|








| |
Journal of Bacteriology, September 2004, p . 6101-6109, Vol .
186, No . 18
Regulation of Tetralin Biodegradation and Identification of Genes Essential for
Expression of thn Operons
O . Martínez-Pérez, E . Moreno-Ruiz, B . Floriano, and E . Santero*
Centro Andaluz de Biología del Desarrollo and Departamento de Ciencias
Ambientales, Universidad Pablo de Olavide, Seville, Spain
Received 25 May 2004/ Accepted 17 June 2004
The tetralin biodegradation genes of Sphingomonas macrogolitabida
strain TFA are clustered in two closely linked and divergent
operons . To analyze expression of both operons under differentgrowth
conditions, transcriptional and translational gene fusionsof the
first genes of each operon to lacZ have been constructedin
plasmids unable to replicate in Sphingomonas and integratedby
recombination into the genome of strain TFA . Expression analysis
indicated that the transcription of both genes is induced insimilar
ways by the presence of tetralin . Gene expression inboth operons is
also subjected to overimposed catabolic repression.Two additional
genes named thnR and thnY have been identified
downstream of thnCA3A4 genes . ThnR is similar to LysR-type regulators,
and mutational analysis indicated that ThnR is strictly required
for expression of the thn operons . Unlike other LysR-type
regulators,ThnR does not repress its own synthesis . In fact, ThnR
activatesits own expression, since thnR is cotranscribed with
the thnCA3A4genes . ThnY is similar to the ferredoxin
reductase componentsof dioxygenase systems and shows the fer2
domain, binding aCys4[2Fe-2S] iron sulfur center, and the
FAD-binding domain,common to those reductases . However, it lacks the
NAD-bindingdomain . Intriguingly, ThnY has a regulatory role, since
it isalso strictly required for expression of the thn
operons . Giventhe similarity of ThnY to reductases and the
possibility ofits being present in the two redox states, it is
tempting tospeculate that ThnY is a regulatory component connecting
expressionof the thn operons to the physiological status of
the cell.
The organic solvent tetralin [1,2,3,4-tetrahydronaphthalene]is a
bicyclic molecule composed of an aromatic and an alicyclicmoiety,
which share two carbon atoms . Tetralin is widely usedas a degreasing
agent and solvent for fats, resins, and waxes,as a substitute for
turpentine in paints, lacquers, and shoepolishes, and also in the
petrochemical industry in connectionwith coal liquefaction [19] .
A concentration of tetralin higherthan 100 µM inhibits bacterial
growth [44] . Its toxicityis partly due to its
lipophilic character, which results inits accumulation in the cell
membranes, thus leading to changesin their structure and function [46,
47] . In addition, tetralinalso forms toxic
hydroperoxides in the cell [17].
A few bacterial strains which are able to aerobically grow on
tetralin as the only carbon and energy source have been isolated[44] .
By the identification of accumulated intermediates, severalreports
suggest that some bacteria, such as Pseudomonas stutzeriAS39
[43], initially hydroxylate and further oxidize the alicyclic
ring whereas others, such as Corynebacterium sp . strain C125
[45], initially dioxygenate the aromatic ring, thus
indicatingthat aerobic metabolism of tetralin can be performed in
differentways . Metabolism of tetralin has been best characterized in
Sphingomonas macrogolitabida strain TFA . Biodegradation of tetralin
by the strain TFA involves initial oxidation of the aromatic
ring to yield 1,2-dihydroxytetralin [1,2-DHT] through reactions
catalyzed by a ring-hydroxylating dioxygenase and by a dehydrogenase
[37] . The catechol intermediate is further metabolized
throughreactions catalyzed by an extradiol dioxygenase, a hydrolase,
a hydratase, and an aldolase, respectively [3,
24, 25] . Interestingly,this
set of enzymes, typically involved in metabolism of onearomatic
ring, is able to cleave both the aromatic and the alicyclicrings of
tetralin, which results in the production of pyruvateand pimelic
semialdehyde [25] . The genes coding for these enzymes
have also been identified and shown to cluster together in two
closely linked operons, which are divergently transcribed [26,
37] [Fig . 1].
|
FIG . 1 . Schematic representation of the two divergent strain TFA
operons, which bear tetralin biodegradation genes . Genes identified in
this work are shown in enlargement at the bottom . Chromosomal insertions
of plasmids bearing transcriptional or translational lacZ gene
fusions to thnB or thnC by a single recombination event
are also schematically represented at the top.
|
|
The success of a catabolic pathway obviously depends on the
capability of the enzymes to metabolize a particular compoundor the
subsequent intermediates but also depends on an efficientregulatory
system . Regulatory proteins and regulated promotersare key elements
that control expression of catabolic operonsto assure that the
enzymes are only produced under appropriateenvironmental conditions
[13] . Thus, the expression of mostcatabolic
operons is regulated by specific inducible systemsof control, which
allow or activate synthesis of the correspondingenzymes only when
the substrate or some intermediate of thepathway is available.
Additionally, expression of catabolic operons is very frequently
subjected to overimposed global regulatory controls, which prevent
transcription of catabolic genes under conditions of nutritional
excess, thus optimizing gene expression by connecting it tothe
metabolic and/or energetic status of the cell [8,
13] . Someglobal controls apparently respond to
different stress signalsand may involve the participation of
alternate sigma factors[7, 9,
32, 48, 50], although
most of them fit within the categoryof carbon catabolite repression,
which prevents expression ofcatabolic operons in the presence of
preferential carbon andenergy sources . Although carbon catabolite
repression appearsto be a conserved phenomenon in bacteria, the
molecular mechanismsthat exert the control may be completely
different in distantlyrelated bacteria [39,
40] . Several reports of bacteria metabolizing
different organic contaminants indicate that the mechanism[s]of
carbon catabolite repression of biodegradative operons isdifferent
from the cyclic AMP-dependent mechanism, which iswell characterized
for enteric bacteria [2, 9,
11, 15, 33, 38].
In addition, more than one global regulatory system may regulate
expression of biodegradative genes within the same bacteria[9,
14].
Very little is known about regulation of catabolic pathwaysin
sphingomonads, although some LysR-type activators have beenrecently
described [5, 22, 36] .
Carbon catabolite repressionhas not yet been documented for this
group of bacteria . Thispaper reports on the regulated expression of
the tetralin biodegradationoperons of S . macrogolitabida
strain TFA, showing that it isinduced in the presence of the pathway
substrate and subjectedto carbon catabolite repression .
Characterization of two regulatorygenes whose products are essential
for thn gene expression isalso described.
Plasmids and bacterial strains. Plasmids and strains used in
this work are listed in Table 1.A 5.3-kb SmaI
fragment from pIZ600 [26] was cloned in pTZ18U[34],
yielding plasmid pIZ619 . pIZ669 was then constructed bycloning a
KIXX cassette [from pUC4-KIXX; Pharmacia] excisedwith HindIII into a
BglII restriction site, interrupting the241st codon of thnY
in pIZ619.
| TABLE 1 . Bacterial strains and plasmids
|
|
Plasmid pIZ1165 was constructed by cloning a 4.5-kb EcoRI fragment
from pIZ604 [26] which bore thn'A4RY and 1.35 kb
downstreamof thnY in a SalI-PstI-SphI-HindIII-lacking pTZ18R
[34] openedwith EcoRI . Then, to construct pIZ601,
an EcoRI fragment, harboringthe Km resistance flanked by
transcriptional terminators frompUT-miniTn5Km [12],
was inserted in pIZ1165 in a PstI site inthnY, interrupting
it after the 140th codon.
An 1.41-kb EcoRV-ApaI fragment, containing the promoter region,
from pIZ608 [26] was cloned between the EcoRV and ApaI sites
of the multiple cloning site of pBluescript II SK[+] [Stratagene]
to yield pIZ1001.
To obtain translational fusions of the promoter for the thnC
or thnB gene to the lacZ reporter gene, plasmids pIZ1002 and
pIZ1003 were constructed . An Asp718-EcoRV fragment from pIZ1001
was cloned between the XmaI and EcoRI sites of pJES379 [42],
yielding plasmid pIZ1002, which carried the translational thnC-lacZ
fusion . Plasmid pIZ1003 carried the translational thnB-lacZ
fusion and was constructed by cloning an Asp718-BamHI fragment
from pIZ1001 between the EcoRI and BamHI sites of pJES379 . The
lacZ fusions maintain the first 124 codons of thnC and the first
217 codons of thnB.
To construct the transcriptional thnC-lacZ and thnB-lacZ
fusions,an Asp718-EcoRV fragment from pIZ1001 was cloned in both
orientationsin the SmaI site of pIC552 [31],
yielding plasmids pIZ1009 [thnC-lacZtranscriptional
fusion] and pIZ1010 [thnB-lacZ transcriptionalfusion].
To construct the broad-host-range plasmid pIZ1016, an EagI-SalI
fragment, bearing the tac promoter and lacIq from pMM40
[28],was excised from pIZ1015 and cloned between
NcoI-SalI sitesof pBBR1MCS-5 [29], removing the
plasmid's lac promoter . PlasmidpIZ1015 was obtained by
cloning an EagI-EcoRI fragment frompMM40, bearing the tac
promoter and lacIq, between EagI-ClaIin
pBluescript II KS[+] [Stratagene].
A plasmid named pIZ1008 harboring the thnR gene was constructed
by cloning a 1.5-kb SacII-PstI fragment from pIZ641 [26]
intopBluescript II KS[+] . A SacI-PstI fragment from pIZ1008 was
inserted into the SalI and PstI sites of pIZ1016, yielding plasmid
pIZ1017.
To construct plasmid pIZ698, a 1.35-kb BamHI-NruI fragment harboring
thnY was excised from pIZ619 and cloned in the SmaI site of
pIZ1016.
Whenever necessary, incompatible cohesive ends were bluntedwith
Klenow polymerase and deoxynucleoside triphosphates orwith T4
polymerase and deoxynucleoside triphosphates.
Escherichia coli DH5
[21] was used for cloning, isolation ofDNA for
sequencing, and other DNA manipulations.
S . macrogolitabida strain TFA [26] harboring
transcriptionalor translational fusions of the promoter for the
thnB or thnCgene to lacZ [TFA-1002, TFA-1003,
TFA-1009, and TFA-1010] wereused for ß-galactosidase assays . TFA
mutants derivativesT601, T653 [26], T655 [26],
T656 [26], T661 [26], T664 [26],
and T669 carrying the translational thnC-lacZ fusion
[T601-1002,T653-1002, T655-1002, T656-1002, T661-1002, T-664-1002,
andT669-1002] were used for complementation experiments or
ß-galactosidaseassays.
To construct the ThnY– mutant strains T669 and T601, plasmids
pIZ669 and pIZ601 were respectively electrotransformed intothe
wild-type TFA strain, and candidates showing homologousrecombination
were isolated as previously described [26].
Plasmids pIZ1002, pIZ1003, pIZ1009, and pIZ1010 were transferred
to strain TFA and TFA mutants by triparental matings . Sincenone of
these plasmids can replicate in TFA, ampicillin-resistant
transconjugants resulted from a single recombination event,leading
to integration of the plasmid into the TFA genome.
Preparation of total DNA from strain TFA and Southern blotting.
Total DNA from strain TFA was prepared as previously described[20] .
Southern blot analyses were performed using digoxigenin-dUTP-labeled
probes and following the instructions of the manufacturer [Boehringer
Mannheim] . Total DNA from T669 and T601 was hybridized witha marked
1.35-kb BamHI-NruI fragment, containing thnY, frompIZ619 .
T669 was also hybridized with a KIXX HindIII probe.An EcoRI
fragment, containing the Km resistance gene, was excisedfrom
pUT-miniTn5Km, labeled, and hybridized to T601 . A 1.41-kb
EcoRV-ApaI fragment, containing the promoter region, was markedand
used as a probe to check the integration of the transcriptionaland
translational fusions.
Media and growth conditions. E . coli strains were
routinely grown in Luria-Bertani [LB] mediumat 37°C . TFA strains
were grown at 30°C in MML richmedium [mineral medium [MM]
supplemented with 0.2% tryptoneand 0.1% yeast extract], LB medium,
or MM medium [16] suppliedwith tetralin in the
vapor phase or/and ß-hydroxybutyrate[ßHB] as the carbon and energy
source . MM medium containing8 mM nitrate or 17 mM urea instead of
ammonium as a nitrogensource was used in some induction kinetics.
Tetralin induction and carbon catabolite repression assays.
Cultures of strains harboring a thnC-lacZ or thnB-lacZ gene
fusion integrated into their chromosomes were grown at 30°Cin
mineral medium containing ßHB as the only carbonand energy source to
exponential phase [optical density at 600nm = 0.8 to 1.0] . Then,
cells were washed to remove the carbonsource and diluted to a final
optical density of about 0.1 inMML, LB medium, or MM medium, which
could be supplemented witha carbon source, in the absence or the
presence of the inducertetralin in the gas phase . Cultures were
grown at 30°C,aliquots were withdrawn at different cell densities,
and ß-galactosidaseactivity was assayed as described by Miller [35].
RNA extraction. RNA extraction was performed as described by
Chomczynski andSacchi [10] . Harvested cells were
subsequently treated withacid phenol, N-lauryl sarcosine, and
guanidinium thiocyanateat 60°C, chloroform, DNase, and proteinase K .
RNA was finallyrecovered after phenol:chloroform:isoamyl alcohol
[25:24:1],and chloroform:isoamyl alcohol [24:1] treatment and
precipitationwith ethanol 96°C and 3 M sodium acetate [pH 5.2].
Reverse transcription and PCR amplification. RNA [2 µg] was
retrotranscribed using a TaqMan kit [AppliedBiosystems] and
following the manufacturer's instructions . Differentamounts [0.8 and
4.8 µg] of the obtained cDNA were usedto amplify a 101-bp fragment
from thnB with the primers thnB-RT1
[5'-AGGTCGGCGTACTTGAAGTC-3'] and thnB-RT2 [5'-AGCAAAGCTCGCAACGCT-3'],
a 142-bp fragment from thnC with primers thnC-RT1
[5'-CAGCCGTCCATCCTGAGATAG-3']and thnC-RT2
[5'-AAGGCAAGTGTCACGGAACTC-3'], and a 136-bp fragmentfrom thnR
with primers thnR-RT1 [5'-CGGTCAAACCGAGTCTGAAGA-3']and thnR-RT2
[5'-ATGGAGCCAACAGCATTTGC-3'] . As an amplificationcontrol, primers
f27 and r519 [26] were used to amplify a 500-bp
fragment corresponding to 16S rRNA . The PCR program consistedof 5
min at 94°C, 20 cycles of 30 s at 94°C, 30 s at57°C, and 30 s at
72°C, and 5 min of elongation at 72°C.Samples were then run in an 8%
acrylamide:bisacrylamide [29:1]gel and stained with ethidium
bromide . To ensure that RNA samplesdid not contain contaminating
DNA, PCR amplification was performedusing RNA preparations as
templates.
Sequence analysis comparison. The obtained sequence was
initially compared using the BLASTpand tBLASTn programs to those in
databases [1] . Sequences thatshowed high
similarity to that of strain TFA were aligned usingthe CLUSTALW
program [49] and default parameters . A distance
matrix and a phylogenetic tree was constructed by the neighbor-joining
method [41] and visualized using the TreeView program.
Nucleotide sequence accession number. The nucleotide
sequence reported here has been submitted tothe DDBJ, EMBL, and
GenBank nucleotide sequence databases andannotated as an update of
the sequence at accession no.
AF157565.
Tetralin induction of the thn operons. To easily test
expression of the tetralin catabolic operons,transcriptional and
translational lacZ gene fusions to thnBand thnC,
the first genes of each operon, were constructed asdescribed in
Materials and Methods, thus yielding the plasmidspIZ1010
[transcriptional thnB-lacZ fusion], pIZ1003 [translational
thnB-lacZ fusion], pIZ1009 [transcriptional thnC-lacZ fusion],
and pIZ1002 [translational thnC-lacZ fusion] . Since none of
these plasmids can replicate in strain TFA, strain derivatives
bearing each plasmid integrated into the genome by a single
recombination event were directly selected as ampicillin-resistant
transconjugants [Fig . 1] . This approach allows testing
expressionof the gene fusions in the same copy number and the same
genomiccontext as the original genes . After confirmation by Southern
blot analysis that transconjugants harbored the appropriate
plasmid integrated in the right genomic region, four of them,each
bearing a different plasmid, were selected for expressionanalysis.
Each strain was grown to exponential phase in mineral medium
containing ßHB as the only carbon and energy source.Growing cells
were then washed and resuspended in mineral mediumwith tetralin in
the gas phase, and expression of the thn operonswas measured
by testing ß-galactosidase activity insamples taken at time
intervals . As shown in Fig . 2, cells growingon ßHB
did not express any of the gene fusions [t= 0 h] . Similar
results were obtained with cultures grown upto stationary phase
[data not shown] . However, expression ofall gene fusions was evident
shortly after the cells were transferredto growing conditions on
tetralin as the only carbon and energysource, thus showing that
expression of both tetralin biodegradationoperons is not
constitutive but induced by the presence of thepathway substrate .
Although activity obtained from the transcriptionalfusions
stabilized a little earlier, both transcriptional andtranslational
gene fusions were induced in similar ways andachieved similar
induction ratios [120-fold and 180-fold inductionfor thnB and
thnC, respectively], thus indicating that regulationwas
exerted at a transcriptional level . According to the maximallevels
of expression, it appears that activity of the thnC promoter
is slightly stronger than that of the thnB promoter.
|
FIG . 2 . Tetralin induction of lacZ fusions to thn genes .
The ß-galactosidase activity of strains bearing a transcriptional
thnB-lacZ fusion [ ],
a translational thnB-lacZ fusion [ ],
a transcriptional thnC-lacZ fusion [•], or a translational
thnC-lacZ fusion [ ]
after the strains were transferred to mineral medium with tetralin as
the only carbon and energy source is shown.
|
|
Carbon catabolite repression of the thn operons. To test
the effect of availability of a readily metabolizedcarbon source on
the induction of thn operons, similar inductionkinetics by
tetralin were carried out using mineral medium containingdifferent
concentrations of ßHB, which allows a highergrowth rate than
tetralin, and two different complex-rich media.As shown for the
thnC-lacZ translational fusion in Fig . 3, increasing
the concentration of carbon in the mineral medium resulted ina
proportional delay and a reduced level of tetralin induction,thus
showing that availability of ßHB prevented expressionof the thn
operons . A result similar to that shown in the presenceof 40 mM ßHB
was obtained using 10 mM of differentfatty acids [hexanoic acid,
octanoic acid, sebacic acid, orsuberic acid] [data not shown], thus
indicating that other carbonsources have the same repressing effect .
The rich medium MMLalso prevented tetralin induction, although
significant expressionwas observed at the end of the induction . Full
repression wasobtained only in LB medium, which contains fivefold
higher concentrationsof tryptone and yeast extract than MML .
Cultures similar tothose used for the induction kinetics but lacking
tetralin inthe gas phase did not induce thnC expression at
all [data notshown], which confirms that thn genes are not
simply inducedby carbon-limited growth conditions but their
expression isalso strictly dependent on the presence of the specific
inducerof the pathway.
|
FIG . 3 . Carbon catabolite repression of tetralin biodegradation genes .
The results of tetralin gene induction in the strain bearing the
translational thnC-lacZ fusion while growing in mineral medium
supplemented with 8 mM [•], 20 mM [ ],
or 40 mM [ ]
ß-hydroxybutyrate, in rich MML medium [ ],
or in LB medium [ ]
are shown.
|
|
Kinetics of induction by tetralin in a mineral medium containing8 mM
ßHB and nitrate or urea as the nitrogen sourceinstead of ammonium
were also carried out . The use of urea ornitrate instead of ammonium
as a nitrogen source significantlyreduced the growth rate [data not
shown], which indicated thatnitrogen availability was the
growth-limiting factor under theseconditions . Although the
concentration of ßHB wasnot high enough to prevent induction of
thnC-lacZ in a mediumcontaining ammonium as the nitrogen source
[Fig . 3 and 4], further
limitation of growth by urea or nitrate prevented thnC-lacZ
expression [Fig . 4] . The use of these nitrogen sources did not
prevent induction of thnC-lacZ expression in a medium containing
tetralin as the only carbon and energy source [data not shown].
These data clearly indicate that carbon limitation but not lowgrowth
rate per se allows induction of thnC by tetralin.
|
FIG . 4 . Effect of nitrogen limitation on catabolic repression of
tetralin biodegradation genes . The results of tetralin gene induction in
the strain bearing the translational thnC-lacZ fusion during
growth in mineral medium with 8 mM ß-hydroxybutyrate and ammonium [•],
urea [ ],
or nitrate [ ]
as the nitrogen source are shown.
|
|
Identification of genes required for thn gene expression.
Previous DNA sequencing identified structural thn genes encoding
enzymes of the tetralin catabolic pathway . Further sequencing
of 3.9 kb has allowed identification of two additional putativeORFs
located downstream of thnA4 and in the same orientationand
the partial sequence of a third ORF located 650 bp awayin the
opposite orientation [Fig . 1] . Comparison of this partial
ORF to those in the databases showed a high level of similarity
to CopB, which is involved in copper resistance; therefore,this
partial ORF is apparently not involved in tetralin biodegradation.
However, the product putatively encoded by the ORF just downstream
of thnA4 showed high similarity to known LysR-type activators
of operons involved in biodegradation of different aromatic
pollutants; therefore, this ORF was named thnR . ThnR showed
highest similarity to DntR from Burkholderia sp . strain DNT
and to NagR from Ralstonia sp . strain U2 [45% identity along
the molecules] [52] . A dendrogram resulting from the
comparisonof amino acid sequences of similar LysR-type activators is
shownin Fig . 5 . Although a number of NahR
activators from differentstrains have been removed from the figure
for simplicity, thedendrogram indicates that ThnR diverged early
from a branchwhere the activators of naphthalene biodegradation
genes [NagR/NahR]cluster together, which suggests a possible
evolutionary relationshipbetween ThnR and activators of
naphthalene-biodegradative operons.
|
FIG . 5 . Dendrogram showing the best tree obtained by the
neighbor-joining method from the alignment of 17 sequences showing
significant similarity to that of ThnR . The ThnR sequence is boxed .
GenBank accession numbers for other sequences are as follows: for NagR [Ralstonia
sp . strain U2],
AF036940.2; for NbzR [Comamonas sp . strain JS765],
AY223675.1; for NahR [Pseudomonas putida AN10],
AF039534.1; for NahR [P . putida pNAH7],
A32837; for HybR [Pseudomonas aeruginosa],
AF087482.1; for MidR [Ralstonia sp . strain TAL1145],
AF312768.2; for PcpR [Sphingomonas chlorophenolica
ATCC39723],
U12290.2; for PnbR [P . putida TW3],
AF292094.1; for SalR [Acinetobacter sp . strain ADP1],
AF150928.2; for CatR [P . putida],
A35118; for AphT [Comamonas testosteroni TA441],
BAA88500; for BenM [Acinetobacter sp . strain ADP1],
AAC46441; for ClcR [P . putida pAC27],
A40641; for PhnS [Burkholderia sp . strain RP007],
AAD09867; for TcbR [Pseudomonas sp . strain P51],
A38861; for HcaR [E . coli K-12],
Q47141.
|
|
The start codon of another ORF [which was named thnY] which
putatively encodes a product 324 amino acids long is seven nucleotides
downstream of the stop codon of thnR . Unlike other thn
genes,the start codon of thnY is not preceded by an evident
Shine-Dalgarnosequence, which suggests that it is not translated to
high levels.BLAST comparison of the putative product to those in the
databasesshowed significant similarity to ferredoxin reductases,
whichare components of systems of electron transfer to dioxygenases
or monooxygenases of different aromatic pollutants . The putative
product showed highest [36%] identity to the ferredoxin reductase
component of naphthalene dioxygenases from different strains,
including Ralstonia sp . strain U2 [52] . This type of
ferredoxinreductase contains three domains . An NAD-1 binding domain,
anFAD-6-binding domain, and a fer2 domain, which binds a
chloroplast-typeCys4[2Fe-2S] iron sulfur center, are
recognizable by sequenceanalysis of their C termini . ThnY showed the
existence of thefer2 and the FAD-6-binding domains in an arrangement
similarto that shown by other ferredoxin reductases . However, the
NAD-1-bindingdomain was not detected . BLAST analysis of the
C-terminal regioncovering 40% of ThnY, where the NAD-binding domain
should be,showed similarity to the corresponding regions of the
ferredoxinreductases [29 to 31% identity to the most similar
sequences].However, this similarity was clearly lower than that
shown bythe N-terminal region covering 60% of the protein [38 to 40%
identity to the most similar sequences] . In addition, pairwise
BLAST of the C-terminal region of ThnY and the consensus NAD-1-binding
domain showed no significant alignment . Multialignment of C-terminal
regions of ferredoxin reductases and the consensus NAD-1-binding
domain showed two blocks of highly conserved residues . Interestingly,
two conserved residues of each block were absent from the sequence
of ThnY . These data clearly suggest that ThnY was originallya
ferredoxin reductase whose NAD-binding domain has degenerated;
therefore, it is not expected that ThnY could bind NAD/NADH.However,
it still keeps some capacity to transfer electronsto the ferredoxin
ThnA3, as tested by tetralin dioxygenase activityassays [data not
shown].
Expression of the thn operons requires ThnR and ThnY.
A collection of KIXX insertion mutants of strain TFA, unableto grow
on tetralin as the only carbon and energy source, waspreviously
constructed [26] . Sequencing has revealed that mutant
strain T656 contains the K1 KIXX insertion at the 69th codonof
thnR, which suggests that ThnR is required for growth on
tetralin . Two additional insertion mutants have been constructed.
Mutant T669 bears a nonpolar KIXX insertion at the 241st codonof
thnY, while mutant strain T601 bears a polar kanamycin resistance
cassette insertion, flanked by transcription terminators, inits
140th codon . None of these mutants were able to grow usingtetralin
as the only carbon and energy source, thus suggestingthat ThnY is
also required for tetralin utilization.
The translational thnC-lacZ fusion was integrated into the
genomeof mutants T656, T669, and T601 . As shown in Table
2, none ofthese mutants were able to induce
thnC expression in responseto tetralin . thnR and thnY
were cloned separately in pIZ1016so that transcription of both genes
proceeded from the isopropyl-ß-D-thiogalactopyranoside
[IPTG]-inducible tac promoter, thus yielding pIZ1017 and pIZ698,
respectively . Mutant T656 transformed with pIZ1017 was ableto
grow on tetralin . In the absence of IPTG, partial inductionof
thnC by tetralin was observed, thus suggesting that plasmid-driven
transcription of thnR was sufficiently high even in the absence
of IPTG . However, maximal levels of thnC induction were achieved
only by adding IPTG [Table 2] . Similar positive
complementationwas observed in the mutants T601 and T669 transformed
with pIZ698[Table 2] . Transformation of T656 with
pIZ698 or T669 and T601with pIZ1017 did not result in a change of
the mutant phenotype[data not shown] . Taken together, these data
clearly show thatthe mutant phenotype of each insertion is due to
lack of thecorresponding product and not to potential effects
preventingexpression of the neighbor gene . Therefore, both ThnR and
ThnYare required for expression of tetralin biodegradation genes.
| TABLE 2 . Expression of the thnC-lacZ translational fusion in
thnR or thnY mutants and complementation of the regulatory
phenotypea
|
|
Given the sequence similarity of ThnY to ferredoxin reductasesand
its residual activity, ThnY requirement for thn operons
induction might be explained if the real function of ThnY wereto
participate in some reaction of the tetralin biodegradationpathway
and if some product of its metabolism, rather than tetralinby
itself, were the real inducer . To test whether tetralin hasto be
metabolized to induce the thn operons, thnC-lacZ fusions,
two in each operon, were constructed in four KIXX insertion
mutants, each lacking one of the activities required for thefirst
four reactions of the tetralin pathway . Expression ofthnC in
these mutants after growth under inducing conditions[8 mM ßHB plus
tetralin] was monitored . As shown inFig . 6, all
mutants, including the one lacking ferredoxin thatis essential for
tetralin dioxygenase activity [37], expressed
thnC to levels even higher than that obtained with the wild-type
strain . As for the wild-type strain, expression of thnC in these
mutants is dependent on the presence of tetralin [data not shown].
These results indicate that tetralin by itself, and not anyof
its metabolic products, is the real inducer.
|
FIG . 6 . Tetralin induction of the translational thnC-lacZ fusion
in different thn mutants . ß-Galactosidase activity of strains
bearing a translational thnC-lacZ fusion was measured 20 h after
transferring them to mineral medium with 8 mM ß-hydroxybutyrate and
tetralin.
|
|
Expression of thnR is coregulated with other thn genes.
Earlier genetic complementation analysis showed that the mutantT656
strain bearing the K1 insertion [thnR::KIXX] could notbe
complemented by the cosmid pIZ629, which carries the wholethn
region but bears a polar mini-Tn5Km insertion in thnC [26].
This data clearly suggested that thnR is transcribed from a
promoter located upstream from the polar insertion in thnC,
although interpretation was not possible until the K1 insertion
had been precisely located within thnR . In turn, this indicates
that ThnR, unlike other LysR-type regulators, does not repress
its own synthesis . Actually, ThnR should activate its own transcription
because ThnR is required to transcribe thnC in the presence
of tetralin.
Coregulation of thnR, thnB, and thnC under inducing [8
mM ßHBplus tetralin] and noninducing [40 mM ßHB with no
tetralin] conditions was analyzed by reverse transcription andPCR
amplification . As shown in Fig . 7, no mRNA corresponding
to any of these genes was detected under noninducing conditions.
However, amplification of fragments of each of these genes was
evident after reverse transcription of mRNA isolated from cultures
grown under inducing conditions, which clearly indicates that
transcription of thnR is regulated just as transcription of
thnB and thnC is.
|
FIG . 7 . Reverse transcription-PCR of thnB, thnC, thnR,
and ribosomal 16S genes . Two different amounts [0.8 and 4.8 µg] of cDNA
obtained by retrotranscription of RNA isolated from strain TFA growing
in MM-8 mM ßHB-tetralin [lanes 2 and 4] or MM-40 mM ßHB [lanes 3 and 5]
were used . Amplification of the 16S ribosomal gene was used as a control
to ensure equivalent amounts of cDNA between different growth
conditions . Lane 1, 1-kb Plus DNA ladder [GibcoBRL].
|
|
In an effort to understand how the ability to metabolize tetralinis
expressed in Sphingomonas, a number of gene fusions were
constructed and integrated by recombination into the genomicregion
containing the original genes . Analysis of expressionof these gene
fusions revealed that the two operons bearingtetralin biodegradation
genes are regulated at the transcriptionallevel [Fig .
2] and that transcription of the thn operons strictly
requires the presence of tetralin in the culture medium . Inductionof
catabolic gene expression by the substrate or by intermediatesof the
pathway is the most common and efficient way of adaptingthe
metabolic capabilities of a bacteria to the opportunitiesoffered by
the environment.
Induction of the thn operons by tetralin is repressed under
carbon-sufficient conditions such as undefined rich medium ormineral
medium containing preferential carbon sources [Fig.3] .
This clearly indicates that the thn operons are also regulated
by a physiological control system which prevents expressionof
tetralin biodegradation capability when it is dispensable,thus
improving adaptation of metabolic capabilities of the bacteriato
their nutritional and energetic needs . Induction of the thn
operons by tetralin does not take place under other growth-limiting
conditions, such as nitrogen limitation [Fig . 4], but only
undercarbon-limiting conditions . Thus, limitation of growth rate
per se is not responsible for the expression levels of thn operons,
as previously shown in other systems such as the alkane degradation
genes [14, 51]; therefore, the
global regulation system controllingexpression of thn genes
is a true carbon catabolite repressionsystem.
The thnR gene, coding for a LysR-type transcriptional activator,
has been identified by sequencing downstream of the thnA3A4
genes, and mutational analysis indicated that ThnR is strictly
required for expression of tetralin biodegradation genes . Sequence
comparison suggested that ThnR may be evolutionarily relatedto
activators of naphthalene biodegradation genes, particularlyto NagR
[52] . Although it is not formally proven, functional
and sequence comparison data strongly suggest that ThnR is the
activator of thn genes in response to tetralin.
The most common arrangement is that the gene coding for the
LysR-type activator is located very closed to and divergentfrom the
activated operon and that the regulator constitutivelyrepresses its
own transcription in a feedback circuit, whichmaintains the
concentration of the activator at levels justhigh enough to allow
expression of the operon whose transcriptionactivates under the
appropriate conditions . Two interestingaspects are that thnR
is cotranscribed with the thnCA3A4 genesand that ThnR does
not appear to repress their own synthesis[compare basal expression
levels in Table 2] . In fact, ThnRappears to
activate its own expression in a positive circuitresponsive to
tetralin, just like thnB or thnC expression [Fig.
7] . Although this is unusual, there are precedents of similar
situations in other LysR-type activators such as lrhA, required
for flagella, motility, and chemotaxis in E . coli [30],
or alkS,required for alkane biodegradation, and it is thought
to allowa faster switch-on or switch-off of the system in response
tothe inducer [6].
ThnR is necessary but not sufficient for transcription of thn
genes . Mutational and complementation analysis clearly indicated
that ThnY, encoded downstream of thnR, is also strictly required
[Table 2] . Expression of thnC-lacZ in mutants
blocked in differentsteps of the tetralin degradation pathway
indicates that theactual inducer of thn operons is tetralin
itself [Fig . 6]; therefore,the requirement for
ThnY cannot be due to lack of an inducerwhose production required
ThnY . Additionally, heterologous expressionof ThnR in both TFA and
E . coli strains did not relieve a strictrequirement of ThnY
for activation [data not shown], which suggeststhat ThnR cannot
activate by itself even when overproduced.Thus, ThnY should be
considered an auxiliary regulatory protein.Again, this is an unusual
situation because in most instancesLysR-type regulated systems are
very simple and involve a singleregulatory component, the activator,
which is able to directlysense the effector and to regulate
transcription . In some systems,an additional regulatory protein has
been shown to modulatethe activity of the activator by binding to it
and thus preventingits function [23] . However, to
our knowledge, this is the firstreport of a LysR-type activator that
requires an auxiliary proteinto activate transcription.
Involvement of accessory regulatory proteins increases the versatility
of the response of regulated systems . Implication of ThnY in
activation of the thn operons and the fact that is similar to
ferredoxin reductases raises a number of intriguing issues,such as
what is the real function of ThnY, how does it exertits regulatory
role, and what is it sensing . Considering itsamino acid sequence, it
is really unlikely that ThnY plays adirect role in the process of
transcriptional activation . Rather,ThnY may be required for ThnR [or
an additional undefined regulator]to adopt or maintain an
appropriate configuration . Since ThnYmight be in an oxidized or a
reduced form, it is tempting tospeculate that its activity may
depend on its redox status [4],thus providing a
way of connecting expression of thn operonsto the
physiological state of the cell . ThnY might be a componentthrough
which catabolic repression of thn operons is exerted.
Alternatively, ThnY might sense oxygen through its FAD-binding
domain, like the oxygen sensor NifL [27], which would make
physiologicalsense, since the degradation pathway is strictly
dependent onoxygen.
This work was supported by the Spanish Comisión Interministerialde
Ciencia y Tecnología, grant BIO2002-03621, by a fellowshipof the
Spanish Ministerio de Educación to O . M.-P., andby a fellowship of
Fundación Cámara to E . M.-R.
* Corresponding author . Mailing address: Centro Andaluz de
Biología del Desarrollo, Universidad Pablo de Olavide, ctra . Utrera Km 1, 41013
Sevilla, Spain . Phone: 34-95-4349386 . Fax: 34-95-4349376 . E-mail: esansan@dex.upo.es .
- Altschul, S . F., T . L . Madden, A . A . Schaffer, J . Zhang, Z .
Zhang, W . Miller, and D . J . Lipman. 1997 . Gapped BLAST and PSI-BLAST: a
new generation of protein database search programs . Nucleic Acids Res . 25:3389-3402 .
- Ampe, F., D . Léonard, and N . D . Lindley. 1998 . Repression
of phenol catabolism by organic acids in Ralstonia eutropha . Appl . Env .
Microbiol . 64:1-6 .
- Andújar, E., M . J . Hernáez, S . R . Kaschabek, W . Reineke, and
E . Santero. 2000 . Identification of an extradiol dioxygenase involved in
tetralin biodegradation: gene sequence analysis, purification and
characterization of the gene product . J . Bacteriol . 182:789-795 .
- Bauer, C . E., S . Elsen, and T . H Bird. 1999 . Mechanisms
for redox control of gene expression . Annu . Rev . Microbiol . 53:495-523.
- Cai, M., and L . Xun. 2002 . Organization and regulation of
pentachlorophenol-degrading genes in Sphingobium chlorophenolicum ATCC
39723 . J . Bacteriol . 184:4672-4680 .
- Canosa, I., J . M . Sanchez-Romero, L . Yuste, and F . Rojo.
2000 . A positive feedback mechanism controls expression of AlkS, the
transcriptional regulator of the Pseudomonas oleovorans alkane
degradation pathway . Mol . Microbiol . 35:791-799.
- Canosa, I., L . Yuste, and F . Rojo. 1999 . Role of the
alternative sigma factor
S
in expression of the AlkS regulator of the Pseudomonas oleovorans
degradation pathway . J . Bacteriol . 181:1748-1754 .
- Cases, I., and V . De Lorenzo. 1998 . Expression systems
and physiological control of promoter activity in bacteria . Curr . Opin .
Microbiol . 1:303-310.
- Cases, I., and V . De Lorenzo. 2000 . Genetic evidence of
distinct physiological regulation mechanisms in the
54
Pu promoter of Pseudomonas putida . J . Bacteriol . 182:956-960 .
- Chomczynski, P., and N . Sacchi. 1987 . Single-step method
of RNA isolation by acid guanidinium thiocyanate-phenol-chloroform extraction .
Anal . Biochem . 162:156-159.
- Collier, D . N., P . W . Hager, and P . V . Phibbs, Jr. 1996 .
Catabolite repression control in the Pseudomonads . Res . Microbiol . 147:551-561.
- de Lorenzo, V., M . Herrero, U . Jakubzik, and K . N . Timmis.
1990 . Mini-Tn5 transposon derivatives for insertion mutagenesis,
promoter probing, and chromosomal insertion of cloned DNA in gram-negative
eubacteria . J . Bacteriol . 172:6568-6572.
- Díaz, E., and M . A . Prieto. 2000 . Bacterial promoters
triggering biodegradation of aromatic pollutants . Curr . Opin . Biotechnol .
11:467-475.
- Dinamarca, A., I . Aranda-Olmedo, A . Puyet, and F . Rojo.
2003 . Expression of the Pseudomonas putida OCT plasmid alkane
degradation pathway is modulated by two different global control signals:
evidence from continuous cultures . J . Bacteriol . 185:4772-4778 .
- Dinamarca, A., A . Ruiz-Manzano, and F . Rojo. 2002 .
Inactivation of cytochrome o ubiquinol oxidase relieves catabolic
repression of the Pseudomonas putida GPo1 alkane degradation pathway .
J . Bacteriol . 184:3785-3793 .
- Dorn, E., M . Hellwig, W . Reineke, and H.-J . Knackmuss.
1974 . Isolation and characterization of a 3-chlorobenzoate degrading
Pseudomonad . Arch . Microbiol . 99:61-70.
- Ferrante, A . A., J . Augliera, K . Lewis, and A . M . Klibanov.
1995 . Cloning of an organic solvent-resistance gene in Escherichia coli:
the unexpected role of alkylhydroperoxide reductase . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci .
USA 92:7617-7621.
- Figurski, D . H., and D . R . Helinski. 1979 . Replication
of an origin-containing derivative of plasmid RK2 dependent on a plasmid
function provided in trans . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 76:1648-1652.
- Gaydos, R . M. 1981 . Naphthalene, p . 698-719 . In
M . Grayson and D . Eckroth [ed.], Kirk-Othmer encyclopedia of chemical
technology, 3rd ed . John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, N.Y.
- Govantes, F., J . A . Molina-López, and E . Santero. 1996 .
Mechanism of coordinated synthesis of the antagonistic regulatory proteins
NifL and NifA of Klebsiella pneumoniae . J . Bacteriol . 178:6817-6823.
- Hanahan, D. 1983 . Studies on transformation of
Escherichia coli with plasmids . J . Mol . Biol . 166:557-580.
- Hara, H., E . Masai, K . Miyauchi, Y . Katayama, and M . Fukuda.
2003 . Characterization of the 4-carboxy-4-hydroxy-2-oxoadipate aldolase gene
and operon structure of the protocatechuate 4,5-cleavage pathway genes in
Sphingomonas paucimobilis SYK-6 . J . Bacteriol . 185:41-50 .
- Heil, G., L . T . Stauffer, and G . V . Stauffer. 2002 .
Glicine binds the transcriptional accessory protein GcvR to disrupt a
GvcA/GcvR interaction and allow GcvA-mediated activation of the Escherichia
coli gcvTHP operon . Microbiology 148:2203-2214.
- Hernáez, M . J., E . Andújar, J . L . Ríos, S . R . Kaschabek, W .
Reineke, and E . Santero. 2000 . Identification of a serine hydrolase, which
cleaves the alicyclic ring of tetralin . J . Bacteriol . 182:5448-5453 .
- Hernáez, M . J., B . Floriano, J . J . Ríos, and E . Santero.
2002 . Identification of a hydratase and a class II aldolase involved in
biodegradation of the organic solvent tetralin . Appl . Environ . Microbiol .
68:4841-4846 .
- Hernáez, M . J., W . Reineke, and E . Santero. 1999 .
Genetic analysis of biodegradation of tetralin by a Sphingomonas
strain . Appl . Environ . Microbiol . 65:1806-1810 .
- Hill, S., S . Austin, T . Eydmann, T . Jones, and R . Dixon.
1996 . Azotobacter vinelandii NIFL is a flavoprotein that modulates
transcriptional activation of nitrogen fixation genes via a redox-sensitive
switch . Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 93:2143-2148 .
- Kleiner, D., W . Paul, and M . J . Merrick. 1988 .
Construction of multicopy expression vectors for regulated overproduction of
proteins in Klebsiella pneumoniae and other enteric bacteria . J . Gen .
Microbiol . 134:1779-1784.
- Kovach, M . E., P . H . Elzer, D . S . Hill, G . T . Robertson, M .
A . Farris, R . M . Roop, I . I., and K . M . Peterson. 1995 . Four new
derivatives of the broad-host-range cloning vector pBBR1MCS, carrying
different antibiotic-resistance cassettes . Gene 166:175-176.
- Lehnen, D., C . Blumer, T . Polen, B . Wackwitz, V . F . Wendish,
and G . Unden. 2002 . LrhA as a new transcriptional key regulator of
flagella, motility and chemotaxis genes in Escherichia coli . Mol .
Microbiol . 45:521-532.
- Macian, F., I . Perez-Roger, and M . E . Armengod. 1994 . An
improved vector system for constructing transcriptional lacZ fusions:
analysis of regulation of the dnaA, dnaN, recF and
gyrB genes of Escherichia coli . Gene 145:17-24.
- Marqués, S., M . Manzanera, M . M . González-Pérez, M . T .
Gallegos, and J . L . Ramos. 1999 . The XylS-dependent Pm promoter is
transcribed in vivo by RNA polymerase with
32
or
38
depending on the growth phase . Mol . Microbiol . 31:1105-1113.
- McFall, S . M., S . A . Sugani, and A . M . Chakrabarty.
1998 . Transcriptional activation of the catechol and chlorocatechol operons:
variations on a theme . Gene 223:257-267.
- Mead, D . A., E . Szczesna-Skorupa, and B . Kemper. 1986 .
Single-stranded DNA "blue" T7 promoter plasmids: a versatile tandem promoter
system for cloning and protein engineering . Protein Eng . 1:67-74.
- Miller, J . H. 1972 . Experiments in molecular genetics .
Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y.
- Miyauchi K., H.-S . Lee, M . Fukuda, M . Takagi, and Y . Nagata.
2002 . Cloning and characterization of linR, involved in regulation of
the downstream pathway for
-hexachlorocyclohexane
degradation in Sphingomonas paucimobilis UT26 . Appl . Environ .
Microbiol . 68:1803-1807 .
- Moreno-Ruiz, E., M . J . Hernáez, O . Martínez-Pérez, and E .
Santero. 2003 . Identification and functional characterization of
Sphingomonas macrogolitabida strain TFA genes involved in the first two
steps of the tetralin catabolic pathway . J . Bacteriol . 185:2026-2030 .
- Petruschka, L., G . Burchhardt, C . Müller, C . Weihe, and H .
Hermann. 2001 . The cyo operon of Pseudomonas putida is
involved in carbon catabolite repression of phenol degradation . Mol . Genet .
Genomics 266:199-206.
- Saier, M . H., Jr. 1996 . Catabolite repression . Res .
Microbiol . 147:439-588.
- Saier, M . H., Jr. 1998 . Multiple mechanisms controlling
carbon metabolism in bacteria . Biotechnol . Bioeng . 58:170-174.
- Saitou, N., and M . Nei. 1987 . The neighbor-joining
method: a new method for reconstructing phylogenetic trees . Mol . Biol . Evol.
4:406-425.
- Santero, E., T . Hoover, A . K . North, D . K . Berger, S . C .
Porter, and S . Kustu. 1992 . Role of integration host factor in stimulating
transcription from the
54-dependent
nifH promoter . J . Mol . Biol . 227:602-620.
- Schreiber, A . F., and U . K . Winkler. 1983 .
Transformation of tetralin by whole cells of Pseudomonas stutzeri AS39 .
Eur . J . Appl . Microbiol . Biotechnol . 18:6-10.
- Sikkema, J., and J . A . M . de Bont. 1991 . Isolation and
initial characterization of bacteria growing on tetralin . Biodegradation 2:15-23.
- Sikkema, J., and J . A . M . de Bont. 1993 . Metabolism of
tetralin [1,2,3,4-tetrahydronaphthalene] in Corynebacterium sp . strain
C125 . Appl . Environ . Microbiol . 59:567-572.
- Sikkema, J., J . A . M . de Bont, and B . Poolman. 1994 .
Interactions of cyclic hydrocarbons with biological membranes . J . Biol . Chem.
269:8022-8028 .
- Sikkema, J., B . Poolman, W . N . Konings, and J . A . M . de
Bont. 1992 . Effects of the membrane action of tetralin on the functional
and structural properties of artificial and bacterial membranes . J . Bacteriol.
174:2986-2992.
- Sze, C . C., and V . Shingler. 1999 . The alarmone [p]ppGpp
mediates physiological-responsive control at the
54-dependent
Po promoter . Mol . Microbiol . 31:1217-1228.
- Thompson, J . D., D . G . Higgins, and T . J . Gibson. 1994 .
CLUSTAL W: improving the sensitivity of progressive multiple sequence
alignment through sequence weighting, position-specific gap penalties and
weight matrix choice . Nucleic Acids Res . 22:4673-4680.
- Valls, M., M . Buckle, and V . de Lorenzo. 2002 . In
vivo UV laser printing of the Pseudomonas putida sigma 54-Pu
promoter reveals that integration host factor couples transcriptional activity
to growth phase . J . Biol . Chem . 277:2169-2175 .
- Yuste, L., I . Canosa, and F . Rojo. 1998 .
Carbon-source-dependent expression of the PalkB promoter from the
Pseudomonas oleovorans alkane degradation pathway . J . Bacteriol . 180:5218-5226 .
- Zhou, N.-Y., S . L . Fuenmayor, and P . A . Williams. 2001.
nag genes of Ralstonia [formerly Pseudomonas] sp . strain
U2 encoding enzymes for gentisate catabolism . J . Bacteriol . 183:700-708 .
Free Online Full-text Article
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
|