|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, September 2004, p . 6015-6024, Vol .
186, No . 18
Involvement of a Plasmid-Encoded Type IV Secretion System in the Plant Tissue
Watersoaking Phenotype of Burkholderia cenocepacia
Amanda S . Engledow,1 Enrique G . Medrano,1,
Eshwar Mahenthiralingam,2 John J . LiPuma,3 and Carlos F .
Gonzalez1*
Department of Plant Pathology & Microbiology, Texas A&M University, College
Station, Texas,1 Cardiff School of Biosciences, Cardiff University,
Cardiff, Wales, United Kingdom,2 Department of Pediatrics and
Communicable Diseases, University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor,
Michigan3
Received 23 April 2004/ Accepted 16 June 2004
Burkholderia cenocepacia strain K56-2, a representative of the
Burkholderia cepacia complex, is part of the epidemic and clinically
problematic ET12 lineage . The strain produced plant tissue watersoaking
[ptw] on onion tissue, which is a plant disease-associated trait.
Using plasposon mutagenesis, mutants in the ptw phenotype were
generated . The translated sequence of a disrupted gene [ptwD4]
from a ptw-negative mutant showed homology to VirD4-like proteins.
Analysis of the region proximal to the transfer gene homolog
identified a gene cluster located on the 92-kb resident plasmidthat
showed homology to type IV secretion systems . The roleof ptwD4,
ptwC, ptwB4, and ptwB10 in the expression of ptw activity
was determined by conducting site-directed mutagenesis . Theptw
phenotype was not expressed by K56-2 derivatives with adisruption in
ptwD4, ptwB4, or ptwB10 but was observed in a
derivative with a disruption in ptwC . Complementation of ptw-negative
K56-2 derivatives in trans resulted in complete restoration
of the ptw phenotype . In addition, analysis of culture supernatants
revealed that the putative ptw effector[s] was a secreted, heat-stable
protein[s] that caused plasmolysis of plant protoplasts . A second
chromosomally encoded type IV secretion system with complete
homology to the VirB-VirD system was identified in K56-2 . Site-directed
mutagenesis of key secretory genes in the VirB-VirD system did
not affect expression of the ptw phenotype . Our findings indicate
that in strain K56-2, the plasmid-encoded Ptw type IV secretion
system is responsible for the secretion of a plant cytotoxic
protein[s].
The Burkholderia cepacia complex [Bcc] consists of nine genomovars
recently elevated to species status [11,
65, 66, 68] . Membersof the
Bcc include plant and animal pathogens as well as catabolically
active soil saprophytes [64] . Some Bcc members can cause
life-threateningrespiratory infections, particularly in persons with
cysticfibrosis [CF] [43] . Studies indicate that
85 to 90% of strainsisolated from infected CF patients are B .
cenocepacia or B.multivorans, with other Bcc species
being infrequently isolated[41] . Several epidemic
clonal lineages of B . cenocepacia havebeen identified [12],
including the ET12 lineage, which is responsiblefor infecting many
CF patients in Canada and the United Kingdom[32,
39]; the PHDC lineage, responsible for nearly all Bcc
infectionsin the mid-Atlantic region of the United States [8];
and theMidwest lineage, which is responsible for infecting numerous
patients in CF centers in the midwestern region of the United
States [42] . Factors that account for the apparent enhanced
capacity of epidemic clones for human infection are unknown.
Postulated clinically associated virulence determinants forB .
cenocepacia include hemolysins [30, 67],
siderophores [62],and cable pili [56] .
The hemolysin induces apoptosis and degranulationof phagocytes [30],
and siderophore production, regulated byquorum sensing [40],
plays a role in the primary colonizationprocess of animal lung and
spleen tissues [62] . Cable pili areimportant in
adherence to the respiratory mucosal blanket andepithelial cells [57].
In B . cepacia type strain ATCC 25416, a plant pathogenic
representativeof the Bcc, a plasmid-encoded pectate hydrolase [Peh]
is a virulencefactor necessary for maceration of onion tissue [24] .
Derivativesof ATCC 25416 that have been cured of the Peh-encoding
plasmiddo not macerate onion tissue . However, the Peh-negative
derivativesremain capable of causing a plant tissue watersoaking
[ptw]phenotype that results from loss of cell membrane integrity
and the accumulation of fluids in the intracellular spaces of
plant tissue [22] . In a survey of isolates from the Bcc
experimentalstrain panel [47], we found that all
of the B . cepacia and B.cenocepacia strains tested and
one B . vietnamiensis strain producedthe ptw phenotype,
suggesting that members of these genomicspecies may produce a
cytotoxic factor[s] that affects plantcell integrity [50].
In recent years, a body of research has substantiated the concept
that bacterial pathogens share common secretion mechanisms forthe
delivery of virulence determinants [9, 54] .
There are numerousexamples of the importance of type III [54]
and type IV secretionsystems [10] in the
infection process for both plant and animalpathogens, with evidence
that elements of the secretion systemsshow an ancestral relationship
to bacterial transport machinery.It has been hypothesized that type
III secretion systems arederived from flagellar assembly
constituents modified to functionas a transport mechanism for
virulence factors [46] . The typeIV secretion
system from Agrobacterium tumefaciens was the firstto be
identified and is used to deliver oncogenic transfer DNAand effector
proteins to plant cells during infection [10,
37].Presently, type IV secretion systems can be categorized as
[i]conjugation systems that mediate DNA transfer to recipient cells,
[ii] effector translocator systems that transfer molecules termed
effectors to eukaryotic cells during infection, or [iii] DNA
uptake or release systems mediating exchange of DNA with themilieu [18] .
The Legionella pneumophila Dot/Icm transporteris an example
of a type IV secretion system that is capableof both conjugation and
effector translocation [e.g., RalF][52] .
Helicobacter pylori possesses two type IV secretion systemswith
differing roles . The Cag secretory apparatus functionsin the
translocation of CagA into host cells, and the Com systemis used to
uptake DNA to facilitate genetic variation and enhancecell survival
[16, 18].
In this study we report on the presence of both a plasmid anda
chromosomally encoded type IV secretion system in B . cenocepacia
strain K56-2 and describe the involvement of the plasmid-encoded
system in the export of a putative protein[s] responsible for
the ptw phenotype.
Media and growth conditions. Descriptions of plasmids and
bacterial strains used in thisstudy are listed in Tables
1 and 2, respectively . Luria Bertani
[LB] medium was used for routine maintenance of cultures . Minimal
medium Vogel Bonner [69] amended with 1.0% glucose
[VBG] wasused in mating experiments . Minimal medium M9 [59]
containing1.0% glucose was used for culturing bacteria for
supernatantanalysis . B . cenocepacia and Escherichia coli
strains were grownat 37°C . Media were supplemented with appropriate
concentrationsof antibiotics as needed for selection . Antibiotics
were addedto media at the following concentrations: 50 µg of
tetracycline[Tc]/ml and 100 µg of trimethoprim [Tp]/ml for B .
cenocepaciaand 10 µg of Tc/ml, 10 µg of gentamicin [Gm]/ml,
40 µg of ampicillin/ml, and 100 µg of Tp/ml forE . coli.
| TABLE 1 . Plasmids used in this study
|
|
| TABLE 2 . Bacterial strains used in this study
|
|
Plant tissue assay and growth study. Plant tissue watersoaking
activity was determined as previouslydescribed [24] .
Onion cultivar 1015Y was used for plant tissueassays . Onion bulb
scales were inoculated, in triplicate, with10 µl of an aqueous
suspension of the isolate being testedas previously described [24] .
Aqueous bacterial suspensionswere adjusted spectrophotometrically [A425
= 0.5] to yield afinal concentration of
106
CFU/scale . Sterile double-distilleddeionized water was used as a
negative control and strain K56-2served as the positive control in
all experiments . Scales wereplaced on a sheet of aluminum foil that
had been surface sterilizedwith 70% ethanol in containers layered
with paper towels thatwere moistened with double-distilled deionized
water, sealed,and incubated at 37°C . Plant tissue watersoaking
activitywas assessed at 24, 48, and 72 h postinoculation by
measuringthe vertical and horizontal diameters of the zones for
triplicatesamples in three independent experiments . Data were
reportedas the average area of tissue watersoaking ± standard
deviations [SD] for the three independent experiments in triplicate.
To obtain a quantitative measure of growth in plant tissue for
strains K56-2, AE307, and AE310, bulb scales were inoculatedwith an
aqueous suspension of the strains as described above.At 0, 24, 48,
and 72 h postinoculation watersoaked zones weremeasured and tissue
was processed to determine the bacterialpopulation . Scales were
commuted and crushed in 0.0125 M phosphatebuffer [pH 7.1] containing
Triton X-100 [0.01%] by using a sterilemortar and pestle . A dilution
series of each tissue slurry wasplated to LB agar containing Gm [10
µg/ml] and Tc [10µg/ml] and was incubated at 37°C for 48 h .
Populationdata for each time interval was expressed as the average
CFU/gramof tissue ± SD for three independent experiments in
triplicate.Tissue watersoaking data were reported as the average
area ofwatersoaking ± SD for three independent experiments in
triplicate.
Activity testing of culture supernatants. Cultures of
strains K56-2, AE307, and AE310 were grown at 37°Cand harvested at
late exponential phase [A425 = 0.9] by centrifugation
[16,000 x g, 15 min, at 5°C] .
Supernatants [1 liter] werefilter sterilized using 0.22 µM filters
[Pall] and wereconcentrated to 3 ml by using an Amicon
ultrafiltration stirredcell [molecular weight cutoff, 10,000] .
Protein concentrationof supernatant concentrates was determined by
the method ofKoch and Putnam [36] . Concentrated
uninoculated medium [1 liter]served as the negative control.
Plant protoplasts were used as the plant tissue system to obtaina
quantitative measurement of activities of concentrated culture
supernatants . Initial testing demonstrated that onion and carrot
protoplasts were similar in sensitivity, and carrots were chosen
because the presence of chromoplasts facilitated a more accurate
evaluation of plasmolytic activity . Protoplasts were obtainedusing
the following procedure [33] . Young carrots were placed
in a 10% sodium hypochlorite solution for 5 min and then were
rinsed four times with sterile double-distilled deionized water.The
epidermis was resected with a sterile scalpel and discarded.Cortical
and phloem tissues were obtained, diced into fragments
2
mm in width, and placed in a sterile petri dish containing20 ml of a
filter-sterilized enzyme solution . The enzyme solutioncontained 10%
mannitol [Fisher], 1.5% cellulase [CalBiochem],0.25% macerase
[CalBiochem], and 0.75% bovine serum albuminfraction V [Sigma] [33] .
Tissue was digested in the dark for5 h at 28°C with gentle shaking
[50 rpm] . The carrot tissuewas strained through nylon mesh and
centrifuged [825 x g for5
min at 25°C] . The supernatant was removed using a pipette,avoiding
disturbance of the protoplasts . The protoplasts werewashed with 20
ml of 10% mannitol by resuspending with gentleswirling and
centrifuged . The supernatant was removed and thepellet was gently
resuspended in 10 ml of 10% mannitol, anda 5-ml 20% sucrose cushion
was carefully layered in the bottomof the tube . The sample was
centrifuged and the protoplastswere collected from the interface and
counted with a hemacytometer[Hausser Scientific] . On average, 1.8
x 106 protoplasts/ml were
obtained.
The plasmolytic activity of supernatants was determined by using
concentrates standardized for protein concentration and adjustedto
10% mannitol . The standardized concentrates, as well as dilutions
[1:1, 1:5, and 1:10], were added to protoplasts . Assay mixturesand
controls were incubated in 96-well microtiter plates [Corning]with
an average concentration of 50 protoplasts per well . Assays,done in
triplicate, were observed for changes in protoplastintegrity at 2-h
intervals for 8 h using a Zeiss inverted microscope.In addition, the
effect of temperature on plasmolytic activitywas tested by heating
concentrates to 100°C for 10 min orat 80, 65, or 37°C for 1 h .
Concentrates were also individuallytreated with 1-mg/ml final
concentrations of proteinase K [BoehringerMannheim] dissolved in
0.05 M Tris-HCl, pH 8; DNase I [3,200U/mg; Sigma] in 50 mM Tris-HCl,
pH 7.5, 10 mM MgCl2, and 50µg of bovine serum albumin/ml;
or RNase A [100 U/mg; Sigma]in 0.25 M Tris-HCl, pH 6.8 . All reaction
mixtures were incubatedat temperatures optimal for each enzyme's
activity and werethen adjusted to 10% mannitol before being mixed
with protoplasts.Each incubation duration was performed in duplicate
in threeindependent experiments with an average of 50 protoplasts
examinedat 0, 2, 4, 6, and 8 h . Data were expressed as percent
plasmolysis± SD for three independent experiments . Plasmolysis was
analyzed as a function of time, dilution, treatment, and their
interactions . Level of statistical significance of the different
variables was determined with an analysis of variance . Statistical
analysis was performed using SAS software and the general linear
model procedure [SAS Institute Inc.].
Mating experiments. For triparental matings, donor,
mobilizer, and recipient suspensionswere made in LB broth from
cultures grown on solid media underselective conditions, as
appropriate, for 18 h . Bacterial suspensionswere adjusted
spectrophotometrically [A600 = 0.5], mixed atan
equal ratio [1:1:1], and transferred to a positively chargedsterile
membrane layered on a 100- by 15-mm LB agar petri dish.Following a
6-h incubation period, the cells from the matingand respective
controls were washed twice in phosphate buffer[0.125 M, pH 7.1] by
centrifugation [12,096 x g for 10 min
at5°C] . The bacterial pellets were suspended in phosphate
buffer and dilution plated to media with appropriate antibiotic
selection . Single-colony isolates of individual transconjugantswere
obtained by streaking on selective media . Cultures weresubjected to
survey lysis followed by agarose gel electrophoresis[23]
to confirm plasmid transfer.
Plasposon mutagenesis. The plasposon pTnMod-RTp' was
employed to obtain initial ptw-negativemutants of strain K56-2 [15] .
Transconjugants were selectedon VBG supplemented with Tp . After 48 h
of incubation at 37°C,isolated colonies were transferred to
homologous media to confirmselection . Trimethoprim-resistant
transconjugants were evaluatedfor ptw activity by using the onion
tissue assay . Transconjugantsthat no longer demonstrated the ptw
phenotype were single-colonypurified, retested, and retained for
further analysis.
DNA isolation and sequence analysis. Genomic DNA was
extracted from plasposon-generated ptw-negativeK56-2 mutants using a
DNeasy kit [QIAGEN] . Three microgramsof DNA were digested with PstI
and self ligated by using T4DNA ligase [New England Biolabs] . The
resulting plasmids weretransformed into E . coli CC118 pir
by CaCl2 transformation [59]and were
selected on LB agar amended with Tp . Survey lysis andagarose gel
electrophoresis were conducted to confirm the presenceof plasmid DNA
in the transformants . Plasmid DNA for sequencingwas extracted using
a HiSpeed Plasmid Midi kit [QIAGEN] . Primersdesigned from the 5' and
3' termini of the plasposon insertwere designated RTp1 and RTp2
[Table 3], respectively, and wereused to sequence
the cloned genomic DNA from B . cenocepaciastrain K56-2 .
Sequencing was conducted by the Institute of Developmentaland
Molecular Biology, Gene Technologies Laboratory, Texas A&M
University . MacVector 7.0 [Oxford Molecular, Ltd.] was usedfor DNA
sequence analysis . DNA sequence for B . cenocepacia strain
J2315 was produced by the Pathogen Sequencing Group at the Sanger
Institute, Hinxton, Cambridge, and can be obtained from
http://www.sanger.ac.uk/Projects/B_cenocepacia/.
| TABLE 3 . Primers used in this study
|
|
Site-directed mutagenesis. Using PCR analysis, ptwD4,
ptwC, ptwB4, and ptwB10 were foundto be located on
two cosmids from a previously constructed K56-2library [62] .
Primer sets PD4 [PD4-1 and PD4-2], PC [PC-1 andPC-2], PB4 [PB4-1 and
PB4-2], and PB10 [PB10-1 and PB10-2] [Table3] were
designed based on sequence data from the B . cenocepaciaGenome
Project . Each PCR [50 µl] was performed using aTaq PCR Core
kit [QIAGEN] and a GeneAmp 2700 [Applied Biosystems].Reactions were
run for 25 cycles, and parameters were as follows:denaturation at
95°C for 30 s; annealing at 55, 52, 56.5,and 54°C for 1 min for
primer sets PD4, PC, PB4, and PB10,respectively; and extension at
72°C for 75 s . Resultingproducts were analyzed by agarose gel
electrophoresis . It wasdetermined that cosmid pSBC-9F5 contained
ptwD4 and ptwC andthat pSBC-3H3 harbored ptwB4 and
ptwB10, respectively . GenesptwD4, ptwC,
ptwB4, and ptwB10, were disrupted using site-directed
mutagenesis . A 10-kb BamHI fragment from pSBC-9F5 and an 11-kbBamHI
fragment from pSBC-3H3 were individually inserted intothe multiple
cloning site [MCS] of pJQ200SK [55] to construct
pASE102 and pASE103, respectively . Plasmids pASE102 and pASE103were
transformed into E . coli DH10B by electroporation [25 µF,2.5
kV, 200
]
followed by selection on LB agar amended withGm . Orientation of
inserted DNA was determined by restrictionenzyme digest analysis
using SmaI . Only plasmids containinginsertions that were in frame
were used in the subsequent experiments.Using pASE102, plasmids
pASE106 and pASE107 were constructedby inserting a Tc-resistance
cassette, obtained as a 1.9-kbfragment from pBR325 [4],
into the ScaI and EcoRV sites of ptwD4and ptwC,
respectively . Plasmids pASE108 and pASE109 were constructedby
inserting the Tc cassette into the ApaI and SacI sites ofptwB4
and ptwB10 of pASE103, respectively . Constructs pASE106,
pASE107, pASE108, and pASE109 were electroporated into E . coli
DH10B, and transformants were selected on LB agar amended withTc and
Gm . Insertion of the Tc resistance cassette was confirmedby
restriction enzyme digest analysis using BamHI and PCR usingprimer
sets PD4, PC, PB4, and PB10 to confirm a 1.9-kb increasein plasmid
size and PCR product, respectively . Plasmids pASE106,pASE107,
pASE108, and pASE109 were individually mobilized intoK56-2 by
utilizing pRK2013 in triparental matings to yield geneticexchange
mutants . Tetracycline-resistant transconjugants weresingle-colony
purified and retested for Tcr . PCR using primersets PD4,
PC, PB4, and PB10 and plasmid survey lysis were usedto confirm
allelic exchange, reflected by the increase in PCRproduct and loss
of the suicide vector . Single-colony isolateswere tested for the ptw
phenotype.
Genes virB6 and virB11, from the chromosomally located type
IV secretion system, were disrupted by site-directed mutagenesis.
Primer sets VB6 [VB6-1 and VB6-2] and VB11 [VB11-1 and VB11-2]
[Table 3] were designed based on sequence data from the Sanger
Centre . Each PCR was performed as described above, except that
the cycle parameters were as follows: denaturation at 95°Cfor 30 s;
annealing at 57.5 and 56°C for 1 min for primersets VB6 and VB11,
respectively; and extension at 72°C for75 s . PCR products were
individually ligated into vector pDrive[QIAGEN] and were transformed
into E . coli DH10B by electroporationfollowed by selection on
LB agar amended with Ap to yield pASE110and pASE111, respectively .
Genes virB6 and virB11 were excisedfrom pASE110 and
pASE111, respectively, by double digestionusing restriction enzymes
PstI and XhoI and were individuallyinserted into the MCS of pJQ200SK
to construct pASE112 and pASE113,respectively . Plasmids pASE112 and
pASE113 were transformedinto E . coli DH10B by electroporation
followed by selectionon LB agar amended with Gm . Using pASE112 and
pASE113, plasmidspASE114 and pASE115 were constructed by inserting a
Tc resistancecassette, from pBR325, into the ScaI site of virB6
or virB11,respectively . Constructs pASE114 and pASE115 were
individuallyelectroporated into E . coli DH10B and
transformants were selectedon LB agar amended with Tc and Gm .
Insertion of the Tc resistancecassette was confirmed by restriction
enzyme digest analysisusing BamHI and PCR primer sets VB6 and VB11
to confirm a 1.9-kbincrease in plasmid size and PCR product,
respectively . PlasmidspASE114 and pASE115 were individually
mobilized into K56-2 bytriparental matings to yield genetic exchange
mutants . Tetracycline-resistanttransconjugants were single-colony
purified and retested forTcr . PCR using primer sets VB6
and VB11 and plasmid survey lysiswere used to confirm allelic
exchange, reflected by the increasein PCR product and loss of the
suicide vector . Single-colonyisolates were tested for the ptw
phenotype.
Complementation of disrupted genes. Complementation of the
disrupted ptwD4, ptwB4, or ptwB10 was
accomplished in trans . Plasmid pURF047 [63] was
amended by insertinga Tp resistance cassette, obtained from R388 as
a BamHI fragment,into the ScaI site in the bla gene to obtain
pASE101 . A 10-kbBamHI fragment from pSBC-9F5 that contained ptwD4
and an 11-kbBamHI fragment from pSBC-3H3 that contained ptwB4
and ptwB11were individually inserted into the MCS of pASE101,
resultingin pASE104 and pASE105, respectively . Plasmids pASE104 and
pASE105were electrotransformed into E . coli DH10B, followed
by selectionon LB agar amended with Tp and Gm . Orientation of
inserted DNAwas determined by restriction enzyme digest analysis
using ScaI.Only plasmids containing in-frame insertions were
used in thesubsequent experiments . Plasmid pASE104 was mobilized
into AE307,and pASE105 was mobilized into AE321 and AE322 to
complementinsertionally disrupted ptw genes .
Tetracycline-resistant andTpr transconjugants were
single-colony purified and retestedfor antibiotic resistance .
Plasmid survey lysis and PCR wereused to confirm plasmid transfer,
which was reflected by thepresence of both the resident and
complement plasmid as wellas inserted and uninserted PCR products.
Isolation and characterization of ptw-negative mutants. A total
of 5,000 transconjugants of strain K56-2 were obtainedby using the
plasposon mutagenesis system . Genomic DNA from20 randomly selected
transconjugants were digested with PstI,which does not cleave the
TnMod-RTp' insert . The DNA fragmentswere separated by agarose gel
electrophoresis, and Southernblots were probed with the Tp cassette
to determine the randomnessof insertion . It was determined that the
plasposon system wassuitable for the generation of random mutations
in the genomeof B . cenocepacia strain K56-2 [data not shown].
From the pool of 5,000 transconjugants, 56 mutants were verified
as ptw-negative using the plant tissue assay [Fig . 1] and
demonstratedno other apparent phenotypic differences compared to
phenotypeof the parental strain . The DNA flanking the plasposon
insertionsite of 10 ptw-negative mutants was cloned and sequenced,
anda BLAST search was performed . The translated gene products
disruptedin clones GM237 and GM242 [Table 2]
showed homology to VirD4-likeproteins, whereas GM241 and GM243
[Table 2] showed homologyto a putative regulator
and promoter, respectively . Thus, ourinitial inquiry was focused on
determining if strain K56-2 possessedand/or utilized a similar
transfer system . Characterizationof the remaining ptw-negative
mutants will be addressed in aseparate report.
|
FIG . 1 . Plant tissue watersoaking assay . [A] Pierced onion bulb scale
inoculated with B . cenocepacia strain K56-2 showing partial
tissue collapse and translucence characteristic of the ptw phenotype .
[B] Pierced onion bulb scale inoculated with sterile water [ptw
negative] . [C] Pierced onion bulb scale inoculated with ptw-negative
mutant AE307 . All ptw-negative mutants expressed no ptw activity on
onion tissue, and inoculated scales showed the same symptoms as that in
panel C.
|
|
Using sequence data from the B . cenocepacia Genome Project,a
60-kb region proximal to the identified virD4-like gene was
analyzed . Strain J2315, the subject of the genome sequence project,
is a member of the ET12 clonal lineage, as is strain K56-2 [47],
and hence the arrangement of genes and their sequence was expected
to be similar . A cluster of 11 genes potentially involved in
the delivery of the ptw effector[s] was identified and designatedthe
ptw cluster [Fig . 2] . Southern analysis of K56-2
lysates[data not shown] determined that the ptw cluster was
locatedon a 92-kb resident plasmid . Other isolates of the ET12
lineage[J2315, BC7, and C5424] were also shown to harbor the ptw
clusteron their resident plasmids [data not shown] . The resident
plasmid,designated pK56-2, has a G-C ratio of 62.7%, and the ptw
clusterhas a G-C ratio of 61%, whereas the value for the whole
genomeis 66.9%.
|
FIG . 2 . A 45-kb segment from plasmid pK56-2 containing the ptw
cluster . Designation of genes was based on homology to gene products of
transfer- and translocation-related proteins and are depicted by solid
arrows . Open reading frames having no homologs are illustrated by
patterned arrows.
|
|
DNA sequence and protein similarities of the ptw cluster.
The encoded products of the ptw cluster showed homology to various
translocation and/or conjugation related proteins from other
bacteria, including Agrobacterium tumefaciens, Salmonella enterica
serovar Typhi, Vibrio cholerae, Novosphingobium aromaticivorans,
and E . coli . Based on amino acid sequence similarity to TraD
and other VirD4-like proteins, the predicted function of ptwD4
could involve nucleoside triphosphatase activity [NTPase] and
may therefore serve as an active motor for secretion [60,
61].PtwB4 and its homolog VirB4 of the VirB-VirD
system may alsoexhibit NTPase activity [2] . Based
on homology to R388 TrwC,PtwC may function as a component of a
relaxosome [44] . PtwB7,PtwB8, PtwB9, and PtwB10
were predicted to form complexes inthe periplasm and/or membrane to
create the pore [74] . PtwB11was also predicted to
have NTPase activity and is part of theTraG subfamily, which belongs
to the large superfamily of typeII/IV secretion NTPases [53] .
PtwN, as well as PtwU, had noVirB-VirD homologs; however, they
possessed homology to TraNand TraU of the F plasmid, respectively .
In the F plasmid systemTraN is an adhesin and TraU is involved in
mating pair stabilization[38].
Based on analysis of gene products with sequence similarityand
the probable involvement in the expression of the ptw phenotype,
ptwD4, ptwC, ptwB4, and ptwB10 were chosen for further
analysis.Translation of the ptwD4 sequence resulted in a
protein thatwas 640 amino acids in length, with a predicted
molecular sizeof 72 kDa and a pI of 6.6 . Further analysis of the
PtwD4 aminoacid sequence, using reverse position specific BLAST
[rpsBLAST]and the conserved domain database, revealed a predicted
WalkerA [P-loop] and B site for nucleotide binding [70]
that is characteristicof type IV secretion ATP-binding proteins [74] .
The predictedP-loop nucleotide binding motif extends from 117 to 124
in theamino acid sequence, and the Walker B motif extends from 338
to 344 . The translated sequence of ptwB4 was 1,013 amino acids
in length, with a predicted molecular size of 108 kDa and apI
of 6.0 . Further analysis of the PtwB4 amino acid sequencefor
hydrophobicity revealed four putative transmembrane domains,which is
characteristic of type IV secretion NTPases [74] . Translation
of the ptwB10 sequence resulted in a protein that was 278 amino
acids in length, with a predicted molecular size of 30 kDa and
a pI of 5.2 . Using rpsBLAST and the conserved domain database,PtwB10
was shown to contain a well-conserved C-terminal hydrophobicregion [74] .
Translation of the ptwC sequence resulted in aprotein that
was 940 amino acids in length, with a predictedmolecular size of 104
kDa and a pI of 6.0 . A Pustell proteinmatrix analysis comparing PtwC
and TrwC from R388 illustratedregions of similarity between the
sequences . At the N terminus[amino acids 1 to 200], PtwC and TrwC
showed 42% identity andsignature motifs [2 and 3] that are conserved
in proteins withDNA-nicking activities [44] . An
analysis of the PtwC C-terminalsequence indicated that PtwC
contained 7 motifs [I, Ib, II,III, IV, V, and IV] characteristic of
helicases [28].
Site-directed disruption of the ptw or virB-virD4
clusters and its effect on the ptw phenotype. Translated products of
the ptw cluster showed homology to proteinsfrom known type IV
secretion systems . Based on their predictedfunction, the role of
ptwD4, ptwC, ptwB4, and ptwB10 in the
expression of the ptw phenotype was determined . Watersoakingmutants
of K56-2 with a disrupted ptwD4 were obtained in theinitial
screening of the plasposon generated mutants and bysite-directed
mutagenesis [Fig . 1 and Table 2] .
Site-directedmutagenesis of ptwD4, ptwC, ptwB4,
and ptwB10 was accomplishedby individual mobilization of
pASE106, pASE107, pASE108, andpASE109, respectively, into K56-2 .
Tetracycline-resistant transconjugantsshowed a 1.9-kb increase in
PCR product, which reflected theinsertion of the Tc cassette [data
not shown] . Insertions inptwD4, ptwB4, and ptwB10
resulted in loss of the ptw phenotype,whereas disruption of ptwC
did not . Representative insertionallyinactivated ptw-negative
mutants of ptwD4, ptwB4, and ptwB10were
designated AE307, AE321, and AE322, respectively, whereasthe
inserted ptwC derivative was designated AE320.
Complementation of ptw-negative mutants was accomplished by
mobilization of pASE104 into AE307 and pASE105 into AE321 orAE322
and selecting for Tcr and Tpr transconjugants . All
transconjugantstested were ptw positive [Fig . 3] .
Plasmid pURF047 derivativeswere used in complementation studies,
because pURF047 is a derivativeof pURF034 that contains the par
locus and is maintained stablywithout selective pressure [>95%
retention over 36 generations],which was a desirable parameter for
plant tissue studies [14].A survey of
transconjugant lysates confirmed plasmid transfer[data not shown] .
Representatives of ptw-positive complementedptwD4, ptwB4,
and ptwB10 mutants were designated AE310, AE323,and AE324,
respectively [Fig . 3].
|
FIG . 3 . Complementation of ptw-negative mutants . [A] Pierced onion bulb
scale inoculated with strain K56-2 showing characteristic ptw activity .
[B] Pierced onion bulb scale inoculated with B . cenocepacia
ptw-negative mutant AE307 showing no ptw activity . [C] Pierced onion
bulb scale inoculated with complemented AE307 [AE310] showing restored
ptw activity.
|
|
Genomic analysis of the J2315 sequence from the Sanger Centre
identified a second cluster on chromosome II, which showed homology
to the VirB-VirD type IV secretion system [Fig . 4] . Using PCR
analysis, the presence of virB1, virB4, virB6,
virB11, and virD4[Table 3], which span
the entire virB-virD cluster, were confirmedin K56-2 [data
not shown] . In A . tumefaciens, virB6 is thoughtto
mediate assembly of the pilus and a functional secretionmachine
through its effects on virB7 and virB9 multimerization
[31], and virB11 is predicted to function as an
NTPase, whichprovides the necessary energy for secretion [74] .
Based on theirpredicted function, the role of virB6 and
virB11 in the expressionof the ptw phenotype was assessed .
Site-directed mutagenesisof virB6 and virB11 was
accomplished by individual mobilizationof pASE114 and pASE115 into
K56-2, yielding AE360 and AE361,respectively . Tetracycline-resistant
transconjugants showeda 1.9-kb increase in PCR product, which
reflected the insertionof the Tc cassette [data not shown] .
Disruption of virB6 orvirB11 did not result in loss of
the ptw phenotype.
|
FIG . 4 . A 12-kb segment containing a VirB-VirD-like type IV secretion
system cluster located on chromosome II of B . cenocepacia strain
J2315 . Designation of genes was based on homology to gene products of
transfer- and translocation-related proteins and are depicted as solid
arrows . Genes virB1, virB4, virB6, virB11,
and virD4 have been identified in strain K56-2.
|
|
Partial characterization of watersoaking effector[s] and population
dynamics. Plant tissue assays indicated that the parental strain K56-2
and the complemented mutant [AE310] caused watersoaking, whereas
the ptwD4 mutant [AE307] did not [Fig . 3] . Growth
and watersoakingwere monitored over a 72-h period using the plant
tissue assayto determine the contribution of ptw activity in
survival andgrowth . Over the 72-h period both K56-2 and AE310 showed
anapproximate 100-fold increase in CFU/gram of tissue and an
increasein the watersoaking area, whereas AE307 showed no
watersoakingactivity and an approximate 1,000-fold decrease in
CFU/gramof tissue over the same period [Table 4].
| TABLE 4 . Growth and watersoaking activity of B . cenocepacia
strain K56-2 and its derivatives in onion tissue
|
|
Based on analysis of the ptw cluster and the putative role of
a type IV secretion system in the export of an effector molecule[s],
it was of interest to determine if culture supernatant concentrates
showed effector activity . Over an 8-h duration, carrot protoplasts
exposed to M9 medium concentrate did not experience significant
plasmolysis compared to that of the protoplast controls [P >
0.05] [Table 5] . However, significant [P
0.05] plasmolysiswas observed for protoplasts exposed to the K56-2
or complementedmutant [AE310] concentrates as early as 2 h, and
plasmolysisincreased at a significant rate for dilutions tested [up
to1:5] over the 8-h time period compared to that of medium controls.
Concentrated supernatant from the ptwD4 mutant [AE307] caused
6.7% plasmolysis after 8 h, which was not statistically different
[P > 0.05] from plasmolysis resulting from treatment with
medium controls . Dilution of the K56-2 and AE310 concentrates
to a protein concentration of 0.02 µg/ml reduced activityto levels
which approximated those of the control and AE307.Temperatures of
37, 65, and 80°C for 1 h or 100°C for10 min did not affect the
plasmolysis activity of the K56-2concentrate . Complete inactivation
of plasmolysis activity wasobserved when the K56-2 concentrate was
treated with proteinaseK; however, incubation with DNase I or RNase
A showed no effecton activity.
| TABLE 5 . Effect of supernatant concentrates from K56-2, ptwD4
mutant [AE307], and complemented ptwD4 mutant [AE310] on carrot
protoplasts
|
|
Previously, the role of a polygalacturonase [PehA] as a virulence
factor in B . cepacia strain ATCC 25416 was investigated [24].
Derivatives cured of a resident plasmid that codes for the PehA
no longer macerated onion tissue; however, the derivatives still
produced a phenotype described as ptw . Of interest in the present
study was the observation that all B . cepacia and B . cenocepacia
isolates and a B . vietnamiensis strain from the Bcc experimental
strain panel [47] produced the ptw phenotype in onion
tissue[50] . In this study K56-2, a B .
cenocepacia strain that producedthe plant disease-associated
phenotype, was genetically analyzedand found to contain a
plasmid-borne gene cluster, designatedptw, that encodes a
type IV secretion system responsible forthe translocation of the ptw
effector protein[s].
The identified gene products in the ptw cluster had homology
to proteins from known type IV secretion systems . Bacteria have
evolved type IV secretion systems to transfer DNA or protein
macromolecules to a wide array of target cell types [2,
10,52] . Originally, the
nomenclature referred to the VirB-VirD-encodedtranslocation system
of A . tumefaciens and two closely relatedsystems encoded by
the transfer region of the IncN plasmid pKM101and the ptl
operon of Bordetella pertussis [10] . In the past
decade, the type IV family has expanded considerably in number
with the relaxation of defining criteria . Currently, type IV
secretion systems are defined as translocation systems ancestrally
related to any conjugation system of gram-negative or -positive
bacteria [10, 25] . However, it is
important to distinguish functionaltranslocation machines from
mobile elements characteristicallyfound in bacterial genomes . Ding
et al . [18] have suggestedthat mutagenesis of a
putative type IV system should yield aphenotype at least consistent
with a translocation defect.
Christie [10] has suggested subclassification of type IV
secretionsystems based on ancestral lineage . Thus, the VirB-VirD
typehas been designated IVA, and the ColIb-P9 Tra and L .
pneumophilaDot-Icm types have been designated IVB . This
subclassificationleft open the possibility of further division of
gram-negativeand -positive secretion systems that differ from IVA
and IVB.Therefore, an alternative grouping scheme has been suggested
by Ding et al . [18] that separates systems based on
functionand does not replace the one previously described but rather
expands its usefulness . This classification method groups type
IV secretion systems as [i] conjugation systems, [ii] effector
translocator systems, or [iii] DNA uptake or release systems[18] .
By definition, the conjugation systems deliver DNA substratesby
establishing direct physical contact with target cells . Examples
include the well-studied A . tumefaciens T-DNA transfer system
and the F, RP4, and R388 plasmid transfer systems . Althoughthe
conjugation systems are known mainly for their role in distributing
DNA among bacterial populations, they can also translocate protein
substrates independently of DNA [73] . There is also a subset
of these systems that can transfer DNA and protein substrates
to a range of eukaryotic cell types, including plant, fungal,and
human [3, 71, 72] . Most
of the members of the type IV effectortranslocator group inject
their substrates directly into theeukaryotic cytosol . This type of
translocation is now recognizedas the dominant virulence mechanism
of the phytopathogen A.tumefaciens and of several medically
important pathogens, includingH . pylori, L . pneumophila,
Brucella spp., and Bartonella spp.[7] .
Also included in this subfamily is the Ptl system of B.pertussis,
even though this system exports its protein substrateindependently
of host-cell contact . Presently, at least 10 typeIVA and several
type IVB systems can be grouped as effectortranslocators and are
thought to be essential for infection[18] . The
DNA uptake and release group, which presently containsthree members,
translocates DNA substrates across the cell envelopeto or from the
extracellular milieu [18] . Neisseria gonorrhoeae
uses a system encoded by the gonococcal genetic island to export
DNA [17, 26] . Recent studies have
established that this systemis very closely related to the F plasmid
conjugation systemof E . coli, even though it is not
performing the same function[17] . The two other
members of this subfamily, Campylobacterjejuni and H .
pylori, translocate DNA in the opposite direction,promoting
genetic variation and cell survival [1, 29].
A notable feature of the type IV secretion systems is their
extreme versatility . These systems can recognize a wide arrayof DNA
and protein substrates, translocate substrates by both
cell-contact-dependent and -independent mechanisms, and deliver
substrates to an exceptionally wide range of prokaryotic and
eukaryotic taxa [18] . The ptw cluster contains
homologs to componentsof multiple type IV secretion systems [Fig.
2] . With respectto function, the plasmid-encoded
type IV secretion system wehave identified in B . cenocepacia
strain K56-2 was involvedin export of an effector[s] that was
responsible for the ptwphenotype . The facts that the Ptw system was
involved in thetranslocation of a protein[s], that it did not
contain all ofthe necessary genetic components to support
conjugation, andthat no oriT homolog was identified indicate
that functionallyit is a member of the effector translocator
subfamily . The differencein the G-C ratio between pK56-2 harboring
the ptw cluster [62.7%]and the G-C ratio for the entire B .
cenocepacia genome [66.9%]suggests acquisition by horizontal
transfer [34].
The presence of a second type IV secretion system in B . cenocepacia
is not unprecedented, because many bacteria, such as H . pylori
and A . tumefaciens, have been found to harbor multiple secretion
systems [18, 35] . The type IV
secretion system located on chromosomeII showed most similarity to
that of the A . tumefaciens VirB-VirDtranslocation system with
respect to arrangement and gene productsimilarity [Fig.
4] . The difference in the G-C ratio of the
chromosomally located type IV secretion system [63%] and theG-C
ratio of the entire genome [66.9%] suggests horizontal acquisition[34],
as with the Ptw translocation system . Evidence suggeststhat the Ptw
system is responsible for export of the protein[s]involved in
expression of the ptw phenotype; however, the substrate[s]
translocated by the VirB-D4 system is unknown.
Identification of a cluster of genes that encoded proteins with
similarities to components of a type IV secretion system allowedfor
strategic generation of K56-2 mutants to support the hypothesisthat
such a system was involved in expression of the ptw phenotype.The
genes selected for functional characterization were ptwD4,
ptwC, ptwB4, and ptwB10 . VirD4-like proteins [PtwD4 homologs]
are cytoplasmic membrane NTP-binding proteins that are essential
for coupling the relaxosome to the macromolecular transport
system [51, 61] . It is thought to interact
with the oriT-boundrelaxosome, which is made up of TrwC and
TrwA, to facilitateDNA transfer [19,
45] . In the Ptw system, however, there isno TrwA
homolog . The ptwD4 product appears to have functionssimilar
to those of Hp0524 of H . pylori . The hp0524 productis
critical for the transfer of CagA from the bacterium to epithelial
cells [21] . Further analysis revealed that the PtwD4 amino
acidsequence contained P-loop and Walker B sites, which are
characteristicof type IV secretion ATP-binding proteins . The ptwC
producthad homology to TrwC, which is both a relaxase that cleaves
at the nic site within the oriT in a strand- and
sequence-specificmanner, and a helicase, which is essential for
transfer [48,49] . Analysis of
PtwC revealed that the N terminus possessedsignature motifs [2 and
3] conserved in proteins with DNA-nickingactivities [44],
and the C terminus possessed signature motifs[I, Ib, II, III, IV, V,
and VI] conserved in DNA helicases [28];however,
there is no identified oriT to facilitate the cleavageand
thus linearization required for DNA transfer . VirB10, thePtwB10
homolog, is a protein located in the periplasmic spacethat is
believed to form the core of the transfer machineryand is possibly
part of the pore that spans the inner and outermembranes [74] .
PtwB10 was shown to contain the C-terminal hydrophobicregion that is
characteristic of VirB10-like proteins . PtwB4showed similarity to
VirB4 of A . tumefaciens, which is a putativenucleoside
triphosphatase that may also serve as an active motorfor secretion [74] .
The PtwB4 amino acid sequence was shownto possess four transmembrane
regions that are characteristicof VirB4-like NTPases [74] .
The ptw phenotype was not expressedby K56-2 derivatives with a
disruption in ptwD4, ptwB4, or ptwB10but was
expressed by a derivative with a disruption in ptwC.These
results correlated with the predicted function of thegene products,
because successful secretion of the ptw effectorprotein[s] would
likely involve the following: a protein thatpotentially couples the
moiety to the secretion system and suppliesthe necessary energy for
export [PtwD4]; a protein that actsin the assembly of the pore
necessary for the passage of thesubstrate and provides energy
necessary for the system to function[PtwB4]; and a protein involved
in structural formation of apore [PtwB10], but not one involved in
the generation of a relaxosome[PtwC].
By combining mutational analysis with cytotoxic assays employing
both plant tissue and protoplasts, we have identified a typeIV
secretion system that appears to export an effector molecule[s]that
is proteinaceous in nature and is responsible for the activity.This
activity plays an important role in the ability of B . cenocepacia
strain K56-2 to cause watersoaking and to grow in plant tissue
[Fig . 2, Table 4] . It appears that in the
plant tissue assaythe role of the effector[s] is to provide
bacterial cells withneeded nutrients by causing leakage of the plant
cell cytosol.Presently, the role of the putative virulence effector
protein[s]in contributing to growth and infection in a pulmonary
environmentis unknown; however, the ptw phenotype appears to be
commonamong isolates belonging to B . cenocepacia that infect
CF patients.
Protein DspE of Erwinia amylovora and WtsE of Pantoea stewartii
subsp . stewartii are involved in elicitation of the watersoaking
phenotype in their respective hosts . The dspE product is a 198-kDa
protein that is required for the production of fireblight disease
symptoms that include watersoaking of apple and pear tissue[5] .
A disruption in wtsE renders P . stewartii subsp . stewartii
incapable of eliciting an observable watersoaking phenotypeand
causing a systemic corn leaf infection [22] . In contrast
to the ptw effector molecule[s], a type III secretion systemis
presumed to export DspE and WtsE from the phytopathogen tothe plant
hosts.
There are two types of substrates typically transported by both
type III and type IV secretion systems [52, 58] .
The first groupalters host processes by mimicking the function of a
eukaryoticprotein . Substrate proteins in this category, however, do
nothave significant sequence similarities with the eukaryotic factor
they mimic, which makes identification difficult . The second
class are genes that were "stolen" from eukaryotic host cellsand
then reshaped . The RalF protein of the L . pneumophila Dot/Icm
system falls into the latter group [52] . Substrates in this
category are relatively easy to identify with genomic analysis.
Secreted substrates from either group can vary in size from
22
kDa for A . tumefaciens VirF to
145
kDa for H . pylori CagA.They also vary in composition, from
monomers to multisubunitstructures that may include protein and/or
DNA [18] . Thus, thereare no universally conserved
primary sequence motifs or physicalcharacteristics that are readily
discernible for secreted effectors.
In conclusion, our study has identified a plasmid-encoded typeIV
secretion system in B . cenocepacia strain K56-2 that was
functionally an effector translocator . The chromosomally locatedtype
IV secretion system showed modular similarity to the A.
tumefaciens VirB-VirD translocation system; however, it wasnot
responsible for the ptw phenotype in B . cenocepacia strain
K56-2.
There are multiple examples for the role of type IV secretion
systems in translocation of both plasmid DNA and proteins associated
with plant and human pathogenesis [9, 10] .
The role of thisputative virulence effector[s] in contributing to
disease isbeing determined in studies using a murine model of
pulmonaryinfection . Studies to identify the structural gene[s] for
theeffector protein[s] and regulatory subunits are in progress.
We are grateful to Pamela Sokol for providing K56-2 genomiclibrary
blots, to James Samuel for his critical reading of themanuscript,
and James Starr for his statistical help . We alsothank Michael B .
Willett, Bianca S . Batista, Francisco Vielma,and Arwyn Hood for
their technical assistance.
This work was supported by grant GONZAL03G0 from the Cystic
Fibrosis Foundation.
* Corresponding author . Mailing address: Department of Plant
Pathology & Microbiology, Texas A&M University, 2132 TAMU, College Station, TX
77843 . Phone: [979] 845-7610 . Fax: [979] 845-6483 . E-mail: cf-gonzalez@tamu.edu .
Present address: Cotton Pathology Research Laboratory, USDA,ARS,
SPARC, College Station, TX 77845.
- Bacon, D . J., R . A . Alm, D . H . Burr, L . Hu, D . J . Kopecko, D .
P . Ewing, T . J . Trust, and P . Guerry. 2000 . Involvement of a plasmid in
virulence of Campylobacter jejuni 81-176 . Infect . Immun . 68:4384-4390 .
- Baron, C., D . O'Callaghan, and E . Lanka. 2002 . Bacterial
secrets of secretion: Euro conference on the biology of type IV secretion
processes . Mol . Microbiol . 43:1359-1365.
- Bates, S., A . M . Cashmore, and B . M . Wilkins. 1998 . IncP
plasmids are unusually effective in mediating conjugation of Escherichia
coli and Saccharomyces cerevisiae . J . Bacteriol . 180:6538-6543 .
- Blank, R . D., and D . B . Wilson. 1982 . Isolation and
characterization of a 2000-bp derivative of pBR322 . Plasmid 7:278-289.
- Bogdanove, A . J., J . F . Kim, Z . Wei, P . Kolchinsky, A . O .
Charakowski, A . K . Conlin, A . Collmer, and S . V . Beer. 1998 . Homology and
functional similarity of an hrp-linked pathogenicity locus, dspEF, of
Erwinia amylovora and the avirulence locus avrE of
Pseudomonas syringae pathovar tomato . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 95:1325-1330 .
- Boyer, H., and D . Roulland-Dussoix. 1969 . A
complementation analysis of the restriction and modification DNA in
Escherichia coli . J . Mol . Biol . 41:115-117.
- Burns, D . L. 2003 . Type IV transporters of pathogenic
bacteria . Curr . Opin . Microbiol . 6:29-34.
- Chen, J . S., K . A . Witzmann, T . Spiker, R . J . Fink, and J . J .
LiPuma. 2001 . Endemicity and inter-city spread of Burkholderia cepacia
genomovar III in cystic fibrosis . J . Pediatr . 139:643-649.
- Christie, P . J., and J . P . Vogel. 2000 . Bacterial type IV
secretion: conjugation systems adapted to deliver effector molecules to host
cells . Trends Microbiol . 8:354-360.
- Christie, P . J. 2001 . Type IV secretion: intercellular
transfer of macromolecules by systems ancestrally related to conjugation
machines . Mol . Microbiol . 40:294-305.
- Coenye, T., P . Vandamme, J . R . W . Govan, and J . J . LiPuma.
2001 . Taxonomy and identification of the Burkholderia cepacia complex .
J . Clin . Microbiol . 39:3427-3436.
- Coenye, T., and J . J . LiPuma. 2002 . Multilocus
restriction typing: a novel tool for studying global epidemiology of
Burkholderia cepacia complex infection in cystic fibrosis . J . Infect . Dis.
185:1454-1462.
- Datta, N., and R . W . Hedges. 1972 . Trimethoprim
resistance conferred by W plasmids in Enterobacteriaceae . J . Gen . Microbiol.
72:349-355.
- DeFeyter, R., C . I . Kado, and D . W . Gabriel. 1990 .
Small, stable shuttle vectors for use in Xanthomonas . Gene 88:65-72.
- Dennis, J . J., and G . J . Zylstra. 1998 . Plasposons:
modular self-cloning minitransposon derivatives for rapid genetic analysis of
gram-negative bacterial genomes . Appl . Environ . Microbiol . 64:2710-2715 .
- Dhar, S . K., R . K . Soni, B . K . Das, and G . Mukhopadhyay.
2003 . Molecular mechanism of action of major Helicobacter pylori
virulence factors . Mol . Cell . Biochem . 253:207-215.
- Dillard, J . P., and H . S . Seifert. 2001 . A variable
genetic island specific for Neisseria gonorrhoeae is involved in
providing DNA for natural transformation and is found more often in
disseminated infection isolates . Mol . Microbiol . 41:263-277.
- Ding, Z., K . Atmakuri, and P . J . Christie. 2003 . The
outs and ins of bacterial type IV secretion substrates . Trends Microbiol .
11:527-535.
- Fekete, R . A., and L . S . Frost. 2000 . Mobilization of
chimeric oriT plasmids by F and R100-1: role of relaxosome formation in
defining plasmid specificity . J . Bacteriol . 182:4022-4027 .
- Figurski, D., and D . R . Helinski. 1979 . Replication of
an origin-containing derivative of plasmid RK2 dependent on a plasmid function
provided in trans . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 76:1648-1652.
- Fischer, W., J . Puls, R . Buhrdorf, B . Gebert, S . Odenbreit,
and R . Hass. 2001 . Systemic mutagenesis of the Helicobacter pylori cag
pathogenicity island: essential genes for CagA translocation in host cells and
induction of interleukin-8 . Mol . Microbiol . 42:1337-1348.
- Frederick, R . D., M . Ahmad, D . R . Majerczak, A . S .
Arroyo-Rodriguez, S . Manulis, and D . L . Coplin. 2001 . Genetic organization
of the Pantoea stewartii subsp . stewartii hrp gene cluster and
sequence analysis of the hrpA, hrpC, hrpN, and wtsE
operons . Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 14:1213-1222.
- Gonzalez, C . F., and A . K . Vidaver. 1979 . Bacteriocin,
plasmid, and pectolytic diversity in Pseudomonas cepacia of clinical
and plant origin . J . Gen . Microbiol . 110:161-170.
- Gonzalez, C . F., E . A . Pettit, V . A . Valadez, and E . Provin.
1997 . Mobilization, cloning, and sequence determination of a plasmid-encoded
polygalacturonase from a phytopathogenic Burkholderia [Pseudomonas]
cepacia . Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 10:840-851.
- Grohmann, E., G . Muth, and M . Espinosa. 2003 .
Conjugative plasmid transfer in gram-positive bacteria . Microbiol . Mol . Biol .
Rev . 67:277-301 .
- Hamilton, H . I., K . J . Schwartz, and J . P . Dillard.
2001 . Insertion-duplication mutagenesis of Neisseria: use in
characterization of DNA transfer genes in the gonococcal genetic island . J .
Bacteriol . 186:4718-4726.
- Herrero, M., V . de Lorenzo, and K . N . Timmis. 1990 .
Transposon vectors containing non-antibiotic resistance selection markers for
cloning and stable chromosomal insertion of foreign genes in gram-negative
bacteria . J . Bacteriol . 172:6557-6567.
- Hodgman, T . C. 1988 . A new superfamily of replicative
proteins . Nature 333:22-23.
- Hofreuter, D., S . Odenbreit, and R . Haas. 2001 . Natural
transformation competence in Helicobacter pylori is mediated by the
basic components of a type IV secretion system . Mol . Microbiol . 41:379-391.
- Hutchison M . L., I . R . Poxton, and J . R . W . Govan. 1998.
Burkholderia cepacia produces a hemolysin that is capable of inducing
apoptosis and degranulation of mammalian phagocytes . Infect . Immun . 66:2033-2039 .
- Jakubowski, S . J., V . Krishnamoorthy, and P . J . Christie.
2003 . Agrobacterium tumefaciens VirB6 protein participates in formation
of VirB7 and VirB9 complexes required for type IV secretion . J . Bacteriol .
185:2867-2878 .
- Johnson, W . M., S . D . Tyler, and K . R . Rozee. 1994 .
Linkage analysis of geographic and clinical clusters in Pseudomonas cepacia
infections by multilocus enzyme electrophoresis and ribotyping . J . Clin .
Microbiol . 32:924-930.
- Jones, R . W., A . O . Jackson, and T . H . Morris. 1990 .
Defective-interfering RNAs and elevated temperatures inhibit replication of
tomato bushy stunt virus in inoculated protoplasts . Virology 176:539-545.
- Karlin, S. 2001 . Detecting anomalous gene clusters and
pathogenicity islands in diverse bacterial genomes . Trends Microbiol . 9:335-343.
- Kersulyte, D., B . Velapatino, A . K . Mukhopadhyay, L .
Cahuayne, A . Bussalleu, J . Combe, R . H . Gilman, and D . E . Berg. 2003 .
Cluster of type IV secretion genes in Helicobacter pylori's plasticity
zone . J . Bacteriol . 185:3764-3772 .
- Koch, A., and S . Putnam. 1971 . Sensitive biuret method
for determination of protein in an impure system such as whole bacteria . Anal .
Biochem . 44:239-245.
- Kumar, R . B., and A . Das. 2002 . Polar location and
functional domains of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens DNA transfer
protein VirD4 . Mol . Microbiol . 43:1523-1532.
- Lawley, T . D., W . A . Klimke, M . J . Gubbins, and L . S . Frost.
2003 . F factor conjugation is a true type IV secretion system . FEMS Microbiol .
Lett . 224:1-15.
- Ledson, M . J., M . J . Gallagher, M . Jackson, C . A . Hart, and
M . J . Walshaw. 2002 . Outcome of Burkholderia cepacia colonization
in an adult cystic fibrosis centre . Thorax 57:142-145 .
- Lewenza, S., B . Conway, E . P . Greenberg, and P . A . Sokol.
1999 . Quorum sensing in Burkholderia cepacia: identification of the
LuxRI homologs CepRI . J . Bacteriol . 181:748-756 .
- LiPuma, J . J. 1998 . Burkholderia cepacia—management
issues and new insights . Clin . Chest Med . 19:473-486.
- LiPuma, J . J., T . Spilker, L . Gill, P . W . Campbell, L . Liu,
and E . Mahenthiralingam. 2001 . Disproportionate distribution of
Burkholderia cepacia complex species and transmissibility factors in
cystic fibrosis . Am . J . Resp . Crit . Care Med . 164:92-96 .
- LiPuma, J . J. 2003 . Burkholderia cepacia complex
as human pathogens . J . Nematol . 35:212-217.
- Llosa, M., S . Bolland, and F . de la Cruz. 1994 . Genetic
organization of the conjugal DNA processing region of the IncW plasmid R388 .
J . Mol . Biol . 233:448-464.
- Llosa, M., S . Zunzunegui, and F . de la Cruz. 2003 .
Conjugative coupling proteins interact with cognate and heterologous
VirB10-like proteins while exhibiting specificity for cognate relaxosomes .
Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 100:10465-10470 .
- Macnab, R . M. 1999 . The bacterial flagellum: reversible
rotary propeller and type III export apparatus . J . Bacteriol . 181:7149-7153.
- Mahenthiralingam, E., T . Coenye, J . W . Chung, D . P . Speert,
J . R . W . Govan, P . Taylor, and P . Vandamme. 2000 . Diagnostically and
experimentally useful panel of strains from the Burkholderia cepacia
complex . J . Clin . Microbiol . 38:910-913 .
- Matson, S . W., W . C . Nelson, and B . S . Morton. 1993 .
Characterization of the reaction product of the ortT nicking reaction
catalyzed by Escherichia coli DNA helicase I . J . Bacteriol . 175:2599-2606.
- Matson, S . W., J . K . Sampson, and D . R . N . Byrd. 2001 . F
plasmid conjugative DNA transfer . J . Biol . Chem . 276:2372-2379 .
- Medrano, E . G. 2002 . Ph.D . thesis . Texas A&M University,
College Station, Tex.
- Moncalián, G., E . Cabe
on,
I . Alkorta, M . Valle, F . Moro, J . M . Valpuesta, F . M . Goñi, and F . de la Cruz.
1999 . Characterization of ATP and DNA binding activities of TrwB, the coupling
protein essential in plasmid R388 conjugation . J . Biol . Chem . 274:36117-36124 .
- Nagai, H., and C . R . Roy. 2003 . Show me the substrates:
modulation of host cell function by type IV secretion systems . Cell .
Microbiol . 5:373-383.
- Planet, P . J., S . C . Kachlany, R . DeSalle, and D . H .
Figurski. 2001 . Phylogeny of genes for secretion NTPases: identification
of the widespread tadA subfamily and development of a diagnostic key
for gene classification . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 98:2503-2508 .
- Plano, G . V., J . B . Day, and F . Ferracci. 2001 . Type III
export: new uses for an old pathway . Mol . Microbiol . 40:284-293.
- Quandt, J., and M . F . Hynes. 1993 . Versatile suicide
vectors which allow direct selection for gene replacement in gram-negative
bacteria . Gene 127:15-21.
- Sajjan, U . S., F . A . Sylvester, and J . Forstner. 2000 .
Cable-piliated Burkholderia cepacia binds to cytokeratin 13 of
epithelial cells . Infect . Immun . 68:1787 .
- Sajjan, U . S., Y . Wu, G . Kent, and J . Forstner. 2000 .
Preferential adherence of cable-piliated Burkholderia cepacia to
respiratory epithelia of CF knockout mice and human CF lung explants . J . Med .
Microbiol . 49:875-882 .
- Salmond, G . P . C. 1994 . Secretion of extracellular
virulence factors by plant pathogenic bacteria . Annu . Rev . Phytopathol . 32:181-200.
- Sambrook, J., E . F . Fritsch, and T . Maniatis. 1989 .
Molecular cloning: a laboratory manual, 2nd ed . Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
Press, Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y.
- Schröder, G., S . Krause, E . L . Zechner, B . Traxler, H . Yeo,
R . Lurz, G . Waksman, and E . Lanka. 2002 . TraG-like proteins of DNA
transfer systems and of the Helicobacter pylori type IV secretion
system: inner membrane gate for exported substrates? J . Bacteriol . 184:2767-2779 .
- Schröder, G., and E . Lanka. 2003 . TraG-like proteins of
type IV secretion systems: functional dissection of the multiple activities of
TraG [RP4] and TrwB [R388] . J . Bacteriol . 185:4371-4381 .
- Sokol, P . A., P . Darling, D . E . Woods, E . Manhenthiralingam,
and C . Kooi. 1999 . Role of ornibactin biosynthesis in the virulence of
Burkholderia cepacia: characterization of the pvdA gene encoding
L-ornithine-N5-Oxygenase . Infect . Immun . 67:443-445 .
- Swarup, S., R . DeFeyter, R . H . Brlansky, and D . W . Gabriel.
1991 . A pathogenicity locus from Xanthomonas citri enables strains from
several pathovars of Xanthomonas campestris to elicit cankerlike
lesions on citrus . Phytopathology 81:802-809.
- Tomasek, P . H., B . Frantz, U . M . Sangodkar, R . A . Haugland,
and A . M . Chakrabarty. 1989 . Characterization and nucleotide sequence
determination of a repeat element isolated from a 2, 4, 5-T degrading strain
of Pseudomonas cepacia . Gene 76:227-238.
- Vandamme, P., D . Henry, T . Coenye, S . Nzula, M . Vancanneyt,
J . J . LiPuma, D . P . Speert, J . R . W . Govan, and E . Mahenthiralingam. 2002.
Burkholderia anthina sp . nov and Burkholderia pyrrocinia, two
additional Burkholderia cepacia complex bacteria, may confound test
results of new molecular diagnostic tools . FEMS Immunol . Med . Microbiol .
33:143-149.
- Vandamme, P., B . Holmes, T . Coenye, E . Mahenthiralingam, J .
J . LiPuma, and J . R . W . Govan. 2003 . Burkholderia cenocepacia sp .
nov., a new twist on an old story . Res . Microbiol . 154:91-96.
- Vasil, M . L., D . P . Krieg, J . S . Kuhns, J . W . Ogle, V . D .
Shortridge, R . M . Ostroff, and A . I . Vasil. 1990 . Molecular analysis of
hemolytic and phospholipase activities of Pseudomonas cepacia . Infect .
Immun . 58:4020-4029.
- Vermis, K., T . Coenye, J . J . LiPuma, E . Mahenthiralingam, H .
J . Nelis, and P . Vandamme. 2004 . Identification of Burkholderia dolosa
sp . nov . [formerly Burkholderia cepacia genomovar VI] . Int . J . Syst .
Evol . Microbiol . 54:689-691.
- Vogel, H . J., and D . M . Bonner. 1965 . Acetylornithinase
of Escherichia coli partial purification and some properties . J . Biol .
Chem . 281:97-106.
- Walker, J . E., M . Saraste, M . J . Runswick, and N . J . Gay.
1982 . Distantly related sequence in the alpha- and beta-subunits of ATP
sythase, myosin, kinases and other ATP-requiring enzymes and a common
nucleotide binding fold . EMBO J . 1:945-951.
- Ward, D . V., and P . C . Zambryski. 2001 . The six
functions of Agrobacterium VirE . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 98:385-386.
- Waters, V . L. 2001 . Conjugation between bacterial and
mammalian cells . Nat . Genet . 29:375-376.
- Wilkins, B . M., and A . T . Thomas. 2000 . DNA-independent
transport of plasmid primase protein between bacteria by the I1 conjugation
system . Mol . Microbiol . 38:650-657.
- Yeo, H., and G . Waksman. 2004 . Unveiling molecular
scaffolds of the type IV secretion system . J . Bacteriol . 186:1919-1926.
Free Online Full-text Article
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
|