S . G . Lazarowitz, G . B . Martin, D . J . Schneider, X .
Tang, C . L . Bender, O . White, C . M . Fraser, and A . Collmer. 2003 . The
complete genome sequence of the Arabidopsis and tomato pathogen
Pseudomonas syringae pv . tomato DC3000 . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 100:10181-10186 .
- Burns, D . L. 1999 . Biochemistry of type IV secretion .
Curr . Opin . Microbiol . 2:25-29.
- Burns, D . L. 2003 . Type IV transporters of pathogenic
bacteria . Curr . Opin . Microbiol . 6:29-34.
- Büttner, D., and U . Bonas. 2002 . Getting
across-bacterial type III effector proteins on their way to the plant cell .
EMBO J . 21:5313-5322 .
- Büttner, D., and U . Bonas. 2002 . Port of entry: the type
III secretion translocon . Trends Microbiol . 10:186-192.
- Cascales, E., and P . J . Christie. 2003 . The versatile
bacterial type IV secretion systems . Nature Rev . 1:137-149.
- Chan, J . W., and P . H . Goodwin. 1999 . The molecular
genetics of virulence of Xanthomonas campestris . Biotechnol . Adv .
17:489-508.
- Charkowski, A . O., J . R . Alfano, G . Preston, J . Yuan, S . Y .
He, and A . Collmer. 1998 . The Pseudomonas syringae pv . tomato HrpW
protein has domains similar to harpins and pectate lyases and can elicit the
plant hypersensitive response and bind to pectate . J . Bacteriol . 180:5211-5217 .
- Chien, C . T., P . L . Bartel, R . Sternglanz, and S . Fields.
1991 . The two-hybrid system: a method to identify and clone genes for proteins
that interact with a protein of interest . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 88:9578-9582.
- Christie, P . J. 2001 . Type IV secretion: intercellular
transfer of macromolecules by systems ancestrally related to conjugation
machines . Mol . Microbiol . 40:294-305.
- Christie, P . J., and J . P . Vogel. 2000 . Bacterial type
IV secretion: conjugation systems adapted to deliver effector molecules to
host cells . Trends Microbiol . 8:354-360.
- Cornelis, G . R., and F . Van Gijsegem. 2000 . Assembly and
function of type III secretory systems . Annu . Rev . Microbiol . 54:735-774.
- da Silva, A . C., J . A . Ferro, F . C . Reinach, C . S . Farah, L .
R . Furlan, R . B . Quaggio, C . B . Monteiro-Vitorello, M . A . Van Sluys, N . F .
Almeida, L . M . Alves, A . M . do Amaral, M . C . Bertolini, L . E . Camargo, G .
Camarotte, F . Cannavan, J . Cardozo, F . Chambergo, L . P . Ciapina, R . M .
Cicarelli, L . L . Coutinho, J . R . Cursino-Santos, H . El-Dorry, J . B . Faria, A .
J . Ferreira, R . C . Ferreira, M . I . Ferro, E . F . Formighieri, M . C . Franco, C .
C . Greggio, A . Gruber, A . M . Katsuyama, L . T . Kishi, R . P . Leite, E . G . Lemos,
M . V . Lemos, E . C . Locali, M . A . Machado, A . M . Madeira, N . M . Martinez-Rossi,
E . C . Martins, J . Meidanis, C . F . Menck, C . V . Miyaki, D . H . Moon, L . M .
Moreira, M . T . Novo, V . K . Okura, M . C . Oliveira, V . R . Oliveira, H . A .
Pereira, A . Rossi, J . A . Sena, C . Silva, R . F . de Souza, L . A . Spinola, M . A .
Takita, R . E . Tamura, E . C . Teixeira, R . I . Tezza, M . Trindade dos Santos, D .
Truffi, S . M . Tsai, F . F . White, J . C . Setubal, and J . P . Kitajima. 2002 .
Comparison of the genomes of two Xanthomonas pathogens with differing
host specificities . Nature 417:459-463.
- Enz, S., S . Mahren, U . H . Stroeher, and V . Braun. 2000 .
Surface signaling in ferric citrate transport gene induction: interaction of
the FecA, FecR, and FecI regulatory proteins . J . Bacteriol . 182:637-646 .
- Evangelista, C., D . Lockshon, and S . Fields. 1996 . The
yeast two-hybrid system: prospects for protein linkage maps . Trends Cell Biol.
6:196-201.
- Flores, A., J . F . Briand, O . Gadal, J . C . Andrau, L . Rubbi,
V . Van Mullem, C . Boschiero, M . Goussot, C . Marck, C . Carles, P . Thuriaux, A .
Sentenac, and M . Werner. 1999 . A protein-protein interaction map of yeast
RNA polymerase III . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 96:7815-7820 .
- Francis, M . S., H . Wolf-Watz, and A . Forsberg. 2002 .
Regulation of type III secretion systems . Curr . Opin . Microbiol . 5:166-172.
- Galan, J . E., and A . Collmer. 1999 . Type III secretion
machines: bacterial devices for protein delivery into host cells . Science
284:1322-1328 .
- Gietz, R . D., and R . A . Woods. 2002 . Transformation of
yeast by the LiAc/SS carrier DNA/PEG method . Methods Enzymol . 350:87-96.
- Gietz, R . D., R . A . Woods, P . Manivasakam, and R . H .
Schiestl. 1998 . Growth and transformation of Saccharomyces cerevisiae .
In D . Spector, R . Goldman, and L . Leinwand [ed.], Cells: a laboratory
manual, vol . I . Culture and biochemical analysis of cells . Cold Spring Harbor
Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y.
- Hale, C . A., and P . A . de Bôer. 1999 . Recruitment of
ZipA to the septal ring of Escherichia coli is dependent on FtsZ and
independent of FtsA . J . Bacteriol . 181:167-176 .
- Harper, J . W., G . R . Adami, N . Wei, K . Keyomars, and S . J .
Ellege. 1993 . The p21 cdk-interacting protein Cip1 is a potent inhibitor
of G1 cyclin-dependent kinases . Cell 75:805-816.
- Harrison-McMonagle, P., N . Denissova, E . Martinez-Hackert,
R . H . Ebright, and A . M . Stock. 1999 . Orientation of OmpR monomers within
an OmpR:DNA complex determined by DNA affinity cleaving . J . Mol . Biol . 285:555-566.
- Hueck, C . J. 1998 . Type III protein secretion systems in
bacterial pathogens of animals and plants . Microbiol . Mol . Biol . Rev . 62:379-433 .
- Huguet, E., K . Hahn, K . Wengelnik, and U . Bonas. 1998.
hpaA mutants of Xanthomonas campestris pv . vesicatoria are
affected in pathogenicity but retain the ability to induce host-specific
hypersensitive reaction . Mol . Microbiology 29:1379-1390.
- Jackson, M . W., and G . V . Plano. 2000 . Interactions
between type III secretion apparatus components from Yersinia pestis
detected using the yeast two-hybrid system . FEMS Microbiol . Lett . 186:85-90.
- James, P., J . Halladay, and E . A . Craig. 1996 . Genomic
libraries and a host strain designed for highly efficient two-hybrid selection
in yeast . Genetics 144:1425-1436 .
- Jeruzalmi, D., M . O'Donnell, and J . Kuriyan. 2001 .
Crystal structure of the processivity clamp loader gamma [
]
complex of E . coli DNA polymerase III . Cell 106:429-441.
- Kenny, L . K. 2002 . Structure/function relationships in
OmpR and other winged-helix transcription factors . Curr . Opin . Microbiol .
5:135-141.
- Kim, J . F., and S . V . Beer. 1998 . HrpW of Erwinia
amylovora, a new harpin that contains a domain homologous to pectate
lyases of a distinct class . J . Bacteriol . 180:5203-5210 .
- Kim, J.-G., B . K . Park, C.-H . Yoo, E., Jeon, J . Oh, and I .
Hwang. 2003 . Characterization of the Xanthomonas axonopodis pv .
glycines Hrp pathogenicity island . J . Bacteriol . 185:3155-3166 .
- Lavander, M., L . Sundberg, P . J . Edqvist, S . A . Lloyd, H .
Wolf-Watz, and A . Forsberg. 2002 . Proteolytic cleavage of the FlhB
homologue YscU of Yersinia pseudotuberculosis is essential for
bacterial survival but not for type III secretion . J . Bacteriol . 184:4500-4509 .
- Lupas, A. 1996 . Coiled coils: new structures and new
functions . Trends Biochem . Sci . 21:375-382.
- Macnab, R . M. 1996 . Flagella and motility, p . 123-145.
In F . C . Neidhardt, R . Curtiss III, J . L . Ingraham, E . C . C . Lin, K . B .
Low, B . Magasanik, W . S . Reznikoff, M . Riley, M . Schaechter, and H . E .
Umbarger [ed.], Escherichia coli and Salmonella: cellular and
molecular biology, 2nd ed . ASM Press, Washington, D.C.
- Nakai, K., and M . Kanehisa. 1991 . Expert system for
predicting protein localization sites in gram-negative bacteria proteins .
Struct . Funct . Genet . 11:95-110.
- Pao, G . M., and M . H . Saier. 1995 . Response regulators
of bacterial signal transduction systems: selective domain shuffling during
evolution . J . Mol . Evol . 40:136-154.
- Parchaliuk, D . L., R . D . Kirkpatrick, R . Agatep, S . L .
Simon, and R . D . Gietz. 1999 . Yeast two-hybrid system . C . Characterizing
positives . Technical Tips Online 1:69:P01714 [Online.] http://tto.trends.com.
- Plano, G . V., J . B . Day, and F . Ferracci. 2001 . Type III
export: new uses for an old pathway . Mol . Microbiol . 40:284-293.
- Ponting, C . P., and L . Aravind. 1997 . PAS: a
multifunctional domain family comes to light . Curr . Biol . 7:674-677.
- Rossier, O., G . Van den Ackerveken, and U . Bonas. 2000 .
HrpB2 and HrpF from Xanthomonas are type III-secreted proteins and
essential for pathogenicity and recognition by the host plant . Mol . Microbiol.
38:828-838.
- Salanoubat, M, S . Genin, F . Artiguenave, J . Gouzy, S .
Mangenot, M . Arlat, A . Billault, P . Brottier, J . C . Camus, L . Cattolico, M .
Chandler, N . Choisne, C . Claudel-Renard, S . Cunnac, N . Demange, C . Gaspin, M .
Lavie, A . Moisan, C . Robert, W . Saurin, T . Schiex, P . Siguier, P . Thebault, M .
Whalen, P . Wincker, M . Levy, J . Weissenbach, and C . A . Boucher. 2002 .
Genome sequence of the plant pathogen Ralstonia solanacearum . Nature
415:497-502.
- Sambrook, J., and D . W . Russell. 2001 . Molecular
cloning: a laboratory manual, 3rd ed . Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press,
Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y.
- Schulte, R., and U . Bonas. 1992 . Expression of the
Xanthomonas campestris pv . vesicatoria hrp gene cluster, which
determines pathogenicity and hypersensitivity on pepper and tomato, is plant
inducible . J . Bacteriol . 174:815-823.
- Simpson, A . J., F . C . Reinach, P . Arruda, F . A . Abreu, M .
Acencio, R . Alvarenga, L . M . Alves, J . E . Araya, G . S . Baia, C . S . Baptista,
M . H . Barros, E . D . Bonaccorsi, S . Bordin, J . M . Bove, M . R . Briones, M . R .
Bueno, A . A . Camargo, L . E . Camargo, D . M . Carraro, H . Carrer, N . B . Colauto,
C . Colombo, F . F . Costa, M . C . Costa, C . M . Costa-Neto, L . L . Coutinho, M .
Cristofani, E . Dias-Neto, C . Docena, H . El-Dorry, A . P . Facincani, A . J .
Ferreira, V . C . Ferreira, J . A . Ferro, J . S . Fraga, S . C . Franca, M . C .
Franco, M . Frohme, L . R . Furlan, M . Garnier, G . H . Goldman, M . H . Goldman, S .
L . Gomes, A . Gruber, P . L . Ho, J . D . Hoheisel, M . L . Junqueira, E . L . Kemper,
J . P . Kitajima, J . E . Krieger, E . E . Kuramae, F . Laigret, M . R . Lambais, L . C .
Leite, E . G . Lemos, M . V . Lemos, S . A . Lopes, C . R . Lopes, J . A . Machado, M .
A . Machado, A . M . Madeira, H . M . Madeira, C . L . Marino, M . V . Marques, E . A .
Martins, E . M . Martins, A . Y . Matsukuma, C . F . Menck, E . C . Miracca, C . Y .
Miyaki, C . B . Monteriro-Vitorello, D . H . Moon, M . A . Nagai, A . L . Nascimento,
L . E . Netto, A . J . Nhani, F . G . Nobrega, L . R . Nunes, M . A . Oliveira, M . C . de
Oliveira, R . C . de Oliveira, D . A . Palmieri, A . Paris, B . R . Peixoto, G . A .
Pereira, H . A . Pereira, Jr., J . B . Pesquero, R . B . Quaggio, P . G . Roberto, V .
Rodrigues, A . J . de M Rosa, V . E . de Rosa, Jr., R . G . de Sa, R . V . Santelli,
H . E . Sawasaki, A . C . R . da Silva, A . M . da Silva, F . R . da Silva, W . A . da
Silva, Jr., J . F . da Silveira, M . L . Silvestri, W . J . Siqueira, A . A . de
Souza, A . P . de Souza, M . F . Terenzi, D . Truffi, S . M . Tsai, M . H . Tsuhako, H .
Vallada, M . A . Van Sluys, S . Verjovski-Almeida, A . L . Vettore, M . A . Zago, M .
Zatz, J . Meidanis, and J . C . Setubal. 2000 . The genome sequence of the
plant pathogen Xylella fastidiosa . Nature 406:151-157.
- Slater, H., A . Alvarez-Morales, C . E . Barber, M . J . Daniels,
and J . M . Dow. 2000 . A two-component system involving an HD-GYP domain
protein links cell-cell signalling to pathogenicity gene expression in
Xanthomonas campestris . Mol . Microbiol . 38:986-1003.
- Stiefel, A., S . Mahren, M . Ochs, P . T . Schindler, S . Enz,
and V . Braun. 2001 . Control of the ferric citrate transport system of
Escherichia coli: mutations in region 2.1 of the FecI
extracytoplasmic-function sigma factor suppress mutations in the FecR
transmembrane regulatory protein . J . Bacteriol . 183:162-170 .
- Stock, A . M., V . L . Robinson, and P . N . Goudreau. 2000 .
Two component signal transduction . Annu . Rev . Biochem . 69:183-215.
- Uetz, P., L . Giot, G . Cagney, T . A . Mansfield, R . S . Judson,
J . R . Knight, D . Lockshon, V . Narayan, M . Srinivasan, P . Pochart, A .
Qureshi-Emili, Y . Li, B . Godwin, D . Conover, T . Kalbfleisch, G . Vijayadamodar,
M . Yang, M . Johnston, S . Fields, and J . M . Rothberg. 2000 . A comprehensive
analysis of protein-protein interactions in Saccharomyces cerevisiae .
Nature 403:623-627.
- Van Gijsegem, F., C . Gough, C . Zischek, E . Niqueux, M .
Arlat, S . Genin, P . Barberis, S . German, P . Castello, and C . Boucher.
1995 . The hrp gene locus of Pseudomonas solanacearum, which
controls the production of a type III secretion system, encodes eight proteins
related to components of the bacterial flagellar biogenesis complex . Mol .
Microbiol . 15:1095-1114.
- Van Sluys, M . A., M . C . de Oliveira, C . B .
Monteiro-Vitorello, C . Y . Miyaki, L . R . Furlan, L . E . Camargo, A . C . da Silva,
D . H . Moon, M . A . Takita, E . G . Lemos, M . A . Machado, M . I . Ferro, F . R . da
Silva, M . H . Goldman, G . H . Goldman, M . V . Lemos, H . El-Dorry, S . M . Tsai, H .
Carrer, D . M . Carraro, R . C . de Oliveira, L . R . Nunes, W . J . Siqueira, L . L .
Coutinho, E . T . Kimura, E . S . Ferro, R . Harakava, E . E . Kuramae, C . L . Marino,
E . Giglioti, I . L . Abreu, L . M . Alves, A . M . do Amaral, G . S . Baia, S . R .
Blanco, M . S . Brito, F . S . Cannavan, A . V . Celestino, A . F . da Cunha, R . C .
Fenille, J . A . Ferro, E . F . Formighieri, L . T . Kishi, S . G . Leoni, A . R .
Oliveira, V . E . Rosa, Jr., F . T . Sassaki, J . A . Sena, A . A . de Souza, D .
Truffi, F . Tsukumo, G . M . Yanai, L . G . Zaros, E . L . Civerolo, A . J . Simpson,
N . F . Almeida, Jr., J . C . Setubal, and J . P . Kitajima. 2003 . Comparative
analyses of the complete genome sequences of Pierce's disease and citrus
variegated chlorosis strains of Xylella fastidiosa . J . Bacteriol .
185:1018-1026 .
- Walhout, A . J . M., R . Sordella, X . Lu, J . L . Hartley, G . F .
Temple, M . A . Brasch, N . Thierry-Mieg, and M . Vidal. 2000 . Protein
interaction mapping in Caenorhabditis elegans using proteins involved
in vulval development . Science 287:116-122 .
- Ward, D . V., O . Draper, J . R . Zupan, and P . C . Zambryski.
2002 . Peptide linkage mapping of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens vir-encoded
type IV secretion system reveals protein subassemblies . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci .
USA 99:11493-11500 .
- Wengelnik, K., and U . Bonas. 1996 . HrpXv, an AraC-type
regulator, activates expression of five of the six loci in the hrp
cluster of Xanthomonas campestris pv . vesicatoria . J . Bacteriol .
178:3462-3469.
- Wengelnik, K., M . M . Russel, and U . Bonas. 1996 .
Expression and localization of HrpA1, a protein of Xanthomonas campestris
pv . vesicatoria essential for pathogenicity and induction of the
hypersensitive reaction . J . Bacteriol . 178:1061-1069.
- Wengelnik, K., O . Rossier, and U . Bonas. 1999 . Mutations
in the regulatory gene hrpG of Xanthomonas campestris pv .
vesicatoria result in constitutive expression of all hrp genes . J .
Bacteriol . 181:6828-6831 .
- Williams, A . W., S . Yamaguchi, F . Togashi, S . Aizawa, I .
Kawagishi, and R . M . Macnab. 1996 . Mutations in fliK and flhB
affecting flagellar hook and filament assembly in Salmonella typhimurium .
J . Bacteriol . 178:2960-2970.
- Winther-Larsen, H . C., and M . Koomey. 2002 .
Transcriptional, chemosensory, and cell-contact-dependent regulation of type
IV pilus expression . Curr . Opin . Microbiol . 5:173-178.
- Wood, D . W., J . C . Setubal, R . Kaul, D . E . Monks, J . P .
Kitajima, V . K . Okura, Y . Zhou, L . Chen, G . E . Wood, N . F . Almeida, Jr., L .
Woo, Y . Chen, I . T . Paulsen, J . A . Eisen, P . D . Karp, D . Bovee, Sr, P .
Chapman, J . Clendenning, G . Deatherage, W . Gillet, C . Grant, T . Kutyavin, R .
Levy, M . J . Li, E . McClelland, A . Palmieri, C . Raymond, G . Rouse, C .
Saenphimmachak, Z . Wu, P . Romero, D . Gordon, S . Zhang, H . Yoo, Y . Tao, P .
Biddle, M . Jung, W . Krespan, M . Perry, B . Gordon-Kamm, L . Liao, S . Kim, C .
Hendrick, Z . Y . Zhao, M . Dolan, F . Chumley, S . V . Tingey, J . F . Tomb, M . P .
Gordon, M . V . Olson, and E . W . Nester. 2001 . The genome of the natural
genetic engineer Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58 . Science 294:2317-2323 .
- Wösten, M . M . S . M. 1998 . Eubacterial sigma-factors .
FEMS Microbiol . Rev . 22:127-150.
- Yang, M., Z . Wu, and S . Fields. 1995 . Protein-protein
interactions analyzed with the yeast two-hybrid system . Nucleic Acids Res .
23:1152-1156.
- Zhu, J., P . M . Oger, B . Schrammeijer, P . J . Hooykaas, S . K .
Farrand, and S . C . Winans. 2000 . The basis of crown gall tumorigenesis J .
Bacteriol . 182:3885-3895.
Free Online Full-text Article
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
|