|
|
|
Journal of Bacteriology, July 2004, p . 4085-4099, Vol . 186, No . 13
Microarray-Based Analysis of the Staphylococcus aureus
|
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
Microarray-based analysis of the transcriptional profiles of the
genetically distinct Staphylococcus aureus strains COL, GP268,
and Newman indicate that a total of 251 open reading frames (ORFs)
are influenced by
B
activity . While
B
was found to positively control 198 genes by a factor of
2
in at least two of the three genetic lineages analyzed, 53 ORFs were
repressed in the presence of
B .
Gene products that were found to be influenced by
B
are putatively involved in all manner of cellular processes,
including cell envelope biosynthesis and turnover, intermediary
metabolism, and signaling pathways . Most of the genes and/or operons
identified as upregulated by
B
were preceded by a nucleotide sequence that resembled the
B
consensus promoter sequence of Bacillus subtilis . A
conspicuous number of virulence-associated genes were identified as
regulated by
B
activity, with many adhesins upregulated and prominently represented
in this group, while transcription of various exoproteins and toxins
were repressed . The data presented here suggest that the
B
of S . aureus controls a large regulon and is an important
modulator of virulence gene expression that is likely to act
conversely to RNAIII, the effector molecule of the agr locus .
We propose that this alternative transcription factor may be of
importance for the invading pathogen to fine-tune its virulence
factor production in response to changing host environments .
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
Transcription of DNA into RNA is catalyzed by RNA polymerase . In
bacteria, one RNA polymerase generates nearly all cellular RNAs,
including ribosomal, transfer, and mRNA . This enzyme consists of six
subunits,
2ßß'![]()
,
with
2ßß'
forming the catalytically competent RNA polymerase core enzyme
(E) . The core is capable of elongation and termination of transcription,
but it is unable to initiate transcription at specific promoter
sequences . The
subunit, which when bound to E forms the holoenzyme (E-
),
directs the multisubunit complex to specific promoter elements and
allows efficient initiation of transcription (reviewed in references
5 and 6) . Therefore,
factors provide an elegant mechanism in eubacteria to allow
simultaneous transcription of a variety of genetically unlinked
genes, provided all of these genes share the same promoter
specificities .
In addition to the housekeeping sigma subunit,
70
or
A,
most bacteria produce one or more additional
subunits, termed alternative
factors, which direct the respective E-
complex to distinct classes of promoters that contain alternative
factor-specific sequences . Alternative
factors have been shown in various bacteria to be of importance for
survival under extreme conditions (7,
14, 23, 31,
38, 44, 49,
60, 68, 73,
78, 79, 80) and to
influence virulence and pathogenicity (8,
13, 32, 35,
37, 42, 51,
57, 61, 71,
75, 78, 81) .
At least six alternative
factors are produced by the enteric bacterium Escherichia coli
(reviewed in reference 6) . Genomic sequence
analysis suggests that many alternative
factors also exist in a number of other pathogenic species such as
Treponema palladium (4 alternative
factors) (21), Vibro cholerae (7 alternative
factors) (29), Mycobacterium tuberculosis (12
alternative
factors) (12), and Pseudomonas aeruginosa (23
alternative
factors) (76) . Two alternative
factors,
B
and
H,
have been identified in Staphylococcus aureus (43,
82).
H
has only recently been characterized as a bona fide S . aureus
sigma factor, which is involved in the transcriptional regulation of
DNA competence factors (56) .
In contrast to
H,
the S . aureus alternative transcription factor
B
has been studied intensively . It has been shown to be involved in the
general stress response (7, 24,
26, 34, 43,
44).
B
also directly or indirectly influences the expression of a variety
of genes (25, 44, 84),
including many associated with virulence, such as
-hemolysin
(26, 34, 84), clumping
factor (58, 60), coagulase (55,
60) fibronectin-binding protein A (58),
lipases (44, 84), proteases (34,
36, 84), and thermonuclease (44,
84) . In addition,
B
has been shown to influence the expression of several global
virulence factor regulators, including SarA (4,
15, 25, 52), SarS (also
known as SarH1) (76), and RNAIII (4,
34) . However, no effect of
B
on S . aureus pathogenicity has been demonstrated in any in
vivo model analyzed to date (7, 34,
60) .
Besides its function in regulating virulence determinants,
B
is likely to play a role in mediating antibiotic resistance .
Inactivation of the gene coding for
B,
sigB, in the homogeneously methicillin-resistant strain COL
increases its susceptibility to methicillin (82)
while mutations within the rsbU-defective strain BB255,
leading to
B
hyperproduction, are associated with an increase in glycopeptide
resistance (3) . Moreover,
B
was shown to affect pigmentation (26,
44), to increase resistance to hydrogen peroxide (26,
44) and UV (26), and to promote
microcolony formation (1) and biofilm production (67) .
The genetic organization of the S . aureus sigB operon (43,
82) closely resembles that of the distal part of
the well-characterized homologous operon of the soil-borne
gram-positive bacterium Bacillus subtilis (reviewed in
references 28 and 65) . DNA microarray
technology-based analysis of the general stress response in
B . subtilis identified 127 genes controlled by
B
(66), and heat shock studies suggest that the
B
regulon of this organism comprises up to 200 genes (reviewed in
references 27 and 30) . Because
S . aureus
B
seems to be a pleotrophic regulator that plays a role in a number of
clinically relevant processes, a number of investigators have begun
characterizing the
B
regulon . Proteomic approaches have identified 27 S . aureus
cytoplasmic proteins and one extracellular protein to be under the
positive control of
B,
and 11 proteins were found to be repressed by the factor (25,
84), indicating that the
B
regulon of this pathogen is likely to comprise a much higher number
of genes than known to date .
In this study, we present DNA microarray-based data from three
distinct genetic backgrounds that suggest that the S . aureus
B
influences the expression of at least 251 genes . Of these, 198 genes
are positively controlled by
B
while 53 genes are repressed in the presence of the alternative
factor .
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
Bacterial strains, media, and growth conditions. Strains and
plasmids used in this study are listed in Table 1.
S . aureus was routinely cultured on sheep blood agar or Luria-Bertani
(LB) medium with rotary agitation at 200 rpm at 35°C . Exogenous
glucose was not added to the growth medium . When included, antibiotics
were used at the following concentrations: ampicillin, 50 mg
liter–1; chloramphenicol, 40 mg liter–1 .
|
Sampling, RNA isolation, and transcriptional profiling.
Overnight cultures of S . aureus were diluted 1:100 into fresh
prewarmed LB medium and grown as described above . For experiment 1,
cultures were grown to an optical density at 600 nm (OD600)
of 2, at which time RNA samples were prepared as described below .
For experiment 2, cultures were grown for 9 h and sample volumes
corresponding to 1010 cells were removed after 1, 3, 5, and
8 h of growth . For RNA isolation, samples were centrifuged at
7,000 x g at 4°C for 5 min, the
culture supernatants were removed, and the cell sediments were
snap-frozen in a dry ice-alcohol mixture . Frozen cells were
resuspended in 5 ml of ice-cold acetone-alcohol (1:1) and incubated
for 5 min on ice . After centrifugation at 7,000
x g and 4°C for 5 min, cells were
washed with 5 ml of TE buffer (10 mM Tris, 1 mM EDTA [pH 8]) and
resuspended on ice in 900 µl of TE . The cell suspensions were
transferred to 2-ml lysing matrix B tubes (Bio 101, Vista, Calif.),
and the tubes were shaken in an FP120 reciprocating shaker (Bio
101) two times at 6,000 rpm for 20 s . After centrifugation at
14,000 x g at 4°C for 5 min, the
supernatants were used for RNA isolation with the RNeasy Midi system
(QIAGEN, Inc., Valencia, Calif.) according to the manufacturer's
recommendations . To remove any contaminating genomic DNA,
approximately 125 µg of total RNA was treated with 20 U of DNase I
(Amersham Biosciences, Piscataway, N.J.) at 37°C for 30 min . The RNA
was then purified with an RNeasy mini column (QIAGEN) by following
the manufacturer's cleanup protocol . The integrity of the RNA
preparations was analyzed by electrophoresis in 1.2% agarose-0.66 M
formaldehyde gels . Reverse transcription-PCR, cDNA fragmentation,
cDNA terminal labeling, and hybridization of approximately 1.5 µg of
labeled cDNA to custom-made Wyeth S . aureus GeneChips were carried
out in accordance with the manufacturer's (Affymetrix Inc.,
Santa Clara, Calif.) instructions for antisense prokaryotic arrays .
The GeneChip contains 7,723 qualifiers representing the consensus
open reading frame (ORF) sequences of the genomes of N315, Mu50, COL,
8325, 252, and 476 as well as those of N315 intergenic regions
greater than 50 bp in length (P . Dunman, E . Murphy, and S . Projan,
unpublished data) . GeneChip arrays were scanned with the GeneArray
laser scanner (Agilent Technologies, Palo Alto, Calif.) . Data for
biological duplicates were normalized and analyzed by using the
GeneSpring, version 5.1, gene expression software package (Silicon
Genetics, Redwood City, Calif.) . Genes that were considered
upregulated in a
B-dependent
manner were found to demonstrate a >2-fold increase in RNA titers
under
B-producing
conditions in comparison to isogenic non-
B-producing
cells . In addition, these genes were considered present by Affymetrix
algorithms in the
B-producing
strains and demonstrated a significant difference in expression (t
test, with a P cutoff of at least 0.05) . Genes considered
downregulated in a
B-dependent
manner demonstrated at least a twofold reduction in RNA transcript
titers in the wild-type as opposed to their isogenic
B
mutant background and were both considered present by the Affymetrix
criteria in mutant cells and where characterized as having significantly
differing amounts of transcripts based on t tests with a P
cutoff of at least 0.05 .
Construction of plasmids pAC7-sigB and pSA0455p. A DNA fragment constituting the sigB ORF of S . aureus COL was amplified by PCR with an upstream primer (5'-GATCATATGGCGAAAGAGTCGAAATCAGC-3') containing an NdeI site (underlined) and a downstream primer (5'-GCGAAGCTTCAAATTCTATTGATGTGCTGC-3') containing a HindIII site (underlined), with italic nucleotides corresponding to positions 2687 to 2709 and 3443 to 3463 of the sequence found under GenBank accession no. Y09929, respectively . The resulting PCR product was digested with NdeI and HindIII and cloned into plasmid pAC7 (70) to obtain pAC7-sigB, which was subsequently transformed by electroporation into E . coli XL1-Blue (Stratagene, La Jolla, Calif.) . Sequence analysis and comparison confirmed the identity of the construct . For pSA0455p, a DNA fragment representing 360 bp of the N315-SA0455 promoter region of COL was generated by PCR with an upstream primer (5'-CGGATCCAGTAGTAGTGATTAGAAAAGAC-3') containing a BamHI site (underlined) and a downstream primer (5'-CGGCTCGAGATAAACTGTTGCCAGGTTCTACG-3) containing an XhoI site (underlined), with italic nucleotides corresponding to positions 227569 to 227592 and 227895 to 227919, respectively, of the sequence found under GenBank accession no. AP003130 . The PCR product was digested with BamHI and XhoI and cloned into promoter probe plasmid pSB40N (39) to obtain pSA0455p . Sequence analysis confirmed the identity of the insert . Plasmid pSA0455p was transformed into E . coli XL1-Blue containing either compatible plasmid, pAC7-sigB or pAC7 .
High-resolution S1 nuclease mapping. For RNA isolation from
recombinant E . coli cultures, strains were grown at 37°C in LB
supplemented with ampicillin and chloramphenicol to an OD600
of 0.3 . At this growth stage, expression of S . aureus sigB was
induced by adding 0.0002% (wt/vol) arabinose, and cultivation was
continued for an additional 3 h . Isolation of total RNA and
high-resolution S1 nuclease mapping were performed as described by
Kormanec (40) . A 450-bp DNA fragment covering the
SA0455 promoter region was amplified by PCR from pSA0455p, with
universal oligonucleotide primer –47 (5'-CGCCAGGGTTTTCCCAGTCACGAC-3'),
labeled at the 5' end with [
-32P]ATP,
and mut80 primer (5'-GGGTTCCGCGCACATTTCCCCG-3') . Forty micrograms of
RNA was hybridized to 0.02 pmol of the 5' end-labeled DNA fragment
(approximately 3 x 106 cpm/pmol
of probe) and treated with 100 U of S1 nuclease . The protected
DNA fragment was analyzed on a DNA sequencing gel together with
G+A and T+C sequencing ladders derived from the end-labeled probe (54) .
| RESULTS AND DISCUSSION |
|---|
Identification of
B-regulated
genes. Proteomic approaches and computational analyses, based on the
method described by Petersohn and colleagues (64),
indicate that the
B
regulon of S . aureus comprises many more genes than described
to date, suggesting that the regulon might be as large as that of the
well-characterized homologous regulon of B . subtilis (reviewed
in references 27 and 30) . In an effort to
better define the S . aureus
B
regulon, DNA microarray studies were performed in three genetically
distinct backgrounds . DNA microarray technology is a powerful tool to
analyze the transcription profiles of the whole genome, provided that
all genes are represented on the respective GeneChip . There is
increasing evidence that extensive variation in gene content exists
among strains of many pathogenic bacterial species . A genomic
comparison of 36 S . aureus strains of divergent clonal lineage
identified a very large genetic variation to be present in this
pathogen, with approximately 22% of the genome being dispensable (18) .
The custom-made Affymetrix S . aureus GeneChip used in this
study includes probes that monitor the expression of virtually all
ORFs from six S . aureus genomes, making it an ideal tool for
the identification of almost all transcriptional changes that are
caused by the alternative transcription factor
B .
Two different approaches were chosen to identify
B-dependent
genes . In experiment 1, the transcriptional profiles of three
genetically distinct S . aureus strains harboring an intact sigB
operon (COL, Newman, and GP268) and their isogenic
rsbUVW-sigB
mutants were analyzed . For this purpose, total bacterial RNA
was obtained from cells that were grown to the late-exponential
growth phase (OD600 = 2), a time point at which
B
has been shown to be active (26) . Comparison of
the transcriptional profiles of the sigB+ strains
to their respective isogenic sigB mutants identified 229 ORFs
to be influenced by
B
by a factor of more than 2 in at least two of the three genetic
backgrounds analyzed (Tables 2 and 3) .
While the majority of ORFs were positively influenced by
B
(Table 2), as expected for a
factor, a number of ORFs that were repressed in the presence of
B
were also identified (Table 3) . Forty-six of the
genes identified were previously shown to be influenced by
B
in S . aureus . Additionally, 23 genes were previously
identified to be regulated by
B
in B . subtilis (30, 66) .
This high correlation indicates that the GeneChip method used
accurately identified the genes belonging to the
B
regulon of the strains analyzed .
|
|
Transcriptional start point (tsp) determinations of
B-driven
transcripts (15, 33), coupled with
B-dependent
in vitro transcription analyses of the asp23 P1 and coa
promoters (55), suggest that the promoter region
of S . aureus
B-regulated
genes contains a consensus sequence that is highly similar to that of
B . subtilis
B-regulated
genes (GttTww12-15gGgwAw) (64) . The similarity of
the
B
promoter consensus sequences of both species is further corroborated
by the findings of Gertz et al . (24, 25),
who demonstrated that the S . aureus asp23 P1 promoter is
recognized by E-
B
in B . subtilis and that all proteins that were identified to
be influenced by
B
in S . aureus by a proteomic approach are encoded by genes
harboring a nucleotide sequence resembling the B . subtilis
B
promoter consensus . Most of the genes identified as upregulated by
B
in this study were also preceded by nucleotide sequences resembling
the
B
promoter consensus of B . subtilis, either directly or as part
of a putative operon . None of the genes identified as downregulated
in a
B-specific
manner contained this sequence within their promoter regions .
Genes influenced by
B
during early growth stages. The approach used in experiment 1 proved
useful for the identification of a large number of
B-regulated
genes (Tables 2 and 3) . However,
this strategy was likely to miss
B-dependent
genes that were expressed only during the early growth stages . In a
second approach, the transcriptional profiles of strain Newman and
its
rsbUVW-sigB
mutant, IK184, were analyzed during several growth stages, e.g.,
1, 3, 5, and 8 h after inoculation (Fig . 1A) . Monitoring
of the transcriptional profiles during different growth stages
confirmed almost all genes identified by experiment 1 as
B
dependent . The experiment also enabled us to identify 23 additional
ORFs as positively regulated by
B
(Table 4) . The majority of these ORFs, represented
by transcriptional profile type 1 (Fig . 1B), were
expressed primarily during the early growth stages (1 and 3 h after
inoculation) while no transcripts were detectable during later growth
(5 and 8 h after inoculation) . Members of this group include several
putative virulence factors such as coa, encoding
staphylococcal coagulase, and fnb, encoding fibronectin
binding protein A, which have previously been demonstrated to be
influenced by
B
and confirmed in this study (55, 58,
60) . In addition, ORFs N315-SA0620, N315-SA2093,
and N315-SA2332, which are all homologues of ssaA of
Staphylococcus epidermidis, encoding the highly antigenic
staphylococcal secretory antigen A (48), were
found to be influenced by
B .
Most of the ORFs listed in Table 4 lacked a
significant
B
consensus promoter in their upstream regions, suggesting that
B
indirectly regulates their transcript titers .
|
|
The transcript titers of a number of ORFs were not only increased in
the wild-type strain during early growth (1 h after inoculation) but
were found to be further enhanced during late growth (8 h after
inoculation), as represented by transcription profile type 2 (Fig.
1B) . It is conceivable that the expression of these
ORFs is again influenced indirectly by
B,
most likely via regulator(s) which are mainly active during the late
growth phase . The increase in expression observed for these ORFs
during the early growth phase may be due to a carryover of the
regulators that were produced during late growth in the preculture
and may be still active even 1 h after inoculation .
Functional classification of ORFs influenced by
B.
The ORFs influenced by
B
represent all functional categories that have been proposed by Kunst
et al . (45), e.g., (i) cell envelope and cellular
processes, including cell wall production, transport, signal
transduction, membrane bioenergetics, and protein secretion; (ii)
intermediary metabolism, including carbohydrate metabolism,
glycolytic pathways, tricarboxylic acid cycle, and amino acid and
lipid metabolism; (iii) information pathways, including DNA
modification and repair, RNA synthesis, and regulation; (iv) other
functions, such as adaptation to atypical conditions or
detoxification; and (v) ORFs similar to proteins with unknown
function . The latter group alone comprises 100 of the 251 ORFs
regulated by
B,
representing a large reservoir of potential factors that may be
responsible for phenotypic properties of S . aureus associated
with
B
activity, such as the development of resistance to methicillin,
glycopeptides, and hydrogen peroxide (3,
26, 44, 82) that have
not been associated with specific genes .
Chromosomal distribution of
B-regulated
genes. The ORFs that are positively controlled by
B
are not evenly distributed over the S . aureus chromosome (Fig.
2) but rather are overabundant in the genomic
regions that are close to the origin of replication (oriC) .
While 77 of 828 ORFs (9.3%) or 69 of 861 ORFs (8%) encoded by the
genome fragments 1 and 3, corresponding to positions 1 to 937880 and
1875761 to 2813641, respectively, are influenced by
B,
only 12 of 816 (1.5%) of the ORFs encoded by genomic region 2
(positions 937880 to 1875760), which is most distal to oriC,
are controlled by
B .
The majority of genes and/or operons in these segments are oriented
with respect to oriC in a manner that minimizes collisions
between the transcribing RNA polymerase and the replication
apparatus . Thus, 71.5% of all genes and 77% of the
B-regulated
ORFs located on genome fragment 1 are encoded by the clockwise
replicating strand, and 72.8% of all genes and 72.5% of the
B-regulated
ORFs located on genome fragment 3 are encoded by the counterclockwise
strand . It has been suggested by Neidhardt and colleagues (59)
that the location of a gene relative to oriC can affect its
level of expression . Genes located near the point of origin of
replication are present in higher numbers in a rapidly growing cell
than those near the terminus, which may be of importance, especially
for those genes that are controlled by promoters operating near the
maximum possible frequency .
|
Putative regulators acting downstream of
B.
A significant number of ORFs (50 of 176 from experiment 1 and 17 of
23 from experiment 2) found to be upregulated by
B
were not preceded by nucleotide sequences resembling the
B
promoter consensus . Some of these genes were expressed only in
sigB+ strains . It is possible that these ORFs were transcribed by
the direct action of E-
B,
despite the lack of an obvious
B
promoter consensus . Alternatively, it is possible that
B
controls the expression of a regulator(s), which would subsequently
promote the expression of these genes . Promising candidates for such
a scenario are the putative regulator homologues YabJ and SpoVG
(N315-SA0455/6), which are likely to be cotranscribed, and were found
to be controlled by
B
(Fig . 3) . The use of a recently described
two-plasmid system (33) allowed us to confirm that
yabJ expression is driven by
B
(Fig . 3C) . tsp determination by S1 mapping
identified yabJ-specific RNA-protected fragments only in the
presence of
B
but not in the absence of the alternate transcription factor . A
perfectly conserved
B
consensus promoter sequence is present upstream of the yabJ
tsp, indicating a direct influence of
B
on the expression of this gene or operon . YabJ belongs to the highly
conserved family of YigF proteins, which have been suggested to
influence a variety of biological processes (69) .
YabJ of B . subtilis was found to have a role in the repression
of purA by adenine (69) . spoVG, encoding the
stage V sporulation protein G, was the first developmentally
regulated gene that was cloned from B . subtilis (74),
and its regulation has been investigated intensively . However, little
is known about the function of this protein . A mutation in spoVG
was shown to impair the sporulation of B . subtilis, apparently
as a result of disintegration of an immature spore cortex (72) .
More recent results suggest that SpoVG interferes with or is a
negative regulator of the pathway leading to asymmetric septation (53) .
In addition to S . aureus, spoVG homologues have been
found in the genomes of several bacteria, such as Archaeoglobus
fulgidus, Borrelia burgdorferi, Listeria monocytogenes,
and S . epidermidis, none of which produce spores . Thus, the
SpoVG homologues of these organisms are likely to mediate functions
other than sporulation . Inactivation of spoVG in a
methicillin-resistant S . epidermidis drastically decreased
methicillin resistance and the formation of a biofilm (D . Mack,
personal communication) . Interestingly, both attributes have also
been linked positively to
B
activity in S . aureus (67,
82) . Attempts to inactivate the S . aureus yabJ and spoVG
homologues are currently ongoing in our laboratory to elucidate
their roles in this organism .
|
Another potential regulator acting downstream of
B
is the gene product of ORF N315-SA1961, a homologue of the BglG/SacY
family of transcriptional antiterminators (ATs) . ATs are regulatory
protein factors that bind to specific sites in the nascent mRNA
to prevent premature termination of gene transcription and to
stimulate elongation by RNA polymerase (83) . Expression of
N315-SA1961 was found to be highly upregulated in strains harboring
an intact sigB operon (Table 2), and the ORF
is preceded by a nucleotide sequence (GTTATT-14-GGGTAT)
that matches the proposed
B
promoter consensus, indicating that the BglG/SacY homologue is
controlled directly by
B .
Influence of
B
on known regulatory elements. S . aureus possesses an array of
virulence factor regulatory elements, such as two-component signal
transduction systems and winged-helix transcription regulatory
proteins . Presumably, these elements interact to influence different
networks of virulence factors on an as-needed basis, thereby
providing cells with the necessary arsenal of virulence determinates
to respond to environmental changes or stimuli (reviewed in reference
10) . The data presented here indicate that three
of these virulence regulators, sarA, sarS, and arlRS,
are upregulated by
B
(Fig . 4A) . Transcription of other well-studied
virulence regulators, such as Sae and Rot, were not significantly
influenced by
B
in these studies .
|
The staphylococcal accessory regulator A, SarA, a member of the
winged-helix transcription proteins is encoded by the sar
locus . Although it is well established that expression of the sar
locus is in part controlled by the action of
B
(4, 15, 52),
it is still a matter of debate whether
B
has a positive or negative effect on the overall level of SarA
production . Much of what is published regarding the influence of
B
on SarA expression is difficult to interpret because most of these
studies were done in strains, such as RN6390 and 8325-4, that harbor
mutations in rsbU, the positive activator of
B,
rendering them sigB deficient (26) . The
discrepancies between the positive influence of
B
on SarA production observed by Gertz et al . (25) in a
proteomic approach and by Bischoff et al . (4) via
reporter gene fusion experiments versus the observed downregulatory
effect of
B
on SarA production reported by Manna et al . (52)
and Cheung et al . (9) may be explained by the fact
that, in the latter studies, an rsbU mutant was used as
parental strain to compare it with its respective sigB mutant .
However, this explanation cannot account for the findings of
Horsburgh et al . (34), who did not observe any
influence of
B
on SarA production either at the transcriptional or at the protein
level . The transcriptional profiling data presented here strongly
suggest that
B
increases the expression of the sar locus (Table
2; Fig . 4A), especially during the later growth
stages (5 and 8 h after inoculation) . Moreover, a direct correlation
between the increase in SarA transcript levels and an increase in
SarA protein is indirectly suggested by the findings that the
expression of four major extracellular proteases of S . aureus
(staphylococcal serine protease V8 [SspA], cysteine protease [SspB],
metalloprotease aureolysin [Aur], and staphopain [Scp]) is
significantly decreased in sigB+ strains (Table
3; Fig . 4) . It was recently demonstrated
by Karlsson and Arvidson (36) that transcription of
these protease genes was suppressed due to increased
B-dependent
expression of SarA . This is further supported by the findings that
several of the ORFs found to be downregulated by
B,
such as glpQ, encoding glycerophosphoryl diester
phosphodiesterase, nuc, encoding staphylococcal
thermonuclease, and plc, encoding a 1-phosphatidylinositol
phospodiesterase precursor, have previously been demonstrated to be
downregulated by SarA (16, 84) .
It is likely that the increase in expression of these genes found in
the
rsbUVW-sigB
mutants is due to decreased production of SarA . Although appealing,
this assumption remains speculative, as both Dunman et al . (16)
and Ziebandt et al . (84) used the rsbU-defective
RN6390 lineage as the genetic background for their analyses, leaving
it open to question what might happen with respect to the sarA
regulon in strains carrying an intact sigB operon . The genetic
background chosen may also explain the observed discrepancy that
several of the genes listed in Table 3 were found
to be downregulated by
B
but upregulated by SarA . Support for such a process is conferred by
the observations that RNAIII expression of the agr locus is
known to be promoted by SarA (11) but decreased by
B
(4, 34) in an unidentified way
that is, however, supposed to be independent from SarA (34) .
The expression of a second winged-helix transcription protein,
SarS (also known as SarH1), belonging to the family of SarA
homologues was previously shown to be influenced by
B
(77) . This was confirmed in two of the three
backgrounds analyzed in this study (Table 2) .
Interestingly, no difference in sarS expression was observed
when comparing strain Newman and its
rsbUVW-sigB
mutant either in the microarray experiments (Table 2;
Fig . 4A) or by Northern blot analysis (data not shown),
further demonstrating that strain-to-strain differences influence
regulon constituents . Sequencing of the
B
promoter regions of sarS of strains Newman and GP268 did not
reveal any differences between the respective regions (which were
identical with the N315 region corresponding to nucleotides 125868 to
126073 of GenBank accession no.
AP003129), leaving the question open as to why expression of
sarS in strain Newman is not affected by
B .
The third known virulence regulatory element observed to be
influenced by
B
was arlRS, encoding a two-component signal transduction system
that influences adhesion, autolysis, and extracellular proteolytic
activity of S . aureus (19) . More recently, it was
also demonstrated to decrease expression of the agr locus while
increasing the expression of SarA (20) . The data
obtained from experiment 2 suggest that arlRS of strain Newman
is upregulated by
B
(Fig . 4A) . However, arlRS did not show up in experiment
1 as influenced by
B
either in strain COL or strain GP268 and is not preceded by a
B
consensus promoter .
Recent results suggest that expression of RNAIII, the effector
molecule of the agr locus, is negatively influenced by
B
(4, 34) . However, results of the
two experiments presented here did not effectively corroborate these
observations, as although slight differences in RNAIII transcription
were detectable between wild-type strains and their respective
rsbUVW-sigB
mutants (Fig . 4A), changes in expression were not
determined to be significant . RNAIII is by far the most prominent RNA
molecule produced by S . aureus during the later growth stages .
As a result, the RNAIII transcript levels of the wild-type strains
already reached amounts that saturated the RNAIII-specific target
oligonucleotides represented on the GeneChip, thus impeding the
detection of differences in RNAIII transcript levels that might be
present between the strain pairs analyzed .
Influence of
B
on expression of virulence determinants. Previous studies demonstrated
that
B
influences the expression of various factors associated with
virulence and pathogenicity of S . aureus (4,
15, 25, 34,
44, 58, 60,
84), which led to the assumption that
B
may be important for virulence of this organism (4,
44) . However, in vivo studies have failed to demonstrate
an effect of
B
on the virulence of S . aureus (34, 60),
implying that such an assumption is no longer tenable . Alternatively,
B
may play a role in pathogenesis; however, the effects of
B-mediated
virulence mechanisms do not play a role in the models chosen in
those experiments .
Analysis of the GeneChip data suggests that
B
influences the expression of a large number of virulence genes in
S . aureus (reviewed in references 10 and
47) . Many of these are reported here for the first
time as genes that are altered transcriptionally by
B .
By comparing the expression profiles of these virulence genes, a
pattern has emerged; most of the exoenzymes and toxins produced by
S . aureus were negatively influenced by
B
(Fig . 4C) while the expression of several adhesins
was found to be clearly increased by
B
(Fig . 4B) . The function of
B
in virulence factor production is therefore exactly the opposite of
that of RNAIII, which is known to act as a negative regulator of
cell wall proteins and a positive regulator of exoenzymes and
toxins in a growth phase-dependent manner (Table 5) (10,
62) . The decreased amounts of exoprotein and toxin
transcripts observed in wild-type strains compared to their
respective mutants may in part be a consequence of lower RNAIII
transcript levels that are present in strains harboring an intact
sigB operon (4, 34) .
Expression of the cap gene cluster is influenced by a variety
of environmental stimuli and affected by several global regulators,
such as RNAIII, SarA, and MgrA, (reviewed in reference 63) .
The microarray data presented here add a further regulator,
B,
to this list and suggest that the alternate transcription factor
influences cap expression in a growth phase-dependent manner
(Fig . 5) . While virtually no cap transcripts were
detectable during the early growth stages (1 and 3 h), expression of
the cap genes increased with ongoing growth (5 and 8 h), being
highest at the latest time point analyzed . After 8 h of growth, a
>50-fold increase in cap-specific transcripts was observable
in strain Newman that was totally missing in its
rsbUVW-sigB
mutant (Fig . 5) . However, the effect of
B
on cap expression is likely to be indirect, as the promoter
region of the cap operon lacks an obvious
B
consensus promoter sequence .
|
|
The finding that expression of so many virulence genes is significantly
altered by
B
warrants further investigation to elucidate its role in infectivity
of S . aureus in additional models of infection . To date,
nothing is known about the expression or activity of
B
during the course of infection . S . aureus is known for its
ability to cause a variety of unrelated infections (reviewed in
reference 50) . It is feasible that the
B-dependent
downregulation of toxins and exoenzymes, combined with the
simultaneous upregulation of adhesins, may enable S . aureus to
cause very specific host-pathogen interactions that have not been
investigated to date . Recent results indicate that
B
is involved in processes that are important for biofilm formation (1,
67); therefore, a comparison of the transcription
profile of biofilm cells to the results we have obtained may identify
genes that are essential for biofilm formation . Additionally, based
on the virulence factor pattern caused by
B,
it is tempting to speculate that this alternative transcription
factor may also be an important player during nasal colonization,
thereby promoting adherence to the host cell matrix without evoking
an inflammatory response . Investigations in our laboratories are
ongoing to address these questions . It is also quite possible that in
vivo conditions leading to S . aureus stress, including those
of high temperature at the site of infection, may induce the stress
responsive
B
factor . Under such conditions, when the host is trying to mount an
immune response at the site of infection, it may be more beneficial
for the bacterium to produce cell surface components that are
involved in camouflaging the organism from the host's defense than to
produce exoproteins .
The present study was designed to extensively characterize the
genes that are regulated by the alternative sigma factor
B
during standard laboratory growth conditions . Under these conditions,
a >20-fold increase in the
B-regulated
gene asp23 was observed (Fig . 5) . In
addition, very stringent criteria were used for the identification of
B-regulated
genes: (i) transcripts demonstrated the same
B-dependent
phenotype in at least two of the three genetic backgrounds tested and
(ii) transcripts passed strict statistical cutoff values . Based on
these criteria, there was an extremely high correlation between the
genes that we identified to be regulated in a
B-dependent
manner and previously recorded results . As a result, it is likely
that the GeneChip method used accurately identified the genes
belonging to the
B
regulon of the strains analyzed . While defining the
B
regulon, we observed a distinguishable pattern among virulence
factors . Subsequent studies that have focused on two S . aureus
adhesions (clfA and fnbA) have confirmed that each gene
is indeed regulated in a
B-dependent
manner and further validated the method used (unpublished data) .
The finding that
B
downregulates the transcription of secreted virulence factors but
upregulates cell surface virulence factors is in direct contrast to
the observations of Kupferwasser et al . (46) . In
that study it was found that salicylic acid mildly induces asp23
(1.9-fold) and corresponds to both the downregulation of certain cell
surface adhesions and the upregulation of secreted proteases . Based
on the low induction rate of asp23, it is difficult to
reconcile whether the virulence factor effects seen in that study are
directly mediated by
B
versus another salicylic acid-responsive process or a combination of
the two . It also raises the question of whether low to moderate
levels of
B
produce a much different physiological phenotype than the levels
tested here . It is also possible that salicylic acid and other
stresses that have previously been shown to modulate
B
activity direct the expression of portions of the
B
regulon . More completely characterizing the
B
regulon will allow subsequent experiments to fully address these
questions and further understand the role, if any, that the
B
regulon plays in pathogenesis .
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
Research in the laboratory of B.B.-B . and M.B . is supported by Swiss
National Science Foundation grants 4049.063201 and 3100A0-100234 and
by the Forschungskredit der Universität Zürich grant 560030 . J.K . is
supported by grant 2/3010/23 from the Slovak Academy of Sciences .
We are also grateful to the Wyeth antimicrobial research department for providing us with the necessary materials for the GeneChip experiments .
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
* Corresponding author . Mailing address: Department of Medical
Microbiology, University of Zurich, Gloriastr . 32, CH-8028 Zurich, Switzerland .
Phone: 41 1 634 26 70 . Fax: 41 1 634 49 06 . E-mail: Bischoff@immv.unizh.ch.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
What Is Antibiotic?,
What Is Prokaryote?,
What Is Pcr?,
What Is Biofilter?,
What Is Molecular Microbiology?,
a,
Microbe,
e,
Microbiology,
s,
Microorganism,
c,
Microbes,
a,
Microorganisms,
e,
Staphylococcus aureus,
e,
Functional genomics,
i,
Micrococci,
n,
Clostridia,
n,
Yeast,
n,
Enterobacters,
e,
Multidrug resistant,
s,
Bacillus anthracis,
i,
Bacillus,
o,
Thermophiles,
s,
Cholera,
c,
Cell cultures,
i,
Escherichia coli,
o,
Thermophile,
c,
Escherichia coli,
i,
Vibriosis,
e,
Cephalosporin,
n,
Escherichia coli,
e,
Vibriosis,
a,
Bacteroides,
r,
Haemophilus
© 2005
Transgalactic Ltd (manufacturer of Bioscreen C software) |
Privacy Statement | P.O. Box
1393, 00101 Helsinki, Finland,
Last modified: May 25, 2005
| ||||||